5 orders · Page 1 of 1
The court held that the interlocutory application had abated due to the death of the appellant, Sri Umesh Ch. Pathak, which occurred on April 27, 2024. This conclusion was reached after the learned counsel for respondent No.1 presented evidence of the appellant's demise in the form of a 'Shraddha Ceremony' invitation card. The court accepted this information and, consequently, declared the application abated. The operative direction was that the application stands closed. No other issues were decided, and the merits of the linked case (RSA/72/2009) were not addressed.
The High Court held that the appeal should be disposed of as withdrawn. This decision was based on the submission made by Mr. Alok Sharma, learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant (Revenue), who prayed for withdrawal of the appeal in view of written instructions received by him. The Court took on record the communication dated 3rd August, 2018, which informed the Commissioner of Income Tax, Pune, for withdrawal of the appeal in view of the revised monetary limit as per CBDT Circular No. 3/2018, dated 11th July, 2018. Consequently, the appeal was disposed of as withdrawn. No specific issue regarding the merits of the case was decided, and no amount in dispute was mentioned.
The High Court found it impossible to answer the re-framed substantial question of law due to conflicting assertions regarding the Revenue's grounds of appeal before the ITAT. The Revenue claimed to have raised an additional ground challenging the admission of additional evidence by the CIT(A) under Rule 46A, while the assessee's affidavits, supported by the counsel who appeared before the ITAT, stated that no such amended grounds were filed or raised. The counsel for the Revenue accepted that the relevant files were weeded out. Given these circumstances, and noting that the Revenue did not dispute that the DSIR had granted approval on July 20, 2006, the High Court upheld the ITAT's order. The Court reasoned that it was better for the Revenue to have raised the issue of the CIT(A)'s order by filing an application under Section 254(2) of the Act if there was an error in the ITAT's recording. The Court concluded by upholding the ITAT's order granting the benefit under Section 35(2AB) to the assessee, answering the question of law against the Revenue and in favour of the assessee.
The High Court held that surcharge under Section 13 of the Rajasthan Sales Tax Act, 1994, is not leviable on the 1% amount paid by the assessee as a condition for exemption. The Court reasoned that the 1% payment was not a tax, fee, or sum in lieu of tax, but a condition to avail exemption from tax. The notification itself referred to it as an 'exemption fee', but the Court clarified that the nomenclature does not determine the nature of the impost. Relying on Supreme Court judgments in Indian Mica Micanite Industries Vs. The State of Bihar & Ors. [1971 (2) SCC 236] and Commissioner of Income Tax, Udaipur, Rajasthan Vs. Mcdowell and Company Ltd. [(2009) 10 SCC 755], the Court found no quid pro quo for it to be considered a fee. The Court also noted that the Department had not claimed it as a lump sum in lieu of tax under Section 5 of the Act of 1994. Therefore, the levy of surcharge was misdirected and misplaced. The Appellate Authority and the Tax Board had rightly concurred in setting aside the Assessing Officer's order. The revision petition was dismissed.