M/S DABUR INDIA LIMITED vs. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (TDS) AND ANOTHER

PDF · subscribers
W.P.(C)/15878/2022HC DelhiDLHC01043025202218 November 2022Bench: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANMOHAN,HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA7 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the impugned order dated October 26, 2022, was non-reasoned and failed to consider the three basic principles for deciding a stay application: prima facie case, balance of convenience, and irreparable injury. The Court noted that the requirement of paying 20% of the disputed demand is not a prerequisite in all cases and can be relaxed, citing the Supreme Court's decision in PCIT vs. M/s LG Electronics India Pvt. Ltd. (2018) 18 SCC 447, which allows tax authorities to grant stay orders on deposit of amounts lesser than 20% based on individual case facts. The Court also referred to the Office Memorandums which provide instances where relaxation is possible, such as when decisions of the Supreme Court or jurisdictional High Court favor the assessee. Consequently, the impugned order was set aside, and the matter was remanded back to the Commissioner of Income Tax for a fresh decision on the stay application after granting a personal hearing to the Petitioner. The Court clarified that no coercive action would be taken against the Petitioner until the stay application is decided.

What were the facts?

The Petitioner, M/s Dabur India Limited, filed several writ petitions challenging an order dated October 26, 2022, which dismissed their application for a stay of demand and directed payment of 20% of the outstanding demand. This demand arose from orders dated August 4, 2021, and September 8, 2020, passed by the Commissioner of Income Tax (TDS) under Section 201/201(1A) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The Petitioner was held to be an "assessee in default" for not deducting TDS under Section 194H on the cost of free samples given under sales promotion schemes, treating them as brokerage/commission. The total demand for Assessment Years 2013-14 to 2020-21 was Rs. 17,65,67,319/-. The Petitioner had appealed these orders and sought a stay, arguing that Section 194H was not applicable to free samples, citing the Delhi High Court's decision in CIT vs. Jai Drinks Pvt. Ltd. The Petitioner contended that their stay application was dismissed arbitrarily and without reasoning.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the order dated October 26, 2022, dismissing the Petitioner's application for stay of demand, is arbitrary and non-speaking, failing to consider the Petitioner's contentions regarding the non-applicability of Section 194H of the Income Tax Act, 1961, to free samples provided under sales promotion schemes. Assessee's Contentions: - The Petitioner argued that the provisions of Section 194H are not applicable to free samples given under sales promotion schemes, as these are trade incentives and not commission/brokerage. They relied on the Delhi High Court's decision in CIT vs. Jai Drinks Pvt. Ltd. (336 ITR 383). - They contended that the additional items provided with purchases are not commission/brokerage as no service was rendered by the purchaser. - The Petitioner stated that their stay application was dismissed arbitrarily and without dealing with their contentions. - They also pointed out that appeals for earlier financial years had been heard and judgments reserved. Revenue's Contentions: - The Revenue contended that the direction to deposit 20% of the demand is in accordance with Office Memorandums dated February 29, 2016, and July 31, 2017.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 194H,Section 201,Section 201(1A)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Heard together (8 matters)

W.P.(C) No.15850/2022
W.P.(C) 15851/2022
W.P.(C) 15878/2022
W.P.(C) 15879/2022
W.P.(C) 15880/2022
W.P.(C) 15881/2022
W.P.(C) 15892/2022
W.P.(C) 15912/2022

Read from the judgment's own cause title. This page is filed under one of them.

Neutral Citation Number: 2022/DHC/005003 W.P.(C) No.15850/2022 & connected matters Page 1 of 7 $~26, 27, 30 to 33, 35 & 40 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI 26 + W.P.(C) 15850/2022 & C.M.Nos.49302-49303/2022 M/S DABUR INDIA LIMITED ..... Petitioner Through: Mr.M.P.Rastogi with Mr.Manu K.Giri and Mr.K.N.Ahuja, Advocates. versus COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (TDS) AND ANOTHER ..... Respondents Through: Mr.Puneet Rai, Sr.Standing Counsel for the Revenue with Ms.Adeeba Mujahid, Advocate. 27 + W.P.(C) 15851/2022 & C.M.Nos.49305-49306/2022 M/S DABUR INDIA LIMITED ..... Petitioner Through: Mr.M.P.Rastogi with Mr.Manu K.Giri and Mr.K.N.Ahuja, Advocates. versus COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (TDS) AND ANOTHER ..... Respondents Through: Mr.Puneet Rai, Sr.Standing Counsel for the Revenue with Ms.Adeeba Mujahid, Advocate. 30 + W.P.(C) 15878/2022 & C.M.Nos.49436-49437/2022 M/S DABUR INDIA LIMITED ..... Petitioner Through: Mr.M.P.Rastogi with Mr.Manu K.Giri and Mr.K.N.Ahuja, Advocates. Digitally Signed By:JASWANT SINGH RAWAT Signing Date:21.11.2022 18:37:13 Signature Not Verified

Neutral Citation Number: 2022/DHC/005003 W.P.(C) No.15850/2022 & connected matters Page 2 of 7 versus COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (TDS) AND ANOTHER ..... Respondents Through: Mr.Puneet Rai, Sr.Standing Counsel for the Revenue with Ms.Adeeba Mujahid, Advocate. 31 + W.P.(C) 15879/2022 & C.M.Nos.49438-49439/2022 M/S DABUR INDIA LIMITED ..... Petitioner Through: Mr.M.P.Rastogi with Mr.Manu K.Giri and Mr.K.N.Ahuja, Advocates. versus COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (TDS) AND ANOTHER ..... Respondents Through: Mr.Puneet Rai, Sr.Standing Counsel for the Revenue with Ms.Adeeba Mujahid, Advocate. 32 + W.P.(C) 15880/2022 & C.M.Nos.49440-49441/2022 M/S DABUR INDIA LIMITED ..... Petitioner Through: Mr.M.P.Rastogi with Mr.Manu K.Giri and Mr.K.N.Ahuja, Advocates. versus COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (TDS) AND ANOTHER ..... Respondents Through: Mr.Puneet Rai, Sr.Standing Counsel for the Revenue with Ms.Adeeba Mujahid, Advocate. Digitally Signed By:JASWANT SINGH RAWAT Signing Date:21.11.2022 18:37:13 Signature Not Verified

Neutral Citation Number: 2022/DHC/005003 W.P.(C) No.15850/2022 & connected matters Page 3 of 7 33 + W.P.(C) 15881/2022 & C.M.Nos.49442-49443/2022 M/S DABUR INDIA LIMITED ..... Petitioner Through: Mr.M.P.Rastogi with Mr.Manu K.Giri and Mr.K.N.Ahuja, Advocates. versus COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (TDS) AND ANOTHER ..... Respondents Through: Mr.Puneet Rai, Sr.Standing Counsel for the Revenue with Ms.Adeeba Mujahid, Advocate. 35 + W.P.(C) 15892/2022 & C.M.Nos.49470-49471/2022 M/S DABUR INDIA LIMITED ..... Petitioner Through: Mr.M.P.Rastogi with Mr.Manu K.Giri and Mr.K.N.Ahuja, Advocates. versus COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (TDS) AND ANOTHER ..... Respondents Through: Mr.Puneet Rai, Sr.Standing Counsel for the Revenue with Ms.Adeeba Mujahid, Advocate. 40 + W.P.(C) 15912/2022 & C.M.Nos.49534-49535/2022 M/S DABUR INDIA LIMITED ..... Petitioner Through: Mr.M.P.Rastogi with Mr.Manu K.Giri and Mr.K.N.Ahuja, Advocates. Digitally Signed By:JASWANT SINGH RAWAT Signing Date:21.11.2022 18:37:13 Signature Not Verified

Neutral Citation Number: 2022/DHC/005003 W.P.(C) No.15850/2022 & connected matters Page 4 of 7 versus COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (TDS) AND ANOTHER ..... Respondents Through: Mr.Puneet Rai, Sr.Standing Counsel for the Revenue with Ms.Adeeba Mujahid, Advocate. Date of Decision: 18th November, 2022 CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MANMOHAN HON’BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA J U D G M E N T MANMOHAN, J: 1. Present writ petitions have been filed challenging the order dated 26th October, 2022 dismissing the Petitioner’s application for stay of demand and directing the Petitioner to pay 20% of the total outstanding demand by 10th November, 2022. Petitioner also seeks stay of the demands raised by virtue of the orders dated 4th August, 2021 and 8th September, 2020 passed by Respondent No. 2 under Section 201/201(1A) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 [‘the Act’] for Assessment Years [AY] 2013-14 to 2020-21 till the disposal of the appeals filed before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals). 2. Learned counsel for the Petitioner states that the Respondent No. 2 passed orders dated 4th August, 2021 and 08th September, 2020 under Section 201/201(1A) of the Act holding that the Petitioner is an “assessee in default” on account of non-deduction of TDS under Section 194H of the Digitally Signed By:JASWANT SINGH RAWAT Signing Date:21.11.2022 18:37:13 Signature Not Verified

Neutral Citation Number: 2022/DHC/005003 W.P.(C) No.15850/2022 & connected matters Page 5 of 7 Act with respect to cost of free samples/goods given by the Petitioner under sales promotion scheme to the stockists thereby treating the cost of items of free samples given under sales promotion scheme as brokerage/commission under Section 194H of the Act. He states that a demand of Rs. 17,65,67,319/- is outstanding in the case of the Petitioner for the AY 2013- 14 to 2020-21. 3. Learned counsel for the petitioner states that the Petitioner filed appeals against the orders passed under Section 201/201(1A) of the Act and also filed a consolidated application dated 9th September, 2022 for seeking a stay on the demand till the disposal of the appeals for all the AYs stating that the provisions of Section 194H of the Act are not applicable on the free samples given under the sales promotion scheme as the same is a trade incentive and not a commission/brokerage as held by this High Court in the case of CIT vs. Jai Drinks Pvt. Ltd. in 336 ITR 383 (Del). He points out that the additional items allowed with the purchases are not commission/brokerage as contemplated under Section 194H of the Act because the purchaser has not rendered any service to the Petitioner. 4. Learned counsel for the petitioner states that the application for stay was dismissed vide order dated 14th September, 2022 holding that the Petitioner has not paid 20% of the disputed demand and has failed to produce any cogent reasons or financial constraints faced by it in payment of 20% of the outstanding demand. He states that the Petitioner filed another application dated 6th October, 2022 before the Respondent No. 2 seeking stay of the demand till the disposal of the appeal. He however states that the Petitioner’s application for stay was dismissed vide the impugned order dated 26th October, 2022 in an arbitrary and non-speaking Digitally Signed By:JASWANT SINGH RAWAT Signing Date:21.11.2022 18:37:13 Signature Not Verified

Neutral Citation Number: 2022/DHC/005003 W.P.(C) No.15850/2022 & connected matters Page 6 of 7 manner without dealing with the contentions raised by the Petitioner in its application. He lastly states that the Petitioner’s appeals for the financial years 2012-13 and 2013-14 have already been heard and judgment(s) reserved. 5. Issue notice. Mr.Puneet Rai, learned senior counsel accepts notice on behalf of the Respondents-Revenue. He states that the direction to deposit 20% of the demand is in accordance with the Office Memorandums dated 29th February, 2016 and 31st July, 2017. 6. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and having perused the two Office Memorandums, in question, this Court is of the view that the requirement of payment of twenty percent of disputed tax demand is not a pre-requisite for putting in abeyance recovery of demand pending first appeal in all cases. The said pre-condition of deposit of twenty percent of the demand can be relaxed in appropriate cases. Even the Office Memorandum dated 29th February, 2016 gives instances like where addition on the same issue has been deleted by the appellate authorities in earlier years or where the decision of the Supreme Court or jurisdictional High Court is in favour of the assessee. 7. In fact the Supreme Court in the case of PCIT vs. M/s LG Electronics India Pvt. Ltd. (2018) 18 SCC 447 has held that tax authorities are eligible to grant stay on deposit of amounts lesser than twenty percent of the disputed demand in the facts and circumstances of a case. The relevant portion of the said judgment is reproduced hereinbelow:- ‘Having heard Shri Vikramjit Banerjee, learned ASG appearing on behalf of the appellant and giving credence to the fact that he has argued before us that the administrative Circular will not operate as a fetter on the Commissioner Digitally Signed By:JASWANT SINGH RAWAT Signing Date:21.11.2022 18:37:13 Signature Not Verified

Neutral Citation Number: 2022/DHC/005003 W.P.(C) No.15850/2022 & connected matters Page 7 of 7 since it is a quasi-judicial authority, we only need to clarify that in all cases like the present, it will be open to the authorities, on the facts of individual case, to grant deposit orders of a lesser amount that 20%, pending appeal.’ 8. In the present case, the impugned order is non-reasoned. The three basic principles i.e. the prima facie case, balance of convenience and irreparable injury have not been considered while deciding the stay application. 9. Consequently, the impugned order is set aside and the matter is remanded back to the Commissioner of Income Tax for fresh decision on the application for stay. However, before deciding the stay application, the Commissioner of Income Tax shall grant a personal hearing to the authorised representative of the Petitioner. For this purpose, list the matter before the Commissioner of Income Tax on 05th December, 2022. 10. It is clarified that till the stay application filed by the petitioner is not decided, no coercive action shall be taken by the Respondents against the Petitioner in pursuance to the demand arising out of the impugned order. With the aforesaid directions, the present writ petition along with pending applications stand disposed of. MANMOHAN, J MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J NOVEMBER 18, 2022 KA Digitally Signed By:JASWANT SINGH RAWAT Signing Date:21.11.2022 18:37:13 Signature Not Verified

More judgments on Section 194H

All 1,396 judgments and leading authorities on Section 194H →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →