CIT v. Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders

349 ITR 336High Court2012#47 most cited

What is CIT v. Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders authority for?

Appellate authorities can entertain fresh claims or revised computations of income made by an assessee, even if these were not submitted through a revised return of income.

956

judgments rely on this decision, according to BharatTax’s citation analysis of 384,370 Indian tax judgments — from 2014 to 2026.

Also referred to as

Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders · 349 ITR 336 · Bombay High Court · appellate authority power · entertain fresh claim · additional ground of appeal · revised computation of income · absence of revised return · section 139 · Goetz India Ltd. · Tribunal power

Issues it is cited on

Judgments citing CIT v. Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders

Deputy CIT-5(1)(1), Mumbai vs. M/S Essar Shipping Limited, Mumbai

In the result, the appeal filed by the revenue stands dismissed

ITA 821/MUM/2022[2015-16]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai14 Nov 2022AY 2015-16

Bench: Shri Amit Shukla, Jm & Shri M Balaganesh, Am आयकरअपीलसं./ I.T.A. No. 821/Mum/2022 (निर्धारणवर्ा / Assessment Year: 2015-16) M/S Essar Shipping Dy. Cit-Circle – 5(3)(1), Limited R. No. 568, Aayakar बिधम/ Essar House, 11, K K Bhavan, M. K. Road, Vs. Marg, Mahalaxmi, Mumbai-400 020 Mumbai-400 034 स्थायीलेखासं./जीआइआरसं./ Pan No. Aacce3707D (अपीलाथी/Appellant) (प्रत्यथी / Respondent) : अपीलाथीकीओरसे/ Appellant By : Shri Prakash R. Mane, Ld. Dr प्रत्यथीकीओरसे/Respondent By : Shri Manoj Patwari/ Shri Rishav Patwari, Ld. Ars सुनवाईकीतारीख/ : 18.08.2022 Date Of Hearing घोषणाकीतारीख / : 14.11.2022 Date Of Pronouncement आदेश / O R D E R Per Amit Shukla: The Aforesaid Appeal Has Been Filed By The Revenue Against Impugned Order Dated 28.02.2022, Passed By Ld. Cit (Appeals)-56, Mumbai For The Quantum Of Assessment Passed U/S 143(3) R.W.S.

For Appellant: Shri Prakash R. ManeFor Respondent: Shri Manoj Patwari/ Shri
Section 115VSection 143(3)Section 28Section 43Section 92Section 92F

…d. CIT (A) based on the provision of law that, foreign dividend income has to be set off against the current year loss. In support of, Ld. CIT (A) has relied on the judgment of Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the case of Pruthvi Brokeers & Shareholders Pvt. Ltd. 349 ITR 336 and held that there is no fetters on the powers of CIT (A) to entertain the claim which has not been claimed in the return of income. 41 I.T.A. No. 821/Mum/2022 M/s Essar Shipping Limited 34. It is an undisputed fact that assessee had declared loss of Rs. 103,44,94,701/- in the return of income. It has also shown foreign dividend income of Rs. 1…

Assistant Commissioner of Income-Tax, Circle - 2, Pune vs. Nalco Water India Ltd., Pune

ITA 151/PUN/2022[2013-14]Status: DisposedITAT Pune07 Oct 2022AY 2013-14

Bench: Shri S.S.Godara & Shri G.D.Padmahshaliआयकर अपील सं. / Ita No.150 /Pun/2022 िनधा"रण वष" / Assessment Year : 2013-14 Nalco Water India Private Vs The Assistant Commissioner Limited, (Formerly Known As . Of Income Tax, Circle-2, Naclo Water India Limited) Pune. S.No.238/239, 3Rd Floor, Quadra 1, Panchshil, Magarpatta Road, Sade Satra Nali, Pune – 411028. Pan: Aaaco 4994 N Appellant / Assessee Respondent /Revenue आयकर अपील सं. / Ita No. 151/Pun/2022 िनधा"रण वष" / Assessment Year : 2013-14 The Assistant Commissioner Of Vs Nalco Water India Private Income Tax, Circle-2, Pune. . Limited, S.No.238/239, 3Rd Floor, Quadra 1, Hadapsar, Magarpatta Road, Sade Satra Nali, Pune – 411028. Pan: Aaaco 4994 N Appellant / Revenue Respondent / Assessee Assessee By Shri Ketan Ved – Ar Revenue By Shri Prashant Gadekar & Shri Piyush Kumar Singh Yadav – Dr Date Of Hearing 26/08/2022 Date Of Pronouncement 07/10/2022 आदेश/ Order Per S.S.Godara, Jm: These Assessee’S & Revenue’S Cross Appeals Ita No.150 & 151/Pun/2022 For A.Y. 2013-14, Arise Against The Cit(A)-13

Section 143(3)

…He could hardly rebut the fact that the assessee had raised its corresponding substantive grounds before the CIT(A) for the first time only. Honourable jurisdictional high court’s landmark decision in CIT vs. Pruthvi Brokers and Shareholders Pvt. Ltd., [2012] 349 ITR 336 has settled the law that such issue could very well be agitated before the CIT(A)’s for the first time. We thus accept the assessee’s arguments in principle and restore its instant first and foremost substantive ground to the Assessing Officer for his necessary computation / verification. The Revenue’s corresponding 4th substantive ground(supra)…

Nalco Water India Ltd., Pune vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-Tax, Circle - 2, Pune

ITA 150/PUN/2022[2013-14]Status: DisposedITAT Pune07 Oct 2022AY 2013-14

Bench: Shri S.S.Godara & Shri G.D.Padmahshaliआयकर अपील सं. / Ita No.150 /Pun/2022 िनधा"रण वष" / Assessment Year : 2013-14 Nalco Water India Private Vs The Assistant Commissioner Limited, (Formerly Known As . Of Income Tax, Circle-2, Naclo Water India Limited) Pune. S.No.238/239, 3Rd Floor, Quadra 1, Panchshil, Magarpatta Road, Sade Satra Nali, Pune – 411028. Pan: Aaaco 4994 N Appellant / Assessee Respondent /Revenue आयकर अपील सं. / Ita No. 151/Pun/2022 िनधा"रण वष" / Assessment Year : 2013-14 The Assistant Commissioner Of Vs Nalco Water India Private Income Tax, Circle-2, Pune. . Limited, S.No.238/239, 3Rd Floor, Quadra 1, Hadapsar, Magarpatta Road, Sade Satra Nali, Pune – 411028. Pan: Aaaco 4994 N Appellant / Revenue Respondent / Assessee Assessee By Shri Ketan Ved – Ar Revenue By Shri Prashant Gadekar & Shri Piyush Kumar Singh Yadav – Dr Date Of Hearing 26/08/2022 Date Of Pronouncement 07/10/2022 आदेश/ Order Per S.S.Godara, Jm: These Assessee’S & Revenue’S Cross Appeals Ita No.150 & 151/Pun/2022 For A.Y. 2013-14, Arise Against The Cit(A)-13

Section 143(3)

…He could hardly rebut the fact that the assessee had raised its corresponding substantive grounds before the CIT(A) for the first time only. Honourable jurisdictional high court’s landmark decision in CIT vs. Pruthvi Brokers and Shareholders Pvt. Ltd., [2012] 349 ITR 336 has settled the law that such issue could very well be agitated before the CIT(A)’s for the first time. We thus accept the assessee’s arguments in principle and restore its instant first and foremost substantive ground to the Assessing Officer for his necessary computation / verification. The Revenue’s corresponding 4th substantive ground(supra)…

Anita Jayant Oswal, Pune vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-Tax, Circle - 7, Pune

In the result, the appeal filed by the assessee stands dismissed

ITA 769/PUN/2018[2014-15]Status: DisposedITAT Pune26 Sept 2022AY 2014-15

Bench: Shri Inturi Rama Rao & Shri Partha Sarathi Chaudhuryआयकर अपील सं. / Ita No.769/Pun/2018 िनधा"रण वष" / Assessment Year: 2014-15 Anita Jayant Oswal, Vs. Dcit, Circle-7, Pune. Banglow No.1, Kumar Elite, Lane No.4, 110, Koregaon Park, Pune- 411001. Pan : Aaapo3272A Appellant Respondent Assessee By Shri Naresh Kumar : Revenue By : Shri M. G. Jasnani Date Of Hearing : 12.09.2022 Date Of Pronouncement : 26.09.2022 आदेश / Order Per Inturi Rama Rao, Am: This Is An Appeal Filed By The Assessee Directed Against The Order Of Ld. Commissioner Of Income Tax (Appeals)- 13, Pune [‘The Cit(A)’] Dated 15.02.2018 For The Assessment Years 2014-15. 2. The Appellant Raised The Following Grounds Of Appeal :- “The Appellant Respectfully Submits That The Appellant May Please Be Allowed To Take The Following Grounds Of Appeal Against The Order Of The Cit(A)-13, Pune In Appeal No Cit(A)-13/16-17/593 Dated 15/02/2018 For A.Y. 2014-15. (1) On The Facts & In The Circumstance Of The Case & In Law, The Hon'Ble Cit (A) Erred In Confirming The Action Of The Ld Ao In Rejecting The Claim Of Rs 31,79,890 Out Of The Total Claim Of Rs 1,24,71,110 Made U/S 54F Of The It Act-1961. The Appellant Craves Leave To Add, Alter, Amend Or Delete Any Or All Of The Above Mentioned Grounds Of Appeal.”

For Respondent: Shri M. G. Jasnani
Section 54Section 54F

…, cannot be made during the course of assessment proceedings. However, the ld. CIT(A) had entertained the additional claim u/s 54 placing reliance on the decision of the Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the case of CIT v. Prithvi Brokers & Shareholders (P.) Ltd., 349 ITR 336 (Bom.) and proceeded to examine the claim on merits. The ld. CIT(A) had extracted the details of investments made in the new two flats and held that two flats cannot be treated as one flat in view of the fact that they cannot be combined into single unit as they are located in different floors placing reliance on the decision of the Hon’ble Bomba…