SABRE GLBL INC.,UNITED STATES OF AMERICA vs. ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX , NEW DELHI

PDF · subscribers
ITA 3233/DEL/2023Status: DisposedITAT Delhi18 November 2026AY 2021-228 pages

In favour of the assessee: the assessee's appeal was allowed. From the AI summary of this appeal.

AI SummaryAllowed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal held that the issue concerning the taxability of receipts as FTS/FIS had been decided in favour of the assessee in the case of Sabre Marketing Nederland vs. ACIT, ITA Nos. 410, 7534 & 381/Del/2019, dated 07.01.2026. The Tribunal extracted relevant portions from this coordinate bench decision, which relied on judicial precedents like CIT vs. Telstra Singapore PTE Ltd. and DIT vs. New Skies Satellite BV. The reasoning emphasized that the assessee did not grant the use or right to use any Intellectual Property Rights, nor did it provide secret processes or formulas. The Tribunal noted that amendments in domestic law cannot be automatically read into the treaty. It also referred to the Salesforce.com Singapore Pte decision, which held that services rendered without imparting knowledge or transferring experience/skill do not fall within the ambit of Article 12 of the treaty. The Tribunal concluded that the amounts received by the assessee from its Indian customers would not constitute Royalty as per Article 12(4) of the India-Netherlands Treaty (applied analogously to the India-US Treaty in the cited precedent) and that the assessee was justified in not offering them to tax. Consequently, grounds 1 to 7 were decided in favour of the assessee. The findings in the lead case (AY 2020-21) were applied mutatis mutandis to AYs 2021-22 and 2022-23. The operative direction was to allow the appeals.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Sabre Glbl Inc., USA, is a US-based company providing technology solutions to the global travel and tourism industry, primarily facilitating airline reservations and bookings through agreements with airlines and hotels. For assessment years 2020-21, 2021-22, and 2022-23, the assessee received fees amounting to Rs.59,25,92,157/- from Indian customers. The assessee claimed these receipts as exempt in India, asserting no physical business presence and that the income was not taxable as Royalty or Fees for Technical Services (FTS)/Fees for Included Services (FIS) under the India-US Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA). The Assessing Officer (AO), following Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP) directions, held these receipts as taxable as FIS/FTS. The assessee appealed these orders.

What were the issues?

1. Whether receipts amounting to Rs.59,25,92,157/- from customers in India qualify as Fee for Technical Services (FTS) under Section 9(1)(vii) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, and Article 12(4) of the India-US DTAA? (Mixed Law and Fact) 2. Whether the services provided by the assessee to its Indian customers, implemented on proprietary software with systems/servers located outside India and without human intervention, qualify as FTS/FIS under the Act or the treaty, considering the judgment in Bharti Cellular Ltd. vs. CIT? 3. Whether the standard services and solutions provided by the assessee to all its customers in India mean the consideration received does not qualify as FTS/FIS, as per Kotak Securities Ltd.? 4. Whether the services rendered by the assessee make available any technical knowledge, skill, or know-how to its Indian customers, enabling them to apply it independently, so as to qualify as FTS/FIS? 5. Whether trainings provided by the assessee to its customers are for the use of services only, not for transferring knowledge or skills for independent future application? 6. Whether the scope of income taxable as FIS/FTS is at par with proposed taxation of automated digital services under UN Model Convention Article 12B? Assessee's Contentions: The assessee argued that it has no Permanent Establishment (PE) in India and its systems are located outside India. It relied on a coordinate bench decision in Sabre Marketing Nederland vs. ACIT, which dealt with identical facts and was decided in favour of the assessee. The assessee further contended that services do not make available technical knowledge, are standard offerings, and trainings are for service usage, not skill transfer. It also argued that the services are provided without human intervention and do not involve the use of Intellectual Property Rights. Revenue's Contentions: The Revenue relied on the detailed findings in the Assessing Officer's order.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 9(1)(vii),Section 143(3),Section 144C(13)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, DELHI BENCH “D” NEW DELHI

Before: SHRI MAHAVIR SINGH & SHRI SANJAY AWASTHI

For Appellant: Shri Tarandeep Singh, Adv. & Shri Sandeep Yadav, Adv
For Respondent: Dr. Shalini Verma, CIT DR
Hearing: 07.10.2026

IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL DELHI BENCH “D” NEW DELHI BEFORE SHRI MAHAVIR SINGH, VICE PRESIDENT AND SHRI SANJAY AWASTHI, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER ITA No.2211/DEL/2023 Assessment Year: 2020-21 SABRE GLBL INC. Vs. ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME 3150, Sabre Drive, Southlake, TAX, Texas 76092, Circle 3(1)(2), International Taxation, United States of America, 4th Floor, Block E-2, Civic Centre, USA, 76092. J.L. Nehru Marg, New Delhi, PAN No. AAACT7216Q Delhi 110002. Appellant Respondent ITA No.3233/DEL/2023 Assessment Year: 2021-22 SABRE GLBL INC. Vs. ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME 3150, Sabre Drive, Southlake, TAX, Texas 76092, Circle 3(1)(2), International Taxation, United States of America, 4th Floor, Block E-2, Civic Centre, USA, 76092. J.L. Nehru Marg, New Delhi, PAN No. AAACT7216Q Delhi 110002. Appellant Respondent & ITA No.720/DEL/2025 Assessment Year: 2022-23 SABRE GLBL INC. Vs. ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME 3150, Sabre Drive, Southlake, TAX, Texas 76092, Circle 3(1)(2), International Taxation, United States of America, 4th Floor, Block E-2, Civic Centre, USA, 76092. J.L. Nehru Marg, New Delhi, PAN No. AAACT7216Q Delhi 110002. Appellant Respondent Assessee by Shri Tarandeep Singh, Adv. & Shri Sandeep Yadav, Adv. Revenue by Dr. Shalini Verma, CIT DR Date of hearing: 07.10.2026 Pronouncement on 18.11.2026 O R D E R PER SANJAY AWASTHI, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER: 1. These are a batch of three appeals pertaining to the same assessee. Since the issues are common across these appeals, all these three appeals are being disposed of through a single order. For the purposes of this adjudication, ITA 2211/Del/2023 pertaining to AY 2020- 21, is being taken as the lead case.

2.

ITA 2211/Del/2023 arises from order of Ld. Assessing Officer, order dated 15.06.2023, passed u/s 143(3) r.w.s. 144C(13) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereafter as “the Act”).

2.1 In this case, the assessee is a company incorporated in USA. During the year under consideration, there are seen to be earnings as fees from various entities amounting to Rs.59,25,92,157/-. The assessee is a tax resident of USA and provides technology solutions to the Global Travel & Tourism Industry. The primary activity of the assessee in India is to facilitate airline reservations and bookings and for this purpose, the assessee is seen to have entered into agreements with various Indian and International Airlines. We find that there are agreements with various hotels in India also. The assessee claimed the entire receipts as exempt from taxation in India on the ground that there is no office or any physical business in India. Moreover, there is a claim that the receipts are not taxable as Royalty or Fees for Technical Services (FTS)/FIS under the India US – DTAA.

2.2 The Ld. Assessing Officer has given a detailed reasoning, following the DRP’s directions dated 10.05.2023, that the entire set of receipts were taxable as FIS/FTS.

2.3 The aggrieved assessee has approached the ITAT with the following effective grounds of appeal:

1.

“That on facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. Assessing Officer (hereinabove referred to as the ‘ld. AO’)/Dispute Resolution Panel (hereinabove referred to as the ‘DRP’) have erred inholding that receipts amounting to Rs.59,25,92,157/- from customers in India qualify as Fee for Technical Services (‘FTS’) under the provisions of Section 9(1)(vii) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (‘the Act’); 2. That on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. AO/DRP have erred in holding that receipts amounting to Rs.59,25,92,157/- from customers in India qualify as Fee for Included Services (‘FIS’) under the provisions of Article 12(4) of the Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement between India and USA (‘the Treaty’); 3. That on facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. AO/DRP have erred in not appreciating that services provided by Appellant to its Indian customers are provisioned through system/servers located outside India, without human intervention, and thus, the services do not qualify as FTS/FIS under the provisions of the Act or the treaty, in accordance with the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Bharti Cellular Ltd. vs. CIT (2010) 193 Taxman 97 (SC); 4. That on facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. AO/DRP has erred in not appreciating that the Appellant provides similar standard services and solutions to all its customers in India, and therefore the consideration received by the Appellant does not qualify as FTS/FIS under the provisions of the Act or the Treaty, in accordance with the judgement of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Kotak Securities Ltd. [(2016) 67 taxmann.com 356]; 5. That on facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. AO/DRP have erred in not appreciating that services rendered by the Appellant do not “make available” any technical knowledge, skill, know-how etc. to its customers in India such that the customers can apply the same on its own without recourse to the Appellant; 6. That on facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. AO/DRP have erred in not appreciating that trainings provided by the Appellant to its customer are only for use of services and not for transfer of knowledge or skills to enable customers to apply such services independently in future. 7. That on facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. AO has erred in holding that the scope of income taxable as FIS/FTS is at par with the proposed taxation of automated digital services under the proposed Article 12B of the United Nations (‘UN’) Model Convention and therefore receipts from customers in India qualify as FTS/FIS.” …………. 3. Before us the Ld. AR argued with the help of detailed paper books and submitted that in all the three appeals the central issue was whether the fees received by the assessee for provision of Airline/Hotel Solution Products, which are implemented on its proprietary software, are chargeable to tax in India as FTS/FIS or not. It was the submission that the assessee does not have a PE in India and the systems used to provide the impugned services are located outside India. The Ld. AR, thereafter placed for our perusal a coordinate bench decision in the case of Sabre Marketing Nederland vs. ACIT, ITA Nos. 410, 7534 & 381/Del/2019, order dated 07.01.2026, admittedly a group company of the assessee. It was pointed out by the Ld. AR that an identical issue has been decided in this case in favour of the assessee. The Ld. AR stated that the facts in the present set of three appeals were identical to the facts prevailing in the Sabre Marketing Nederland (supra) case. Accordingly, the Ld. AR pointed out that in pages 7 to 16 of this order the issue has been discussed and decided in favour of the assessee. The Ld. AR took us through the order of the coordinate bench of ITAT in this regard.

3.1 The Ld. DR, on the other hand, relied on the detailed findings in the Ld. AO’s order.

4.

We have considered the submissions of Ld. AR/DR. We find that the impugned issue has been decided in favour of the assessee in the case of Sabre Marketing Netherland (supra). At this stage we can do no better than to extract the relevant portions from this order and apply the same to the facts of the present three appeals. The extracts are as under:

“7. In the case before us, the Assessee had not given any use or right to use any Intellectual Property Rights to the Customers. In fact this has been addressed by the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of CIT vs. Telstra Singapore PTE Ltd. reported in 467 ITR 302 (Del.). The relevant operative portion of the said judgment is reproduced below: ……. 8. As per the definition of Royalty given in the Treaty, the Assessee should have given the Secret Process or Formula to the Customers in India, which is factually not done in the instant case before us. Reliance in this regard has been rightly placed by the Learned AR on the decision of the Hon’ble Delhi High court in the case of DIT vs. New Skies Satellite BV reported in 382 ITR 114 (Del.) wherein the relevant operative portion is reproduced hereunder: -------- 8.1 Though this decision was rendered in the context of functions performed by the Transponder, the analogy could be drawn to the facts of the instant case before us. One of the essences of this judgment is that any amendment made in the domestic law cannot be read automatically into the Treaty for the purpose of taxability of Royalty or otherwise. 9. The third limb of the definition of Royalty under the treaty speaks about information concerning industrial, commercial or scientific experience. To explain the same, the Learned AR rightly placed reliance on the decision of this Delhi Tribunal in the case of Salesforce.com Singapore Pte vs. DDIT (IT) reported in 137 taxmann.com 3 (Del Trib.) dated 25.03.2022 wherein the relevant operative portion is reproduced hereunder: “13. We have given thoughtful consideration to the contentions of the Ld. DR and have duly considered the written submissions. In our understanding of the facts, the assessee provides web- based online access to its customer’s data hosted on servers located in data centers maintained by the assessee outside India. The assessee does not have any data centers in India and hence it cannot be considered to have a fixed place of business in India. The assessee neither has a place of management in India nor has any equipment or personnel in India. This fact has also been accepted by the Ld. CIT(A) in his order. Therefore, in the absence of granting any control over the equipment belonging to the assessee to its customers, the allegation of the AO that the amount so received will constitute ‘Royalty’ is not acceptable. 14. Further, the assessee does not provide any information concerning industrial, commercial, scientific experience. The assessee only processes the proprietary data of the customers and provides the result in form of desired reports etc. On this count also, it cannot be said that consideration for CRM services are in the nature of royalty. 15. In our considered opinion, if the services have been rendered de hors imparting of knowledge or transfer of any knowledge, experience or skill, then such services will not fall within the ambit of article 12 of the treaty. 16. Further, by granting access to the information forming part of the database, the assessee neither shares its own experience, technique or methodology employed in evolving databases with the users, nor imparts any information relating to them. 17. In our considered view, the income earned by the assessee form the Indian customers with respect to the subscription fees for CRM cannot be taxed as royalty as per Section 9(1)(vi) of the Act as well as article 12(3) of the treaty.”

9.1 It is pertinent to note that this decision has been affirmed by the Hon’ble Delhi High Court reported in 165 taxmann.com 580 (Del HC). This decision is relied upon only for the limited purpose of non-taxability of Royalty under the Treaty using the third limb of the definition given in the Treaty. 10. In view of the aforesaid observations and respectfully following the various judicial precedents relied upon hereinabove, we hold that the amounts received by the Assessee from its Indian customers would not constitute Royalty as per Article 12(4) of India- Netherlands Treaty and accordingly the Assessee was duly justified in not offering the same to tax in India.” Respectfully following the findings given in the case of Sabre Marketing Netherland (supra), the issue pertaining to ground nos. 1 to 7 in ITA 2211/Del/203 are decided in favour of the assessee.

4.1 Considering the decision rendered in ITA 2211/Del/2023, the finding therein will apply, mutatis mutandis, to the remaining two appeals for AYs 2021-22 & 2022-23 also.

5.

In the result, the three appeals of the assessee are allowed.

Order pronounced in the open court on 18.11.2026

Sd/- Sd/- (MAHAVIR SINGH) (SANJAY AWASTHI) VICE PRESIDENT ACCOUNTANT MEMBER Dated: 18.11.2026 *Kavita Arora, Sr. P.S. Copy forwarded to: 1. Appellant 2. Respondent 3. CIT 4. CIT(Appeals) 7

5.

DR: ITAT ASSISTANT REGISTRAR ITAT, NEW DELHI

More judgments on Section 9(1)(vii)

All 1,751 judgments and leading authorities on Section 9(1)(vii) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →