COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, GUWAHATI vs. M/S FANTASTI BUILDCON PVT LTD

PDF · subscribers
ITA/8/2012HC GauhatiGAHC01024520201223 February 20152 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the Tribunal's findings were not perverse. Regarding the first question, the Court found the respondent's submissions sound and proper, answering it in the negative. For questions 2 and 3, the Court noted that the respondent showed the sale price at Rs 9 crore odd in its books, and the department provided no contra material to disprove these entries. Therefore, these questions were answered in the affirmative. Concerning question 4, the Court found the Tribunal's adverse inference sound and proper because the respondent insisted on obtaining the statement of the responsible party from the vendor company, which was not produced. This question was also answered in the affirmative. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed.

What were the facts?

The respondent company purchased a hotel for Rs 10.40 crore on October 30, 2006. During a search operation, an agreement was found indicating a sale price of Rs 3,500 per square foot, suggesting undervaluation compared to the Rs 800 per square foot in the sale deed. The real-estate broker, Mr. Modi, stated the agreement was made on behalf of the respondent company. The Assessing Officer, relying on this, initiated reassessment proceedings under Section 148 and passed an order under Section 16, alleging suppressed income of Rs 35.10 crore. The CIT(A) dismissed the respondent's appeal, but the ITAT allowed it. The department appealed to the High Court.

What were the issues?

The High Court framed four substantial questions of law: 1. Whether the Tribunal's deletion of the addition was perverse because the documents relied upon did not refer to the same property, as argued by the Revenue? 2. Whether the addition, if justified, should have been made under Section 69B and not Section 69 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, as held by the Tribunal? 3. Whether the Department failed to discharge its burden under Section 69B of proving additional investment, as held by the Tribunal? 4. Whether Section 114(g) of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, was attracted, as held by the Tribunal? The Revenue contended that Mr. Modi's statement and the agreement clearly showed the transaction was on behalf of the respondent company, and the Tribunal failed to appreciate the evidence properly. The respondent argued that the company was not incorporated when the agreement was dated, cheques issued were for a different agreement, Mr. Modi's statement was incredible, and the vendor's representatives were not examined by the Assessing Officer.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 148,Section 16,Section 69B,Section 69,Section 114(g)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

ITA 8/2012 BEFORE HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE(ACTG.) HON’BLE MR JUSTICE P. K. SAIKIA Heard the appellant and the respondent. 2) The respondent company purchased a hotel by a registered sale deed dated 30th October, 2006 for a sum of Rs 10.40-crore. The department during a search operation in the house of one Mr Modi, a real-estate broker, unearthed an agreem ent between Mr Modi and the erstwhile owner of the hotel. In the said agreement the sale price was fixed at Rs 3,500/- per square feet. On the basis of the said agreement it was found that the sale price shown in the sale deed of the privat e respondent at Rs 800/- per square feet is deliberately undervalued. It also ap pears that a statement of Mr Modi was recorded in which he has stated that the a greement seized from his custody was made by him on behalf of the private respon dent. On the basis of the said statement an enquiry was initiated that the compa ny has suppressed its income to the tune of Rs 35.10-crore. 3) The assessing officer in the enquiry found on the basis of the statement of Mr Modi and the agreement found in the search proceedings that the responden t company is guilty of suppressing its income and avoiding the tax and after iss uing a show-cause notice for reopening of the assessment under section 148 of th e Income Tax Act, 1961 passed an assessment order under section 16 of the Income Tax Act. Aggrieved by the said order the respondent filed an appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax(Appeals) ~ Guwa-255/2010-11. 4) The Commissioner of Income Tax dismissed the said appeal. Aggrieved by t he said order the respondent filed an appeal before the Income Tax Appellate Tri bunal ~ ITA 104/Gau/2011. The Tribunal allowed the appeal. Aggrieved by the said order the department filed this appeal. 5) This Court framed the following substantial questions of law while admit ting the appeal. 1) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the T ribunal was perverse in deleting the addition made by the Assessing Officer on t he ground that the two documents relied upon for such addition did not refer to the same property? 2) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the T ribunal was justified and correct in law in holding that even if the addition wa s justified, it should had been made under Section 69B of the Income Tax Act, 19 61 and not under section 69 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. 3) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was justified and correct in holding that the Department has failed to discharge the burden under Section 69B of the Income Tax Act, 1961 of proving that the as sessee made additional investment? 4) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was justified and correct in law in holding that the provision of Section 114(g) of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 is attracted in the case? 6) The counsel for the appellant submits that the statement of the agreemen t-holder clearly discloses that the agreement was made on behalf of the responde nt company. The agreement also discloses a payment of advance amount of Rs 4-cro re, which, according to the agreement-holder, was paid by the respondent company . The respondent company issued cheques towards advance payment to the vendor an d virtually purchased the property. Therefore there appears to be no reasonable nexus and substantial evidence available to show that the agreement made by Mr M odi with the erstwhile owner was in fact for the benefit of the company and that the Tribunal did not appreciate the evidence in proper perspective, thus erred

in allowing the appeal. 7) Per contra, the counsel for the respondent submits that (1) the agreemen t which the department is placing reliance on is dated 4th August, 2006 when the company was not even incorporated, therefore the question of authorising Mr Mod i by the company does not arise. (2) The cheques issued by the vendor company ar e in respect of the agreement which was entered into with the vendor company and towards which part payments have been made by cheques. (3) The statement of Mr Modi before the assessing officer that he had entered into an agreement on behal f of the respondent company is incredible because to wriggle out of the awkward situation he had to name only the respondent company who has purchased the prope rty, since he could not have successfully attributed to any other person except the respondent company. (4) The person who executed the sale deed on behalf of t he vendor company or any of its directors have not been examined by the assessin g officer in order to come to the conclusion that the agreement between the vend or company and Mr Modi was in fact for the benefit of the respondent company. 8) The Tribunal took all the above aspects into consideration and came to t he right conclusion that the order of the assessing officer and the Commissioner of Income Tax(Appeals) is illegal and thus set aside the order. There is no per versity in the findings recorded by the Tribunal. We find that the submissions m ade by the counsel for the respondent company appears to be sound and proper. Th e first question of law is answered in the negative. 9) In respect of the question 2 and 3, the respondent company has shown the sale price in the account books at Rs 9-crore odd. The department has not found any contra material to controvert the entries in the account books of the respo ndent company. Therefore the question 2 and 3 are answered in the affirmative. 10) It is the contention that the statement of the responsible part of the v endor company was recorded in course of the survey and the respondent company ha d insisted production of the said statement and furnishing copy of the same, whi ch was not produced and copy not furnished to the respondent company. In that vi ew of the matter the adverse inference drawn by the Tribunal is sound and proper . The question 4 is also answered in the affirmative. Accordingly the appeal is dismissed.

More judgments on Section 148

All 49,222 judgments and leading authorities on Section 148 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →