COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, KOLKATA - II, KOLKATA vs. M/S RUNGTA SONS (P) LTD.

PDF · subscribers
ITA/25/2012HC CalcuttaWBCHCO000300201201 April 20243 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the appeal lacked merit. It noted that the Hon'ble Supreme Court in T.N. Godavaram Thirumalpad –vs- Union of India had held that 'Net Present Value' is a fee. The assessee was compelled to make the payment of NPV to continue its mining operations. The ITAT had elaborately dealt with the issue and recorded its findings in paragraphs 12 to 15 of its order dated 5.8.2011. The CIT(A) had allowed the appeal, and the ITAT affirmed the CIT(A)'s order. Furthermore, the High Court referred to its own coordinate bench's decision in Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Tax 1 –vs-. Rungta Mines Ltd. [2018] 96 taxmann.com 166 (Calcutta), where a similar question was considered, and the appeal of the Income Tax Department was dismissed following Supreme Court judgments. Consequently, both substantial questions of law were answered in favour of the assessee and against the revenue.

What were the facts?

The Revenue (Commissioner of Income Tax, Kolkata - II) is in appeal before the High Court against the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT). The ITAT had upheld the order of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [CIT(A)], which deleted the disallowance of Rs. 3,95,56,500/- claimed by the assessee, M/s Rungta Sons (P) Ltd. This amount represented the Net Present Value (NPV) paid by the assessee for carrying on mining operations. The assessment year in question is 2006-07. The CIT(A) had allowed the assessee's appeal, and the ITAT affirmed this decision. The Revenue contends that the NPV relates to earlier previous years and is capital in nature, thus not allowable under Section 37(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

What were the issues?

1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal erred in law in upholding the order of the CIT(A) deleting the disallowance of ‘Net Present Value’ (NPV) of Rs.3,95,56,500/-, considering it relates to earlier previous years and is capital in nature, hence not allowable under Section 37(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961? (Mixed question of law and fact) 2. Whether the impugned order is bad, arbitrary, illegal, perverse, and a result of non-application of mind, liable to be set aside and/or quashed? (Question of law) Assessee's Contentions: The assessee argued that the NPV payment was necessary to continue its mining operations and was treated as a fee by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in T.N. Godavaram Thirumalpad –vs- Union of India. The ITAT elaborately dealt with this issue and recorded its findings. The CIT(A) allowed the appeal, and the ITAT affirmed it. Revenue's Contentions: The Revenue contended that the NPV relates to earlier previous years and is capital in nature, therefore, it cannot be allowed as a deduction under Section 37(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 37(1)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

O-25 IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA SPECIAL JURISDICTION (INCOME TAX) ORIGINAL SIDE ITA/25/2012 COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, KOLKATA - II, KOLKATA VS M/S RUNGTA SONS (P) LTD. BEFORE : THE HON'BLE JUSTICE SURYA PRAKASH KESARWANI -A N D- THE HON'BLE JUSTICE RAJARSHI BHARADWAJ DATED : 1ST APRIL, 2024 Appearance : Ms. Smita Das De, Adv. ….for appellant Mr. Subash Agarwal, Adv. Mr. Brijesh Kumar Singh, Adv. Mr. Nitish Bhanddery, Adv. ….for respondent 1. Heard Ms. Smita Das De, learned standing Counsel for the appellant and Sri Subash Agarwal, learned counsel assisted by Mr. Brijesh Kumar Singh, learned counsel for the respondent/assessee. 2. This appeal has been admitted on the following substantial questions of law:- “(a) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case the Income Tax, Appellate Tribunal erred in law in upholding the order of CIT(A) deleting the disallowance of ‘Net Present Value’ (NPV) of Rs.3,95,56,500/- without appreciating the fact that it relates to 2 earlier previous years and is capital in nature and hence cannot be allowed U/s. 37(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961? (b) Whether the impugned order is bad, arbitrary, illegal perverse and the same is nothing but a total non-application of mind of the concerned respondent and the same is liable to be set aside and/or quashed?” 3. The assessee paid a sum of Rs. 3,95,56,500/-towards the ‘Net Present Value’ so as to carry on the mining operation. Hon’ble Supreme Court in T.N. Godavaram Thirumalpad –vs- Union of India in I.A. No. 826 in W.P.(C) No. 202/1995 decided on 26.09.2005 held that the ‘Net Present Value’ is a fee. Without payment of NPV the assessee could not carry on his mining operation. He was compelled to make payment so as to continue his mining business. The Tribunal has elaborately dealt with the issue and recorded its finding in paragraph 12 to 15 of the impugned order dated 5.8.2011 in I.T.A. No. 933/Kol/2009 relating to assessment year 2006-07. The CIT(A) allowed the appeal of the respondent/assessee and the order of the CIT(A) was affirmed by the I.T.A.T. by the impugned order. 4. Similar question as involved in the present appeal, came for consideration before this Court in the case of Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Tax 1 –vs-. Rungta Mines Ltd. [2018] 96 taxmann.com 166 (Calcutta) in G.A. No. 2977 of 2015 decided on 21.06.2018. By the aforesaid order this Court dismissed the appeal 3 of the Income Tax Department, following some judgements of Hon’ble Supreme Court on principle of law. 5. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, the findings of fact recorded by the I.T.A.T. in the impugned order and the judgement of the Co-ordinate Bench in the case of Rungta Mines Ltd. (supra) we do not find any merit in this appeal. 6. Consequently, the appeal is dismissed. 7. Both the substantial questions of law are answered in favour of assessee and against the revenue. (SURYA PRAKASH KESARWANI, J.) (RAJARSHI BHARADWAJ, J.) GH/sg.

More judgments on Section 37(1)

All 7,382 judgments and leading authorities on Section 37(1) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →