YASHOVARDHAN BIRLA vs. SSISTANT DIRECTOR OF INCOME TAX (INV.) AND ANR.

PDF · subscribers
WP/2143/2018HC BombayHCBM01022097201805 July 2018Author: HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE PRAKASH D. NAIK15 pages
AI SummaryPartly Allowed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court allowed the writ petition partly. It set aside the impugned order dated April 12, 2018, and the order issuing the Letter of Request dated April 13, 2018. The matter was remanded back to the trial court for a fresh hearing of the application preferred by the respondent. The petitioner was to be afforded an opportunity of hearing. The Court noted that while the respondent argued that Section 166A of the CrPC does not mandate notice, the nature of the prayers in the application, including restraint and attachment orders, and the allegation that assets were proceeds of crime, warranted an opportunity for the petitioner to be heard. The Court balanced the principle of natural justice with the need for investigation. Pending the decision of the trial court, the amounts in the entities subject to the application were not to be transferred. All points raised in the petition were kept open, and no observations on the merits of the case were made. The trial court was directed to decide the proceedings expeditiously.

What were the facts?

The petitioner, Yashovardhan Birla, challenged an order dated April 12, 2018, and a Letter of Request dated April 13, 2018, passed by the Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate. These orders were issued in a complaint filed by the Assistant Director of Income Tax alleging offences under Section 277 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, and Sections 181, 186, 191 read with 193 of the Indian Penal Code. The complaint was filed on September 4, 2015. The petitioner had previously filed several writ petitions challenging orders of the Income Tax Settlement Commission and the Assessing Officer. The impugned orders were passed on applications filed by the respondent, seeking investigation in foreign jurisdictions and restraint/attachment of assets. The petitioner contended these orders were passed without affording him an opportunity of hearing.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the impugned orders dated April 12, 2018, and April 13, 2018, were passed in violation of the principles of natural justice, specifically the right to be heard, by the learned Magistrate? (Question of law and fact) 2. Whether the powers under Section 166A of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, can be exercised in a private complaint without affording an opportunity of hearing to the accused? Assessee's Arguments: - The impugned orders were passed without affording any opportunity to the petitioner, behind his back. - The trial court erred in mechanically passing the orders and issuing the Letter of Request. - No notice was given to the petitioner or his advocate. - The court exceeded its jurisdiction under Section 166A and Section 105 of the CrPC. - Provisions under Section 105 C to 105 J of the CrPC, which contemplate show cause notices, were not followed. - The powers under Section 166A CrPC cannot be exercised in a private complaint. Revenue's Arguments: - For initiating proceedings under Section 166A of the CrPC, there is no necessity of giving notice to the persons against whom such action is initiated. - It is the prerogative of the investigating agency to seek investigation contemplated under Section 166A of the CrPC. - The application was preferred only under Section 166A of the CrPC, which does not require issuance of notice.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 277,Section 181,Section 186,Section 191,Section 193,Section 166A,Section 105,Section 105C,Section 105J

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO. 2143 OF 2018 Yashovardhan Birla … Petitioner Vs. Assistant Director of Income Tax (Inv.) & Anr. … Respondents. ... Mr. Haresh Jagtiani, Sr. Counsel a/w Mr. Siddhesh Bhole a/w Mr. Rayden Fernandes and Nilhil Ghate I/b Mr. Haresh Jagtiani and Associates for Petitioner. Mr.   A.C.   Singh,   Additional   Solicitor   General   a/w   Mr.   Suresh Kumar & Geetika Gandhi for the Respondent No.1. Mr. P.H. Gaikwad and Mrs. N.S. Jain, APP for the Respondent­ State. ... CORAM  : PRAKASH D. NAIK, J. DATE     :  05th JULY, 2018.

P.C. 1. Heard both sides for final disposal. 2. The petitioner has invoked jurisdiction of this Court under Article 227 of Constitution of India as well as to inherent powers under Section 482 of Code of Criminal Procedure challenging the order dated 12th  April, 2018 passed by the Court of Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate 38th Court, Ballard Pier, Mumbai as well   as   the   Letter   of   Request   dated   13th  April,   2018   in   CC 192/SW/15. 1 of  15

3.

The brief facts which are necessary to adjudicate the issue involved in this matter are as follows:­ (a) Complaint was filed by the respondent No.1 in the Court of learned   38th  Additional   Chief   Metropolitan   Magistrate's   Court, Ballard Pier, Mumbai on 4th  September, 2015 alleging offences under Section 277 of Income Tax Act,1961, Sections 181, 186, 191 read with Section 193 of Indian penal Code.  Learned Magistrate has   taken   cognizance   of   the   said   complaint   and   the   same   is pending in the said Court.   The petitioner has been impleaded as accused in the said complaint.  The petitioner appeared before the trial Court and furnished bail bond. (b) Petitioner filed Writ Petitions bearing Nos. 1208 of 2016, 1209 of 2016, 1210 of 2016, 1211 of 2016, 1212 of 2016, 1213 of 16,   1324   of   2016   and   1326   of   2016   in   this   Court   seeking directions to Income Tax Settlement Commission who had rejected the application of petitioner dated 30th March, 2016 for settling his cases for assessment years 1998­99 to 2014­15 vide order dated 12th April, 2016.  This Court by order dated 3rd August, 2016 and 10th August, 2016 set aside order dated 12th April, 2016 passed by Income Tax Settlement Commission and Order dated 30th March, 2 of  15

2016 passed by Assessing Officer, thereby restoring application of settlement on the file of Commissioner.  The petitioner filed stay application dated 18th July, 2016 and 19th September, 2016 before the   trial   Court,   on   the   ground   that   the   order   of   Settlement Commission would have directed bearing on the complaint.  The respondent   opposed   the   application   by   filing   reply   on   18th December,   2017.   Application   was   adjourned   to   12th  February, 2018. (c) Since the application seeking settlement was rejected on 27th September, 2017.   The said order was challenged by preferring Writ Petition No. 862 of 2018. The Writ Petition was heard by this Court and interim order was passed on 6th April 2018 granting stay ad­interim   against   assessing   officer   proceeding   further   with scheduled dated of 12th  April, 2018 for conducting assessment. The order of stay was thereafter extended on 20th April, 2018. (d) On 12th February, 2018, the proceedings pending before the trial   Court   were   adjourned   to   2nd  July,   2018.     The   learned Magistrate   was   on   leave.   On   9th  April,   2018,   the   respondent preferred an application before the Court of learned Magistrate for taking the matter on board vide Exh.15.  In view of the request, the trial Court was pleased to take the matter on board and on the 3 of  15

same day application vide Exh.16 was filed before the learned Magistrate   under   Section   166­A   of   the   Code   of   Criminal Procedure.  The application was put up for hearing on 12th April, 2018. (e) On 12th  April, 2018, the advocate for the department was heard and the learned Magistrate was pleased to pass order on the said   application.     The   learned   Magistrate   directed   issuance   of Letter   of   Request   requesting   Foreign   Country   Government   of Bailiwick   of   Guernsey   to   make   investigation   in   this   particular account of accused and to submit that report to Court as early as possible. (f) On 13th April,2018, the respondent No.1 moved the court for taking the matter on board by preferring application Exh.17.  In the application Exh.17, it was stated that in view of order dated 12th April, 2018, there is urgency to send a proforma to Minister of Home Affairs India at the earliest.  The Court then proceeded to pass the order of Letter of Request in the form annexed to the petition.     Subsequently,   the   petitioner   learnt   about   the   orders passed  by  the   learned  Magistrate  and  hence   preferred  present petition challenging the said order. 4. It is submitted by the counsel for the petitioner that the 4 of  15

impugned orders were passed without affording any opportunity to the petitioner.   It is submitted that the proceeding before the trial Court would due for hearing on 2nd July, 2018.  However, the respondent No.1 had taken the matter on board on 9th April, 2018 and thereafter the order was passed on 12th April, 2018 which was followed by order dated 13th April, 2018.  It is submitted that the proceedings are pending in the trial Court since 2015 and all of a sudden, the application was preferred before the trial Court behind the back of the petitioner wherein the said order was passed.  The trial   Court   has   erred   in   mechanically   passing   impugned   order dated 12th  April, 2018 and issuing impugned Letter of Request dated 13th April, 2018.  No notice was given to petitioner or his advocate   by   respondent.     The   Court   has  exceeded   jurisdiction under Section 166A of Code of Criminal Procedure and Section 105 of Code of Criminal Procedure.   It was necessary to follow provisions envisaged under Section 105 C to 105 J of Code of Criminal Procedure.  The said provisions contemplate issuance of show cause notice as to why the properties should not be attached. The   Writ   Petition   No.   862   of   2018   is  pending   in   High  Court wherein   the   relief   sought   have   bearing   on   maintainability   of complaint, in which impugned order was passed.  The outcome of 5 of  15

Settlement   Commission   would   have   direct   bearing   on   the complaint. It is submitted that by stating that huge amount is lying in the said account in foreign country respondent has tried to cause prejudice in the mind of Court.   It is submitted that the application preferred by the Respondent No.1 also mentions in paragraph 16 that Income Tax Department through International Legal Assistant intends to restrain the accused from transferring funds and winding up of the entities, based in the   Bailiwick of Guernsey as it appears that the assets of said entities on which the accused is beneficial owner are proceeds of crime.       He further pointed out that in the application, the respondents have prayed for issuance of Letter of Request and Letter of Rogatory to the relevant foreign court to issue an attachment order in respect of said entities and also sought restrain order restraining transfer of funds from the said entities.  It is thus submitted that considering the   averments   made   in   the   application   and   the   reliefs  sought therein the Court ought not to have passed the said orders without giving an opportunity of hearing to the petitioner.  It is submitted that apart from the violation of principle of nature justice, even on merits as the order was not warranted.   It is submitted that the powers under Section 166­A of Code of Criminal Procedure cannot 6 of  15

be exercised in a private complaint which was pending before the Court.    It is therefore submitted that the impugned orders be set aside. 5. Mr.   Anil   Singh,   learned   Additional   Solicitor   General submitted that the complaint was filed invoking Section 277 of Income Tax Act 1966 and Section 181, 186, 191 read with 193 of IPC.   It is submitted that for initiating any proceedings under Section 166­A of Code of Criminal Procedure, there is no necessity of giving any notice to the persons against whom such action is initiated.  It is submitted that it is prerogative of the investigating agency to seek of investigation contemplated under Section 166­A of Code of Criminal Procedure.  It is submitted that an application was   preferred   only   under   Section   166­A   of   Code   of   Criminal Procedure which do not require issuance of show cause notice to the person against whom the relief are sought.  It is submitted that in   the   application   itself   it   was   stated   that   there   is   sufficient evidence collected by the investigating agency with regards to the amounts in the said country in relation to the entities in which the petitioner   is   the   beneficiary   and   therefore   the   trial   Court   has rightly passed said orders.  It is submitted that there is no violation of principle of natural justice.   The trial Court is empowered to 7 of  15

pass such order.  He relied upon the decision in the case of Union of   India   and   another   ­Vs­   W.N.Chadha1,  in   support   of   his opportunity submission that of hearing was not required to be given for invoking provisions of Section 166 A of Code of Criminal Procedure.   It is submitted that from the title of the application preferred before the trial Court it is clear that the relief was sought only under Section 166­A of Code of Criminal Procedure and not under Section 105­C.  It is submitted that for the reasons stated in the   application   and   the   reasons   assigned   by   the   Court   while allowing the application, the interference of this Court is not called for.  The investigation is required to be conducted expeditiously so that amount lying in the account is not transferred and therefore in the interest of justice it was necessary to seek such reliefs from the Court.  It is submitted that investigation contemplated under Section 166­A of Code of Criminal Procedure can be sought by preferring application in the complaint. Such investigation was sought   within   the   purview   of   the   definition   of   investigation enumerated   in   the   Code   of   Criminal   Procedure.     It   is   thus submitted   that   the   petition   is   devoid   of   merits   and   the   same deserves to be dismissed. 11993 Supp (4) Supreme Court Cases 260. 8 of  15

6.

Having considered the rival submissions and perusal of the documents on record it is apparent that the complaint was filed by the respondent before the competent court invoking the provisions of the Income Tax Act as well as Indian Penal Code in the year 2015 which is pending in the said Court.   It appears that the respondent had gathered some information as stipulated in the complaint before the trial Court with regards to the account in the entities mentioned therein and therefore it was felt necessary to prefer an application.  However, on perusal of the Roznama, it is crystal clear that the complaint was listed before the Court on 12th February, 2018 and since the Court was on leave, the board was discharged and the proceedings were adjourned to 2nd July, 2018. In the circumstances, there was no occasion for the petitioner to appear before the trial Court on 9th April, 2018, 12th April, 2018 or 13th  April, 2018.   The impugned order passed by the trial Court proceeds on the basis that the accused and his advocate are found absent when repeatedly called out.  It appears that the Court was under belief that the matter was due for hearing on that day or that   they  were   put   to  notice   and  in   spite   of  that   neither  the advocate nor the accused were present in the Court when the applications was heard by the Court.  It is seen that the application 9 of  15

Exh.15 was moved before Court for taking the matter on board on 9th April, 2018.  It was stated that the complainant intends to file an application under Section 166 A read with 105 C of Code of Criminal Procedure for issuing Letter of Request to the competent authority for investigation.  The said application was allowed and matter was taken on board. The application vide Exh.16 seeking the reliefs stated hereinabove was taken on record and the same was   posted   for   hearing   on   12th  April,   2018.     While   passing impugned order, the Court was pleased to observe that on perusal of record it is found that the complainant has mentioned regarding the accounts maintained by the accused in the foreign country i.e Government of  Bailiwick of Guernsey.  It is further observed that in the said account there is huge amount of Rs.400 crorers and there is apprehension that accused would transfer the said amount from the account to any other country.  Hence, it is necessary to issue   letter   of   request   that   the   Government   of     Bailiwick   of Guernsey to investigate and to collect the evidence or material in respect   of  the   account  maintained  by  the  accused  in   the  said country   and   to   examine   orally   any   person   supposed   to   be acquainted with the facts and circumstances of the case and to record his statement made in the course of such examination and 10 of  15

also  require   such   person   or  any  other  person   to  produce   any document or thing which may be in his possession pertaining to the   case   and   the   alleged   account   of   accused   and   forward   all evidence so collected to the Court.  The Court issued such Letter of Request calling for report as early as possible. 7. The   application   preferred   by   the   respondent   No.1   gives details about said entities.  It is prayed in the application that the Letter of Request and Letter of Rogatory be issued to the Foreign Court to place restraint order restraining transfer of funds from the entities viz Banyan Tree Trust and Kinetic Holding Limited.  The applicant further prayed that the Letter of Request or Letter of Rogatory be issued to the relevant foreign court to place a restraint order on Confiance Limited restraining  it from executing fund asset transfer away from entities stated therein.   It was further prayed that Court may issue Letter of Request / Letter of Rogatory to relevant foreign Court to issue attachment order in respect of entitles though not based in Guernsey but managed from that Country by Confiance Limited.  It is also pertinent to note that in the   application   it   is   mentioned   the   Income   Tax   Department through   International   legal   assistance   intends   to   restrain   the accused from transferring funds and winding up of entities based 11 of  15

in that country as it appears that the assets of said entities of which the accused is beneficial owner are proceeds of crime.  On perusal of the letter, it can be seen that the assistance is sought from the foreign country with regards to restraint order as well as the attachment order.  The letter also refers to Section 105­C of Code of Criminal Procedure which relates to assistance in relation to orders of attachment or forfeiture of property.  In the case of Union   of   India   Vs.   W.N.Chadha(Supra)   the   petitioner   had challenged the order passed by High Court knocking down the very   registration   of   FIR   and   all   proceedings   arising   thereon including   issue   of   Letter   of   Rogatory.     The   contention   of respondent before the High Court was that FIR does not disclose commission of offence and Letters of Rogatory were issued without jurisdiction and without following principle of natural justice.  The submission was accepted by High Court that there was violation of principle   of   natural   justice.     It   is   apparent   that   the   letter   of Rogatory was issued under Section 166­A of Code of Criminal Procedure.   The steps to issue such letter were adopted when investigation in pursuant to registration of FIR was in progress. The Hon'ble Supreme Court observed that rule of  audi alteram partem  is not attracted for investigation under Section 166A of 12 of  15

Code   of   Criminal   Procedure.     The   investigating   officer   is   not deciding any matter  except collecting material for  ascertaining whether a prima­facie case is made out or not and a full enquiry in case of filing report under Section 173(2) of Code of Criminal Procedure follows in a trial before the Court or Tribunal before filing report and at that stage rule of audi alteram partem  cannot be applied. 8. In the present case, the proceedings were pending before the competent court, the matter was adjourned to 2nd July, 2018 and the application was preferred on 9th April, 2018 by taking matter on board.   The nature of prayers made in the application are highlighted above.   It is also alleged that the assets of which petitioner is owner are proceeds of crime.  Letter of Request refers to invoking Section 105 C of Code of Criminal Procedure.   The Letter of Request also refers to restraint order and attachment order.   In the circumstances stated hereinabove, it was expected that the trial Court ought to have given an opportunity to the Petitioner.  However, one cannot ignore the purport of preferring the   application   and   apprehension   expressed   therein.   In   the circumstances, the balance will have to be struck between the principle of natural justice and need for investigation into aspects 13 of  15

as claimed in the application preferred by the respondents.  In the circumstances, I pass the following order. ORDER (i) Writ Petition is allowed partly allowed. (ii) Impugned order dated 12th  April, 2018 and order issuing Letter of Request dated 13th April, 2018 are hereby set aside. The matter   is   remanded   back   to   the   trial   Court   for   hearing   the application preferred by the respondent afresh. The petitioner be afforded an opportunity of hearing the application preferred by the respondent no.1. (iii) In the meantime, without prejudice to the rights / objections of both the parties and subject to the decision of the trial court in the application preferred by the respondent No.1, the amount in the entities which is subject matter of the application preferred by the respondent no.1 may not be transferred to any other account; (iv) All points raised in this petition are kept open; (v) It is clarified that this Court has not made any observations on   merits   of   the   case   and   the   trial   Court   shall   decide   the proceedings in accordance with law; 14 of  15

(vi) The parties through their counsel to appear before the trial Court   on   1st  August,   2018.     The   application   be   decided expeditiously; (vi) Petition stands disposed of.

( PRAKASH D. NAIK, J. ) 15 of  15 Sachidanand Kuttan Nair Digitally signed by Sachidanand Kuttan Nair Date: 2018.07.17 19:36:48 +0530

More judgments on Section 277

All 33 judgments and leading authorities on Section 277 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →