8 orders · Page 1 of 1
The High Court dismissed the appeal filed by the Revenue. The dismissal was based on the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) Circular No. 17 of 2019, dated August 8, 2019, which amended Circular No. 3 of 2018. This circular enhanced the monetary limits for filing appeals to reduce litigation. The monetary limit for filing an appeal before the High Court was fixed at Rs. 1.00 crore. In the present appeal, the tax effect was Rs. 19,47,918.00, which is well below the prescribed monetary limit. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed on this procedural ground. The court noted that if the appeal fell within the exceptions under paragraph 10 of Circular No. 3 of 2018, the Revenue could seek revival of the appeal. No decision was made on the substantial questions of law.
The Tribunal erred in upholding the reassessment. The Court held that the Assessing Officer's jurisdiction to reopen assessment under Section 147 is not a power of review and cannot be exercised based on a mere change of opinion. Reassessment requires specific, reliable, and relevant information that comes to the AO's possession subsequently, indicating an omission or failure by the assessee to disclose material facts, or fresh facts that expose untruthfulness. Mere oversight, inadvertence, or a mistake committed by the AO does not constitute grounds for reassessment. The AO in this case relied on *Kalyanji Mavji & Co.*, ignoring subsequent Supreme Court judgments in *Indian & Eastern Newspaper Society* and *A.L.A. Firm* which did not accept the former's view regarding reassessment based on existing judgments. The reassessment was necessitated by the AO's misunderstanding of legal precedents that existed at the time of the original assessment. Therefore, the reassessment proceedings were without jurisdiction. Substantial questions of law 1 and 2 were answered in favour of the assessee. Question 3 was rendered unnecessary. The impugned orders were set aside.
The High Court of Delhi, considering the submission made by the Revenue's counsel, held that the appeal should be dismissed on account of low tax effect. The court noted that the tax effect was below the stipulated threshold limit of ₹2,00,00,000/- as per the Circular dated 17.09.2024 and did not fall under any of the exceptions mentioned therein. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed without delving into the merits of the ITAT's order. No specific finding on the ITAT's order itself was made.
The High Court allowed the appeal to be withdrawn. The Court noted the submission of the learned Senior Standing Counsel for the appellant (revenue) that the appeal could be withdrawn as per CBDT Circular No. 17 of 2019, dated 08.08.2019, if the tax effect is below Rs. 1.00 crore. The Court also took into consideration that the subject matter of the appeal was covered by a previous judgment of the High Court in ITTA No. 163 of 2019, which had considered the said circular. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed as withdrawn. The Court granted liberty to the appellant to file an application for restoration of the appeal if it is later found that the subject matter falls within the exceptions mentioned in the circular. No order as to costs was made. Any pending miscellaneous applications were also disposed of as infructuous.
The High Court partly allowed the appeal. Regarding schedule A property, the court held that the sale deed (Ex.B.B) clearly shows it was executed in favour of the first defendant for valid consideration, and there is no mention of late S.V. Rama Murthy paying the sale consideration. Therefore, schedule A property is the exclusive property of the first defendant, and the plaintiff is not entitled to any share in it. The trial court's decree to this extent was modified. Concerning schedule E property, the court held that while nomination in insurance policies or service records is for convenience, it does not divest the law of succession. The nominee is not entitled to the entire amount to the exclusion of class-I heirs. Since late S.V. Rama Murthy died intestate, the insurance amount and pensionary benefits are his self-acquired properties, and the plaintiff and defendants 1 to 5 are class-I heirs entitled to an equal share. The trial court's finding that the plaintiff is entitled to a 1/6th share in schedule E property was sustained. The appeal was dismissed in respect of schedule E property. The operative direction was to modify the preliminary decree concerning schedule A property and sustain it for schedule E property.
The High Court allowed the appeal in favour of the assessee. The Court referred to its earlier judgment concerning the same assessee for assessment years 1991-92 and 1992-93. It noted that while the Corporation initially did not accept the liability for survey expenses, it subsequently accepted it for the year 1992-93 and showed it in its books of account under the mercantile system. The Court found that the survey expenses were almost identical and required to be allowed as revenue expenses. Applying the principles from the Supreme Court's judgment in Empire Jute Co. Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Income Tax, the Court held that expenses which yield fruitful results and are necessary for the relevant time and development, in line with the nature of the expenses, cannot be considered capital expenses and must be treated as revenue expenses. Therefore, the issue was answered in favour of the assessee and against the department.
The Tribunal's finding that the Insurance Company failed to discharge its burden of proving that the truck driver lacked a valid driving licence was upheld. The Court reasoned that the investigation report was laconic and the investigator did not contact the driver or owner. The burden on the Insurance Company, as per the ruling in Yogesh (supra), was not discharged by merely issuing a notice. Regarding the compensation for Mal Chand's death, the Court found that while the Income Tax Return filed after his death was questionable, the Tribunal's average income assessment and use of multiplier 8, in light of the excessive multiplicand, was justified and did not warrant interference. For Kaushal Kumar's death, the Court found the multiplicand just and proper but noted the multiplier of 11 was less than the 14 indicated in Sarla Verma (supra). Consequently, Smt. Pushpa Devi was awarded an additional Rs. 72,000/- with interest. The compensation for Smt. Pushpa Devi's injuries, totaling Rs. 65,000/-, was deemed just and proper based on the evidence, including 7-8% permanent disablement and lack of proof of income, and did not require interference. The appeals by the Insurance Company and two cross-objections were dismissed, while one cross-objection was partly allowed.
The High Court held that the investment made by the assessee in its joint venture companies, namely Sudha Modern Dhall Mill Limited, Delta Oils & Fats Limited, Sri Gumvaurappan Swamy Oil Foods & Fats Limited, and Godavari Edible Bran Oil Limited, constituted a violation of Section 11(5) read with Section 13(1)(d) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. This was because the investments were made in shares of companies that were not Government Companies or corporations established under Central or provincial Acts, and the shares were held beyond the cut-off date of November 30, 1983. Consequently, the assessee was not entitled to claim the benefit of exemption under Section 11 of the Act for these investments. However, the Court clarified that only the income derived specifically from such an investment made in violation of Section 13(1)(d) of the Act is liable to tax, and not the entire income of the assessee. The Court relied on decisions from the Bombay, Delhi, and Karnataka High Courts, and noted the dismissal of a Special Leave Petition by the Supreme Court in a similar matter. The orders of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal were modified to this extent.