2 orders · Page 1 of 1
The High Court held that the Tribunal erred in setting aside the entire penalty order without adjudicating the issue of concealment on merits. The AO had made a specific finding of concealment of particulars of income, supported by reasoning. While the finding regarding furnishing inaccurate particulars might have been an observation made in passing without sufficient reasoning, the charge of concealment was independently established by the AO. The Court noted that the Tribunal had not examined the grounds raised by the assessee regarding whether mere rejection or withdrawal of a claim amounts to concealment. Therefore, the appeal was allowed, and the matter was remitted back to the Tribunal to decide the appeal afresh on the issue of concealment of particulars of income. Question No. 1 was left unanswered, and Question No. 2 was answered by stating that the penalty order could not be set aside in its entirety merely because the AO also mentioned furnishing inaccurate particulars, when a positive finding of concealment was recorded.
The High Court reframed the questions of law. Regarding the first reframed question, the Court held that the cancellation notice issued on March 6, 2012, did not suffer from jurisdictional error, as the Commissioner had the power to cancel registration under Section 12A on that date. However, the Court found that the Commissioner wrongly gave effect to the cancellation from AY 2009-10. The Court agreed with the principle that exceeding the threshold in the proviso to Section 2(15) does not automatically lead to cancellation of registration, citing judgments from Bombay, Karnataka, and Madras High Courts. The Court noted that the ITAT had not recorded findings on the merits of the assessee's contention regarding its charitable purpose or the date from which cancellation could be effected. Therefore, the matter was remitted to the Tribunal to decide these issues afresh in accordance with law, including the judgment in CIT (Exemption) Vs. Yamuna Expressway Industrial Development Authority. The appeal was partly allowed.