THE PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX vs. SRI RAVINDRA KUMAR PROPRIETOR OF MAA GAYATRI

PDF · subscribers
T.A./42/2019HC JharkhandJHHC01029459201924 March 2022Bench: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE APARESH KUMAR SINGH,HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK ROSHAN3 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court dismissed the application for condonation of delay (I.A. No.9505 of 2019) and consequently dismissed the Letters Patent Appeal (L.P.A No.42 of 2019). The primary reason for dismissal was the lack of justification in the application for condonation of delay. The Court found no adequate explanation for the significant delay of 1133 days, noting the absence of specific details regarding the "adverse situations" and the mobilization of resources. Furthermore, the Court examined the merits to form a prima facie opinion. It held that the cause of action, which involves proving a forced resignation from an employer in Gujarat, did not vest territorial jurisdiction in the Jharkhand High Court, despite the issuance of a provisional certificate from Dhanbad. The Court reasoned that merely because a provisional certificate was issued from Dhanbad, it did not grant jurisdiction to the Jharkhand High Court to entertain the writ petition. The operative direction was the dismissal of both the delay condonation application and the appeal.

What were the facts?

The appellant, Manoranjan Kumar Singh, filed a Letters Patent Appeal (LPA) No. 42 of 2019 before the Jharkhand High Court, seeking to condone a delay of 1133 days in filing the appeal. The appeal was against an order that dismissed his writ petition (W.P(S) No.78 of 2015) on the grounds of lack of territorial jurisdiction. The appellant cited adverse situations and paucity of money as reasons for the delay. The writ petition was filed challenging a forced resignation from his employer, Gujarat Mineral Development Corporation Ltd., located in Ahmedabad, Gujarat. The appellant contended that the issuance of a Competency Certificate by the Board of Mining Examination in Dhanbad, Jharkhand, conferred territorial jurisdiction on the Jharkhand High Court.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the High Court of Jharkhand has territorial jurisdiction to entertain W.P(S) No.78 of 2015, considering the cause of action arose from a forced resignation by an employer located in Gujarat and the issuance of a provisional certificate from Dhanbad. Assessee's Arguments: - The appellant argued that the Competency Certificate was issued by respondent no.2 (Board of Mining Examination, Dhanbad), and a prayer was made to affirm its validity. This, he contended, established territorial jurisdiction for the Jharkhand High Court. He relied on Supreme Court judgments such as Kusum Ingots & Alloys Ltd. v. Union of India & Anr., Om Prakash Srivastava v. Union of India & Anr., Rajendran Chingaravelu v. R.K. Mishra, Additional Commissioner of Income Tax & Ors., and Nawal Kishore Sharma v. Union of India to support his claim of having a good case on merits. Revenue's Arguments: - The revenue did not explicitly record arguments in the judgment. However, the High Court's decision implies that the revenue likely supported the dismissal of the writ petition on jurisdictional grounds.

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI (Letters Patent Appellate Jurisdiction) L.P.A No. 42 of 2019 Manoranjan Kumar Singh, s/o Ramyatan Prasad Singh, r/o Flat No.SE-2, Annoda Apartment, South Office Para, PO & PS-Doranda, District-Ranchi (Jharkhand) .… Appellant

Versus 1. The Union of India through the Secretary of Ministry of Labour and Employment, New Delhi 2. The Chairman, Board of Mining Examination, Constituted under Coal Mines Regulation 1957, Directorate General of Mine Safety, Dhanbad. P.O- Dhanbad & P.S - Dhanbad, District- Dhanbad (Jharkhand) 3. The Managing Director Gujarat Mineral Development Corporation Ltd. Khanij Bhavan, Near University Ground, 132 ft, Ring Road, Ahmedabad, Gujarat 4. The General Manager(P&A),Gujarat Mineral Development Corporation Ltd. 132ft Ring Road, Khanij Bhavan, University Ground, Ahmedabad, Gujarat. 5. The General Manager (L&P) of Gujarat Mineral Development corporation 132 ft. Ring Road, Near University Ground,Vestrapur, Ahmedabad, Gujarat 6. The Manager (P) of Gujarat Mineral Development Corporation Ltd. Lignite Project Panandhro, Kutch (Bhuj), Gujarat .....Respondents --------------

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SHREE CHANDRASHEKHAR HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RATNAKER BHENGRA For the Appellant : Mr. Harendra Kumar Singh, Advocate

Mr. Dharmendra Kr. Maltiyar, Advocate For the Union of India : Mr. Devanand Kumar, C.G.C

---------------

O R D E R

18th May 2023 Per, Shree Chandrashekhar, J. I.A. No.9505 of 2019 This application has been filed under section 5 of the Limitation Act seeking condonation of delay of 1133 days in filing L.P.A No.42 of 2019. 2. Mr. Harendra Kumar Singh, the learned counsel for the applicant states that on account of adverse situations and paucity of money the applicant could not file this Letters Patent Appeal within the period of limitation.

2 L.P.A No.42 of 2019 3. The applicant has stated as under: “4. That the petitioner accepting this judgment as final as his ill fate, started to manage money in his adversity to file this case in the Gujrat High Court but he could not succeed to manage money in time in his state of adversity.” 4. However, we do not find any explanation whatsoever indicated in this application for condonation of delay as to what were those adverse situations and when, how and from whom he mobilized resources for filing the present Letters Patent Appeal.

5.

The applicant has also referred to several judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court including “Kusum Ingots & Alloys Ltd. v. Union of India & Anr.” (2004) 6 SCC 254, “Om Prakash Srivastava v. Union of India & Anr.” (2006) 6 SCC 207, “Rajendran Chingaravelu v. R.K. Mishra, Additional Commissioner of Income Tax & Ors.” (2010) 1 SCC 457 and “Nawal Kishore Sharma v. Union of India” (2014) 9 SCC 329 to support his stand that he has a good case on merits. 6. We have also examined the matter on merits to form a prima- facie opinion whether the applicant would suffer irreparable loss if delay in filing this Letters Patent Appeal is not condoned. 7. The learned Single Judge has dismissed the writ petition on the ground of lack of territorial jurisdiction of the High Court of Jharkhand to entertain W.P(S) No.78 of 2015. The learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that the Competency Certificate was issued by the respondent no.2 and a prayer for a direction upon the respondent nos.1 and 2 to affirm, confirm and convey to the Mineral Development Corporation Limited that Competency Certificate granted under Coal Mines Regulation Act, 1957 is as good as original has been made in the writ petition and, therefore, the High Court of Jharkhand has territorial jurisdiction to entertain W.P(S) No.78 of 2015. 8. The expression “cause of action” refers to bundle of facts which the plaintiff/applicant/petitioner shall be required to prove to claim a relief from the Court. This would necessarily mean that a fact which is necessary to establish the claim only is required to be proved in the Court of law. The Competency Certificate a copy of which has been annexed by the applicant vide Annexure-2 in the present appeal records that the certificate (original) shall be issued on submission of Diploma Certificate in original. This is also

3 L.P.A No.42 of 2019 of vital importance that the applicant came before the writ Court challenging the so-called resignation on 19th October 2011 forced by his employer which is situated at Ahmedabad, Gujarat. This therefore would evince no doubt that the applicant is required to prove only such facts which are necessary to establish that the forced resignation was bad in law. 9. While so, merely because a provisional certificate has been issued from the Board of Mining Examination, Directorate General of Mine, Safety at Dhanbad, the High Court of Jharkhand shall have no jurisdiction to entertain the writ petition. 10. Moreover, having found no justification in the application under section 5 of the Limitation Act, I.A No.9505 of 2019 is dismissed. L.P.A No. 42 of 2019 Consequently, L.P.A No.42 of 2019 is dismissed. (Shree Chandrashekhar, J.) (Ratnaker Bhengra, J.) Jharkhand High Court, Ranchi Dated : 18th May 2023 sudhir/N.A.F.R.

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →