MANOJ KUMAR SHARMA (PAN NO. BUFFPS6146D) vs. INCOME TAX OFFICER WARD 2(2), GAUTAM BUDH NAGAR

PDF · subscribers
IAPL/13/2020HC AllahabadUPHC01034852202017 February 20204 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The Tribunal held that the two questions of law raised by the appellant could not be termed as substantial questions of law, as they were essentially factual in nature. Regarding the first issue of service of notice under Section 148, the Tribunal, relying on the order of the CIT(A), found that the appellant's claim was negated by his own admission. The appellant had received a notice under Section 274 dated May 4, 2017, at the address "Manoj Kumar Sharma, Nai Abadi, Dadri, G.B. Nagar." Since this notice was served by postal authorities on the same address, and no notices were returned as unserved for want of a correct or complete address, the presumption of bonafide in favor of the state held ground. Therefore, the appellant could not claim the address was incorrect or incomplete. For the second issue concerning additional evidence, the Tribunal noted that the CIT(A)'s order at paragraph 8 indicated that the AO had responded to the fresh evidence submitted by the appellant and rejected it, recommending the dismissal of the appeal. The Tribunal found no substantial question of law and dismissed the appeal.

What were the facts?

The appeal concerns Manoj Kumar Sharma (appellant) against an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (Tribunal). The appellant challenged the Tribunal's judgment dated October 3, 2019, which arose from an appeal against the order of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-I dated May 11, 2018. The core of the dispute revolves around the service of notice under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, and the consideration of additional/fresh evidence by the CIT(A). The appellant contended that notices were not properly served at the address "Manoj Kumar Sharma, Nai Abadi, Dadri, G.B. Nagar." The Revenue argued that the appellant's own admission of receiving a notice under Section 274 dated May 4, 2017, at the same address, negated this claim.

What were the issues?

The Tribunal had to decide two questions of law: 1. Whether there was no service of notice under section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961? 2. Whether additional/fresh evidence was taken into consideration by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-I? The appellant argued that the address used for serving notices under Section 148 was incorrect, and merely because notices were not returned by postal authorities, it could not be presumed they were served. The appellant contended that the assessment order was bad in law due to non-service of notice. Regarding the second issue, the appellant's contentions are not explicitly detailed in the provided text, but the CIT(A)'s order indicates that the Assessing Officer (AO) rejected the fresh evidence submitted by the appellant. The Revenue's arguments are not separately detailed but are implicitly addressed by the findings of the lower authorities.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 260A,Section 148,Section 274,Section 271(1)(c)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

(1) Court No. ­ 7 Case :­ INCOME TAX APPEAL No. ­ 13 of 2020 Appellant :­ Manoj Kumar Sharma C­470, Beta­1, Greater  Noida, Gautam Budha Nagar (Uttar Pradesh)­201308 (Pan  No.BUFFPS6146D) Respondent :­ Income Tax Officer, Ward 2(2), Gautam Budh  Nagar, Room No.404, A­2d, 4th Floor, Sector­24, Noida,  Gautam Budh Nagar, Uttar Pradesh – 201301 Counsel for Appellant :­ Chandra Bhan Gupta Counsel for Respondent :­ Gaurav Mahajan Hon'ble Biswanath Somadder,J. Hon'ble Dr. Yogendra Kumar Srivastava,J. 1. This appeal, under section 260­A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, has been taken out in respect of a judgment and order of the learned Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Delhi Bench (S.M.C.), New Delhi, dated 3rd October, 2019. The appellant has essentially tried to make out a case on two questions of law, which, according to the learned advocate appearing for the appellant, are substantial questions of law. The questions of law are as follows:­ 1. “Whether there was no service of notice under section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 ? 2.   Whether   additional/fresh   evidence   was   taken   into consideration by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)­ I ?” 2. In our view, the two questions of law cannot be termed as   “substantial   questions   of   law”.   The   answer   to   the   two questions, however, are clearly reflected in the order of the Commissioner   of   Income   Tax   (Appeals)­I   dated   11th  May, 2018, wherefrom the appellant preferred an appeal before the learned Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Delhi Bench (S.M.C.), New Delhi. 3. So far as the first question is concerned, the following

(2) paragraphs extracted from the order of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)­I will speak for itself:­ “10. The appellant raised a ground that the address on which the   notices   were  sent   by   the   Ld.   AO   being  “Manoj   Kumar Sharma, Nai Abadi, Dadri, G.B. Nagar” was not the correct address as there could be more than one Manoj or Manoj Kumar or Manoj Kumar Sharma in Dadri and the post office might have ended up serving the notices of the Ld. AO to any one of those persons named Manoj. It was contended by the appellant that merely because the notices sent by the Ld. AO were   not   returned   by   the   postal   authorities   it   cannot   be presumed that those notices stood served upon the appellant and   the   service   of   notice   was   complete   in   terms   of   the provisions of law. Based upon such logic, the appellant has contended that there was no service of notice u/s 148 and therefore, the impugned assessment order was bad in law and liable to be deleted. 11. The ground taken by the appellant stands negated by the admitted position of the appellant himself. 12. The appellant has stated in its reply to the report of the Ld. AO that the appellant came to know about the best judgment assessment in its case only when it received the notice u/s 274 of I.T. Act, 1961 asking it to show cause vide a penalty u/s 271(1)(c) of I.T. Act, 1961 be not imposed on the appellant. A copy of the said notice has been placed on the record of this office under self authentication by the appellant. It is seen that the   said   notice   vide   F.   No.   ITO/W­2(2)/Noida/271(1) (c)/2017­18 dated 04.05.2017 file F. No./PAN/229/148 was issued on the same address on which the Ld. AO has issued earlier notices, i.e., Manoj Kumar Sharma, Nai Abadi, Dadri, G.B. Nagar. 13. Once the postal authorities have duly served the notice issued by the Ld. AO upon the appellant on that address as on

(3) May, 2017 there can be no ground unless proved otherwise to assume that postal authorities would not have been able to serve the notices issued by the Ld. AO upon the appellant on that very address earlier, i.e., prior to the service of notice in May 2017. As none of the notices were returned by the postal authorities as unserved for want of complete or correct address the presumption of bonafide as obtaining in favour of the State would hold the ground. In any case, the appellant has received the notices sent by the Ld. AO on that same address as late as May 2017 and it cannot claim that the address was incorrect or incomplete. 14. Therefore, in view of the admission of the appellant the claim of the appellant that it did not receive the notices issued by the Ld. AO because of the address on which the said notices were sent by the Ld. AO was either incomplete or incorrect is not tenable.” 4. So far as the second question is concerned, the answer to the   same   is   at   paragraph   8   of   the   said   order   of   the Commissioner   of   Income   Tax   (Appeals)­I   dated   11th  May, 2018, which reads as follows:­ “8. The Ld. AO by its report dated 26.03.2018 submitted its response to the fresh evidence of the appellant and rejected the same   and   recommended   that   the   grounds   raised   by   the appellant were neither maintainable nor acceptable in the eyes of the law and the appeal of the appellant deserved to be dismissed by this office.” 5. Both   these   issues   were   considered   by   the   learned Tribunal   while   passing   the   judgment   and   order   dated   3rd October,   2019,   which   is   evident   from   a   plain   reading   of paragraph 5 of the said judgment and order dated 3rd October, 2019. In order to avoid prolixity, we refrain from reproducing the same.

(4) 6. As stated hereinbefore, we do not find any substantial question(s) of law involved in this matter. Rather, the issues are essentially factual in nature. The appeal is, therefore, liable to be dismissed and stands dismissed accordingly. Order Date :­ 18.2.2020 Shahroz (Biswanath Somadder,J.) (Dr. Y.K. Srivastava,J.)

More judgments on Section 148

All 49,222 judgments and leading authorities on Section 148 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →