DCIT, CENTRAL CIRCLE -2(4), HYDERABAD vs. MSB PHARMACHEM PVT LTD, HYDERABAD
In favour of the assessee: the Revenue's appeal was dismissed. From the AI summary of this appeal.
What did the Tribunal hold?
The Tribunal held that the penalty levied under Section 271DA for alleged violation of Section 269ST was unsustainable in law. The Tribunal noted that while the assessee admitted additional income, this admission alone did not conclusively prove a violation of Section 269ST. The seized digital material was considered 'non-speaking and dumb' regarding transaction-wise and buyer-wise details of sales. The Tribunal relied on the principle that penalty proceedings are penal in character, requiring the department to establish the contravention with cogent material, not solely on the basis of assessment proceedings or admissions. The Tribunal cited the decisions in Sait Bansilal & Rangisetti Veeranna Vs. Commissioner of Income Tax and Commissioner of Income Tax Officer Vs Khoday Eswarsa and sons to support the view that findings in assessment proceedings are relevant but not final in penalty proceedings, and further evidence is needed. Since the AO failed to gather sufficient evidence to establish a violation of Section 269ST, the penalty was deleted. The orders of the CIT(A) deleting the penalty were upheld.
What were the facts?
The Revenue filed appeals against the orders of the CIT(A) for Assessment Years (AYs) 2019-20 and 2020-21, concerning the deletion of penalties levied under Section 271DA of the Income Tax Act, 1961. A search under Section 132 was conducted on the assessee, MSN Pharmachem Pvt Ltd, on February 24, 2021. During the search, digital evidence (Excel worksheets on a pen drive) was seized, indicating cash receipts from the sale of spent solvents and scrap. The assessee admitted additional income of Rs. 4,51,88,803/-. The Assessing Officer (AO) initiated penalty proceedings under Section 271DA for alleged violations of Section 269ST, citing receipt of cash amounts of Rs. 2,00,000/- or more for single transactions.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the learned CIT(A) erred in deleting the penalty of Rs. 2,15,42,065/- levied under Section 271DA of the Income Tax Act, 1961, for alleged violation of Section 269ST. Assessee's contentions: - Admission of additional income does not automatically imply a violation of Section 269ST. - The seized Excel sheets lacked specific details to establish violations of Section 269ST, such as receipt of Rs. 2,00,000/- or more in aggregate from a person in a day, or in respect of a single transaction, or relating to one event or occasion, otherwise than through specified modes. - The AO erred in shifting the burden of proof onto the Revenue to establish individual buyer-wise breakups, overlooking statutory presumptions under Sections 132(4A) and 292C. - The AO was not justified in treating each date-wise entry as a single transaction under Clause (b) of Section 269ST in the absence of verifiable sales invoices, cash receipts, or buyer books. Revenue's contentions: - The digital evidence (Excel workbook) dynamically proved the receipt of cash amounts exceeding Rs. 2,00,000/- on multiple specific dates for unaccounted sales of spent solvents. - The assessee accepted the credibility and accuracy of the seized digital data by voluntarily offering additional unaccounted income, making it legally inconsistent to label the data as 'dumb or non-speaking' for penalty provisions. - The AO was justified in treating each date-wise entry as a single transaction under Clause (b) of Section 269ST in the absence of verifiable day-wise sales invoices, cash receipts, or buyer books.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 132,Section 153A,Section 269ST,Section 271DA,Section 274,Section 132(4A),Section 292C
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Hyderabad “A” Bench, Hyderabad
आदेश / ORDER
PER BENCH : These two appeals filed by the Revenue are directed against the separate orders passed by the Learned Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-12, Hyderabad, both dated 16.03.2026 for the A.Ys 2019-20 and 2020-21 respectively. Since identical issues are involved in these two appeals, for the sake of convenience, these appeals were heard together and are being disposed off, by this common consolidated order. 2. The Revenue has, more or less raised common grounds of appeal in both the assessment years. Therefore, for the sake of brevity, grounds of appeal filed for Asst. Year 2019-20 in ITA. No. 2003/Hyd/2026 are reproduced as under : “1. The learned CIT(A) erred both on facts and in law in deleting the penalty of Rs.2,15,42,065/- levied under Section 271 DA of the Income Tax Act, 1961. 2. The learned CIT(A) erred in failing to appreciate that the digital evidence (Excel workbook) seized from the custody of the group's cashier dynamically proved the receipt of cash amounts exceeding on multiple specific dates for the unaccounted sale of spent solvents.
3 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
The learned CIT(A) failed to evaluate that the assessee company had accepted the absolute credibility and accuracy of the exact same seized digital data by voluntarily validating it to Offer additional unaccounted income of Rs.4,51,88,803/- in its return of income filed under Section 153A, making it legally inconsistent to label the same document as 'dumb or non- speaking' for penalty provisions. 4. The learned CIT(A) erred in shifting the entire burden of proof onto the Revenue to establish individual buyer-wise breakups, overlooking the statutory presumptions available to the Department under Section 132(4A) and Section 292C of the Act concerning documents seized during a search operation. 5. The learned CIT(A) failed to appreciate that in the absence of any verifiable day-wise sales invoices, cash receipts, or buyer books maintained by the assessee to prove that the single daily entries represented distinct collective payments under the AO was justified in treating each date-wise entry as a single transaction under Clause (b) of Section 269ST. 6. Appellant craves leave to amend or alter or modify the ground/grounds wherever necessary.”
The brief facts of the case are that a search and seizure action under Section 132 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, was carried out in the MSN Group of cases on 24.02.2021. The assessee is one of the companies covered under Section 132 of the Act. During the course of search proceedings at the registered and corporate office of the assessee on 24.02.2021, it was found that the used solvents in the form of effluents/recovered waste/spent solvents were sold to vendors in the unorganised sector, mostly in cash. The details of unaccounted cash received from the sale of spent solvents and scrap were recorded in Excel worksheets and stored in a 16GB Sony Pen Drive, which was found in the possession of Shri B. Buchi Reddy, Cashier, and seized as Annexure A/MSN/OFF/HD1. Based on the evidence found during the course of search, the assessee company had admitted additional income towards the
4 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
sale of spent solvents and scrap amounting to Rs.4,51,88,803/- for the year under consideration and also filed a return of income in response to notice under Section 153A of the Act, declaring the additional income offered towards the sale of spent solvents and scrap. During the course of assessment proceedings, the A.O., on the basis of the evidence found during the course of search, coupled with the admission of the assessee towards unaccounted cash received from the sale of spent solvents and scrap, arrived at a satisfaction that the assessee company had received cash of Rs.2,00,000/- or more for a single transaction, in violation of the provisions of Section 269ST of the Act. Accordingly, the details were forwarded to the Additional CIT, Central Range-2, Hyderabad, vide letter dated 25.05.2023, for necessary action. The Jt. CIT/Addl. CIT, Central Range-2, Hyderabad, issued a show- cause notice under Section 274 r.w.s. 271DA of the Act, on 07.03.2024 and called upon the assessee to explain why penalty under Section 271DA of the Act, should not be levied for violation of the provisions of Section 269ST of the Act, since an amount of Rs.4,51,88,803/- was received by the assessee in the above- mentioned transactions otherwise than by an account payee cheque or an account payee bank draft or through an electronic clearing system through a bank account.
In response to the show-cause notice, the assessee submitted that mere admission of additional income towards unaccounted receipts from the sale of spent solvents and scrap does not lead to a conclusion that there is a violation of the provisions of Section 269ST of the Act, so as to initiate penalty under Section 271DA of
5 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
the Act. The assessee further submitted that the A.O. had considered entries recorded in an Excel sheet found in a Pen Drive, which contained details of unaccounted sales of spent solvents and scrap by different units of the assessee company or group, and also the receipt of cash from buyers. However, there were no details as to the violation of the provisions of Section 269ST of the Act, because the Excel sheets did not show any details as to the receipt of an amount of Rs.2,00,000/- or more in aggregate from a person in a day, or in respect of a single transaction, or in respect of transactions relating to one event or an occasion from a person, otherwise than by an account payee cheque, an account payee bank draft, or through an electronic clearing system through a bank account. Therefore, merely on the basis of admission of additional income and filing of a return disclosing the said additional income in response to notice under Section 153A of the Act, it does not lead to a conclusion that the assessee had violated the provisions of Section 269ST of the Act, which warrants levy of penalty under Section 271DA of the Act.
The Ld. JCIT/Addl. CIT, after considering the submissions of the assessee and also taking note of the provisions of Section 269ST of the Act, which deal with the receipt of an amount of Rs.2,00,000/- or more in aggregate from a person in a day, in respect of a single transaction, or in respect of transactions relating to one event or occasion, observed that there was no dispute on the fact that the seized material clearly showed the recording of date-wise sales of spent solvents and scrap by the assessee group companies, which were reflected in a segment of
6 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
one of the Excel sheets. These date-wise transactions of sale of spent solvents by each company of the assessee group were held to fit into clause (b) of Section 269ST of the Act, i.e., receipt of Rs.2,00,000/- or more in respect of a single transaction. Though the assessee claimed that the date-wise amounts shown in Segment-I related to the sale of spent solvents and pertained to transactions with numerous persons at different units of the company, the assessee failed to submit any supporting evidence in respect of the same. Since the assessee claimed that the cash received towards the sale of spent solvents and scrap in respect of a single transaction was not in excess of the specified amount, the Ld. JCIT/Addl. CIT held that it was for the assessee to discharge the burden with relevant evidence. The assessee should have produced verifiable evidence in support of its claim that the cash was received within the specified limit as per the provisions of Section 269ST of the Act. Since the assessee had failed to prove the same, the Ld. JCIT/Addl. CIT, on the basis of the seized documents found during the course of search, quantified the amount received in excess of Rs.2,00,000/- in respect of single transactions pertaining to the sale of spent solvents, which worked out to Rs.2,15,42,065/- for the financial year from 01.04.2018 to 31.03.2019, and levied penalty of Rs.2,15,42,065/- under Section 271DA of the Act, for violation of the provisions of Section 269ST of the Act.
7 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
Aggrieved by the order passed by the JCIT/Addl. CIT, the assessee preferred an appeal before the Ld. CIT(A). Before the Ld. CIT(A), the assessee challenged the order passed under Section 271DA of the Act, and claimed that the penalty order passed by the JCIT/Addl. CIT was barred by limitation in view of the specific provisions of Section 275(1)(c) of the Act. The assessee also challenged the penalty levied under Section 271DA of the Act, in light of the reasons given by the JCIT/Addl. CIT in the order passed under Section 271DA, and claimed that the JCIT/Addl. CIT had failed to establish the violation of Section 269ST of the Act, so as to invoke the provisions of Section 271DA of the Act.
The Ld. CIT(A), after considering the relevant submissions and also taking note of the observation of the Tribunal in Para 15 to 18 of the order in the case of M/s. MSN Laboratories Private Limited Vs. ACIT in ITA Nos. 2164, 2165, 2171 and 2172/Hyd/2025, order dated 25.02.2026, deleted the penalty levied u/s 271DA of the Act. The Ld. CIT(A) further observed that, the seized Excel data contained in Segment-1 reflected consolidated, date-wise sales of spent solvents from various plants/divisions and group companies. However, the said data did not contain buyer-wise or transaction-wise details, nor did it identify the individual buyers or establish the amount and date of cash receipt from each buyer. The Ld. CIT(A) further observed that, the date-wise sales figures appearing in the Excel sheets could not, by themselves, be treated as evidence of receipt of cash from a single buyer in a single transaction. The mere recording of sales on a particular date did
8 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
not establish that the assessee had received an amount of Rs.2,00,000/- or more from a person in a day, in respect of a single transaction, or in respect of transactions relating to one event or occasion, as contemplated under Section 269ST of the Act. The Ld. CIT(A) accordingly held that, the material relied upon by the A.O. was not sufficient to establish a violation of the provisions of Section 269ST of the Act. Therefore, the Ld. CIT(A) deleted the penalty imposed under Section 271DA of the Act. The relevant portion of Ld. CIT(A) order is reproduced below :
“6.1.14 I have considered the assessment order, penalty order, submissions of the appellant and the judgment of the Hon’ble ITAT relied upon by the appellant. 6.1.14.1 On merits, it is observed that the Addl. CIT has relied primarily on Segment-I of the Excel workbook contained in the seized pen drive, which records date-wise figures of sale of spent solvents by different companies and plants of the MSN group. On the basis of the entries exceeding Rs. 2 lakhs on certain dates, the Addl. Commissioner concluded that such entries represent receipt of Rs. 2 lakhs or more in respect of a single transaction within the meaning of clause (b) of Section 269ST and accordingly levied penalty of Rs. 2,15,42,065/-. 6.1.14.2 However, on a careful examination of the seized material and the explanation offered by the appellant, it becomes evident that the entries in Segment-I only represent aggregate sales recorded on a particular date by different plants or divisions of multiple group companies. The seized Excel sheet does not contain any transaction-wise details of sales made to individual buyers. The sheet also does not contain the identity of the buyers, the date of receipt of cash from such buyers or the amount received from each buyer. Further, the seized material itself indicates that the cash receipts were not necessarily contemporaneous with the date of sale and in certain cases advances were received and subsequently adjusted against sales. The aggregate cash receipts from buyers were recorded only on a weekly basis in Segment-2 and Segment-5 of the Excel sheet. 6.1.14.3 Thus, the seized material does not establish the fundamental ingredients necessary to attract clause (b) of Section 269ST. There is no material showing that the appellant received Rs. 2 lakhs or more in respect of a single identifiable transaction. The figures appearing in
9 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
Segment-I only represent aggregate sales on a given date and may include multiple sales to different buyers across different plants. Without identifying the individual buyer and the actual amount received from such buyer in a particular transaction, it is not possible to conclude that the statutory threshold prescribed under Section 269ST has been violated. 6.1.14.4 The jurisdictional Hon’ble ITAT, Hyderabad, in the appellant’s own group case, has examined the very same issue relating to seized material and the same Excel workbook found in the pen drive of the cashier. After detailed examination, the Hon’ble ITAT held that the seized Excel sheet only contains consolidated figures relating to aggregate sales of spent solvents made by multiple companies of the group and that the material does not contain buyer-wise or transaction-wise details required to establish violation of Section 269ST. The Hon’ble ITAT further held that in penalty proceedings the burden lies on the Revenue to establish the occurrence of default with cogent and tangible evidence and that mere admission of additional income or presence of figures in the seized sheet cannot by itself justify levy of penalty. 6.1.14.5 The Hon’ble ITAT observed that the seized material relied upon by the Assessing Officer was wholly non-speaking and did not contain the necessary particulars of individual transactions or receipts from identifiable buyers. The entries appearing in the Excel sheet did not disclose the names of the parties, the nature of the transactions, or the specific circumstances in which the amounts were received. In the absence of such basic details, the entries by themselves could not be treated as conclusive evidence to establish that any person had received [amount unclear in source] or more in cash in respect of a single transaction or event. On this basis, the Hon’ble ITAT held that the fundamental conditions required for invoking the provisions of Section 269ST were not demonstrated and consequently the penalty imposed under Section 271DA was not sustainable on the facts of the case. 6.1.14.6 The Hon’ble ITAT further noted that the factual foundation for initiating penalty proceedings had not been properly verified by the Assessing Officer. The assessment records did not establish, with transaction-wise evidence, that the alleged receipts were actually received in cash or that they represented receipts exceeding the statutory threshold of [amount unclear in source] from a person in a day or in relation to a single transaction or event. The identity of the payer, the nature of the underlying transactions, and their linkage with the regular books of account were also not verified. The Hon’ble ITAT pointed out that the records did not clearly show whether the transactions were already recorded in the books, reconciled with statutory records, or supported by reliable documentary evidence. It was also observed that issues such as mismatch in transaction details, duplication of entries, aggregation errors, and lack of correlation between the seized material and the books of account had not been properly examined. In view of these deficiencies,
10 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
the Hon’ble ITAT concluded that the Assessing Officer had failed to establish the factual basis required to demonstrate a violation of Section 269ST and to sustain the penalty under Section 271DA. For ready reference, the relevant portion of the Hon’ble ITAT order is reproduced as under: 23. Coming back to Ground Nos. 6, 7 & 8 of assessee’s appeal and by above grounds, the assessee challenged penalty levied by the A.O. under Section 271DA of the Act on merits for A.Ys. 2018-19 to 2021-22. The A.O. levied the penalty under Section 271DA of the Act for violation of Section 269ST of the Act on the ground that the assessee has received cash in excess of Rs. 2 lakhs or more in respect of a single transaction for sale of unaccounted scrap and spent solvents. The A.O. levied penalty on the basis of Excel workbook found from the pen drive in the possession of Shri B. Buchi Reddy, Cashier, during the course of search, where he had maintained the details of date-wise sales of spent solvents and scraps along with the details of opening cash in hand, amount received from the buyers/receivable and closing cash in hand. The above worksheet also contained the details of party-wise sales by each company of MSN Group by different units/plants along with amounts paid to the M.D. of the MSN Group and other family members, including employees, for various expenses. The A.O. considered Segment (1) of the Excel workbook, which appears at the extreme right of the Excel sheets pertaining to sale of spent solvent, and it contained the details of date of sale, amount and the name of the company/plant of the company which made the sales, and considered only the amounts which exceeded Rs. 2 lakhs or more on a particular date for the purpose of levying penalty under Section 271DA of the Act for all the A.Ys.
We have gone through the relevant Excel sheets found from the pen drive of Shri B. Buchi Reddy, Cashier of assessee’s group, which is available in the paper book filed by the assessee. We find that the relevant Excel sheets were maintained in common for all five companies of MSN Group, including the assessee, in respect of unaccounted sales of spent solvent and scraps. As explained therein, the entries in the Excel sheets are found to be made in five distinct data segments. The entries in all the five segments are usually bunched together for a period of one week. Segment-I, which appears at the extreme left of the Excel sheet, pertains to sales of spent solvents and it contains the details of date of sale, amount and the name of the company/plant of the company which made the sales. This segment is found separately for each period and the total of such sales for the concerned period of one week is drawn at the bottom of Segment-I for each period. Segment 2, which appears to the immediate right of Segment (1) for each period, contains the details of the opening balance of net receivables/payables at the beginning of the period, sales made for the relevant period, aggregate cash received from the buyers during the period and closing balance of net receivables/payables at the end of the period. Segment (3), which appears to the immediate right of Segment (2) for each period, contains the buyer-wise break-up of the closing balance of net receivables/payables. Segment (4), which appears to the immediate right of Segment (3) for each period, pertains to the sale of scraps made in cash and it contains the name of the company/plant or division of the
11 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
company which made the sales. The total of such cash sales of scraps for the concerned period of one week is drawn at the bottom of Segment (4) for each period. Segment (5), which appears below Segment (2) for each period, contains the details of opening balance of cash, aggregate of the cash received for the relevant period out of the sales of spent solvent and scraps, cash handed over to Shri M.S.N. Reddy, his family members during the period, cash handed over to the employees named therein and closing balance at the end of the period. As mentioned earlier, the details of sale of spent solvent are recorded in Segment (1) of the Excel sheet and it contains the date-wise details of spent solvent made by each plant/division of five companies of the group. The entries recorded therein represent the aggregate sales made on a said date to a buyer/multiple buyers, as the case may be. The above Excel sheet does not show any details of each sale made to each buyer on the said date by the plant/division of the said company. Further, on perusal of the Excel sheet, we find that the sale proceeds in cash in respect of sales of spent solvent recorded in Segment (1) are not received immediately. This feature is evident from the fact that the amount of aggregate cash received from sale of spent solvents during a particular period, as recorded in the corresponding Segment-2 and Segment-5, does not match with the total amount of sales of spent solvents as recorded at the bottom of Segment-I for the said period. It may also be seen that in some cases, the cash received is in advance from the buyers and the cash receivables against the sales made to such buyer are adjusted against the said advance. It will be noticed that the details of receipt of cash from the buyers either towards the advance or towards sale proceeds and the amount of cash received on each date are not recorded either in Segment (2) or Segment (5) or anywhere else in the seized material. Though the sales of spent solvents were made by various plants of each of the five companies of the group at different locations to multiple buyers at each of such locations, the cash receipts from such sales from all the buyers put together were recorded by the cashier as a single entry for the entire period of one week in Segment (2) and Segment (5) of the Excel sheet. The details of buyers from whom such cash was received during the relevant period of one week, the date of such receipts and the amount of such receipts from each buyer and the names of the companies/plants in respect of whose unaccounted sales of spent solvents such cash was received have not been recorded by the cashier in the Excel sheet. As a result of the said manner of recording the unaccounted sale of spent solvents and cash receipts by the cashier in the Excel sheet, it is abundantly clear that the date-wise information recorded in Segment (1) only reveals the aggregate amount of cash sales of spent solvents on each particular date by different companies/divisions/plants of the group, but not the amount of sales achieved by the assessee company alone on a particular date, as claimed by the A.O. In the absence of recording such details in the Excel sheets, the quantum of cash sales in respect of each single transaction of unaccounted sale of spent solvent is not ascertainable in order to arrive at any conclusion as to whether the amount received in respect of a single transaction is Rs. 2 lakhs or more. We further note that, except the entry appearing on a particular date in excess of Rs. 2 lakhs or more having been considered by the A.O., there is no tangible and cogent material on record to infer the violation of the provisions of clause (b) of Section 269ST of the Act in the case of the
12 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
assessee. The material available in the Excel sheet does not contain any data that reveals unambiguously that the assessee was in receipt of cash of Rs. 2 lakhs or more in respect of a single transaction. Therefore, in our considered view, there is no material on record for the A.O. to allege that the assessee has committed violation of the provisions of Section 269ST of the Act for the purpose of levy of penalty under Section 271DA of the Act. 25. We further note that it is a settled law that the burden of establishing the occurrence of default by the assessee under the relevant provision of the statute, which makes the assessee liable for penalty under the Act, with the aid of tangible and cogent evidence, is on the Revenue, since the allegation of such violation is made by the Revenue. In the present case, since the allegation of violation of Section 269ST of the Act has been made by the A.O., the onus lies on the Revenue to establish the said alleged violation by the assessee. However, as noted in the earlier part of this order, from the material considered by the A.O. for the purpose of levy of penalty under Section 271DA of the Act, no such evidence is forthcoming from the seized material and no evidence to the said fact has been brought on record by the A.O. Although the Ld. Jt. CIT observed that it is for the assessee to discharge the burden by furnishing the relevant evidence and prove that the cash received towards the sale of spent solvents and scraps is less than the amount specified under Section 269ST of the Act and the assessee has not discharged the burden, but in our considered view, once the A.O. makes the allegation that the assessee had violated the provisions of Section 269ST of the Act, then it is for the A.O. to prove the allegation with relevant evidence. Once the A.O. discharges the burden of evidence, then the assessee has to disprove the claim of the A.O. by explaining the details to the A.O. for the purpose of levying penalty under Section 271DA of the Act. In the present case, admittedly, there is no evidence of any kind of sales bills or cash receipts for sale of unaccounted spent solvents and scraps. The only evidence which was found during the course of search was one Excel sheet maintained for the entire group by the Cashier and, as explained by the assessee, the above document contains details of sales made for a particular period by the group as a whole in respect of all the five companies and from different plants/units. Since the assessee group consists of five companies and further has multiple units/plants which generate spent solvents and scraps, and also the assessee discharges the spent solvents and scraps from different units/plants to different buyers, in our considered view, only on the basis of consolidated entries appearing in Segment (1) of the Excel sheet, it cannot be alleged that the assessee violated clause (b) of Section 269ST of the Act for imposing penalty under Section 271DA of the Act. Therefore, in our considered view, the A.O. has not conclusively proved the violation of provisions of Section 269ST of the Act so as to levy penalty under Section 271DA of the Act, and thus, in our considered view, penalty levied by the A.O. is not sustainable on merits on the facts of the case and in law. 26. We further note that the admission of the assessee does not ipso facto lead to levy of penalty, even though the assessee has made a statement regarding receipt of amount from the sale of spent solvents and scrap. Further, mere confessional statement without there being any documentary evidence in proof of such break-up of transactions cannot
13 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
be solely relied upon while considering the penalty proceedings. Such evidence by way of statement might be considered for making the assessment, but, however, for consideration of the penalty proceedings, being independent in nature, further additional evidence is required to be brought on to the file as corroborative in nature. Moreover, the assessment proceedings and penalty proceedings are altogether different, and the evidence that was relied upon during the assessment proceedings may not be considered as the sole factor and sufficient evidence for levy of penalty. This legal principle is supported by the decision of the Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court of Andhra Pradesh in the case of Sait Bansilal & Rangisetti Veeranna Vs. Commissioner of Income Tax - [1972] 83 ITR 750 (AP), wherein the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh held that “Tax and Penalty, like tax and penal interest, are distinct and different concepts under the Act. Penalty is in addition to the tax determined as payable by the assessee. Penalty cannot be taken as additional tax for all purposes. The penalty and assessment proceedings are not one and the same proceedings. The findings given in the assessment proceedings would only be relevant and admissible but not final and conclusive in penalty proceedings. In penalty proceedings, further evidence can be led to rebut the findings given in the assessment proceedings.” According to the said case law, it can be understood that in order to levy penalty, the Assessing Officer has to gather the evidence from the seized material. But, in fact, the seized material is wholly non- speaking and dumb with regard to the transaction-wise and buyer-wise details of the sales of spent solvents embedded in the date-wise sales recorded in Segment-I. There is no material whatsoever to reach any conclusion regarding contravention of the provisions of clause (b) of Section 269ST. Consequently, the penalty under Section 271DA cannot be levied. We also refer to the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax Officer Vs. Khoday Eswarsa and Sons [1972] 83 ITR 369, where it was held that “Penalty proceedings being penal in character, the department must establish that the receipt of the amount in dispute constitutes income of the assessee. Apart from the falsity of the explanation given by the assessee, the department must have before it, before levying penalty, cogent material or evidence from which it could be inferred that the assessee had consciously concealed the particulars of his income or had deliberately furnished inaccurate particulars in respect of the same and that the disputed amount is a revenue receipt. No doubt, the original assessment proceedings for computing the tax may be a good item of evidence in the penalty proceedings, but the penalty cannot be levied solely on the basis of the reasons given in the original order of assessment.” Therefore, in our considered view, the materials considered by the A.O. for the purpose of levy of penalty under Section 271DA for violation of Section 269ST does not show any evidence of violation of clause (b) of Section 269ST of the Act, and thus, penalty levied by the A.O. under Section 271DA is unsustainable under law. 27. In this view of the matter and considering the facts and circumstances of the case, we are of the considered view that the penalty levied by the A.O. under Section 271DA of the Act for alleged violation of Section 269ST of the I.T. Act, 1961, is unsustainable in law. Therefore, on this count also, penalty levied by the A.O. should be deleted. The Ld. CIT(A), without appreciating the relevant facts, simply sustained the
14 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
penalty levied by the A.O. Thus, we set aside the order of the Ld. CIT(A) and direct the A.O. to delete the penalty levied under Section 271DA of the Act for the A.Ys. 2018-19 to 2021-22. 28. In the result, the appeals filed by the assessee for the A.Ys. 2018-19 to 2021-22 are allowed.”
6.1.15 by the Hon’ble ITAT in the appellant's own group cases relating to the same seized pen drive and the same excel workbook maintained by the cashier of the group. The penalty in the present case has also been levied by the Addl. Commissioner on the basis of the entries appearing in segment-I of the excel sheet by treating the date-wise figures of sales as individual cash receipts exceeding Rs.2 lakhs. However, as clearly brought out in the findings of the Hon'ble ITAT, segment-I merely records the aggregate value of sales of spent solvents made by various plants and divisions of multiple companies of the MSN group on a particular date. The sheet does not contain buyer-wise or transaction-wise details. It does not indicate the identity of the buyers, the amount received from each buyer, or the date of receipt of cash. The seized material itself shows that the cash receipts from buyers were recorded only on a consolidated basis for a weekly period in other segments of the workbook and that such receipts did not necessarily coincide with the dates of sale recorded in segment- 1. Therefore, the date-wise figures appearing in segment- 1 only represent aggregate sales rnade on a particular date and cannot be equated with the amount received from a single buyer in a single transaction. In view of the above factual position and the categorical findings 6.1.16 recorded by the Hon'ble ITAT, the basis adopted by the Addl. Commissioner for invoking the provisions of section 269ST in the present case cannot be sustained. The penalty has been levied by treating consolidated figures of sales as individual receipts without establishing the identity of the payer, the nature of the transaction, or the actual amount received from each buyer. No transaction-wise evidence has been brought on record to demonstrate that the appellant had received or more in respect of a single transaction or from a person in a day or in relation to a single event. As held by the Hon'ble ITAT, in penalty proceedings the burden lies squarely on the revenue to establish the occurrence of default through cogent and tangible evidence. In the absence of buyer-wise details, sales invoices, cash receipts or any other corroborative material, the consolidated entries appearing in the excel sheet cannot by themselves establish violation of section 269ST. Therefore, following the binding decision of the Hon'ble ITAT on the identical seized material and identical issue in the appellant's own group cases, the penalty levied under section 27 IDA in the present case is not sustainable on facts.” “6.2 Apart from the above, on the technical issue relating to the validity of the order passed under Section 271DA of the Act in the light of Section
15 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
275(1)(c), the Hon’ble ITAT held that the penalty order dated 27.09.2024 was barred by limitation and therefore non-est in law. The Hon’ble ITAT observed that for the purpose of computing the limitation prescribed under Section 275(1)(c), the relevant starting point is not the date on which the Addl./Jt. CIT issued the show-cause notice under Section 274 read with Section 271DA, but the date on which the Assessing Officer first initiated action for imposition of penalty by making a reference to the competent authority. In the present case, the Assessing Officer had sent the reference on 25.05.2023. Therefore, six months from the end of that month expired on 30.11.2023. Since the penalty order was ultimately passed only on 27.09.2024, the Hon’ble ITAT held that the order was clearly beyond the period of limitation prescribed under Section 275(1)(c) of the Act and consequently liable to be quashed. 6.2.1 The Hon’ble ITAT further observed that the reliance placed by the Revenue on CBDT Circular No. 9/2016 and the decision of the Hon’ble Kerala High Court in the case of Grihalakshmi Vision was not applicable in the facts of the present case. The Hon’ble ITAT preferred to follow the later decision of the Hon’ble Karnataka High Court in the case of Pr. CIT v. K. Umesh Shetty and also relied upon the decision of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in Pr. CIT v. Rishikesh Buildcon (P.) Ltd., wherein it was held that the date on which the Assessing Officer initiates action for penalty proceedings is the relevant date for computing the limitation under Section [unclear in source]. The Hon’ble ITAT also referred to the similar view taken by the Hyderabad Bench in the case of M/s. Sireesha Pochareddy. Applying these judicial principles to the facts of the case, the Hon’ble ITAT concluded that the penalty order passed under Section 271DA was invalid and liable to be quashed on the ground of limitation. 6.2.2 On the issue relating to recording of a valid satisfaction by the Assessing Officer in the assessment order regarding the alleged violation of the provisions of Section 269ST of the Act, the Hon’ble ITAT held that the penalty proceedings cannot be held to be invalid merely on the ground that elaborate satisfaction was not recorded in the assessment order. The Hon’ble ITAT observed that the assessment records indicated that the Assessing Officer had identified the alleged cash transactions exceeding the prescribed threshold during the course of assessment proceedings and had thereafter made a reference to the competent authority for initiation of penalty proceedings under Section 271DA. According to the Hon’ble ITAT, such reference by the Assessing Officer itself indicates that the Assessing Officer had formed a prima facie satisfaction regarding the alleged violation of Section 269ST. Therefore, the requirement of recording satisfaction for initiating penalty proceedings stood substantially complied with and the penalty proceedings could not be invalidated solely on this ground. For ready reference, the relevant judgment is reproduced below:
“……..15. We have heard both the parties, perused the material available on record and had gone through the orders of the authorities below. We have also
16 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
carefully considered the relevant legal ground taken up by the assessee challenging the validity of the order passed by the A.O. under Section 271DA of the Act in light of provisions of Section [unclear in source] of the Act. We have also carefully considered the relevant circulars issued by the CBDT and also the case laws referred to by the learned counsel for the assessee and the Ld. Sr. AR present for the Revenue. The assessee had taken a legal ground challenging the validity of penalty order passed by the A.O. on limitation for the A.Ys. 2018-19 and 2019-20. The assessee claims that the penalty order is invalid in law as the same is time-barred. Admittedly, in the present case, the penalty proceedings were triggered from the A.O. with a reference to the Jt. CIT for taking necessary action for imposition of penalty under Section 271DA of the Act. The A.O. had sent information regarding the violation of provisions of Section 269ST of the Act for the A.Ys. 2018-19 and 2019-20 on 25.05.2023. Based on the reference received from the A.O., the Addl. CIT, Central Range-2, issued a show-cause notice under Section 274 r.w.s. 271DA of the Act on 07.03.2024 and passed the order under Section 271DA of the Act on 27.09.2024. Therefore, it is necessary for us to examine whether the penalty order passed by the A.O. under Section 271DA of the Act dated 27.09.2024 is within the limitation provided under Section 275(1)(c) of the Act or is barred by limitation. 16. The provisions of Section 275(1)(c) of the Act deal with the time limit for passing the penalty orders. As per the provisions of Section 275(1)(c) of the Act, no penalty order shall be passed after the expiry of (a) the financial year in which the proceedings, in the course of which action for imposition of the penalty has been initiated, are completed, or (b) six months from the end of the month in which the action for imposition of penalty is initiated, whichever is later. In the present case, the assessment under Section 153A of the Act was concluded on 31.03.2023 and the action for imposition of penalty under Section 271DA of the Act has not been initiated in the course of assessment proceedings. Therefore, clause (a) of Section [unclear in source] of the Act is not applicable. Further, clause (b) of Section 275(1)(c) of the Act provides six months from the end of the month in which the action for initiation of penalty is initiated and in the present case, the A.O. has sent a proposal or reference to the Jt. CIT for taking necessary action on 25.05.2023. As held by the Hon’ble Karnataka High Court in the case of Pr. CIT v. K. Umesh Shetty (supra), the date of a reference made by the A.O. to the Addl. CIT for imposition of penalty under Section 271DA of the Act was to be treated as the triggering point for initiation of penalty proceedings under Section 271DA of the Act. A similar view has been taken by the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of Pr. CIT v. Rishikesh Buildcon (P.) Ltd. (supra), where it has been held that pursuant to the completion of the quantum proceedings by the A.O., further penalty proceedings against the assessee under Section 271DA for violating the provisions of Section 269ST of the Act were also initiated in December 2008; six months from the end of the month in which the penalty proceeding was initiated should be considered. The sum and substance of the ratios laid down by various High Courts for determining the limitation for passing the penalty orders as referred to under Section [unclear in source] of the Act is that the date on which the A.O. sent the proposal to the Addl. CIT/Jt. CIT should be considered, but not the date on which the Jt. CIT issued the show- cause notice under Section 274 r.w.s. 271DA of the Act. In the present case, the A.O. sent reference to the Jt. CIT on 25.05.2023 for taking action for imposition of penalty under Section 271DA of the Act. Therefore, in our considered view, the starting point for initiation of the action for imposition of penalty within the meaning of Section 275(1)(c) of the Act is from 25.05.2023 and for the purpose of determining the limitation period for passing the penalty order, six months from
17 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
the end of May 2023 should be considered, but not from 07.03.2024, i.e., the date on which the authority issued the show-cause notice under Section 274 r.w.s. 271DA of the Act. Since the A.O. sent reference to the Jt. CIT on 25.05.2023, in our considered view, six months’ period should be considered from the end of May 2023, i.e., 31.05.2023, and if we consider the starting point from 01.06.2023, then the A.O. ought to have passed the order under Section 271DA of the Act on 30.11.2023. In the present case, since the A.O. has passed the order under Section 271DA of the Act on 27.09.2024, in our considered view, it is barred by limitation and the same is non-est in the eyes of law.
Coming back to the argument of the Ld. Sr. AR for the Revenue in light of CBDT Circular No. 9 of 2016 dated 26.04.2016 and also the decision of the Hon’ble Kerala High Court in the case of Grihalakshmi Vision v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax (supra), that for commencement of limitation for penalty proceedings under Section 271DA of the Act, it is the date on which the Jt. CIT issued a show-cause notice under Section 274 r.w.s. 271DA of the Act that is to be considered, but not the date on which the A.O. sent a proposal to the Jt. CIT for taking action for imposition of penalty under Section 271DA of the Act. In our considered view, although the Hon’ble Kerala High Court in the above case has held that the competent authority to levy penalty being a Jt. Commissioner and for the purpose of limitation, the date on which the Jt. CIT issued the show-cause notice should be considered, the fact remains that the above decision of the Hon’ble Kerala High Court and the circular issued by the CBDT had been considered by the Hon’ble Karnataka High Court in the case of Pr. CIT v. K. Umesh Shetty (supra) and held that it was in disagreement with the view taken by the Hon’ble Kerala High Court on the ground that a perusal of the said judgment does not show that there was any reference from the A.O. to the “competent authority,” unlike the case in hand. Since the decision of the Hon’ble Karnataka High Court is of a later date and also it had taken into account the decision of the Hon’ble Kerala High Court and distinguished the above judgment, in our considered view, the arguments of the Ld. Sr. AR in light of the Hon’ble Kerala High Court and the CBDT Circular No. 9 of 2016 do not hold good and cannot be accepted. Further, other case laws relied upon by the Ld. Sr. AR for the Revenue are also not considered, because the facts of the above cases are entirely different from the facts of the assessee’s case. 18. The learned counsel for the assessee had relied upon the decision of the Hon’ble Karnataka High Court in the case of Pr. CIT v. K. Umesh Shetty (supra). The Hon’ble Karnataka High Court had considered an identical issue of levy of penalty under Section 271D of the Act, in light of limitation provided under Section 275(1) of the Act and after considering the relevant facts has held as under:
“6.7 In the facts of this case, these twin purposes can be achieved by treating the reference by the ITO to the Additional Commissioner as the triggering point or initiation of penalty proceedings. The ITO vide letter dated 16.11.2016 had admittedly made the reference. The Additional Commissioner of Income Tax issued the Show Cause Notice only on 10.11.2017 (nearly a year later) proposing the levy of penalty under Section 271D of the Act. The Penalty Order was made on 22.02.2018. If the reckoning point is 16.11.2016, it is clear that the proceedings were completed beyond the period of limitation, as rightly contended by the
18 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
learned counsel appearing for the Assessee. Even otherwise, the concept of delay and laches would creep in; no explanation whatsoever has been offered by the Revenue for the laxity shown in belatedly issuing the show-cause notice/proposition notice which they claim amounted to initiation of penalty proceedings. This view has animated the reasoning of the impugned order of the Tribunal, may be a bit inarticulately. 6.8. The reliance of Panel Counsel for the Revenue on the Coordinate Bench decision in COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX v. TAM TAM PEDDA GURUVA REDDY does not come to his aid since the same has been rendered largely fact-specific. The other decision, namely GRIHALAKSHMI v. ADDITIONAL COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-7, at para 10, observed as under” ‘Question to be considered is whether proceedings for levy of penalty are initiated with the passing of the order of assessment by the Assessing Officer or whether such proceedings have commenced with the issuance of the notice issued by the Joint Commissioner. From statutory provision, it is clear that the competent authority to levy penalty being the Joint Commissioner. Therefore, only the Joint Commissioner can initiate proceedings for levy of penalty...’ These observations arguably support the view of Revenue, is true. However, we respectfully disagree with the said view. That apart, a perusal of the said judgment does not show that there was any reference made by the ITO to the competent authority, unlike in the case at hand. Further, the following observations in para 10 in D.M. Manasvi v. Commissioner of Income Tax (1973) 3 SCC 207 would cast some doubt on the correctness of Grihalakshmi, supra. ‘We are also [unclear in source] not impressed by the argument advanced by the appellant that the proceedings for the imposition of penalty were initiated not by the Income Tax Officer but by the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner when the matter had been referred to him under Section 274(2) of the Act. The proceedings for the imposition of penalty in terms of sub-section (1) of Section 271 have necessarily to be initiated either by the Income Tax Officer or by the Appellate Assistant Commissioner. The fact that the Income Tax Officer has to refer the case to the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner if the minimum imposable penalty exceeds the sum of rupees one thousand in a case falling under clause (c) of sub- section (1) of Section 271 would not show that the proceedings in such a case cannot be initiated by the Income Tax Officer. The Income Tax Officer in such an event can refer the case to the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner after initiating the proceedings. It would, indeed, be the satisfaction of the Income Tax Officer in the course of the assessment proceedings regarding the concealment of income which would constitute the basis and foundation of the proceedings for levy of penalty.’” 6.9 The reliance of the Panel Counsel on CBDT Circular No. 9/DV/2016 dated 26.04.2016 has been issued in terms of Grihalakshmi (supra). Para 4 of the Circular states: The above judgment reflects the “Departmental View”. However, para 5, in a way, suggests following the decision of a High Court within whose
19 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
territorial jurisdictional limits the penalty proceedings are taken up. The same reads as under: “Where any High Court decides this issue contrary to the ‘Departmental View’, the ‘Departmental View’ thereon shall not be operative in the area falling in the jurisdiction of the relevant High Court. However, the CCIT concerned should immediately bring the judgment to the notice of the Central Technical Committee. The CTC shall examine the said judgment on priority to decide as to whether filing of SLP to the Supreme Court will be an adequate response for the time being or some legislative amendment is called for.” Therefore, much reliance cannot be placed on this Circular. In the above circumstances, the questions of law framed by us have to be answered in favour of the respondent assessee and, as a consequence, the appeal is liable to be and accordingly dismissed, costs having been made easy”. 19. The assessee had also relied upon the decision of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of Pr. CIT v. Rishikesh Buildcon (P.) Ltd. (supra). The Hon’ble Delhi High Court, in light of penalty levied under Section 271D of the Act and the limitation provided under Section 275(1)(c) of the Act, held as under: “12. The predecessor Bench of this Court in the aforesaid judgments has held that where the A.O. has initiated the penalty proceedings in his/her assessment order, the said date is to be taken as the relevant date as far as the section of the Act is concerned. In these cases, the quantum proceedings were completed by the A.O. on 17th/18th December 2008, and the A.O. initiated the penalty proceedings in December, 2008, thus, the last date by which the penalty order could have been passed is 30th June, 2009. The six months from the end of the month from which action of imposition of penalty initiated would expire on 30th June, 2009. However, in this case, admittedly, the penalty order(s) were passed on 29th September, 2009, and therefore, the ITAT rightly concluded that the order(s) were barred by limitation. 13. Consequently, we answer the question of law against the Revenue and in favour of the assessee by holding that, in the facts and circumstances of the present appeals, the ITAT was correct in law in deleting the penalty imposed by the Additional Commissioner of Income Tax under Section 271D of the Act, on the ground that the penalty order(s) dated 29th September, 2009, were passed beyond the time period prescribed by Section [unclear in source] of the Act, the same having been passed after the lapse of six months from the end of the month in which the penalty proceedings were initiated by the A.O.” 20. A similar issue has been considered by the Coordinate Bench of the ITAT, Hyderabad, in the case of M/s. Sireesha Pochareddy in ITA No. 1270/Hyd/2024, dated 12.09.2025. The ITAT, Hyderabad Bench had considered an identical issue of limitation for passing the penalty order under Section 271D of the Act and, after considering the provisions of Section [unclear in source] of the Act and by following the decision of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of PCIT v. Mahesh Wood Products Pvt. Ltd. (supra), had held as under:
20 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
“6. We have heard both the parties, perused the material on record and gone through the orders of the authorities below. As per the provisions of [unclear in source] of the Act, no order imposing penalty under this Chapter-XXI shall be passed in any other case after the expiry of the financial year in which the proceedings, in the course of which action for the imposition of penalty has been initiated or completed, or six months from the end of the month in which action for imposition of penalty is initiated, whichever period expires later. In the present case, although the date on which the Assessing Officer has referred to the Range Head is not clear, but undoubtedly, if we go by the first show-cause notice issued by the Assessing Officer, proposing penalty under Section 271D of the Act, i.e., on 30.03.2021, the order imposing penalty under Section 271D of the Act ought to have been passed on or before 30.09.2021, whereas, in the present case, the Assessing Officer passed the order imposing penalty under Section 271D of the Act on 25.01.2022. Therefore, in our considered view, the order passed by the Assessing Officer is beyond the time limit provided under the provisions of Section 275(1)(c) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 and thus, it is invalid, void ab initio, barred by limitation and liable to be quashed. This legal principle is supported by the judgment of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of PCIT v. Mahesh Wood Products Pvt. Ltd. (supra) and decision of ITAT, Chennai in the case of DCIT v. Shri Subramaniam Thanu (supra), wherein it has been clearly held that in terms of Section [unclear in source] of the Act, it would be the date on which the Assessing Officer wrote a letter to the PCIT recommending issuance of show-cause notice and, if the competent authority decides to issue a show-cause notice, the limitation would begin from the date of the letter of the Assessing Officer recommending initiation of the penalty proceedings. In the instant case, if we go by the said initiation date, i.e., 30.03.2021, any order passed beyond the six months from the end of the relevant month in which the show-cause notice was issued under Section 271D of the Act, i.e., dated 25.01.2022 in the instant case, is barred by limitation.” 7. Coming back to the arguments of the learned Sr. AR, Dr. Sachin Kumar, present for the Revenue, in light of CBDT Notification No. 113/2021, dated 17.09.2021, the CBDT, in exercise of the powers conferred under sub-section (1) of Section 3 of the Taxation and Other Laws (Amendment) Act, 2021 (in short, “TOLA”), has extended the time limit up to 31.03.2022 for the completion of any action referred to in clause (a) of sub-section (1) of Section 3 of the said Act, which relates to passing of any order for imposing penalty under Chapter XXI of the Income Tax Act, 1961. Therefore, the order passed by the Assessing Officer dated 25.01.2022 is well within the extended period of limitation by virtue of the CBDT Notification dated 17.09.2021 (supra), and the learned CIT(A), without appreciating the facts of the case, simply quashed the assessment order passed by the Assessing Officer. We find that the Hon’ble Supreme Court has examined the issue of notification issued by the CBDT in exercise of the powers conferred under Section 3(1) of TOLA in the case of Union of India v. Rajeev Bansal [2024] 167 taxmann.com 70 (SC), and clearly held that in case the completion of any action relates to passing of any order falls between 20.03.2020 and 31.03.2021, then the said “due dates” are extended by virtue of Section 3(1) of TOLA up to 30.06.2021.
21 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
In the present case, going by the show-cause notice issued by the Assessing Officer proposing penalty under Section 271D of the Act, which was dated 30.03.2021, therefore, in our considered view, the completion of action relating to passing of any order for imposing penalty under Chapter XXI of the Act falls on or before 30.09.2021. In our considered view, the said “due date” is beyond the period specified under the provisions of TOLA, i.e., between 20.03.2020 and 31.03.2021, and therefore, the Notification issued by the CBDT dated 17.09.2021 does not extend the due date for passing the order imposing penalty under Section 271D of the Act in the present case up to 30.09.2021. Therefore, we are of the considered view that the arguments advanced by the learned Sr. AR for the Revenue in light of CBDT Notification dated 17.09.2021 (supra) do not hold good and are therefore rejected. 8. In this view of the matter, considering the facts of the case and also by following the judgment of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of PCIT v. Mahesh Wood Products Pvt. Ltd. (supra) and the decision of ITAT, Chennai, in the case of DCIT v. Shri Subramaniam Thanu (supra), we are of the considered view that there is no error in the reasons given by the learned CIT(A) to quash the penalty order passed by the Assessing Officer under Section 271D of the Act, dated 25.01.2022. We accordingly uphold the order of the learned CIT(A) and dismiss the appeal filed by the Revenue. Consequently, the cross-objections raised by the assessee are allowed. 21. In this view of the matter and considering the facts and circumstances of the case and also by following the ratios of the case laws discussed herein above, we are of the considered view that the order passed by the Ld. A.O. under Section 271DA of the Act dated 27.09.2024 is clearly barred by limitation in terms of Section [unclear in source] of the Act. Therefore, we quash the order passed by the Ld. A.O. under Section 271DA of the Act dated 27.09.2024 for A.Y. 2018-19. 22. A similar issue is involved in the appeal filed by the assessee for A.Y. 2019- 20 in ITA No. 2165/Hyd/2025, where the assessee has challenged the order passed by the Ld. A.O. under Section 271DA of the Act, dated 27.09.2024, in light of the provisions of Section [unclear in source] of the Act. The reasons given by us in preceding paragraph Nos. 15 to 21 shall mutatis mutandis apply to this appeal as well. Therefore, for the detailed reasons given in the preceding paragraphs, we are of the considered view that the order passed by the Ld. A.O. under Section 271DA dated 27.09.2024 for A.Y. 2019-20 is barred by limitation and thus, we quash the order passed by the Ld. A.O. under Section 271DA of the Act for A.Y. 2019-20.”
6.2.3 The core issue relating to levy of penalty under Section 271DA has already been decided in favour of the appellant on merits. However, relying on the decision of the Hon’ble ITAT, it is noted that the Tribunal did not accept the contention that the penalty proceedings were invalid merely because detailed satisfaction was not recorded in the assessment order regarding violation of Section 269ST. The Hon’ble ITAT observed that the Assessing Officer had identified the alleged transactions during assessment and had made a reference to the competent authority for initiating penalty proceedings, which indicates formation of prima facie
22 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
satisfaction. Therefore, the requirement of recording satisfaction stood complied with. Accordingly, the grounds are treated as PARTLY ALLOWED and the remaining technical issues are not examined as they are academic in nature.”
Aggrieved by the order of Ld. CIT(A), the Revenue is now in appeal before the Tribunal.
The Ld. CIT-DR for the Revenue, Ms. U. Mini Chandran, submitted that, the Ld. CIT(A) had erred in deleting the penalty levied under Section 271DA of the Act, because there was a clear violation of Section 269ST by the assessee company, which was evident from the satisfaction arrived at by the A.O., wherein he had clearly stated that, the assessee company had received Rs.2,00,000/- or more in respect of a single transaction, in violation of Section 269ST of the Act, towards unaccounted receipts from the sale of spent solvents. Further, the evidence found during the course of search in the form of an Excel workbook stored in a Pen Drive clearly showed unaccounted cash receipts from the sale of spent solvents, and the same had been accepted by the assessee company, which had also admitted additional income during the course of search. The Ld. CIT-DR further submitted that, the Ld. CIT(A) failed to appreciate that, the assessee had accepted the credibility and accuracy of the very same seized digital data by voluntarily offering additional unaccounted income of Rs.4,51,88,803/- towards the sale of spent solvents and scrap in its return of income filed under Section 153A of the Act. Therefore, the argument of the learned counsel for the assessee that there was no evidence of violation of
23 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
Section 269ST of the Act, was contrary to the material available on record and could not be accepted. The Ld. CIT-DR further submitted that, in the absence of any verifiable day-wise sales invoices, cash receipts or buyer-wise books maintained by the assessee to establish that the daily entries represented distinct collective payments below Rs.2,00,000/-, the A.O. was justified in treating each date-wise entry as a single transaction under clause (b) of Section 269ST of the Act. She further submitted that the Ld. CIT(A) erred in shifting the entire burden of proof onto the Revenue to establish individual buyer-wise breakups, overlooking the statutory presumptions available to the Department under Sections 132(4A) and 292C of the Act, in respect of documents seized during the course of search. Since there was clear evidence of receipt of cash in excess of Rs.2,00,000/-, the A.O. had rightly levied penalty under Section 271DA of the Act, and, therefore, the order of the Ld. CIT(A) should be set aside and the penalty levied by the A.O. should be sustained. In this regard, she relied upon the decision of the ITAT, Chennai Bench, in the case of Sri Sai Balaji Gas Cylinder (P) Ltd. Vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax (2023) 155 Taxmann.com 319 (Chennai), and also the decision of the Hon’ble Madras High Court in the case of Tvi. Chandro Process Vs. DCIT (2025) 173 Taxmann.com 976 (Madras).
The Ld. CIT-DR for the Revenue further submitted that, the Ld. CIT(A) has also failed to appreciate the fact that the assessment in the present case was not determined on estimation basis and the A.O. has made the additions towards unaccounted
24 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
receipts from sale of spent solvents and scrap on total receipts and it is only the Tribunal has estimated the expenditure to the extent of 60% of unaccounted receipts and balance of 40% of receipts has been treated as income. Therefore, the observation of the Ld. CIT(A) that the assessment has been completed on estimation basis and the income ahs been estimated is incorrect, and thus, the Ld. CIT(A) was erred in allowing relief to the assessee by following the decision of Tribunal in the case of MSN Laboratories Pvt. Ltd. Vs. ACIT (supra).
The learned counsel for the assessee, Shri M.V. Prasad, C.A., submitted that, this issue is squarely covered by the decision of the ITAT, Hyderabad Bench, in the appellant’s own group case, in the case of M/s. MSN Laboratories Private Limited Vs. ACIT in ITA Nos. 2164, 2165, 2171 and 2172/Hyd/2025, order dated 25.02.2026, where the Tribunal, on an identical set of facts, in light of the search conducted in the MSN Group of cases on 24.02.2021 and the relevant seized materials considered by the JCIT/Addl. CIT for the purpose of levy of penalty under Section 271DA, and after considering the relevant order passed by the JCIT/Addl. CIT under Section 271DA dated 27.09.2024, held that, the order passed by the JCIT/Addl. CIT under Section 271DA was barred by limitation. The Ld. CIT(A), in the present appeals, has allowed relief to the assessee and deleted the penalty levied by the JCIT/Addl. CIT u/s 271DA in both the assessment years by following the decision of ITAT, Hyderabad Bench, in the case of MSN Laboratories Private Limited Vs. ACIT (supra), and held that, the penalty order passed by the JCIT/Addl. CIT is barred by
25 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
limitation. The learned counsel for the assessee further submitted that, the Revenue has raised identical grounds of appeal, which were already considered by the Tribunal in the above case for the earlier assessment years. Since the basis for the levy of penalty is the search action conducted under Section 132 of the Act, in the case of the MSN Group of cases and the levy of penalty under Section 271DA of the Act, for acceptance of cash for sale of spent solvent and scrap in contravention of Section 269ST of the Act, is also from the very same seized material, the Ld. CIT(A) has rightly deleted the addition made by the A.O. towards levy of penalty under Section 271DA of the Act. Therefore, he submitted that, the appeal filed by the Revenue needs to be dismissed, both on the ground of limitation as well as on merits.
The learned counsel for the assessee further, referring to the order of the Ld. CIT(A) and the order of the Tribunal in the case of MSN Laboratories Pvt. Ltd. Vs. ACIT (supra), submitted that, although the Ld. CIT(A) has not finally decided the issue of limitation in passing the penalty order and held that, the order passed by the A.O. under Section 271DA of the Act, is barred by limitation as per the provisions of Section 275(1)(c) of the Act. Further, although the assessee has not filed a separate appeal against the issue of limitation, either by filing an appeal or by cross-objection, but supported the order of the Ld. CIT(A) under Rule 29 of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal Rules, 1963 and since the assessee got relief on merits, the assessee has supported the order on the issue of limitation in passing the penalty order
26 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
and, therefore, submitted that, since the issue is fully covered in favour of the assessee by the decision of the ITAT, Hyderabad, in the case of M/s. MSN Laboratories Vs. ACIT (supra), the order passed by the Ld. CIT(A) should be upheld, as well as the order passed by the A.O. under Section 271DA of the Act, held as barred by limitation under Section 275(1)(c) of the Act.
Per contra, the Ld. CIT-DR relied upon the decision of the Hon’ble Karnataka High Court in the case of JCIT and another Vs. Ganesh Agarwal, reported in (2026) 490 ITR 701, and argued that, as per the provisions of Section 275(1)(c) of the Act, the limitation for passing the penalty order runs from the date when the JCIT or the ITO issues a show-cause notice under Section 274 r.w.s. 271DA. If we consider the date of the show-cause notice, the order passed by the JCIT is well within the limitation period provided under Section 275(1)(c) of the Act, and, therefore, the arguments of the learned counsel for the assessee, in light of Rule 29 of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal Rules, 1963, on the decision of the ITAT, Hyderabad, in the case of MSN Laboratories Vs. ACIT (supra), are devoid of merit and need to be rejected.
We have heard both the parties, perused the material available on record and had gone through the orders of the authorities below. The A.O. levied penalty under Section 271DA of the Act, for contravention of the provisions of Section 269ST of the Act, in light of the incriminating material found during the search under Section 132 of the Act, which showed unaccounted cash receipts from the sale of spent solvents and scrap, and observed
27 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
that, the assessee had violated the provisions of Section 269ST of the Act, which attracted the provisions of Section 271DA of the Act, and therefore, levied penalty equal to the amount of cash receipts in excess of Rs.2,00,000/-. We find that, the issue involved in the present appeal is no longer res integra, and the Coordinate Bench of the ITAT, in the case of MSN Laboratories Private Limited Vs. ACIT (supra) had considered the issue of penalty levied by the JCIT/Addl. CIT under Section 271DA of the Act, for contravention of Section 269ST of the Act, in light of the search action conducted under Section 132 of the Act, in the MSN Group of cases on the very same seized material considered by the JCIT/Addl. CIT for the purpose of levy of penalty and after considering the relevant facts, deleted the penalty levied by the A.O., both on limitation under Section 275(1)(c) of the Act, as well as on merits. The relevant findings of the Tribunal are reproduced hereunder:
“15. We have heard both the parties, perused the material available on record and had gone through the orders of the authorities below. We have also carefully considered the relevant legal ground taken up by the assessee challenging the validity of the order passed by the A.O under section 271DA of the Act in light of provisions of section 275(1)(c) of the Act. We have also carefully considered the relevant circulars issued by the CBDT and also the case laws referred to by the learned Counsel for the assessee and the Ld. Sr. AR present for the Revenue. The assessee had taken a legal ground challenging the validity of penalty order passed by the A.O on limitation for the A.Ys 2018-19 and 2019-20. The assessee claims that the penalty order is invalid in law as the same is time barred. Admittedly, in the present case, the penalty proceedings were triggered from the A.O with a reference to the Jt. CIT for taking necessary action for imposition of penalty under section 271DA of the Act. The A.O had sent information regarding the violation of provisions of section 269ST of the Act for the A.Ys 2018-19 and 2019-20 on 25/05/2023. Based on the reference received from the A.O, the Addl. CIT, Central Range-2 issued a
28 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
show cause notice under section 274 r.w.s. 271DA of the Act, on 7/3/2024 and passed the order under section 271DA of the Act on 27/09/2024. Therefore, it is necessary for us to examine, whether the penalty order passed by the A.O under section 271DA of the Act dated 27/09/2024 is within the limitation provided under section 275(1)(c) of the Act or is barred by limitation. 16. The provisions of section 275(1)(c) of the Act, deals with time limit for passing the penalty orders. As per the provisions of section 275(1)(c) of the Act, no penalty order shall be passed after the expiry of (a) financial year in which the proceedings, in the course of which action for imposition of the penalty has been initiated are completed or (b) Six months from the end of the month in which the action for imposition of penalty is initiated, whichever is later. In the present case, the assessment under section 153A of the Act was concluded on 31/03/2023 and the action for imposition of penalty under section 271DA of the Act has not been initiated in the course of assessment proceedings. Therefore, clause (a) of section 275(1)(c) of the Act is not applicable. Further, clause (b) of section 275(1)(c) of the Act provides Six months from the end of the month in which the action for initiation of penalty is initiated and in the present case the A.O has sent a proposal or reference to the Jt.CIT for taking necessary action on 25/05/2023. As held by the Hon'ble Karnataka High Court, in the case of Pr. CIT vs. K. Umesh Shetty (Supra), the date of a reference made by the AO to the Add. CIT for imposition of penalty under section 271DA of the Act, was to be treated as triggering point for initiation of penalty proceedings under section 271DA of the Act. A similar view has been taken by the Hon'ble Delhi High Court in the case of Pr. CIT vs. Rishikesh Buildcon (P) Ltd (Supra) where it has been held that pursuant to the completion of the quantum proceedings by the A.O, further penalty proceedings against the assessee under section 271DA for violating the provisions of section 269ST of the Act was also initiated in Dec. 2008, 6 months from the end of the month in which the penalty proceeding was initiated should be considered. The sum and substance of ratios laid down by various High Courts for determining the limitation for passing the penalty orders as referred to under section 275(1)(c) of the Act, is the date on which the A.O sent proposal to the Addl. CIT/ Jt. CIT should be considered but not from the date on which the Jt. CIT issued show cause notice us 274 r.w.s. 271DA of the Act. In the present case, the A.O sent reference to the Jt. CIT on 25/05/2023 for taking action for imposition of penalty under section 271DA of the Act. Therefore, in our considered view, the starting point for initiation of the action for imposition of penalty within the meaning of section 275(1)(c) of the Act is from 25/05/2025 and for the purpose of determining the limitation period for passing the penalty order, Six months from the end of May 2023 should be considered, but not from 7/3/2024, i.e. date on which the authority issued show
29 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
cause notice under section 274 r.w.s. 271DA of the Act. Since the A.O sent reference to Jt. CIT on 25/05/2023, in our considered view, Six months period should be considered from the end of May 2023 i.e. 31/05/2023 and if, we consider the starting point from 1/06/2023, then the A.O ought to have passed the order under section 271DA of the Act on 30/11/2023. In the present case, since the A.O has passed the order under section 271DA of the Act on 27/09/2024, in our considered view, it is barred by limitation and the same is non-est in the eyes of law. 17. Coming back to the argument of the Ld. Sr. AR for the Revenue in light of CBDT Circular No.9 of 2016 dated 26/04/2016 and also the decision of the Hon'ble Kerala High Court in the case of Grihalakshmi Vision vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax (Supra) that for commencement of limitation for penalty proceedings under section 271DA of the Act, it is the date on which the JCIT issued a show cause notice under section 274 r.w.s. 271DA of the Act is to be considered, but not on the date on which the A.O sent a proposal to the JCIT for taking action for imposition of penalty under section 271DA of the Act. In our considered view, although the Hon'ble Kerala High Court in the above case has held that the competent authority to levy penalty being a Jt. Commissioner and for the purpose of limitation, the date on which the Jt. CIT issued show cause notice should be considered. However, the fact remains that the above decision of the Hon'ble Kerala High Court and the circular issued by the CBDT had been considered by the Hon'ble Karnataka High Court in the case of Pr. CIT vs. K. Umesh Shetty (Supra) and held that it in disagreement with the view taken by the Hon'ble Kerala High Court on the ground that a perusal of the said judgement does not show that there was any reference from the AO to “competent authority” unlike the case in hand. Since the decision of Hon’ble Karnataka High Court is on later date and also it had taken into account the decision of Hon’ble Kerala High Court and distinguished the above judgment, in our considered view, the arguments of ld. Sr. AR in light of Hon'ble Kerala High Court and the CBDT Circular No.9 of 2016 does not hold good and cannot be accepted. Further, other case laws relied upon by the ld. Ar. AR for the revenue is also not considered, because facts of the above cases are entirely different from the facts of the assessee case. 18. The learned Counsel for the assessee had relied upon the decision of the Hon'ble Karnataka High Court in the case of Pr. CIT vs. K. Umesh Shetty (Supra). The Hon'ble Karnataka High Court had considered an identical issue of levy of penalty under section 271D of the Act, in light of limitation provided under section 275 (1)(c) of the Act and after considering the relevant facts has held as under:
30 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
“6.7 In the facts of this case, these twin purposes can be achieved by treating the reference by the ITO to the Additional Commissioner as the triggering point or initiation of penalty proceedings. The ITO vide letter dated 16.11.2016 had admittedly made the reference. The Additional Commissioner of Income Tax issued the Show Cause Notice only on 10.11.2017 (nearly a year later) proposing the levy of penalty u/s 271D of the Act. The Penalty Order was made on 22.02.2018. If the reckoning point is 16.11.2016, it is clear that the proceedings were completed beyond the period of limitation, as rightly contended by the learned counsel appearing for the Assessee. Even otherwise , the concept of delay & latches would crop in; no explanation whatsoever has been offered by the Revenue for the laxity shown in belatedly issuing the show cause notice/proposition notice which they claim, amounted to initiation of penalty proceedings. This view has animated the reasoning of the impugned order of the Tribunal, may be a bit inarticulately . 6.8. The reliance of Panel Counsel for the Revenue on the Coordinate Bench decision in COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX vs. TAM TAM PEDDA GURUVA REDDY does not come to his aid since the same has been rendered largely fact-specific. The other decision namely GRIHALAKSHMI VISION vs. ADDITIONAL COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-7 at para 10 observed as under: “Question to be considered is whether proceedings for levy of penalty, are initiated with the passing of the order of assessment by the Assessing Officer or whether such proceedings have commenced with the issuance of the notice issued by the Joint Commissioner. From statutory provision, it is clear that the competent authority to levy penalty being the Joint Commissioner. Therefore, only the Joint Commissioner can initiate proceedings for levy of penalty…” These observations arguably support the view of Revenue, is true. However, we respectfully disagree with the said view. That apart, a perusal of the said judgment does not show that there was any reference made by the ITO to the competent authority, unlike in the case at hand. Further the following observations in para 10 in D M Manasvi vs Commissioner of Income Tax (1973) 3 SCC 207 would cast some doubt on the correctness of Grihalakshmi supra.
“We are also not impressed by the argument advanced on behalf of the appellant that the proceedings for the imposition of penalty were initiated not by the Income Tax Officer but by the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner when
31 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
the matter had been referred to him under section 274(2) of the Act. The proceedings for the imposition of penalty in terms of sub- section (1) of section 271 have necessarily to be initiated either by the Income Tax Officer or by the Appellate Assistant Commissioner. The fact that the Income Tax Officer has to refer the case to the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner if the minimum imposable penalty exceeds the sum of rupees one thousand in a case falling under clause (c) of sub-section (1) of section 271 would not show that the proceedings in such a case cannot be initiated by the Income Tax Officer. The Income Tax Officer in such an event can refer the case to the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner after initiating the proceedings. It would, indeed, be the satisfaction of the Income Tax Officer in the course of the assessment proceedings regarding the concealment of income which would constitute he basis and foundation of the proceedings for levy of penalty”. 6.9 The reliance of the Panel Counsel on CBDT Circular No.9/DV/2016 dated 26.04.2016 has been issued in terms of GRIHALAKSHMI supra. Para 4 of the Circular states: The above judgment reflects the “Departmental View”. However, para 5 in a way suggests to follow the decision of a High Court, within whose territorial jurisdictional limits the penalty proceedings are taken up. The same reads as under: “Where any High Court decides this issue contrary to the “Departmental View”, the “Departmental View” thereon shall not be operative in the area falling in the jurisdiction of the relevant High Court. However, the CCIT concerned should immediately bring the judgment to the notice of the Central Technical Committee. The CTC shall examine the said judgment on priority to decide as to whether filing of SLP to the Supreme Court will be adequate response for the time being or some legislative amendment is called for.” Therefore, much reliance cannot be placed on this Circular.
In the above circumstances, the questions of law framed by us have to be answered in favour of the respondent assessee and as a consequence, appeal is liable to be and accordingly dismissed, costs having been made easy”.
32 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
The assessee had also relied upon the decision of the Hon'ble Delhi High Court in the case of Pr. CIT vs. Rishikesh Buildcon (P) Ltd (Supra). The Hon’ble Delhi High Court, in light of penalty levied u/s 271D of the Act and the limitation provided u/s 275(1)(c) of the Act, held as under: “12. The predecessor bench of this Court in the aforesaid judgments has held that where the AO has initiated the penalty proceedings in his/her assessment order, the said date is to be taken as the relevant date as far as the section 275(1)(c) of the Act is concerned. In these cases, the quantum proceedings were completed by the AO on 17th/18th December 2008, and the AO initiated the penalty proceedings in December, 2008, thus, the last date by which the penalty order could have been passed is 30th June, 2009. The six months from the end of the month from which action of imposition of penalty was initiated would expire on 30th June, 2009. However, in this case, admittedly, the penalty order(s) were passed on 29th September, 2009, and therefore, the ITAT rightly concluded that the order(s) were barred by limitation. 13. Consequently, we answer the question of law against the Revenue and in favour of the Assessee by holding that, in the facts and circumstances of the present appeals, the ITAT was correct in law in deleting the penalty imposed by the Additional Commissioner of Income Tax, under section 271D of the Act, on the ground that the penalty order(s) dated 29th September, 2009, was passed beyond the time period prescribed by Section 275(1)(c) of the Act, the same having been passed after the lapse of six months from the end of the month in which the penalty proceedings were initiated by the AO.” 20. A similar issue has been considered by the Coordinate Bench of ITAT, Hyderabad, in case of M/s. Sireesha Pochareddy in ITA No.1270/Hyd/2024, dated 12/093/2025. The ITAT, Hyderabad bench had considered an identical issue of limitation for passing penalty order u/s 271D of the Act, and after considering provisions of section 275(1)(c) of the Act, and by following the decision of Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of PCIT vs. Mahesh Wood products Pvt Ltd(Supra) had held as under: “6. We have heard both the parties, perused the material on record and gone through the orders of the authorities below. As per the provisions of sec.275(1)(c) of the Act, no order imposing penalty under this Chapter-XXI shall be passed in any other case after the expiry of the financial year in which the proceedings, in the course of which action for the imposition of penalty has been initiated or completed or six months from the end of the month in which action for imposition of penalty is initiated whichever period expires later. In the present case, although, the date on which, the Assessing Officer has referred to range head is not clear,
33 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
but, undoubtedly, if we go by the first show cause notice issued by the Assessing Officer, proposing penalty u/sec.271D of the Act, i.e., on 30.03.2021, the order imposing penalty u/sec.271D of the Act ought to have been passed on or before 30.09.2021, whereas, in the present case, the Assessing Officer passed the order imposing penalty u/sec.271D of the Act on 25.01.2022. Therefore, in our considered view, the order passed by the Assessing Officer is beyond the time limit provided under the provisions of sec.275(1)(c) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 and thus, it is invalid, void abinitio, barred by limitation and liable to be quashed. This legal principle is supported by the Judgment of Hon'ble Delhi High Court in the case of PCIT vs., Mahesh Wood Products Pvt. Ltd., (supra) and decision of ITAT, Chennai in the case of DCIT vs. Shri Subramaniam Thanu (supra), wherein it has been clearly held that in terms of sec.275(1)(c) of the Act, it would be the date on which the Assessing Officer wrote a letter to the PCIT recommending to issue show cause notice and if the Competent Authority decide to issue a show cause notice, the limitation would begin to run from the date of letter of the Assessing Officer recommending 'initiation' of the penalty proceedings. In the instant case, if we go by the said 'initiation' date i.e., 30.03.2021, any order passed beyond the six months from the end of the relevant month in which show cause notice issued u/sec.271D of the Act i.e., dated 25.01.2022 in the instant case, is barred by limitation. 7. Coming back to the arguments of the learned Sr. AR Dr. Sachin Kumar, present for the Revenue, in light of CBDT's Notification No.113/2021, dated 17.09.2021. The CBDT in exercise of the powers conferred by sub-sec.1 of sec.3 of Taxation and Other Laws Amendment Act, 2021 [in short "TOLA"], has extended the time limit up-to 31.03.2022 for the completion of any action referred to in clause(a) of sub- sec.(1) of sec.3 of the said Act relates to passing of any order for imposing of penalty under Chapter-XXI of the Income Tax Act, 1961 and, therefore, the order passed by the Assessing Officer dated 25.01.2022 is well within the extended period of limitation by virtue of the CBDT's Notification dated 17.09.2021 (supra) and that, the learned CIT(A) without appreciating the facts of the case, simply quashed the assessment order passed by the Assessing Officer. We find that the Hon'ble Supreme Court has examined the issue of Notification issued by the CBDT in exercise of the powers conferred u/sec.3(1) of TOLA in the case of Union of India vs. Rajeev Bansal [2024] 167 taxmann.com 70 (SC) and clearly held that in case the completion of any action relates to passing of any order falls between 20.03.2020 and 31.03.2021, then, the said "due dates" are extended by virtue of sec.3(1) of TOLA "up-to 30.06.2021". In the present case, going by the show cause
34 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
notice issued by the Assessing Officer, imposing penalty u/sec.271D of the Act, was dated 30.03.2021. Therefore, in our considered view, the completion of action relates to passing of any order for imposing of penalty under Chapter- XXI of the Act falls on or before 30.09.2021 and in our considered view, the said "due date" is beyond the period specified under the provisions of TOLA i.e., between 20.03.2020 and 31.03.2021 and, therefore, the Notification issued by the CBDT dated 17.09.2021 does not extend the due date for passing the order imposing penalty u/sec.271D of the Act in the present case up-to 30.09.2021. Therefore, we are of the considered view that the arguments advanced by the learned Sr. AR for the Revenue in light of CBDT's Notification dated 17.09.2021 (supra), does not hold good and, therefore, rejected. 8. In this view of the matter, considering the facts of the case and also by following the Judgment of Hon'ble Delhi High Court in the case of PCIT vs., Mahesh Wood Products Pvt. Ltd., (supra) and decision of ITAT, Chennai in the case of DCIT vs. Shri Subramaniam Thanu (supra), we are of the considered view that there is no error in the reasons given by the learned CIT(A) to quash the penalty order passed by the Assessing Officer u/sec.271D of the Act, dated 25.01.2022. We, accordingly, uphold the order of the learned CIT(A) and dismiss the appeal filed by the Revenue. Consequently, the cross objections raised by the assessee are allowed.” 21. In this view of the matter and considering the facts and circumstances of the case and also by following the ratios of case laws discussed herein above, we are of the considered view that the order passed by the Ld. AO u/s 271DA of the Act dated 27/09/2024 is clearly barred by limitation in terms of sec 275(1)(c) of the Act. Therefore, we quash the order passed by the Ld. AO, u/s 271DA of the Act dated 27/09/2024 for AY. 2018-19. 22. A similar issue is involved in the appeal filed by the assessee the A.Y 2009-10 in ITA No. 2165/Hyd/2025, where the assessee has challenged the order passed by the Ld. AO u/s 271DA of the Act, dated 27/09/2024 in light of provisions of sec 275(1)(c) of the Act. The reason given by us in preceding paragraph Nos. 15 to 21 shall mutatis mutandis applies to this appeal, as well. Therefore, for the detailed reasons given in preceding paras, we are of the considered view that the order passed by the Ld. AO u/s 271DA dated 27/09/2024 for A.Y 2019-20 is barred by limitation and thus, we quash the order passed by the Ld. AO u/s 271DA of the Act for AY 2019-20. 23. Coming back to Ground Nos. 6, 7 & 8 of assessee’s appeal and by above grounds, the assessee challenged penalty levied by
35 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
the A.O under section 271DA of the Act on merits for A.Ys 2018-19 to 2021-22. The A.O levied the penalty under section 271D of the Act for violation of section 269ST of the Act on the ground that the assessee has received cash in excess of Rs.2 lakhs or more in respect of a single transaction for sale of unaccounted scrap and spent solvents. The A.O levied penalty on the basis of excel work book found from the Pen Drive in the possession of Shri B Buchi Reddy, Cashier during the course of search where he had maintained the details of date-wise sales of spent solvents and scraps along with the details of opening cash in hand, amount received from the buyers/receivable and closing cash in hand. The above worksheet also contained the details of party-wise details of sales by each companies of MSN Group by different units/plants along with amounts paid to the M.D of the MSN Group and other family members including employees for various expenses. The A.O considered segment (1) of excel workbook which appears at extreme right of the excel sheets pertaining to sale of spent solvent and it contained the details of date of sale amount and the name of the company/plant of the company which made the sales and considered only the amounts which exceeds Rs.2 lakhs or more in a particular date for the purpose of levying penalty under section 271DA of the Act for all the A.Ys. 24. We have gone through the relevant excel sheets found from the Pen Drive of Shri B. Buchi Reddy, Cashier of assessee’s group which is available in the paper book filed by the assessee. We, find that the relevant excel sheets was maintained for common for all five companies of MSN Group, including the assessee in respect of unaccounted sales of spent solvent and scraps. As explained therein, the entries in the excel sheets are found to be made in five distinct data segments. The entries in all the five segments are usually bunched together for a period of one week. Segment-1, which appears at the extreme left of the excel sheet, pertains to sales of spent solvents and it contains the details of date of sale, amount and the name of the company/plant of the company which made the sales. This segment is found separately for each period and the total of such sales for the concerned period of one week is drawn at the bottom of the segment-1 for each period. Segment 2, which appears to the immediate right of segment (1) for each period, contains the details of the opening balance of net receivables/payables at the beginning of the period, sales made for the relevant period, aggregate cash received from the buyers during the period and closing balance of net receivables/payables at the end of the period. Segment (3) which appears to the immediate right of segment (2) for each period contains the buyer- wise break-up of the closing balance of net receivables/payables. Segment (4) which appears to the immediate right of segment (3) for each period pertains to the sale of scraps made in cash and it contains the name of the company/plant or division of the
36 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
company which made the sales. The total of such cash sales of scraps for the concerned period of one week is drawn at the bottom of the segment (4) for each period. Segment (5) which appears below segment (2) for each period contains the details of opening balance of cash, aggregate of the cash received for the relevant period out of the sales of spent solvent and scraps, cash handed over to Shri M.S.N. Reddy, his family members during the period, cash handed over to the employees named therein and closing balance at the end of the period. As mentioned earlier, the details of sales of spent solvent are recorded in the segment (1) of excel sheet and it contains the date-wise details of spent solvent made by each plant/division of 5 companies of the group recorded therein represents the aggregate sales made on a said date to a buyer/multiple buyers as the case may be. The above excel sheet does not show any details of each sale made to each buyer on the said date by the plant/division of the said company. Further, on perusal of the excel sheet, we find that the sale proceeds in cash in respect of sales of spent solvent recorded in segment (1) are not received immediately. This feature is evident from the fact that the amount of aggregate cash received from sale of spent solvents during a particular period, as recorded in the corresponding segment-2 and segment-5, does not match with the total amount of sales of spent solvents as recorded in the bottom segment-1 for the said period. It may also be seen that in some cases, the cash received is in advance from the buyers and the cash receivables against the sales made on such buyer is adjusted against the said advance. It will be noticed that the details of receipt of cash from the buyers either towards the advance or towards sale proceeds and the amount of cash received on each date are not recorded either in segment (2) or segment (5) or anywhere else in the seized material. Though the sales of spent solvents were made by various plants of each of the 5 companies of the group at different locations to multiple buyers at each of such location, the cash receipts from such sales from all the buyers put together were recorded by the cashier as a single entry for the entire period of one week in segment (2) and segment (5) of excel sheet. The details of buyers from whom such cash was received during the relevant period of one week, the date of such receipts and the amount of such receipts from each buyers and the names of the companies/plant in respect of whose unaccounted sales of spent solvents, and such cash was received have not been recorded by the cashier in the excel sheet. As a result of the said manner of recording the unaccounted sale of spent solvents and cash receipts by the cashier in the excel sheet, it is abundantly clear that the date-wise information recorded in segment (1) only reveals the aggregate amount of cash sales of spent solvents on each particular date by different companies/divisions/plants of the group but not the amount of sales achieved by the assessee company alone on a
37 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
particular date as claimed by the A.O. In the absence of recording such details in the excel sheets, the quantum of cash sales in respect of each single transaction of unaccounted sale of spent solvent is not ascertainable in order to arrive any conclusion as to whether the amount received in respect of a single transaction is Rs.2 lakhs or more. We further note that except the entry appearing in a particular date in excess of Rs. 2 lakhs or more has been considered by the A.O, there is no tangible and cogent material on record to infer the violation of the provisions of clause (b) of section 269ST of the Act in the case of the assessee. The material available in the excel sheet does not contain any data that reveals unambiguously that the assessee was in receipt of cash of Rs.2 lakhs or more in respect of a single transaction. Therefore, in our considered view, there is no material on record for the A.O to allege that the assessee has committed violation of the provisions of section 269ST of the Act for the purpose of levy of penalty under section 271DA of the Act. 25. We further note that, it is a settled law that the burden of establishing the occurrence of default by the assessee under the relevant provision of the statute which makes the assessee liable for penalty under the Act with the aid of tangible and cogent evidence is on the revenue, since the allegation of such violation is made by the Revenue. In the present case, since the allegation of violation of section 269ST of the Act has been made by the A.O, the onus lies on the Revenue to establish the said alleged violation by the assessee However, as noted in earlier part of this order, from the material considered by the A.O for the purpose of levy of penalty under section 271DA of the Act, no such evidence is forthcoming from the seized material and no evidence to the said fact has been brought on record by the A.O. Although the Ld. Jt. CIT observed that it is for the assessee to discharge the burden by furnishing the relevant evidence and prove that the cash received towards the sale of spent solvents and scraps is less than the amount specified under section 269ST of the Act and the assessee has not discharged the burden, but in our considered view, once the A.O makes the allegation that the assessee had violated the provision of section 269ST of the Act, then it is for the A.O to prove the allegation with relevant evidences. Once the A.O discharge the evidences, then the assessee has to disprove the claim of the A.O by explaining the details to the A.O for the purpose of levying penalty under section 271DA of the Act. In the present case, admittedly, there is no evidence of any kind of sales bills or cash receipts for sale of unaccounted spent solvents and scraps. The only evidence which was found during the course of search was one excel sheet maintained purpose by the Cashier for the entire group and as explained by the assessee, the above document contains details of sales made for a particular period by the group as a whole in respect of all the five companies and from different
38 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
plants/units. Since the assessee group is consisting of five companies and further have multiple units/plants which generates spent solvents and scraps and also assessee discharges the spent solvents and scraps from different units/plants to different buyers, in our considered view, only on the basis of consolidated entries appearing in segment (1) of excel sheet, it cannot be alleged that the assessee violated clause (b) of section 269ST of the Act for imposing penalty under section 271DA of the Act. Therefore, in our considered view, the A.O has not conclusively prove for the violation of provisions of section 269ST of the Act so as to levy penalty under section 271DA of the Act, and thus, in our considered view penalty levied by the AO is not sustainable on merits on the facts of the case and in law. 26. We further note that, the admission of the assessee does not Ipso Facto lead to levy of penalty, even though the assessee has made a statement regarding receipt of amount from the sale of spent solvents and scrap. Further, mere confessional statement without there being any documentary evidence in proof of such breakup of transactions cannot be solely relied upon while considering the penalty proceedings. Such evidence by way of statement might be considered for making the assessment but however for consideration of the penalty proceedings being independent in nature, further additional evidences are required to brought on to the file as corroborative in nature. More over the assessment proceedings and penalty proceedings are different all together and the evidences that were relied upon during the assessment proceedings may not be considered as sole factor and sufficient evidences for levy of penalty. This legal principle is supported by the decision of the Hon'ble Jurisdictional High court of Andhra Pradesh in the case of Sait Bansilal & Rangisetti Veeranna Vs. Commissioner of Income Tax - [1972] 83 ITR 750 (AP), wherein the Hon'ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh held that "Tax and Penalty, like tax and penal interest, are distinct and different concepts under the Act. Penalty is in addition to the tax determined as payable by the assessee. Penalty cannot be taken as additional tax for all purposes. The penalty and assessment proceedings are not one and the same proceedings. The findings given in the assessment proceedings would only be relevant and admissible but not final and conclusive in penalty proceedings. In penalty proceedings, further evidence can be led to rebut the findings given in the assessment proceedings." According to the said case law, it can be understood that in order to levy of penalty, the Assessing Officer has to gather the evidence from the seized material. But in fact, the seized material is wholly non-speaking and dumb with regard to the transaction-wise and buyer-wise details of the sales of spent solvents embedded in the date-wise sales recorded in segment-1. There is no material whatsoever to reach any conclusion regarding contravention of the provisions of
39 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
clause (b) of section 269ST. Consequently, the penalty U/s 271D cannot be levied. We, also refer to the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme court in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax Officer Vs Khoday Eswarsa and sons [1972] 83 ITR 369, where it was held that "Penalty proceedings being penal in character, the department must establish that the receipt of the amount in dispute constitutes income of the assessee. Apart from the falsity of the explanation given by the Assessee, the department must have before it before levying penalty cogent material or evidence from which it could be inferred that the assessee had consciously concealed the particulars of his income or had deliberately furnished inaccurate particulars in respect of the same and that the disputed amount is a revenue receipt. No doubt, the original assessment proceedings for computing the tax may be a good item of evidence in the penalty proceedings but the penalty cannot be levied solely on the basis of the reasons given in the original order of assessment". Therefore, in our considered view the materials considered by the AO for the purpose of levy of penalty u/s 271DA for violation of section 269ST does not show any evidence of violation of clause (b) of section 269ST of the Act, and thus, penalty levied by the AO u/s 271DA is unsustainable under law. 27. In this view of the matter and considering the facts and circumstances of the case, we are of the considered view that the penalty levied by the A.O under section 271DA of the Act for alleged violation of section 269ST of the I.T. Act 1961 is unsustainable in law. Therefore, on this count also, penalty levied by the A.O should be deleted. The Ld. CIT (A) without appreciating the relevant facts simply sustained the penalty levied by the A.O. Thus, we set aside the order of the Ld. CIT (A) and direct the A.O to delete the penalty levied under section 271DA of the Act for the A.Y 2018-19 to 2021-22.”
In this view of the matter, and considering the facts of the present case and also by respectfully following the decision of the ITAT, Hyderabad, in the appellant’s own group case, in the case of MSN Laboratories Private Limited Vs. ACIT (supra), we are of the considered view that, there is no error in the reasons given by the Ld. CIT(A) to delete the penalty levied under Section 271DA of the Act. Thus, we are inclined to uphold the findings of the Ld. CIT(A) and dismiss the appeal filed by the Revenue.
40 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
In the result, the appeal filed by the Revenue in ITA No.2003/Hyd/2026 for A.Y. 2019-20 is dismissed.
ITA No.2007/Hyd/2026 for A.Y. 2020-21
The facts and issues involved in this appeal are identical to the facts and issues, which we had considered in Revenue’s appeal in ITA No.2003/Hyd/2026 for the A.Y. 2019-20. The reasons given by us in the preceding paragraphs Nos. 14 to 16 of this order shall equally apply to this appeal, as well. Therefore, for similar reasons, we uphold the findings of the Ld. CIT(A) to delete the penalty under Section 271DA of the Act, for the A.Y. 2020-21, and dismiss the appeal filed by the Revenue. 18. In the result, the appeal filed by the Revenue in ITA No.2007/Hyd/2026 for A.Y. 2020-21 is dismissed.
To sum up, both the Revenue appeals are dismissed.
Order pronounced in the Open Court on 13th November, 2026.
Sd/- Sd/- श्री विजय पाल राव (मंजूनाथ जी) (VIJAY PAL RAO) (MANJUNATHA G.) उपाध्यक्ष /VICE PRESIDENT लेखा सदस्य/ACCOUNTANT MEMBER
Hyderabad, dated 13.11.2026. TYNM/sps
41 ITA Nos.2003 and 2007/Hyd/2026
आदेशकी प्रतिलिपि अग्रेषित/ Copy of the order forwarded to:- 1. निर्धारिती/The Assessee : MSN PHARMACHEM PVT LTC C-24, MSN HOUSE, INDUSTRIAL ESTATE, KV RANGAREDDY, BALANAGAR, SANATHNAGAR HYDERABAD-500018, TELANGANA 2. राजस्व/ The Revenue : 1. ACIT, CENTRAL CIRCLE -2(4) 6TH FLOOR, AAYAKAR BHAVAN, BASHEERBAGH, HYDERABAD-500004, TELANGANA
2.DCIT, CENTRAL CIRCLE -2(4) 6TH FLOOR, AAYAKAR BHAVAN, BASHEERBAGH, HYDERABAD-500004, TELANGANA 3. The Principal Commissioner of Income Tax (Central), Hyderabad. 4. विभागीयप्रतिनिधि, आयकर अपीलीय अधिकरण, हैदराबाद / DR, ITAT, Hyderabad 5. गार्डफ़ाईल / Guard file
आदेशानुसार / BY ORDER
Senior Private Secretary, ITAT, Hyderabad.
GEETHA Digitally signed by GEETHA VISHWANATHAN DN: C=IN, O=INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL HYDERABAD, 2.5.4.20=fff52f4bdbd8c1faf4d9bc1b8157b0d648ac4049d668b28b2ca12ec8baf5aa71, OU=INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL,CID - 7079141, 2.5.4.17=500080, S=Telangana, VISHWANATHAN SerialNumber=78b106a34018ddebb6525c6db66e1f41656628afdc4474204cd60eeba1d782ed, CN=GEETHA VISHWANATHAN Date: 2026.11.17 12:42:17 +05'30'
More judgments on Section 132
- DCIT Central Circle 32, Delhi vs M/S Triveni Tv Networks Private Limited…ITA 5661/DEL/2026[2019-20]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2019-20
- Quickpaisa Fintech Private Limited, Delhi vs Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax…ITA 1067/DEL/2026[2018-19]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2018-19
- Quickpaisa Fintech Private Limited, Delhi vs Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax…ITA 1066/DEL/2026[2017-18]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2017-18
- Asst. Commissioner of Income Tax, Central… vs Jagdish Kumar Dhingra, DelhiITA 5462/DEL/2024[2017-18]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2017-18
- Asst. Commissioner of Income Tax, Central… vs Apichem Laboratories Pvt Ltd, HyderabadITA 2394/HYD/2026[2021-22]Status: Disposed13 Nov 2026AY 2021-22
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Subrat Kumar Samal vs. The Commissioner, CGST, Cx And Customs, BhubaneswarOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- Laxmipriya Biswal vs. Assistant Commissioner Of State Tax,BhubaneswarOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- M/S Shree Jagannath Engineering,Angul vs. Assistant Commissioner, Angul Division ,AngulOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- M/S. Archana Agro, Nayagarh vs. The Chief Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes And Goods And Services Tax, CuttackOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- M/S.Shree Jagannath Associates, Angul vs. The Chief Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes And Goods And Services Tax, CuttackOrissa · 3 Nov 2026