C I T KOTA vs. M/S CHAMAN LAL and BROTHERS
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court decided the issues as follows: On the first issue concerning interest under Section 158BFA(1), the Court accepted the view of the Delhi High Court in *CIT vs. Mesco Airlines Ltd.*, holding that the assessee is bound to pay interest after 20 days from the date documents are supplied by the department. This issue was decided in favour of the department. On the second issue regarding surcharge under Section 113, the Court relied on the Supreme Court judgment in *CIT vs. Vatika Township Private Limited* and answered the issue in favour of the assessee. On the third issue concerning the reduction of the GP rate on unrecorded sales, the Court, in view of the factual matrix and the Tribunal's observations, answered the issue in favour of the assessee. The last issue regarding the deletion of additions under Section 158BC was also decided in favour of the assessee, based on the Tribunal's observation that the creditors were recorded in the books and no evidence of non-genuineness was found during the search. The appeals were disposed of accordingly.
What were the facts?
These appeals by the CIT, Kota (appellant) against M/s Chaman Lal & Brothers (respondent) concern assessment years not explicitly stated but relate to block assessments. The appeals challenge orders of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) which had partly allowed the assessee's appeals. The core dispute revolves around additions made by the Assessing Officer (AO) and the subsequent relief granted by the ITAT. Specifically, the appeals question the ITAT's interpretation of Section 113 regarding surcharge, its reduction of the GP rate on unrecorded sales, and the deletion of additions related to interest and sundry creditors under block assessment provisions.
What were the issues?
The High Court was called upon to decide the following questions of law: 1. Whether the Tribunal correctly interpreted Section 113 of the Income Tax Act concerning surcharge. 2. Whether the Tribunal was justified in reducing the GP rate from 15% to 8.5% on unrecorded sales, considering the Tribunal's reasoning that the GP included sales tax and octroi. 3. Whether the Tribunal was justified in deleting the addition of interest of Rs. 16,40,738/- levied under Section 158BFA(1). 4. Whether the Tribunal was justified in upholding the deletion of the levy of surcharge under Section 113. 5. Whether the Tribunal was justified in deleting additions of Rs. 8,78,292/- made by the AO under Section 158BC. Assessee's arguments: The assessee contended that the deletion of additions related to sundry creditors was justified as these were recorded in the books, no evidence of non-genuineness was found during the search, and they were not detected as a result of the search. The assessee also relied on the Supreme Court judgment in *CIT vs. Vatika Township Private Limited* to support the deletion of surcharge. Revenue's arguments: The revenue argued that interest under Section 158BFA(1) was mandatory for delayed payment. They also contended that the Tribunal's view on the GP rate was not just and proper and required modification. The revenue further argued that the addition of Rs. 8,78,292/- was made in accordance with Section 158BC.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN BENCH AT JAIPUR D.B. Income Tax Appeal No. 347 / 2008 C I T Kota ----Appellant Versus M/S Chaman Lal & Brothers ----Respondent Connected With D.B. Income Tax Appeal No. 568 / 2008 C I T Kota ----Appellant Versus M/S Chaman Lal & Brothers ----Respondent _____________________________________________________ For Appellant(s) : Ms. Parinitoo Jain For Respondent(s) : Mr. Gunjan Pathak _____________________________________________________ HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE K.S. JHAVERI HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE VIRENDRA KUMAR MATHUR Judgment 29/05/2017 In all these appeals identical question of law and facts are involved and they relate to the same assessee therefore, they are decided by this common judgment. 1. By way of these appeals, the appellant has assailed the judgment and order of the Tribunal whereby the Tribunal has partly allowed the appeal of the assessee. 2. This court while admitting the matters framed the following questions of law:-
(2 of 6)
In DBITA No. 347/2008 “i) Whether under the facts and circumstances of the case and in law the Tribunal has interpreted the provisions of Section 113 in its right perspective? ii) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the ld. ITAT is justified in reducing the g.p. rate from 15% to 8.5% applied on unrecorded sales by holding that the g.p includes sales tax at rate of 4% and octroi etc. At the rate of 2.5% when admittedly sales tax at the rate of 4% and octroi at the rate of 2.5% was not paid as the sales were unrecorded?” In DBITA No. 568/2008 i) Whether under the facts and circumstances of the case in law, the Tribunal was justified in deleting the addition of interest of Rs. 16,40,738/- levied u/s 158BFA(1) which is being contrary to the mandatory provisions of law of Section 158BFA(1)? ii) Whether under the facts and circumstances of the case and in law the Tribunal was justified in upholding the order of CIT(A) of deleting the levy of surcharge u/s 113 for Rs. 7,62,746/- contrary to the provisions of law? iii) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the ld. ITAT is justified in reducing the g.p. rate from 15% to 8.5% applied on unrecorded sales by holding that the g.p includes sales tax at the rate of 4% and octroi etc. at the rate of 2.5% was not paid as the sales were unrecorded? iv) Whether under the facts and circumstances of the case, the ld. ITAT is justified in deleting the additions of Rs. 8,78,292/- which has been made in accordance with the provisions of Section 158BC by the Assessing Officer. In DBITA No. 568/2008 3. Regarding the first issue, the counsel for the appellant contended that in view of the decision of Delhi High Court in case of CIT vs. Mesco Airlines Ltd. reported in [2010] 327 ITR 554 (Delhi), wherein under the law after the documents supplied by the department, the assessee is bound to pay interest for the
(3 of 6)
delayed payment. Taking into consideration the documents which are supplied after 20 days of statutory period to be given to the assessee thereafter, he is required to make payment. 4. On the other issue, counsel for the appellant contended that the view taken by the Tribunal is not just and proper and is required to be modified. However, counsel for the respondents has relied upon the judgment in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) vs. Vatika Township Private Limited reported in [2014] 367 ITR 466 (SC) wherein speaking for the Supreme Court it has been held in para 18 which reads as under:- “18. From the reading of the aforesaid statutory provisions in abstract, particularly relating to surcharge, it is clear that though provision for surcharge under the Finance Act has been in existence since 1995, in so far as levy of surcharge for block assessment is concerned, it is introduced by insertion of aforesaid proviso of Section 113. It is in this background, the question has arisen as to whether this surcharge on block assessment has been levied for the first time by the aforesaid proviso coming into effect from 01.06.2002 or it is only clarificatory in nature because of the reason that the provision for surcharge was made in the Finance Act in the year 1995 and that covered surcharge on block assessment as well.” 5. He contended that in view of the judgment in case of Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) vs. Vatika Township Private Limited (supra), the issue is required to be answered in favour of the assessee. 6. On the third issue, counsel for the appellant has contended that GP rate which is referred by the Tribunal in para 11 is contrary to law and is required to be reversed and fourth issue
(4 of 6)
regarding the deletion of 8,78,292/- under Section 158BC by the assessing officer. Counsel for the appellant has taken us to observations made by the AO in para 6.1 & 6.2 which was considered by the CIT(A) in para 7.3 which reads as under:-- “7.3. It is submitted that the AO has estimated unaccounted investment in purchases at the rate of 25% of cost of goods sold which is very high and also unjust. The ld. A/R has shown the copy of annexure A-31, A-32 and A-20. A-31 is a ledger account of a creditor and A-20 and A-22 are the ledger account of debtor. In the creditor ledger account generally the payment to the creditors are made between 1 month to 2 months whereas payment from the debtor are received within 7 days and in some time it took 2 months time. Purchases and sales are in rotation, therefore, in the fitness of the thing I take investment in 1 month purchases as unexplained investment in unaccounted business which is worked out as under:- Particulars A.Y. 97-98 A.Y. 98-99 Unrecorded sales as per AO 22,79,764/- 1,04,12,697/ - Less : Profit on sale @ 8.5% 1,93,780/- 8,85,079/- Cost of Goods sold 20,85,984/- 95,27,618/- Cost for 30 days of purchase 173832 793968 Set off of profit and investment in purchases 367612 (193780+173 832) Cost addition 173832 426086 Total addition 599918 Thus, the AO is directed to make addition of Rs. 599918 on account of investment in purchases as against addition of Rs. 26,97,148/-.”
(5 of 6)
However, in para 21 & 24, the Tribunal has observed as under:- “21. Ground No. 4 of the Revenue is against deleting the addition of Rs. 8,78,292/- on account of undisclosed sundry creditor. 24. After considering the rival submission, we noted that these are made creditors recorded in the regular books of accounts. Neither any document/paper/evidence was found during the course of search suggesting about non-genuiness of the creditor nor any evidences was gathered by the AO at his level for treating the said creditor as non-genuine. Section 158BC provides for computation of undisclosed income on the basis of evidences found in search and such other material or information available with AO relatable to such evidence. When the amount was duly disclosed in the balance sheet, it cannot be said that it was detected as a result of search. Therefore, these amounts cannot be treated as undisclosed income while completing the assessment u/s 158BC of the Income Tax Act. This view is supported by the following precedents:- Dang & Co. (P) Ltd. vs. DCIT 94 ITD 29 (Delhi) (TM) CIT vs. Ravi kant Jain [2001] 250 ITR 141 (Delhi) Bhagwati Prasad Kedia vs. CIT [2001] 248 ITR 562 (Cal.) M/s Jugal Kishore Modi Investment Co. Ltd. vs. ACIT XXXIII Tax World 1 Thus ground No. 4 of the Revenue is dismissed.” 8. On the first issue, in view of the decision of Delhi High Court (supra) the assessee is bound to pay interest after 20 days from the date of documents supplied by the department and therefore, we accept the view taken by the Delhi High Court. The issue is decided in favour of the department against the assessee and if the above amount is not paid, it will be open for the department
(6 of 6)
to recover the same and on issue No. 2 in view of the judgment in Vatika Township (supra), the issue is answered in favour of the assessee against the department. On the third issue, in view of the factual matrix and the observations made by the Tribunal on page 11, the issue is answered in favour of the assessee and the last issue is also decided in favour of assessee in view of the observations made in para 24 as reproduced hereinabove. In DBITA No. 347/2008 9. In this appeal, issue no. 1 is covered by issue no. 2 of Appeal No. 568/2008 and issue no. 2 is covered by issue no. 3 in Appeal No. 568/2008. The issues are accordingly answered in favour of assessee. 10. The appeals stand disposed off. (VIRENDRA KUMAR MATHUR),J. (K.S. JHAVERI),J. A.Sharma/17-18
More judgments on Section 113
- Mahendra Singh Dharampal & Co., Udaipur vs ACIT, Circle-2, UdaipurITA 229/JODH/2024[2011-12]Status: Disposed28 Jan 2026AY 2011-12
- Sab Developers Private Limited, Chandigarh vs Income Tax Officer, Ward-5(1), ChandigarhITA 1071/CHANDI/2025[2011-12]Status: Disposed10 Nov 2025AY 2011-12
- Smt.B.Renuka vs Joint CITITTA/128/200821 Aug 2025
- Pramod Swarup Agarwal Thru. Authorized… vs Prin. Director of Income Tax (Inv.) Lko…WTAX/30/20253 Jun 2025
- M/S. Gaurav Investments, Mumbai vs DCIT, CC-8(1), MumbaiITA 5184/MUM/2024[2017-18]Status: Disposed29 Apr 2025AY 2017-18
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- M/S Jaleswar Packaging, Bhubaneswar vs. Superintendent, CGST And Central Excise, BhubaneswarOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- Talasethi Sanmukharao vs. Commissioner, CT And GST, Odisha, CuttackOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- M/S Ramamani Behera (Trade Name S.V.Enterprises) Bhubaneswar vs. Addl Commissioner Of GST And Central Excise, BhubaneswarOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- Prasanta Kumar Biswal vs. The Chief Commissioner, CGST, Central Excise And Customs, BhubaneswarOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- M/S.Dibyanee Agency., Keonjhar. vs. Chief Commissioner Of CT And GST, Odisha, CuttackOrissa · 11 Nov 2026