TRUSINE ELECTRONICS PRIVATE LIMITED,NEW DELHI vs. ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, DELHI
What did the Tribunal hold?
The Tribunal found that the CIT(A) was economical with fact-finding and ignored submissions regarding TSPL's qualified technical manpower. The Tribunal noted that while the AO proceeded with the facts before him, the CIT(A) failed to adequately consider the assessee's evidence. The Tribunal also observed that the mere existence of an agreement and payment does not bind the AO to hold that the payment was exclusively for business purposes, citing Premier Breweries Limited vs. CIT and Schneider Electric India Limited vs. CIT, which relied on Lachminarayan Madan Lal vs. CIT. The Tribunal deemed it fit to set aside the non-speaking impugned order and remand the matter to the CIT(A) for reconsideration. The CIT(A) is to consider the available facts, determine the specific services rendered to justify the impugned amount, and is at liberty to accept new evidence or call for a remand report from the AO. The Tribunal also briefly addressed the rule of consistency, stating that if new facts cast doubt on previously accepted expenditure, relying solely on consistency would be perverse. The appeal is partly allowed for statistical purposes.
What were the facts?
The assessee, Trusine Electronics Private Limited, is in appeal against the order of the NFAC (formerly CIT(A)) for Assessment Year 2017-18. The Assessing Officer (AO) disallowed Rs. 1,72,66,526 claimed as professional charges/fee/commission/liaison charges paid to a sister concern, M/s Trusine Solutions Private Limited (TSPL). The AO found that the services rendered by TSPL did not justify the payment from the assessee's business perspective. The CIT(A) upheld the AO's disallowance. The assessee is aggrieved by this confirmation and has approached the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT).
What were the issues?
1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances, the CIT(A) erred in confirming the disallowance of Rs. 1,72,66,526/- made by the AO under Section 37(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (the Act)? 2. Whether the CIT(A) failed to appreciate that the expenditure was incurred wholly and exclusively for the assessee's business and was supported by documentation? 3. Whether the CIT(A) erred in holding that no services were rendered by TSPL without cogent evidence? 4. Whether the CIT(A) erred in confirming the addition without appreciating that the AO failed to invoke or satisfy the mandatory conditions prescribed under Section 40A(2)(b) while making the disallowance under Section 37(1)? 5. Whether the CIT(A) passed a non-speaking order in violation of Section 250(6) of the Act? Assessee's contentions: The expenditure was incurred wholly and exclusively for business purposes based on a commercial agreement dated 05.04.2013, supported by invoices, books of account, TDS certificates, and communications. TSPL provided services like market research, R&D, technical know-how, and payment collection. TSPL had 19 qualified personnel and sufficient assets and income to render services. The AO was swayed by invoice nomenclature. The AO failed to invoke Section 40A(2)(b). The CIT(A) passed a non-speaking order. Relied on Sassoon J. David & Co. (P.) Ltd. vs. CIT, CIT vs. Walchand & Co. (P.) Ltd., S.A. Builders Ltd. vs. CIT(Appeals), Hero Cycles (P.) Ltd. vs. CIT, Radha Soami Satsang vs. CIT, CIT vs. Nainital Bank Limited. Revenue's contentions: Not recorded in the judgment.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, DELHI BENCH “E” NEW DELHI
Before: SHRI VIMAL KUMAR & SHRI SANJAY AWASTHI
IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL DELHI BENCH “E” NEW DELHI BEFORE SHRI VIMAL KUMAR, JUDICIAL MEMBER AND SHRI SANJAY AWASTHI, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER ITA No.7458/DEL/2026 Assessment Year: 2017-18 TRUSINE ELECTRONICS PRIVATE Vs. ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME LIMITED, TAX, B-17/2, Okhla Industrial Area, Circle 25(2), New Delhi, Phase-II, New Delhi, Delhi 110002. Delhi 110020. PAN No. AAACT0853D Appellant Respondent Assessee by Shri Saubhagya Agarwal, Adv. Shri V. Rajkumar, Adv. Ms. Suman Jain, FCA & Shri Vaibhav Srivastava, Adv. Revenue by Shri Tarun Sharda, Sr. DR Date of hearing: 21.09.2026 Pronouncement on 18.11.2026 O R D E R PER SANJAY AWASTHI, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER: 1. This appeal arises from order dated 10.07.2026, passed u/s 250 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereafter as “the Act”), by NFAC.
1.1 It is seen that vide assessment order dated 23.12.2019 the Ld. AO has disallowed an amount of Rs.1,72,66,526/-, claimed as professional charges/fee/commission/liaison charges, as paid to a sister concern in the name and style of M/s Trusine Solutions Private Limited (hereafter TSPL). The Ld. AO has given a detailed finding that the services rendered by M/s TSPL did not justify the said payment from the angle of the business of the assessee. 1 1.2 The aggrieved assessee approached the Ld. CIT(A) where also he could not succeed on the basis of rather very cryptic and short findings (page 2 of the impugned order) through which the action of Ld. AO has been upheld.
1.3 Further aggrieved, the assessee has now approached the ITAT with the following grounds:
“That on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) has erred in confirming the disallowance of Rs.1,72,66,526/- made by the Assessing Officer under section 37(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961; 2. That the CIT(A) has failed to appreciate that the impugned expenditure was incurred wholly and exclusively for the purposes of the appellant’s business and was duly supported by the agreement, invoices, books of account and other documentary evidence placed on record; 3. That the CIT(A) has grossly erred in holding that no services were rendered by M/s Trusine Solutions Private Limited merely on assumptions, conjectures and surmises without bringing any cogent evidence on record to rebut the documentary evidence furnished by the appellant; 4. That the CIT(A) has erred both in law while confirming the addition without appreciating the fact that AO has failed to invoke or satisfy the mandatory conditions prescribed under section 40A(2)(b), while making disallowance under section 37(1) of the Act, 1961. 5. That the CIT(A) has passed the impugned order without properly considering and adjudicating upon the submissions and evidences filed by the appellant and has, therefore, passed a non-speaking order in violation of the provisions of section 250(6) of the Act. 6. That all the grounds of appeal raise herein above are independent ground and without prejudice to each other. 7. The appellant craves leave to add, amend, alter, modify or delete any of the above grounds as well as to submit additional grounds on or before at the time of hearing of the appeal.” 2
Before us the Ld. AR argued with the help of a paper book and a case laws compilation and stated that the impugned expenditure was wholly and exclusively incurred for the purposes of business of the assessee. It was pointed out that such expenditure was incurred on the basis of a commercial agreement between the assessee and M/s TSPL, dated 05.04.2013, and this agreement was placed for our perusal at pages 65 to 73 of the Paper Book. The Ld. AR read out from the said agreement to point out that M/s TSPL was engaged to provide services like market research, R&D, technical knowhow, payment collection and all manner of allied services. It was the submission that the said agreement was duly brought to the notice of the authorities below and in the Ld. AO’s order this fact is clearly visible. It was the further submission that the assessee had paid for the actual services rendered by M/s TSPL for the assessee and in this regard TDS certificates, confirmations and communication between the assessee and M/s TSPL were also supplied to the authorities below. It was argued that there was no dearth of evidence available to show that the impugned payments were duly made under an existing agreement, through banking channels and on the basis of services rendered by M/s TSPL. It was also argued that the assessee required continuous technical support for adding value to its products and also keeping pace with the latest technological innovations in the field of the assessee’s business. It was for this purpose that the assessee took a conscious decision, for its commercial wellbeing, 3 to associate with one Shri M.C. Tyagi, who is a qualified Electronic Engineer, so that the assessee’s product could be efficiently marketed and also improved over time. It was pointed out by the Ld. AR that this arrangement suited the assessee since all manner of much needed services were made available to the assessee, without there being fixed overhead charges and other liabilities which would have certainly arisen in case Shri M.C. Tyagi had been placed on the rolls of the assessee company. It was also the submission that the Ld. AO has been overly persuaded by the nomenclature/description adopted in the invoices raised by the M/s TSPL as “commission” and “liaison service charges”. It was pointed out by the Ld. AR that the language used in the invoices was not material since the services were rendered as per the agreement dated 05.04.2013 and it was not the assessee’s case that the impugned payment was made merely for providing liaison service charges etc. It was also pointed out by the Ld. AR that vide submissions dated 30.07.2025 filed before the Ld. CIT(A), it was duly pointed out that M/s TSPL had engaged as many as 19 technically qualified personnel for rendering the services as required under the agreement dated 05.04.2013. The Ld. AR pointed out these facts at pages 6 to 7 of the Paper Book and stated that these submissions had been ignored by the Ld. CIT(A) when he passed the impugned order. Regarding the allegation by the Ld. AO that M/s TSPL did not possess sufficient assets to be able to provide the necessary services required as per the agreement dated 4 05.04.2013, it was pointed out that detailed financial statements of M/s TSPL were placed before the authorities below (depicted at pages 82 to 93 of the Paper Book), to show that M/s TSPL had income from operations to the tune of Rs.2,00,33,854/- for the year ending 31.03.2017 and there were sufficient assets in the balance sheet (page 82 of the Paper Book) to indicate that M/s TSPL was sufficiently equipped to carry out the terms of agreement dated 05.04.2013. In this connection the Ld. AR submitted that the fact of payments being made for rendering services to the assessee were not in doubt and there were several e-mail communications placed on record to show that M/s TSPL was actively involved in engaging with the customers of the assessee and was continuously safeguarding its business interests.
2.1 The Ld. AR also relied on several case laws, which may be listed with a brief about the relevancy of the same:
1) Sassoon J. David & Co. (P.) Ltd. vs. CIT, (1979) reported in 118 ITR 261 (SC) – A businessman is to decide what is good for his business and make expenditure accordingly; 2) CIT vs. Walchand & Co. (P.) Ltd. reported in 65 ITR 381 (SC) – It is for a businessman to decide what is good for his business and incur expenditure accordingly; 3) S.A. Builders Ltd. vs. CIT(Appeals), (2007) reported in 288 ITR 1 (SC) – Through this case the principle that the AO 5 cannot step into the shoes of the assessee to decide what is good for his business, was laid stress on; 4) Hero Cycles (P.) Ltd. vs. CIT, (2015) reported in 379 ITR 347 (SC) – Here also the same principle as in S.A. Builders case (supra) was enunciated; 5) Radha Soami Satsang vs. CIT, (1992) reported in 193 ITR 321 (SC) – In this case, the principle of consistency versus the principle of res-judicata was discussed and decided in favour of the principle of consistency. The Ld. AR pointed out that the impugned expenditure claimed in earlier years had been allowed at assessment stage. On that basis such expense should be allowed during this year also; 6) CIT vs. Nainital Bank Limited reported in (1966) 62 ITR 638 (SC) – In this case, again, the principle of letting a businessman decide on the nature of expenses for the benefit of his business rather than any Assessing Officer sitting in judgment over that, was laid down; 7) CIT vs. Neo Polypack reported in 245 ITR 492 – The principle of consistency has been supported; 8) Berger Paints India Limited vs. CIT, (2004) reported in 266 ITR 99 – The principle of consistency has been supported here also.
The Ld. AR stated that there was a considerable body of judicial literature to support the view that an expense has to be judged from the point of view of the businessman and not from the point of view of any Assessing Officer. It was also argued that since similar expenses had been allowed in previous years, hence, there was no reason to disallow the same during the year under consideration, as the facts remained the same.
The Ld. DR, on the other hand, stated that this was a case of diversion of funds where virtually an amount slightly more than the entire profit before tax of Rs.1,56,10,215/- was diverted to a sister concern and to a person who was certainly part of a connected group entity. It was the submission that the assessee had set up an alternative commercial structure with Shri M.C. Tyagi holding 15% of the shareholding in M/s TSPL, mainly to divert profits from the assessee company. The Ld. DR relied on the findings of Ld. AO rendered in pages 4 to 5 of his order and read out the same for our benefit as under:
“3.3 At the outset, the reply of the assessee has been considered but it is untenable because of the following reasons: a) As per the agreement, the Trusine Solutions Private Limited (TSPL) will carry out the research and development, design and product solution for the assessee, however, despite of specifically asked no information has been furnished in respect to carry out any research and development for the assessee company. b) Further, the agreement as shared by the assessee, it is stated therein that TSPL will conduct the market search to find out the prospective customer however no information or details has been provided by the assessee 7 that what kind of search has been carried out by the party to find out the prospective customer. c) The agreement also states that TSPL provides the technical knowhow, for manufacturing/assembly, installation and after sales services of the products, in this regard, it is noted that the assessee company is established in the year January 1991 whereas the TSPL is incorporated in October 2012, therefore, from the said fact it is remotely to conceive an idea that what kind of knowhow the new company has in its realm which the assessee company did not accompanied with keeping the fact into the consideration the assessee has well established knowhow in house in the field of products as manufactured by it since 1981. At this juncture, it is noted from the financial statement of the TSPL that the said company did not have enough assets in its depreciation schedule through which it can claimed that such knowhow has been provided to the assessee company. This is also being noted from the profit and loss account of TSPL that it has not expended a huge expenditure through which it can claimed that it has generated the knowhow in respect of product. The fact is also being noted that both the director in the assessee company is having a substantial influence over TSPL, had the director was involved in providing the knowhow to the assessee company then what will be the benefit that being the same director cannot provide the services to the assessee company. d) It is further noted form the agreement that TSPL is provide the services to assessee such as product approved from customers, assist and ensure the collection of sales proceeds and other allied services, the same has been read in the juxtaposition to the communication e-mail which has been furnished by the assessee to substantiate its claim. From the perusal of the e-mail it is noted that while communicating with customer there is one Mr. M.C. Tyagi uses the portal name of the assessee company which is Trusine.com. Hence, it is impossible to state that on the part of customer whether they are dealing with TSPL or assessee company rather human probability says it is the assessee company who is dealing with the customer. Even the e-mail signature of Mr. M.C. Tyagi did not contains the distinguishment that he being a TSPL dealt with the customer. Hence, the services which has been rendered by Mr. MC Tyagi by using the assessee portal cannot be treated as services carried out by TSPL independently. e) The assessee has raised the contention that the company has incurred such expenses in the preceding years also and the same was allowed as deduction. In this regard, it is settled legal principle that under the income tax 8 proceedings, each year is independent year and the principle of “res judicata” and “estoppel” are not applicable in the income tax proceedings. Having said that it is relevant to read the principle of consistency with regard to the instant fact. The principle of consistency is followed when the facts remain the same in each of the assessment year but in the instant case the assessee failed to furnish the documents on the basis of which it can be revealed that the services was actually rendered by M/s Trusine Solutions Pvt. Ltd. to the assessee company. Vide notice dated 11.12.2019 the assessee was specifically asked to furnish the project report, any report which has been made with regard to market search for prospective customers, however, despite of furnishing the three reply and sufficient opportunity the assessee not furnished the above stated documents through which the substance of the transaction can be curve out. Hence, from the above the assessee failed to furnish the substantive evidence through which the transaction can be corroborated.” “3.4 Further, the assessee contended that it has furnished the copies of bills and copies of ledger account to substantiate the transaction. Therefore, it is necessary to evaluate the submission dated 04.11.2019 of the assessee along with the bills/ledgers: a) From the perusal of the ledger account the bills/invoices has been debited in the said ledger on account of liaisioning/commissioning expenses hence the charges are paid to TSPL is contrary to the agreement for which it has been entered. b) It is further submitted that from the perusal of the e-mail, bills/invoices there is no material furnished by the assessee through which it can be developed that the TSPL has provided the market and research development activity for the company, to find out the prospective services customer to the assessee company and other related clause for which agreement was entered. c) Further, in case any services which has been provided by TSPL to the assessee company then it has a quantum of services which has two low [sic] which cannot be measure on the paradigm of section 40A(2)(b) of the Act.” 4. Considering the arguments advanced by both the sides which mainly centered around the fact that payments had been made to M/s TSPL within the frame work of an agreement and the factum of payment was not in doubt as an admitted fact, it was felt that the locus classicus 9 on this issue needed to be discussed and argued by both the sides. Accordingly, the case of Lachminarayan Madan Lal vs. CIT, (1972) reported in 86 ITR 439 (SC), was pointed out to both the sides and the relevant portion from the same was informed so that the two sides could assist the Bench in arriving at a conclusion regarding the issue at hand. It was pointed out that in this case law the mere existence of an agreement and undoubted fact of payment were not considered enough to preclude the AO from investigating and enquiring on the relevancy of commission payment from the point of view of the business of an assessee.
4.1 The Ld. AR attempted to distinguish the facts of the present case from this case law and stated that the payment to M/s TSPL had been classified as commission and liaisoning charges but the payments were for a comprehensive package of services. The assessee had demonstrated that Shri MC Tyagi and his team had been performing the services in line with the agreement for the same.
4.2 The Ld. DR, on the other hand, stated that even though the Ld. AO had not mentioned or even relied on this case law, but had generally followed the mandate available to him and had enquired and investigated the utility of such payments (impugned) from the business angle of the assessee. It was the submission that the Ld. AO has recorded a detailed finding about the vagueness of services rendered and has rightly questioned the utility of such payment vis-a-vis the business of the assessee.
We have heard the rival contentions, and we have carefully perused the documents on record as well as those filed through the paper book. We have also carefully considered the case laws relied on by the Ld. AR. Since the facts of the case have been extensively dealt with in the Ld. AR/DR’s averments, we do not deem it fit to reiterate the same at this stage. However, the issues to be decided need to be briefly captured for focusing our attention on the same:
a) There is an agreement dated 05.04.2013 between the assessee and M/s TSPL, indicating a host of services to be rendered by M/s TSPL for the benefit of the assessee; b) Payments have been made by the assessee to M/s TSPL after deducting tax at source and obviously through banking channels; c) Certain e-mails have been placed on record to show that M/s TSPL has been engaging with the clients of the assessee; and d) M/s TSPL is a sister concern of the assessee.
We find that the assessee concern pre-dates the coming into being of M/s TSPL by several decades. Thus, there is some strength in the Ld. AO’s assertion that the assessee had been carrying on its business without any such help as is purportedly given by M/s TSPL, in the past. We also find 11 that the nature of services mentioned on the invoices are rather narrow in terms of the number of services mentioned in the commercial agreement and only “liaisoning” and “commission” have been mentioned. Even though the Ld. AR has vehemently argued that such description or nomenclature attributed to the entire gamut of services provided by M/s TSPL should not be considered as the sole determining factor, it is certainly to be considered as one of the factors indicating the narrow range of services provided by M/s TSPL. We also find that the assessee supplied a list of 19 technically qualified persons working as employees of M/s TSPL, who purportedly rendered all manner of services, apart from merely “liaisoning” activities, but we also find that M/s TSPL has revenues from some other activities also since their receipts are not only entirely subsumed in the gross payments made by the assessee. Thus, the extent of technical services provided to the assessee, as forcefully claimed by the Ld. AR, cannot simply be inferred from the fact that technically qualified persons are actually working as employees of M/s TSPL, since they may be performing functions for the benefit of M/s TSPL’s other business activities, details of which are not before us. To elaborate this point further, we are unable to be persuaded that such technically qualified employees of M/s TSPL have to be presumed to be rendering services to the assessee also in addition to their other responsibilities. No evidence in this regard has been placed at any of the stages by the assessee to lend credence to the claim that the 12 entire conspectus of services outline in the agreement dated 05.04.2013 are being provided to the assessee. Thus, we agree with the finding of the Ld. AO in principle that the assessee has not been able to establish the utility from his business point of view regarding the nature and extent of services rendered by M/s TSPL and the benefit accruing to the assessee’s business. A further fact that also needs to be considered at this stage is that the recipient of the impugned amount is a sister concern of the assessee and thus, there is a justified suspicion regarding diversion of profits. We may also analyze the contention of the Ld. AR, with the weight of the case laws relied upon by him, regarding the supremacy of a businessman’s consideration about what kind of expenses are good for his business. We find that, as a general principle there can be no quarrel with this proposition. However, considering the case of Lachminarayan Madan Lal (supra), we need to carve out an exception when it comes to payment of commission etc. by an assessee. We are also conscious of the fact that the utility from the point of view of business and payments like the impugned, are basically factual issues which need to be determined on the touchstone of relevant case laws. We may also refer to a few case laws which would guide us in deciding this issue:
i. Lachminarayan Madan Lal (supra) the following portion is relevant: In our opinion, the facts of this case come within the rule laid down by this court in Swadeshi Cotton Mills co. Ltd. vs. Commissioner of 13 Income tax [1967] 63 ITR 57 (SC). The question whether an amount claimed as an expenditure was laid out or expended wholly and exclusively for the purpose of the business has to be decided on the facts and in the light of the circumstances in each case. The mere existence of an agreement between the assessee and its selling agents or payment of certain amounts as commission, assuming there was such payment, does not bind the Income-tax Officer to hold that the payment was made exclusively and wholly for the purpose of the assessee’s business. Although there might be such an agreement in existence and the payments might have been made, it is still open to the Income-tax Officer to consider the relevant-factors and determine for himself whether the commission said to have been paid to the selling agents or any part thereof is properly deductible under section 37 of the Act.” [Emphasis added]
ii. Premier Breweries Limited vs. CIT, (2015) reported in 372 ITR 180 (SC) - In this case para 11 is relevant and the same may be extracted as under: 11. A reading of the questions initially framed and subsequently reframed show that what was done by the High Court is to retain three out of twelve questions, as initially framed, while discarding the rest. Some of the questions discarded by the High Court were actually more proximate to the question of perversity of the findings of fact recorded by the learned Tribunal, than the questions retained. From a reading of the Order of the High Court it is clear that the High Court examined the entitlement of the appellant assessee to deduction/disallowance by accepting the agreements executed by the assessee with the commission agents; the affidavits filed by C. Janakiraman and Shri A.N. Ramachandra Nayar, husbands of the two lady partners of RJ Associates and also the payments made by the assessee to RJ Associates as well as to Golden Enterprises. The question that was posed by the High Court was whether acceptance of the agreements, affidavits and proof of payment would debar the assessing authority to go into the question whether the expenses claimed would still be allowable under Section 37 of the Act. This is a question which the High Court held was required to be answered in the facts of each case in the light of the decision of this Court in Swadeshi Cotton Mills Co. Ltd. vs. CIT [1967] 63 ITR 57 and Lachminarayan Madan Lal vs. CIT [1972] 86 ITR 439 (SC). In fact the High Court noted the following observations of this Court in Lachminarayan (supra): “The mere existence of an agreement between the assessee and its selling agents or payment of certain amounts as commission, assuming there was such payment, does not bind the Income Tax Officer to hold that the payment was made exclusively and wholly for the purpose of the assessee’s business. Although there might5 be such an agreement in existence and the payments might have been made. It is still open to the Income Tax Officer to consider the relevant facts and determine for himself whether the commission said to have been paid to the selling agents or any part thereof is properly deductible under Section 37 of the Act.”
iii. Schneider Electric India Limited vs. CIT, (2008) reported in 304 ITR 360 (Del.) – In this case para 11 is relevant: “11. With regard to the existence or otherwise of a written agreement between the parties, our attention has been drawn to Lachminarayan Madan Lal vs. CIT [1972] 86 ITR 439 wherein it has been held by the Supreme Court that even if there is an agreement between the assessee and its selling agents or payment of certain amounts as commission, assuming there was such payment, that does not bind the Income-tax Officer to hold that the payment was made exclusively and wholly for the purposes of the assessee’s business. The Supreme Court observed as follows: - “…….Although there might be such an agreement in existence and the payments might have been made, it is still open to the Income- tax Officer to consider the relevant factors and determine for himself whether the commission said to have been paid to the selling agents or any part thereof is properly deductible under Section 37 of the Act.” (p. 446) 5.1 Considering the totality of facts and circumstances of this case, we find that the Ld. AO proceeded with the facts before him and arrived at an adverse conclusion regarding the assessee. We find that the Ld. CIT(A) has been economical at best with the fact-finding and has totally ignored the submissions of the assessee regarding qualified technical manpower available in M/s TSPL presumably for rendering services to the assessee. Accordingly, we deem it fit to set aside the impugned order, which is non-speaking, and remand this matter back to the file of Ld. CIT(A) for considering the facts available with the assessee and also determining what kind of specific services were rendered to justify earning the impugned amount. For this purpose, the Ld. CIT(A) would be at liberty to accept new evidence and also call for a remand report from the Ld. AO as and when required. We direct accordingly. 15
Before parting with this issue, it is felt that we need to briefly address the issue regarding the rule of consistency. Without getting into any debate about the rule of consistency versus The principle of res judicata, it needs to be mentioned that once facts are brought to light which may cast a doubt on some aspect of expenditure which may have been accepted in previous years, it would be a perverse logic to rely on the rule of consistency to debunk such facts and accept the justification of an expense at face value, merely because the same has been accepted in previous years, even though there may be facts available which may indicate to the contrary.
In the result, the appeal of the assessee is partly allowed for statistical purposes.
Order pronounced in the open court on 18.11.2026
Sd/- Sd/- (VIMAL KUMAR) (SANJAY AWASTHI) JUDICIAL MEMBER ACCOUNTANT MEMBER Dated: 18.11.2026 *Kavita Arora, Sr. P.S. Copy forwarded to: 1. Appellant 2. Respondent 3. CIT 4. CIT(Appeals) 5. DR: ITAT ASSISTANT REGISTRAR 16 ITAT, NEW DELHI
More judgments on Section 37(1)
- Vikram Muradia, Delhi vs ITO Ward 27(1), DelhiITA 8158/DEL/2026[2024-2025]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2024-2025
- Amit Jain, Rohini, Delhi vs ITO Ward 49(1), DelhiITA 4533/DEL/2026[2019-20]Status: Disposed13 Nov 2026AY 2019-20
- Fomento Karnataka Mining Company Private… vs Joint Commissioner of Income Tax, Margao…ITA 14/PAN/2023[2011-12]Status: Disposed6 Nov 2026AY 2011-12
- Fomento Karnataka Mining Company Private… vs Joint Commissioner of Income Tax, Margao…ITA 13/PAN/2023[2010-11]Status: Disposed6 Nov 2026AY 2010-11
- M/S. City Union Bank, Kumbakonam vs ACIT, Circle-2(1), TrichyITA 475/CHNY/2025[2020-21]Status: Disposed6 Nov 2026AY 2020-21
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Sanjurani Giri vs. The Principal Commissioner, CGST And Central Excise, BhubaneswarOrissa · 17 Nov 2026
- Deepankar Mohanty vs. Union Of INDIAOrissa · 17 Nov 2026
- Dinabandhu Majhi vs. Assistant Commissioner Of State Tax, CT And GST, KoraputOrissa · 17 Nov 2026
- Makardhwaj Kaudi vs. State Of OdishaOrissa · 17 Nov 2026
- M/S Sahoo Supply Agency, Balasore vs. Central Board Of Indirect Taxes And CustomsOrissa · 17 Nov 2026