COMNR.OF INCOME TAX vs. M/S.KASI SALESandSERVI
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court allowed the cross-objection filed by the plaintiff and set aside the judgment and decree of the trial court, thereby decreeing the suit and restraining the defendant from interfering with the plaintiff's peaceful possession. The appeal filed by the defendant was dismissed. The Court found that the plaintiff had successfully established that schedule B property is part and parcel of the layout and is reserved as a road margin, based on documentary evidence including Exs.P12, P13, and P16, and a sketch by BDA officials (Ex.C1). The defendant failed to produce any title documents to substantiate his claim over schedule B property. Furthermore, the defendant's claim over the same 12 guntas of land was previously dismissed by the trial court and confirmed by the High Court in RFA.No.299/2008. The Court held that the trial court had misappreciated the clinching evidence, particularly regarding the road margin and the defendant's lack of title. The Court concluded that the plaintiff was entitled to the discretionary relief of injunction as the defendant's interference was without any semblance of right or title. The findings of the trial court on issues concerning the road margin and the defendant's title were found to be perverse and erroneous.
What were the facts?
The plaintiff, Sri V Nagendra, filed a suit for declaration and permanent injunction against the defendant, Sri A J Ishwar Kumar, concerning a property identified as schedule B. The plaintiff claimed ownership of a site purchased in 1993, formed by the Income Tax Department Co-Operative Housing Society Limited. He asserted that the northern boundary of his property was a road, with a 53 ft road margin between the main road and his site. The defendant contested this, claiming his grandfather, Musalappa, originally owned Survey No. 6/2, retained 12 guntas, and the defendant inherited this 'suit schedule B property', which he alleged was falsely claimed by the plaintiff as a road margin. The defendant admitted the plaintiff's title to schedule A property. The trial court dismissed the plaintiff's suit.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the Trial Court erred in not granting perpetual injunction to the plaintiff, and therefore, is the cross-objection filed by the plaintiff liable to be allowed? (This issue relates to the plaintiff's right to an injunction under Section 38 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963, and the court's discretion under Section 36). 2. Whether the findings recorded by the Trial Court on Issue Nos. 2 and 3 suffer from infirmities and warrant interference by the High Court? (These issues pertain to the defendant's claim of ownership and saleable title over schedule B property). Assessee's (Plaintiff's) Contentions: The plaintiff argued that schedule B property is part of the layout and is a reserved road margin, supported by documents like Ex.P12 (conversion order) and Ex.P13 (conversion sanction certificate), which mandated a 50 ft road margin, and Ex.P16 (approved layout plan). He contended that the defendant has no right over schedule B property and his interference warrants an injunction. The plaintiff also relied on the dismissal of a previous suit filed by the defendant seeking title over 12 guntas. The plaintiff argued that the trial court misappreciated the evidence and erred in dismissing the suit. Revenue's (Defendant's) Contentions: The defendant contended that schedule B property was originally owned by his grandfather, Musalappa, who retained 12 guntas after selling Survey No. 6/2, and that the defendant inherited this property. He claimed this was falsely identified as a road margin by the plaintiff. The defendant admitted the plaintiff's title to schedule A property.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 22ND DAY OF APRIL, 2022
BEFORE
THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
R.F.A NO.1180 OF 2010(DEC/INJ) C/W R.F.A CROB NO.38 OF 2013
IN RFA NO.1180/2010 BETWEEN:
SRI. V NAGENDRA S/O LATE VENKATARAMANAIAH AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS R/AT NO.26, NAGENDRA NILAYA 1ST MAIN, II CROSS, KRISHNAIAHNA PALYA, INDIRANAGARA POST, BANGALORE-560038 ...APPELLANT (BY SRI.A KUMARAVEL, ADVOCATE)
AND: SRI. A J ISHWAR KUMAR S/O A M JAGADISAN AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS R/AT NO.21, RAJARAJESHWARI, INCOME TAX LAYOUT, SADANANDA NAGARA, BANGALORE-560038 …RESPONDENT (BY SRI.B.N.PRAKASH, ADVOCATE FOR M/S LAWYERS INC FOR R1)
THIS RFA IS FILED U/S 96 OF CPC AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED: 18.03.2010 PASSED IN OS.8385/2005 ON THE FILE OF THE XVII-ADDL. CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE,(CCH-16), BANGALORE, DISMISSING SUIT FOR DECLARATION AND PERMANENT INJUNCTION.
IN RFA CROB NO.38/2013 BETWEEN:
SRI A J ISHWAR KUMAR S/O A M JAGADEASAN AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS RAJARAJESHWARI NO 21, INCOME TAX LAYOUT, SADHANANDA NAGAR BANGALORE-560 038 ...CROSS OBJECTOR (BY SRI.B.N.PRAKASH, ADVOCATE FOR M/S LAWYERS INC)
AND: SRI V NAGENDRA S/O LATE VENKATARAMANAIAH AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS NO 26, NAGENDRA NILAYA I MAIN, 2ND CROSS, KRISHNAYYAPALYA INDIRANAGAR POST BANGALORE-560 038 …RESPONDENT (BY SRI.A.KUMARAVEL, ADVOCATE)
THIS RFA.CROB IS FILED U/O 41, RULE-22 OF CPC, AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED: 18.03.2010 PASSED IN O.S.8365/2005 ON THE FILE OF THE XVII-ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE, CCH-16, BENGALURU CITY, DISMISSING SUIT FOR DECLARATION AND PERMANENT INJUNCTION.
THESE RFA AND RFA CROB HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR JUDGMENT ON 25.03.2022, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENT THIS DAY, COURT DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
JUDGMENT
The captioned appeal is filed by the defendant in O.S.No. 8365/2005 questioning the findings recorded by the Court below on Issue Nos.2 and 3. Cross-objection is filed by the plaintiff in O.S.No.8365/2005.
For the sake of convenience, the parties are referred to as per their rank before the trial Court.
The brief facts of the case are as under:
3(a) The plaintiff claims to be the owner of the site in the layout formed by the Income Tax Department Co- Operative Housing Society Limited. The plaintiff has purchased a site under registered sale deed dated 2.9.1993. The plaintiff claims that Society has formed a layout after obtaining approval of the layout plan from the then City
Improvement Trust Board. As per the layout plan, plaintiff claims, the northern boundary of the property purchased by him is a road. The plaintiff has also contended that between the main road and the property owned by the plaintiff there is a road margin of 53 ft. The plaintiff's grievance that defendant without having any semblance of right is trying to interfere and therefore, the present suit was filed.
3(b) The defendant on receipt of summons contested the proceedings and contended that his grand father Musalappa, who was the original owner having sold Survey No.6/2 has retained 12 guntas and after his death the defendant claims that he has inherited the suit schedule 'B' property which is falsely claimed by the plaintiff as a road margin. The defendant however admitted title of plaintiff insofar as schedule A property is concerned and hence, prayed for dismissal of the suit.
3(c) The Trial based on rival contentions formulated the following issues:
"1. ಾೆ ' ' ೆಡೂ ¸Àéತು ರೆ ಮತು ೋ ಾ ಇೆಂದು ಾ ರುಜುಾತು ಪ#$ಾ%&ೇ?
()ತ ೇ+,ೆಯ .ಾ ಾ 3ರ(/ ೇ+ದಂ0ೆ ' ' ೆಡೂ ಸ2ತು ತನ4 0ಾತನ ಸ20ೆಂದು ಪ56ಾ ರುಜುಾತುಪ#$ಾ%&ೇ?
()ತ ೇ+,ೆಯ .ಾ ಾ 1ರ(/ ೇ+ದಂ0ೆ ತನ8ೆ '©' ೆಡೂ ಸ2ತನು4 9ೇೆ ವ ;8ೆ ಾಾಟ ಾಡಲು ಹಕು@ ಇ0ೆಂದು ಪ56ಾ ರುಜುಾತು ಪ#$ಾ%&ೇ?
' ' ೆಡೂ ಸ26ನ(/ ಪ56ಾ ಕಟBಡ ಕಟBಲು ಪ5ಯ64$ದಂದು ಾ ರುಜುಾತು ಪ#$ಾ%&ೇ?
ಾ ಯು ಾಶ2ತ Eಬಂಧ,ಾHೆ ಪIೆಯಲು ಅಹEಾ%&ೇ?
ಏನು ಆೇಶ ಅಥಾ #Qæ?"
3(d) The plaintiff in support of his contention examined himself as P.W.1 and got marked documents vide Exs.P1 to 17. The defendant examined himself as D.W.1 and got marked Exs.D1 to D23.
3(e) The Trial Court having assessed the oral and documentary evidence answered issue No.1 in the negative by holding that plaintiff has failed to prove that schedule B property is a road margin. While answering Issue Nos.2 and 3, the learned Judge held that the defendant has failed to prove
that schedule B property was originally owned by his grand father Musalappa and further held that defendant has also failed to prove that he has a saleable title insofar as schedule B property is concerned.
Feeling aggrieved by the same, the defendant has preferred this regular first appeal.
Heard the learned counsel for the defendant and learned counsel appearing for the plaintiff. Perused the pleadings, oral and documentary evidence.
The following points would arise for consideration:
(1) Whether the Trial Court erred in not granting perpetual injunction and therefore, the cross-objection filed in Crob.No.38/2013 is liable to be allowed?
(2)Whether the finding recorded by the Trial Court on Issue Nos.2 and 3 suffers from infirmities and warrants interference at the hands of this Court?
Regarding Point No.1:
6(a) The plaintiff's specific case is that schedule B property is a part and parcel of the layout formed in Survey No.6/2. The plaintiff to substantiate his claim has relied on the official memorandum for having sanctioned conversion as per Ex.P12. On perusal of Ex.P12, this Court would find that as per condition No.4, the society was required to leave road margin of 50 ft.
It would be useful for this Court to cull out clauses (4) and (5) of Ex.P12, which is the conversion order passed by the Deputy Commissioner, Bengaluru, which reads as under: "4. A road margin of 50(fifty) feet from the centre of the cart track (approach) Road to the nearest edge of the structures should be reserved, vacant and no constructions should be put up within this road margin per G.O.No.PWD.7556-665 R B.8-54-5 dt: 12.02.1955.
Other required road margins and open spaces etc., should also be reserved in the area as per rules and specifications of the C.I.T.B Bangalore and layout and other charges should also be paid to C.I.T.B. Bangalore in full as fixed by them."
It would be also useful for this Court to cull out clauses 4 and 5 of Ex.P13, which is the conversion sanction certificate issued by the Tahsildar, Bengaluru: "4. A road margin of 50(fifty) feet from the centre of the cart track (approach) Road to the nearest edge of the structures should be reserved, vacant and no constructions should be put up within this road margin per G.O.No.PWD.7556-665 R and B.8-54-5 dated: 12.02.55.
Other required road margins and open spaces etc., should also be reserved in the area as per rules and specifications of the C.I.T.B Bangalore and layout and other charges should also be paid to C.I.T.B. Bangalore in full as fixed by them."
Exs.P12 and P13 if examined along with Ex.P16, which is the approved layout plan, the existence of road margin is clearly reflected in Ex.P16. If the clinching evidence vide Exs.P12, 13 and 16 coupled with the sketch produced by the BDA Official as per Ex.C1 is examined, this Court would find that defendant has no semblance of right over schedule B property. On the contrary, the plaintiff who is the owner of the site has succeeded in establishing that schedule B property is part and
parcel of the layout and the same is reserved as a road margin.
6(b) Be that as it may, the clinching evidence on record would indicate that schedule B property is part and parcel of the layout formed in Survey No.6/2. Defendant who is asserting title has not at all produced any title documents nor has produced any document indicating that his grand father retained 12 guntas of land as claimed by the defendant. In O.S.No.5888/1993 wherein the suit filed by present defendant who is the plaintiff therein seeking the relief of declaration of title over 12 guntas of land under an unregistered gift deed and in the alternative to grant the relief of declaration of title by way of adverse possession has been dismissed by the Trial this in the connected appeal i.e. RFA.No.299/2008 arising out the aforesaid suit has confirmed the judgment and decree of the Trial Court.
6(c) If the claim of the defendant is rejected in the connected suit and if no documents are produced in the
present suit to establish his title, then I am of the view that plaintiff is entitled for injunction as the defence set up by the defendant in the present case on hand without any semblance of right and title amounts to interference. The clinching evidence on record is not at all properly appreciated by the Trial Court. The evidence led by the plaintiff establishes his lawful possession. The schedule B property is abutting to plaintiff's property and the defendant is high handedly claiming right and title over schedule B property. Therefore, both the requisite ingredients to seek discretionary relief of injunction exists in the present case on hand. The learned Judge has virtually misread the entire evidence on record and has therefore, committed an error in not properly appreciating the evidence on record.
6(d) It is a trite law that irrespective of whether injunction sought is temporary or perpetual, the jurisdiction to grant injunction is discretionary. Although the words 'in its discretion' are absent from Sections 38 and 41, but the
language of Section 36 renders the remedy under both the sections discretionary. It is also trite law that plaintiff must seek injunction with clean hands. Therefore, equitable relief of permanent injunction has to be granted in the present case on hand and this Court is of the view that defendant is guilty on account of his inequitable conduct. The claim made by the plaintiff is fair. The propriety of granting an injunction depends upon the facts of each particular case and the general principle of equity as related to injunctions and the discretion that has to be exercised by the Court has to be judicial discretion and the Court has to take note of the fact that by granting injunction should not result in oppression and injury to the other side. It is a trite law that Courts will not grant injunction when good conscience does not require it, where it will cause injustice. The present set of facts also does indicate that it would be reasonable and equitable to grant an injunction to the plaintiff. If injunction is granted, it will tend to promote justice. It is a trite law that to grant injunction
plaintiff has to establish his right. The existence of right and consequent violation are pre-requisite condition to grant an injunction. An injunction will not issue to protect a right which is not lawful and legal. Therefore, in the present set of facts and circumstances and having regard to the clinching evidence led in by plaintiff, this Court is of the view that plaintiff is entitled for discretionary relief of injunction.
Accordingly, point No.1 is answered in the affirmative by holding that the plaintiff is entitled for injunction.
Regarding point No.2:
While discussing point No.1 in the preceding paragraph this Court has recorded a finding that defendant has failed to establish his title over schedule B property. The suit filed by the present defendant in O.S.5888/1993 is dismissed by the Trial Court and the same is confirmed by this Court in RFA.No. 299/2008. This Court has held that present defendant would not acquire any right and title on the basis of an unregistered gift deed. This Court has also rejected the claim of the
defendant in regard to plea of adverse possession. Therefore, the findings recorded by the Trial Court on Issue Nos.2 and 3 do not suffer from any infirmities and would not warrant interference at the hands of this Court. Accordingly, point No.2 is answered in the negative.
In view of the findings recorded by this Court supra, following conclusions are recorded:
(i)The Trial Court erred in dismissing the suit thereby declining to grant injunction in favour of plaintiff.
(ii)The finding of the Trial Court that plaintiff has failed to establish existence of road margin and schedule B property is perverse and contrary to the clinching evidence on record vide Exs.P12, 13 and P16 and also the sketch prepared by the BDA officials as per Ex.C1.
(iii)The Trial Court has not at all properly appreciated the clinching evidence on record. The defendant is asserting right on the basis of the sale deed and gift deed executed by one Nagaveni and Kumaravelu. In the connected appeal bearing
RFA.No.299/2008, this Court has held that defendant's vendor has failed to establish his title either under the alleged gift deed or by way of adverse possession. Therefore, the present defendant who is asserting title under his vendors would not get any better title and since there is tangible evidence indicating interference by defendant, the Trial Court erred in dismissing the suit.
(iv)The findings and conclusions arrived at by the Trial Court is contrary to the clinching evidence on record and therefore, the findings recorded on Issue Nos.1 to 3 and 5 being palpably erroneous is liable to be reversed by this Court.
For the foregoing reasons, I pass the following:
ORDER
The cross-objection in RFA.Crob.38/2013 is allowed. The judgment decree dated 18.03.2010 passed in O.S.No.*8365/2005 by the XVII Additional City Civil and Sessions Judge, Bengaluru, is set aside. Consequently, suit is * Corrected vide Chamber order dated: 10.01.2024.
decreed restraining defendant from interfering with plaintiff's peaceful possession.
Consequently, the appeal filed in RFA.1180/2010 is dismissed.
Office to draw the decree accordingly.
Sd/- JUDGE
*alb/-
More judgments on Section 38
- Asokan Ramadass, Coimbatore vs DCIT, Ncc-2, CoimbatoreITA 1003/CHNY/2026[2024-25]Status: Disposed6 Nov 2026AY 2024-25
- Asokan Ramdass, Coimbatore vs ACIT, Ncc-2, CoimbatoreITA 1002/CHNY/2026[2022-23]Status: Disposed6 Nov 2026AY 2022-23
- Asokan Ramdass, Coimbatore vs ACIT Ncc-2, CoimbatoreITA 1001/CHNY/2026[2021-22]Status: Disposed6 Nov 2026AY 2021-22
- ACIT Circle 3(2)(1), Mumbai vs The National Bank for Agriculture and Rural…ITA 1963/MUM/2026[2023-24]Status: Disposed16 Oct 2026AY 2023-24
- Gurudatta Nagari Sahakari Pathsanstha… vs ITO Ward 14(3), PuneITA 51/PUN/2026[2018-19]Status: Disposed15 Oct 2026AY 2018-19
Latest GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Puran Singh Fartyal vs. Khushal SinghUttarakhand · 18 Nov 2026
- Rama Gupta Construction vs. State Of UttarakhandUttarakhand · 18 Nov 2026
- Abhay Kumar Sharma vs. State Of OdishaOrissa · 18 Nov 2026
- Sunita Pandey vs. State Of UttarakhandUttarakhand · 17 Nov 2026
- Ashutosh Gupta vs. The Commissioner Central Goods And Services TaxUttarakhand · 17 Nov 2026