VODAFONE IDEA LIMITED vs. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (TDS) KOLKATA

PDF · subscribers
ITA/118/2019HC CalcuttaWBCHCO000240201901 July 20243 pages
AI SummaryAllowed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that both substantial questions of law should be answered in favour of the assessee and against the revenue. This decision was based on the binding judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Bharti Cellular Limited (Supra). The Supreme Court had concluded that cellular mobile service providers are not under a legal obligation to deduct tax at source on the income/profit component in payments received by distributors/franchisees from third parties/customers, or while selling/transferring pre-paid coupons or starter-kits to distributors. Consequently, Section 194H was held to be not applicable to the facts and circumstances of such cases. The appeals filed by the assessee-cellular mobile service providers challenging the High Courts' judgments were allowed, and those judgments were set aside. The appeals filed by the Revenue challenging the High Courts' judgments were dismissed. The High Court directed that there would be no orders as to costs. The appeal before the High Court was allowed.

What were the facts?

The appellant, Vodafone Idea Limited, is in appeal before the High Court at Calcutta against an order concerning assessment years 2010-11 and 2011-12. The dispute revolves around the appellant's obligation to deduct tax at source (TDS) under Section 194H of the Income Tax Act, 1961, on discounts allowed to its distributors for pre-paid SIM cards and recharge vouchers. The revenue contends that the appellant failed to comply with Section 194H, making it liable as an assessee in default under Section 201. The appeal was admitted on substantial questions of law concerning this obligation and the consequent demand for tax and interest.

What were the issues?

1. Whether, considering the relationship between the appellant (Vodafone Idea Limited) and its distributors and their course of dealings, the appellant was required to comply with Section 194H of the Income Tax Act, 1961, concerning tax deduction at source on discounts provided to distributors for pre-paid SIM cards and pre-paid vouchers/recharge coupons? (Question of law) 2. Whether the appellant can be deemed an assessee in default under Section 201 for non-compliance with Section 194H, and whether any tax or interest can be demanded from it? (Question of mixed law and fact) Assessee's Contention: The assessee argued that Section 194H was not applicable to the discounts allowed to distributors. They relied on the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Bharti Cellular Limited (Now Bharti Airtel Limited) Vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax Circle-57, Kolkata and Anr. dated 28.02.2024. Revenue's Contention: The revenue contended that the appellant was liable to deduct TDS under Section 194H and was an assessee in default. No specific authorities or precedents were mentioned for the revenue's arguments in the judgment, other than their position being contrary to the Supreme Court's ruling.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 194H,Section 201

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

O-68

IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA SPECIAL JURISDICTION ORIGINAL SIDE

ITA/118/2019

VODAFONE IDEA LIMITED VS COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (TDS) KOLKATA

BEFORE : THE HON’BLE JUSTICE SURYA PRAKASH KESARWANI

And THE HON’BLE JUSTICE RAJARSHI BHARADWAJ Date : 24th June, 2024. Appearance: Mr. Sachit Jolly, Adv. Mr. Aditya Rathore, Adv. Mr. Indranil Banerjee, Adv. … for the appellant.

Ms. Smita Das De, Adv. ... for the respondent.

1.

Mr. Sachit Jolly, learned Counsel appears for the appellant through video conference and Smt. Smita Das De, learned standing Counsel appears for respondent. 2. The matter relates to assessment years 2010-11 and 2011-12. 3. The appeal has been admitted by this Court by order dated 12.12.2018 on the following substantial questions of law: a)Whether having regard to the relationship between the appellant and its distributors and course of dealings between them, the appellant was required

to comply with the provisions of section 194H of the Income Tax Act, 1961 relating to tax deduction at source with reference to the discount allowed to the distributors in respect of pre-paid sim cards and pre-paid vouchers/recharge coupons?

b)Whether the appellant can be deemed to be an assessee in default under section 201 for non- compliance with section 194H and any tax or interest can be demanded from it?

4.

Both the learned Counsel for the parties jointly state that the controversy is covered by the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 28.2.2024 in civil appeal no. 7257 of 2011 [Bharti Cellular Limited(Now Bharti Airtel Limited) Vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax Circle-57, Kolkata and Anr.] and in view thereof, both the substantial questions of law deserve to be answered in favour of the assessee and against the revenue. 5. We find that in the case of Bharti Cellular Limited (Supra), Hon’ble Supreme Court concluded as under: “In view of the aforesaid discussion, we hold that the assessees would not be under a legal obligation to deduct tax at source on income/profit component in payments received by distributors/franchisees from third parties/customers, or while selling/transferring the pre-paid coupons or starter-kits to the distributors.

Section 194-H of the Act is not applicable to the facts and circumstances of this case. Accordingly, the appeals filed by the assessee-cellular mobile service providers, challenging the judgments of the High Courts of Delhi and Calcutta are allowed and these judgments are set aside. The appeals filed by the Revenue challenging the judgments of High Courts of Rajasthan, Karnataka and Bombay are dismissed. There would be no orders as to cost. Pending applications, if any, shall stand disposed of.” 6. Following the aforesaid judgment in the case of Bharti Cellular Limited (Supra) and also as stated jointly by learned Counsel for the parties, the substantial questions of law are answered in favour of the assessee and against the revenue. 7. The appeal is Allowed.

(SURYA PRAKASH KESARWANI, J.)

(RAJARSHI BHARADWAJ, J.)

More judgments on Section 194H

All 1,396 judgments and leading authorities on Section 194H →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →