1 orders · Page 1 of 1
The Tribunal erred in holding that clearance from the 'Committee of Disputes' was a mandatory requirement for entertaining appeals between the Income Tax Department (Union of India) and undertakings owned by State Governments. The Supreme Court's directions in the ONGC cases were intended for disputes involving Central Government entities and its public sector undertakings, not for disputes between State Government undertakings and Central Government departments. The Constitution provides its own mechanisms for resolving inter-governmental disputes. Therefore, the ITAT's view was vitiated by errors apparent on the face of the record and it misdirected itself by applying the ONGC precedents. The impugned order of the ITAT is quashed. The ITAT is directed to dispose of the appeals on merits expeditiously. The related appeals filed by the Revenue are also allowed on the same reasoning.