COMMNR.OF INCOME TAX vs. RANJIT KU.BADAJENA
What did the High Court hold?
The Court agreed with the Insurance Company that the monthly income of Rs.6000/- was correctly taken, noting that averaging income tax returns for the last three years might even lead to a lower figure. Regarding future prospects, the Court, in light of National Insurance Ltd. vs. Pranay Sethi, held that the deceased, being self-employed or on a fixed salary, was entitled to an addition of 40% of the established income. On the multiplier, the Court found substance in the Insurance Company's submission that for a deceased aged 30 years, the correct multiplier, as per Sarla Verma vs. DTC, is 17, not 18. The Court recalculated the compensation, arriving at a total of Rs.12,12,400/-. This amount, less any amount already paid, was to be paid by the Insurance Company within three months with interest at 6% per annum from the date of petition till realization. The appeal was disposed of.
What were the facts?
The appellants, claimants in a motor accident case, filed an appeal against the judgment dated 15.11.2014 passed by the Additional District and Sessions Judge-III, Patna. The original claim case, registered as Claim Case no.188 of 2002, arose from an accident on 8.7.2002 where the deceased, Bal Mukund Kumar, died after his motorcycle was hit by a bus. The lower court awarded compensation of Rs.8,28,500/- with interest. The appeal was preferred by the claimants seeking enhancement of the compensation amount. The owner and driver of the bus (respondent nos. 1 and 2) were not issued notice as the appeal was on a limited point of quantum. The Oriental Insurance Company Limited was the respondent.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the monthly income of the deceased was correctly quantified by the lower court, and if not, what should be the correct monthly income (turning on principles of compensation assessment in motor accident cases). 2. Whether future prospects should be added to the deceased's income for calculating compensation (turning on principles of compensation assessment). 3. Whether the correct multiplier was applied by the lower court, and if not, what should be the correct multiplier (turning on principles of compensation assessment and the age of the deceased). Assessee's arguments: The monthly income of the deceased was Rs.8500/-, but the lower court erroneously quantified it around Rs.6000/-. Future prospects were not considered. Revenue's arguments: The lower court rightly calculated the monthly income by averaging income tax returns. The multiplier of 18 was wrongly applied; it should be 17 based on the deceased's age of 30 years, as per Sarla Verma vs. DTC. Future prospects were rightly not added in the 2014 decision.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA Miscellaneous Appeal No.23 of 2015 ====================================================== 1. Rita Kumari and Ors wife of Late Balmukund Kumar 2. Ramjee Prasad Son of Bhagwat Prasad 3. Raj Kumar Devi wife of Ramjee Prasad All resident of village- Salempur Post- Chanaura, P.S.- Rahui Bena, District- Nalanda at present resident at B/57, Kankarbagh Colony, P.O. P.S.- Kankarbagh, District- Patna ... ... Appellant/s Versus 1. Braj Kishore Choubey and Ors son of Sri Gopal Choubey Resident of Radha Krishna Mandir, Muradpur, P.S.- Pirbahore, P.O.- Bankipore, District- Patna owner of Bus No. BR-P/7170 2. Jogi Sharma Son of Ram Swarath Sharma, Resident of Chhoti Pahadi, P.S.- Alamganj Agamkuan, Post- Pahari Patna City, District- Patna 3. The Oriental Insurance Company Limited, City Branch Office VI, South Gandhi Maidan, P.S.- Gandhi Maidan, District- Patna Pin 800 002 ... ... Respondent/s ====================================================== Appearance : For the Appellant/s : Mr. Dhananjay Kumar Tiwary, Adv. For the Respondent/s : Mr. Ashok Priyadarshi, Adv. ====================================================== CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PARTHA SARTHY ORAL ORDER 7 07-07-2022 Heard learned counsel for the appellants and learned counsel for the Insurance Company Ltd.-respondent no.3. The appeal having been preferred by the claimants/appellants on the limited point of enhancement of the quantum of compensation, no notice needs to be issued to respondent nos. 1 and 2 who are the owner and driver of the bus in question. The instant appeal under section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 has been preferred against the judgment dated 15.11.2014 passed in Claim Case no.188 of 2002 by the
Patna High Court MA No.23 of 2015(7) dt.07-07-2022 2/5 learned Additional District and Sessions Judge-III, Patna whereby it was held and ordered that the claimants were entitled to get compensation amount of Rs.8,28,500/- within 45 days failing which they would be entitled to interest on the awarded amount at the rate of 10% from 26.5.2014 till actual date of payment. The facts in brief are that on 8.7.2002 at about 8.15 pm the deceased along with his friend was going on a motorcycle when they meet with an accident with the bus bearing registration no. BR 01P 7170 coming from the opposite side. As a result of the bus dashing against the motorcycle, Bal Mukund Kumar died on the spot. The injured were taken to the hospital where post mortem examination was conducted. A case being Chauk P.S. Case no.120 of 2002 dated 8.7.2002 was registered under sections 279 and 304A of the Indian Penal Code against the driver. It is further submitted that the claim case was filed by the claimants which was registered as Claim Case no.188 of 2002. After issuance of notice, evidence was led on behalf of the applicants/claimants which was both oral as well as documentary. By judgment dated 15.11.2014 the learned Additional District Judge-III was pleased to allow the claim case and granted compensation as stated above. It is against the said judgment that the instant appeal has been preferred praying for
Patna High Court MA No.23 of 2015(7) dt.07-07-2022 3/5 increase in the quantum of compensation . It is submitted by learned counsel for the appellants that the monthly income of the deceased was Rs.8500/-, however erroneously the learned Court below has quantified his monthly income to be around Rs.6000/ per month. It is further submitted that future prospects has also not been taken into account in calculating the quantum of compensation. The appeal is opposed by learned counsel appearing for the Oriental Insurance Company Limited (‘Insurance Company’ in short). It is submitted that the learned Court below has rightly calculated the monthly income of the deceased which was done taking into account the average of the income shown in the income tax return. It is submitted that in fact on detailed calculation, the amount of monthly income may go even lower than what has been taken in calculating the compensation. It is further submitted that in the compensation, the multiplier has wrongly been taken as 18, and the same should be 17 taking into consideration the chart given in paragraph no.40 in the judgment of Sarla Verma versus DTC and another [(2009) 6 SCC121] and the age of the deceased being 30 years. On query by the Court, it is further submitted by learned counsel for the Insurance Company that the instant case was decided in the year 2014 wherein the future prospect had
Patna High Court MA No.23 of 2015(7) dt.07-07-2022 4/5 rightly not been added in calculating the annual salary of the deceased. Having heard learned counsel for the appellant and learned counsel for the Insurance Company, so far as the question of calculation of taking Rs.6000/- per month as monthly income of the deceased is concerned, the Court is in agreement with the submission made by learned counsel for the Insurance Company. Further in calculating the average monthly income taking into account the income tax return for the last three years, the monthly income may go down even further. However not going into the details thereof, the monthly income with respect to the deceased is taken as Rs.6000/. Further in view of the judgment in the case of National Insurance Ltd. versus Pranay Sethi [(2017) 16 SCC 680], in case the deceased was self employed or on fixed salary an addition of 40% of the established income has been given as future prospects. The Court holds the deceased in the instant case also to be entitled to the same. Further on the question of multiplier, the Court once again finds substance in the submission made on behalf of Insurance Company that from the chart given in the case of Sarla Verma (surpa) for ascertaining the multiplier the relevant age would be the age of the deceased which is 30 years in the instant case and as such the correct multiplier would be 17 and
Patna High Court MA No.23 of 2015(7) dt.07-07-2022 5/5 not 18. Taking into account the above, the calculation of the compensation payable to the claimants/appellants would come as follows: 1. Monthly income of the deceased Rs. 6000/ 2. Future prospects at the rate of 40% Rs. 2400/ Total Rs. 8400/ 3. Annual income of the deceased Rs.1,00,800/ (Rs.8400/ X 12) - 4. Less of personal expense (1/3) Rs. 33,600/ Rs. 67,200/ 5. Compensation (X17) Rs.11,42,400/ 6. Other conventional head+18000/ at the rate of Rs.3000 for 2005, 2008, 2011, 2014, 2017 and 2020 Rs. 70,000/ Rs.12,12,400/ The aforesaid total amount of Rs.12,12,400/ shall be paid by the Insurance Company to the respondent/claimants after deducting the amount already paid within a period of three months with interest thereon at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of petition till the date of realization. The appeal stands disposed off.
Bibhash/- (Partha Sarthy, J) U
More judgments on Section 173(1)
- M/S Nhdpl South Private Limited vs The Deputy CommissionerITA/586/202223 Jan 2023
- Ultratech Cement Limited vs State of Karnataka and OrsWA/200057/202122 Dec 2022
- Principal Commissioner of I.T.-1 vs Orissa Mining Corp.LtdITA/14/201825 Feb 2022
- Tata Refractories Lt vs Comnr.of I.TaxITA/55/20097 Feb 2022
- The Principal Commissioner of Income Tax-7 vs M/S Technotree Convergence LtdITA/69/202130 Jun 2021
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Shashibhusan Moharana vs. The Superintendent Of CGST And Central Excise, DhenkanalOrissa · 4 Nov 2026
- Paramount Tea Marketing PVT. LTD. vs. Union Of INDIA And 3 OrsGauhati · 4 Nov 2026
- Md. Junaid vs. The State Of BiharPatna · 4 Nov 2026
- M/S Sanjeevini Health Care vs. M/S.Vijayalakshmi And AssociatesKarnataka · 4 Nov 2026
- Trilok Chandra vs. State Tax OfficerUttarakhand · 4 Nov 2026