VEDANTA LIMITED.,PANAJI vs. THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, CIRCLE-1 (1), PANAJI., PANAJI

PDF · subscribers
ITA 139/PAN/2017Status: DisposedITAT Amritsar06 November 2026AY 2012-1349 pages
AI SummaryPartly Allowed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal decided the appeal partly allowing it for statistical purposes. Regarding Ground Nos. 10 to 10.2 concerning transfer pricing adjustments for management consultancy services, the Tribunal noted that the issue had been set aside to the file of the TPO for fresh adjudication in a subsequent year (AY 2014-15) by the same Tribunal, with an appeal pending before the Delhi High Court. Considering the pending appeal and no change in facts, the Tribunal restored the issue to the TPO for fresh adjudication, considering judicial precedents and the assessee's contentions about growth demonstrating tangible benefits. Similarly, for Ground Nos. 10.3 and 10.4 concerning transfer pricing adjustments on interest on loans paid to AEs, the Tribunal observed that for AY 2014-15, the DRP had directed the TPO to compute ALP based on LIBOR plus, and after giving effect to those directions, the adjustments were deleted. Therefore, the Tribunal restored this issue to the TPO for carrying out a similar exercise as done for AY 2014-15, after considering relevant details and deciding in accordance with law. The remaining grounds were considered general or consequential and did not require adjudication. The operative direction for the allowed grounds was to restore them to the file of the TPO for fresh adjudication.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Vedanta Limited, filed an appeal before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) challenging the assessment order dated February 27, 2017, passed under Section 143(3) read with Section 144C(13) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, for Assessment Year 2012-13. The revenue is represented by the ACIT, Circle-1(1), Panaji. The assessee's returned loss of Rs. 10,95,72,44,910/- under normal provisions and Rs. 5,46,38,82,139/- as book profit under Section 115JB was assessed by the Assessing Officer (AO) as income of Rs. 20,34,97,60,728/- and Rs. 11,09,96,10,526/-, respectively. The appeal raises multiple grounds concerning disallowance of business losses, disallowance under Section 14A, provision for unascertained liabilities, additional depreciation, unexplained stocks, additions to book profits, and transfer pricing adjustments.

What were the issues?

The Tribunal was called upon to decide several issues, including: 1. Whether the AO and Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP) erred in denying set off for current year business losses amounting to Rs. 24,70,72,00,000/- of demerged undertakings, contrary to High Court orders (Grounds 3, 3.1, 3.2, 3.3). 2. Whether the AO and DRP erred in disallowing Rs. 5,47,04,00,000/- under Section 14A read with Rule 8D, particularly concerning strategic investments and lack of fresh investments (Grounds 4, 4.1, 4.2, 4.3, 4.4). 3. Whether the AO and DRP erred in disallowing Rs. 219,50,96,732/- by treating a provision for copper concentrate purchase as an unascertained liability (Ground 5). 4. Whether the AO and DRP erred in disallowing Rs. 16,53,28,387/- as additional depreciation under Section 32(1)(iia) for the iron ore and mining division, contrary to Supreme Court and High Court precedents (Grounds 6, 6.1). 5. Whether the AO and DRP erred in adding Rs. 8,72,15,100/- for alleged unexplained stocks (Ground 7). 6. Whether the AO and DRP erred in disallowing Rs. 5,47,04,00,000/- and Rs. 16,53,28,387/- while computing book profit under Section 115JB, as these are not listed in the Explanation to Section 115JB (Grounds 8, 9). 7. Whether the TPO and DRP erred in making a transfer pricing addition of Rs. 19,17,83,200/- on management consultancy services and representative office fees paid to Associated Enterprises (AEs), and Rs. 2,58,82,219/- on interest paid to AEs (Grounds 10, 10.1, 10.2, 10.3, 10.4). The assessee argued that the scheme of arrangement was sanctioned by the High Courts, and the AO/DRP failed to give effect to it. They contended that the denial of loss set-off was contrary to court orders and that the allegations of a colourable device were rejected by the Bombay High Court. For Section 14A, it was argued that no disallowance should be made for strategic investments or where no fresh investments were made. Regarding unascertained liabilities, the provision was based on quotation price and was ascertained. For additional depreciation, reliance was placed on judicial precedents holding iron ore extraction as 'manufacture' or 'production'. For transfer pricing, the assessee argued that services were rendered, benefits were derived, and payments were accepted as arm's length in prior years. For interest on loans, it was argued that the rates were within permissible limits and benchmarked appropriately. The revenue's contentions are not explicitly detailed for each ground but are implicit in the AO/DRP's actions.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 143(3),Section 144C(13),Section 115JB,Section 2(19AA),Section 72A,Section 14A,Section 32(1)(iia)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, PANAJI DB BENCH, PANAJI

Before: DR.MANISH BORAD & SHRI VINAY BHAMORE

For Appellant: Shri Ajay Vohra, Advocate
For Respondent: Shri Naveen Kumar B, CIT-DR
Hearing: 13.08.2026Pronounced: 06.11.2026

PER DR. MANISH BORAD, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER :

The captioned appeal at the instance of assessee pertaining to A.Y. 2012-13 is directed against the Assessment order dated 27.02.2017 passed u/s.143(3) r.w.s.144C(13) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (in short ‘the Act’).

2.

Assessee has raised following grounds/additional grounds of appeal :

“1. That the Ld. Assessing Officer ("AO") erred on facts and in law in assessing the income of the Appellant at Rs.20,34,97,60,728/- under the normal provisions of the Income Tax Act, 1961 ("the Act") and Rs.11,09,96,10,526/- under Section 115JB of the Act as against the loss of Rs.10,95,72,44,910/- returned by the Appellant, under normal provisions of the Act and Rs.5,46,38,82,139/- declared as book profit under Section 115JB of the Act for the subject Assessment Year ("AY") 2012-13. Vedanta Limited

2.

That the order of the Ld. AO dated 27.02.2017 is illegal, beyond jurisdiction and bad in law since the Ld. AO failed to give effect to the Scheme of Arrangement ('Scheme') sanctioned by the Hon'ble Bombay High Court (at Goa) vide order dated 03.03.2013 and the Hon'ble Madras High Court vide order dated 25.07.2013. DISALLOWANCE OF LOSS

3.

That the Ld. AO and the Hon'ble Dispute Resolution Panel ("DRP") erred on facts and in law in denying set off for current year business losses amounting to Rs.24,70,72,00,000/-of the demerged aluminum business undertaking of Vedanta Aluminum Limited ('VAL') and demerged power division of Sterlite Energy Ltd. ("SEL") which had merged into the Appellant with effect from 01.04.2011 and 01.01.2011 respectively.

3.

1 That the Ld. AO and the Hon'ble DRP have grossly erred in law by not giving full effect to the Scheme and by not following the orders of the Hon'ble Bombay High Court and Hon'ble Madras High Court.

3.

2 That the Ld. AO and the Hon'ble DRP erred in denying the set off for losses by alleging that the Scheme was a colourable device to evade payment of taxes without appreciating that the Hon'ble Bombay High Court (at Goa) had rejected the very same argument.

3.

3 That the Ld. AO and the Hon'ble DRP erred in disallowing the set off for losses by invoking Section 2(19AA) and Section 72A of the Act without appreciating that the said Section had no relation whatsoever with current year profits or losses. DISALLOWANCE UNDER SECTION 14A

4.

That on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. AO and the Hon'ble DRP grossly erred in making a disallowance of Rs.5,47,04,00,000/- on account of expenditure allegedly incurred in earning exempt income, by invoking Rule 8D of the Income Tax Rules, 1962 ("the Rules") r.w.s Section 14A of the Act.

4.

1 That the Ld. AO and the Hon'ble DRP erred in making a disallowance under Section 14A read with Rule 8D of the Rules without appreciating that no disallowance under Section 14A of the Act could have been made where dividend arose from strategic investments made by the Appellant/Assessee into subsidiary companies.

4.

2 That the Ld. AO and the Hon'ble DRP erred in making a disallowance under Section 14A read with Rule 8D of the Rules without appreciating that no disallowance under Section 14A of the Act could be made where no fresh investments were made during the year except for investments in subsidiary companies.

4.

3 That the Hon'ble DRP erred in rejecting the Appellant's contention that the Ld. AO had disallowed the Appellant's claim under Section 14A read with Rule 8D of the Rules without recording the satisfaction to the effect that the Appellant's claim is incorrect. Vedanta Limited

4.

4 Without prejudice, the Ld. AO and the Hon'ble DRP grossly erred in failing to adhere to the prescribed Rule 8D of the Rules while making the disallowance. PROVISION FOR UNASCERTAINED LIABILITIES

5.

That in the present facts and circumstances, the Ld. AO and the Hon'ble DRP erred in making a disallowance of Rs.219,50,96,732/- to the income of the Appellant by treating the provision made by the Appellant towards purchase of copper concentrate as unascertained liability without appreciating that the provision/liability had been accrued in the books of the Appellant on the basis of quotation price received by the Appellant and, therefore, the liability was an ascertained and crystallized liability. DISALLOWANCE OF ADDITIONAL DEPRECIATION

6.

That the Ld. AO and the Hon'ble DRP erred in disallowing Rs. 16,53,28,387/- claimed as additional depreciation by the Appellant in respect of the iron ore and mining division on purchase of new plant and machinery by holding that the Appellant was no engaged in the 'manufacture' or 'production' of any article or thing and, therefore, not entitled to the benefit under Section 32 (1)(iia) of the Act.

6.

1 That in holding as aforesaid, the Ld. AO and the Hon'ble DRP erred in not appreciating that the Hon'ble Supreme Court, in Appellant's own case in CIT v. Sesa Goa Ltd. 271 ITR 331 and the jurisdictional High Court in the case of V.M. Salgaonkar & Bros. Pvt. Ltd. (Tax Appeal No. 41 of 2014) have on similar facts held that the Appellant's business of extraction and processing of iron ore amounted to 'manufacture' or 'production' and therefore, entitled to additional depreciation under Section 32(1)(iia) of the Act. DISALLOWANCE FOR ALLEGED UNEXPLAINED STOCKS IN APPELLANT'S BOOKS

7.

That the Ld. AO and the Hon'ble DRP erred in making an addition of Rs.8,72,15,100/-by erroneously holding that the Appellant failed to provide a proper reconciliation of stock by comparing the accounts of the Appellants with the returns filed by the Appellant with the Indian Bureau of Mines ("IBM"). ADDITIONS TO BOOK PROFITS

8.

That the Ld. AO and the Hon'ble DRP, while computing the book profit under Section 115JB of the Act, erred in disallowing Rs.5,47,04,00,000/- under Section 14A of the Act, without appreciating that such disallowance could not have been made while computing book profit under Section 115JB since it is not one of the items mentioned in the Explanation to Section 115JB of the Act.

9.

That the Ld. AO and the Hon'ble DRP erred in disallowing additional depreciation amounting to Rs. 16,53,28,387/- under Section 32(1)(iia) of the Act while computing the book profit under Section 115JB of the Act, without appreciating that the said disallowance does not fall under any of the items mentioned in the Explanation to Section 115JB of the Act. Vedanta Limited

TRANSFER PRICING

10.

That the Ld. TPO and the Hon'ble DRP erred in making a transfer pricing addition of Rs. 19,17,83,200/- by treating the Arm's Length Price ('ALP') in respect of payment of Management Consultancy Services including representative office fee paid by the Appellant to its Associated Enterprises ('AE') at Rs.4,79,45,800/-.

10.

1 That in holding as aforesaid, the Ld. TPO and the Hon'ble DRP erred in holding that the services were repetitive and that the Appellant had failed to demonstrate the rendition of services and the benefits derived from the services received without appreciating that the Appellant had lead contemporaneous evidence to demonstrate the actual rendition of services and the benefits derived by the Appellant even though, as per the settled legal position in this context, the Appellant was not required to demonstrate any benefit from receipt of such services.

10.

2 That the Ld. TPO and the DRP have further failed to appreciate that the Appellant has received and made payment for such services, to its AEs and the same have been accepted to be at arm's length in all the previous years and therefore, without there being any change in facts, the Ld. TPO could not have disallowed any part of the said payments.

18.

3 That the TPO further erred in making an addition of Rs.2,58,82,219/- to the income of the Appellant by treating the interest paid by the Appellant to its AEs viz. Vedanta Resources Holding Limited and Welter Trading Limited, Cyprus as excessive.

10.

4 That the TPO erred in making the aforesaid addition without appreciating that the interest paid by the Appellant, i.e. 2.5% per annum, 6.09% per annum and 5.9% per annum are within the permissible limits originally sanctioned by the RBI and, therefore, deemed to be at arm's length.

11.

That the Ld. AO erred in not allowing credit for prepaid taxes - TDS, advance tax, self-assessment tax. The grounds of appeal made herein above are without prejudice to each other. The Appellant craves leave to alter, amend and/or withdraw all or any of the grounds of appeal herein or add any further grounds as may be considered necessary and to submit such statements, documents and papers as may be considered necessary either before or during the time of hearing. Additional Grounds :

1.

The captioned appeal has been filed by the Appellant/ Assessee, challenging additions made in the final assessment order dated 27.02.2017 passed by the Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle 1(1), Panaji, Goa under section 143(3) read with section 144C(13) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 ('the Act') for Assessment Year ('AY') 2012-13. Vedanta Limited

2.

In continuation to the grounds of appeal raised by the Appellant in the captioned appeal, the Appellant craves leave of the Hon'ble Tribunal to raise the following additional grounds/ supplemental grounds of appeal and prays the same maybe admitted and considered as a part of the captioned appeal, while adjudicating the same: "That on the facts and circumstances of the case, the Final Assessment Order dated 27.02.2017 passed by Ld. AO is illegal and void ab initio, having been passed after the expiry of limitation prescribed under Section 153 of the Act, and therefore, liable to be quashed."

3.

It is submitted that the additional ground raised do not require any fresh examination of facts and can be adjudicated on the basis of material available on record. Since the issue goes to the root of the matter and is required to be adjudicated in the interest of justice. Reliance in this regard is placed on the decision of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of National Thermal Corporation Limited vs. CT: (1998) 229 ITR 383 (SC).

4.

In the interest of justice, it is humbly submitted that the additional grounds of appeal raised herein above, may kindly be adjudicated and admitted by virtue of discretion vested with the Hon'ble Tribunal under Rule 11 of the Rules and the Hon'ble Tribunal may decide on merits after providing an opportunity to the Appellant of hearing in the matter.”

3.

At the outset, ld. Counsel for the assessee requested for not pressing the Additional grounds of appeal in view of the order of the decision of Coordinate Bench, Delhi in the case of assessee in ITA No.5368/Del/2019 order dated 17.11.20211. The said additional grounds are dismissed as ‘not pressed’.

4.

Brief facts of the case are that the assessee is a Limited Company formerly known as Sesa Goa Limited. Return of income for A.Y. 2012-13 e filed on 27.11.2012 declaring total income of Rs.2253.24 crore under the normal provisions and book profit at Rs.2581.81 crore and the same was processed u/s.143(1) on 18.10.2013 computing the total income at Rs.2253.24 crore. Subsequently, the assessee filed revised return on 21.03.2014 declaring total loss of (-) Rs.1179.40 crore under the normal provisions and book profit at Rs.546.39 crore. Case selected for scrutiny through CASS followed by validly serving statutory notices u/s.143(2) and 142(1). Ld. Assessing Officer considering the Vedanta Limited

international transactions carried out during the year referred those matters to the ld. Transfer Pricing Officer (TPO) on 24.12.2014 for computing the Arm’s Length Price (ALP). Ld. Transfer Pricing Officer passed the order on 29.01.2016. Thereafter, draft assessment order prepared on 31.03.2016 against which the assessee filed appeal before the Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP) and vide order dated 23.12.2016 ld. DRP rejected the contentions and arguments of the assessee and upheld the disallowance on the issue of Management Consultant charges at Rs.19.18 crore and interest paid at Rs.2.59 crore.

5.

Further, ld. Assessing Officer also carried out the scrutiny proceedings on the other issues. Firstly, disallowance u/s.14A of the Act was made applying Rule 8D of the Income Tax Rules, 1962 computing disallowance at Rs.547.04 crore. Addition also made for the provisions for unascertained liability at Rs.65.92 crore. Ld. Assessing Officer also disallowed additional depreciation at Rs.16.53 crore on the basis of the observation of ld. DRP that assessee is not a manufacturer. Further, ld. Assessing Officer also disallowed the set off of the current year loss claimed in the revised return amounting to Rs.2470.72 crore. Ld. Assessing Officer made reference to the observation of ld. DRP affirming the action of the Assessing Officer that the assessee has not fulfilled the conditions prescribed u/s.72A of the Act. The assessee has revised the return on account of the fact that the business undertaking of Vedanta Aluminium Limited was demerged and merged into Sesa Goa Limited, Vedanta Aluminium Limited consisted of Power Division and Aluminium Division and assessed at Mumbai. The losses pertaining to the Aluminium Division were set off against the income of the assessee and similarly loss pertaining to Sterlite Energy Limited were set off against the income of the assessee on merger. Ld. Assessing Officer also observed the facts about the order passed by the Hon’ble High Court Vedanta Limited

of Judicature Bombay at Goa dated 03.04.2013 and that Hon’ble High Court of Madras order dated 25.07.2013 sanctioning the Scheme of Amalgamation arrangement amongst Sterlite Energy Limited, Sterlite Industries India Limited, Vedanta Aluminium Limited, Madras Aluminium Company Limited. Further, the order has been approved by the Division Bench vide order dated 12.08.2013 and for the purpose of giving effect to the Scheme of Amalgamation arrangement and Audited accounts were re-drawn and revised return has been filed on 21.03.2014 declaring loss of (-) Rs.1779.40 crore. However, ld. Assessing Officer has observed that the Scheme of Amalgamation is a device adopted by the assessee to evade payment of tax resulting into substantial loss/revenue and such schemes are considered to be a colourable device with the motive of evading payment of tax. Ld. Assessing Officer accordingly has disallowed the clam of loss of Vedanta Aluminium Limited and other companies totalling to Rs.2470.72 crore.

6.

Further, ld. Assessing Officer also made addition for excess unsubstantiated stock in books based on his observation that there is difference in the stock as per books of account of the assessee and as shown in Form H1 filed with Indian Bureau of mines which in quantity is 113740 Metric Tonn (62424 DMT at Goa + 51316 WMT at Karnataka). Ld. DRP also supported the observation of the Assessing Officer stating that the assessee has not explained the source of stock or movement thereof and also not provided reconciliation from day to day stock register/entries, lorry receipts, delivery challans etc and therefore the stock of62424 DMT at Goa and 51316 WMT at Karnataka valued at Rs.3,99,40,848 and Rs.4,72,74,352 respectively remained unsubstantiated and unexplained. Further, ld. Assessing Officer while computing the book profit added disallowance u/s.14A as well as disallowance on additional depreciation and revised the book profit at Rs.1109.96 Vedanta Limited

crore as against Rs.546.39 crore shown by the assessee and assessed the income at Rs.2034.97 crore as against the revised computation of income filed during the course of assessment proceedings declaring loss at Rs.1097.72 crore.

7.

Aggrieved assessee is now in appeal before this Tribunal challenging the order of the Assessing Officer passed u/s.143(3) r.w.s.144C(13) of the Act.

8.

Ld. Counsel for the assessee vehemently argued and referred to the following written submissions :

// this space is intentionally left blank // Vedanta Limited Vedanta Limited Vedanta Limited Vedanta Limited Vedanta Limited Vedanta Limited Vedanta Limited Vedanta Limited Vedanta Limited Vedanta Limited Vedanta Limited Vedanta Limited Vedanta Limited Vedanta Limited Vedanta Limited Vedanta Limited Vedanta Limited Vedanta Limited Vedanta Limited Vedanta Limited Vedanta Limited

9.

On the other hand, ld. DR vehemently argued supporting the order of the Assessing Officer as well as the directions given by ld. DRP u/s.144C(5) of the Act dated 23.12.2016 and further made submissions on each of the issues but the overall contentions have been raised supporting the order of Assessing Officer.

10.

We have heard the rival submissions and perused the record placed before us. The first effective issue raised in Ground No.2 and Ground Nos. 3 to 3.3 is against the disallowance of set off of current year loss arising out of the Scheme of Amalgamation arrangement sanctioned by the Hon’ble High Court of Judicature, Bombay at Goa and Hon’ble High Court, Madras. Facts in brief relating to this issue are that the assessee filed original return of income declaring income at Rs.2253.24 crore for A.Y. 2012-13. At that time, the Scheme of Amalgamation involving M/s. Sterlite Energy Limited, M/s. Sterlite Industries India Limited and Madras Aluminium Limited, Vedanta Aluminium Limited and the appellant’s earlier company Sesa Goa Limited was pending for the sanction of Hon’ble Court of Judication, Bombay at Goa and at Madras. As per the said scheme of amalgamation arrangement; (i) M/s. Sterlite Industries India Limited to merge into appellant w.e.f. 01.04.2011 as the appointed date; (ii) The power business undertaking of Madras Aluminium Limited (MALCO) to be hived off into Vedanta Aluminium Limited w.e.f. 01.04.2012 as the appointed date; (iii) MALCO to merge into appellant w.e.f. 17.08.2013; (iv) Sterlite Energy Limited to merge into appellant w.e.f.01.01.2011 and lastly (v) Aluminium business Division of Vedanta Aluminium Limited to demerge and then merge into appellant w.e.f.01.04.2011 as the appointed date. Further, the scheme received the approval of Hon’ble Bombay High Court at Goa vide order dated 03.04.2013 and on an appeal by certain shareholders against the order of Single Judge of the Hon’ble Bombay High Court, received the approval from the Division Bench

30 Vedanta Limited

vide order dated 12.08.2013. Similarly, the scheme pending before the Hon’ble Madras High Court received sanction vide order dated 25.07.2013. Subsequent to the approval of the aforesaid scheme Sesa Goa Limited became M/s.Sterlite Industries India Limited effective from 18.09.2013 and later on changed to Vedanta Limited effective from 21.04.2015. 11. Now subsequent to the restructuring scheme getting duly approved by the Hon’ble Bombay High Court, the assessee revised its audited accounts and return of income on 21.03.2014 declaring loss at Rs.1179.40 crore. This loss has been arrived because the assessee had positive income prior to the giving effect to the merger approved by the Hon’ble High Court but thereafter current year losses of the merged entities namely Sterlite Energy Limited and Vedanta Limited receiving the sanction from the Hon’ble High Court effective from 01.04.2011, the current year positive income turned into losses. Ld. Assessing Officer has referred such scheme as a colourable device disallowing the set off losses and non fulfilment of conditions u/s.72A of the Act. During the course of assessment proceedings, when the issue regarding set off of the losses of the merged entities were disallowed by the Assessing Officer and the matter reached before ld. DRP the objections raised by the assessee were rejected by the ld. DRP observing as follows :

“7. The AO has made detailed discussion in the order. Among other arguments made by the AO; the main argument is non-fulfilment of conditions under section 72A of the IT Act. The explanation to the section 72A is examined, which is as under: (7) For the purposes of this section, (a) "accumulated loss" means so much of the loss of the predecessor firm or the proprietary concern or the private company or unlisted public company before conversion into limited liability partnership or the amalgamating company or the demerged company, as the case may be, under the head "Profits and gains of business or profession" (not being a loss sustained in a speculation

31 Vedanta Limited

business) which such predecessor firm or the proprietary concern or the company or amalgamating company or demerged company, would have been entitled to carry forward and set off under the provisions of section 72 if the reorganization of business or conversion or amalgamation or demerged had not taken place;

8.

It is seen that the definition includes the loss of the current year also and therefore action of the AO is correct. The Panel has gone through the objections and the AO's order and is of the considered opinion that the objections are not acceptable..."

12.

In the above finding of ld.DRP reference has been made to the non- fulfilment of the conditions prescribed u/s.72A of the Act. We note that section 72A of the Act refers to the provisions relating to carry forward of set off of accumulated loss and unabsorbed depreciation allowance in Amalgamation or Demerger and the same reads as under :

“Provisions relating to carry forward and set off of accumulated loss and unabsorbed depreciation allowance in amalgamation or demerger, etc. 72A. (1) Where there has been an amalgamation of— (a) a company owning an industrial undertaking or a ship or a hotel with another company; or (b) a banking company referred to in clause (c) of section 5 of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 (10 of 1949) with a specified bank; or (c) one or more public sector company or companies with one or more public sector company or companies; or (d) an erstwhile public sector company with one or more company or companies, if the share purchase agreement entered into under strategic disinvestment restricted immediate amalgamation of the said public sector company and the amalgamation is carried out within five years from the end of the previous year in which the restriction on amalgamation in the share purchase agreement ends, then, notwithstanding anything contained in any other provision of this Act, the accumulated loss and the unabsorbed depreciation of the amalgamating company shall be deemed to be the loss or, as the case may be, allowance for unabsorbed depreciation of the amalgamated

32 Vedanta Limited

company for the previous year in which the amalgamation was effected, and other provisions of this Act relating to set off and carry forward of loss and allowance for depreciation shall apply accordingly : Provided that the accumulated loss and the unabsorbed depreciation of the amalgamating company, in case of an amalgamation referred to in clause (d), which is deemed to be the loss or, as the case may be, the allowance for un-absorbed depreciation of the amalgamated company, shall not be more than the accumulated loss and unabsorbed depreciation of the public sector company as on the date on which the public sector company ceases to be a public sector company as a result of strategic disinvestment. Explanation.—For the purposes of clause (d),— (i) "control" shall have the same meaning as assigned to in clause (27) of section 2 of the Companies Act, 2013 (18 of 2013); (ii) "erstwhile public sector company" means a company which was a public sector company in earlier previous years and ceases to be a public sector company by way of strategic disinvestment by the Government; (iii) "strategic disinvestment" means sale of shareholding by the Central Government or any State Government or a public sector company, in a public sector company or in a company, which results in-- (a) reduction of its shareholding to below fifty-one per cent; and (b) transfer of control to the buyer: Provided that the condition laid down in sub-clause (a) shall apply only in a case where shareholding of the Central Government or the State Government or the public sector company was above fifty-one per cent before such sale of shareholding: Provided further that requirement of transfer of control referred to in sub-clause (b) may be carried out by the Central Government or the State Government or the public sector company or any two of them or all of them. (2) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1), the accumulated loss shall not be set off or carried forward and the unabsorbed depreciation shall not be allowed in the assessment of the amalgamated company unless— (a) the amalgamating company— (i) has been engaged in the business, in which the accumulated loss occurred or depreciation remains unabsorbed, for three or more years; (ii) has held continuously as on the date of the amalgamation at least three-fourths of the book value of fixed assets held

33 Vedanta Limited

by it two years prior to the date of amalgamation; (b) the amalgamated company— (i) holds continuously for a minimum period of five years from the date of amalgamation at least three-fourths of the book value of fixed assets of the amalgamating company acquired in a scheme of amalgamation; (ii) continues the business of the amalgamating company for a minimum period of five years from the date of amalgamation; (iii) fulfils such other conditions as may be prescribed to ensure the revival of the business of the amalgamating company or to ensure that the amalgamation is for genuine business purpose. (3) In a case where any of the conditions laid down in sub-section (2) are not complied with, the set off of loss or allowance of depreciation made in any previous year in the hands of the amalgamated company shall be deemed to be the income of the amalgamated company chargeable to tax for the year in which such conditions are not complied with. (4) Notwithstanding anything contained in any other provisions of this Act, in the case of a demerger, the accumulated loss and the allowance for unabsorbed depreciation of the demerged company shall— (a) where such loss or unabsorbed depreciation is directly relatable to the undertakings transferred to the resulting company, be allowed to be carried forward and set off in the hands of the resulting company; (b) where such loss or unabsorbed depreciation is not directly relatable to the undertakings transferred to the resulting company, be apportioned between the demerged company and the resulting company in the same proportion in which the assets of the undertakings have been retained by the demerged company and transferred to the resulting company, and be allowed to be carried forward and set off in the hands of the demerged company or the resulting company, as the case may be. (5) The Central Government may, for the purposes of this Act, by notification in the Official Gazette, specify such conditions as it considers necessary to ensure that the demerger is for genuine business purposes. (6) Where there has been reorganisation of business, whereby, a firm is succeeded by a company fulfilling the conditions laid down in clause (xiii) of section 47 or a proprietary concern is succeeded by a company fulfilling the conditions laid down in clause (xiv) of section 47, then, notwithstanding anything contained in any other provision of this Act, the accumulated loss and the unabsorbed depreciation of the predecessor firm or the proprietary concern, as the case may be, shall be deemed to be the loss or allowance for depreciation of the successor company for the purpose of previous year in which business reorganisation was effected and other provisions of 34 Vedanta Limited

this Act relating to set off and carry forward of loss and allowance for depreciation shall apply accordingly : Provided that if any of the conditions laid down in the proviso to clause (xiii) or the proviso to clause (xiv) to section 47 are not complied with, the set off of loss or allowance of depreciation made in any previous year in the hands of the successor company, shall be deemed to be the income of the company chargeable to tax in the year in which such conditions are not complied with. (6A) Where there has been reorganisation of business whereby a private company or unlisted public company is succeeded by a limited liability partnership fulfilling the conditions laid down in the proviso to clause (xiiib) of section 47, then, notwithstanding anything contained in any other provision of this Act, the accumulated loss and the unabsorbed depreciation of the predecessor company, shall be deemed to be the loss or allowance for depreciation of the successor limited liability partnership for the purpose of the previous year in which business reorganisation was effected and other provisions of this Act relating to set off and carry forward of loss and allowance for depreciation shall apply accordingly : Provided that if any of the conditions laid down in the proviso to clause (xiiib) of section 47 are not complied with, the set off of loss or allowance of depreciation made in any previous year in the hands of the successor limited liability partnership, shall be deemed to be the income of the limited liability partnership chargeable to tax in the year in which such conditions are not complied with. 82[(6B) Where any amalgamation or business reorganisation, as the case may be, is effected on or after the 1st April, 2025, any loss forming part of the accumulated loss of the predecessor entity under sub-section (1), (6) or (6A), being— (a) the amalgamating company; or (b) the firm or proprietary concern; or (c) the private company or unlisted public company, as the case may be, which is deemed to be the loss of the successor entity, being— (i) the amalgamated company; or (ii) the successor company; or (iii) the successor limited liability partnership, as the case may be, shall be carried forward in the hands of the successor entity for not more than eight assessment years immediately succeeding the assessment year for which such loss was first computed for original predecessor entity.] (7) For the purposes of this section,—

35 Vedanta Limited

(a) "accumulated loss" means so much of the loss of the predecessor firm or the proprietary concern or the private company or unlisted public company before conversion into limited liability partnership or the amalgamating company or the demerged company, as the case may be, under the head "Profits and gains of business or profession" (not being a loss sustained in a speculation business) which such predecessor firm or the proprietary concern or the company or amalgamating company or demerged company, would have been entitled to carry forward and set off under the provisions of section 72 if the reorganisation of business or conversion or amalgamation or demerger had not taken place; (aa) "industrial undertaking" means any undertaking which is engaged in— (i) the manufacture or processing of goods; or (ii) the manufacture of computer software; or (iii) the business of generation or distribution of electricity or any other form of power; or (iiia) the business of providing telecommunication services, whether basic or cellular, including radio paging, domestic satellite service, network of trunking, broadband network and internet services; or (iv) mining; or (v) the construction of ships, aircrafts or rail systems; [(ab) "original predecessor entity" means predecessor entity in respect of the first amalgamation under sub-section (1) or first business reorganisation under sub-section (6) or (6A);] (b) "unabsorbed depreciation" means so much of the allowance for depreciation of the predecessor firm or the proprietary concern or the private company or unlisted public company before conversion into limited liability partnership or the amalgamating company or the demerged company, as the case may be, which remains to be allowed and which would have been allowed to the predecessor firm or the proprietary concern or the company or amalgamating company or demerged company, as the case may be, under the provisions of this Act, if the reorganisation of business or conversion or amalgamation or demerger had not taken place; (c) "specified bank" means the State Bank of India constituted under the State Bank of India Act, 1955 (23 of 1955) or a subsidiary bank as defined in the State Bank of India (Subsidiary Banks) Act, 1959 (38 of 1959) or a corresponding new bank constituted under section 3 of the Banking Companies (Acquisition and Transfer of Undertakings) Act, 1970 (5 of 1970) or under section 3 of the Banking Companies (Acquisition and Transfer of Undertakings) Act, 1980 (40 of 1980).

36 Vedanta Limited

13.

Now in the above provision, in section 72A(i) firstly refers to the accumulated loss of the amalgamating company to be deemed to be the loss or, as the case may be, allowance for unabsorbed depreciation of the amalgamated company. Further, section 72A(7) defines the word ‘accumulated loss’ as the loss which the entity prior to getting merged or amalgamated would have been entitled to carry forward and set off under provisions 72 if the reorganisation of business or conversion or amalgamation or demerger had not taken place. On overall consideration of section 72A, we note that section 72A does not deal with current year losses but only deals with accumulated loss and unabsorbed depreciation from preceeding years. Ld. Counsel for the assessee has stated that the accumulated loss and unabsorbed depreciation of amalgamating companies and demerged undertaking were duly carried forward by the appellant u/s.72A of the Act which has been set off against the income in subsequent years and that the Revenue has not disputed set off of such brought forward loss in assessments completed for subsequent years and therefore Revenue has accepted the scheme of restructuring and has allowed the benefit of accumulated losses in the subsequent years.

14.

In the present appeal, we note that assessee has furnished regular return of income u/s.139(1) of the Act on 27.11.2012 totalling at Rs.2253.24 crore and the statutory time limit provided under the Act to revise the return for A.Y. 2012-13 is 31.03.2014. Now prior to the last date for filing the revised return, the scheme of amalgamation arrangement pending before the Hon’ble High Court of Bombay received the sanction with appointed date 01.04.2011. Sterlite Industries India Limited as well as Aluminium Division of Vedanta

37 Vedanta Limited

Limited demerged into the appellant w.e.f. 01.04.2011. Now prior to the merger/demerger Sterlite Industries India Limited and Vedanta Aluminium Limited have also filed their regular return of income declaring losses and subsequent to the sanctioning of the scheme of amalgamation arrangement by the Hon’ble High Court of Judicature, Bombay at Goa, the assessee re-drew the audited accounts duly incorporating the financial transactions of Sterlite Industries India Limited and Aluminium Division of Vedanta Limited and the current year losses for these two companies were set off against the current year profits of the assessee company existed prior to the merger/demerger. Now the scheme of merger/demerger has got the assent by the Division Bench of Hon’ble High Court of judicature, Bombay at Goa vide order dated 12.08.2013 dismissing the Revenue’s appeal and thereby confirming the order passed by the Single judge on 03.04.2013 sanctioning the scheme. So it remains an admitted fact that prior to the filing of the regular return of income on 27.11.2012 the scheme was already submitted and pending for approval from the Hon’ble High Court of Bombay at Goa and that after filing the regular return of income on 27.11.2012, sanction/approval received on 03.04.2013 and the assessee had sufficient time to revise the return upto 31.03.2014 and in between when the matter was taken up by certain shareholders against the order dated 03.04.2013, the Division Bench of Hon’ble Bombay High Court dismissed the Revenue’s appeal vide order dated 12.08.2013 and therefore assessee validly filed a revised Income Tax Return on 21.03.2014 declaring loss of Rs.1179.40 crore. All these series of events clearly indicate that the assessee has acted within the legally permissible limits provided under the Act and has filed the regular return, revised the return as well as revised the computation of income based on the approval of the Scheme of Amalgamation

38 Vedanta Limited

arrangement by the Hon’ble Bombay High Court at Goa and to give the effect to this scheme the total business income for the year has been computed and since certain merged/demerged entities were having current year losses they had to be taken care of while calculating the income for the year and therefore after considering the current year loss of the merged/demerged entities the final income for the year turned into loss. Therefore, in our considered view firstly section 72A of the Act has no application on the present set of facts as it is a case of the set off of current year losses against the current year income and it is not a case of set off of accumulated losses or accumulated depreciation of preceeding years the entities prior to the merger/demerger. Secondly, in the subsequent years Revenue has not disputed the set off of accumulated losses and unabsorbed depreciation and therefore Revenue has accepted the scheme of restructuring and lastly the scheme of merger, amalgamation/ demerger cannot be held to be a colourable devise because carrying out of such activity of merger/demerger/amalgamation is provided under the law and the scheme has been placed before the Hon’ble High Court of Bombay as well as Hon’ble High Court of Madras and after due examination of the scheme and considering the contentions of all the parties Hon’ble High Court of Bombay and Madras had given the sanction. We therefore find that ld. Assessing Officer erred in disallowing the current year losses at Rs.2470.72 crore incurred in the Aluminium business Division of Vedanta Aluminium Limited as well as current year loss of Sterlite Industries India Limited against the current year income of the assessee company. Finding of lower authorities on this issue is reversed. Ground Nos.2 and 3 to 3.3 raised by the assessee are hereby allowed.

39 Vedanta Limited

15.

The second issue raised in Ground Nos. 4.1 to 4.4 is against disallowance u/s. 14A of the Act. We observe that assessee has earned dividend income of Rs.1049.87 crore which includes the dividend received from mutual funds as well as subsidiary companies and claimed exemption u/s. 10(34) of the Act. Assessee has offered suo motu disallowance of Rs.1,78,48,472/- in respect of salary and administrative cost. However, ld. Assessing Officer has disregarded the calculation made by the assessee and applied Rule 8D(2)(ii) and 8D(2)(iii) computing interest disallowance at Rs.469.24 crore and indirect expenditure of 0.5% of the average value of investments calculated at Rs.77.80 crore. First fold of contention made by ld. Counsel for the assessee is that ld. Assessing Officer erred in mechanically applying Rule 8D without recording any valid satisfaction by ignoring the suo motu disallowance offered by the assessee computed on a rationale and scientific basis and also submitted that ld. Assessing Officer has not even discussed about the incorrectness of expenses suo motu offered and in absence of such valid satisfaction disallowance u/s. 14A r.w.s 8D is completely invalid and also referred to judicial precedents referred supra. Reliance has also been made to various other decisions carried out in assessee’s other group concerns wherein also there was absence of any proximate nexus of expenditure with dividend income being established and in the absence of valid satisfaction qua correctness of suo motu disallowance u/s. 14A has been deleted.

16.

We note that recording of valid satisfaction has to be examined on each year to year basis since the Assessing Officer carries outs its work each year in a separate manner. In the instant case for the year under appeal, ld. Assessing Officer has asked the assessee to explain why the disallowance u/s.14A r.w.s 8D should not be made

40 Vedanta Limited

and such query has been made by the Assessing Officer giving reference to the examination of the Balance Sheet where assessee has been holding huge investments which are earning dividend income as well as the submissions filed by the assessee for the calculation of suo motu disallowance. It remains an admitted fact that assessee company has earned the dividend income of Rs.1049.87 crore and the average investments over the year are Rs.15,916.63 crore. It is also noted that huge amount of dividend has been received from mutual funds as well as investments in subsidiary companies. Section 14A(2) of the Act provides that the Assessing Officer shall determine the amount of expenditure incurred in relation to such exempt income which does not form part of the total income under this Act in accordance with such method as may be prescribed if the Assessing Officer having regard to the accounts of the assessee is not satisfied with the correctness of the claim of the assessee in respect of such expenditure in relation to income which does not form part of total income under this Act. We find that ld. Assessing Officer has examined the Balance Sheet but then examining each and every entry in the books related to expenditure incurred in connection to earning dividend income of such huge Limited Company is next to impossible for an Assessing Officer and also to minutely verify about the claim made by the assessee. In such scenario, ld. Assessing Officer is left with only two options, firstly either accepting the submissions and the details furnished by the assessee computing suo motu disallowance at its face value or to apply Rule 8D of the Income Tax Rules. There is no mechanism with the Assessing Officer to verify the correctness of the disallowance suo motu offered by the assessee considering the magnitude of accounts of the assessee in appeal before us. Therefore, what remains is the application of Rule 8D. In our considered opinion, ld.

41 Vedanta Limited

Assessing Officer has recorded proper satisfaction of being not satisfied with the correctness of the claim of the assessee and moved on to apply Rule 8D of the Act. Therefore, this ground of the assessee that impugned disallowance is uncalled for as ld. Assessing Officer has not recorded any valid satisfaction does not have any merit and the same is hereby dismissed.

17.

So far as the alternative contention of the assessee regarding computation of disallowance u/s.8D(2)(ii) and 8D(2)(iii) of the Act is concerned, we note that under Rule 8D(2)(ii) interest disallowance has been made by the Assessing Officer at Rs.469.24 crore. We note that the accumulated interest free funds in the form of share capital, reserves and surplus at the year end appearing in the Balance sheet at Rs.35,277.83 crore are much more than the closing value of investment at Rs.21,952.29 crore. We find that Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of South Indian Bank Limited v. CIT (2021) 438 ITR 1, Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the case of CIT vs. HDFC Bank Ltd. (2014) 366 ITR 505 and the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of CIT (LTU) v. Reliance Industries Ltd. (2019) 410 ITR 466 have consistently held that if the own funds of the appellant exceeds the investments it needs to be presumed that such investments are made out of interest free funds. Therefore, in absence of any specific finding of the Assessing Officer about the application of borrowed funds for making investments yielding exempt income, in the light of the above judicial precedents, we are of the considered view that disallowance u/s. 14A r.w.s Rule 8D(2)(ii) is uncalled for and to this extent disallowance u/s.14A of the Act is deleted.

18.

As regards the third limb i.e. Rule 8D(2)(iii) as per which ld. Assessing officer has calculated the disallowance u/s.14A at 42 Vedanta Limited

Rs.79.58 crore applying 0.5% rate on the average investments at Rs.1596.63 crore, we take note of the Special Bench decision in the case of ACIT vs. Vireet Investment Pvt. Ltd. (2017) 82 Taxman 415 (Delhi - Trib.) (SB)/165 ITD 27, judgment of Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of ACB India Ltd. vs. ACIT, (2015) 374 ITR 108 (Del), and that in the case of PCIT v. Caraf Builders and Constructions Pvt. Ltd., reported in (2019) 414 ITR 122 (Delhi High Court) consistently holding that for the purpose of Rule 8D(2)(iii) only those investments which actually yield exempt income during the year have to be taken into consideration. Also, we note that assessee has earned dividend income from mutual funds which normally recovers the charges from the assessee to maintain the mutual funds and for switching the funds in mutual funds and therefore any further disallowance under rule 8D(2)(iii) of the Act towards indirect expenditure for investing in mutual funds is uncalled for.

19.

We therefore deem it appropriate that for the specific purpose for calculation of disallowance u/s. 14A read with Rule 8D(2)(iii), the matter needs to be restored to the file of Assessing Officer before whom the assessee shall furnish details of investments yielding exempt income (excluding the investment made in the mutual funds as well as investment made in subsidiary/ holding companies for business purposes) and in the light of the decision of Hon’ble Special Bench in the case of ACIT vs. Vireet Investment Pvt. Ltd. (supra) ld.Assessing Officer shall carry out verification of the details filed by the assessee and recompute the disallowance under Rule 8D(2)(iii) of the Act and shall also give set off of the suo motu disallowance offered by the assessee in the Income Tax Return. Thus, Ground Nos. 4.1 to 4.4 raised by the assessee are partly allowed for statistical purposes.

43 Vedanta Limited

20.

Ground No. 5 is against the addition for provision for unascertained liability. Facts stated are that the assessee purchased copper concentrate for production of copper Anode, Cathode, continuous copper rods. It is claimed that in view of fluctuations in price of copper and as per prevailing international practices, assessee makes the purchases on the basis of provisional price for the quotational period and the final price is finalized at the end of the quotational period. However, where the quotational period ends after the close of financial year, the liability is recognized at the end of the financial year because it is finally settled in the subsequent year. It is claimed that the issue raised is covered in favour of the assessee by the decision of Coordinate Bench Delhi in assessee’s own case for A.Y. 2010-11 vide ITA 1484/Del/2019 dated 09.10.2019. Considering the same, we deem it appropriate to restore the issue to the file of Assessing Officer for necessary verification of the assessee’s contention in the light of the decision of Coordinate Bench in assessee’s own case referred supra. Ground No.5 raised by the assessee is allowed for statistical purposes.

21.

Ground Nos. 6 and 6.1 are raised against the disallowance of additional depreciation which has been affirmed by the ld.CIT(A) confirming the observations made by the Assessing Officer that assessee is not engaged in the business of Manufacture of any article or thing in terms of section 2(29)(BA) of the Act. Ld. Counsel stated that in appellant’s own case of CIT v. Sesa Goa Limited 271 ITR 371 the Hon’ble Apex Court has held that extraction and processing of iron ore amounts to production and following the said judgment this Tribunal in the case of assessee has decided the very same issue for A.Y. 2008-09 to 2010-11 in favour of the assessee

44 Vedanta Limited

allowing the claim of additional depreciation. Respectively following the same, the claim of additional depreciation u/s.32(1)(iia) on the purchase of new Plant and Machinery acquired and installed in iron ore division is hereby allowed.

22.

Ground No. 7 is against the disallowance of unexplained stock in the books. During the course of Assessment Proceedings, ld. Assessing Officer asked the assessee to explain the difference in the value of stock shown in Form H-1 filed with the Indian Bureau of Mines (IBM) and valuation of closing stock appearing in the Balance Sheet as on 31.03.2022. Ld. Counsel for the assessee claimed that despite the submissions of the appellant in this regard, ld. Assessing Officer made addition observing that the assessee failed to provide proper reconciliation of stock by compiling the accounts of the assessee with the returns filed with the Indian Bureau of Mines. Even ld. DRP also confirmed the action. Assessee has claimed that the stock as per the return filed with IBM and books of account cannot match on account of moisture, crude ore in IBM return, sub grade core, stock outside the mines, handling loss, purchase of ore and loan cargo etc. Further, It is also submitted that the excess value of stock has been shown in the Balance Sheet over and above the forms filed with the IBM and therefore there is no loss to the Revenue warranting any adjustment. It is further claimed from the assesee’s side that it has shown excess stock as closing stock over and above the stock reported in IBM and there need not be any case for disallowance or addition in this regard because once the stock is recorded in the books the source stands explained and the same cannot be treated as unexplained stock. We find force in the contention of ld. Counsel for the assessee and if the assessee has already shown excess value of stock over and above the stock

45 Vedanta Limited

furnished in the forms filed with IBM, then certainly there is no loss to the Revenue. However, since the Revenue Authorities have alleged that the assessee has failed to provide proper reconciliation of stock, we set aside this issue for the limited purpose to the file of Assessing Officer to only examine the veracity of the contention of the assessee and if its proved that assessee has shown excess stock as closing balance over and above the stock reported to IBM then no addition for unexplained stock on this issue will be called for. Ground No. 7 raised by the assessee is allowed for statistical purposes.

23.

Ground No.8 is against the addition of disallowance u/s. 14A for computing book profit. We find that the issue stands squarely covered by the judgment of Hon’ble Special Bench in the case of ACIT v. Bhushan Steels Limited vide ITA No. 593/Del/2015 dated 29.09.2015 consistently holding that disallowance u/s. 14A is not required to be added to arrive at the book profit. Even in the assessee’s own case this Tribunal vide order dated 21.09.2020 for A.Y. 2014-15 has deleted the similar disallowance In view thereof, Ground No. 8 raised by the assessee is hereby allowed.

24.

Ground No. 9 is against the disallowance adjustment of additional depreciation disallowed while computing the book profit. We find that the disallowance of additional depreciation has already been deleted while dealing with the Ground Nos. 6 and 6.1 placing reliance on the judgment of Hon’ble High Court in assessee’s own CIT vs. Sesa Goa Ltd. 271 ITR 331 where the Hon’ble court has held that extraction and processing of iron ore amounts to production and therefore since additional depreciation claimed has already been allowed, there remains no reason for making any adjustment for computing the book profit. Ground No. 9 raised by the assessee is hereby allowed.

46 Vedanta Limited

25.

Ground No. 10 and 10.2 has been raised against the Transfer Pricing Adjustment on account of international transaction of payment of Management fees. We observe that the assessee received Strategic Planning and Consultancy Services from Vedanta Resources PLC under Management Consultancy Agreement dated 29.03.2015 for providing services in the nature of Strategic Advice, Financial and Treasury and Legal advice, Marking Advice, IT Support, Human Resources Management. For the purpose of Transfer Pricing documentation the aforesaid transactions were benchmarked using Transactional Net Margin Method as the appropriate method. Further since the margin of the appellant is 4.3% which is higher than that of the comparable companies @4.07% the international transactions undertaken by the appellant was regarded to have been taken at Arm’s Length Price. Ld. TPO observed that assessee failed to show any tangible evidence that some direct benefit is derived nor the assessee could produce any evidence to substantiate the payment for the remaining 4 sub heads except Strategic Advice. Thus, ld. TPO only allowed 1/5th of total payments at ALP and for the remaining 4/5th the value was treated as Nil resulting into alleged adjustment. Before us ld. Counsel for the assessee has contended that assessee has entered into intra group services agreement with Associated Enterprise in the year 2005 and since then the turnover has increased multiple times and the growth is almost 353% in seven years which itself indicate that tangible and direct evidence have been derived by the appellant from the use of intra group services. In support, reliance has been placed on the decision of Coordinate Bench, Delhi in the case of Aricent Technologies (Holdings) Limited vide order ITA No.90/Del/2013 order dated 26.07.2019and the decision of Hon’ble Bombay High Court in 47 Vedanta Limited

the case of CIT v. Merck Ltd. in ITA No 272/2014. It has also been claimed that similar payments have been made in the earlier years as well but neither ALP nor allowability of the same has ever been disturbed by the ld. TPO/Assessing Officer in the assessment for those years. Therefore, there being no change in the facts on the addition/adjustment made in this year should be deleted on this ground alone. However, during the course of the hearing itself, it is brought to our notice that in the subsequent year 2014-15 similar issue has been adjudicated by this Tribunal vide order dated 21.09.2020 in ITA No. 12/Del/2020 whereby the issue has been set aside to the file of ld.TPO for afresh adjudication and against the said decision the assessee has preferred appeal before the Hon’ble Delhi High Court vide ITA No. 163 of 20021 which is currently pending for adjudication. Considering the same and there being no change in the facts, we deem it appropriate that the issue deserves to be restored to the file of ld.TPO for fresh adjudication on due consideration of judicial precedents referred and relied by ld. Counsel for the assessee as well as to verify the contentions of the assessee about the growth in last several years demonstrating tangible and direct benefits derived by the appellant from use of intra group services. Ground Nos. 10 to 10. 2 raised by the assessee are allowed for statistical purposes.

26.

Ground Nos. 10.3 and 10.4 are against the Transfer Pricing adjustment on account of the interest on loan paid to Associated Enterprises. We observe that the appellant paid Rs.105.56 crore as interest on loan borrowed from Associated Enterprises namely Vedanta Resources Holdings Ltd., Welter Trading Limited, Cyprus. For arriving at ALP, assessee relied upon USD Industrial curve rates keeping in view the credit rating of the appellant. However, ld. TPO

48 Vedanta Limited

disregarded the economic analysis undertaken by the assessee and proceeded with the prime lending rates of the currency in which loans are borrowed and made alleged adjustment at Rs.2,58,82,219/-. Ld. Counsel has claimed that the rates applied by the TPO are only applicable in respect of borrowers enjoying high credit rate whereas the loan instrument issued by the appellant have a low credit rating of BB- or B+. Therefore, the benchmark analysis undertaken by the ld.TPO is not in accordance with law. For this reliance has been placed on the decision of Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of Cotton Naturals Private Limited 276 ITR 445 (Delhi) where the Hon’ble court has held that examination of loan agreement and determination of credit rating is required before benchmarking analysis of inter company loans. Similar view has also been taken by the Coordinate Bench Hyderabad in the case of Neovantage Innovation Park Private Limited Vs. ITO in IT(TP) Nos. 340 & 456/Hyd/2022. Further, it is brought to our notice that for the A.Y. 2014-15 in assessee’s own case similar adjustments were made however, ld. DRP rejected the approach of the ld. TPO to consider prime lending rate of the respective currencies as the Arms Length rate of interest and has directed the TPO to compute Arms Length Price on the basis of LIBOR + and after giving effect to the directions of ld. DRP the adjustments made by the ld. TPO on account of payment of interest was deleted. Considering the same as well as identical facts, we deem it appropriate that this issues also deserves to be restored to the file of ld. TPO for carrying out similar exercise as has been carried out for A.Y. 2014-15 as per the directions given by ld. DRP and after considering the relevant details filed by the assessee shall decide in accordance with law. Thus, Ground Nos. 10.3 and 10.4 raised by the assessee are allowed for statistical purposes.

49 Vedanta Limited

27.

Remaining grounds being general, consequential in nature needs no adjudication.

28.

In the result, the appeal of the assessee is partly allowed for statistical purposes.

Order pronounced on 06th November 2026 under Rule 34(5) of the Income Tax (Appellate Tribunal) Rules, 1963. (VINAY BHAMORE) (MANISH BORAD) JUDICIAL MEMBER ACCOUNTANT MEMBER Panaji; दिन ांक / Dated : 06th November, 2026. Satish Satish Kumar Kumar Madishetty Madishetty Date: 2026.11.16 16:44:09 +05'30'

आदेश की प्रतिलिपि अग्रेषित / Copy of the Order forwarded to : अपीलार्थी / The Appellant. 1. प्रत्यर्थी / The Respondent.

2.3.

The Pr. CIT concerned. विभागीय प्रतिनिधि, आयकर अपीलीय अधिकरण, Panaji 4. ‘DB’ Bench / DR, ITAT, Panaji ‘DB’ Bench गार्ड फ़ाइल / Guard File. 5. आदेशानुसार / BY ORDER,

////

More judgments on Section 144C(13)

All 3,530 judgments and leading authorities on Section 144C(13) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →