COMMNR.INCOME TAX vs. ORIENTAL SECURITY
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court partly allowed the appeal. Regarding schedule A property, the court held that the sale deed (Ex.B.B) clearly shows it was executed in favour of the first defendant for valid consideration, and there is no mention of late S.V. Rama Murthy paying the sale consideration. Therefore, schedule A property is the exclusive property of the first defendant, and the plaintiff is not entitled to any share in it. The trial court's decree to this extent was modified. Concerning schedule E property, the court held that while nomination in insurance policies or service records is for convenience, it does not divest the law of succession. The nominee is not entitled to the entire amount to the exclusion of class-I heirs. Since late S.V. Rama Murthy died intestate, the insurance amount and pensionary benefits are his self-acquired properties, and the plaintiff and defendants 1 to 5 are class-I heirs entitled to an equal share. The trial court's finding that the plaintiff is entitled to a 1/6th share in schedule E property was sustained. The appeal was dismissed in respect of schedule E property. The operative direction was to modify the preliminary decree concerning schedule A property and sustain it for schedule E property.
What were the facts?
The appellants/defendants are challenging a judgment and decree dated November 6, 2002, from the IV Senior Civil Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad, passed in OS No. 317 of 1997. The original suit was filed by the respondent/plaintiff for partition and allotment of her 1/6th share in suit schedule properties A to E. The trial court partly decreed the suit, granting the plaintiff a share in schedule A and E properties, but dismissed the claim for B, C, and D properties. The defendants contend that schedule A property is the exclusive property of the first defendant, purchased in 1975, and that the trial court erred in holding it was purchased with the salary of the deceased S.V. Rama Murthy. They also argue that schedule E property, comprising insurance and pensionary benefits, was received by the first defendant with the consent of other appellants.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the impugned judgment and decree dated 06.11.2002 of the trial court is sustainable? 2. Whether the plaintiff is able to establish that schedule-A & E properties are the joint family properties of both plaintiff and defendants 1 to 5 and entitled for 1/6th share each? 3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for 1/6th share in the schedule-E property as claimed? Assessee's arguments: The impugned judgment and decree are based on erroneous conclusions contrary to settled legal principles. Schedule A property is the exclusive property of the first defendant, purchased in 1975 under Ex.B.B, and there is no evidence that it was purchased with the salary of late S.V. Rama Murthy. The trial court should have dismissed the suit in respect of schedule A property. Schedule E property, consisting of insurance and pensionary benefits, was received by the first defendant with the consent and knowledge of appellants 2 to 5. Revenue's arguments: No arguments were recorded for the respondent/revenue.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY FOURTH DAY OF AUGUST TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY TWO PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A.VENKATESHWARA REDDY C.C.C.A. NO: 28 OF 2003 Appeal under Section 96 of Code of Civil Procedure aggrieved by the Judgment and decree dated 0611112002 made in OS No.317 of 1997 on the file of the Court of the lV Senior Civil Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad. Between: 1. Smt. S.Radhamma, W/o late S.V. Rama Murthy Household 2. S.Ratnababu, S/o late S.V. Rama Murthy Doctor 3. S.Ajay Kumar, S/o late S.V. Rama Murthy Service All R/o H.No.1-8-588/10/A, Achaiah Nagar, Bagh Lingampally, Hyderabad. 4. Smt. S.Ratnamala, Wo Sadanand Household No 1-9-25219/50, Near Municipal Park, East MCH Colony, Parsigutta, Hyderabad. 5. Smt. S.Revathi, W/o S. Anjaneyulu Household F/o HMT Colony, Nacharam Road' HYderabad ...A''ELLANTS AND Smt. S. Ratnakala, W/o K. Narsimha Household Rl/o H.No.1-9-911N211, Ram Nagar, Hyderabad ...RESPONDENT Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to suspend the operafion ofjudgment and decree dated 0611112002 passed in OS No.317 of 1997 on the file of the Fourth Senior Civil Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad. For the Appellants : SRI P.NARASING RAO, Advocate For the Respondent : NONE APPEARED The Court made the following: JUDGMENT CMP. NO: 1362 OF 2003
THE HON,BLE SRI JUSTICE A. VENKATESHWARA REDDY CCCA No.28 of 2OO3 JUDGMENT: The appellants/defendants have filed this Appeal assailing the judgment and decree dated 06.11.2002 in OS No.317 of 7997 on the file of the learned IV Senior Civil Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad. 2. The plaintifl has filed the original suit No.317 of 1997 for partition and allotment of her 1/6tr share in suit schedule A to E properties. After full length trial, the suit of the plaintiff was partly decreed only in respect of schedule A & E properties, whereas the suit was dismissed in respect of schedule B, C and D properties. 3. Assailing the said findings recorded by the triai Court, the defendants have filed this appeal on the following grounds: i) that the impugned judgment and decree is based on the erroneous conclusions which are contra-ry to the settied principles of law.
Page 2 of 20 AVRJ CCCA No.28 of 2003 ii) that the plaint A-schedule is the exclusive property of 1"t defendant. She has purchased the same under Ex.B.B in the year 1975, but the trial Court fell in error in passing a preliminary decree for partition of plaint A & E schedule properties holding that schedule-A property rvas purchased under Ex.B.B with the salary ol late S.V. Rama Murthy. There is no evidence to that effect on record. iii) that the trial Court ought to have dismissed the suit of the plaintiff 1n respect of schedule-A property also. Though the defendants have placed clinching evidence to falsify the suit claim of the plaintiff, the trial Court has wrongly decreed the suit in respect of schedule-A & E properties. iv) that schedule-E property is the insurance amount of Rs.1,OO,OO0/- and the pensionary benefits of Rs.4,O0,OO0/- of late S.V. Rama Murthy. The 1"t defendant has received the said amount with the consent and knowledge of appellalts 2 to 5 /defendants 2 to 5.
Page 3 of 20 AV RJ CCCA No.28 of 2003 4. Heard learned counsei ior the appellants/ defendants and in spite of granting ample opportunity, none appeared on behalf of the respondents. Accordingly the appeal was treated as heard. 5. In the light of the material available on record and the grounds ol appeal, the points arise for my consideration are: i) whether the impugned judgment and decree dated 06.11.2012 of the trial Court is sustainable? whether the plaintiff is able to establish that schedule-A & E properties are the joint family properties of both plaintiff and defendants 1 to 5 and entitled for I /6tn share each? and ii) iii) whether share the plaintiff is entitled for 1/6th in the schedule-E property as claimed? 6. Since all the above issues are interrelated, to avoid repetition and for the sake of convenience, it is proposed to answer all the above issues together as under.
Page 4 of 20 AVRJ CCCA No.28 of 2003 Point Nos. [i) to (iii): 7. For the sake of convenience, the parties are hereinafter referred to as plaintifl and defendants as arraved in the suit. 8. The plaintiff has filed the original suit for partition and separate possession of I l6th share in the suit schedule A to E properties. Be it stated that the trial Court has rejected the claim of the plaintiff for partition and separate possession in respect of schedule B, C and D properties and only decreed in respect of schedule A & E properties. The first defendant is the mother. defendants 2 & 3 are the brothers and the plaintiff and defendants 4 & 5 are the sisters and they are the children of late S.V. Rama Murthy. The parties are Hindus by religion and governed by Mitakshara School of Hindu Law. Late S.V. Rama Murthy, father ol the plaintiff and defendants 2 to 5 and husband of the 1"t defendant died on 15.12.1995. Before his death, he was working as Deputy Engineer in Mechanical Section, APSRTC Musheerabad Division. During his life time, late S.V. Rama Murthy has acquired the house property with
municipal bearing No.1-B-588/ 1O/A at Atchayyanagar locality, near Baghlingampally Housing Boarcl Quarters in Hyderabad, hereinafter referred as'schedule-A property'. Similarly, the 1"t defendant was paid Rs. 1,00,000/- towards insurance amount and Rs.4,00,000/- towards pensionary benefits of late S.V. Rama Murthy hereinafter referred as schedule-B property. Though the plaintiff has made her c1aim, the defendants refused to allot any share either in Schedule-A or Schedule-E properties. Hence, the suit is liled b-v the plaintifl 9 . The defendants 1 to 5 have filed the written statement denying the claim of the plaintiff stating that it is a speculative suit filed by the plaintiff. She is aware of the fact that none of the plaint schedule properties are the joint family properties. The relationship between the parties and the date of death of late S.V. Rama Murthy are not in dispute. It is also not in dispute that late S.V. Rama Murthy was working as Deputy Manager in APSRTC before his death. In fact, schedule-A property is a self-acquired . propertl' of l"t defendant, she has purchased the same Page 5 of 20 AVRJ CCCA No.28 of 2OO3
Page 6 of 20 AVRJ CCCA No.28 of 2003 through registered sale deed dated O9.12.1975 and it is within the knowledge of the plaintiff. trqual1y, the plaintiff is aware cf payment of insurance claim amount and pensionary benefits of the 1"t defendant being the widow ol late S.V. Rama Murthy. She is not entitled to agitate for the same and prayed for dismissal of the suit. 10. On the strength of the above pleadings, the following issues were settled: i) whether the plaintiff is entitled for preliminary decree for partition as prayed for? and ii) to what relieP 11. During trial, on behalf of the plaintiff, she herself got examined as PW. 1, no documentary evidence is fiied on her behalf and after closing the plaintiff's evidence, on behalf of the defendants, the 1"t defendant-mother is examined as DW.1. In her evidence, Exs.B.1 to B.l2 xe marked and accordingiy defence evidence was closed. has alswered the issue No.1 partly in fa The trial Court our of plaintiff holding that the plaintiff is entitled lor a decree and allotment of | /66 share in schedule-A & E properties.
Page 7 of 20 AVRJ CCCA No.28 of 2oo3 Assailing the said judgment and decree, the defendants have filed the present appeal. 12. The specilic claim of the plaintiff is that her father late S.V. Rama Murthy has purchased the schedule-A property, through registered sale deed, dated 09.12.1975 on the name of the lst defendant, who is her mother and it is not the property belonging to the l"t defendant. The plaintiff having pleaded So, did not examine any independent witness nor fiIed the certified copy of said sale deed clated 09.12.I975. Whereas, the contesting defendants have filed the said document in original and marked as Ex.B.B. 13. The contention of the plaintiff is that late S.V. Rama Murthy has purchased the schedule-A property under Ex.B.8 "vith his savings from the salary in the name of lbt defendant to avoid income tax complications. Whereas, 1"t defendant herself got examined as DW.1. It is in her evidence Ex.B.B original sale deed stated above dated 09.12.1975 in respect of schedule-A property is exhibited. A plain reading of Ex.B.8 would show that a sale deed.<,vds
Page 8 of 20 AVRJ CCCA No.28 of 2003 executed in favour of 1.t defendant for a valid consideration of Rs.15,000/-. Nowhere in Ex.B.8 it is mentioned that late S.V. Rama Murthy has paid the sale consideration. attestor to Ex.B.8 14. The plaintiff has got issued a legal notice dated 24.03.1997 before filing the suit informing that she has never signed for withdrawal of deposits from Nagarjuna Finance Limited ald alleged criminal lorgery and misappropriation. The said legal notice was marked as Ex.B.9. Reply notice is Ex.B.1O wherein and whereunder the defendants have claimed damages for Rs.50,O0O/-. Though initially the original suit is filed in respect of plaint A to E schedule properties, the trial Court has dismissed the suit of the piaintiff in respect of schedule-B, C, and D properties. The plaintiff did not choose to prefer any appeal against such dismissal order. The defendants have preferred this appeal assailing the said judgment and decree only in respect of schedule A & E properties. The said S.V. Rama Murthv is also not cited as a witness or
Page 9 of 20 AVRJ CCCA No.2B of 2003 15. As stated above, on behalf of the plaintiff, she herself got examined as PW. 1, whereas on behaif of the defendants, the 1st defendant, who is mother ol the plaintiff and defendants 2 to 5, is examined as DW.l. Exs.B.l to El.12 documents were marked. The plaintiff in her evidence in the chief examination reiterated her stand taken in the pleadings in the plaint. However, no documentary evidence is filed. Whereas, the 1"t defendant as DW. I has categorically stated that schedule-A property was purchased by her out of her savings. Though the plaintiff has stated that her father has purchased the suit schedule property on the name of l"t defendant, she has faiied to adduce any satisfactory evidence to that effect. 16. In her cross-examination, PW.l-plaintiff has stated that her late father served in APSRTC almost from the lower post and reached to the cadre of Deputy Mechanical Engineer by promotion before his death and he looked after the entire family, performed the marriages of herself and defendants 2, 4 & 5 during his life time and he has taken the responsibility of entire family. He had no other income
Page 10 of 20 AVRJ CCCA No.2B of 2OO3 the pensionary benefits including the insurance policy arnount was withdrawn by the defendants. 17. Ex.B.1 is demand notice dated 05.07.1996. Exs.B2 and E}.3 are property tax payment receipts. Exs.B.4 and B.5 are receipts for payment of electricity bills. Ex.B.7 is except his salary during his life time. She has stated that schedule-A property was purchased in the year 1975. At that time, she was aged about four years arrd she does not know the income of her iather in the year 1975. But she came to know that her father purchased the suit schedule A'property on the name of l"t defendant. She has not seen the title deed of suit schedule-A property. She does not know whether the lst defendant has saved money prior to her marriage by doing tailoring work and kept the savings with her parents. She denied the suggestion that at the time of her marriage, she was given dowry and other articles were presented. She has stated that gratuity and pensionary benefits were paid to the 1st defendant being the widow of late S.V. Rama Murthy also as her name is mentioned as nominee. But she has no record to show that
Page 11 of 20 AVRJ CCCA No.28 of 2OO3 water demand notice. Ex.B.6 is receipt issued by Hyderabad Water Works. Ex.B.8 is original registered sale deed. Ex.B.9 is legal notice. Ex.B.10 is repil- notice. Al1 these documents are not in dispute. The Exs.B.1 to B.3 shows that the schedule-A property 1S standing on the name of l"t defendant and she has been paying the property tax. Similarly, Exs.A.4 to A.7 would estabiish that electricity bills were raised on the name of i "t defendant being the owner of schedule-A property alcl water bills were also raised on her name and the l"t defendant has paid the said amount. Ex.B.B is registered sale deed document No.46O3 of 1975, dated 09.12.1975. 18. It is the specillc case of the defendants as per the pleadings and in the written statement and additional written statement and also as per the oral evidence of DW.1 on whose narne schedule-A property is purchased under Ex.B.8 that it is purchased by the 1"1 defendant from out of her savings. She used to '*,ork as tailor before and after her marriage, she was helping the family by erttending the weaving work and she was earning about Rs.2,000/-
Page 12 of 20 AVRJ CCCA No.28 of 2003 per month. The evidence of DW. 1 remained uncontraverted throughour the cross-examination. In fact, at the time of purchase of schedule-A property under Ex.B.8, admittedly the plaintiff was aged about four years, she does not know the source of income of either late S.V. Rama Murthy or the 1"t defendant who is her mother. She has cleariy stated that her father late S.V. Rama Murhty was looking after the entire responsibility of their family and performed the marriages of plaintiff and defendants 2, 4 & 5. Nowhere in Ex.B.8 it is mentioned that the sale consideration of Rs. 15,000/- is paid by late S.V. Rama Murthy. On the other hand, it is clearly mentioned that the vendee- 1"t delendant in pursuance to the agreement of sale has paid the entire sale consideration of Rs. 15,000/- before the Sub-Registrar at the time of registration of the document and the vendor has acknowledged the receipt of said amount. 19. The trial Court in para-11 of the impugned judgment has referred the provisions of Section 3 (2) of Prohibition of Benami Property Transactions Act, 1988 (for short 'the
Page 13 of 20 AVRJ CCCA No.28 of 2003 Act') and observed that unless the contrary is proved, it has to be presumed that the said property' has been purchased for the benefit of his wife and unmarried daughter and this provision makes it crystal clear to negative the contention of the learned counsel for the defendants that the plaintiff is estopped from taking plea of bena.rni transaction covered by Ex.B.8. 20. Be it stated that except the oral evidence of PW. 1, the plaintiff has not adduced any other oral and documentary evidence. Admittedly, she was aged about four years at the time of execution of Ex.B.B registered sale deed in respect of schedule-A property. She is not able to explain the source of income of her father or that her mother for purchase of schedule-A property, therefore, the Court has to necessarily rely upon the contents of Ex.B.8 a-lone, wherein and whereunder it is categorically mentioned that the l"t defendant has paid the entire sale consideration of Rs. 15,OOO/ - in pursualce to the agreement of sale and that in the presence of Sub-Registrar concerned, the .vendor has acknowledged the receipt ol Rs. 15,000 /- from I I
Page 14 of 20 AVR.J CCCA No.28 of 2003 the l"t defendant. There is nothing on record to show that late S.V. Rama Murthy has contributed the sale consideration and that it is benami transaction. trven if it is admitted for a moment that late S.V. Rama Murthy has paid the sale consideration, in view of the Section 3 (2) of the Act unless the contrary is proved, it sha11 be presumed that the said property was purchased by late S.V. Rama Murthy for the benefit of his r,i,ife - 1't defendant. 21. The Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Nand Kishore Mehra u. Sushila Mehral , while dealing with the presumption under Section 3 (21 of the Act held that the purchase made by a person in the name of his wife or unmarried daughter shal1 be presumed unless otherwise rebutted to be purchase made for the benefit of the wife or unmarried daughter, as the case may be, thereby making the wife or unmarried daughter in whose name property purchased to be the real owner with the consequence that the property thus purchased shall not be construed to be a property held benami by such wife or the unmarried 1 AIR 1995 sc 2 l4s \
Page 15 of 20 AVRJ CCCA No.28 of 2003 daughter for the husband or the father as the case may be. The resultant position shall be that the wife or the daughter as the case may be shall be the absolute owner and the husband cannot claim title as against the wife or the unmarried daughter as the case may be. Therefore, because of the above statutory presumption contained in sub-section (2) of Section 3 of the Act that unless contra-ry is proved the purchase of the property by a person in the name of his wife or unmarried daughter as the case may be, is for her benefit. 22. The Apex Court in Sitaram Agarual & another v. Subarata Chanrq & Darz.krishna Dhara & other&. held that onus of proof is on the person alleging that the transaction is a benami. Therefore, in the instant case, the burden is on the plaintiff to establish that her late father S.V. Rama Murthy has purchased schedule-A property under Ex.B.8 on the name of the l"t defendant and he had no intention to purchase the same for her benefit and it was always treated as joint family property of plaintiff and (2OO8l 7 SCC 716
Page 16 of 20 AVRJ CCCA No.28 of 2003 defendants, but she has failed to adduce such evidence. As discussed above, she was aged about four years at the time of purchase of schedule-A property under Ex.B.8 and she did not choose to examine anv of the close relations in support of her case that the transaction under Ex.B.B is a benami transaction and the property was not purchased for the benefit of 1"t defendant. 23. Per contra, the entire material availabie on record including the oral evidence of l"t defendant as DW.1, who is the vendee under Ex.B.B and the contents of Ex.B.8, the relevant documents such as property tax, electricity bills and water tax bills would establish that the property was purchased by the l"t defendant and she is the absolute owner. rebut the presumption contained in sub-section (2) . of Section 3 of the Act. 24. In that view of the matter, I hold that the trial Court has failed to appreciate the evidence available on record on the issue No.1 in respect of schedule-A property. The ora-l d documentarli evidence adduced on behalf of plaintiff Therefore, I hold that the plaintiff has failed to
Page 17 of 20 /\VRJ CCCA llo.28 ot 2OO3 and defendants would only establish that schedule-A property was purchased by the l"t defendant on her name in the year 1975 under Ex.B.B and she has paid the sale established, the purchase of schedule-A property under Ex.B.B shall be presumed only for the benelit of 1"t defendant and it has to be construed as her self-acquired propertv and that during her life time, the plaintiff and defendants 2 to 5 cannot claim any right or interest in respect of the same. Thus, the findings recordt:d by the trial Court passing a preliminary decree aliotting 1 / 6th share to the plaintiff and each of the defendants 1 to 5 in respect of schedule-A property are against the evidence avaiiable on record and liable to be set aside. 25. The plaintilf has also claimed for her 1/6d, share in schedule-E property. It is the case of the plaintiff that late S.V. Rama Murthy has taken insurance pohcy and the 1"1 defendant was the nominee being his wife and the insurance company has paid Rs.1,OO,00O/- to the 1.t defendant and she has also received Rs.a,00,000/ - consideration. Even otherwise, unless contra,ry is
Page 18 of 20 AVRJ CCCA No.28 of 2003 retirement benefits of late S.V. Rama Murthy from APSRTC. The defendants are not disputing the said amounts received by the Iirst defendant. However, the defendants have opposed stating that the first defendant in her capacity as widow and nominee has received the retirement benefits from APSRTC and also from Insurance Company. 26. The law is well settled that the nomination cannot divest the law of succession. Though for the sake of convenience, in the insurance policy or in the service records, the name of nominee is mentioned, nominee is not entitled to get the entire amount in exclusion of class-I heir of late S.V. Rama Murthy. There is no dispute about the relationship of plaintiff and defendants I to 5. It is also an admitted fact that late S.V. Rama Murthy died intestate. Thus, the amount of Rs. 1,00,000/- covered by insurance policy and the pensionar5z benefits of Rs.4,OO,OOO/- are his self-acquired properties, the plaintiff and defendants 1 to 5 are the class-I heirs of late S.V. Rama Murthy and are qual share in the said amount. Hence, I do entitled for e
Page 19 of 20 AVRJ CCCA No.28 of 2OO3 not find any irregularity in the findings recorded by the trial Cor-rrt in respect of scheduie-E property r,r,herein the plaintiff and defendants 1 to 5 are entitled for 1/6tt share each 27. For all the reasons stated above, in the light of the oral and documentarSr evidence available on record, I hold that the plaintiff is not entitled lor any share in schedule-A property covered by Ex.B.S and as it is the exclusive property of l"t defendant and accordingly the claim of the plaintiff for partition and allocation of 1/6th share in the schedule-A property is negatived. Whereas, the plaintiff is entitled for | /6th share in the schedule-E property and the findings recorded by the trial Court to that effect are sustained. 2A. In the result, the appeal is partly allowed only in respect of schedule-A property declaring the schedule-A property covered by Ex.B.8 is the exclusive property of the l.t defendant and that the plaintiff is not entitled for partition and allocation of 1/6th share in the same. aI d Accordingl.v, to the extent of schedule-A property the I
Page 20 of 20 AVRJ CCCA No-2a of 2003 preliminary decree dated 06.11.2002 in OS No.317 of 1997 on the Iile of the learned IV Senior Civil Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad, shall stand modified. Whereas, the appeal is dismissed in respect of schedule-E property, the plaintiff is entitled for her 1/6th share in schedule-E property and the findings recorded by the tria-l Court to that effect are sustained. However, in the circumstances of the case, there sha-ll be no order as to costs. As a sequel, interlocutory applications, if any pending in this appeal, shall stand closed. 1 l Sd/.'!.isHyA?*rmR /rrRuE coPY// sec,or'rY/rrrcen i,H:if if :IB,$:",,:if}ifi #fi{i"iT#sly"rtbad(w'ihrec'rds) a Two CD CoPles S. One SPare CoPY l<l- --/ (, To I
HIGH COURT DATED:2410812022 1 \1? ?r stP NII STAT ! o,') JUDGMENT t CCCA.No.28 of 2003 PARTLY ALLOWING CCCA IN RESPECT OF SCHEDULE -A PROPERTY AND DISMISSING IN RESPECT OF SCHEDULE -E PROPERTY. t, \r
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY FOURTH DAY OF AUGUST TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY TWO PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A.VENKATESHWARA REDDY Between: 1. Smt. S.Radhamma, W/o late S.V. Rama Murthy Household 2. S.Ratnababu, S/o late S.V. Rama Murthy Doctor 3. S.Ajay Kumar, S/o late S.V. Rama Murthy Service All F/o H.No.1-8-588/10/A, Achaiah Nagar, Bagh Lingampally, Hyderabad. 4. Smt. S.Ratnamala, Wo Sadanand Household No 1-9-25219150, Near Municipal Park, East MCH Colony, Parsigutta, Hyderabad. 5. Smt. S.Revathi, W/o S. Anjaneyulu Household Rl/o HMT Colony, Nacharam Road, Hyderabad ...APPELLANTS AND Smt. S. Ratnakala,Wlo K. Narsimha Household R/o H.No.1-9-91141211, Ram Nagar, Hyderabad ...RESPONDENT Appeal under Section 96 of CPC against the Judgment and decree of the Court of the lV Senior Civil Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad in OS No.317 of 1997. ORDER: This appeal coming on for hearing and upon perusing the grounds of appeal, the Judgment and decree of the Lower Court and the material papers in the suit and upon hearing the arguments of Sri P.Narasing Rao, advocate for the Appellant and ofthe Respondent not appeared in person or by Advocate. This Court doth Order and decree as follows :- 1. That the appeal be and hereby is partly allowed only in respect of Schedule - A property declaring the Schedule -A property covered by Ex-B.B in the exclusive property of the 1"t defendant. 2. That the plaintiff be and hereby is not entitled for partition and allocation of 1/6th share of the same. 3. That the preliminary decree dated 0611112002 in OS No.317/1997 on the file of the learned lV Senior Civil Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad be and hereby is modified to the extent of Schedule-A property. C.C.C.A. NO: 28 OF 2003
To 4. That the appeal be and hereby is dismissed in respect of Schedule -E property. 5. That the plaintiff be and hereby is entitled for'1/6th share scheclule -E property and the findings recorded by the Trial Court to that effect are sustained. 6. That there be no Order as to costs in this appeal. Sd/-K.SRIN RAO JOINT REG //TRUE COPY// SEC;TIO OFFICER 1. The lV Senior Civil Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad. 2. Two CD Copies 3. One Spare Copy .t U Kj
HIGH COURT DATED:241082022 DECREE CCCA.No.28 of 2003 PARTLY ALLOWING CCCA IN RESPECT OF SCHEDULE -A PROPERTY AND DISMISSING IN RESPECT OF SCHEDULE -E PROPERTY. t\,)X
More judgments on Section 96
- Dy. Commissioner of Income-Tax-1(1)(1)… vs Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited…ITA 5/MUM/2025[2017]Status: Disposed7 Oct 2026
- Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited… vs DCIT, Circle 1(1)(1), MumbaiITA 6759/MUM/2024[2017-18]Status: Disposed7 Oct 2026AY 2017-18
- Nagendra Prasad, Patna vs ITO Ward -5(3) Patna, Dak BanglowITA 362/PAT/2026[2016-17]Status: Disposed29 Sept 2026AY 2016-17
- Jyotikaben W-O Mohanlal Chunilal Prajapati vs State of GujaratX-OBJ/21/201516 Sept 2026
- Airoli Itp Development Private Limited… vs Dy CIT Circle 1(1)(1), Mumbai CityITA 6708/MUM/2024[2021-22]Status: Disposed10 Sept 2026AY 2021-22
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- M/S Jaleswar Packaging, Bhubaneswar vs. Superintendent, CGST And Central Excise, BhubaneswarOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- Talasethi Sanmukharao vs. Commissioner, CT And GST, Odisha, CuttackOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- M/S Ramamani Behera (Trade Name S.V.Enterprises) Bhubaneswar vs. Addl Commissioner Of GST And Central Excise, BhubaneswarOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- Prasanta Kumar Biswal vs. The Chief Commissioner, CGST, Central Excise And Customs, BhubaneswarOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- M/S.Dibyanee Agency., Keonjhar. vs. Chief Commissioner Of CT And GST, Odisha, CuttackOrissa · 11 Nov 2026