COMNR.OF INCOME TAX vs. S.J.CHARITABLE TRUST

PDF · subscribers
ITA/68/2012HC OrissaODHC01000679201212 September 2018Bench: MR. JUSTICE K. S. JHAVERI (CJ),MR. JUSTICE K.R.MOHAPATRA4 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court addressed two substantial questions of law. Regarding the first question, the Court acknowledged that while consistency in the method of valuation is important, for each year the market price of goods can change, and thus the value of stock would accordingly change. The Court found that the A.O. had assessed the stock on the basis of the price at which goods were sold by the assessee, and if the market rate was higher, the tax effect could have been more. The Court agreed with the view taken by the A.O. and affirmed by the ITAT, answering the first question in favour of the revenue. Concerning the second question, the Court held that the decision in CIT vs. British Paints India Ltd. laid down principles for stock valuation considering the facts and circumstances of that specific case. The Court found that the sale price of goods having not changed every year, the method of valuation of stock cannot be applied in the same manner as held in British Paints India Ltd. Therefore, the Court answered the second question in favour of the revenue.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Bal Mukand Aggarwal, proprietor of Bal Iron and Steel Co., is in appeal against the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT). The Assessing Officer (A.O.) determined that the assessee had undervalued closing stock by showing items purchased at lower rates. The A.O. valued the closing stock as on 31.03.2007 at ₹91,84,351/-, against the assessee's declared amount of ₹73,15,253/-. This resulted in an addition to income and enhanced tax liability. The CIT(Appeals) examined the A.O.'s order and found no rejection of accounts or need for adjustment, stating the method of valuation was consistent. However, the ITAT concluded that closing stock should be valued at the lower of cost or market price, disagreeing with the assessee's average price method and upholding the A.O.'s order.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the Tribunal's order is unsustainable and perverse for overlooking material on record, rejecting consistency and regularity of the valuation method, and erroneously assuming jurisdiction without invoking Section 145 of the Income Tax Act, 1961? 2. Whether the decision in CIT vs. British Paints India Ltd. (1992) Supp.(1) SCC 55 is a binding precedent regarding the method of valuation of stock? Assessee's Contention: The CIT(Appeals) had examined the A.O.'s order and found no rejection of books of accounts or need for adjustment in closing stock valuation. The assessee argued that the method of valuation was consistent and that the A.O. had adopted an accounting method different from what the assessee had consistently followed. The assessee relied on the principle of consistency. Revenue's Contention: The revenue contended that the ITAT correctly concluded that closing stock should be valued at the lower of cost or market price, and that the assessee's average price method was contrary to established propositions. The revenue also argued that the ITAT rightly considered Section 145 of the Act and relevant case law.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 145,Section 144

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

214 IN THE

BAL MUKAND

COMMISSION CORAM: H

Present M

* SANJEEV PR

1.

T this Court vid 2. T (hereinafter r found that the the closing st E HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB CHANDIGARH I D ND AGGARWAL PROPERITOR, B

V NER OF INCOME TAX, PATIAL

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJ HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJ Mr. Divya Suri, Advocate and Mr. Sachin Bhardwaj, Advocate Mr. Amanpreet (A.P.) Singh, Sen for the respondent. *** RAKASH SHARMA, J. (Oral) This Appeal was admitted on the de order dated 29.04.2014:- (i) Whether under the facts an Tribunal order is unsus overlooking the ‘Materia consistency and regularity particularly while there is application of jurisdiction, of Section 145 of the Incom (ii) Whether the decision of C (1992) Supp.(1)SCC 55 i principles of law regardin stock?” The Income Tax Appellate Trib referred as “the ITAT”), in its e Assessing Officer (A.O.) had tock has been undervalued by sh

B AND HARYANA AT H ITA-68-2012 (O&M) Date of Decision: 05.08.2024 BAL IRON AND STEEL CO.

.…...Appellant V/s. LA (PUNJAB)

.....Respondent

NJEEV PRAKASH SHARMA NJAY VASHISTH for the appellant. nior Standing counsel, e following questions of law by nd circumstances of the case, the stainable and perverse, while al on Record' and rejecting the ty of the method of valuation, s an erroneous assumption and without invoking the provisions me Tax Act, 1961? CIT vs. British Paints India Ltd. is a binding precedent for the ng the method of valuation of bunal, Chandigarh Bench ‘B’ order dated 27.09.2011, has reached to the conclusion that howing item purchased by the Suresh Kumar 2024.08.08 13:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document

ITA-68-2012 (O&

Assessee at lo while the ass Accordingly, as on 31.03 `73,15,253/-. and according 3. I appellant that found that t rectification o basis of the pr has been con variation in wrongfully a appellant has 4. T stock is to b concept of a valuation of th view of the p (hereinafter re A.L.A. Firm Chainrup Sa aside the orde 5. A of law is wh &M)

Page 2 of 4 ower rates. Market price of such sessee had himself sold the sam the A.O. valued the closing stoc 3.2007 @ `91,84,351/- again The same was added to the inc gly the tax amount was enhanced It is the submission of the learn t the CIT(Appeals) had examin the A.O. had not rejected th or adjustment to be made in the roper valuation. It was also state nsistent as done by the appellan the method of valuation and adopted the accounting metho been consistently following. The ITAT however reached to t be valued at costs of market p average price, as adopted by he closing stock is contrary to su powers contained in Section 145 eferred as “the Act”) and consid Vs. CIT; (1991) 189 ITR (SC) ampatram Vs. CIT; (1953) 24 er of the CIT(Appeals) and uphel As regards the question No.(i) f hether “Material on Record” co h items was found @ `26,500/- me at the price of `23,478/-. ck of 391.190 MT @ `23,478/- nst the declared amount of curred income of the Assessee d. ned counsel for the applicant- ned the order of the A.O. and he books of accounts. Any closing stock should be on the ed that the method of valuation nt and there could not be any d the Assessing Officer had od different from what the the conclusion that the closing rice whichever is lower. The the Assessee, in computing uch established proposition. In 5 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 dering the law as laid down in following earlier judgement in 4 ITR 481 (SC), the ITAT set ld the order of the A.O. framed as substantial question ould be overlooked, we have Suresh Kumar 2024.08.08 13:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document

ITA-68-2012 (O&

already given the record ma market rate. H on the basis o If the market more i.e. on t price of good value of stock 6. W consistency a would remain valuation is c may change a change and th to be differen been introduc “Se Met (1) busi subj acco regu (2) from to b inco (3) corr whe &M)

Page 3 of 4 n our thoughtful consideration to aterial for assessing the value of However, in the present case, on of the price on which the goods h rate assessment is done, the tax the basis of amount of `26,500 ds by the Assessee @ `23,438/ ks to be `91,84,358/-. We are of the firm view tha and validity of method of valu n same for different assessment oncerned, for each year the mar and therefore, the value of the he same even for the same amoun nt. Thus, it is for that purpose alo ced in the Income Tax, 1961 whi ection 145. thod of accounting — Income chargeable under the h iness or profession” or “Income ject to the provisions of sub-se ordance with either cash or mer ularly employed by the assessee. The Central Government may n m time to time 2 [income computati be followed by any class of assessee ome. Where the Assessing Officer rectness or completeness of the a ere the method of accounting prov o the said aspect and find that f stock has to be based on the n facts, the A.O. has assessed it had been sold by the Assessee. x effect could have been much 0/-. While considering the sale /-, the A.O. has arrived at the at so far as the principle of uation is concerned, the same years. However, so far as the rket price of a particular goods stock would also accordingly nt of stock, valuation will have one Section 145 of the Act has ch reads as under:- head “Profits and gains of e from other sources” shall, ection (2), be computed in rcantile system of accounting notify in the Official Gazette ion and disclosure standards] es or in respect of any class of is not satisfied about the accounts of the assessee, or vided in sub-section (1) [has Suresh Kumar 2024.08.08 13:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document

ITA-68-2012 (O&

not com sect man 7. I account of the average mark sale price of g 8. K taken by the A favour of resp 9. A adjudication, Ltd.; (1992)S stock, conside would therefo The sale pric valuation of s British Paint in favour of th 10. I 11. A of accordingly

August 5, 202 Ess Kay

Whether Whether R &M)

Page 4 of 4 been regularly followed by the ass mputed in accordance with the st tion (2)], the Assessing Officer ma nner provided in section 144.]” In the present case, the valuati e change in market price as well ket could not have been taken up goods could not change in every Keeping in view the above, we a A.O. and affirmed by the ITAT pondent-revenue. As regards question No.(ii) we find that the decision of C Supp.(1)SCC 55 has laid down ering the facts and circumstanc ore not be a binding precedent ce of goods having not change stock cannot be applied in the sa ts India Ltd. (Supra). We accor he respondent/revenue. In view of the aforesaid, the App All pending applications filed in y.

[SANJ

speaking / reasoned

: Reportable

: essee, or income has not been tandards notified under sub- ay make an assessment in the ion of stock has changed on as change in the sale price, the p by the Assessee because the year. are in agreement with the view and answer question No.(i) in framed by this Court for CIT vs. British Paints India n the method of valuation of ces of the said case alone and in all cases as noticed above. ed every year, the method of ame manner as held in CIT vs. dingly answer question No.(ii) peal is dismissed. n this case shall stand disposed JEEV PRAKASH SHARMA] JUDGE SANJAY VASHISTH] JUDGE Yes / No Yes / No

Suresh Kumar 2024.08.08 13:28 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document

More judgments on Section 145

All 1,584 judgments and leading authorities on Section 145 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →