M/S MONDELEZ INDIA FOODS PRIVATE LIMITED vs. COMMISSONER OF COMMERCIAL TAXES

PDF · subscribers
STRE/84/2020HC AllahabadUPHC01066978202031 August 20201 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the High Court hold?

The Court directed the revisionist company to pay a sum of Rs. 2 crore within 30 days under the U.P. VAT Act and Rs. 30 lacs within 30 days under the Central Sales Tax Act. For the remaining disputed tax liability under both Acts, the revisionist company was directed to furnish security other than cash, bank guarantee, or bank draft. The Court disposed of both revisions with these observations. Additionally, pending appeals were directed to be decided by the appellate authority within three months from the date of the order. The specific finding on the legality of the initial demand or the merits of the tax escapement claim was not explicitly detailed, focusing instead on interim directions for deposit and security.

What were the facts?

The revisionist, M/s Mondelez India Foods Private Limited, filed two commercial tax revisions against a common order dated March 30, 2020. This order was passed by the Commercial Tax Tribunal, which upheld the first appellate authority's direction for the assessee to pay 50% of the disputed tax liability. The assessing authority had created a demand of Rs. 46.5 crores under the VAT Act and Rs. 1.45 crores under the Central Sales Tax Act for the Assessment Year 2016-17. The assessee contended that its books of accounts were maintained in accordance with law, no tax had escaped assessment, and the admitted tax of Rs. 64.9 crores had been deposited. The court was considering the matter of these disputed demands.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the Tribunal erred in affirming the direction to pay 50% of the disputed tax liability, considering the assessee's contention of proper maintenance of accounts and no tax escapement. Assessee's Contention: The assessee argued that a huge illegal demand had been created, its books of accounts were duly maintained as per law, there was no escapement of tax, and the entire admitted tax had been deposited. They relied on the principle that tax demands should be based on proper assessment and not arbitrary. Revenue's Contention: The judgment does not record specific arguments from the revenue's side regarding the disputed tax liability or the directions issued by the lower authorities.

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Court No. - 69 Case :- SALES/TRADE TAX REVISION No. - 84 of 2020 Revisionist :- M/S Mondelez India Foods Private Limited Opposite Party :- Commissoner Of Commercial Taxes Counsel for Revisionist :- Nishant Mishra,Tanmay Sadh Counsel for Opposite Party :- C.S.C. And Case :- SALES/TRADE TAX REVISION No. - 86 of 2020 Revisionist :- M/S Mondelez India Foods Private Limited Opposite Party :- Commissoner Of Commercial Taxes Counsel for Revisionist :- Nishant Mishra,Tanmay Sadh Counsel for Opposite Party :- C.S.C. Hon'ble Ashok Kumar,J. Heard Sri Tarun Gulati, learned senior counsel assisted by Sri Nishant Mishra, learned counsel for the revisionist. These are two commercial trade tax revisions filed by the revisionist company against a common order dated 30.3.2020. By the impugned order the Commercial Tax Tribunal has affirmed the order passed by the first appellate authority by which the first appellate authority has directed the assessee company to pay 50% of the disputed tax liability. Learned senior counsel has submitted that in fact huge illegal demand has been created by the assessing authority under the VAT Act for the Assessment Year 2016-17 to the tune of Rs.46.5 crores and sum of Rs.1.45 crores under the Central Sales Tax for the Assessment Year 2016-17. Learned senior counsel has submitted that the books of accounts are duly maintained by the company strictly in accordance with law and there is no escapement of tax at the hands of the company. The entire admitted tax has already been deposited by the company to the tune of Rs.64.9 crores under the VAT and Central Sales Tax Act. Considering the entirety of the matter this Court deem it appropriate to direct the revisionist company to pay/ deposit sum of Rs.2 crore within a period of 30 days under the U.P. VAT Act and Rs.30 lacs. within a period of 30 days under the Central Sales Tax Act. For the balance disputed tax both under the VAT Act and under the Central Sales Tax Act the revisionist company will furnish the security other than cash, bank guarantee or bank draft. With the above observations, both the revisions are disposed of. The pending appeals are directed to be decided by the appellate authority within three months from today. Order Date :- 1.9.2020 S.S.

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →