PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-2 vs. M/S.ATLANTA ARSS JV

PDF · subscribers
ITA/25/2018HC OrissaODHC01010915201805 December 2018Bench: MR. JUSTICE K. S. JHAVERI (CJ),MR. JUSTICE K.R.MOHAPATRA7 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the High Court hold?

The Tribunal noted that the statement of Mr. Arvind Kumar, OSD (Land), Noida Authority, recorded on 29.05.2026, which placed on record two notifications that the decree holder claimed were already quashed, required clarification. Consequently, the Tribunal deemed it expedient to summon the Estate Officer, Noida Authority, for the next hearing to clarify this issue. The Tribunal directed the registry to issue a court notice to the Estate Officer, Noida Authority, by all modes, including electronic mode, requiring their appearance on 31.07.2026 via video conferencing. No final decision was made on the suitability of any of the properties as security in this interim order. The specific reasoning for the need for clarification was the potential conflict between the notifications presented by the Noida Authority and the decree holder's assertion that these notifications had been quashed. The operative direction was to summon the Estate Officer for clarification.

What were the facts?

This case involves an execution proceeding where the decree holder, M/s. Netherlands India Communications Enterprises Ltd., is seeking to enforce a decree against the Union of India. The primary dispute revolves around the suitability of various properties as security. The properties under scrutiny include flats in Noida, residential and commercial plots in Salarpur Khadar, agricultural land in Dastumpur and Falaida Khadar, and a commercial property in Supernova Spira Commercial. The objector, likely representing the judgment debtor, has raised objections regarding the ownership, valuation, and legal status of these properties, citing notifications, public notices, and press releases from the Noida Authority. The decree holder, conversely, relies on sale deeds, valuer's reports, and court judgments to establish the properties' worth and legality. The assessment years are not specified. The order under challenge is an interim order passed by the Registrar General of the Delhi High Court.

What were the issues?

The Tribunal had to decide the following issues regarding the suitability of properties as security for the decree: 1. Whether Flats No. G-1 & G-3 in Tower A, Plot No. 03B, Village Bhangel Begampur, Noida, are suitable securities, considering the Noida Authority's notification dated June 1989 and conflicting valuations. * **Assessee's Contention:** The notification is not an acquisition notification, and the SDM's report indicates no restrictions on sale or purchase. The valuer's higher valuation should be accepted. * **Revenue's Contention (Objector):** The properties are not suitable securities due to the Noida Authority's notification and the conflicting valuations, with the objector questioning the basis of the valuer's higher valuation. 2. Whether the Residential and Commercial Plots in Khasra Nos. 735-739, Village Salarpur Khadar, are suitable securities, given the Noida Authority's acquisition notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, public notices regarding illegal construction, and press releases naming the decree holder for encroachment, as well as conflicting valuations. * **Assessee's Contention:** Relies on Supreme Court judgments (Rajendra Estate Private Ltd. vs. State of UP & Ors.) that quashed similar notifications and High Court judgments (Rajendra Kumar & Ors. Vs. State of UP) directing expungement of Noida's name. Argues that the public notice only prohibits construction and sale/purchase, not acquisition. The valuer's higher valuation should be accepted, and mutation is not essential for title (Balwant Singh & Anr. vs. Daulat Singh). * **Revenue's Contention (Objector):** The land has been acquired. Relies on public notices and press releases indicating illegal construction and encroachment by the decree holder. Questions the valuer's higher valuation due to lack of supporting documents and objects to the property not being mutated in the decree holder's name. 3. Whether the Agricultural land in Khata No. 176, Khasra No. 22 and Khata No. 177, Khasra No. 24, Village Dastumpur, is suitable security, considering the sale deed in favour of the decree holder and the valuation dispute. * **Assessee's Contention:** Sale deed exists, and the valuer's higher valuation should be accepted. * **Revenue's Contention (Objector):** Objects to the valuer's higher valuation due to lack of supporting sale deeds. 4. Whether the Agricultural land in Khata No. 554, 564, 570, Khasra Nos. 553/1, 553/2, 553/3, Village Falaida Khadar, is suitable security, given the lack of a registered sale deed and the physical possession being with another individual. * **Assessee's Contention:** Relies on an unregistered Agreement to Sell and Power of Attorney. * **Revenue's Contention (Objector):** Property should not be accepted as security due to the absence of a sale deed and physical possession with Mr. Sohan Pal Singh. 5. Whether the Supernova Spira Commercial property is suitable security, considering the ownership with Supernova Spira Commercial, the Supreme Court's order regarding possession handover, and conflicting valuations. * **Assessee's Contention:** Relies on a Supreme Court order (Ram Kishor Arora Vs. Bank of Maharashtra & Ors.) empowering a committee to handover possession. Argues that the revenue department's valuation is based only on circle rate and that allotment letters can be treated as security (Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. S.R.Jeyashanker). * **Revenue's Contention (Objector):** The ownership is with Supernova Spira Commercial, not the decree holder. The valuation is based on circle rate.

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

$~ * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI + OMP (ENF.) (COMM.) 25/2018 M/S NETHERLANDS INDIA COMMUNICATIONS ENTERPRISES LTD. .....Decree Holder Through: Mr. D. Moitra, Mr. Dhruv Tamta, alongwith Mr. Rohit Kumar, AR and Mr. Sanjay Kumar, Director of the decree holder Mr. Manu Beri, Adv. for Intervenor versus UNION OF INDIA. .....Judgement Debtor Through: None CORAM: REGISTRAR GENERAL SH. ARUN BHARDWAJ O R D E R % 24.07.2026 1. Further argument advanced on behalf of both the sides, the gist of which is noted in ensuing discussion, property wise:- (i) Built up Flat No. G-1 & G-3 in Tower A, Plot No. 03B comprising of Khasra No. 225 building known as Smart Homes situated in the Revenue Estate of Village- Bhangel Begampur, Noida Tehsil- Dadri, Distt. G. B. Nagar, 201304, UP admeasuring 125.46 sq mtrs each i.e. 2700 sq feet. (a) The report of SDM, Dadri, Gautambudh Nagar dated 02.02.2026 states that Flat No.G-1 is under the ownership and physical possession of M/s. This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 28/07/2026 at 11:32:59

Netherland (India) Communication Enterprises Ltd. through AR Jalam Singh and Flat No.G-3 is under the ownership and physical possession of M/s GTI Infotel Pvt. Ltd. through the same authorized signatory and according to circle rate the combined value is Rs.75,24,900/-. The Sale Deeds of both these flats are dated 12.01.2024. (b) According to Mr. Arvind Kumar, OSD (Land), Noida Authority, as per records of the said authority, khasra no. 225 in Village- Bhangel Begampur, Noida Tehsil- Dadri, Distt. G. B. Nagar, 201304, UP, is though a private property but 715 acres land of Village Bhangel Begampur is under the notification of Noida Authority and without prior permission of the authority, the owner cannot carry out any construction on the said khasra. He has relied on notification dated June 1989 in support of his statement. As per this notification an area of 715 acres in Village- Bhangel Begampur shall be part of Noida (New Okhla Industrial Development Authority). (c) The learned counsel for the objector relied on the aforesaid statement of Mr. Arvind Kumar to submit that these properties are not suitable securities. On the other hand, learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that this notification is not a notification of acquisition of land and as per the report given by SDM this land is free of any restriction for sale and purchase. (d) The other bone of contention between the parties is that according to the officials of revenue department, the valuation of both these flats is Rs.75,24,900/- but according to the valuer appointed with the consent of both the parties, the value of each flat is Rs. 87,75,000/-. (e) The learned counsel for the objector submitted that this valuation is on the basis of field enquiry and there is no supporting document in the nature of sale deed etc. for accepting this valuation given by the valuer. This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 28/07/2026 at 11:32:59

(ii) Residential Plot comprised in Khasra No. 735, 736, 737, 738 and 739 situated at Village- Salarpur Khadar Pargana and Tehsil Dadri, Distt. Gautam Budh Nagar, UP admeasuring 1255.6 sq yards (1050 sq mtrs) + Commercial Plot comprised in Khasra No. 735, 736, 737, 738 and 739 situated at Village- Salarpur Khadar Pargana and Tehsil Dadri, Distt. Gautam Budh Nagar, UP admeasuring 145.19 sq yards (121.4 sq mtrs). a. The report of SDM, Dadri, Gautambudh Nagar dated 02.02.2026 states that this land is in possession of M/s. Netherland (India) Communication Enterprises Ltd. through AR Jalam Singh. The said company is stated to be in possession and according to circle rate the value of the land is Rs.2,57,69,920/-. The Sale Deeds of these plots are dated 30.03.2024 and 01.04.2024. b. As per the statement of Mr. Arvind Kumar, OSD (Land), the land in question has been acquired by the authority as per due process of law and dispute in relation to the same is sub-judice in court. He has relied upon notification dated 30.09.2009 under Section 4 of Land Acquisition Land, 1894 as per which aforesaid khasras of Village Salarpur Khadar admeasuring 0.145, 0.164, 0.316, 0.304 and 0.202 (totalling 1.131) have been acquired. c. The learned counsel for the objector has relied on public notice issued by Noida Authority which is stated to be displayed on the website of the said authority where it is informed to general public that illegal construction work has been carried out in several khasras including aforementioned khasras of village Salarpur Khadar on 45 mtrs wide road from Bhangel main road which is illegal and demolition /ceiling process of which is underway. The public is cautioned that it is illegal to carry out any buying and selling or commercial This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 28/07/2026 at 11:32:59

activities in relation to the above. The learned counsel has also relied on Press Release issued by Noida Authority on 15.07.2025 as per which notices have been issued to the encroachers and at Sr. No. 13 is M/s. Netherland (India) Communication Enterprises Ltd. through AR Jalam Singh. It is submitted that these press releases have been issued after the execution of sale deed in favour of M/s. Netherland (India) Communication Enterprises Ltd. d. The learned counsel for the petitioner has relied on Rajendra Estate Private Ltd. Vs. State of UP & Ors. 2013 SCC Online SC 1526 in which notification dated 11.09.2008 issued under Section 4(1) of LA Act, 1894 and declaration dated 30.09.2009 made by State Government under Section 6(1) of the Act, was the subject matter of the dispute. The Hon’ble Supreme Court had quashed both the notifications for the reasons recorded in the said judgments. The learned counsel for the petitioner further relied on a judgment of Hon’ble High Court of Allahabad in the case of Rajendra Kumar & Ors. Vs. State of UP dated 26.09.2023 in which the respondents were directed to expunge the name of Noida from the revenue records in relation to the land of the petitioners and to mutate their name in place of Noida. The learned counsel further submitted that Mr. Arvind Kumar has not shown any other notification acquiring this property and even the public notice relied upon by learned counsel for the objector nowhere state that the land has been acquired. The notice only prohibits construction in that land and prohibits buying and selling or commercial activities in relation to the land. e. The learned counsel for the objector further submitted that the Estate Officer Noida be requested to examine the records and give details of the pending cases referred in the statement of Mr. Arvind Kumar and he be examined to elicit from him why there is a prohibition in buying and selling of This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 28/07/2026 at 11:32:59

the particular land. f. The valuation of this property as per the revenue department is Rs.2,57,69,920/- but according to the valuer appointed with the consent of the parties, the value is Rs.24,46,67,851/-. The learned counsel for the objector submitted that this valuation is on the basis of field inquiry and there is no supporting document in the nature of sale deed etc. for accepting this valuation given by the valuer. Moreover, he has objected that the land is not yet mutated in the name of M/s. Netherland (India) Communication Enterprises Ltd. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the petitioner has relied on Balwant Singh & Anr. vs. Daulat Singh 1997 (7) SCC 137 to submit that mutation of a property in the revenue record does not create or extinguish any title nor does it have any presumptive value on title. iii. Agricultural land comprised in khata no. 176, khasra no. 22 and khata no. 177 khasra no. 24 situated at Village Dastumpur, Pargana and Tehsil- Jewar District Gautambudh Nagar, UP admeasuring 4.75 bighas (0.4005 hect). a. As per the report of SDM Jewar, District Gautambudh Nagar, UP dated 14.01.2026, the land in question is in the name of Rishi Pal s/o- Sh. Vidha but he has executed sale deed in favour of M/s. Netherland. The valuation given is Rs.36,03,600/-. The sale deed of this land is dated 11.08.2023. The learned counsel for the objection submitted that he could not find any objection in this piece of land but object to the valuation given by the valuer appointed by this court for the same reason that there is no sale deed in support of such a valuation i.e. Rs. 1,78,12,500/-. This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 28/07/2026 at 11:32:59

iv. Agricultural land comprised in khata no. 554 khasra no. 553/1, khata no. 564 khasra no. 553/2, khata no. 570 khasra no. 553/3 situated at Village Falaida Khadar, Pargana and Tehsil – Jewar, Distt. Gautambudh Nagar, UP admeasuring 3.75 acres (1.518 hect). a. The petitioner has relied on copy of Agreement to Sell on a stamp paper of Rs.500/- (which is not even registered), and power of attorney. The learned counsel for the objector submitted that as there is no sale deed, this property be not accepted as security. He has referred to the letter of SDM dated 02.02.2026 as per which the physical possession over the land is of Mr. Sohan Pal Singh. v. Supernova Spira Commercial situated at Plot no. 3 Sector 94, Noida, Distt- Ghaziabad, UP admeasuring 4796 sq feet. a. According to the report of SDM, Dadri, Gautambudh Nagar dated 02.02.2026, the ownership of this property is with Supernova Spira Commercial who is in possession of the same and the value of the same is Rs.3,09,10,088/-. Learned counsel for the petitioner has relied on order dated 16.12.2025 passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 11052/2025 in the case titled as Ram Kishor Arora Vs. Bank of Maharashtra & Ors. to submit that the Hon’ble Supreme Court has empowered Court Appointed Committee which is likely to handover the possession shortly. He further submitted that the petitioner has paid a sum of rupees more than 8 crores 50 lakhs (95% of the sale consideration) and the valuation given by revenue department is only on circle rate. Learned counsel for the petitioner has relied on a judgment delivered by Hon’ble High Court of Madras titled of Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. S.R.Jeyashanker, 2014 SCC Online This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 28/07/2026 at 11:32:59

Madras 11241 to submit that on the basis of allotment letter also the property can be treated as safe security. 2. Having noted the arguments advanced on behalf of both the sides, it is observed that the statement of Mr. Arvind Kumar, OSD (Land), Noida Authority recorded on 29.05.2026, wherein he placed on record two notifications, which according to the decree holder, have already stood quashed, requires clarification. Therefore, it is deemed expedient to summon the Estate Officer, Noida Authority on the next date of hearing. 3. Accordingly, registry is directed to issue court notice to Estate Officer, Noida Authority by all modes including electronic mode with the direction to appear before this court on the next date of hearing through video conferencing by using the link i.e. https://dhcdja.webex.com/meet/dja.dhc.vc4 for clarification qua the aforesaid issue on 31.07.2026. Dasti in addition. ARUN BHARDWAJ REGISTRAR GENERAL JULY 24, 2026 akr This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 28/07/2026 at 11:32:59

Latest GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →