5 orders · Page 1 of 1
The High Court held that the present appeal filed by the Revenue is not maintainable. The Court found that the observation in paragraph 3 of the ITAT's order was merely a recital of the assessee's submissions regarding the AO's failure to follow procedures under Section 148A and amended Section 151. The Tribunal had not recorded independent reasoning but merely followed a coordinate bench's order. The Court clarified that stating a procedure was not followed does not constitute an adverse comment or stricture against the officer, which is a condition for certain exceptions under the litigation policy. Furthermore, the Court noted that when an entire order is quashed on jurisdictional grounds, it does not necessarily mean the tax effect is unquantifiable. The net tax liability was Rs. 1,23,07,705/-, and with interest, the total liability was Rs. 2,09,62,403/-. The Court reiterated that for the purpose of ascertaining appeal maintainability under the litigation policy, interest and penalty liabilities are not to be examined. Consequently, the appeal was found to be below the specified monetary limit and was dismissed.
The High Court held that the present appeal is below the monetary limit specified under the binding Circular No.5 of 2024. The Court found that the case falls under the exceptional Clause 3.1(f) of the said Circular, but ultimately dismissed the appeal on the grounds of it being below the monetary threshold. The Court referred to a separate appeal (Income Tax Appeal No. 183 of 2026) decided on the same day, which also dealt with the monetary limit specified in the Circular. The ITAT's finding that the reassessment proceedings were invalid due to improper approval under Section 151 was noted, but the High Court did not adjudicate on the merits of this finding. The operative direction was to dismiss the appeal. No issue was expressly left undecided by the High Court, other than the merits of the ITAT's decision on reassessment, which were not reached due to the dismissal on the preliminary ground.
The High Court held that the present appeal is not maintainable. The Court reasoned that while the ITAT had quashed the re-assessment order, the original re-assessment order had quantified the tax effect at Rs. 1,41,74,009/-. The Court found that the revenue's reliance on Clause 3.1(f) of the Circulars was misplaced. This clause pertains to situations where tax effect is not quantifiable or involved, such as cancellation of registration or orders under Section 263, which may necessitate a fresh assessment. However, in this case, a specific tax amount had been imposed through the re-assessment order. The Court concluded that merely because the assessment order was set aside on legal grounds, it did not mean the tax effect was not quantified. Therefore, the appeal was found to be below the prescribed taxable limit under the CBDT Circulars.
The High Court allowed the writ petition. The Court noted that the counter-affidavit filed by the respondents explicitly stated that the bank accounts in question were related to the business transactions of AL Yaseen Trading Co. Pvt. Ltd. and not associated with the assessee, Smt. Sangita Tawari. It was further stated that the petitioner's PAN (AEBPT4722P) had been wrongly linked by the bank with these accounts, and the bank had reported cash withdrawals under the petitioner's PAN. The Court found that the Income Tax Department's stand, as reflected in the counter-affidavit, was that the petitioner's PAN card was inadvertently attached to the company's PAN card, and the petitioner had no role to play. Given this admission by the respondents, the Court concluded that the petitioner was not liable for any tax or penalty. Consequently, the assessment order dated May 24, 2021, penalty orders under Section 271AAC(1) and Section 272A(1)(d), and the revisional order dated March 20, 2026, rejecting the revision under Section 264, were set aside.
The High Court held that the reassessment proceedings initiated by the show cause notice dated 15.04.2024 for AY 2017-18 were invalid. The Court found merit in the assessee's contention that the information flagged by the risk management strategy did not constitute fresh information requiring a subsequent reopening. The revenue's own supplementary affidavit indicated that the bank in which unexplained credits appeared was Punjab National Bank, whereas the initial reassessment proceedings were based on cash deposits in Oriental Bank of Commerce. Crucially, the revenue acknowledged that the entire credit transactions for the year under consideration had been examined during the initial reassessment proceedings. Therefore, the subsequent reopening was not justified. The writ petition was allowed to the extent of the limited prayer, and the reassessment proceedings were quashed.