18 orders · Page 1 of 1
The Tribunal held that the writ petition is without substance and dismissed it. The court distinguished the case of Catalysts vs. State of U.P. and others, finding it distinguishable on facts. In Catalysts, an assessment order was set aside and remanded, and during remand proceedings, reassessment was initiated. The present case involved escaped assessment for the entire year, for which the extended period of limitation under Section 29(7) of the U.P. VAT Act, 2008, was invoked. The Tribunal reasoned that Section 29(1) empowers the assessing authority to make assessment or reassessment if there is reason to believe that turnover has escaped assessment, and authorization under Section 29(7) can be granted even if no assessment order was initially passed. The court also noted that an interpretation of Catalysts that conflicts with the Full Bench judgment in Commissioner of Sales Tax vs. Jag Mohan Nath (1972) 29 STC 663 (All) would be incorrect. The ratio decidendi is that escaped assessment for an entire year can be subject to reassessment proceedings under Section 29(1) and 29(7) of the U.P. VAT Act, 2008, even in the absence of a prior assessment order for that year, provided the conditions for invoking the extended period of limitation are met.
The Tribunal acknowledged that it is an admitted case that the demand has already been recovered. Therefore, no order for the return of the recovered amount was deemed necessary at that stage, unless the petitioner succeeds in her appeal. To meet the ends of justice and as agreed by the learned counsel for the Department, the Tribunal directed that the appeal of the petitioner pending before the CIT (Appeals), Ghaziabad, be decided on merits in accordance with law, expeditiously, preferably within two months from the date of presentation of a copy of the order. The petitioner was to be afforded a reasonable opportunity of hearing. The issue of returning the recovered amount was implicitly left undecided pending the outcome of the appeal.
The Court directed the revisionist company to pay a sum of Rs. 2 crore within 30 days under the U.P. VAT Act and Rs. 30 lacs within 30 days under the Central Sales Tax Act. For the remaining disputed tax liability under both Acts, the revisionist company was directed to furnish security other than cash, bank guarantee, or bank draft. The Court disposed of both revisions with these observations. Additionally, pending appeals were directed to be decided by the appellate authority within three months from the date of the order. The specific finding on the legality of the initial demand or the merits of the tax escapement claim was not explicitly detailed, focusing instead on interim directions for deposit and security.
The Tribunal noted that the revenue had stated that the impugned attachment order dated 07.02.2020 had been lifted and the attached account released after the recovery of 20% of the disputed amount. Consequently, reliefs (a) and (c) sought in the writ petition no longer survived. Relief (b) regarding interim relief could not be granted at that stage, as the petitioner could apply for interim relief before the CIT(A). The Tribunal acknowledged the revenue's statement that they did not intend to press further recovery till the disposal of the petitioner's appeal. The primary remaining prayer was for a time-bound decision of the appeal. The Tribunal directed the respondent no. 3 (CIT(A)) to decide the petitioner's appeal in accordance with law, expeditiously, preferably within two months from the date of presentation of a certified copy of the order. The CIT(A) was to fix a date for the appeal upon submission of the order copy and make efforts to decide it within the stipulated period. The writ petition was disposed of with these observations.
The Tribunal, comprising Hon'ble Pankaj Mithal, J. and Hon'ble Surya Prakash Kesarwani, J., disposed of the writ petition in the interest of justice. Instead of keeping the matter pending, the Court directed the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeal), Agra, U.P. (respondent no.1) to decide the petitioner's statutory appeal, filed on January 11, 2020, against the assessment order dated December 26, 2019, as expeditiously as possible. The decision was to be preferably within six weeks from the date a copy of the order is produced before the Commissioner, provided the office is regularly working and not closed due to the COVID-19 Pandemic. If the office was not working, the appeal was to be decided within six weeks of the resumption of work. The Court also expected that the stay application pending in the appeal would be dealt with within the aforesaid time, even if it meant addressing it on merits or otherwise if a full appeal decision was not possible for inevitable reasons.
The Tribunal held that the two questions of law raised by the appellant could not be termed as substantial questions of law, as they were essentially factual in nature. Regarding the first issue of service of notice under Section 148, the Tribunal, relying on the order of the CIT(A), found that the appellant's claim was negated by his own admission. The appellant had received a notice under Section 274 dated May 4, 2017, at the address "Manoj Kumar Sharma, Nai Abadi, Dadri, G.B. Nagar." Since this notice was served by postal authorities on the same address, and no notices were returned as unserved for want of a correct or complete address, the presumption of bonafide in favor of the state held ground. Therefore, the appellant could not claim the address was incorrect or incomplete. For the second issue concerning additional evidence, the Tribunal noted that the CIT(A)'s order at paragraph 8 indicated that the AO had responded to the fresh evidence submitted by the appellant and rejected it, recommending the dismissal of the appeal. The Tribunal found no substantial question of law and dismissed the appeal.
The Tribunal held that a mandatory order directing the respondent no. 2 to consider the writ petitioner's representation could not be issued by the writ Court. This was primarily because there was no specific provision under the Income Tax Act that mandates the consideration of such a representation by the concerned authority. Furthermore, the Tribunal observed that the averments in the writ petition indicated the existence of a private dispute between the petitioner and Mangu Singh. Consequently, the Court found itself unable to pass any order as prayed for by the petitioner. The writ petition was accordingly dismissed.
The Tribunal held that the impugned order dated January 24, 2020, could not be sustained and was liable to be set aside solely on the ground that an opportunity of hearing was not demonstrably granted to the assessee. While the order acknowledged the consideration of the assessee's written submissions, it failed to record that a proper hearing was afforded. Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the order. The respondent authority was granted liberty to decide the assessee's petition for stay of demand afresh, ensuring that the assessee is given an adequate opportunity of hearing. The writ petition was disposed of accordingly.
The High Court held that the Supreme Court's decision in MCorp Global Pvt. Ltd. is not applicable to the present case. The Supreme Court in MCorp Global had held that the Tribunal was not authorized to take back a benefit granted by the assessing officer. In this case, the ITAT did not pass such an order. Instead, it merely set aside the issue of commission expenses to the assessing officer for fresh adjudication after examining the parties. Furthermore, the ITAT had explicitly observed that the Revenue's appeal was partly allowed for statistical purposes only. Consequently, the High Court found no substantial question of law requiring formulation and disposed of the appeal.
The Tribunal held that the assessee was liable for penalty under Section 10-A read with Section 10(b) of the Central Sales Tax Act. The Court distinguished the present case from the Apex Court's judgment in Commissioner of Sales Tax, U.P. Vs. M/s Sanjiv Fabrics, finding that the assessee in the present case had full knowledge that its application for adding items to the registration certificate had not been allowed. The assessee continued to import goods under Form-C despite this knowledge. The Tribunal reasoned that the assessee could not plead ignorance of the certificate of registration and its contents, and therefore, could not be considered to have acted bonafidely. The Court found no illegality or infirmity in the orders of the Tribunal and dismissed the revisions, answering the substantial questions of law in favour of the revenue.
The Tribunal held that the writ petition was liable to be dismissed. It found that the reassessment proceedings were initiated because the assessee had misrepresented in his return and audit report regarding the applicability of Section 40A(3) and Rule 6DD. The Tribunal noted that the payments of Rs.3,40,000/- made by the petitioner to M/s Jalan Synthetics were deposited in their bank account, and the petitioner failed to provide evidence that these deposits were made at the instance of M/s Jalan Synthetics or due to any business exigency. Consequently, the benefit of exemption under Rule 6DD was rightly denied. The Tribunal upheld the impugned order dated 19.01.2016 passed by the Principal Commissioner, Income Tax, Gorakhpur, which concluded that the transfer of funds was not covered by any exception under Rule 6DD. The Court also reiterated that its jurisdiction under Article 226 is limited to examining the decision-making process, not the decision itself, and found no illegality, irrationality, or procedural impropriety in the decision-making process of the authorities. Therefore, the petitioner's contentions were not accepted, and the writ petition was dismissed.
The Tribunal disposed of the writ petition by granting liberty to the petitioner to avail the alternative remedy. The reasoning was based on the submission by the respondent's counsel that the assessment orders, which led to the demand notices, were appealable under Section 246-A of the Income Tax Act. This section provides an effective and efficacious alternative remedy. The Tribunal did not decide the merits of the demand notices or the assessment orders themselves. The operative direction was to permit the petitioner to pursue the statutory appeal.
The Tribunal held that the petitioner failed to discharge the burden of proof to rebut the presumption of correctness of the official acts of the revenue authorities. The orders dated 28.10.2019 and 26.11.2019 specifically recorded that prior approval under Section 151 was taken from the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Noida. The petitioner's plea that no such approval was appended with the objection was deemed deficient. The Tribunal found no reason to doubt the correctness of these findings, which were not shown to be perverse. Regarding the denial of a copy of the Section 151 approval, the Tribunal held that such approval is a jurisdictional prerequisite, and the assessee is fully entitled to a copy. The denial by the revenue authority was deemed unsustainable in law. However, this did not invalidate the reassessment proceedings themselves, as the Tribunal found no infirmity in them. The reassessment proceedings were not liable to be interfered with.
The Tribunal held that the assessment order dated December 10, 2019, was passed without affording a reasonable opportunity of hearing to the petitioner. The notice dated December 6, 2019, was served on the petitioner on December 11, 2019. There was no record of any other notice being issued to the petitioner indicating a hearing on December 10, 2019. The Tribunal found that the notice was served after the date of the hearing and the passing of the assessment order. Consequently, the writ petition was allowed in part, and the matter was remitted to the Assessing Officer (respondent no. 2) to pass a fresh order in accordance with law after providing an opportunity of hearing to the petitioner. The petitioner agreed to appear before the Assessing Officer on January 20, 2020.
The Tribunal held that the impugned duplicate bills, issued based on assessments made without adhering to the provisions of the U.P. Municipal Corporation Act, 1959, specifically without issuing notice or providing an opportunity of hearing to the petitioner, cannot be sustained and are liable to be quashed. The reasoning was that the procedural requirements of the Act were not followed. The Tribunal allowed the writ petition and quashed the impugned duplicate bills. However, it clarified that this order would not prevent respondent no. 3 from initiating fresh proceedings against the petitioner strictly in accordance with the provisions of the Act. No issue was expressly left undecided.
The Tribunal's order is set aside, and the revision is allowed. The Court found that the assessing authority imposed penalty solely because the driver lacked the relevant inter-state sale documents. While the Tribunal upheld the reduced penalty, it did so based on the finding that not carrying documents indicated an intention to evade tax. However, the Court noted that the First Appellate Authority had recorded findings of fact that the goods were for producing non-taxable goods and that the machine was returned due to being non-functional, meaning no concluded sale occurred. The Court emphasized that for penalty under Section 15A to be imposed, there must be a clear finding of fact that the goods were transported with the intention to evade tax. Relying on judgments in Commissioner of Sales Tax Vs. S/S Haring India Limited and M/s Polyplex Corporation Limited Vs. Commissioner of Trade Tax, the Court held that the authorities had not recorded a clear finding of intention to evade tax. The fact that the revisionist produced all documents at the first instance indicated no such intention. Therefore, the penalty was not sustainable.
The High Court declined to pass any order in the writ petition that could prejudice either party in the pending statutory appeal before the ITAT. The Court found that the statutory appeal required expeditious hearing and disposal. Therefore, the writ petition was disposed of with a direction to the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Circuit Bench at Varanasi, to hear and dispose of the pending statutory appeal filed by the writ petitioner as expeditiously as possible, preferably within two months but not later than three months from the date of communication of the order. The Tribunal was also directed to consider the contentions the writ petitioner sought to raise. The Court further stipulated that neither the petitioner nor the Revenue should seek unnecessary adjournments, and the Tribunal should not grant them unless exigency demanded.
The High Court, while acknowledging the pending statutory appeal before the ITAT, chose not to pass any order in the writ petition that could prejudice either party. The Court allowed the petitioner's application to amend the prayer of the writ petition. The primary decision was to direct the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Circuit Bench at Varanasi, to hear and dispose of the pending statutory appeal filed by the petitioner as expeditiously as possible, preferably within two months but not later than three months from the date of communication of the order. The Tribunal was also directed to consider the contentions of the writ petitioner while disposing of the appeal. Both parties were cautioned against seeking unnecessary adjournments, and the Tribunal was directed not to grant them unless exigencies demanded.