MR.LAXMIDHAR SAHOO vs. ASST.COMMNR.I.TAX

PDF · subscribers
ITA/54/2004HC OrissaODHC01028508200431 December 2018Author: MR. JUSTICE JUDGE-1,MR. JUSTICE JUDGE-26 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the assessee's conduct of denying possession of the locker during the search and subsequently claiming the cash belonged to the family was indicative of concealment. The Tribunal's reasoning, which relied on the AO's detailed findings, was found to be sound. The AO had noted the assessee's inability to specify the source of savings from HUF income, the lack of explanation for keeping such a large sum in cash in a locker, and the attempt to conceal the locker's existence. The Tribunal correctly observed that the slip found in the locker could not have been placed there in anticipation of a search, as it contradicted the sequence of events. Therefore, the Tribunal was justified in reversing the CIT(A)'s deletion of the addition of Rs. 86,000. The issue was answered in favor of the Department and against the assessee.

What were the facts?

The appellant, the assessee, is challenging an order dated 29.01.2004 passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Cuttack Bench. The ITAT had allowed an appeal by the Income Tax Department, reversing the decision of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) (CIT(A)) for assessment years 1990-91 and 1991-92. The dispute centers on an amount of Rs. 86,000 found in a bank locker. The search was conducted on 28.11.1990, but the locker was opened on 21.12.1990. Initially, the assessee denied possession of a locker. Upon its discovery, the assessee claimed the cash belonged to the HUF, derived from agricultural and house property income. The Assessing Officer (AO) treated this cash as concealed income, a view upheld by the ITAT but initially reversed by the CIT(A).

What were the issues?

1. Whether a slip dated 24.12.1990 found in a locker during a search could have been entirely discarded by the Tribunal, in view of Section 132(4A) of the Income Tax Act? (Question of law) 2. Whether the Tribunal's finding would have been different had it considered the slip dated 24.12.1990, indicating the Rs. 86,100 belonged to the family and not the petitioner, along with other materials? (Question of mixed law and fact) Assessee's contentions: The assessee argued that the slip found in the locker, indicating the cash belonged to the family, should have been considered by the Tribunal. The Tribunal's decision to discard this evidence was incorrect. Revenue's contentions: The revenue contended that the assessee initially denied possession of the locker, and only later claimed the cash belonged to the HUF. The explanation provided was unsatisfactory, and the nexus between the alleged HUF income and the cash was not established. The revenue argued that the slip was an afterthought, and the cash represented concealed income.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 132(4A),Section 271(1)(c),Section 143(3)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

13.

15.05.2019

By way of this Income Tax Appeal, the appellant has challenged order dated 29.01.2004 passed by the learned Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Cuttack Bench, Cuttack in ITA Nos.11 & 12/CTK/2000 for the assessment years 1990-91 & 1991-92, whereby learned Tribunal has allowed the appeal preferred by the Income Tax Department and reversed the finding arrived at by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-I, Bhubaneswar, Orissa.

This Court has admitted appeal on 31.08.2004 on the following substantial questions of law. (i) Whether the slip dated 24.12.1990 found from the locker in course of search could have been totally discarded by the Tribunal in view of section 132 (4- A) of the Income Tax Act? (ii) Whether the finding of the Tribunal in this impugned order would have been entirely different had it considered the slip dated 24.12.1990 found from the locker to the effect that the amount of Rs.86,100/- belongs to the family and not to the petitioner along with other materials.”

We have gone through the order of assessment passed by the learned Assessing Officer under Annexure-3, wherein it has been observed as under:-

“I have perused the Valuation report. The cost of construction as estimated by the Valuation Officer, appears to be very reasonable. During the course of hearing, the assessee was asked vide this office letter dated 27th September, 1993 as to explain why the value as estimated by the Valuer should not be adopted while completing the ITA No.54 of 2004

assessment of the assessee. In reply, the assessee referred only to cash flow statement and year-wise breakup of construction expenditure wherein he has stated that he has spent Rs.1,00,000/- only during the year. But he could not produce any evidence to that effect. He does not maintain any account and the investment in house property shown by him is not supported by any evidence. Accordingly, the cost of construction as estimated by the Valuer is taken as expenditure under the head construction of house property while recasting the cash flow statement. CASH FOUND LOCKER WITH PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK (Rs.86,000/-):

An amount of Rs.86,000/- was found in the Locker maintained by the assessee with Punjab National Bank. The original search was conducted on 28.11.90 but the Locker was opened on 21.12.90 i.e. after a gap of about one month. During the course search, assessee had denied possession of any locker, but subsequently the same came to the knowledge of the Department. When the locker was opened and the cash was found, the assessee gave a statement that the amount belong to the HUF being savings from Agriculture and House property income. The House property income of the assessee is Rs.11,000/- per year. It is further seen that the assessee is the owner of about 2 acres of agricultural land. Thus, the earning of income out of house property and agriculture is not denied. The question remains whether any such earning had resulted any savings, which was found in the form of cash in the locker. The assessee has not been able to state what part of income from H.P. and what part of income from Agriculture. Further it has also not been mentioned why such huge amount kept in bank locker and not in any bank account. It is also a fact that by not admitting the possession of locker at the time of search, the assessee had attempted to conceal the possession of this cash. Had this been out of any known source like, HUF, the assessee would have openly invested the same in profitable deposits. Therefore, the explanation given by the assessee considered as far from

satisfactory. Particularly, the nexus between the so- called income of the HUF and the amount of Rs.86,000/- is not established. On the other hand this explanation appears to be an afterthought of the assessee in the intervening period between the search and when the locker was opened. Thus, considering the explanation of the assessee is against the pre-ponderance of probabilities, I consider the amount of Rs.86,000/- is concealed income of the assessee detected from the locker.

As per the discussion, the case flow statement is recasted by not including the opening balance and the so-called receipt from wife and HUF and withdrawal from Sri Ram Alu Bhandar and adopting the investment in House property at Rs.1,63,436/- as under:-

To opening Cash Balance Nil By Building A/C 1,63,436 “Drawings from Business

“Domestic expenses 6,580 75,000 “LIC Premium 4,372 Nabaghan Pradhan & Partners 23,000 “Income tax paid 30,000 “Own Business 56,155 “Firm-tax paid

“LIC Receipts 5,000 (Sri 18,000 “Bank Interest 1,902 “Investment in 2,000 “Withdrawal From Baroda (SB) 18,000 “Interest Accrual

P.N.B (SB) 1,70,280 Bank of Baroda (SB)

Nil PNB (SB)

Andhra (FD)

“Concealed income from “Other Sources” 62,528 “Deposits in

PNB (SB)

1,46,725

Syndicate (DD) 13,850

Cash Seized 25,000

4,11,865

4,11,865

The above amount of Rs.62,528/- represents the out-goings over and above the incoming and is the concealed income of the assessee during this asst. year.

Subject to above remarks, the total income is computed as under:_ 1. BUSINESS (SHARE INCOME): (a) M/s Sri Ram Alu Bhandar (Subject to rectification) 19,433 (b) M/s Nabaghan Pradhan & Partners as determined

22,974 (c) Income from own business as shown

56,155 Rs. 98,562/- 2. Cash found in Locker with P.N.B. considered as concealed income of the assessee (as discussed)

Rs. 86,000/- 3. Concealed income from ‘Other Sources’ as discussed

Rs. 62,528/-

Total income Rs.2,47,090/-

Initiate penalty proceedings u/s. 271(1)(c) of the I.T. Act.

Assessed u/s. 143(3) on a total income of Rs.2,47,090/- issue D.N. Challan and copy of A.O.”

However, Commissioner of Income Tax (appeals), while allowing the appeal, relying on a chit as referred to in his note, the report of the Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Investigation Circle-I, Bhubaneswar (page 20 of the brief), which was an afterthought by the assessee, reversed the finding. However, learned Tribunal has rightly reversed the finding of the CIT (appeals) and observed at paragraph-6 as under:

“6 However for the AY 1991-92 Id. CIT (A) proceeded to delete the addition of Rs.86.000 holding that it was not established that the case belonged to the assessee and by placing reliance on the written slip found during the search in the locker not having proved as bogus finding

no alternative, accepted that the cash belonged to the HUF. We are unable to convince ourselves to this finding of the Id. CIT (A) inasmuch as the AO in his order had very clearly brought on record the following: “During the course of search, the assessee had denied possession of any locker, but subsequently same came to knowledge Department. When the locker was opened and the cash was found, the assessee gave a statement that the amount belong to the HUF being savings from agriculture and house property income. The house property income assessee is Rs.11,000/- per year. It is further seen that the assessee is the owner of about 2 acres of agriculture land. Thus, the earning on income out of house property and agriculture is not denied. The question remains whether any such earning had resulted any savings, which was found in the form of cash in the locker. The assessee has not been able to state what part of income from HP and what part of income from agriculture. Further, it has also not been mentioned why such huge amount kept in bank locker and not in any bank account. It is also a fact that by not admitting the possession of locker at the time of search, the assessee had attempted to conceal the possession of this cash. Had this been out of any known sources like HUF, the assessee would have openly invested the same in profitable deposits. Therefore, the explanation given by the assessee considered is far from satisfactory. Particularly, the nexus between the so called in one of the HUF and the amount of Rs.86,000 is not established. On the other hand this explanation appears to be an after though of the assessee in the intervening period between the search and when the locker was opened.”

In view of the above and the ld. CIT (A) also having deliberated upon the income of the HUF, could not have brushed aside the finding of the AO noted above. We hold of the view that the slip found in the locker could not have been there in anticipation of a search which belies total sequence of events and the acumen of subverting the probability in the normal course of search

action. Therefore, we are inclined to reverse the order of the Id. CIT (A) on the deletion of addition of Rs.86.000 as fraud by the AO as a clear finding which the assessee has not been able to justify keeping in view totality of the facts as brought on record. In the result the appeal for the AY 1991-92 is partly allowed and Rs.86.000.”

In our consider opinion, false statement has been made by the assessee that there is no locker in his name and when the locker was found to be his name, he asserted that the cash found in the said locker belongs to his family members. Thus, the cash found after one month, is the undisclosed income of the petitioner. Thus, no interference is called for. Accordingly, the issue is answered in favour of the Department and against the Assessee.

The Income Tax Appeal is accordingly dismissed.

.…….......……………… ( K.S. Jhaveri ) Chief Justice

…………………..……… (K.R. Mohapatra) Judge

More judgments on Section 132(4A)

All 641 judgments and leading authorities on Section 132(4A) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →