COMMNR.INCOME TAX vs. ORIENTAL SECURITY
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court allowed the appeal in favour of the assessee. The Court referred to its earlier judgment concerning the same assessee for assessment years 1991-92 and 1992-93. It noted that while the Corporation initially did not accept the liability for survey expenses, it subsequently accepted it for the year 1992-93 and showed it in its books of account under the mercantile system. The Court found that the survey expenses were almost identical and required to be allowed as revenue expenses. Applying the principles from the Supreme Court's judgment in Empire Jute Co. Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Income Tax, the Court held that expenses which yield fruitful results and are necessary for the relevant time and development, in line with the nature of the expenses, cannot be considered capital expenses and must be treated as revenue expenses. Therefore, the issue was answered in favour of the assessee and against the department.
What were the facts?
The appellant, Rajasthan State Mineral Development Corporation, is challenging an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) which allowed the department's appeal. The dispute concerns the deductibility of expenditure amounting to Rs. 85.08 lacs incurred for the removal of overburden and related activities for extracting existing minerals from mines that were already in operation. The assessee contended that this expenditure was revenue in nature and an integral part of its profit-earning activities. The Assessing Officer had treated this expenditure as capital in nature, disallowing the deduction. The CIT(A) had initially ruled in favour of the assessee, holding the expenses to be revenue. However, the ITAT reversed this decision, deeming the expenditure capital.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the recurring expenditure for the removal of overburden and other related activities for the extraction of existing minerals from operational mines is allowable under Section 37(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, as revenue expenditure, or if it is capital in nature. Assessee's Contention: The appellant argued that the expenditure was revenue in nature and an integral part of its revenue-generating activities. They relied on the CIT(A)'s order which, after considering the factual matrix, held the expenses to be revenue. The assessee also cited the Supreme Court decision in Commissioner of Income Tax vs. Kirkend Coal Co. and the principles laid down in Bombay Steam Navigation Co. v. Commr. of Income-tax and Empire Jute Co. Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Income Tax, emphasizing that expenditure integral to the profit-earning process should be treated as revenue. Revenue's Contention: The respondent (department) supported the ITAT's judgment, arguing that the Tribunal's view was just and proper. They also pointed to an earlier judgment for the same assessee for assessment years 1991-92 and 1992-93 where similar expenses were allowed.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN BENCH AT JAIPUR. D.B. Income Tax Appeal No.29/2003 Rajasthan State Mineral Development Corporation Vs. Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Jaipur DATE OF JUDGMENT ::: 14.12.2016 HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE K.S. JHAVERI HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE DINESH MEHTA Mr. Sanjay Jhanwar, for the appellant. Mr. Anuroop Singhi, for the respondent. * BY THE COURT:- (Per Hon'ble Jhaveri, J.) 1. By way of this appeal, the appellant has assailed the judgment and order of the Tribunal whereby Tribunal has allowed the appeal preferred by the department. 2. This court while admitting the appeal on 27.5.2003 had framed following substantial question of law:- “Whether the recurring expenditure for removal of overburden and other related activities for extraction of existing minerals from mines under operation is not allowable under Section 37(1) of the Act being revenue in nature and an integral part of revenue generating activities and therefore whether the learned Income Tax Appellate Tribunal's order in disallowing such expenditure of Rs.85.08 lacs by treating the same as capital in nature is justified and correct?” 3. Counsel for the appellant contended that the expenditure which has been shown by the appellant was revenue expenditure. He further submits that the CIT(A) while giving detailed reasons has held in favour of the assessee and has discussed the complete factual matrix.
After taking into consideration, the facts in favour of the assessee, it held that the expenditure are revenue expenses.
In this regard, the order of the Tribunal reads as under:- “On consideration of the facts of the case as detailed by the A/R, it is seen that the amount had been paid to the contractor to remove the over-burden consisting of earth, rocks, bushes, etc., covering the minerals in the mines area of Fluorspar Mines of Bhinmal, District Jalore. Since these mines were already in operation since 1976, no new asset had been brought into existence as a result of the removal of the over- burden. Continuous process of removal of over- burden was to facilitate the continuous process of the mining in the area. Therefore, in this context the expenditure has to be regarded as revenue in nature. This ground of appeal is thus allowed.” 5. Counsel for the appellant further contended that the tribunal has committed an error in reversing the view taken by CIT(A), in view of the decision of Supreme Court in Commissioner of Income Tax vs. Kirkend Coal Co. reported in (1970) 77 ITR 0530 which reads as under:- The facts of this case lie within narrow compass. The assessee M/s. Kirkand Coal Co. is a firm carrying on coal mining business. During the accounting year ending on December 31, 1956, that company spent a sum of Rs. 21,911 for stowing operations. The department of Mines required the assessee to stow certain galleries near the pit-mouth as a condition precedent for working the colliery during the accounting year. The assessee claimed that the said expenditure was a, revenue expenditure coming within Section 10(2) (xv) of the Act. The Income-tax Officer as well as the Appellate Assistant Commissioner overruled the contention of the assessee. They considered that expenditure as capital
expenditure and hence not deductible as a permissible allowance. But on a further appeal, the Appellate Tribunal came to the conclusion that: “Stowing is an operation carried out in the process of extraction of coal and unless it is carried out extraction of coal is not possible irrespective of the fact whether depillaring has been done or not in this year. This expenditure, is, in our opinion, a revenue expenditure, as it is necessary for the purpose of extraction of coal.” On the basis of that finding, it allowed the assessee's appeal and allowed the expenditure in question as a permissible deduction. The High Court has accepted the conclusion of the Tribunal. The finding of the Appellate Tribunal that stowing is an operation carried out in the process of extraction of coal and unless it is carried out, extraction of coal is not possible irrespective of the fact whether depillaring has been done or not is a finding of fact. That finding was binding on the High Court. It is equally binding on us. In view of that finding, the High Court was justified in holding that the expenditure in dispute is a revenue expenditure. This Court had in various decisions laid down the principles to be applied in distinguishing revenue expenditure from capital expenditure. In Bombay Steam Navigation Co. v. Commr. of Income-tax, Bombay AIR 1965 SC 1201 this Court observed: “Whether a particular expenditure is revenue expenditure incurred for the purpose of business must be determined on a consideration of all the facts and circumstances, and by the application of Principles of Commercial Trading. The question must be viewed in the larger context of business necessity or expediency. If the outgoing or expenditure is so related to the carrying on or conduct of the business, that it may be regarded as an integral part of the profit-earning process and not for acquisition of an asset or a right of a permanent character, the possession of which is a condition of the carrying on of the business, the expenditure may be regarded as revenue expenditure.”
5.1 In case of Empire Jute Co. Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Income Tax reported in (1980) 124 ITR 0001, the Supreme Court held as under:- When dealing with cases of this kind where the question is whether expenditure incurred by an assessee is capital or revenue expenditure, it is necessary to bear in mind what Dixon, J. said in Hallstrom's Property Limited v. Federal Commissioner of Taxation(1): "What is an outgoing of capital and what is an outgoing on account of revenue depends on what the expenditure is calculated to effect from a practical and business point of view rather than upon the justice classification of the legal rights, if any, secured, employed or exhausted in the process." The question must be viewed in the larger context of business necessity or expediency. If the outgoing expenditure. is so related to the carrying on or the conduct of the business that it may be regarded as an integral part of the profit-earning process and not for acquisition of an asset or a right of a permanent character, the possession of which is a condition of the carrying on of the business, the expenditure may be regarded as revenue expenditure. See Bombay Steam Navigation Co. (1953) Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income- tax(2) The same test was formulated' by Lord Clyde in Robert Addze & Son's Collieries Ltd. v. Inland Revenue(3) in these words: "Is it part of the company's working expenses, is it expenditure laid out as part of the process of profit earning ? or, on the other hand, is it a capital outlay, is it expenditure necessary for the acquisition of property or of rights of permanent character, the possession of which is a condition of carrying on its trade at all ?" It is clear from the above discussion that the payment made by the assessee for purchase of loom hours was expenditure laid out. as part of the process of profit- earning. It was, to use Lord Soumnar's words, an outlay of a business "in order to carry it on and to earn a profit out of this expense as an expense of carrying it on." It was part of the cost of operating the profit earning apparatus and was clearly in the nature of revenue expenditure. It was pointed out by Lord Radcliffe in Commissioner of Taxes v. Nchanga Consolidated
Copper Mines Ltd. (supra) that "in considering allocation of expenditure between the capital and income accounts, it is almost unavoidable to argue from analogy." There are always cases falling indisputably on one or the other side of the line and it is a familiar argument in tax courts that the case under review bears close analogy to a case falling on the right side of the line and must therefore be decided in the same manner. If we apply this method, the case closes to the present one that we can find is Nchanga Consolidated Copper Mines case (supra). The facts of this case were that three companies which were engaged in the business of copper mining formed a group and consequent on a steep fall in- the price of copper in the world market, this group decided voluntarily to cut its production by 10 per cent which for the three companies together meant a cut of 27000 tons for the year in question. It was agreed between the three companies that for the purpose of giving effect to this cut, company should cease production for one year and that the assesses company and company R should undertake between them the whole group programme for the year reduced by the overall cut of 27000 tons and should pay compensation to company for the abandonment of its production for the year. Pursuant to this agreement the assessee paid to company 1,384,565 by way of its proportionate share of the compensation and the question arose whether this payment was in the nature of capital expenditure or revenue expenditure. The Privy Council, held that the compensation paid by the assessee to company in consideration of the latter agreeing to cease production for one year was in the nature of revenue expenditure and was allowable as a deduction in computing the taxable income of the assessee. Lord Radcliffe delivering the opinion of the Privy Council observed that the assessee's arrangement with companies R and "out of which the expenditure arose, made it a cost incidental to the production and sale of the output of the mine" and as such its true analogy with an operating cost. The payment compensation represented expenditure incurred by the assessee for enabling it to produce more goods despite the cut of 10 per cent and it was plainly part of the cost of performing the income-earning operation. This decision bears a very close analogy to the
present case and if payment made by the assessee company to company for acquiring an advantage by way of entitlement to produce more goods notwithstanding the cut of 80 percent was regarded by the Privy Council as revenue expenditure, a fortiori; expenditure incurred by the assessee in the present case for purchase of loom hours so as to enable the assessee to work the profit making apparatus for a longer number of hours and produce more goods than what the assessee would otherwise be entitled to do, must be held to be of revenue character. 6. Counsel for the appellant also relied the judgment of Supreme Court in Empire Jute Co. Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Income Tax (supra) in para no. 6 & 7. 6.1 In case of Bikaner Gypsums Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Income Tax reported in (1991) 187 ITR 0039, it has been held as under:- The question whether a particular expenditure incurred by the assessee is of Capital or Revenue nature is a vexed question which has always presented difficulty before the Courts. There are a number of decisions of this Court and other courts formulating tests for distinguishing the capital from revenue expenditure. But the tests so laid down are not exhaustive and it is not possible to reconcile the reasons given in all of them, as each decision is rounded on its own facts and circumstances. Since, in the instant case the facts are clear, it is not necessary to consider each and every case in detail or to analyse the tests laid down in various decisions. However, before we consider the facts and circumstances of the case, it is necessary to refer to some of the leading cases laying down guidelines for deter- mining the question. In Assam Bengal Cement Co. Ltd. v. The Commissioner of Income Tax, West Bengal, [1955] 1 SCR 972,'this Court observed that in the great diversity of human affairs and the complicated nature of business operation, it is difficult to lay down a test which would apply to
all situations. One has, therefore, to apply the criteria from the business point of view in order to determine whether on fair appreciation of the whole situation the expenditure incurred for a particular matter is of the nature of capital expenditure or a revenue expenditure. The Court laid down a simple test for determining the nature of the expenditure. It observed: Whether payments made by an assessee for removal of any restriction or obstacle to its business would be in the nature of capital or revenue expenditure, has been considered by courts. In Commissioner of Inland Revenue v. Carron Company, [1966-69] 45 Tax Cases 13 the assessee carried on the business of iron founders which was incorporated by a Charter granted to it in 1773. By passage of time many of its features had become archaic and unsuited to modern conditions and the company's commercial performance was suffering a progressive decline. The Charter of the company placed restriction on the company's borrowing powers and it placed restriction on voting rights of certain members. The company decided to petition for a supplementary Charter providing for the vesting of the management in Board of Directors and for the removal of the limitation on company's borrowing powers and restrictions on the issue and transfer of shares. The company's petition was contested by dissenting share-holders in court. The company settled the litigation under which it had to pay the cost of legal action and buy out the holdings of the dissenting share- holders and in pursuance thereof a supplementary Charter was granted. In assessment proceedings, the company claimed deduction of payments made by it towards the cost of obtaining the Charter, the amounts paid to the dissenting share- holders and expensed in the action. The Special Commissioner held that the company was entitled to the deductions. On appeal the House of Lords held that since the object of the new Charter was to remove obstacle to profitable trading, and the engagement of a competent Manager and the removal of restrictions on borrowing facilitated the day-to-day trading operation of the company, the expenditure was on income account. The House of Lords considered the test laid down by Lord Cave L.C. in British Insulated Company's
case and held that the payments made by the company, were for the purpose of removing of disability of the company trading operation which prejudiced its operation. This was achieved without acquisition of any tangible or intangible asset or without creation of any new branch of trading activity. From a commercial and business point of view nothing in the nature of additional fixed capital was thereby achieved. The Court pointed out that there is a sharp distinction between the removal of a disability on one hand payment for which is a revenue payment, and the bringing into existence of an advantage, payment for which may be a capital payment. Since, in the case before the Court, the Company had made payments for removal of disabilities which confined their business under the out of date Charter of 1773, the expenditure was on revenue account. In Empire Jute Company v. C.I. T, [1980] 124 ITR I, this Court held that expenditure made by an assessee for the purpose of removing the restriction on the number of working hours with a view to increase its profits, was in the nature of revenue expenditure. The Court observed that if the advantage consists merely in facilitating the assessee's trading operations of enabling the management and conduct of the assessee's business to be carried on more efficiently or more profitably while leaving he fixed capital untouched, the expenditure would be on revenue account even though the advantage may endure for an indefinite future. We agree with the view taken in the aforesaid two decisions. In our opinion where the assessee has an existing right to carry on a business, any expenditure made by it during the course of business for the purpose of removal of any restriction or obstruction or disability would be on revenue account, provided the expenditure does not acquire any capital asset. Payments made for removal of restriction, obstruction or disability may result in acquiring benefits to the business, but that by itself would not acquire any capital asset. In considering the cases of mining business the nature of the lease the purpose for which expenditure is made, its relation to the carrying on of the business in a profitable manner should be considered. In the instant case existence of Railway Station, yard and buildings on the surface of the demised land operated as an
obstruction to the assessee's business of mining. The Railway Authorities agreed to shift the Railway establishment to facilitate the assessee to carry on his business in a profitable manner and for the purposes the assessee paid a sum of Rs.3 lakhs towards the cost of shifting the Railway construction. The payment made by the assessee was for removal of disability and obstacle and it did not bring into existence any advantage of an enduring nature. The Tribunal rightly allowed the expenditure on revenue account. The High Court in our opinion failed to appreciate the true nature of the expenditure. 6.2 In case of Pingle Industries Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Income Tax reported in (1960) 40 ITR 0067, it has been observed as under:- Applying the above test to the present case, it is obvious that the monthly payments of Rs. 1,666- 10-8 did not represent the lease amount for a month. This was a case in which the assessee bad acquired an asset of an enduring character for which he had to put his hand in his pocket for a very large sum indeed. He paid Rs. 96,000 down, but for the rest he asked for easy terms. The amount paid every month was not in any sense a payment for acquisition of the right from month to month. It was really the entire sum chopped into small payments for his convenience. Nor can the amount be described as a business expense, because the outgoings every month were not to be taken as spent over purchase of stones but in discharge of the entire liability to the jagir. Some of the cases to which we were referred may now be briefly noted. Hakim Ram Prasad, In re (1) was a case of renting of a cinema projector for 10 years. The amount paid was thus hire for the machine. 'In Commissioner of Income-tax v. Globe Theatres Ltd. (2) the assessee advanced Rs. 10,000 to a company for the construction of a cinema house which was never built. Since the amount was not salami or premium but only advance rent, it was held deduct- ible. Commissioner of Income-tax v. Kolhia Hirdagarh Co. Ltd. (3) was a case of commission on every ton of coal raised, and it
was held to be revenue expenditure. These cases are entirely different, and can be of no authority for payments, such as we have. Reliance was also placed upon Parmanand Haveli Ram In re (4), Nand Lal Bhoj Raj, In re (5) and Commissioner of Income-tax v. Tika Ram & Sons (6). In the first two, expenditure to acquire lands bearing certain salts in the earth, which could be converted into potassium nitrate, sodium chloride or saltpetre, was regarded as revenue expenditure. They follow the line of reasoning which the same Court adopted in the Full Bench case of Benarsidas (7), which we have considered in detail earlier. They involved shortterm contracts, and in the Full Bench case it was stated that the case of long-term leases was on a different footing, though, in our opinion, the decisive factors in such cases will be the nature of the acquisition and the reason for the payment. Cases on the other side-of the line where payments were regarded as capital expenditure are Commissioner of Income-tax v. Chengalroya Mudaliar (8) and Chengalvaroya Chettiar v. Commissioner of Income-tax (9). There the expenditure was for a lease for excavation of lime shells. Since the lease conferred exclusive privilege and a new business regarded not as the right to win shells. All these cases turned on different facts, and it is not necessary to decide which of them in the special circumstances were correctly decided. This enquiry will hardly help in the solution of the case in hand. We are, however, satisfied that in this case the assessee acquired by his long-term lease a right to win stones, and the leases conveyed to him a part of land. The stones in situ were not his stock-in-trade in a business sense but a capital asset from which after extraction he converted the stones into his stock- in-trade. The payment, though periodic in fact, was neither rent nor royalty but a lump payment in instalments for acquiring a capital asset of enduring benefit to his trade. In this view of the matter, the High Court was right in treating the outgoings as on capital account.” 7. Counsel for the respondent has supported the judgment of the Tribunal and contended that the view taken
by the Tribunal is just and proper and that in earlier judgment for the same assessee, for the relevant year 1991-92 & 1992-93, their expenses were allowed. 8. We have heard counsel for the parties. 9. Taking into consideration the observations which are made by this court in earlier judgment of the same assessee in para no. 11 & 13 holding as under:- He relied upon the decision of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Alembic Chemical Works Co. Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Income Tax, reported in (1989) 177 ITR 0377 and Empire Jute Co. Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Income Tax, reported in (1980) 124 ITR 0001 and contended that under mercantile system, the expenses were shown in the year 1992-93 and even while assessment order was passed for the year 1991-92, the assessee was made clear that he is accepting the liability and he further contended that he will not make payment which was made by the State Government for the expenditure incurred for the survey which is being done. Therefore, the Corporation had no other option to make payment which has no capital value. Taking into consideration the fact initially the Corporation has not accepted the liability, therefore, the observations which are made by the Tribunal for the year 1991-92 were in the peculiar facts where the liability was not accepted but subsequently for the year 1992-93, the Corporation has accepted the liability which was shown in the books of account and in view of the matter additions made by the tribunal for the relevant year would not be applicable in the changed circumstances. Since, they accepted the liability, the resolution which is sought to be passed on 28.8.1992 was administrative formality but for the Income-tax purpose it is shown in the books of account mercantile system, therefore, though the point raised by Mr. Singhi is remained an academic issue but facts and law in mercantile system which is debited for the relevant year i.e. 1992-93.
It is thus very clear that the survey expenses are almost identical and hence required to be allowed as revenue expenses. 11. In view of the observations made by the Supreme Court in the Judgment of Empire Jute Co. Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Income Tax (Supra), we are of the opinion that the expenses which gives fruitful result require to be done according to the necessity of relevant time and development with the nature of expenses. 12. In that view of the matter, it cannot be capital expenses and is to be considered as revenue expenses. 13. Therefore, the issue is answered in favour of the assessee and against the department. 14. The appeal stands allowed. (Dinesh Mehta), J. (K.S. Jhaveri), J. Brijesh61.
More judgments on Section 37(1)
- Vikram Muradia, Delhi vs ITO Ward 27(1), DelhiITA 8158/DEL/2026[2024-2025]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2024-2025
- Trusine Electronics Private Limited, New… vs Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, DelhiITA 7458/DEL/2026[2017-18]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2017-18
- Amit Jain, Rohini, Delhi vs ITO Ward 49(1), DelhiITA 4533/DEL/2026[2019-20]Status: Disposed13 Nov 2026AY 2019-20
- Fomento Karnataka Mining Company Private… vs Joint Commissioner of Income Tax, Margao…ITA 14/PAN/2023[2011-12]Status: Disposed6 Nov 2026AY 2011-12
- Fomento Karnataka Mining Company Private… vs Joint Commissioner of Income Tax, Margao…ITA 13/PAN/2023[2010-11]Status: Disposed6 Nov 2026AY 2010-11
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- M/S Multitech Agro INDIA (Opc) PVT LTD vs. The State Of KarnatakaKarnataka · 5 Nov 2026
- Gopa Satya Madhava Subbarao vs. The State Of Andhra PradeshAndhra Pradesh · 5 Nov 2026
- M/S Kallu Cable vs. The Commissioner State Goods And Service TaxUttarakhand · 5 Nov 2026
- M/S Dream Home Interiors vs. The Commissioner Of Commercial TaxesKarnataka · 4 Nov 2026
- Jishu Suklabaidya vs. The Union Of INDIA And 16 Ors.Gauhati · 4 Nov 2026