COMM.OF INCOME TAX vs. SANJAY MEMORIAL INST
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court answered the first substantial question of law in favour of the assessee, following the decision in CIT, Chennai vs. Tamilnadu Industrial Investment Corporation Limited, which was upheld by the Supreme Court. The Court held that the proviso to Section 36(1)(viia)(a) carves out an exception and can be read independently, especially with the phrase "at its option". For the second and third substantial questions of law, which were clubbed, the Court held that Rule 8D of the Income Tax Rules, 1962, is prospective in operation and not retrospective, following its own decision in PCIT vs. Dhansar Engineering Co. (P) Ltd. Therefore, these questions were answered in favour of the assessee, and the Assessing Officer was directed to re-compute accordingly. The fourth substantial question of law was deemed to be entirely factual and was left undecided as the matter was remanded back to the Assessing Officer for a fresh decision.
What were the facts?
The assessee, M/s. Indian Bank, filed an appeal before the High Court at Calcutta against an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Kolkata, for the assessment year 2003-2004. The appeal was admitted on substantial questions of law concerning deductions under Section 36(1)(viia)(a) and Section 14A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, and the computation of book profit under Section 115JB. The ITAT had passed the order being challenged by the assessee. The amount in dispute for the deduction under Section 36(1)(viia)(a) was Rs. 140,33,70,000/-. The procedural history involves the assessee's claim for deductions, the Assessing Officer's action, the ITAT's decision, and the subsequent appeal to the High Court.
What were the issues?
The Tribunal had to decide four substantial questions of law: 1. Whether the Tribunal erred in holding that the deduction under the first proviso to Section 36(1)(viia)(a) was alternative to that under sub-clause (a), disallowing the assessee's claim of Rs. 140,33,70,000/- under the first proviso. 2. Whether the Tribunal erred in holding that the proviso to sub-sections (2) and (3) of Section 14A, inserted with effect from April 1, 2007, and Rule 8D, inserted on March 24, 2008, were procedural and retrospective, thus applicable for assessment year 2003-2004. 3. Whether the Tribunal erred in directing the Assessing Officer to decide disallowance under Section 14A as per Rule 8D without first finding that the assessee's claims regarding expenditure for tax-free interest income were incorrect. 4. Whether the Tribunal erred in holding that only provisions for ascertained liabilities/expenses were not to be added back for book profit computation under Section 115JB, and that deductions for provisions for bad and doubtful debts, standard assets, depreciation of investment, fraud and forgery, stationery wastage, and tangible assets were not allowable unless for ascertained liabilities/expenses. Assessee's contentions: The assessee argued for the allowability of deductions under Section 36(1)(viia)(a) and contended that the provisions of Section 14A and Rule 8D were not retrospective. The assessee also argued against the restrictive interpretation of Section 115JB regarding provisions. Revenue's contentions: The revenue contended that the deduction under the first proviso to Section 36(1)(viia)(a) was alternative to sub-clause (a). The revenue likely supported the ITAT's view on the applicability of Section 14A and Rule 8D, and the interpretation of Section 115JB.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 36(1)(viia)(a),Section 14A,Section 115JB
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
OD–4 IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA SPECIAL JURISDICTION (INCOME TAX) ORIGINAL SIDE ITA/70/2011 M/s. INDIAN BANK VS. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-II, KOLKATA BEFORE : THE HON’BLE JUSTICE T.S. SIVAGNANAM And THE HON’BLE JUSTICE HIRANMAY BHATTACHARYYA Date : 20th March, 2023 Appearance : Mr. C. Bhaskaran, Adv. Ms. Swapna Das, Adv. …for the appellant. Mr. Aryak Dutt, Adv. …for the respondent.. The Court : - This appeal filed by the assessee under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act (the Act) is directed against the order dated September 30, 2009 passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal “B” Bench, Kolkata in ITA NO.2486/Kol/2007 for the assessment year 2003-2004. The appeal was admitted on 18.03.2011 on the following substantial questions of law:- “1. Whether the Tribunal below, while interpreting section 36(1)(viia)(a) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, committed substantial error of law in holding that deduction under the first proviso was alternative to that under sub-clause (a) and that no deduction under the first proviso was allowable if deduction had been allowed under sub-clause (a) thereby rejecting the appellant’s
claim for deduction of Rs.140,33,70,000/- under the first proviso ? 2. Whether the Tribunal below committed substantial error of law in holding that the proviso of sub-sections (2) and (3) inserted in Section 14A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 with effect from April 1,2007 and Rule 8D inserted in the Income Tax Rules 1962 on March 24, 2008 was procedural and retrospective and were applicable for the assessment year 2003-2004? 3. Whether the Tribunal below committed substantial error of law in directing the Assessing Officer to decide disallowance under section 14A of the Income-tax Act as per Rules 8D of the Income- tax Rules 1962 without arriving at any finding that the claims of the appellant as regards expenditure incurred in relation to tax free interest income was not correct ? 4. Whether the Tribunal below committed substantial error of law in holding that only provision for ascertained liability/expense was not to be added back in computation of book profit under section 115JB and that the deduction in the appellant’s case in respect of provisions for bad and doubtful debts, standard assets, depreciation of investment, fraud and forgery, stationery wastage and tangible assets could not be allowed unless the same were for ascertained liability/expense ? We have heard Mr. C. Bhaskaran, learned counsel assisted by Ms. Swapna Das, learned advocate for the appellant/assessee and Mr. Aryak Dutt, learned standing counsel for the respondent/revenue.
The first substantial question of law is whether the Tribunal was right in holding that the deduction under the first proviso to Section 36(1)(viia)(a) was alternative to that under sub-clause (a) and that no deduction under the first proviso was allowable if the deduction had been allowed under sub-clause (a). Identical issue was considered in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax, Chennai vs. Tamilnadu Industrial Investment Corporation Limited reported in (2019)112 Taxmann.com 386 (Mad.). The only distinction in the said case was that the respondent assessee in the said case was Public Financial Institution to which sub- clause (c) under the said provision would stand attracted. The question of applying sub-clause(3) in Section 36(1)(viia)(a) does not arise and the proviso cannot be read independently was rejected for the reason that the proviso to sub-clause (c) in Section 36(1)(viia)(a) uses the words “at its option”. The proviso provided that a Public Financial Institution or a State Financial Corporation or a State Industrial Investment Corporation referred to in sub-clause (c) of Section 36(1)(viia)(a) shall, at its option, be allowed to in any of the two consecutive assessment years commencing on or after 1st April, 2003 and ending before 1st April, 2005, deduction in respect of any provision made by it for any assets classified by the Reserve Bank of India as doubtful assets or loss assets in accordance with the guidelines issued by it in this behalf, of an amount exceeding 10% of such assets shows in the books of account of such institution or corporation, as the case may be, on the last day of the previous year. Thus, the Court held that the proviso carves out an exception from the stipulation in sub-clause(c), otherwise the use of the expression “at its option” would lose its significance. The said decision would squarely apply to the case on hand and the only distinction being sub-clause(a) of Section 36(1)(viia)(a) would stand attracted in the case on hand and the said provision was given effect to from the assessment year 2000-01. The decision in the case of Tamilnadu
Industrial Investment Corporation Limited was challenged by the revenue before the Hon’ble Supreme Court and the Special Leave Petition was dismissed as reported in (2019) 112 Taxmann.com 387 (SC). Thus, following the above decision, the substantial question of law no.1 is answered in favour of the assessee. So far as the substantial questions of law nos.2 and 3 are concerned, they could be clubbed together and those questions were considered by this Court in the case of PCIT vs. Dhansar Engineering Co. (P) Ltd. reported in (2022) 135 Taxmann.com 167(Cal.). In the light of the said decision, the procedure under Rule 8D of the Income Tax Rules, 1962 was held to be prospective in operation and not retrospective. Thus, the substantial questions of law nos.2 and 3 are answered in favour of the appellant/assessee and the Assessing Officer is directed to do the re- computation bearing in mind the above legal principle. So far as the substantial question of law no.4 is concerned, we are of the view that it is entirely factual and moreover the matter is remanded back to the Assessing Officer for a fresh decision in the matter and, therefore, the substantial question of law no.4 need not be answered in this appeal. In the result, the appeal (ITA/70/2011) is allowed to the extent indicated leaving the substantial question of law no.4 unanswered on the above reason. (T.S. SIVAGNANAM, J.)
(HIRANMAY BHATTACHARYYA, J.) pkd/GH/AS/s.pal
More judgments on Section 14A
- Mpg Hotels and Infrastructure Ventures Pvt… vs Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Central…ITA 309/COCH/2025[2010-11]Status: Disposed6 Nov 2026AY 2010-11
- Delite Infrastructure Private Limited, New… vs Assistant Commissioner of Income-Tax…ITA 954/DEL/2024[2017-18]Status: Disposed30 Oct 2026AY 2017-18
- Blacksoil Capital Private Limited (As… vs DCIT, Circle-1(1), HyderabadITA 2217/HYD/2026[2017-18]Status: Disposed9 Oct 2026AY 2017-18
- Hiral Construction, Mumbai vs ITO Ward 42(1)(2), MumbaiITA 8431/MUM/2025[2017-18]Status: Disposed8 Oct 2026AY 2017-18
- The Dy DIT (It) 1(2), Mumbai vs M/S Citi Bank N.A, MumbaiITA 4981/MUM/2007[2002-2003]Status: Disposed8 Oct 2026AY 2002-2003
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Jishu Suklabaidya vs. The Union Of INDIA And 16 Ors.Gauhati · 4 Nov 2026
- M/S Sun Shine Metal Works vs. State Of U.P And AnotherAllahabad · 4 Nov 2026
- M/S Bansal Sanitary Store vs. State Of U.P. And 2 OthersAllahabad · 4 Nov 2026
- M/S Princess Girls Collection vs. State Of U.P. And AnotherAllahabad · 4 Nov 2026
- Prabhat Kumar vs. The State Of BiharPatna · 4 Nov 2026