THE PR COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-1 AND ANOTHER vs. PASHUPATI CASTINGS LTD.,

PDF · subscribers
IAPL/183/2026HC AllahabadUPHC01575711202601 November 2026Author: SWARUPAMA CHATURVEDI,SAUMITRA DAYAL SINGH3 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the present appeal filed by the Revenue is not maintainable. The Court found that the observation in paragraph 3 of the ITAT's order was merely a recital of the assessee's submissions regarding the AO's failure to follow procedures under Section 148A and amended Section 151. The Tribunal had not recorded independent reasoning but merely followed a coordinate bench's order. The Court clarified that stating a procedure was not followed does not constitute an adverse comment or stricture against the officer, which is a condition for certain exceptions under the litigation policy. Furthermore, the Court noted that when an entire order is quashed on jurisdictional grounds, it does not necessarily mean the tax effect is unquantifiable. The net tax liability was Rs. 1,23,07,705/-, and with interest, the total liability was Rs. 2,09,62,403/-. The Court reiterated that for the purpose of ascertaining appeal maintainability under the litigation policy, interest and penalty liabilities are not to be examined. Consequently, the appeal was found to be below the specified monetary limit and was dismissed.

What were the facts?

The Revenue filed an appeal before the Allahabad High Court against an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Agra Bench. The ITAT had allowed the assessee's appeal, ITA No. 19/AGR/2026, for Assessment Year 2017-18, setting aside the reassessment proceedings initiated under Section 147 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, on jurisdictional grounds. The ITAT's decision was based on the assessee's submission that the Assessing Officer (AO) had not followed the procedures prescribed under the new regime of Section 148A and amended Section 151 of the Act. The Revenue's appeal was challenged on the preliminary ground that it was filed below the monetary threshold of Rs. 2 crores, as stipulated by Circular No. 5 of 2024.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the present appeal filed by the Revenue is maintainable, considering the monetary threshold stipulated in Circular No. 5 of 2024, and if the tax effect is quantifiable for determining maintainability. Assessee's arguments: The assessee contended that the ITAT's order was based on the AO's failure to follow the procedures under the new regime of Section 148A and amended Section 151 of the Act, leading to the quashing of reassessment proceedings. The assessee argued that the tax effect is not quantifiable as the entire reassessment order was set aside on jurisdictional grounds, and therefore, the appeal should not be maintainable if below the threshold. Revenue's arguments: The Revenue argued that the appeal is maintainable. Firstly, it submitted that the total tax payable, including interest, amounts to Rs. 2,09,62,403/-, which exceeds the Rs. 2 crore threshold, citing Clause 3.1 (e) read with (f) of Circular No. 5 of 2024. Secondly, it relied on paragraph 3 of the ITAT's order and Clause 3.1 (e) of the Circular to argue maintainability. Thirdly, it contended that since the reassessment order was set aside on jurisdictional grounds, the merit issues were not examined, making the tax effect not quantifiable, and thus the appeal is maintainable.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 147,Section 148A,Section 151

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD INCOME TAX APPEAL No. - 183 of 2026 Court No. - 39 HON'BLE SAUMITRA DAYAL SINGH, J. HON'BLE SWARUPAMA CHATURVEDI, J. 1. Heard Shri Amit Mahajan, Learned Senior Standing Counsel for the revenue and Shri Suyash Agarwal, learned counsel for the assessee. 2. Present appeal has arisen against the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Agra Bench "DB":Agra, dated 17.03.2026 whereby the assessee's appeal ITA No. 19/AGR/2026 for AY 2017-18, Pashupati Castings Ltd. vs ITO, has been allowed on jurisdictional ground. Thus, the entire reassessment proceedings initiated against the assessee under Section 147 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as the Act) for the A.Y. 2017-18 has been dropped. 3. At the outset, preliminary objection has been raised that the present appeal has been filed below the threshold monetary limit Rs. 2 crores. 4. The above preliminary objection has been met on the strength of Clause 3.1 (e) read with (f) of Circular No. 5 of 2024 dated 15.03.2024 and computation sheet of tax. Thus, it has been submitted on behalf of the revenue that the total tax payable is Rs. 2,09,62,403/-. 5. Alternatively, in view of observation made in paragraph 3 of the order of the Tribunal, it has been submitted, by virtue of Clause 3.1 (e) of the Circular dated 15.03.2024, the present appeal is maintainable. 6. Still, alternatively, it has been submitted, since the entire reassessment order has been set aside on jurisdictional ground, the merit issues have not Versus Counsel for Appellant(s) : Amit Mahajan Counsel for Respondent(s) : Suyash Agarwal The Pr Commissioner Of Income Tax-1 And Another .....Appellant(s) Pashupati Castings Ltd., .....Respondent(s)

been examined. Therefore, the tax effect is not quantifiable. 7. Having heard counsel for the parties and having perused the record, we find, the present appeal is not maintainable. In the first place, as to the observation made in paragraph 3 of the order of the Tribunal, we find, only this much has been observed by the Tribunal: "Since the notice is issued on 1-4-2021, the provisions of new section 148A and amended section 151 of the Act kicks in. Admittedly, the Learned AO had not followed any of the procedures prescribed under the new regime and the amended provisions of section 148A and amended provisions of section 151 of the Act. Accordingly, it was submitted that the entire reassessment framed under section 147 of the Act deserves to be quashed." 8. That part of the order is recital of the submissions advanced by the assessee. As to the finding, the Tribunal has only followed the order of its coordinate bench in Aseem Sehgal v. ITO, in ITA Nos. 154 to 156/Del/2025 dated 30.07.2025. No independent reasoning has been recorded. Even otherwise, by merely stating that no procedure of law may have been followed while framing the assessment order, it may not be inferred that any stricture/adverse comment has been made. Clause 3.1(e) is referable only to strictures or adverse comments passed specifically with reference to any officer and not to the reasoning disapproved. It is in the nature of proceedings that the appeal authority may make such observations to support its conclusion that the order appealed against is contrary to the procedure established or has been passed in disregard to the procedure established or is violative of the procedure established. Those observations or reasoning are not adverse to the author of the order impugned before the appeal authority but are referable only to the error noted in the order. 9. Similarly, where the entire order is quashed or set aside on jurisdictional ground, it may not involve a case where tax effect is not quantifiable. Here, the net tax liability is Rs. 1,23,07,705/-. Thereon, interest has been added leading to the total tax liability together with interest is Rs. 2,09,62,403/-. 10. It is fundamental in this branch that where under the litigation policy, the maintainability of the appeal hinges on tax effect, interest and penalty IAPL No. 183 of 2026

liabilities are not to be examined for the purposes of ascertaining the maintainability of the appeal as per the litigation policy of the Union of India. 11. Consequently the appeal is found to be below the monetary limit specified under the binding Circular. It is accordingly dismissed. November 2, 2026 Prakhar IAPL No. 183 of 2026

(Swarupama Chaturvedi,J.) (Saumitra Dayal Singh,J.) Digitally signed by :- PRAKHAR SRIVASTAVA High Court of Judicature at Allahabad

More judgments on Section 147

All 57,238 judgments and leading authorities on Section 147 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →