Smt.B.Renuka vs. Joint CIT

PDF · subscribers
ITTA/128/2008HC TelanganaHBHC01045437200821 August 2025Author: P.SAM KOSHY,NARSING RAO NANDIKONDA10 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the search and seizure, though not at the assessee's direct premises, were conducted at the premises of her husband, Sri B.S. Neelakanta, who substantially controlled it. Furthermore, the Meridian Educational Society, involved in the property transactions, was also a family concern managed by relatives, including the assessee's husband and uncle. The seized documents and articles were therefore deemed relevant and important, unlike in the cases cited by the assessee where the nexus between the custodian of documents and the individual named was different. The concurrent findings of the AO and CIT(A), affirmed by the ITAT, were not warranted for interference. The appeal was dismissed, with the question of law answered in favor of the Revenue. The ITAT's partial allowance regarding surcharge under Section 113 was not elaborated upon in the High Court's decision, but the core additions concerning property value and financial transactions were upheld.

What were the facts?

This appeal by the assessee, Smt. B. Renuka, challenges the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) for the block period 1989-90 to 1998-99 and 01.04.1999 to 27.07.1999. The ITAT had partly allowed the assessee's appeal regarding the levy of surcharge under Section 113 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, but upheld the Assessing Officer's (AO) determination of property value at Rs. 1,99,26,696/- instead of Rs. 1,09,84,081/-. The case originated from search and seizure proceedings under Section 132, leading to the issuance of a notice under Section 158BD. The assessee declared nil undisclosed income. The AO added Rs. 7,75,000/- for financial transactions, Rs. 17,78,523/- for unaccounted investment in Meridian School property, and Rs. 5,10,000/- for rent income, totaling Rs. 30,73,523/-.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the ITAT erred in upholding the addition of Rs. 7,75,000/- representing financial transactions with Sri B. Naganna, Rs. 17,78,523/- as unaccounted investment in Meridian School property, and Rs. 5,10,000/- as rental income, as undisclosed income, despite the assessee's contentions regarding chit fund subscriptions and the actual property purchase value? (Mixed law and fact, turning on Sections 158BD, 132, and principles of evidence). Assessee's arguments: The search and seizure were not conducted at the assessee's premises, and the seized materials (loose sheets, diary entries) did not belong to the assessee, rendering them irrelevant under Section 34 of the Indian Evidence Act and lacking evidential value. The property purchase value was Rs. 1,09,84,081/-, not Rs. 1,99,26,696/-. The Rs. 7,75,000/- related to a private chit fund subscription. Revenue's arguments: The ITAT found the assessee's explanations unsatisfactory and not supported by cogent evidence. The seized materials were relevant as the search was conducted at the assessee's husband's premises, and the Meridian School property transactions involved family members.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 260A,Section 113,Section 132,Section 158BD,Section 142(1),Section 143(2),Section 34

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

I s447 ] rN rHE HrGH "",*lfff$"tJl=^tt^TE oF TELANGANA THURSDAY, THE TWENTY FIRST DAY OF AUGUST "'"''"in/ii iHousAND AND TWENTY FlvE THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE P'SAM KOSHY THE HoN'BLE snr lusrrci'nlnstt'tc RAo NANDIKoNDA PRESENT I.T,T.A.Nol 1280F 2008 Appeal under Section 260 A of the lncorne Tax Act' 1961 aggrieved by the order dated 02-03-2007 in l.T.(SS) A.No.148/Hyd/2002 on the fire of the lncome Tax Appellate Tribunal, Hyderabad Bench 'A" Hyderabad Between: Smt. B. Renuka, Hyderabad. Wo. B.S. Neelakanta, 6-3-883/2/4' Tejaswi Plaza' Paniagutta' ...ApPellant ...ResPondent ^"joint ClT, Central Circle-ll, Hyderabad Counsel for the Appellant: Mr' A'V'A' Siva Kartikeya' representing Mr. A.V. Krishna KoundtnYa Counsel forthe Respondent: Ms' K' Mamata Choudary The Court delivered the following: JUDGMENT

THE H NOU RABLESRI JUsTICE P.SAM KOSHY E UR B ES TI E INC M T T B P D K A EAL 2 o L JUDGMENT: (per the Hon,bte sri Justice p.Sam Koshy) Heard Mr. A.V.A. Siva Kartikeya, learned counsel, representing Mr. A.V. Krishna Koundinya, learned counsel for the appellant, and Ms. K. Mamata Choudary, learned Senior Standing Counsel for Income Tax Department appearing on beharf of the respondent. 2' The instant appear under section 260A ofthe Income Tax Act, 1961 (for short, the .Act,) has been filed by the appellant / assessee challenging the order passed by the Income Tax Apperate Tribunar, Hyderabad Bench 'A'(for short, the .ITATJ in I.T. (S.S.) A.No.14BlHy d/2[Oz,for the btock period 1989-90 to 1998_99 and 01.04.1999 to 27.O7.tggg, decided on 08.06.2007. 3. Vide the impugned order, the ITAT parfly allowed the appeal preferred by the appellant to the extent of the findings of the Assessing officer so far as the levy of surcharge under proviso to section 113 0f the Act which according to the ITAT courd had been revied as section 113 0f the Act was introduced only w.e.f. 01.06.2002 and, therefore, surcharge ..t

Page 2 of 8 could not had been levied upon in cases where search was itself carried out before the introduction of proviso to section 113 of the Act' However' the ITAT disallowed the contention of the appellant and maintained the order passed by the Assessing Officer and that by the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals)-I' Hyderabad (for short 'CIT (Appeals)') to the extent of the value of the property being determined at Rs'1'99'26'696/- and not Rs.1,09.84,081/-' ' 4. As has been mentioned earlier' the matter pertains to the block period 1989-90 to 1998-99 and 01'04'1999 to 27 'O7 '1999' 5, The brief facts of the case are that' search and seizure proceedings were initiated by the Department under Section 132 of the Act' The Department found certain incriminating materials such as cash books' ledgers and other documents and' subsequently' a notice under Section 1588D of the Act was issued to the appellant' In response to the said notice, the appellant filed its return of income in Form No'28 declaring undisclosed income as'nil'for the aforesaid block period' Later on' notices under section 142(1) and 143(2) of the Act were issued by the the appellant to produce evidences and the response given by the appellant' the Department added an amount of Rs'7'75'000/- to be the undisclosed income by way of financial transaction with one Sri B'Naganna' Department calling uPon explanations. Based uPon

Page 3 of 8 unaccounted investment made in Meridian schoor property for an amount oF Rs'17'78'523/- and rentar income received from Meridian schoor property amounting to Rs.S,10,000/_; all totaling to Rs.30,73,523/_. 6' Aggrieved by the above additions made by the Assessing officer, the appellant preferred an appeal before the CIT (Appeals) and it was contended that the apperant arong with sri B. Naganna had subscribed for a private chit and the starting chit was drawn by the apperant. out of the said amount' the appe'ant used to pay monthry instarments to the chit fund. Hence, the appellant prayed for deletion of this amount of Rs.7,75,O00/- from the income of the appellant. 7. Likewise, it was contended by the appellant that the total payment made to the landlord in the process of purchasing of Meridian schoor property was Rs.1,09,84,OBI/_. Whereas, the landlord has shown the value of the property sold to be Rs.1,99,2 2,696/_. Meanwhite, the appellant and others had also proposed to acquire the entire property, besides the property purchased by them from Meridian school property and therefore, the landowner might have added the value of the property to Rs.1,99,26,696/-. But the propgsed acquiring of the property besides Meridian educationar society somehow faired and the sare did not materia lize.

8.

It was further contended by the appellant that the Department has also seized certain day-to-day cash transactions maintained by their accountant. Further, during the search and seizure operation' no cash payments were found to have been made in all these transactions and' therefore, the appellant prayed for deletion of an amount of Rs.17,88,523l- which was added by the Assessing Officer' 9. The CIT (Appeals) uiron due verification of the facts' and on due scrutiny of the documents and explanations provided by the appellant' found that the explanations given by the appellant were not satisfactory or unacceptable. It was the observation of the CIT (Appeals) that these amounts were not refrected in regurar returns of income fired by the appellant and therefore' it had to be treated as unaccounted income earned by the appeilant in the past. The cIT (Appears) arso found that the appellant has not been able to produce cogent and strong piece of evidence, both in respect of having subscribed the chits and also having received any gifts etc. In the absence of which, a presumption has to be drawn that the amount of Rs'7'75'000/- represents investment out of undisclosed sources of income and affirmed the additions of the said amount made by the Assessing Officer' Page 4 of 8 given by the appellant was that the value of 1O. The exPla nation property Purchased by her from Meridian educationEl*society was

,,.,. Page 5 of 8 Rs.1,09,84,081/_ and not Rs.1,99,26,696/- as was projected by the landowner of the said society, and found it to be unacceptabre expranation of there being an in-between negotiations for adjacent rands, the process of which might have been added by the society in their books of accounts while showing the sale of property to the appellant. 11' The said expranation was found to be unacceptable for the simpre reason that 'the manner oF entries made in the books of accounts of- Meridian educational society as to whether there was a comprete breakup given of ta'ying the amount of cheque payment made by the appertant of Rs.1,09,84,0gl/_ and an amount of Rs.69,80,000/_ was added and betow which there was also registration charges reflected at Rs.19,64,6 lS/_. en of which added together comes to Rs.1,99,28 ,696/_. 12' The aforesaid entries got substantiated from further material which was co'ected in the course of seizure that is part of the diary entry which reflected that, of this Rs.1,99,28,696/_, there was a total amount paid of Rs.1,87,50,000/- with a balance shown at Rs.11,76,690/_. Again there was an additional Rs.6,00,000/_ payment made reducing the balance amount payable at Rs.5,76,696/- and there was yet another entry which showed that of the total amount payable of Rs.1,93,5O,OOO/_ only a balance of Rs.5,76,696/- was left to be paid. Therefore, the CIT (Appeals) taking into consideration sub-section 4(A) of Section 132 0r the Act

Page 6 of 8 disallowed the contentions raised by the appellant and in the process treated the amount of Rs.89,42,6tl/- as an unaccounted investment' 13. The said finding given by the CIT (Appeals) was also tested by the appellant before the ITAT and the ITAT also found that the explanation given by the appellant was not satisfactory or did not have much force' L4.ThelearnedcounselfortheappellanthadreliedUponthefollowing judgments in support of his contentions' viz'' 1) Commissioner of Income Tax vs' Engineers India Limitedl; 2) B. J. Services Co' Middle East Ltd' vs' Ass'stant Commiss'oner of Income-tax2; 3) Common Cause (A Registered Society) and Others vs' Union of India and Others3; 4) Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax and Another vs' Sunil Kumar Sharmaa; and 5) Deputy Commissioner of Income-Tax and Another vs' Sunil Kumar Sharmas' 15. The contention of the learned counsel for the appellant primarily was, firstly the search and seizure was not carried out at the premises of '120141 15 supreme Court cases 420 '1zot61 tao trn tae (uttarakhand) ' [zorz] :sq trR zzo (sc) o [2024] 469 lrR 197 (Karn) ' lzoz+1+as tt". ztt (sc) ..- r!

Page Z of 8 the appe'ant and secondry, the nature of search and seizure was on roose sheets of paper or entries made in a diary which again did not belong to the appelrant' Therefore, on both these counts those materiars wourd be who'y irrerevant so far as evidence admissible under section 34 0f the Indian Evidence Act and also does not carry any evidential value. 16' However' when we look into the materiar facts of the present case, it wourd revear that the premises where the search and seizure was conducted in fact belonged to the apperant,s husband namery Sri B.s. Neerakanta' Further, the so-calred transactions carried out in the name of Meridian educationar society arso berongs to the famiry of the apperant where the appe,ant's husband is the secretary and her uncle is the chairman of the said society respectively. 17 ' Because the search and seizure was carried out in the premises which was substantiaily under the contror of the apperant,s husband and .rtu,rr." also being made in the course of search of the said premises; the relevance of those documents and articres seized receives more rerevance --..*. and importance, unlike the facts in the judgments which were relied upon by the learned counsel for the appellant where the nexus between the person from whose custody the documents were received and the name oF the individuals reflected were quite different. Moreover, apart from the fact that the search and seizure was conductecr at the premises of the a

Page 8 of 8 appellant's husband, educational institution it is also relevant to mention that even the in' whose name the transactions relating to investments have been made also belong to the same family i'e' the appellant, as it is all are relatives who are managing the affairs of the said educational society including her uncle and her husband' 18. In the aforesaid factual backdrop and the judgments relied upon by the learned counser for the appeilant being distinguishabre on facts itserf, Weareoftheconsideredopinionthattheconcurrentfindingsgivenbythe Assessing Officer which have been affirmed by the CIT (Appeals) does not warrant interference. The instant appeal therefore fails and is accordingly dismissed. The question oi law raised stands answered in favour of the Revenue and against the appellant' No costs' 19. As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending if any' shall stand closed. sD/ A.V.S. PRASAD EPUTY REGISTRAR //TRUE COPYI/ SECTION OFFICER To, Kam/ghyt-

The lncome Tax Appellate Tribunal' Hyderabad Bench 'A" ci""'dl:i"-rrri. n.t rrisnna rounalnv"' Advocate [OPUC] il & i" r,rr". r' Mamata Choudary' Advocate [OPUC] Two CD CoPies Hyderabad :

HIGH COURT DATED:21 t}Btz}zs JUDGMENT lTTA.No.128 of 2OOB DISMISSING OF THE APPEAL G*{^ w,-_ -<foE€ \., . 'i\ t.. .' \ // 2o srp mm- .....,... 'i.- .,^ 'i.

More judgments on Section 113

All 78 judgments and leading authorities on Section 113 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →