23 orders · Page 1 of 1
The High Court held that the Assessing Officer (AO) cannot resort to reassessment proceedings solely for verification purposes, as there is a distinction between 'reason to believe' and 'reason to suspect'. The AO's recorded reasons explicitly stated that the sale transactions 'need to be verified', which indicates a 'reason to suspect' rather than a 'reason to believe' that income had escaped assessment. This aligns with established legal principles that reassessment proceedings must be based on a genuine belief of escaped income, not a fishing or roving inquiry. The Court cited *Income Tax Officer Versus Lakhmani Mewal Das* and its own previous ruling in *Naveen Kumar Jaiswal Versus Income Tax Department* to emphasize that reasons for reopening must be clear, unambiguous, and not vague, and cannot be supplemented by affidavits or oral submissions. The ITAT's reliance on *Principal Commissioner of Income-tax-5 versus Manzil Dinesh Kumar Shah* and *Principle Commissioner of Income-tax, Versus Sheetal Dushyant Chaturvedi* was found to be correct. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed on the sole ground that the AO lacked sufficient reason to believe for initiating reassessment.
The High Court held that the date of completion of training and the subsequent order confirming the Sub-Inspectors in service are the crucial dates for determining inter-se seniority. The Court found that the Jharkhand Police Manual does not leave the question of seniority to general principles but deals with it specifically through Rule 689(c). Rule 682(d) also excludes the period of training/probation for seniority calculation, except for pension. The Court distinguished the judgments cited by the respondents, emphasizing the specific provisions within the Police Manual regarding the importance of training completion and confirmation. The Court noted that while private respondents were appointed earlier, their training completion and confirmation were later than the direct recruits. The Court found neither the petitioners' nor the respondents' arguments regarding delays in appointment or training completion persuasive, stating such delays are common in administration. The critical factor is the determination of seniority based on existing rules. Consequently, the impugned seniority list dated September 9, 2024, was quashed and set aside. The respondents were directed to re-arrange and publish a final seniority list treating direct recruit candidates as senior to LDCE candidates, with an exception for direct recruits whose probation was extended, in which case their seniority would be fixed from their confirmation date. This exercise was to be completed within ten weeks.
The High Court held that the ITAT's order did not require interference. The Court noted that while there is no bar to initiating two proceedings under Section 263 for the same assessment year if within the time limit, the PCIT lacks jurisdiction to cancel an assessment order that has already been cancelled in a prior Section 263 proceeding. The first assessment order dated December 28, 2016, was cancelled by the first Section 263 order dated December 29, 2017. However, the second Section 263 order dated March 28, 2019, erroneously cancelled the non-existent first assessment order, while the second assessment order dated December 31, 2018, remained valid. The Court found that the PCIT's second Section 263 exercise was to re-examine issues already examined by the Assessing Officer twice. The ITAT rightly held that directing the Assessing Officer to scrutinize the same expenses for a third time was not permissible. The High Court confirmed the ITAT's order, dismissing the revenue's appeal as no substantial question of law was involved. The third assessment order dated December 28, 2019, was held to have no legal effect.
The High Court held that the ITAT had committed a gross error by failing to consider the reassessment order dated 15.12.2017, which was the subject matter of the appeal before it. Instead, the ITAT focused on the initial assessment order dated 31.03.2016 and quashed it based on a decision in the case of Kamendra Mishra, which dealt with the initial assessment. The ITAT did not discuss the facts or legality of the reassessment order dated 15.12.2017, nor did it expressly quash it. However, by allowing the appeal that stemmed from the CIT(Appeals) order upholding the reassessment order, the ITAT's decision adversely affected the validity of the reassessment order. The Court found the ITAT's order to be perverse as it was made on technical grounds without considering the relevant facts of the reassessment order. Therefore, the interest of justice demanded that the impugned ITAT order be quashed and the matter remitted back to the ITAT for a fresh decision on merits after verifying all aspects of the case. The questions of law were decided in favour of the revenue.
The High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi allowed the prayer made by the learned counsel for the Appellant-Revenue. The Court noted that the Revenue sought permission to withdraw the appeals on instructions, citing that the tax effect of the disputed amount fell below the monetary limit for preferring appeals before the High Court, in terms of CBDT Circular No. 17 of 2019 read with CBDT Circular No. 3 of 2018. The Court also granted liberty to the appellant to avail of alternative remedies as permissible in law. Consequently, the appeals were dismissed as withdrawn. The specific findings on the merits of the original dispute are not part of this order as the appeals were withdrawn.
The High Court allowed the prayer made on behalf of the appellant. The Court noted that the appellant sought permission to withdraw the appeal based on written instructions. The reason provided was that the tax effect of the disputed amount was less than the monetary limit for preferring an appeal before the High Court, in terms of revised circular no. 3/2018 of CBDT, and the case did not fall into any of the exceptions prescribed in Para 10 of the said Circular. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed as withdrawn. No decision was made on the merits of the case.
The High Court allowed the prayer made on behalf of the appellant. The Court noted that the appellant sought permission to withdraw the appeal based on written instructions. These instructions indicated that the tax effect of the disputed amount was below the monetary limit for preferring an appeal before the High Court, as per revised circular no. 3/2018 of CBDT, New Delhi, and that the case did not fall within the exceptions mentioned in Para 10 of the circular. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed as withdrawn. Any pending interlocutory applications were also closed. No decision on the merits of the case was made.
The High Court considered the prayer made by the learned counsel for the appellant (Revenue) to withdraw the appeal. The Revenue's request was based on the fact that the tax effect of the disputed amount was below the revised monetary limit for preferring appeals before the High Court, as stipulated by CBDT Circular No. 3/2018, and the case did not meet any of the exceptions outlined in Para 10 of that Circular. The Court found no reason to disallow the withdrawal. Therefore, the High Court acceded to the request. The appeal was dismissed as withdrawn. No decision was made on the merits of the underlying tax dispute.
The High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi decided to dismiss the appeal as withdrawn. The court granted the prayer made on behalf of the appellant (the revenue) to withdraw the appeal. The reasoning was based on the petitioner's submission that they had received instructions to withdraw the appeal due to the tax effect being below the monetary limit prescribed by CBDT Circular No. 3/2018 for filing appeals before the High Court. The operative direction was the dismissal of the appeal as withdrawn. No issue was left undecided as the appeal was disposed of on procedural grounds.
The High Court granted the appellant's prayer to withdraw the appeal. The Court noted that the learned counsel for the appellant sought permission to withdraw the appeal on instruction, citing that the tax effect of the disputed amount was less than the monetary limit for preferring appeals before the High Court, in terms of CBDT Circular No. 03/2018. The Court directed that the instructions contained in the email sent to the Court be kept on record. Consequently, the instant appeal was dismissed as withdrawn. No substantive issues were decided on merits.
The High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi held that the appeal should be dismissed as withdrawn. This decision was based on the submission made by the learned counsel for the appellant, who sought permission to withdraw the appeal on written instructions. The reason for withdrawal was that the tax effect of the disputed amount was below the monetary limit for preferring an appeal before the High Court, as per CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. The Court directed that a copy of the email containing the instructions be kept on record. Consequently, the instant appeal was dismissed as withdrawn. No specific issue regarding the merits of the original assessment or the order under challenge was decided.
The High Court allowed the prayer of the learned counsel for the appellant (Revenue) to withdraw the appeal. The Court noted that the tax effect of the disputed amount was below the monetary limit for preferring an appeal before the High Court, in terms of CBDT Circular No. 3/2018. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed as withdrawn. No decision on the merits of the case was rendered. The operative direction was to dismiss the appeal as withdrawn.
The High Court granted liberty to the appellant (Income Tax Department) to file a review petition before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, if permissible in law, concerning the issues related to the levy of interest. In view of the prayer made by the appellant for withdrawal of the appeals, the High Court dismissed the instant appeals as withdrawn. The specific findings on the merits of the original dispute, if any, were not decided as the appeals were withdrawn. The ratio decidendi is that appeals can be withdrawn if the tax effect falls below the prescribed monetary limit, with liberty granted for further review on specific issues if legally permissible.
The High Court granted liberty to the appellant (Income Tax Department) to file a review petition before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, if permissible in law, concerning the issues related to the levy of interest. In view of the prayer made by the appellant for withdrawal of the appeals, the High Court dismissed the instant appeals as withdrawn. The specific findings on the merits of the original dispute, if any, were not decided as the appeals were withdrawn. The ratio decidendi is that appeals can be withdrawn if the tax effect falls below the prescribed monetary limit, with liberty granted for further review on specific issues if legally permissible.
The High Court dismissed the application for condonation of delay (I.A. No.9505 of 2019) and consequently dismissed the Letters Patent Appeal (L.P.A No.42 of 2019). The primary reason for dismissal was the lack of justification in the application for condonation of delay. The Court found no adequate explanation for the significant delay of 1133 days, noting the absence of specific details regarding the "adverse situations" and the mobilization of resources. Furthermore, the Court examined the merits to form a prima facie opinion. It held that the cause of action, which involves proving a forced resignation from an employer in Gujarat, did not vest territorial jurisdiction in the Jharkhand High Court, despite the issuance of a provisional certificate from Dhanbad. The Court reasoned that merely because a provisional certificate was issued from Dhanbad, it did not grant jurisdiction to the Jharkhand High Court to entertain the writ petition. The operative direction was the dismissal of both the delay condonation application and the appeal.
The High Court granted liberty to the appellant to file a review petition before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, if permissible in law, concerning the issues relating to the levy of interest. In view of the prayer made by the appellant for withdrawal of the appeal, the High Court dismissed the instant appeal as withdrawn. The primary reason for withdrawal was the tax effect being below the prescribed monetary limit for appeals, as per CBDT Circular No. 23/2019. The court did not decide on the merits of the case. The issue of whether the appellant is entitled to file a review petition was addressed by granting liberty to do so, subject to legal permissibility.
The High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi, in view of the submissions made by the learned counsel for the appellant, dismissed the instant appeal as withdrawn. The appellant was granted liberty to move before the learned ITAT in accordance with law. The specific findings on the merits of the case or the original dispute are not recorded as the appeal was withdrawn. The ratio decidendi of this decision pertains to the procedural aspect of appeal maintainability based on tax effect and the court's power to allow withdrawal with liberty to approach the appropriate forum.
The High Court allowed the appellant's prayer to withdraw the appeal. The court noted that the learned counsel for the respondent did not object to the withdrawal. Consequently, the instant appeal was dismissed as withdrawn. The court granted the appellant liberty to prefer a review application before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Ranchi Bench, Ranchi, if permissible in law. The court clarified that it is up to the appellant to seek a review of the impugned order. The interlocutory application (I.A. No. 4221 of 2021) was also closed. No decision was made on the merits of the case.
The High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi allowed the Revenue's prayer to withdraw the appeal. The Court noted that the learned counsel for the appellant Income Tax Department sought permission to withdraw the appeal in view of internal instructions dated 25.02.2022 issued by the Principal C.I.T, Dhanbad, stating that the tax effect for preferring the appeal was Rs. 78,63,030/- including interest and penalty. The Court also noted that the learned counsel for the respondent did not object to this prayer. Consequently, the instant appeal was dismissed as withdrawn. No decision was made on the merits of the case.