COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX vs. M/S CHANDMAL SARAWGI and CO

PDF · subscribers
ITA/9/2011HC GauhatiGAHC01007643201104 February 20152 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The Tribunal held that the addition of Rs. 13,73,136/- was not justified. It reasoned that the seized documents GD-8 to GD-12 were found in the custody of Hazarimal Bajaj, an employee, who admitted they belonged to him and his family members. The AO admitted that the investments reflected in the returns of Hazarimal and his family were examined. The Tribunal found no specific evidence presented by the AO to prove that these investments belonged to the assessee rather than Hazarimal Bajaj. Similarly, for the additions concerning Mishrilal Bajaj and Vijay Kumar Bajaj, the Tribunal noted that these individuals were taxpayers, had admitted the seized documents belonged to them and their families, and had filed returns. The Tribunal found no cogent evidence to link these transactions to the assessee. The Tribunal also noted that the ladies mentioned were taxpayers who filed returns, and their statements were recorded. Since the seized documents were admitted to belong to Hazarimal Bajaj and not the assessee, and the Revenue did not controvert this admission with evidence found during the search, the additions were deemed unjustified. The Tribunal upheld the order of the CIT(Appeals).

What were the facts?

A search of the assessee's premises on 27-11-1998 led to the discovery of a diary (GD No. 8) detailing investments in shares made by an employee, Hazarimal Bajaj, and his family members, amounting to Rs. 13,73,136/-. The Assessing Officer (AO) treated this amount as the assessee's undisclosed income and passed an assessment order. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) set aside the AO's order, deeming the addition illegal. The Department appealed this decision to the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT). The ITAT, in its order, considered various seized documents (GD-8 to GD-12) and statements recorded under Section 132(4). The ITAT also noted additions related to gifts/withdrawals for Mishrilal Bajaj (Rs. 1,25,000/-) and Vijay Kumar Bajaj (Rs. 38,500/-), and amounts related to other ladies.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the addition of Rs. 13,73,136/- to the assessee's income, based on seized documents GD-8 to GD-12, was justified, turning on Section 69 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. 2. Whether the addition of Rs. 1,25,000/- (gift received by Mishrilal Bajaj and withdrawal from bank) was justified, turning on Section 69 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. 3. Whether the addition of Rs. 38,500/- (gift/loan received by Vijay Kumar Bajaj) was justified, turning on Section 69 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. Assessee's Contentions: The seized documents GD-8 to GD-12, detailing investments, belonged to Hazarimal Bajaj and his family members, who are taxpayers and admitted ownership. The AO failed to provide specific evidence that these investments related to the assessee. For additions concerning Mishrilal Bajaj and Vijay Kumar Bajaj, the seized documents pertained to them and their families, who are taxpayers and admitted the transactions. Cogent evidence linking these to the assessee was lacking. Revenue's Contentions: The Revenue argued that the Tribunal's findings were perverse and contrary to the evidence on record. The Revenue did not present specific arguments for each addition but generally contested the Tribunal's conclusion that the additions were unjustified.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 132(4),Section 69

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

ITA 9/2011 P R E S E N T HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING) MR. K. SREEDHAR RAO THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE P. K. SAIKIA (K Sreedhar Rao, CJ (Acting) A search of the house of the resident of the respondent was conducted on 27-11-1 998 by the Income Tax Officers. One diary was found described as GD No. 8 in the said diary, the name of the employee working as Accountant under the assessee a nd his family members and relatives were found with details of the investment of money in different shares. The amount shown in the diary was Rs. 13,73,136/-. T he A.O. considered the said amount as undisclosed income of the assessee and pas sed assessment order. The CIT appeals set aside the order of the A.O. and held t hat the inclusion of the said amount to the income of the assessee is illegal. T he Department filed an appeal before the appellate Tribunal. The Tribunal, in it s order in paragraph 23, 24, 25 and 29 has made the following observations: 23. As regards ground No.2 - addition of Rs. 13,73,136/-, Rs. 1,25,000/-, Rs. 3 8,500/-, Rs. 30,000/- and Rs. 1,00,000/- The A.O. has discussed the addition in the order on pages 3 to 5. The assessee h as brought on record the copy of submission dated 12.6.2000 placed on page 45, i n reply to A.O.s letter placed on pages 126 & 127 dt. 10.5.2000 & 19.6.2000, dep osition recorded on 27-11-1998 on pages 131 to 134 and deposition recorded on 04 -07-2000 placed on page 135 to 139 which makes clear that the seized documents G D-8 to GD-12 were found and provided to Shri Hazarimal Bajaj who is employee. Th e documents seized contained the details of investment in shares in the name of Hazarimal Bajaj and his family members and money/gift received by some others. T he statement u/s. 132(4) recorded by the A.O. dated 27-11-1998 and 04-07-2000 du ring assessment and during search wherein Hazarimal Bajaj submitted that he is t axpayer and admitted that the seized documents belonged to him (question No. 9) and using the folders GD-9 to GD-12 being employee and GD-8 relates to note book of Gupta business diary and further in the submission dated 12.6.2000, the asse ssee confirmed the same. Since Shri Hazarimal Bajaj is taxpayer with the Revenue admitting that investment belongs to him and his family. The A.O. admitted that the investment reflected in returns of Hazarimal and his family members (A.O. p age 4) and examined and opined being found investment in his and family members’ name cannot be easily brushed out unless there is documents showing that the in vestment belongs to assessee with corroborative evidence. The seizure of the doc ument from the custody of Hazarimal Bajaj does not lead to addition without just ification since Mr. Hazarimal Bajaj accepted that the investment belongs to him and his family members. Therefore, we are of the opinion that the addition of Rs . 13,73,136/- is not justified since no specific evidence has brought on record by the A.O. that this investment based on seized documents GD-8 to GD-12 relates to the assessee and not Mr. Hazarimal Bajaj. 24. In case of gift received by Mishrilal Bajaj and withdrawal from bank Rs. 1,25,000/-, he is assessee. Return filed on 30-07-1998 for assessment year and afterwards, deposition dated 04-07-2000, seized documents belong to him and his family members (page 137/138). The deposition cannot be ruled out unless seized documents shows that gift and loan were from undisclosed income of the assessee. 25. In case of gift/loan received by Vijay Kumar Bajaj Rs. 38,500/- seized d ocument the A.O. discussed the addition on pages 3 to 5. The deposition dated 26 -02-1999 which was before the A.O. and on 21-07-2000 was placed on record on pag es 179 to 183 along with return, computation, details of source and confirmation . Not related to assessee he is family member of Hazarimal Bajaj. Mr. Hazarimal Bajaj admitted that seized documents belong to him and family members. Mr. Vijay Kumar Bajaj admitted loan given by him (question No. 6). He is taxpayer filing returns. Return for assessment year 1998-99 filed on 16-10-1998 (paper book page 184), therefore, for want of cogent evidence no addition is called for. ****** ******* *******

29.

It is a fact that the above mentioned ladies are taxpayers filed returns of income on 30-07-98 and 22-10-98 not controverted by the Ld. D.R. Their state ments were recorded u/s. 132(4) placed on record. The documents seized i.e. GD-8 to GD-12 are admitted and belongs to Hazarimal Bajaj and not the assessee, ther efore, such admission being evidenced has to be controverted by the Revenue on t he basis of evidence fround during the search. Not doing so, the addition for th e name sake cannot be justified. The Tribunal based on the oral and documentary evidence has come to the conclusi on that the addition of the amount of the income of the assessee was illegal and upheld the order of the CIT appeals with elaborate discussion with reference to the evidence. Upon considering the order of the appellate Tribunal, we do not find that there is any perversity in appreciating the materials on record and in coming to the c onclusion. The only possible question, the Revenue could urge that the finding of the appel late Tribunal is perverse and contrary to the evidence and material on record, h owever, such question would not arise in the light of the above observations ext racted above made by the Tribunal in coming to the conclusion while upholding th e order of the CIT appeals. In that view of the matter, the appeal stands dismissed.

More judgments on Section 132(4)

All 4,074 judgments and leading authorities on Section 132(4) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →