314 orders · Page 5 of 7
The High Court modified the impugned award. Regarding the first issue, the Court found that the Tribunal's assessment of the appellant's monthly income at Rs. 4,500/- was on the lower side, considering he was an accountant in a private firm. The Court assessed his monthly income at Rs. 6,000/-. Regarding the second issue, applying the principle of adding 40% for future prospects to the revised monthly income of Rs. 6,000/-, the monthly income became Rs. 8,400/-. With 80% disability, the annual loss of income was calculated at Rs. 80,640/-. Using a multiplier of 16 (based on the appellant's age of 31 years, 8 months, and 26 days), the compensation for loss of income was Rs. 12,90,240/-. Adding medical costs (Rs. 4,02,561/-) and compensation for loss of amenities, pain, suffering, and attendant charges (Rs. 40,000/-), the total compensation was determined to be Rs. 17,32,801/-. The Oriental Insurance Company was directed to pay this amount, less any amount already paid, with interest at 6% per annum from the date of the judgment until payment.
The High Court addressed the compensation calculation for the deceased Lionel Michael Noronha. The Tribunal had taken his income as Rs. 5,000/- per month and awarded Rs. 5,80,000/-. The Court noted that the deceased was born on 08.09.1986, making him 22 years old at the time of the accident, thus the multiplier should be 18. While the Tribunal found salary documents (Exhibits P20 and P21) unconvincing, the Court considered the salary certificate (Exhibit P8) and salary register which indicated a monthly income of Rs. 8,000/-. Therefore, the Court found it just and reasonable to take the notional income as Rs. 8,000/- per month. The Court applied 40% towards future prospects and deducted 50% towards personal expenses, as he was a bachelor. This resulted in a loss of dependency of Rs. 12,09,600/-. Additionally, the parents were awarded Rs. 40,000/- each for filial consortium and Rs. 30,000/- under conventional heads, totaling Rs. 13,19,600/-. The Court modified the award to this enhanced amount. MFA No. 2397/2015 filed by the claimants was allowed in part, and MFA No. 8140/2014 filed by the insurance company was dismissed.
The Tribunal held that the present appeal is not maintainable because appellant No. 1, a company, has been struck off the Register of Companies under Section 248 of the Companies Act, 2013. Section 250 of the Act states that a company whose name is removed ceases to operate except for realizing amounts due to or discharging liabilities of the company. The pending proceedings were neither for realizing amounts due to appellant No. 1 nor for discharging its liabilities. The Tribunal distinguished the judgments relied upon by the appellants, stating they pertained to situations where dissolved companies had filed suits for recovery of amounts due to them. The Tribunal also found that the other appellants could not maintain the appeal as they were inducted as sub-tenants by appellant No. 1 or other sub-tenants, and thus had no privity of contract with respondents No. 1 to 5. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed on the ground of maintainability. Regarding the merits, the Tribunal found no ground to interfere with the learned Single Judge's order, noting that the learned Single Judge had segregated the suit for recovery of possession and mesne profits, and the issue of mesne profits was still pending for evidence.
The High Court held that the burden of proof lay on the plaintiffs to establish that suit item Nos. 9 to 12 were purchased from joint family funds. The plaintiffs failed to produce any records to demonstrate that the family possessed surplus funds for such purchases, relying solely on the oral testimony of PW.1. The Court noted that while there is a presumption of a joint family, there is no presumption regarding joint family property. Conversely, defendant No.1 produced evidence (sale deeds, Exs.D2(a) to 3(a), 4 to 6) showing his income from medical practice and as a member of the Legislative Council, indicating a sufficient source of income for acquiring these properties. The First Appellate Court's finding that the plaintiffs failed to prove the existence of a joint nucleus from which defendant No.1 purchased these properties was deemed correct upon re-appreciation of the evidence. Therefore, the substantial questions of law were answered in the affirmative, upholding the First Appellate Court's decision.
The High Court allowed the cross-objection filed by the plaintiff and set aside the judgment and decree of the trial court, thereby decreeing the suit and restraining the defendant from interfering with the plaintiff's peaceful possession. The appeal filed by the defendant was dismissed. The Court found that the plaintiff had successfully established that schedule B property is part and parcel of the layout and is reserved as a road margin, based on documentary evidence including Exs.P12, P13, and P16, and a sketch by BDA officials (Ex.C1). The defendant failed to produce any title documents to substantiate his claim over schedule B property. Furthermore, the defendant's claim over the same 12 guntas of land was previously dismissed by the trial court and confirmed by the High Court in RFA.No.299/2008. The Court held that the trial court had misappreciated the clinching evidence, particularly regarding the road margin and the defendant's lack of title. The Court concluded that the plaintiff was entitled to the discretionary relief of injunction as the defendant's interference was without any semblance of right or title. The findings of the trial court on issues concerning the road margin and the defendant's title were found to be perverse and erroneous.
The Tribunal held that the reliance by the respondents on sale deeds to disentitle the appellants to the 17.03.1988 exemplar was unsustainable. The proximity of the land to developed/posh colonies was admitted by the respondents, and the potentiality of the land must be considered for its foreseeable use, not just its actual agricultural use. The Tribunal found no justification for not applying the value of the 17.03.1988 exemplar. Regarding the categorization and compensation, the Tribunal noted that the LAC gave different categorizations for contiguous villages with similar potentiality and proximity to developed colonies. It observed that the LAC awarded the same compensation (Rs. 27,34/- per Bigha) for lands categorized differently (Sailabi, Khadar, Flooded land). This approach, coupled with the proximity to developed colonies, indicated the government viewed these lands for potential development on an equal scale. Therefore, the vast difference between the award of village Behlolpur Khadar and the other villages was unwarranted. The Tribunal relied on *Union of India v. Bal Ram and Anr.* to state that there is no justification to make any distinction between lands lying in different villages if the purpose of acquisition is the same and the lands are identical and similar, and that it would be unfair to discriminate between landowners. The Tribunal also found that the respondents' emphasis on the land being flooded or in 'Forward Bunds' was not supported by evidence, as the reference to flooding in the Site Inspection Report was based on officials' statements without documentary evidence and would be diluted by waterlogging during heavy rains. The Tribunal found the judgment of the High Court in *Union of India v. Bal Ram and Anr.* to be fair and reasonable. The operative direction was to apply the value of the 17.03.1988 exemplar and to ensure similar compensation in similar areas to avoid discrimination.
The High Court disposed of the appeal on the ground of low tax effect. It noted that the tax effect involved in the appeal was Rs. 16,37,016/-, which was less than the threshold limit of Rs. 1 crore. Therefore, the Revenue was not permitted to pursue the appeal. The Court did not delve into the merits of the substantial questions of law raised by the Revenue. The operative direction was that the appeal stands disposed of on this procedural ground. No issue was expressly left undecided, as the appeal was not decided on its merits.
The High Court of Kerala dismissed the appeals filed by the assessee(s) on the ground that they had availed the option to settle the disputes under the 'Vivad se Viswas' scheme. The Court recorded the statement made by the assessee's counsel and dismissed their appeals accordingly. Similarly, the appeals filed by the Revenue were also dismissed, acknowledging the assessee's settlement under the 'Vivad se Viswas' scheme. The Court clarified that if the assessee(s) could not avail the benefit of settlement or failed to deposit the stipulated amount, they and the Revenue were granted liberty to file a petition for recalling the order and to have their respective appeals heard on merit. The operative direction was the dismissal of all appeals, with liberty to recall.
The Tribunal rejected the revisionist's grounds. Regarding the first ground, it was held that the assessing authority had examined the bill book produced by the revisionist and noted that it did not contain the original bill. This finding was not denied by the revisionist in subsequent appeals. For the second ground, the Tribunal observed that the revisionist had not denied the finding that sales related to bill nos. 107 and 121 were indicated in the list of sales produced before the Assessing Authority. Concerning the third ground, the Tribunal held that the assessment order was passed after issuing a notice, and the revisionist had ample opportunity to rebut findings during the first and second appeals, which they failed to do. The Tribunal cited the Apex Court's decision in Sudarshan Silks & Sarees vs. Commissioner of Income Tax, Karnataka, stating that the Tribunal is the final fact-finding authority. Consequently, no perversity or illegality was found, and no case for interference was made out. The revision and connected revision were dismissed at the admission stage.
The High Court recorded the submission made by the learned standing counsel for the appellant/revenue that the appeal cannot be prosecuted on the ground of low tax effect. Based on this submission, the Court dismissed the appeal on the ground of low tax effect. Consequently, the substantial questions of law that were raised in the appeal were left open and not decided on merits. The operative direction was to dismiss the appeal. No issue was expressly left undecided, as the appeal itself was disposed of on a procedural ground.
The High Court of Karnataka, based on the submission made by the learned counsel for the appellants (the Revenue), held that the appeal was not maintainable. The reasoning provided was solely based on the monetary limits stipulated in Circular No.17 of 2019. Consequently, the Court dismissed the appeal as such. No decision was made on the merits of the original dispute that led to the ITAT's order. The operative direction was to dismiss the appeal.
The High Court noted that substantial questions of law (a) to (d) had been answered in favour of the assessee by a previous Division Bench order in ITA No.230/2008. Regarding substantial question of law (e), it was submitted by both parties that this issue had not been dealt with by the ITAT. Consequently, the parties jointly submitted that the matter should be remitted to the Assessing Officer for a fresh decision on substantial question of law (e). The High Court accepted this joint submission, set aside the orders of the Assessing Officer, CIT(Appeals), and ITAT, and remitted the matter to the Assessing Officer to decide substantial question of law (e) afresh by a speaking order expeditiously. The appeal was disposed of accordingly. The issue of substantial question of law (f) was not expressly decided.
The High Court disposed of the appeal on the grounds of low tax effect, keeping open the questions of law. Liberty was granted to the appellant to apply for restoration of the appeal within three months from the date of the order if they found that the matter was covered by any exceptions in the CBDT circulars. The court explicitly stated that the appeal was disposed of with liberty in the aforementioned terms, and no costs were awarded. Pending interlocutory applications were also disposed of as they did not survive. The specific issues or grounds of appeal were not decided on merits.
The Tribunal's decision to grant recovery rights to the Insurance Company was set aside. The Court found that the report (Ex.RW3/B) claiming the driving licence was fake was based on verbal information and lacked written corroboration from the RTO Allahabad. The witness from the investigating agency admitted to not visiting the RTO himself and not producing the person who did, nor any application for verification. Therefore, it could not be held that the driving licence was fake, and consequently, no recovery rights could be granted. The argument for a 25% addition for future prospects was rejected, upholding the Tribunal's 30% addition, as the deceased's appointment letter (Ex.P4) clearly indicated permanent employment in the Officer's Cadre. The age of the deceased was maintained at 46 years as per the post-mortem report, and the multiplier of 13 was upheld. However, the compensation under conventional heads and loss of consortium was re-calculated based on Supreme Court precedents like National Insurance Company Ltd. vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. The annual income was reassessed to ₹3,39,280/- after deducting income tax. The total compensation was reworked to ₹45,76,374/-. The Insurance Company's appeal was dismissed, the owner's appeal was allowed, and the claimants' cross-objections were allowed.
The High Court answered the first substantial question of law in favour of the assessee, following the decision in CIT, Chennai vs. Tamilnadu Industrial Investment Corporation Limited, which was upheld by the Supreme Court. The Court held that the proviso to Section 36(1)(viia)(a) carves out an exception and can be read independently, especially with the phrase "at its option". For the second and third substantial questions of law, which were clubbed, the Court held that Rule 8D of the Income Tax Rules, 1962, is prospective in operation and not retrospective, following its own decision in PCIT vs. Dhansar Engineering Co. (P) Ltd. Therefore, these questions were answered in favour of the assessee, and the Assessing Officer was directed to re-compute accordingly. The fourth substantial question of law was deemed to be entirely factual and was left undecided as the matter was remanded back to the Assessing Officer for a fresh decision.
The High Court held that since the assessee had settled the dispute with the department and paid the entire amount of disputed tax, the present appeal filed by the Revenue was dismissed as withdrawn. The court explicitly stated that the substantial questions of law were left open, meaning the merits of the original dispute were not decided by the High Court. The operative direction was the dismissal of the appeal as withdrawn. No specific issue was left undecided; rather, the entire appeal was disposed of on procedural grounds related to the settlement.
The Tribunal dismissed the appeal. The reasoning was based on CBDT Circular No. 3/2018, which mandates that appeals should not be filed before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal if the tax effect does not exceed Rs. 20,00,000. The circular also provides for pending appeals below the specified tax limits to be withdrawn or not pressed. Since the tax effect in the present appeal was stated to be less than Rs. 50 lac, and the circular sets a limit of Rs. 20,00,000 for ITAT appeals, the appeal was dismissed. The appellant was granted liberty to revive the appeal if it was not covered by the ambit of the circular. The ratio decidendi is that appeals with a tax effect below the prescribed monetary limits in the CBDT circular should not be pursued.
The High Court granted permission as prayed for by the Revenue. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed as withdrawn. The Court also granted the liberty to the Revenue to revive the appeal in case any discrepancy comes to notice at a later stage, acknowledging that human error cannot be ruled out. The specific findings on the merits of the original appeal are not discussed as the appeal was withdrawn. The ratio decidendi of this order pertains to the procedural aspect of allowing withdrawal of an appeal based on CBDT circulars and tax effect, with a reservation for revival. No issues were expressly left undecided, as the appeal was disposed of on a procedural ground.
The High Court dismissed the appeal filed by the Revenue. The primary reason for dismissal was that the tax effect in the instant appeal was well below the monetary limit of Rs. 2.00 crore for filing appeals before the High Court, as stipulated by CBDT Circular No. 9 of 2024, which amended Circular No. 5 of 2024. The Court noted that if the appeal fell within any exception provided in Circular No. 5 of 2024, the Income Tax Department would be at liberty to seek revival of the appeal. No order as to costs was made. The operative direction was the dismissal of the appeal.
The High Court held that the appeal lacked merit and was dismissed. Regarding the first issue, the Court noted that both parties before the ITAT had conceded that the issue of notional interest from V.B. Desai & Co. was covered by the Tribunal's order dated 28.09.2008 for assessment year 1993-94. The appellant did not dispute before the High Court that the controversy for assessment year 2002-03 was identical to that for assessment year 1993-94, nor did it dispute the findings in the earlier ITAT order. The earlier order had directed deletion of the addition of Rs. 9.02 crores on account of alleged accrued interest, finding that the Special Court had adjudicated that the shares and bonds were given in full and final settlement of the assessee's dues. The High Court found no infirmity in the ITAT's impugned order, which was in conformity with its earlier decision. Regarding the second issue, the Court noted that the appellant's counsel could not point out any concession on a question of law granted before the Tribunal. The substantial questions of law were answered accordingly.
The High Court held that the Tribunal erred in fixing the entire liability on the appellant. It reasoned that in a head-on collision between two vehicles, it is a case of contributory negligence, and absent evidence to the contrary, the liability should be split 50% between the insurers of both vehicles. The Court also found that the Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. was not liable to compensate the claimant as he was the owner-cum-driver of his vehicle and there was no separate policy covering personal liability. Regarding the quantum of compensation, the Court found that the Tribunal wrongly deducted 1/3rd of the income for personal expenses in a disability case and that the claimant, being a practicing advocate, would suffer a loss of earning capacity due to his permanent disability, necessitating the use of the multiplier method. The Court recalculated the compensation, awarding Rs. 5,15,973 for medical/transport, Rs. 1,00,000 for agony, and Rs. 17,05,000 for permanent disability and loss of future earning, totaling Rs. 24,20,973. The appellant was directed to pay 50% of this total amount, after deducting payments already made, with 6% interest.
The Tribunal dismissed the appeal, holding that it was governed by CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. The circular clearly states that appeals shall not be filed before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal where the tax effect does not exceed Rs. 20,00,000. Since the tax effect in the present case was brought to the notice of the court as being less than Rs. 50 lac, and the circular sets a limit of Rs. 20 lac for ITAT appeals, the appeal was deemed not maintainable under the revised guidelines. The Tribunal granted liberty to the appellant (Revenue) to revive the appeal if it was not covered by the ambit of the circular. The ratio decidendi is that departmental appeals must adhere to the monetary limits set by the CBDT for filing appeals, and appeals filed below these limits are liable for dismissal or withdrawal.
The High Court held that the appeal stands dismissed in view of CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. The circular mandates that appeals shall not be filed before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal if the tax effect does not exceed Rs. 20,00,000. Since the tax effect in the present case was less than Rs. 50 lakh (and by implication, less than Rs. 20 lakh for the ITAT stage, which is the relevant limit for appeals before the Tribunal), the appeal was not to be pursued. The Court granted liberty to the appellant (Revenue) to revive the appeal if it was not covered by the ambit of the circular. The ratio decidendi is that departmental appeals are governed by the monetary limits prescribed by the CBDT, and appeals below these limits are to be dismissed or not pressed, unless falling under specific exceptions outlined in the circular.
The High Court of Punjab and Haryana, at Chandigarh, decided that the appeal would not be pursued by the Department. This decision was based on an agreement between the parties that the dispute had been settled under the 'Vivad Se Vishwas Scheme'. Consequently, the appeal was disposed of as not pressed. No findings on the merits of the original dispute were made, and no operative directions were issued other than the dismissal of the appeal. The specific terms of the settlement under the 'Vivad Se Vishwas Scheme' were not elaborated upon.
The High Court disposed of the appeal on the ground of low tax effect, as the tax effect was below the threshold limit fixed by the CBDT. Consequently, the substantial questions of law were left open and not decided on merits. The operative direction was that the appeal stands disposed of on the ground of low tax effect. No specific finding was given on the substantial questions of law, and no issue was expressly left undecided as the appeal was not adjudicated on its merits.
The High Court dismissed the appeal filed by the revenue on the ground of low tax effect. The Court noted that the tax effect was below the threshold limit stipulated by the CBDT Circular, which indicated that the revenue should not pursue such appeals. Consequently, the substantial question of law framed at the time of admission was left open and not decided on merits. The operative direction was the dismissal of the appeal. No other issues were expressly left undecided.
The High Court noted the submission by the learned counsel for the appellant that the appellant had settled the dispute with the department under the Vivad Se Vishwas scheme. Consequently, the appellant prayed for the withdrawal of the instant appeal. The Court, as prayed for, dismissed the present appeal as withdrawn. Any pending miscellaneous applications, if any, were also dismissed as a sequel to the main appeal being withdrawn. No decision was made on the merits of the original dispute.
The High Court of Karnataka considered the memo filed by the assessee's counsel seeking leave to withdraw the appeal. For the reasons assigned in the memo, the Court dismissed the appeal as withdrawn. The judgment does not provide any findings on the merits of the case or the substantial questions of law, as the appeal was withdrawn by the assessee. No specific issue was decided by the Tribunal, and therefore, no ratio can be derived from this judgment on the merits of the case. The operative direction was to dismiss the appeal as withdrawn.
The High Court held that the findings of the CIT(A) and the ITAT were findings of fact based on the relevant evidence on record. Both authorities had concluded that, apart from the retracted statement, there was no material to justify the addition under Section 69 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, especially on a protective basis. The Court found that all investments were recorded in the assessee's books, negating the need for addition. The revenue failed to produce evidence to prove the incorrectness of the transactions declared in the assessee's books. Consequently, the impugned order of the ITAT was not interfered with. The substantial question of law was answered accordingly, and the appeal was dismissed. The principle established is that retracted statements alone, without corroborating evidence, are insufficient to make additions under Section 69, particularly when transactions are duly recorded in the assessee's books.
The Tribunal held that the present appeal is covered by the judgment of a Division Bench of this Court dated 26.02.2026 in ITA-517-2008, titled M/s Vardhman Textiles Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Income Tax and another. Based on the consensus between the parties, the questions of law raised in the appeal were answered in favour of the appellant-assessee. The appeal was allowed in terms of the law laid down in the Vardhman Textiles Ltd. case. Any pending miscellaneous applications were also disposed of. The specific issues decided in the Vardhman Textiles Ltd. case, and thus indirectly in this appeal, are not detailed in the provided text, but the outcome for this appeal is a favorable decision for the assessee.
The High Court held that the broken period interest paid by the assessee (SBI) is an allowable deduction from its business income. The Court distinguished the Supreme Court's decision in Vijaya Bank Ltd. v. Additional CIT, noting that in Vijaya Bank, the interest was offered under Section 18 ('Income from other sources'), whereas in the present case, the assessee has consistently offered the broken period interest income as business income under Section 28 of the Act since its inception. The Court found that the Supreme Court in CIT v. Citibank had held that when income is brought to tax under the head of business under Section 28, the decision in Vijaya Bank Ltd. does not apply. The High Court also referred to the Bombay High Court's decision in American Express International Banking Corporation, which took a similar view. Therefore, the substantial questions of law were answered against the Revenue and in favour of the assessee. The appeals were dismissed.
The Tribunal held that the assessee was entitled to the allowance of interest on borrowed capital used for business purposes. The Tribunal found, based on the evidence on record, that the loans advanced by the assessee to its subsidiaries were funded from its own internal accruals or profits generated from the sale of shares. It noted that the AO had not made any disallowance for similar advances in the original assessment proceedings for the relevant and subsequent assessment years, which demonstrated the acceptance of the source of funds. The Tribunal also referred to the decision in J. K. Industries Ltd. Vs. CIT, stating that if interest-free advances are less than the cash profit generated, it should be presumed that the advances were paid out of the assessee's profits. The High Court, in its review, found no perversity in the Tribunal's findings of fact, which were based on evidence. Therefore, the High Court concluded that the substantial question of law was answered against the revenue.
The High Court noted the submission made by the learned counsel for the appellant that the appellant had expired and the legal representatives could not be traced, leading to a lack of instructions to prosecute the appeal. Consequently, the Court dismissed the appeal for want of prosecution. The dismissal was made with liberty to revive the appeal if the need arises. No decision was made on the merits of the original appeal filed against the ITAT's order.
The High Court held that the expenditure incurred for the replacement of steel rolls used in re-rolling mills should be treated as revenue expenditure. The Tribunal was justified in dismissing the revenue's appeal on this issue. The Court relied on the Supreme Court's decision in CIT vs. Sarvana Spinning Mills P. Ltd., which clarified that 'current repairs' under Section 31(i) are expenditures incurred to preserve and maintain an existing asset, not to bring a new asset into existence or obtain a new advantage. The Court found that the Tribunal had considered the factual aspects in depth, and the revenue could not controvert the factual position. The Court also noted that the CIT(A)'s findings, which were affirmed by the Tribunal, were based on documents considered even by the Assessing Officer. Regarding the second issue of deemed dividend, the Court found no ground to interfere with the Tribunal's conclusion. Consequently, the appeal for AY 2005-06 was dismissed, and the substantial questions of law were answered against the revenue. The appeal for AY 2006-07 was also dismissed due to low tax effect.
The Tribunal noted that the appellant's counsel had informed the court about the circular dated 11.07.2018 of the Department of Revenue to the Central Board of Direct Taxes, which empowered learned counsel to withdraw appeals pending before the High Court if the disputed amount was less than one crore rupees, as per the latest fixation of limits by the Department and enhanced by circular No. 17/2019 dated 08.08.2019. Consequently, based on the aforementioned circular, the learned counsel for the appellant expressed the desire to withdraw the appeal. The High Court, therefore, dismissed the appeal as withdrawn. No specific finding was made on the merits of the case.
The Tribunal's decision is set aside. The Court found that while the definition of 'forest' under the Act excludes land principally used for cultivation of long-duration crops, this exclusion is in contrast to lands not predominantly used for cultivation or not cultivated with long-duration crops. The Court noted that cultivation here and there is insufficient to exclude land, but conversely, plantation throughout is not strictly necessary if the land is used for cultivation and related activities. Based on the Advocate Commissioner's and Expert's reports, which indicated significant cultivation of long-duration crops (coffee, cardamom, arecanut, pepper) with plants of considerable age, the presence of electrified buildings, pump houses, sprinklers, and electric fences, and the absence of undergrowth in the notified land compared to thick undergrowth in adjoining vested forest, the Court concluded that the predominant activity was agriculture of long-duration crops. Therefore, the notified land should be excluded from the definition of 'forest'. The appeal is allowed, and the impugned judgment and notification are set aside concerning the appellants' land.
The High Court allowed the appeal and set aside the conviction. The Court held that the Explanation to Section 13(1) of the PC Act, as it stood at the relevant time, did not mandate that intimation must be given exclusively to the employer. Disclosure in income tax returns or to the investigating officer would also suffice. The Court found that the investigating officer and the trial court erred in not accounting for Rs. 86,500 from NSC proceeds, as evidenced by the bank statement (Ex.D.5). Similarly, the Court held that the appellant had income from agriculture, and Rs. 72,000 of this income should have been accounted for, as evidenced by Ex.D.6, which showed intimation to the Deputy General Manager of Canara Bank. The Court also found error in calculating household expenditure based on gross salary, stating it should be based on net salary. The revised calculation showed the difference between assets and expenditure and income to be Rs. 1,49,699, which was less than 10% of the total income (Rs. 1,89,825.9). Citing the Supreme Court's ratio in Krishnananda Agni Hotri, the Court held that the disproportionate assets were within the permissible limit for acquittal. Additionally, the Court noted that the check period of approximately two years was too short to provide a comprehensive picture, referencing State of Maharashtra v. Pollonji Darabshaw Daruwalla.
The Tribunal's decision to award 6% interest from the date the insurance company was impleaded as a party respondent was modified. The High Court held that the claimants are entitled to interest at 6% per annum from the date of presentation of the claim petition (October 18, 2008) until final realization. Regarding the quantum of compensation for funeral rites, loss of consortium, and loss of love and affection, the Tribunal's award was upheld, and no enhancement was granted. The High Court found that the Tribunal had considered all aspects of the matter, including the evidence and statements of witnesses, when determining the deceased's income. The Tribunal's assessment of the deceased's income as Rs. 10,000/- per annum was deemed reasonable and justified based on the documentary evidence and conflicting witness testimonies presented before it. Therefore, the compensation awarded on account of loss of dependency was not interfered with. The appeal was allowed only to the extent of modifying the interest period.
The High Court held that there is no provision under the Income Tax Act, 1961, for the abatement of appeal proceedings before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal. The Court found that the ITAT's direction to abate the proceedings was not in accordance with the law. Consequently, the High Court disposed of the appeal pending before it and directed that the appeal before the ITAT be revived and restored to its original number. The Tribunal was further directed to decide the appeal within three months, providing adequate opportunities to both parties. The principle derived is that appellate proceedings cannot be abated merely because an issue is raised before a higher court, and the Tribunal must proceed to decide the appeal unless specifically stayed or adjourned for valid reasons not amounting to abatement.
The Tribunal noted that the appeal was directed against an order of the ITAT, Cuttack, and the tax effect was less than Rs. 50 lakhs. The court then extensively quoted CBDT Circular No. 3/2018, which revised the monetary limits for filing departmental appeals. Specifically, it highlighted that appeals shall not be filed before the Appellate Tribunal where the tax effect does not exceed Rs. 20,00,000. The circular also stated that it would apply retrospectively to pending appeals, which could be withdrawn or not pressed. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed. However, the appellant was granted liberty to revive the appeal if it was found not to be covered by the ambit of the circular.
The Tribunal held that the appeal was not maintainable due to the issuance of CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. The circular, issued under Section 268A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, revised the monetary limits for filing departmental appeals. For appeals before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, the monetary limit was set at Rs. 20,00,000. Since the tax effect in the present case was stated to be less than Rs. 50 lakhs, and implicitly less than Rs. 20 lakhs as per the circular's applicability to the ITAT, the appeal was dismissed. The Tribunal granted liberty to the appellant (Revenue) to revive the appeal if it was found not to be covered by the ambit of the circular. The reasoning is based on the explicit directive within the circular to not file appeals where the tax effect does not exceed the specified monetary limits, and to withdraw or not press pending appeals below these limits. The ratio decidendi is that departmental appeals are subject to monetary limits prescribed by the CBDT under Section 268A, and appeals falling below these limits are to be dismissed or withdrawn.
The Tribunal held that the appeal stands dismissed in view of CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. The circular, issued under Section 268A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, revises the monetary limits for filing departmental appeals. Specifically, it states that appeals shall not be filed before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal if the tax effect does not exceed Rs. 20,00,000. Since the tax effect in the instant appeal was brought to notice as being less than Rs. 50 lakhs, and by implication less than the Rs. 20 lakhs threshold for ITAT appeals, the appeal is not maintainable. The appellant (Revenue) is granted liberty to revive the appeal if it is found not to be covered by the ambit of the circular. The ratio decidendi is that departmental appeals must adhere to the monetary limits prescribed by the CBDT for efficient litigation management, unless specific exceptions apply.
The Tribunal held that the appeal stands dismissed in view of CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. The circular mandates that appeals shall not be filed before the ITAT where the tax effect does not exceed Rs. 20,00,000. Since the tax effect in the present appeal was less than Rs. 50 lakh (and implicitly less than Rs. 20 lakh as per the circular's applicability to ITAT), the appeal was not maintainable under the revised guidelines. The Tribunal granted the appellant liberty to revive the appeal if it is found not to be covered by the ambit of the circular. The ratio decidendi is that departmental appeals are subject to monetary limits prescribed by the CBDT under Section 268A, and appeals falling below these limits are to be dismissed or not pressed.
The Tribunal held that the appeal stands dismissed in view of CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. The circular specifies that appeals shall not be filed before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal where the tax effect does not exceed Rs. 20,00,000. Since the tax effect in the present appeal was brought to notice as being less than Rs. 50 lac, and the circular sets a limit of Rs. 20,00,000 for ITAT appeals, the appeal is not maintainable. The Tribunal granted liberty to the appellant (Revenue) to revive the appeal if it is found not to be covered by the ambit of the circular. The ratio decidendi is that departmental appeals are governed by the monetary limits prescribed by the CBDT under Section 268A, and appeals filed below these limits are to be dismissed. The operative direction is the dismissal of the appeal with liberty to revive.
The Tribunal held that the appeal stands dismissed in view of CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. The circular, issued under Section 268A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, revised the monetary limits for filing departmental appeals. For appeals before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), the monetary limit was set at Rs. 20,00,000. The present appeal's tax effect was stated to be less than Rs. 50 lakhs. The Tribunal noted that the circular also applies retrospectively to pending appeals. Therefore, as the tax effect in the present appeal was below the prescribed monetary limit for filing appeals before the ITAT, the appeal was dismissed. The appellant was granted liberty to revive the appeal if it was not covered by the ambit of the circular. The ratio decidendi is that appeals filed by the Revenue before the ITAT, where the tax effect is below the prescribed monetary limit as per CBDT Circular No. 3/2018, are liable to be dismissed.
The Tribunal held that the appeal stands dismissed in view of CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. The circular, issued under Section 268A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, revised the monetary limits for filing departmental appeals, setting a limit of Rs. 20,00,000 for appeals before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal. Since the tax effect in the instant appeal was less than Rs. 50 lakhs (and implicitly less than Rs. 20 lakhs, as per the circular's applicability to the ITAT), the appeal was dismissed. The appellant was granted liberty to revive the appeal if it was found not to be covered by the ambit of the circular. The ratio decidendi is that appeals with a tax effect below the prescribed monetary limits, as per the CBDT circular, are to be dismissed.
The High Court dismissed the appeal filed by the Revenue. The dismissal was based on Circular No. 1/2019 dated 08.08.2019 issued by the CBDT, which enhanced the monetary limits for filing appeals by the Income Tax Department before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunals, High Courts, and Supreme Court to reduce litigation. Paragraph 2 of this circular specifies a monetary limit of Rs. 1 crore for filing an appeal before the High Court. The Court noted that the tax effect in the instant appeal was well below this monetary limit. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed in terms of the aforementioned circular. However, the Court also stated that if the appeal came within the exceptions provided in paragraph 10 of Circular No. 3 of 2018, it would be open to the Income Tax Department to seek revival of the appeal. No order as to costs was made.
The High Court held that the appeal stands dismissed in view of CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. The Court noted that the tax effect in the appeal was less than Rs. 50 lakh, which is the revised monetary limit for filing appeals before the High Court as stipulated in the circular. The Court granted liberty to the appellant to revive the appeal if it is not coming within the ambit of the circular. The reasoning is based on the directive issued by the CBDT under Section 268A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, to reduce litigation by setting monetary limits for departmental appeals. The ratio decidendi is that appeals with a tax effect below the prescribed monetary limits, as per the circular, are not to be pursued, unless specific exceptions apply. The operative direction is the dismissal of the appeal with liberty to revive.