237 orders · Page 2 of 5
The High Court allowed the writ petition. It acknowledged the admitted facts presented by the Standing Counsel, which established that the refund was granted approximately 15 months after the Trade Tax Tribunal had passed orders directing the refund. The Court found that in view of these admitted facts, the petitioners had become entitled to interest for the delayed payment of the refund. The Court directed the respondent no.3 (Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Tax, Moradabad) to pay interest to the petitioners within two weeks from the date of the order. The rate of interest was to be determined as per the provisions of the applicable Act, namely the U.P. Trade Tax Act, 1948, or the U.P. VAT Tax Act, 2008, as the case may be. The Standing Counsel was instructed to inform the relevant respondents in writing for compliance. No issue was expressly left undecided.
The Tribunal noted the conflicting reassessment orders passed by the National Faceless Assessment Centre concerning co-owners of the same land. It acknowledged the revenue's submission that steps would be taken to remove anomalies and the government's commitment to take action against erring officers. The Tribunal also took note of the CBDT's instructions dated 23.04.2022, issued under Section 119 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, which provide for the constitution and functioning of 'Local Committees to deal with Taxpayers' Grievances from High-Pitched Scrutiny Assessment'. The court observed that such grievances reflect harassment and lead to unproductive work. The Tribunal issued directions in the nature of mandamus to ensure the effective implementation of these instructions, including circulating them to Tax Bar Associations, displaying them on the Income Tax Department's website, publishing them in newspapers, ensuring the constitution and functionality of Local Committees within specified timelines, establishing a monitoring cell, and mandating the disposal of grievance petitions within two months. The writ petition was disposed of with liberty to the petitioner to avail statutory remedies.
The Tribunal held that the conditions enshrined in Clause (d) of Section 148A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, were satisfied for the issuance of the notice under Section 148 of the Act. The court noted that Section 148A(d) requires the Assessing Authority to conduct an enquiry, provide an opportunity of hearing, consider the assessee's reply, and then pass an order on the basis of available material to determine if it is a fit case to issue a notice under Section 148. The judgment states that at this stage, the Assessing Authority is not required to adjudicate on merits but only to ascertain if a notice under Section 148 is warranted. The first proviso to Section 148, which requires information suggesting escaped assessment and prior approval, was implicitly considered satisfied. The Tribunal found no good reason to interfere with the impugned order and directed the petitioner to avail the remedy of raising all available defenses before the Assessing Officer in proceedings under Section 147.
The Tribunal quashed the impugned notice under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, dated March 31, 2021, issued for AY 2014-15, the notice dated January 13, 2022, under Section 144 of the Act, and the reassessment order dated March 31, 2022, under Section 147 read with Section 144B of the Act. The Tribunal's decision was based on the admission made by the learned Additional Solicitor General on behalf of the respondents. The ASG conceded that as per Clause 7.1 of the CBDT's Circular dated May 11, 2022, notices under Section 148 relating to AYs 2013-14, 2014-15, and 2015-16 would not attract the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in *Ashish Agarwal*. Consequently, the impugned notice issued on April 1, 2021, for AY 2014-15 was clearly barred by limitation and therefore without jurisdiction. The Tribunal explicitly stated that in view of this admission, it did not propose to deal with other arguments raised by the petitioner, including the question of conferment of jurisdiction, leaving them open. The writ petition was allowed.
The Tribunal held that in view of the admitted facts and the precedent set by the Division Bench judgment in Daujee Abhushan Bhandar Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Union of India and 2 others, the writ petition deserves to be allowed. The impugned notice under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, issued to the petitioner for the assessment year 2016-17, was quashed. Consequently, if any re-assessment order had been passed pursuant to this notice, it was declared non est and also quashed. The ratio decidendi is that if a controversy is covered by a binding precedent of a coordinate bench, the court should follow it to grant relief. The operative direction was to quash the notice and any consequential order.
The High Court dismissed the writ petition. The Court noted that the petitioner has a right of appeal under Section 246-A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, against the impugned reassessment order. Without expressing any opinion on the merits of the petitioner's case, the Court held that the writ petition was not the appropriate forum for adjudication. The petitioner was left open to file an appeal before the competent authority if they were so advised. No specific findings were made on the validity of the assessment order, reassessment proceedings, or penalty notices, as the petition was disposed of on procedural grounds.
The Tribunal held that the Assessing Authority possessed information regarding a cash deposit of Rs. 2,06,58,500/-, which was not irrelevant or unfounded. Consequently, the jurisdictional notice issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, could not be considered to be without jurisdiction. The Court found no merit in the writ petition. The ratio decidendi is that if the Assessing Authority has some relevant material, even if there are some discrepancies in the initial reporting, it can form a valid belief for issuing a notice under Section 148. The operative direction was to dismiss the writ petition, with liberty granted to the petitioner to challenge the impugned reassessment order dated 29.03.2022 in appeal under Section 246A of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The appellate authority was directed to entertain the appeal if filed within three weeks with a certified copy of the order, without raising objections as to limitation. No issue was expressly left undecided.
The Tribunal held that the respondents admitted that the impugned notice under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, was issued to the petitioner on April 1, 2021, which was after the expiry of the limitation period on March 31, 2021. The respondents also conceded that the controversy was covered by the judgment of this Court in Daujee Abhushan Bhandar Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Union Of India And 2 Others (Writ Tax No.78 of 2022) decided on March 10, 2022. Consequently, the Tribunal disposed of the writ petition in terms of the said judgment. The impugned notice under Section 148 dated March 31, 2021, and the reassessment order dated March 12, 2022, were quashed. The ratio decidendi is that a notice issued under Section 148 beyond the statutory limitation period is void ab initio and liable to be quashed. The operative direction was to quash the notice and the reassessment order.
The Tribunal held that the respondents admitted that the impugned notice under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, was issued to the petitioner on April 1, 2021, which was after the expiry of the limitation period on March 31, 2021. The respondents also conceded that the controversy was covered by the judgment of the Court in Daujee Abhushan Bhandar Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Union Of India. Consequently, the writ petition was disposed of in terms of the said judgment. The impugned notice dated March 31, 2021, and the reassessment order dated March 27, 2022, were quashed. The ratio decidendi is that a notice issued under Section 148 beyond the prescribed limitation period is void ab initio and liable to be quashed.
The Tribunal held that the notice under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, was a jurisdictional notice and the 'reasons to believe' recorded by the Assessing Authority were totally unfounded and not bonafide. Therefore, the notice was without jurisdiction, and the Assessing Authority could not have assumed jurisdiction to issue it. The Tribunal relied on Supreme Court judgments in Commissioner of Income Tax, Delhi vs. Kelvinator of India Ltd. and Radha Krishna Industries vs. State of H.P., emphasizing that reopening of assessment must be based on 'tangible material' and that 'reasons must have a live link with the formation of the belief'. Since the Section 148 notice was quashed, the subsequent reassessment order, which was based on the invalid notice, also deserved to be quashed. The writ petition was allowed, and the impugned notice and reassessment order were quashed. No issue was expressly left undecided.
The High Court noted that the reassessment proceedings were initiated for Assessment Year 2013-14 based on a notice under Section 148 dated March 30, 2021. The Court observed that the limitation for passing the reassessment order for AY 2013-14 had expired on March 31, 2022. The Revenue, through its counsel, admitted that the limitation had not been extended by any statutory provision or Government order. Consequently, no reassessment order could be passed pursuant to the impugned notice. The Court found that for all practical purposes, the writ petition had become infructuous due to the expiry of the limitation period. Therefore, the Court did not delve into the issue of jurisdiction or whether the reassessment was based on a change of opinion. The writ petition was disposed of on the ground of limitation.
The Tribunal held that the reassessment proceedings were initiated without jurisdiction and amounted to a 'change of opinion'. During the regular assessment for AY 2017-18, the Assessing Officer had called for and examined details of cash deposits and other financial information from the petitioner, and after considering these, passed the assessment order. Therefore, initiating reassessment proceedings on the same set of facts, specifically regarding cash deposits, constituted a 'change of opinion', which is not a valid ground for reassessment. The Tribunal further found that the 'reasons to believe' recorded by the Assessing Officer were neither bonafide nor based on reasonable grounds. The reliance on the CBDT Circular dated 04.03.2021 was found to be a blind application without considering the requirement of forming a 'reasonable belief' that income chargeable to tax had escaped assessment, as stipulated in paragraph 3 of the circular. The reassessment order was also found to be arbitrary, lacking any whisper on how the undisclosed income of Rs. 38,83,000/- was arrived at. Consequently, the impugned notice under Section 148 and the reassessment order were quashed. The writ petition was allowed with costs.
The Tribunal's order upholding the penalty was set aside. The Court found that at the time of detention in October 2011, Section 50(2) of the UP VAT Act required registered dealers to carry prescribed declarations or documents, but did not mandate them to be 'duly filled'. The amendment requiring 'duly filled' forms came later. Crucially, the Court reiterated the principle established in M/s Jain Shudh Vanaspati Ltd. (supra) and M/s Rama Pulses (supra), that an intention to evade tax is a necessary ingredient for imposing penalty under the Act. The material on record did not indicate any such intention to evade tax, as all documents were available, and entries were made in the dealer's books. The Court clarified that while incomplete Form-38 might be a ground for seizure, imposing a penalty requires satisfaction that there was an attempt to evade tax, supported by material evidence and a guilty mind. The penalty orders were based on circulars contrary to the Act and a Single Judge decision that was distinguished by a Division Bench. Therefore, the penalty order could not be sustained.
The Tribunal noted that both parties jointly stated that the controversy in the present writ petition is squarely covered by the Division Bench judgment dated September 30, 2021 (as corrected by the order dated October 8, 2021) in Writ Tax No. 524 of 2021 (Ashok Kumar Agarwal Versus Union of India and Ors). Consequently, the impugned notice dated April 13, 2021, was quashed, and the writ petition was disposed of on the same terms and conditions as provided in the judgment of Ashok Kumar Agarwal (supra). The specific reasoning of the Ashok Kumar Agarwal judgment, which would have formed the basis for quashing the notice and the notifications, is not elaborated in this order, but the joint submission indicates it addressed the validity of Section 148 notices issued under the amended provisions and the related notifications. No issue was expressly left undecided.
The learned counsels for both the petitioner and the respondents jointly stated that the controversy in the present writ petition was squarely covered by the Division Bench judgment dated September 30, 2021 (as corrected by the order dated October 8, 2021) in Writ Tax No. 524 of 2021 (Ashok Kumar Agarwal Versus Union of India and Ors). Based on this joint submission, the Court quashed the impugned notice dated April 13, 2021. The writ petition was disposed of on the same terms and conditions as provided in the judgment of Ashok Kumar Agarwal (supra). The specific findings on each issue are implicitly covered by the reliance on the Ashok Kumar Agarwal judgment, which presumably dealt with the validity of Section 148 notices and related explanations issued during the relevant period.
The Tribunal, in view of the joint submission by the learned counsels for both the petitioner and the respondent, quashed the impugned notice dated 28.05.2021 issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The writ petition was disposed of on the same terms and conditions as provided in the Division Bench judgment of Ashok Kumar Agarwal Versus Union of India and Ors. The reasoning was that the controversy was squarely covered by the aforementioned precedent. The operative direction was to quash the notice and dispose of the petition accordingly. No issues were expressly left undecided.
The High Court disposed of the writ petition in terms of the statement made by the learned Senior Standing Counsel for the respondents. The statement indicated that the refund along with interest had been granted to the petitioner. However, there was an ongoing dispute concerning the computation of interest, for which the petitioner had moved an application. This application was being considered afresh by the authority and was expected to be resolved shortly. Therefore, the court did not delve into the merits of the refund claim or the interest computation dispute but relied on the assurance of resolution by the revenue authorities. No specific issue was left undecided, as the court acted upon the statement made by the respondents.
The Tribunal held that the controversy in the present writ petition was squarely covered by a previous judgment of the same Court in Writ Tax No. 78 of 2022 (Daujee Abhushan Bhandar Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Union Of India and 2 Others). Based on this precedent, the Tribunal allowed the writ petition. The reasoning was that the notice, having been issued on 01.04.2021, was beyond the limitation period which expired on 31.03.2021, as confirmed by the respondent's own instructions. Consequently, the impugned notice under Section 148 and the consequential reassessment orders were quashed. The operative direction was to quash the notice and the reassessment orders.
The learned counsels for the parties jointly stated that the controversy involved in the present writ petition is squarely covered by the Division Bench judgment dated 30.09.2021 (as corrected by the order dated 08.10.2021) in Writ Tax No. 524 of 2021 (Ashok Kumar Agarwal Versus Union of India and Ors). In view of this joint statement, the Tribunal quashed the impugned notice and disposed of the writ petition on the same terms and conditions as provided in the judgment of Ashok Kumar Agarwal (supra). The specific reasoning or ratio decidendi from the Ashok Kumar Agarwal judgment that led to this decision is not detailed in this order, but it implies that the grounds for challenging the reassessment proceedings in the present case were identical to those decided in the cited precedent. The operative direction was to quash the impugned notice and dispose of the petition.
The Tribunal, in view of the joint statement made by the learned counsels for the parties, quashed the impugned notice under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The writ petition was disposed of on the same terms and conditions as provided in the judgment of Ashok Kumar Agarwal (supra). The reasoning was that both parties agreed that the controversy was squarely covered by the Division Bench judgment in Ashok Kumar Agarwal. Consequently, the impugned notice was held to be without jurisdiction, and the subsequent assessment order was also quashed. The ratio decidendi is that if a notice under Section 148 is found to be without jurisdiction, as per a binding precedent, it should be quashed, and the writ petition disposed of accordingly. The operative direction was to quash the notice and dispose of the writ petition.
The Tribunal noted that the respondent no. 2 had produced an order dated 06.04.2022, which was addressed to the Officer In-charge of Sarai Inayat Police Station, Prayagraj. This order explicitly stated that no adverse view had been taken under the Income-tax Act, 1961, and no further proceedings were pending. Consequently, the order directed the police station to take necessary steps for the release of the seized cash amounting to Rs. 1,74,140/- to the petitioner at the earliest. The Tribunal observed that in view of this action taken by the respondent no. 2, the relief sought by the petitioner in the writ petition had already been granted. Therefore, no cause of action survived, and the writ petition was disposed of. The Tribunal did not expressly leave any issue undecided.
The Allahabad High Court, in view of the joint statement made by the learned counsels for the parties, quashed the impugned notice dated April 13, 2021, issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The Court also disposed of the writ petition on the same terms and conditions as provided in the judgment of Ashok Kumar Agarwal (supra). This implies that the reassessment proceedings initiated by the impugned notice were set aside, and the challenge to the CBDT notifications was also decided in line with the precedent. The reasoning is based on the applicability of the Ashok Kumar Agarwal judgment, which presumably dealt with similar issues concerning reassessment notices issued under the amended provisions and the validity of related CBDT notifications. The operative direction was to quash the notice and dispose of the petition accordingly.
The Tribunal, in view of the joint statement made by the learned counsels for the parties, quashed the impugned notice dated 05.04.2021 issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, for AY 2015-16. The writ petition was disposed of on the same terms and conditions as provided in the Division Bench judgment dated 30.09.2021 (as corrected by the order dated 08.10.2021) in Writ Tax No. 524 of 2021 (Ashok Kumar Agarwal Versus Union of India and Ors). The reasoning was that the controversy in the present writ petition was squarely covered by the aforementioned judgment. The operative direction was to quash the notice and dispose of the petition accordingly. No issues were expressly left undecided.
The High Court held that judicial discipline and propriety require subordinate authorities to follow orders of higher appellate authorities unreservedly, unless their operation has been suspended by a competent court. The mere fact that an order is not acceptable to the department or is the subject matter of an appeal or SLP does not furnish a ground for not following it. The Court cited judgments from the Supreme Court and various High Courts, including the Bombay High Court in M/s Associated Cables Pvt. Ltd., emphasizing that filing an SLP does not make a High Court order bad in law or give a license to the revenue to proceed as if the order is stayed or in abeyance. Consequently, the impugned notice dated March 31, 2021, issued on April 1, 2021, under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, was held to be without jurisdiction and quashed. The consequential reassessment order dated March 29, 2022, and the order rejecting objections dated March 19, 2022, were also quashed as the jurisdictional notice was invalid. The Court directed the respondents to maintain judicial discipline and follow the doctrine of binding precedent. The writ petition was allowed.
The High Court held that the petitioner has an alternative remedy of appeal under Section 246-A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, against the impugned reassessment order dated 30.03.2022. The Court noted that the 'reason to believe' for initiating reassessment proceedings existed, as the information available to the respondents was not irrelevant, arbitrary, or extraneous. The Court did not delve into the merits of the petitioner's arguments regarding 'change of opinion' or the validity of the subsequent notices and assessment order, as the primary ground for dismissal was the availability of an alternative statutory remedy. Therefore, the writ petition was dismissed on the ground of alternative remedy.
The Tribunal held that the 'reason to believe' recorded by the assessing authority failed to meet the standard of an honest and prudent person acting on reasonable grounds and arriving at a cogent conclusion. The reasons were found to be totally unfounded. Consequently, the jurisdictional notice issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, was deemed to be without jurisdiction. The Tribunal relied on Supreme Court judgments in State of Uttar Pradesh & Others vs. Aryaverth Chawal Udyog & Others and The Commissioner of Sales-Tax U.P. vs. M/s. Bhagwan Industries (P) Ltd., Lucknow, emphasizing that the material on which the assessing authority bases its opinion must not be arbitrary, irrational, vague, distant, or irrelevant, and must have a rational connection to the formation of the belief. Since the notice under Section 148 was without jurisdiction, all subsequent proceedings, including the reassessment order and demand notice, could not be sustained. The Tribunal quashed the impugned notice dated 31.03.2021, the order dated 09.03.2021 rejecting the objection, the reassessment order dated 31.03.2022, and the demand notice dated 31.03.2022. The writ petition was allowed with costs.
The Tribunal noted that the learned counsels for both parties jointly stated that the controversy involved in the present writ petition was squarely covered by the Division Bench judgment dated September 30, 2021 (as corrected by the order dated October 8, 2021) in Writ Tax No. 524 of 2021 (Ashok Kumar Agarwal Versus Union of India and Ors). Consequently, in view of the joint statement, the Tribunal quashed the impugned notice dated June 25, 2021, and disposed of the writ petition on the same terms and conditions as provided in the judgment of Ashok Kumar Agarwal (supra). The specific findings on each issue were not detailed as the decision was based on the precedent and joint submission. The operative direction was to quash the notice and dispose of the petition.
The Tribunal held that the impugned notice under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, dated March 31, 2021, was issued without jurisdiction. The reasoning was based on the admitted facts from the respondents' short counter-affidavit, which stated that the automated triggering of the email for the notice occurred on April 1, 2021, at 05:30:08 AM. Since the limitation period for issuing the notice for Assessment Year 2013-14 expired on March 31, 2021, a notice triggered and delivered on April 1, 2021, was considered beyond the statutory time limit. The Tribunal relied on its prior judgment in Writ-Tax No. 78 of 2022 (Daujee Abhushan Bhandar Pvt. Ltd. vs. Union of India & 2 Ors.) for this conclusion. Consequently, the writ petition was allowed, and the impugned notice and any consequential re-assessment order were quashed.
The Allahabad High Court, in view of the joint statement made by the learned counsels for the parties, held that the controversy involved in the writ petition is squarely covered by the Division Bench judgment dated September 30, 2021 (as corrected by the order dated October 8, 2021) in Writ Tax No. 524 of 2021 (Ashok Kumar Agarwal Versus Union of India and Ors). Consequently, the impugned notice dated April 6, 2021, issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, for Assessment Year 2015-16, was hereby quashed. The writ petition was disposed of on the same terms and conditions as provided in the Ashok Kumar Agarwal judgment. The court did not separately address the constitutional validity of the notifications, as the matter was resolved based on the precedent.
The High Court, in view of the joint statement made by the learned counsels for the parties, held that the controversy involved in the present writ petition is squarely covered by the Division Bench judgment dated 30.09.2021 (as corrected by the order dated 08.10.2021) in Writ Tax No. 524 of 2021 (Ashok Kumar Agarwal Versus Union of India and Ors). Consequently, the impugned notice dated 29.06.2021 was quashed. The writ petition was disposed of on the same terms and conditions as provided in the aforementioned judgment of Ashok Kumar Agarwal. The specific findings on the constitutionality of the explanations or the validity of the notice under Section 148, beyond their being covered by the precedent, are not detailed in this order, as the parties agreed to dispose of the matter based on the prior judgment.
The Tribunal held that the order of the two authorities below (First Appellate Authority and Tribunal) were findings of fact. The learned Standing Counsel for the revisionist could not rebut the submissions made by the respondent's counsel that for inter-State purchases made for and on behalf of an Ex. U.P. principle, there is no liability of tax. This proposition of law is supported by the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Commissioner of Sales Tax and others vs. M/s Bakhtawar Lal Kailash Chand Arthi and others reported in 1992 U.P.T.C. 971. Consequently, the High Court was of the view that no substantial question of law was involved in the present revision. The revision was dismissed.
The Tribunal held that neither the notice issued under Section 148 nor the order rejecting the petitioner's objection suffered from any illegality or infirmity. The reasons recorded by the assessing authority indicated that the information received from the Investigating Wing was independently verified by the assessing officer, who perused the assessee's return and a statement recorded on oath. This led to an independent conclusion that the assessee had made a significant cash payment for property purchase, indicating escapement of income. The Tribunal noted that the reasons for reopening were not based on books of account or documents seized in the search of M/s Celebrations City Projects (P) Ltd., and therefore, Section 153C was not applicable. The Tribunal also referred to Explanation 2(b) to Section 147, stating that if a return was filed but no assessment was made, and the assessing officer noticed understated income, it would be deemed a case of escaped assessment. Consequently, the writ petition was dismissed, with liberty to the assessing authority to proceed with reassessment proceedings.
The Tribunal noted the joint submission by the learned counsels for both the petitioner and the respondent that the controversy involved in the present writ petition is squarely covered by the Division Bench judgment dated 30.09.2021 (as corrected by the order dated 08.10.2021) in Writ Tax No. 524 of 2021 (Ashok Kumar Agarwal Versus Union of India and Ors). In view of this joint statement, the Tribunal quashed the impugned notice dated 16.06.2021 issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, and the consequential notice dated 27.09.2021 under Section 143(2) of the Act, along with the connected reassessment proceedings for AY 2013-14. The writ petition was disposed of on the same terms and conditions as provided in the judgment of Ashok Kumar Agarwal (supra). The specific reasoning or ratio decidendi from the Ashok Kumar Agarwal judgment was not elaborated upon in this order, as it was relied upon by consent.
The Tribunal noted the joint submission by both the petitioner and the revenue that the controversy in the present writ petition was squarely covered by the Division Bench judgment dated 30.09.2021 (as corrected by the order dated 08.10.2021) in Writ Tax No. 524 of 2021 (Ashok Kumar Agarwal Versus Union of India and Ors). Consequently, in view of this joint statement, the Tribunal quashed the impugned notice dated 29.06.2021 issued under Section 148 of the Act. The writ petition was disposed of on the same terms and conditions as provided in the judgment of Ashok Kumar Agarwal (supra). The reasoning for quashing the notice and disposing of the petition is based on the precedent established in the Ashok Kumar Agarwal case, which addressed similar issues concerning reassessment proceedings and the validity of CBDT notifications.
The Court noted the joint submission by the learned counsels for the petitioner and the respondents that the controversy in the present writ petition was squarely covered by the Division Bench judgment dated 30.09.2021 (as corrected by the order dated 08.10.2021) in Writ Tax No. 524 of 2021 (Ashok Kumar Agarwal Versus Union of India and Ors). Consequently, in view of this joint statement, the impugned notice dated 23.06.2021 was hereby quashed. The writ petition was disposed of on the same terms and conditions as provided in the judgment of Ashok Kumar Agarwal (supra). The specific reasoning from the Ashok Kumar Agarwal judgment, which would have formed the basis for quashing the notice and proceedings, was not detailed in this order but was implicitly adopted.
The Tribunal noted that both parties jointly stated that the controversy in the present writ petition was squarely covered by the Division Bench judgment dated September 30, 2021 (as corrected by the order dated October 8, 2021) in Writ Tax No. 524 of 2021 (Ashok Kumar Agarwal Versus Union of India and Ors). Consequently, the impugned notice was quashed, and the writ petition was disposed of on the same terms and conditions as provided in the judgment of Ashok Kumar Agarwal. The reasoning for quashing the notice and proceedings would be based on the findings in the Ashok Kumar Agarwal case, which addressed similar challenges to reassessment notices issued under the amended provisions and the validity of related CBDT notifications. The operative direction was to quash the notice and dispose of the petition accordingly.
The High Court, in view of the joint statement made by the learned counsels for the parties, held that the controversy involved in the writ petition is squarely covered by the Division Bench judgment dated 30.09.2021 (as corrected by the order dated 08.10.2021) in Writ Tax No. 524 of 2021 (Ashok Kumar Agarwal Versus Union of India and Ors). Consequently, the Court quashed the impugned notice dated 23.06.2021 issued under Section 148 of the Act. The writ petition was disposed of on the same terms and conditions as provided in the judgment of Ashok Kumar Agarwal (supra). The reasoning is based on the parties' consensus that the precedent judgment was directly applicable, thus obviating the need for an independent adjudication of the issues raised. The operative direction was to quash the notice and dispose of the petition.
The learned counsels for both the petitioner and the respondents jointly stated that the controversy involved in the present writ petition is squarely covered by the Division Bench judgment dated September 30, 2021 (as corrected by the order dated October 8, 2021) in Writ Tax No. 524 of 2021 (Ashok Kumar Agarwal Versus Union of India and Ors). In view of this joint statement, the Tribunal quashed the impugned notice dated April 6, 2021, issued under Section 148 of the Act. The writ petition was disposed of on the same terms and conditions as provided in the judgment of Ashok Kumar Agarwal (supra). The specific findings on the validity of the explanations to the notifications or the reassessment proceedings themselves were not elaborated upon, as the decision was based on the precedent cited by both parties.
The Tribunal held that the impugned notice under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, was issued within the period of limitation. The reasoning was based on the certificate from the Senior Superintendent of Post Office, Ghaziabad, dated 30.04.2022, which certified that article No. EU362756858IN was booked from Speed Post Center BNPL, Ghaziabad, on 31.03.2021, and was the notice issued to the petitioner. The track consignment report, filed with an earlier counter-affidavit, showed that this article was delivered to the petitioner on 01.04.2021. Therefore, the issuance date of 31.03.2021 was considered well within time. Consequently, the sole argument of the petitioner that the notice was issued beyond the period of limitation on 01.04.2021 was rejected. The writ petition was dismissed, with the petitioner left open to participate in the reassessment proceedings. No other issues were expressly left undecided.
The High Court held that the writ petition was not maintainable. The Court observed that the dispute appeared to be primarily a family matter, with the tax evasion allegations arising from discord between family members. Consequently, the Court found that such a writ petition was not entertainable in the given circumstances. No specific directions were issued regarding the tax evasion allegations or the representation, as the petition itself was dismissed on grounds of maintainability. The Court did not decide on the merits of the tax evasion claims.
The Tribunal, in view of the joint statement made by the learned counsels for both the petitioner and the respondent, quashed the impugned notice dated 5.4.2021. The writ petition was disposed of on the same terms and conditions as provided in the Division Bench judgment of Ashok Kumar Agarwal Versus Union of India and Ors. The reasoning is based on the parties' consensus that the present case is squarely covered by the precedent. The operative direction is to quash the notice and dispose of the writ petition accordingly. No issue was expressly left undecided.
The Tribunal held that the writ petitions were frivolous and not entertainable. Regarding the challenge to the assessment orders, the Tribunal noted that the petitioners had filed appeals under Section 246A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, which were pending. Therefore, the challenge to the assessment orders could not be entertained through writ petitions. Concerning the challenge to the orders passed on stay applications, the Tribunal observed that the petitioners had filed applications in terms of paragraph 4(C) of the Office Memorandum/Circular dated 29.02.2016, which were pending before the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax. The Tribunal concluded that challenging orders on stay applications via writ petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution of India was not permissible under these circumstances. Consequently, all writ petitions were dismissed.
The Court noted that the petitioner had consented to the order passed under Section 127(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, dated 15.03.2022, which empowered the DCIT, Central Circle, Bareilly, to exercise the powers of the assessing officer. Consequently, the relief sought to quash the impugned order (Relief No. 1) was no longer surviving. For the remaining reliefs (Nos. 2 and 3), the Court observed that the petitioner had already filed an application under Section 132B of the Act on 23.04.2021, which was pending. The Revenue assured that this application would be considered by the competent authorities in accordance with law and an appropriate order would be passed within a time-bound period. The Court, with the consent of both parties, disposed of the writ petition by directing the respondents to decide the petitioner's application dated 23.04.2021, under Section 132B, expeditiously, preferably within two months. The Court explicitly stated that it had not expressed any opinion on the merits of the petitioner's case.
The High Court, in view of the joint statement made by the learned counsels for the parties, quashed the impugned notice dated June 30, 2021, issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. Consequently, the writ petition was disposed of on the same terms and conditions as provided in the Division Bench judgment of Ashok Kumar Agarwal Versus Union of India and Ors. The reasoning was that the controversy was squarely covered by the precedent case. The operative direction was to quash the notice and dispose of the writ petition accordingly. No specific issue was left undecided, as the matter was resolved based on the agreed precedent.
The Tribunal noted that both the learned counsel for the petitioner and the learned counsel for the respondents jointly stated that the controversy involved in the writ petition was squarely covered by the Division Bench judgment dated 30.09.2021 (as corrected by the order dated 08.10.2021) in Writ Tax No. 524 of 2021 (Ashok Kumar Agarwal Versus Union of India and Ors). Consequently, in view of this joint statement, the impugned notice dated 28.06.2021 was quashed. The writ petition was disposed of on the same terms and conditions as provided in the judgment of Ashok Kumar Agarwal (supra). The specific reasoning from the Ashok Kumar Agarwal judgment, which would have formed the basis for quashing the notice and the reassessment proceedings, is not detailed in this order, but the principle applied is that the present case falls under the precedent set by the Division Bench.
The Tribunal noted the joint submission by the learned counsels for both parties that the controversy in the present writ petition was squarely covered by the Division Bench judgment dated September 30, 2021 (as corrected by the order dated October 8, 2021) in Writ Tax No. 524 of 2021 (Ashok Kumar Agarwal Versus Union of India and Ors). Based on this joint statement, the Tribunal quashed the impugned notice dated April 5, 2021. The writ petition was disposed of on the same terms and conditions as provided in the Ashok Kumar Agarwal judgment. The specific findings on the ultra vires nature of the notifications were not elaborated upon in this order, as the decision was based on the precedent. The operative direction was to quash the notice and dispose of the petition in terms of the cited judgment.
The Tribunal held that the impugned notices under Section 148 of the Act could not be considered without jurisdiction or bad in law. The reasoning was based on the perusal of the reasons recorded by the Assessing Authority and the approval granted by the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax. The Tribunal found that prima facie, there was relevant material available to the Assessing Authority indicating escapement of income. Consequently, the Tribunal found no good reason to interfere with the notices. The operative direction was to dismiss all the writ petitions. The petitioners were granted liberty to challenge the reassessment orders in appeal under Section 246A of the Act, if advised, and to raise all available objections to those orders. Any observations made in the order were clarified not to impede the petitioners' right to appeal.
The Tribunal noted the joint submission by the learned counsels for both the petitioner and the respondent that the controversy involved in the writ petition was squarely covered by the Division Bench judgment dated 30.09.2021 (as corrected by the order dated 08.10.2021) in Writ Tax No. 524 of 2021 (Ashok Kumar Agarwal Versus Union of India and Ors). Based on this joint statement, the Tribunal quashed the impugned notice dated 16.06.2021. The writ petition was disposed of on the same terms and conditions as provided in the judgment of Ashok Kumar Agarwal (supra). The specific findings on the validity of the notifications or the reassessment proceedings themselves, beyond their being covered by the cited precedent, were not detailed as the parties agreed to dispose of the matter based on the prior judgment.
The Tribunal, in view of the joint statement made by the learned counsels for the parties, quashed the impugned notice dated 26.04.2021 issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act for Assessment Years 2013-14, 2015-16 and 2017-18. The writ petition was disposed of on the same terms and conditions as provided in the judgment of Ashok Kumar Agarwal (supra). The reasoning is based on the concession by both parties that the present case is squarely covered by the precedent case. The operative direction is the quashing of the notice and disposal of the writ petition.
The Tribunal, in view of the joint statement made by the learned counsels for both parties, quashed the impugned notice dated 25.6.2021 issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act for Assessment Year 2016-17. The writ petition was disposed of on the same terms and conditions as provided in the Division Bench judgment dated 30.09.2021 (as corrected by the order dated 08.10.2021) in Writ Tax No. 524 of 2021 (Ashok Kumar Agarwal Versus Union of India and Ors). The specific reasoning or ratio decidendi from the Ashok Kumar Agarwal case was not elaborated upon in this judgment, other than stating that the present case was squarely covered by it. No issue was expressly left undecided.