Research and analysis

Questions about Indian tax case law that are usually answered from impression, answered instead by counting. Every piece here is computed from the judgments on this database, and says which ones.

Case law tracker26 September 2026

Section 147A and the JAO–FAO controversy: where it stands

The Finance Act, 2026 inserted section 147A, backdated to 1 April 2021, so that reassessment notices issued by the jurisdictional Assessing Officer rather than a faceless one would stand. The Punjab & Haryana High Court has held it unconstitutional, and the Supreme Court has stayed that ruling. Meanwhile the Tribunal benches have split four ways on what to do with the ground.

  • Jyoti Sareen v. Union of India (P&H HC, 10 September 2026): section 147A unconstitutional, because section 151A and the 2022 scheme it was meant to override were left unamended
  • Supreme Court stay of 18 September 2026, on condition that the assessments do not proceed; final hearing listed for 3 December 2026
  • 31 ITAT orders address section 147A: 6 apply it and reject the JAO ground, 16 send the matter back to await the High Courts, 8 decide on another ground, 1 upholds a quashing without applying it
  • Jaipur and Chennai consistently send the matter back; Guwahati and Bangalore apply the section; Pune decides on the AY 2015-16 time limit instead
  • 909 ITAT orders since 2023 discuss section 151A with the faceless or jurisdictional officer question
Read the full analysis →

Outcome analysis22 September 2026

The assessee wins nearly three out of four appeals at the ITAT

There is no published success rate for the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal in India. We read the outcome of every order on this database from 2024 onwards and split them by who actually brought the appeal — because “allowed” means the appellant won, and one appeal in eight is the Revenue’s.

  • Of 59,912 decided appeals, 87.8% were brought by the assessee and 12.2% by the Revenue
  • An assessee appeal succeeds wholly or partly 72.9% of the time; a Revenue appeal 41.8%, and is dismissed outright in 52.9% of cases
  • A clean win is 44.5% — “partly allowed” accounts for the other 28.5%
  • The rate barely moves across three years: 73.5%, 72.9%, 72.4%
  • By bench it moves enormously: 90.5% in Cuttack against 35.8% in Amritsar — a question worth asking, not evidence of bias
  • “Allowed for statistical purposes” is counted as a remand, not a win; treating it as one adds about a point and a half
Read the full analysis →

Citation analysis18 September 2026

The second most-cited authority in Indian tax litigation is a land acquisition case

Every judgment on this database was scanned for the authorities it relies on, and the references resolved into decisions. The result is a ranking nobody had counted before, and it is dominated at the top not by charging provisions but by the threshold questions of whether the Tribunal will hear an appeal at all.

  • 732,794 citations across 292,668 judgments, resolving to 26,763 distinct decisions
  • National Thermal Power v. CIT leads at 5,796 citing judgments; Collector, Land Acquisition v. Mst. Katiji — a land acquisition case — is second at 3,926
  • 1,000 decisions, under 4% of those ever cited, carry 46.5% of all citation weight
  • Roughly a quarter of citations are to decisions handed down before 2000; the 1970s alone are cited 30,485 times
  • Sections 147 and 148 outrank every charging provision by judgment count
  • 55% of judgments cite no reported authority at all
Read the full analysis →

How these figures are produced

Every judgment on BharatTax is scanned for the law-report citations it contains — references in the form 229 ITR 383 — and the case name in front of each. Those references are resolved into decisions rather than strings, so that a case reported in two series counts once and not twice, and a ranking by how often the corpus relies on a decision becomes possible.

Nothing here is generated from a model’s recollection of Indian tax law. The figures come from the corpus, and the decisions they point to have pages of their own:

  • Landmark cases — the full ranking, with the proposition each decision stands for and every judgment here that follows it.
  • Sections of the Act — the leading authorities on each provision, and the judgments applying it.
  • The judgments themselves — ITAT, High Court and Supreme Court decisions in full text.

A post’s figures are fixed at the date it carries and are not recomputed as the corpus grows, so that a number quoted from it stays checkable.