314 orders · Page 4 of 7
The High Court held that the findings recorded by the ITAT were findings of fact based on the consideration of relevant evidence on record. Therefore, the High Court found no manifest error of law in the impugned order of the ITAT. Consequently, the appeal filed by the Revenue was dismissed. No substantial question of law was answered in favour of the assessee and against the revenue.
The High Court held that the investment made by the assessee in its joint venture companies, namely Sudha Modern Dhall Mill Limited, Delta Oils & Fats Limited, Sri Gumvaurappan Swamy Oil Foods & Fats Limited, and Godavari Edible Bran Oil Limited, constituted a violation of Section 11(5) read with Section 13(1)(d) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. This was because the investments were made in shares of companies that were not Government Companies or corporations established under Central or provincial Acts, and the shares were held beyond the cut-off date of November 30, 1983. Consequently, the assessee was not entitled to claim the benefit of exemption under Section 11 of the Act for these investments. However, the Court clarified that only the income derived specifically from such an investment made in violation of Section 13(1)(d) of the Act is liable to tax, and not the entire income of the assessee. The Court relied on decisions from the Bombay, Delhi, and Karnataka High Courts, and noted the dismissal of a Special Leave Petition by the Supreme Court in a similar matter. The orders of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal were modified to this extent.
The Tribunal held that the appellant is not entitled to the benefit of CENVAT Credit on capital goods. The reasoning was based on the undisputed fact that the appellant availed CENVAT credit amounting to ₹2,78,012/- on capital goods and simultaneously claimed depreciation on the same part of the value of capital goods under Section 32 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. This action was a clear violation of Rule 4(4) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004/2002, which explicitly states that CENVAT credit shall not be allowed in respect of that part of the value of capital goods which represents the amount of duty on such capital goods, if the manufacturer claims depreciation under Section 32 of the Income Tax Act. The Tribunal found that the appellant did not fulfill the condition for allowing CENVAT credit. The court further noted that the appellant's claim of filing a revised Income Tax return for a later year (2003-04) did not rectify the violation for the disputed years (2001-02 and 2002-03), as the benefit of depreciation was not surrendered for those assessment years. Consequently, the impugned order of the Tribunal was affirmed, and the appeal was dismissed. No issue was expressly left undecided.
The Tribunal held that the appeal should be dismissed as withdrawn. This decision was based on the request made by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Admn. & TPS.), Bhubaneswar, citing CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. The circular stipulates that appeals should not be filed where the tax effect does not exceed Rs. 20,00,000 before the ITAT. The Tribunal acknowledged the circular's provisions and the letter requesting withdrawal. The ratio decidendi is that appeals below the specified monetary limits, as per the CBDT circular, are to be withdrawn or not pressed. The operative direction was to dismiss the appeal as withdrawn. The appellant (Revenue) was granted liberty to revive the appeal if it was found not to be within the ambit of the circular. No specific issue was left undecided.
The Tribunal decided to dismiss the appeal as withdrawn. This decision was based on the letter received from the Commissioner of Income Tax (Admn. & TPS.), Bhubaneswar, requesting withdrawal in accordance with CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. The circular stipulates that appeals should not be filed where the tax effect does not exceed Rs. 20,00,000 before the Appellate Tribunal. The Tribunal noted that the appeal involved a tax effect less than this limit. The operative direction was to dismiss the appeal as withdrawn. However, the appellant was granted liberty to revive the appeal if it was found not to be covered by the aforementioned circular.
The Tribunal decided to dismiss the appeal as withdrawn. This decision was based on the request made by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Admn. & TPS.), Bhubaneswar, citing CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. The circular mandates that appeals should not be filed if the tax effect is below the specified monetary limit of Rs. 20,00,000 for appeals before the ITAT. The Tribunal noted that the appeal was being dismissed solely on the grounds of this circular and the Revenue's request. The appellant was granted liberty to revive the appeal if it was found not to be covered by the ambit of the circular. The ratio decidendi is that appeals below the prescribed monetary limits, as per CBDT directives under Section 268A, are to be withdrawn or not pressed, unless specific exceptions apply.
The Tribunal decided to dismiss the appeal as withdrawn. This decision was based on the letter of request received from the Commissioner of Income Tax (Admn. & TPS.), Bhubaneswar, dated September 26, 2018. The request for withdrawal was made in light of CBDT Circular No. 3/2018, which sets monetary limits for filing departmental appeals. The circular stipulates that appeals should not be filed if the tax effect is below Rs. 20,00,000 for appeals before the ITAT. The Tribunal found that the appeal in question fell within this category of having less tax effect than the prescribed limit. The operative direction was to dismiss the appeal as withdrawn. However, the appellant was granted liberty to revive the appeal if it was later found not to be covered by the ambit of the aforementioned circular.
The High Court held that the assessment order was passed at the dictation of higher authorities, which amounts to bias and vitiates the assessment proceedings. The Court reasoned that a statutory authority cannot allow its decision to be influenced by the dictation of superiors, as this amounts to surrendering its discretion. The Court distinguished between general power of superintendence and interference in the adjudication process, stating that the true test of bias is not actual bias but the real danger of bias from the viewpoint of a fair-minded and informed observer. Consequently, the Court found that the order of initiation of reassessment was void. Regarding the second issue, the Court held that since the order of initiation was declared void, the question of remanding the case for fresh assessment did not arise. Furthermore, the Court noted that the limitation period for framing the reassessment order had lapsed. The Court dismissed the appeals filed by the Revenue and allowed the cross-appeals filed by the assessee, stating that the Revenue could initiate reassessment proceedings in accordance with law if permissible.
The High Court held that the tax effect in all the appeals was lower than the prescribed amount of ₹50,00,000/-. Consequently, the Court dismissed the appeals as not maintainable due to the low tax effect. The reasoning was purely based on the monetary threshold stipulated for the maintainability of appeals. The applications filed in conjunction with the appeals were allowed. No specific findings were made on the substantive issues that might have led to the original dispute, as the appeals were disposed of on a preliminary ground. The principle established is that appeals with a tax effect below the prescribed limit are not entertainable by the High Court.
The High Court held that the appeal filed by the Revenue was dismissed in terms of CBDT Circular No. 9 of 2024 dated 17.09.2024. The Court observed that the tax effect in the instant appeal was well below the monetary limit of Rs. 2.00 crore prescribed for filing appeals before the High Court. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed on this procedural ground. The Court also stated that any pending miscellaneous applications would stand closed. The judgment further provided that if the appeal fell within any exception mentioned in Circular No. 5 of 2024, the Income Tax Department would be at liberty to seek revival of the appeal. No costs were awarded. The Court did not decide on the substantive issues of the appeal.
The High Court held that the trial court's finding that the relief of specific performance could not be granted was improper and perverse. It reasoned that the materials on record and admissions indicated a valid lease deed with an option to purchase, which the plaintiffs had proven by exercising the option and paying the full consideration to the defendant's agent. The court found that the agency was not disputed, making payment to the agent equivalent to payment to the principal. Therefore, RFA No.508/2009 filed by the landlord was allowed. Regarding O.S. No.5955/1996, the court held that the lease deed was not unconscionable or void. It reasoned that the sole owner had executed a valid GPA, and the defendant or his successors could not contend otherwise, especially since they relied on the GPA in other proceedings. The court found that the plaintiffs in O.S. No.5955/1996 could not claim partition due to the existing lease with an option to purchase. The trial court erred in finding that the entire consideration was not paid. Consequently, the finding that the document providing the option to purchase was null and void was unjustified. The appeals were allowed, the impugned judgment and decree were set aside, O.S. No.1696/1996 was allowed with a decree of specific performance, and O.S. No.5955/1996 was dismissed. The cross-objection was also dismissed.
The Tribunal decided to dismiss the appeal as withdrawn. This decision was based on the request made by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Admn. & TPS.), Bhubaneswar, in their letter dated 26.9.2018. The withdrawal was sought in accordance with CBDT Circular No. 3/2018, which specifies that appeals involving a tax effect below Rs. 20,00,000 before the ITAT should not be filed. The Tribunal noted that the appeal was being dismissed as withdrawn based on this circular. However, the appellant was granted liberty to revive the appeal if it was found not to fall within the ambit of the aforementioned circular. The ratio decidendi is that appeals below the prescribed monetary limits, as per CBDT circulars, can be withdrawn by the Revenue.
The High Court noted the submission by the petitioner's counsel that the dispute had been settled under the Vivad Se Vishwas Scheme and that the petitioner sought withdrawal of the petition. Based on this submission, the Court ordered the petition to be dismissed as withdrawn. Any interim directions previously issued were also vacated. The judgment does not contain any findings on the merits of the original dispute or the application of the Vivad Se Vishwas Scheme.
The High Court held that no question of law, much less substantial questions of law, arose for consideration in the appeal. The Court found that the matter was entirely factual. The Assessing Officer had examined documents, including bill No.64 dated 14.3.1997, a road challan, and Form No.40, which indicated the purchase and dispatch of goods during the financial year 1996-97. The consignment crossed Cooch Bihar on 28.3.1997. The Assessing Officer concluded that the assessee failed to produce evidence proving the consignment was received after March 1997. Consequently, the purchase of Rs.6,35,360/- was correctly attributed to the financial year 1996-97 and disallowed for assessment year 1998-99. The Appellate Authority and the Tribunal had also re-examined the factual aspects and affirmed the Assessing Officer's view, noting that no other documents were produced by the assessee to discharge the onus of proof. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed.
The High Court held that no substantial question of law arises for consideration on most of the issues. Regarding the exclusion of comparables with negative or abnormally high profits, the Court found the Tribunal's reasoning to be in conformity with the Act and Rules, stating that companies with abnormal profits or losses cannot be regarded as reliable comparables. The Court also found no infirmity in the Tribunal's exclusion of comparables with profit margins below 6%, given the assessee's cost-plus 6% contractual arrangement and risk-mitigated environment. Concerning Satyam Computers Limited, the Court held that no prima facie material was placed on record to establish falsification of its financial statements, and its profit margin was within the range of other accepted comparables, thus no reason existed to exclude it. The issue regarding the treatment of donations and income-tax refunds was not adjudicated as it did not fall within the scope of the remand directions from the Supreme Court.
The High Court dismissed the appeal filed by the Revenue. The primary reason for dismissal was that the tax effect in the instant appeal was well below the monetary limit of Rs. 2.00 crore fixed for filing appeals before the High Court, as per CBDT Circular No. 9 of 2024 dated 17.09.2024. The Court noted that this circular amended the previous Circular No. 5 of 2024 to reduce litigation by enhancing monetary limits for appeals. The Court also stated that if the appeal came within the exceptions of Circular No. 5 of 2024, the Revenue could seek revival of the appeal. No order as to costs was made. The operative direction was the dismissal of the appeal.
The High Court held that the date of completion of training and the subsequent order confirming the Sub-Inspectors in service are crucial for determining inter-se seniority. The Court found that the Jharkhand Police Manual, specifically Rule 689(c), exhaustively deals with the determination of seniority for Sub-Inspectors and does not leave it to general principles. Rule 682(d) further clarifies that the period of training/probation is excluded for counting seniority, except for pension purposes. The Court distinguished the judgments cited by the respondents, noting that the Police Manual gives due importance to the completion of training and subsequent confirmation. The Court was not impressed by arguments regarding delays in appointment or training, stating such delays are common in administrative setups. Therefore, the impugned Seniority List dated 09.09.2024 was quashed and set aside. The Court directed the respondents to re-arrange and publish a Final Seniority List by treating direct recruit candidates as senior to LDCE candidates, with a specific exception for direct recruits whose probation was extended, in which case their seniority would be fixed from their confirmation date. This exercise was to be completed within ten weeks. All writ petitions were allowed.
The Tribunal considered the letter of request from the Commissioner of Income Tax (Admn. & TPS.), Bhubaneswar, dated September 26, 2018, and the provisions of CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. The circular, issued under Section 268A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, revised the monetary limits for filing departmental appeals. Specifically, it set a limit of Rs. 20,00,000 for appeals before the ITAT. The Tribunal noted that the appeal in question (I.T.A. No. 142 of 2006) involved a tax effect less than this prescribed limit. Consequently, in view of the Revenue's request for withdrawal based on the circular, the Tribunal dismissed the appeal as withdrawn. However, the appellant was granted liberty to revive the appeal if it was found not to fall within the ambit of the circular.
The Tribunal held that the plaintiff-respondent had proved mental cruelty by the defendant-appellant. The reasoning was based on the evidence on record, including instances of the defendant-appellant making false complaints against the plaintiff-respondent to higher authorities, making baseless allegations against his parents, and damaging their reputation. The Tribunal found that these actions left no doubt that the lower court had not committed any illegality in holding the commission of mental cruelty. The impugned judgment of the lower court was based on a proper consideration of the evidence and did not suffer from any illegality. The Tribunal also noted that irretrievable breakdown of marriage is not a ground for divorce under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, but reiterated the Supreme Court's recommendation to the Union of India to consider incorporating it as a ground. The appeal was dismissed.
The Tribunal considered the letter of request from the Commissioner of Income Tax (Admn. & TPS.), Bhubaneswar, dated September 26, 2018, seeking withdrawal of the appeal. The Tribunal also perused the contents of CBDT Circular No. 3/2018, which was issued under Section 268A of the Income-tax Act, 1961. This circular revises the monetary limits for filing departmental appeals, setting a limit of Rs. 20,00,000 for appeals before the ITAT. In view of the Revenue's request and the provisions of the circular, the Tribunal decided to dismiss the appeal as withdrawn. However, the appellant was granted liberty to revive the appeal if it was found not to fall within the ambit of the circular.
The High Court held that the appeal is not maintainable. The submission made by the learned counsel for the appellants (Revenue) was that the appeal was not maintainable in view of the monetary limits stipulated in Circular No.17 of 2019 dated August 8, 2019, passed by the Director (ITJ), Central Board of Direct Taxes. Following this submission, the Court dismissed the appeal as such. No decision was made on the merits of the case or the underlying tax dispute. The operative direction was to dismiss the appeal.
The Tribunal considered the letter of request from the Commissioner of Income Tax (Admn. & TPS.), Bhubaneswar, dated September 26, 2018, and the accompanying CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. In light of the request to withdraw the appeal due to the tax effect being below the prescribed monetary limit, the Tribunal decided to dismiss the appeal as withdrawn. The Tribunal also granted liberty to the appellant to revive the appeal if it was found not to fall within the ambit of the aforementioned circular. The judgment does not record any decision on the merits of the original appeal.
The Tribunal considered the letter from the Commissioner of Income Tax requesting the withdrawal of the appeal due to the tax effect being less than the monetary limit prescribed by CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. The Tribunal perused the said letter and the Circular. The Circular, issued under Section 268A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, specifies that appeals shall not be filed before the Appellate Tribunal where the tax effect does not exceed Rs. 20,00,000. Paragraph 13 of the Circular clarifies that pending appeals below the specified tax limits may be withdrawn. Consequently, the Tribunal dismissed the appeal as withdrawn. However, the appellant was granted liberty to revive the appeal if it was found not to fall within the ambit of the Circular.
The Tribunal decided to dismiss the appeal as withdrawn. This decision was based on the letter received from the Commissioner of Income Tax (Admn. & TPS.), Bhubaneswar, requesting withdrawal in accordance with CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. The circular stipulates that appeals should not be filed if the tax effect does not exceed Rs. 20,00,000 before the Appellate Tribunal. The Tribunal perused the letter and the circular. The ratio decidendi is that appeals falling below the monetary limits prescribed by the CBDT circular are to be withdrawn or not pressed. The operative direction was to dismiss the appeal as withdrawn, with the liberty granted to the appellant to revive the appeal if it was found not to be within the ambit of the circular.
The Tribunal decided to dismiss the appeal as withdrawn. This decision was based on the letter received from the Commissioner of Income Tax (Admn. & TPS.), Bhubaneswar, requesting withdrawal due to the tax effect being below the monetary limit specified in CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. The Tribunal noted that the circular, issued under Section 268A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, provides for the withdrawal or non-filing of appeals where the tax effect is less than Rs. 20,00,000 for appeals before the ITAT. The ratio decidendi is that appeals with a tax effect below the prescribed monetary limits, as per CBDT circulars, are to be withdrawn or not pressed. The operative direction was to dismiss the appeal as withdrawn, with a liberty granted to the appellant to revive the appeal if it was found not to be covered by the aforementioned circular.
The Tribunal decided to dismiss the appeal as withdrawn. The reasoning was based on the letter received from the Commissioner of Income Tax requesting withdrawal due to the tax effect being below the prescribed limit as per CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. The Tribunal noted that the circular, issued under Section 268A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, sets a monetary limit of Rs. 20,00,000 for appeals before the ITAT. The Tribunal granted the appellant liberty to revive the appeal if it was found not to be covered by the ambit of the circular. The operative direction was the dismissal of the appeal as withdrawn.
The High Court disposed of all the appeals filed by the Revenue. The primary reason for disposal was that the tax effect in each of these appeals was less than Rs. 2 crores. In accordance with CBDT Circular No. 9/2024 dated 17.09.2024, the Court held that such appeals are to be disposed of, leaving the questions of law raised therein open. The Revenue was granted liberty to apply for restoration of these appeals by filing an interlocutory application within three months from the date of the order, should they discover that the appeals fall within the exceptions stipulated in the circular. Pending interlocutory applications were also disposed of.
The High Court held that the learned trial court should not have granted the decree of specific performance. The court reasoned that there was a serious dispute regarding the sale consideration, the value of the suit property, and the payment of the sale consideration. The plaintiff's claim of being in lawful possession was also found to be unsubstantiated, as the defendant contended the property documents were given only for ascertaining the market price. The court noted that the plaintiff failed to clarify the dispute regarding the receipt for full and final payment of sale consideration with cogent evidence. Citing precedents like Sardar Singh v. Krishna Devi and Saradamani Kandappan vs. Rajalakshmi & Ors., the court emphasized that specific performance is a discretionary relief, and its grant depends on the totality of circumstances, including the conduct of parties, the terms of the contract, and the time elapsed. The court found that granting specific performance after a significant delay, especially when there are disputes about payment and property value, would give an unfair advantage to the plaintiff and cause hardship to the defendant. Therefore, the judgment and decree of the trial court were set aside.
The Tribunal considered the letter from the Commissioner of Income Tax requesting the withdrawal of the appeal due to the tax effect being below the monetary limit prescribed by CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. The Circular, issued under Section 268A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, specifies a monetary limit of Rs. 20,00,000 for appeals before the ITAT. The Tribunal noted that pending appeals below the specified tax limits could be withdrawn or not pressed. Consequently, in view of the Revenue's request and the provisions of the circular, the Tribunal dismissed the appeal as withdrawn. However, the appellant was granted liberty to revive the appeal if it was found not to be covered by the said Circular.
The High Court held that the plaintiff, as a landlord, continues to be in legal possession over the leased property and is competent to maintain a suit for injunction, even without physical possession. This was based on the Supreme Court's judgment in Sadashiv Shyama Sawant (supra), which clarified that a landlord who holds possession through a tenant is not deprived of possession in law and can sue for dispossession if the tenant is forcibly dispossessed. Therefore, a decree for permanent injunction can be granted even if the plaintiff has no physical or actual possession. Regarding the location of the property, the Court found that the first appellate court had properly appreciated the revenue records, including the Shajra (map) and Khasra, and the Survey Commission report. The concurrent finding of the trial court and the first appellate court that the disputed property was not situated in Khasra No. 495/2, coupled with the evidence pointing to its location in Khasra No. 490, led the High Court to conclude that the revenue records were correctly appreciated. The appeal was dismissed.
The High Court addressed the three substantial questions of law. Regarding the first issue, the Court held that the assessee was not a construction contractor but a developer undertaking construction activities for sale. It noted that the revenue had accepted the assessee's accounting method in previous years and that the assessee itself changed its method to Percentage Completion Method in subsequent years, making the issue revenue-neutral for the assessment year in question. Citing the Supreme Court's decision in CIT vs. Bilahari Investment Private Limited, the Court affirmed that the Completed Contract Method leads to an objective assessment of results. Therefore, the Court answered the first substantial question of law in the affirmative, in favour of the assessee. For the second and third issues concerning the classification of rental income, the Court relied on its own decision in CIT-III vs. Velankani Information Systems (P) Ltd. This precedent held that if an assessee is in the business of developing commercial buildings and letting them out, such income is 'income from business' and not 'income from house property', irrespective of separate rental deeds or the provision of facilities. Consequently, the Court answered questions 2 and 3 against the revenue and in favour of the assessee. The Court dismissed the appeal, affirming the ITAT's order.
The High Court allowed the application for withdrawal (I.A.No.13904/2019). Consequently, the appeal was dismissed as withdrawn. The Court granted the liberty prayed for by the Revenue to file an application for revival of the appeal. It was clarified that the withdrawal of the appeal by the Revenue would not be considered an affirmation of the Tribunal's order on merits. The legal issue claimed by the Revenue was left open to be adjudicated in an appropriate case. No specific finding on the merits of the case was made.
The High Court held that the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal erred in reversing the order of the CIT(A). The Court found that the CIT(A) had considered all material particulars and details placed by the assessee, including the maintenance of separate accounts for trading in shares and investment. The assessee had clearly indicated their intention to hold shares as investments by debiting the cost to the investment account. The Court noted that the ITAT's reasoning was identical to that in the case of M/s. Gyan Traders Limited, where the High Court had allowed the assessee's appeal. Applying the legal principles derived from Supreme Court decisions like CIT Versus Vazir Sultan and Sons and Union of India Versus Azadi Bachao Andolan, the Court concluded that the object with which the operations are carried on is important. The Court emphasized that the assessee had maintained a separate investment account, which was a material fact that the ITAT failed to consider. Therefore, the Court found the view of the CIT(A), who had considered all relevant materials, to be correct. The appeal filed by the assessee was allowed, and the substantial question of law was answered in favour of the assessee.
The High Court allowed the Revenue's request to withdraw the appeal. The Court noted that the learned Senior Standing Counsel for the appellant (Revenue) sought leave to withdraw the appeal in light of Circular No. 09/2024 dated 17.09.2024, with the liberty to revive the same if the subject matter of the appeal fell within the exceptions provided in Circular No. S/2024 dated 15.03.2024. Accordingly, the appeal was dismissed as withdrawn in terms of the liberty prayed for. Miscellaneous applications, if any, were also closed. No order as to costs was made. The specific grounds or merits of the original appeal were not adjudicated upon.
The Tribunal considered the letter of request from the Commissioner of Income Tax (Admn. & TPS.), Bhubaneswar, dated September 26, 2018, which sought the withdrawal of the appeal. This request was based on CBDT Circular No. 3/2018, which specifies monetary limits for filing departmental appeals. The circular states that appeals should not be filed if the tax effect does not exceed Rs. 20,00,000 before the ITAT. In view of the Revenue's request and the provisions of the circular, the Tribunal decided to dismiss the appeal as withdrawn. The appellant was granted liberty to revive the appeal if it was found not to fall within the ambit of the aforementioned circular. The ratio decidendi is that appeals below the prescribed monetary limits, as per CBDT circulars, are to be withdrawn.
The High Court held that the findings of the CIT(A) and the ITAT were findings of fact based on the consideration of relevant evidence on record. The Court found no perversity in the impugned order of the ITAT, despite the Revenue's counsel being asked to point it out. As no merit was found in the appeal, the appeal was dismissed. The substantial question of law was answered accordingly. The operative direction was the dismissal of the appeal.
The High Court noted the submission made by the learned counsel for the appellant that the dispute has been settled under the Vivad se Vishwas Scheme. Consequently, the appellant expressed no intention to pursue the appeal further. Based on this submission, the High Court ordered that the appeal stands closed. The reasoning is that once a dispute is settled under a scheme like Vivad se Vishwas, the pending appeals related to that dispute become infructuous. The ratio decidendi is that appeals settled under such schemes are to be closed without adjudication on merits. The operative direction was to close the appeal and consequently, all pending miscellaneous petitions were also closed.
The High Court held that the Tribunal failed to consider the income from share transactions and future prospects. Evidence, including share certificates (Exs. P11, P12) and Income Tax Returns (Ex. P15) for assessment year 2006-07, showed a profit of Rs. 42,000/- from share dealings. The Court applied the principle from National Insurance Company vs. Pranay Sethi ((2017) 16 SCC 680) regarding future prospects. Calculating the total income by adding 15% for future prospects to the Tribunal's figure resulted in Rs. 12,197/-. Deducting 1/3rd for personal expenses, the loss of dependency was determined to be Rs. 8,78,148/-. The compensation for loss of consortium and loss of love and affection was enhanced to Rs. 55,000/- each for claimant No. 1 and claimant No. 2 respectively, considering claimant No. 2's handicapped status. Loss of estate and funeral expenses were also increased to Rs. 25,000/- each. The total compensation was enhanced to Rs. 10,38,148/-.
The Tribunal dismissed the appeal. The decision was based on CBDT Circular No. 3/2018, which revised the monetary limits for filing departmental appeals. The circular specifies that appeals shall not be filed before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal if the tax effect does not exceed Rs. 20,00,000. While the judgment notes the tax effect brought to its notice was less than Rs. 50 lakh, it proceeds to dismiss the appeal in view of the circular. The Tribunal granted liberty to the appellant (Revenue) to revive the appeal if it is not coming within the ambit of the circular. This implies that if the tax effect for the specific ITAT appeal was indeed below Rs. 20 lakh, the appeal would be dismissed. The ratio decidendi is that appeals filed by the Revenue must adhere to the monetary limits prescribed by the CBDT circulars for filing appeals, unless specific exceptions apply.
The Court held that the compensation awarded by the Reference Court was not adequate. It noted that applying a flat rate of 12% escalation per annum from 1959 to 1989 on the Collector's base value of Rs. 26,000/- per Bigha would result in Rs. 1,19,600/-, which is still below the Reference Court's award. However, applying a graded escalation rate as per the Om Prakash case (6% for 1959-1965, 10% for 1966-1973, and 12% for 1974-1992) would lead to a compensation of Rs. 5,92,246/- per Bigha. Considering the exemplar sale deed dated March 17, 1988, and the agricultural use of the land, the Court deemed it appropriate to award compensation at the rate of Rs. 2,07,500/- per Bigha for the acquired land in village Kilokari. Following the principle in K. Periasami case, this rate was also applied to the land acquired in villages Khizrabad, Nangli Razapur, and Garhi Mendu. The appellants had already received Rs. 89,600/- per Bigha, and the balance amount, along with interest and statutory benefits, was to be paid. The Court also invoked Section 28A of the Land Acquisition Act, stating that all persons whose land was similarly acquired under the same notification would be entitled to this enhanced compensation.
The Court held that the acquired land in village Kilokari should be awarded compensation at the rate of Rs. 2,07,500/- per Bigha. Following the principles laid down in K. Periasami case, the compensation awarded for village Kilokari shall also be awarded to the land acquired under the same notification in villages Khizrabad, Nangli Razapur, and Garhi Mendu. This means these lands are also entitled to compensation at Rs. 2,07,500/- per Bigha. The Court reasoned that the exemplar sale deed dated March 17, 1988, was available and proved, and the uncontroverted evidence reflected the agricultural use of the land. The Court also invoked Section 28A of the Land Acquisition Act, stating that once a rate of compensation is judicially determined, the benefit must extend to all persons whose land was acquired under the same notification. The appellants had already received Rs. 89,600/- per Bigha, and the balance amounts, along with interest and statutory benefits, are to be paid. The appeals are allowed.
The High Court dismissed the appeal against the acquittal. The Court reiterated the principles governing appeals against acquittal, emphasizing that interference is warranted only in cases of patent perversity, misreading or omission to consider material evidence, or when the judgment is clearly unreasonable. The Court cited Supreme Court judgments in State of Rajasthan v. Gujjar Mal and Mallappa & Ors. v. State of Karnataka, highlighting that the presumption of innocence is strengthened upon acquittal, requiring a higher threshold for reversal. The Court found that the trial court's appreciation of evidence could not be termed perverse or wholly unreasonable. Merely because another view was possible did not justify overturning the acquittal. Given the passage of time (over 15 years since acquittal), reversing the judgment would occasion prejudice and be a travesty of justice. Therefore, the High Court found no legal or factual justification to unsettle the trial court's well-reasoned judgment of acquittal and declined to grant leave.
The Tribunal held that the appeal filed by the assessee was not maintainable in view of CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. The circular, issued under Section 268A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, revised the monetary limits for filing departmental appeals. Specifically, it stipulated that appeals should not be filed before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) where the tax effect does not exceed Rs. 20,00,000. Since the tax effect in the present appeal was stated to be less than Rs. 50 lac, and implicitly below the Rs. 20 lac threshold for ITAT appeals, the appeal was dismissed. The appellant was granted liberty to revive the appeal if it was found to fall outside the ambit of the circular. Pending miscellaneous cases connected to this appeal were also disposed of.
The High Court addressed two substantial questions of law. Regarding the first question, the Court acknowledged that while consistency in the method of valuation is important, for each year the market price of goods can change, and thus the value of stock would accordingly change. The Court found that the A.O. had assessed the stock on the basis of the price at which goods were sold by the assessee, and if the market rate was higher, the tax effect could have been more. The Court agreed with the view taken by the A.O. and affirmed by the ITAT, answering the first question in favour of the revenue. Concerning the second question, the Court held that the decision in CIT vs. British Paints India Ltd. laid down principles for stock valuation considering the facts and circumstances of that specific case. The Court found that the sale price of goods having not changed every year, the method of valuation of stock cannot be applied in the same manner as held in British Paints India Ltd. Therefore, the Court answered the second question in favour of the revenue.
The Tribunal held that the appeal filed by the Revenue stood dismissed in view of CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. The circular mandates that appeals shall not be filed before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal if the tax effect does not exceed Rs. 20,00,000. As the tax effect in the present appeal was less than Rs. 50 lac, and by implication less than the Rs. 20 lac threshold for ITAT appeals, the appeal was not maintainable. The Court further clarified that the appellant (Revenue) is at liberty to revive the appeal if it is found not to be covered by the ambit of the Circular. Pending miscellaneous cases connected to this appeal were also disposed of. The ratio decidendi is that appeals below the prescribed monetary limits, as per CBDT Circulars issued under Section 268A, are not to be entertained by the appellate authorities, and such appeals are liable to be dismissed.
The High Court dismissed both appeals filed by the revenue. The Court's decision was based on the reasoning provided in its judgment delivered on 22.04.2022 in Income Tax Appeal No.19 of 2013, in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. Surendra Shantilal Peety and other connected matters. The primary ground for dismissal was that the tax effect involved in these appeals was less than the monetary limit prescribed in the earlier circulars issued by the revenue from time to time. Consequently, the Court stated that it was not required to answer any substantial questions of law that had been formulated by the Court while admitting these appeals. No order as to costs was made.
The High Court of Kerala dismissed the appeals filed by the assessees, noting their decision to settle the disputes under the 'Vivad se Vishwas' scheme and their consequent withdrawal from prosecuting the appeals. The Court also dismissed the appeals filed by the Revenue, as the underlying disputes were settled by the assessees. The Court clarified that if the assessees could not avail the full benefit of the settlement or failed to deposit the stipulated amount, they and the Revenue were granted liberty to file a petition for recalling the order to hear their respective appeals on merit. The operative direction was the dismissal of all appeals with liberty to seek recall.
The High Court modified the award of the Learned Tribunal. It found that the involvement of the offending vehicle was proven, citing an eyewitness and the owner's non-contest. The Court determined the deceased's age as 40, applying a multiplier of 15 based on Sarla Verma. The annual income was fixed at Rs. 3,87,216, with income tax of Rs. 70,459 deducted, resulting in a net income of Rs. 3,16,757. Future prospects were added at 30% of the annual income, amounting to Rs. 63,351.4. General damages for loss of estate, consortium, and funeral expenses were calculated at Rs. 84,000. The total compensation was determined to be Rs. 42,01,842. The Court directed the insurance company to deposit the balance amount, along with interest, within six weeks. The appeal was disposed of, modifying the Tribunal's award.