2 orders · Page 1 of 1
The High Court held that the Tribunal's findings were not perverse. Regarding the first question, the Court found the respondent's submissions sound and proper, answering it in the negative. For questions 2 and 3, the Court noted that the respondent showed the sale price at Rs 9 crore odd in its books, and the department provided no contra material to disprove these entries. Therefore, these questions were answered in the affirmative. Concerning question 4, the Court found the Tribunal's adverse inference sound and proper because the respondent insisted on obtaining the statement of the responsible party from the vendor company, which was not produced. This question was also answered in the affirmative. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed.
The Tribunal held that the addition of Rs. 13,73,136/- was not justified. It reasoned that the seized documents GD-8 to GD-12 were found in the custody of Hazarimal Bajaj, an employee, who admitted they belonged to him and his family members. The AO admitted that the investments reflected in the returns of Hazarimal and his family were examined. The Tribunal found no specific evidence presented by the AO to prove that these investments belonged to the assessee rather than Hazarimal Bajaj. Similarly, for the additions concerning Mishrilal Bajaj and Vijay Kumar Bajaj, the Tribunal noted that these individuals were taxpayers, had admitted the seized documents belonged to them and their families, and had filed returns. The Tribunal found no cogent evidence to link these transactions to the assessee. The Tribunal also noted that the ladies mentioned were taxpayers who filed returns, and their statements were recorded. Since the seized documents were admitted to belong to Hazarimal Bajaj and not the assessee, and the Revenue did not controvert this admission with evidence found during the search, the additions were deemed unjustified. The Tribunal upheld the order of the CIT(Appeals).