314 orders · Page 1 of 7
The High Court held that the assessee's conduct of denying possession of the locker during the search and subsequently claiming the cash belonged to the family was indicative of concealment. The Tribunal's reasoning, which relied on the AO's detailed findings, was found to be sound. The AO had noted the assessee's inability to specify the source of savings from HUF income, the lack of explanation for keeping such a large sum in cash in a locker, and the attempt to conceal the locker's existence. The Tribunal correctly observed that the slip found in the locker could not have been placed there in anticipation of a search, as it contradicted the sequence of events. Therefore, the Tribunal was justified in reversing the CIT(A)'s deletion of the addition of Rs. 86,000. The issue was answered in favor of the Department and against the assessee.
The High Court noted that the assessee's counsel invited attention to the Supreme Court judgment in J.K. Industries Limited and Others, arguing for the benefit of the matching principle. The Court observed that this contention was not considered by the Tribunal, and the assessee had not been afforded an opportunity to present it. The revenue's counsel did not dispute this submission. Consequently, the High Court, in view of the law laid down by the Supreme Court and the lack of opportunity for the assessee, quashed the order passed by the Tribunal concerning the appeal preferred by the revenue. The matter was remitted back to the Tribunal to decide it afresh after affording an opportunity to all parties to raise all admissible contentions. The Court stated that it was not necessary to answer the substantial questions of law.
The Tribunal granted permission to the appellant (Revenue) to withdraw the appeal. This decision was based on Circular No.17/2019 dated 08.08.2019, which specifies that appeals with a tax effect below Rs.1 crore should be withdrawn. The Revenue stated that the tax effect in this particular appeal was less than Rs.1 crore, thus satisfying the condition for withdrawal under the circular. The Tribunal accepted this submission and allowed the withdrawal. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed as withdrawn. No other issues were decided on merits.
The High Court found that the truck driver was initially responsible for entering a no-entry zone and crossing the highway without a signal. However, the victim, driving the Honda City car under the influence of alcohol, failed to judge the distance and dashed into the back of the truck. Consequently, the Court apportioned negligence: 60% to the offending truck and 40% to the victim. The Court recalculated the compensation, considering the victim's monthly income as Rs. 33,000/- (after deducting taxes from Rs. 33,871/-), adding 50% for future prospects, applying a multiplier of 17, and deducting 50% for personal expenses, resulting in Rs. 50,49,000/-. General damages of Rs. 33,000/- were added, making the total compensation Rs. 50,82,000/-. The insurance company was held liable to pay 60% of this amount, which is Rs. 30,49,200/-, along with interest at 6% per annum from the claim date. The Court directed the Registrar General to calculate and disburse the amount, refunding any excess to the insurance company or directing the company to pay any shortfall.
The High Court, for reasons assigned in a related order (ITA No.54/2013), answered all the substantial questions of law against the revenue and in favour of the assessee. This implies that the High Court found that the assessee had satisfied the conditions for deduction under Section 80IB(10), that proportionate deduction for smaller units was permissible, and that the commercial area calculation was correctly applied by considering individual residential blocks. The reasoning behind this decision is not detailed in the provided text, but it follows the findings of the related appeal. The appeal filed by the revenue has been dismissed.
The Tribunal held that the appeal filed by the Income Tax Department was not maintainable. The reasoning was based on CBDT Circular No. 3/2018, which stipulates that appeals shall not be filed before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal if the tax effect does not exceed Rs. 20,00,000. In this case, the tax effect was stated to be less than Rs. 50 lac, and the appeal was filed after the issuance of the circular. The Tribunal dismissed the appeal, stating that the appellant was at liberty to revive it if it did not come within the ambit of the circular. The ratio decidendi is that departmental appeals are subject to monetary limits prescribed by CBDT circulars, and failure to adhere to these limits leads to dismissal. The operative direction was to dismiss the appeal.
The High Court dismissed the appeal filed by the Income Tax Department. The Court noted that the tax effect in the appeal was less than Rs. 50 lac. It referred to CBDT Circular No. 3/2018, which revised the monetary limits for filing departmental appeals. According to the circular, appeals before the High Court should not be filed if the tax effect does not exceed Rs. 50,00,000. The Court observed that the appeal was filed after the issuance of this circular and that the circular applies retrospectively to pending appeals. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed. However, the appellant was granted liberty to revive the appeal if it was found not to be covered by the ambit of the circular. The Court did not decide the merits of the original dispute.
The Gauhati High Court, Itanagar Bench, held that the Public Interest Litigation (PIL) had become infructuous. The Court noted the submission by the learned Advocate General for the State of Arunachal Pradesh that all hydro-power projects in the Siang valley have been abandoned and that the process for cancellation of contracts is being undertaken. The Court accepted this submission and was of the opinion that there was no reason to keep the PIL pending. The operative direction was to close the PIL. However, the Court stipulated that if the State of Arunachal Pradesh decides to proceed with the construction of dams in the future, such actions must be strictly in accordance with the law, taking into full consideration the safety, security, and all other aspects concerning the affected people. The Court further observed that if any violations occur, the petitioners or any other affected persons would be at liberty to approach the Court again. No specific issue was left undecided; the PIL was disposed of based on the State's submissions.
The High Court held that time was the essence of the contract. The plaintiffs failed to prove their readiness and willingness to perform their part of the contract before November 15, 2005. The evidence, including the delay in replying to the termination notice and the filing of the suit nearly three years after the agreement, did not support their claim. The court noted that the plaintiffs never requested the defendant to obtain the sketch survey within the stipulated time. The court found that the trial court had erred in decreeing the suit, as its findings were contrary to the express terms of the agreement and the evidence on record. Consequently, the appeal was allowed, the trial court's judgment and decree were set aside, and the suit was dismissed. The ratio is that even if certain procedural steps are pending, if time is of the essence and the purchaser fails to pay the balance consideration by the stipulated date, specific performance cannot be granted.
The High Court of Gujarat held that the appeal is disposed of in view of the low tax effect, as indicated by the Revenue. The court referred to Circular No. 17/2019, which sets a monetary limit of Rs. 1,00,00,000 for appeals before the High Court. Since the appeal was not pressed by the Revenue due to this circular, the court disposed of the appeal accordingly. The court also reserved the liberty for the Revenue to revive the tax appeal in case of any difficulty. No specific issue regarding the merits of the original assessment or the order under challenge was decided.
The appeal filed by the Income Tax Department was dismissed. The Court referred to Circular No. 3/2018 issued by the CBDT, which sets revised monetary limits for filing appeals. Specifically, it states that appeals shall not be filed before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal if the tax effect does not exceed Rs. 20,00,000 and before the High Court if the tax effect does not exceed Rs. 50,00,000. The circular also provides that pending appeals below the specified tax limits may be withdrawn or not pressed. Since the tax effect in the present appeal was stated to be less than Rs. 50 lac, the appeal was dismissed in view of this circular. The appellant was granted liberty to revive the appeal if it was not coming within the ambit of the circular.
The High Court held that the benefit of exemption should not be denied solely due to a delay in furnishing the audit report, especially when it can be produced at a later stage before the Assessing Officer or Appellate Authority with sufficient cause. The Court acknowledged the ongoing Covid-19 pandemic around the time of filing and considered the petitioner's contention of suffering from Covid-19 as genuine, particularly as the revenue did not object. Citing its own decision in Action Research for Health and Socio-economic Development vs. CBDT, the Court found that the CIT had not applied his mind conscientiously. The Court emphasized that substantial justice should prevail over technicalities. Consequently, the order of the CIT rejecting the condonation of delay was set aside. The matter was remitted to the authority to consider the audit report in Form 10B as if it were filed within the specified period, invoking Section 119(2)(b) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, and grant consequential relief. The writ petition was disposed of with these directions.
The High Court held that in view of the continuous non-appearance of the petitioner and his counsel, and considering the communication produced by the respondents' counsel, it appeared that the respondents had complied with the order dated 13.05.2013. The court noted that an amount of Rs. 1,23,184.00 had been credited to the petitioner's wife's account after deducting income tax at source. Consequently, the contempt notice was recalled, and the contempt proceedings were dropped. However, the petitioner was granted liberty to seek revival of the contempt petition if the cause survived and if they were so advised.
The High Court permitted the appellant-Revenue to withdraw the appeal. The reasoning was based on the revised monetary limits for filing appeals as per Circular No. 17 of 2019, which increased the threshold to Rs. 1,00,00,000/-. The Court noted the Revenue's submission that the appeal might not be maintainable under these new limits. Furthermore, the Court granted liberty to the appellant to seek revival of the appeal if it was subsequently found that the matter fell within the exceptions specified in Clause 10 of Circular No. 3 of 2018. No decision was made on the merits of the substantive issues of the appeal.
The High Court held that the Assessee's activity of processing Run-of-Mines (ROM) iron ore, which is crude ore with impurities and practically of no use, into Iron Ore Concentrate Fines through magnetic separation constitutes 'manufacturing' or 'processing' for the purpose of Section 10B of the Income Tax Act. The Court referred to dictionary definitions of beneficiation and magnetic separation, which involve improving the grade and purity of ores. It also cited precedents and the definition of 'manufacture' under Section 2(r) of the Special Economic Zones Act, 2005, which includes bringing into existence a new product with a distinctive name, character, or use. The Court found that the beneficiation process undertaken by the Assessee transformed the original product into a commercially viable end product, distinct and different from the original product, thus passing the twin tests laid down by the Supreme Court. Consequently, the Court found no reason to interfere with the Tribunal's findings on the sole substantial question of law. The appeals were dismissed.
The Tribunal held that the appeal filed by the Income Tax Department was not maintainable due to the tax effect being less than the monetary limit prescribed by CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. The circular, issued under Section 268A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, revised the monetary limits for departmental appeals, setting Rs. 20,00,000 as the limit for appeals before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal. Since the tax effect in the present case was less than Rs. 50 lakh (and implicitly less than Rs. 20 lakh as per the circular's threshold for ITAT), the appeal was dismissed. However, the appellant (Income Tax Department) was granted liberty to revive the appeal if it was found not to be covered by the ambit of the circular. The ratio decidendi is that appeals below the stipulated monetary limits, as per CBDT Circular No. 3/2018, are to be dismissed, unless specific exceptions apply.
The High Court dismissed the miscellaneous appeal. Regarding the issue of 100% disability, the Tribunal held that the renewal of the conductor's license (Exhibit-A) did not prove that the claimant did not suffer 100% disability. The Tribunal found this contention insufficient to modify the Labour Court's judgment. Concerning the driver's license, the Tribunal noted that the owner of the bus had not appeared, and the driver's license was not produced. The Labour Court had decided the issue of a valid driving license against the owner and granted the appellant liberty to pay and recover from the owner. The Tribunal found no reason to modify the judgment on this point either. The Court emphasized that under Section 30 of the Employees' Compensation Act, 1923, an appeal can only be admitted on a question of law. After discussing the facts and arguments, the Court concluded that no question of law was involved in admitting the present miscellaneous appeal and therefore, no interference was required. The appeal was dismissed. The operative direction was to send the trial court record back to the learned court forthwith.
The Court agreed with the Insurance Company that the monthly income of Rs.6000/- was correctly taken, noting that averaging income tax returns for the last three years might even lead to a lower figure. Regarding future prospects, the Court, in light of National Insurance Ltd. vs. Pranay Sethi, held that the deceased, being self-employed or on a fixed salary, was entitled to an addition of 40% of the established income. On the multiplier, the Court found substance in the Insurance Company's submission that for a deceased aged 30 years, the correct multiplier, as per Sarla Verma vs. DTC, is 17, not 18. The Court recalculated the compensation, arriving at a total of Rs.12,12,400/-. This amount, less any amount already paid, was to be paid by the Insurance Company within three months with interest at 6% per annum from the date of petition till realization. The appeal was disposed of.
The Tribunal held that Brigadier (Retd.) Shyam Prasada and his siblings are each entitled to a 1/6th share in the land beneath the suit property. The assertion of no-objection certificates/disclaimers did not establish a surrender of interest in favour of Mrs. Dayavati. The contesting defendants failed to prove any subsisting oral family arrangement whereby the plaintiff and supporting defendants relinquished their shares. Mrs. Dayavati had ownership rights only in 50% of the subject property. Since Mr. Savitri Prasada died intestate, his 50% share is to be distributed equally among his Class I heirs, including the subject property and movable assets, as the Will dated 24.02.1966 was not proved. The Will dated 09.11.1992 and codicil dated 24.02.2000 executed by Mrs. Dayavati were proved, thus her 50% share devolves upon Mr. Arun Prasada, with cash and shares (except for one bank account) devolving equally on her three daughters. The suits were not barred by limitation. A preliminary decree will be drawn allocating 1/6th share to Brigadier (Retd.) Shyam Prasada and his siblings in the suit property. The testamentary case stands disposed of.
The High Court dismissed the appeals filed by the revenue. The Court accepted the statement made by the learned counsel for both parties that no reasons were required to be recorded. The dismissal was based on the reasoning provided in the Court's judgment delivered on 22.04.2022 in Income Tax Appeal No. 19 of 2013, in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. Surendra Shantilal Peety and other connected matters. The appeals were dismissed in view of the tax effect involved being less than the monetary limit prescribed in the earlier circulars issued from time to time. Consequently, the Court was not required to answer any substantial questions of law that were formulated while admitting these appeals. No order as to costs was made.
The High Court held that the MACT correctly analyzed the evidence and rightly concluded that the accident was caused by the negligent parking of the truck without proper lights. The arguments regarding the invalidity of the insurance policy and lack of a valid driving license were unsubstantiated. The court found that Arun Prasad was driving the Santro car with a valid license, and the insurance policy, though issued in the name of the deceased owner, was valid as premiums were accepted. The compensation for deaths (Rs. 20,61,844/-) was correctly computed based on income tax returns, multiplier, personal expenses, and future prospects, following precedents like Sarla Verma and Santosh Devi. The claim for enhancement was dismissed as the MACT had considered all relevant factors. The compensation for injuries (Rs. 7,45,404/-) was also found to be based on proved medical bills and records. The court found no illegality or perversity warranting interference. All appeals were dismissed.
The High Court, after perusing a report filed pursuant to its order dated December 23, 2019, concluded that it did not consider it necessary to issue any further directions in the matter. Consequently, the applications filed before the Court were disposed of. The judgment does not delve into the merits of the Income Tax Appeals themselves, nor does it provide any findings on the substantive tax disputes. The operative part of the order solely addresses the disposal of the interlocutory applications based on the filed report.
The Court held that the market value of the acquired land in village Kilokari should be awarded at the rate of Rs. 2,07,500/- per Bigha. This decision was based on the principle that once a judicial determination of compensation is made for acquired land, all persons whose land was similarly acquired under the same notification are entitled to the same compensation, as per Section 28A of the Land Acquisition Act. Therefore, the land in villages Khizrabad, Nangli Razapur, and Garhi Mendu, acquired under the same notification and having similar topography and potentiality, are also entitled to this enhanced compensation. The appellants had already received Rs. 89,600/- per Bigha, and the balance amount, along with interest and statutory benefits, is to be paid. The Court did not leave any issue undecided.
The High Court held that the 'A' schedule property was purchased by defendant no.1 and therefore, the trial court rightly held it to be joint family property of the plaintiffs and defendant no.3, granting them equal shares. This finding was not challenged by the defendants and was justified by the Supreme Court's decision in Revanasiddappa and another Vs. Mallikarjuna and others. Thus, Point No.1 was answered in the affirmative. Regarding 'B' schedule property, the Court noted that a portion devolved upon defendant no.1 from his father, and even if another portion was purchased by him, it could not be entirely self-acquired. The admission by defendant no.3 during cross-examination that plaintiffs also had a share in 'B' schedule property indicated material irregularity in the trial court's denial of any share. Furthermore, the Court observed that other suits concerning different properties were pending, and there was no consolidation of all joint family properties for the relief claimed. The trial court's judgment also showed a lack of application of mind. Consequently, the impugned judgment and decree were set aside, and the matter was remanded to the trial court for fresh consideration after allowing parties to lead further evidence. The appeal was partly allowed.
The High Court held that the ITAT's finding that supervisors were sub-contractors was perverse, as it was not supported by evidence and was contrary to the books of account showing supervisors were paid salaries as employees. The Court found that supervisors acted as agents of the assessee for disbursing payments to individual labourers. Since no individual payment exceeded Rs. 20,000/-, and the supervisors acted as agents required to make cash payments on behalf of the assessee, the conditions of the second proviso to Section 40A(3) read with Rule 6DD(l) of the Income Tax Rules, 1962, were met. Therefore, the disallowance under Section 40A(3) was not sustainable. The ITAT's order upholding the disallowance was set aside, and the substantial question of law was answered in favour of the assessee.
The High Court held that the substantial questions of law raised in the present appeal had indeed been decided by the Full Bench of the Court in the case of Director of Income Tax International Taxation and Ors. Vs. Schlumberger Asia Services Ltd. and Ors. (reported in 414 ITR Page 1). The Court further noted that the Full Bench had answered these questions of law in favour of the assessee and against the revenue. Consequently, by following the precedent set by the Full Bench, the High Court answered the questions of law in this appeal in favour of the assessee and against the revenue. The operative direction was to dismiss the income tax appeal.
The High Court dismissed the acquittal appeals. The Court found that the complainant/appellant failed to prove the existence of any legal liability or debt. There was no documentary evidence to establish the Rs. 35,00,000/- cash payment, nor a satisfactory explanation for its source, especially given the complainant's admitted annual income of Rs. 3,50,000/-. The complainant also failed to disclose the exact date, place, and mode of payment, or details of the land transaction. The Court acknowledged that for such a large sum, documentary evidence would be expected, but none was produced, creating doubt about the alleged advance. Regarding notice, while it was returned as 'locked/no one available,' it was sent to the correct address, and in such circumstances, it could be presumed served as per D. Vinod Shivappa. However, the primary failure was proving the debt. The Appellate Court rightly found the complainant failed to prove legal liability and that the respondent raised a probable defense. The High Court held that the Appellate Court's findings were plausible and did not suffer from illegality or perversity, aligning with the principles for appeals against acquittal, including the presumption of innocence in favor of the accused. The judgment of the Appellate Court was upheld.
The High Court held that the principle of mutuality cannot be extended to the income earned by a Chit Fund Company, as it is considered a business concern. This decision was based on a Division Bench judgment of the same High Court in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax vs. Koyur Textiles, which established that the principle of mutuality is not applicable to such entities. The Court also referred to its own recent order dated November 2, 2023, in a batch of similar appeals, which also decided the issue in favour of the Revenue. Consequently, all the instant appeals were rejected, with the question of law being decided in favour of the Revenue. No costs were awarded.
The Tribunal noted that the statement of Mr. Arvind Kumar, OSD (Land), Noida Authority, recorded on 29.05.2026, which placed on record two notifications that the decree holder claimed were already quashed, required clarification. Consequently, the Tribunal deemed it expedient to summon the Estate Officer, Noida Authority, for the next hearing to clarify this issue. The Tribunal directed the registry to issue a court notice to the Estate Officer, Noida Authority, by all modes, including electronic mode, requiring their appearance on 31.07.2026 via video conferencing. No final decision was made on the suitability of any of the properties as security in this interim order. The specific reasoning for the need for clarification was the potential conflict between the notifications presented by the Noida Authority and the decree holder's assertion that these notifications had been quashed. The operative direction was to summon the Estate Officer for clarification.
The High Court decided to remand the case back to the trial court. It acknowledged that the appellants had raised substantial issues, including the lack of willful default due to insufficient funds, the unconsidered request for land attachment, the non-responsibility of Directors No. 2 and 3 as principal officers, and the filing of returns with nil taxable income but significant book profit. Crucially, the Court considered the applications filed under Section 391 of the Cr.P.C. to receive additional documents, including an order from the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal dated 31.12.2014, which mandated a re-computation of the assessee's income. The Court found these documents relevant to the grounds raised in the appeals. Consequently, the High Court set aside the conviction and sentence dated 09.01.2014 and remanded C.C. No. 117 of 2011 back to the trial court for a fresh consideration of all issues and documents, with an opportunity for both sides to adduce further evidence. The trial court was directed not to be influenced by any observations made by the High Court on the merits of the case.
The High Court held that the findings of the Assessing Officer, CIT(A), and Tribunal regarding the entitlement and extent of allowance for expenses incurred at 'Visalam' resort are unsustainable due to a lack of details and need re-examination in light of additional material. Consequently, the substantial questions (a) and (b) related to this issue were answered in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue. The matter was set aside and remitted to the Assessing Officer for fresh consideration and disposal, with liberty to the assessee to place additional explanations/documents. Regarding the claim for deduction under Section 80IB, the High Court found no reason to interfere with the Tribunal's order of remand to the primary authority. The Tribunal's direction to the AO to examine the Section 80IB claim vis-à-vis the books of account was confirmed. The scope and contentions on the inclusion of ayurvedic expenditure as part of business activity attracting Section 80IB deduction, and the nature of services provided by the assessee attracting Section 80IB, were left open for consideration in an appropriate case. Question (c) was answered in favour of the Revenue and against the assessee in this regard.
The High Court held that the assessee failed to establish a satisfactory correlation between the cash withdrawals and deposits, and the claim regarding land transaction negotiations was not proven. The Tribunal rightly concluded that the source of income was not established. The court found the assessee's plea of providing funds to siblings and re-depositing them, raised for the first time via an affidavit, lacked substantial evidence. The judgment in Vanitha G was distinguished as it involved proper appreciation of books of accounts and passbooks, which were not maintained by the present assessee. The court affirmed that quoting a wrong provision is not fatal, and the appellate authority has the power to invoke the correct provision, citing Commissioner of Income-tax v. Nirbheram Deluram. Additions are not made simultaneously under Sections 68 and 69. Even if a bank passbook is not treated as books of accounts under Section 68, it can be used for additions under Section 69. The onus is on the assessee to explain cash deposits, and in the absence of acceptable evidence, the amount can be added as income. The affidavit did not satisfy the source of income for the cash deposits. The substantial questions of law were answered in favour of the Revenue.
The High Court held that the VDIS certificate issued to the assessee under Section 68(2) of the Finance Act, 1997, dated 31.03.1998, was a fact recorded by the CIT(Appeals) and the ITAT. The Department admitted that such a certificate was issued, and there was no evidence that it was cancelled by any process known to law. Therefore, the benefit of immunity conferred by the VDIS certificate could not be denied to the assessee. The Court found it untenable for the Department to accuse the assessee of fraud by pleading ignorance of the Section 148 notices at the time of issuing the VDIS certificate, especially since the Department itself had issued both the Section 148 notices and the VDIS certificate. Consequently, questions (i), (ii), and (iii) were answered in the negative in favour of the assessee and against the Department. The appeals were allowed.
The Tribunal considered the request for withdrawal of the appeal made by the Income Tax Department. The request was based on CBDT Circular No. 3/2018, which sets revised monetary limits for filing appeals. According to the circular, appeals involving a tax effect below Rs. 20,00,000 before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal should not be filed or, if pending, should be withdrawn. The letter from the Commissioner of Income Tax explicitly stated that the appeal involved less tax effect than the prescribed limit. Therefore, the Tribunal, in view of the letter and the CBDT circular, dismissed the appeal as withdrawn. The appellant was granted liberty to revive the appeal if it was found not to be within the ambit of the circular.
The Tribunal held that the receipt of corpus donations as revenue donations in earlier years cannot be the sole ground for rejecting an application for registration under Section 12AA of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The Tribunal reasoned that this is an issue that can be examined by the assessing officer during the assessment proceedings. Furthermore, the Tribunal found that the Commissioner had not doubted the genuineness of the Trust's activities. The Tribunal reiterated the settled legal principle that for registration under Section 12AA, the Commissioner must examine if the objects of the Trust are charitable and if its activities are genuine. If both are affirmative, registration cannot be denied. The Tribunal concluded that these aspects were rightly examined and relief was granted. Consequently, the High Court found no question of law arising for consideration and dismissed the appeal filed by the revenue.
The High Court held that the Assessing Authority was not right in treating 50% of AMC receipts as attributable to the supply of spares for the assessment years 2005-2006, 2007-2008, and 2008-2009. The Court found that the restoration of the earlier order for 2007-2008 and 2008-2009 by the appellate authority, due to the assessee's non-compliance with the remand direction to produce accounts, was flawed. The Court reasoned that restoring an order previously held to be mechanically passed without application of mind would perpetuate illegality. To serve the interests of justice, the Court fixed 6% of the AMC receipts for these assessment years as representing the value of spares sold, taking note of a figure accepted by the department for assessment year 2006-2007, which the assessee did not dispute. The Assessing Authority was directed to pass revised orders within two months. For the Writ Petition concerning 2009-10, the Court set aside the appellate authority's order (Ext. P3) for failing to consider specific directions in a prior order (Ext. P2) and directed the Assessing Authority to re-assess based on the directions in Ext. P2 within two months. The principle is that a 'best judgment assessment' must have a reasonable nexus to available material and cannot be arbitrary.
The High Court, in its judgment, noted that the present appeals (ITA Nos. 61 & 64 of 2018) raise the same questions and circumstances as those in ITA No. 67/2018 and connected matters, filed by the assessee's mother, K.M. Fathima. The Court had previously delivered a separate judgment on 11.03.2022 in ITA No. 67/2018 and batch, wherein both grounds raised by the assessee's mother were rejected in favour of the Revenue. It was conceded that the grounds canvassed in the present appeals are identical and similar to the aforementioned batch. Therefore, by following the view taken in ITA No. 67/2018 and connected batch, the High Court answered the questions in favour of the Revenue and against the assessee. The operative direction was to dismiss the appeals, upholding the ITAT's decision.
The High Court, after considering the arguments and the applications filed under Section 391 of the Cr.P.C., decided to receive the additional documents. These included Dossier Reports for AY 2008-09, files pertaining to TRO proceedings, the entire proceedings related to the sanction order, and a common order dated 22.05.2015 passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal. The Court found these documents to be relevant to the grounds raised in the appeals. The Court was of the considered opinion that the trial court needed to re-examine all issues raised by the appellants, considering the newly admitted documents. Consequently, the High Court set aside the conviction and sentence dated 09.01.2014 passed by the Special Court for Economic Offences. The case (C.C. No. 133 of 2011) was remanded back to the trial court with a direction to reconsider the complaint afresh, providing an opportunity to both sides to adduce further evidence. The trial court was cautioned not to be influenced by any comments or observations made by the High Court on the merits of the case.
The Special Court held that Miscellaneous Application No. 54 of 2018 would be disposed of with directions, while Miscellaneous Application No. 52 of 2018 was dismissed. Regarding MA No. 54 of 2018, the Court ordered that the stop transfer instructions in respect of the 11,16,200 shares of Apollo Tyres Limited (ATL) shall continue to operate. The Custodian is directed to publish a public notice inviting claims from bona fide owners or purchasers of these shares within ten weeks. ATL is also to notify registered shareholders and those who lodged shares for transfer or dematerialization to approach the Court within the same period. ATL is at liberty to file an application to lift the stop transfer instructions, which the Court will consider based on the material provided. The Court will ultimately decide on the transfer of shares to the Custodian or their release from restraint based on the outcome of these applications. The Custodian may file a report seeking further directions. For MA No. 52 of 2018, the Court found no shred of material to sustain the claim of the notified parties, leading to its dismissal. The reasoning for dismissal of MA/52/2018 was that the notified parties' claim was based on the premise of possessing share certificates and transfer deeds, but they had not produced documents evidencing purchase and delivery, and the material was not in an identifiable state.
The High Court held that the Tribunal's finding that the aircrafts were utilized for business purposes was a finding of fact, supported by the Assessee's chartering income. Even if directors used the aircrafts for business meetings or occasional personal use, maintenance and depreciation expenses could not be disallowed. At best, personal use would be a perquisite to the user, not a ground for disallowing expenses incurred by the company. The Court also noted that the Revenue had conceded similar issues in other assessment years for the same Assessee, making it difficult to take a contrary stand. Therefore, substantial question of law no. (i) was answered against the Revenue. Regarding lease rent, the Tribunal's finding was based on Supreme Court and Rajasthan High Court judgments, and the fact that the lessor claimed depreciation. The Assessee had not claimed depreciation. The Tribunal's view that the lease rent was deductible as revenue expenditure was not illegal. Thus, substantial question of law no. (ii) was answered against the Revenue. The appeal was dismissed.
The Tribunal held that the present appeal filed by the revenue was not maintainable. This decision was based on the admitted fact that the revenue involved in the appeal was below the monetary limit of Rs. 1 crore, as stipulated by the CBDT vide its Circular No. 17/2019, dated August 8, 2019. Since both parties admitted this position, the Tribunal dismissed the appeal on the grounds of the disputed tax being below the threshold limit. No decision was made on the merits of the original appeal.
The Tribunal held that the applicants could not re-agitate the issue of whether they were fronts and benamidars of late Harshad Mehta, or whether their attached assets could be utilized for discharging the liabilities of the late Harshad Mehta and the group. This was based on the consistent view of the Special Court regarding the "group theory," as enunciated by the Supreme Court in the cases of Rasila S. Mehta and Jyoti Mehta, and successive orders of the Special Court. The Tribunal found that the doctrine of stare decisis and the principles of res judicata applied, precluding a fresh determination of the group theory issue. Consequently, the applicants' contention that they did not owe any liability was rejected. The Tribunal stated that once it is held that the applicants are members of the Harshad Mehta group and their attached assets are liable to be utilized for discharging the group's liabilities under Section 11 of the TORT Act 1992, the quantum of individual assets and liabilities becomes less significant. The Court would consider the assets and liabilities of the group as a whole for distribution. The Tribunal also noted that the question of whether attached assets ought to be released upon de-notification does not arise for consideration at this stage and has not been delved into, as it can be determined in an appropriate case where it warrants adjudication.
The Tribunal decided that the appeal should be dismissed as withdrawn. The reasoning was based on the submission by the learned counsel for the appellants that the tax effect involved in the appeal was below the monetary limit of Rs. 2,00,00,000/-. Consequently, the learned counsel for the department submitted that the appeal be dismissed as withdrawn in accordance with Circular No. 09/2024 dated September 17, 2024, issued by the Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue, Central Board of Direct Taxes. The Tribunal accepted this submission and passed an order dismissing the appeal as withdrawn. No specific findings on the merits of the case were made, and no issues were left undecided as the appeal was disposed of on a procedural ground.
The High Court dismissed the acquittal appeals. The Court found that the complainant/appellant failed to prove the existence of any legal liability or debt. There was no documentary evidence to establish the Rs. 35,00,000/- cash payment, nor a satisfactory explanation for its source, especially given the complainant's admitted annual income of Rs. 3,50,000/-. The complainant also failed to disclose the exact date, place, and mode of payment, or details of the land transaction. The Court acknowledged that for such a large sum, documentary evidence would be expected, but none was produced, creating doubt about the alleged advance. Regarding notice, while it was returned as 'locked/no one available,' it was sent to the correct address, and in such circumstances, it could be presumed served as per D. Vinod Shivappa. However, the primary failure was proving the debt. The Appellate Court rightly found the complainant failed to prove legal liability and that the respondent raised a probable defense. The High Court held that the Appellate Court's findings were plausible and did not suffer from illegality or perversity, aligning with the principles for appeals against acquittal, including the presumption of innocence in favor of the accused. The judgment of the Appellate Court was upheld.
The High Court held that the substantial questions of law raised in these Income Tax Appeals have been answered in favour of the assessee by the Supreme Court's judgment dated 28.02.2024 in Civil Appeal No. 7257 of 2011 and connected cases. Consequently, the High Court allowed these appeals. The reasoning is based on the binding precedent set by the Supreme Court. The operative direction is that the appeals are allowed, with the substantial questions of law being answered in favour of the assessee and against the revenue. No issues were expressly left undecided.