Late Sri G. Nageswara Rao vs. The Commissioner of Incometax,

PDF · subscribers
ITTA/97/2004HC TelanganaHBHC01047217200410 December 2014Author: CHALLA KODANDA RAM,L.NARASIMHA REDDY6 pages
AI SummaryAllowed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the Tribunal's order did not accord with its own reasoning. The Court found that the appellant had provided a cash flow statement explaining his financial position, and the Tribunal itself observed that the house property income for the relevant assessment years was below the taxable limit and that the appellant was entitled to the benefit of Section 158BB(c)(B) of the Act. This clause allows for the computation of undisclosed income based on entries in books of account where income does not exceed the maximum amount not chargeable to tax, even if no return was filed. The Tribunal's observation that the income was below the taxable limit and should be excluded, while referencing judicial decisions, should have led to a conclusion that the Assessing Officer's refusal to consider the appellant's explanation was unsustainable. Instead, the Tribunal dismissed the appeal. The High Court found that the appellant had explained the source of income and that the block assessment order was contrary to law. Therefore, the appeal was allowed, and the order of assessment was set aside. No issue was expressly left undecided.

What were the facts?

The appellant, late Sri G.Nageswara Rao, had income from house property, agriculture, and a transport business. He entrusted the transport business to his son and ceased filing returns as his income from the remaining two sources fell below the taxable limit. A search was conducted on his son's premises on 10.10.1996. The appellant, aged 78 at the time, was issued a notice under Section 158BC of the Income Tax Act and filed a 'Nil' return. The Assessing Officer determined an undisclosed income of Rs.5,87,086/- comprising income from investment in construction, long-term capital gains, and house property. The appellant appealed to the ITAT. During the pendency of the appeal, the appellant died, and his legal representative was brought on record. The ITAT acknowledged the appellant's entitlement to the benefit of Section 158BB(c)(B) but ultimately dismissed the appeal. The present appeal is filed under Section 260A of the Act against the ITAT's order.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the Tribunal erred in dismissing the appeal when its own reasoning indicated that the appellant was entitled to the benefit of Section 158BB(c)(B) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, which mandates consideration of entries in books of account even if no return is filed, provided income does not exceed the maximum amount not chargeable to tax? Assessee's Contention: The appellant argued that the Assessing Officer and the Tribunal failed to consider the cash flow statement prepared by the appellant, which explained his financial affairs and showed that his income from house property and agriculture for the years 1986-87 to 1997-98 did not exceed the taxable limits. The appellant contended that the Tribunal's observation that the income was below the taxable limit and should be excluded, coupled with reliance on judicial pronouncements, should have led to the setting aside or modification of the assessment order, not its dismissal. The appellant relied on the principles derived from Section 158BB(1)(c)(B) of the Act. Revenue's Contention: The judgment does not record any specific arguments made by the revenue.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 158BC,Section 158BB,Section 158BB(1)(c)(B),Section 260A

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE L.NARASIMHA REDDY

and

THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE CHALLA KODANDA RAM

I.T.T.A. No. 97 of 2004

% 10.12.2014

Between:

Late Sri G.Nageswara Rao Rep.by Sri G.Mohan Rao. ... APPELLANT Versus

$ The Commissioner of Income Tax. ...RESPONDENT

< Gist:

> Head Note:

! COUNSEL FOR THE APPELLANT :- Smt.K.Neeraja ^COUNSEL FOR RESPONDENT :- Sri J.V.Prasad

? Cases Referred:

THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE L.NARASIMHA REDDY

AND

THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE CHALLA KODANDA RAM

I.T.T.A. No. 97 of 2004

JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble Sri Justice L.Narasimha Reddy)

This appeal is referable to an assessee by name, late

Sri G.Nageswara Rao. During the pendency of the proceedings, he died and his son is brought on record.

The appeal arises out of an order, dated 19.02.2004, passed by the Visakhapatnam Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal in IT (SS) A.No.7/V/99.

The brief facts pertaining to the case are as under:

The appellant was having income from house property, agriculture as well as transport business. Whenever his income exceeded the taxable limits, he filed return. On account of his old age, he is said to have entrusted the transport business to his son,

who is an independent assessee. The appellant was deriving income only from two sources, namely house property and agriculture. Though he filed returns for quite some period, he discontinued to file the same on the ground that the income, after transfer of transport business to the son was below the limits. A search was conducted on 10.10.1996 in the house of the son of the appellant. By that time, the appellant was aged 78 years. A notice under Section 158BC of the Income Tax Act (for short ‘the Act’) was issued to him and in response to the same, the appellant filed a ‘Nil’ return. The Assessing Officer, however, passed an order, dated 29.10.1997, holding that there exists a sum of Rs.5,87,086/- as undisclosed income. It was mentioned that the figure represents the income from investment in construction, long term capital gains and the one from house property.

The appellant approached the Tribunal by filing the appeal. During the pendency of the appeal, he died and his legal representative was brought on record. The Tribunal took the view that the appellant is entitled for the benefit of Section 158BB(c)(B) of the Act. However, the Tribunal, ultimately, dismissed the appeal. Hence, this further appeal under Section 260A of the Act.

Heard Smt.K.Neeraja, learned counsel for the appellant and the learned Standing Counsel for the respondent.

The appeal arises out of block assessment proceedings. The undisputed facts are that the appellant did not file returns for a period exceeding ten years before the search was conducted, but

he was the assessee earlier thereto. Though he was not maintaining the books of account, he explained his financial state of affairs through cash flow statement, prepared in the context of search and seizure. The same was part of record and it is also placed before us. According to this, the income from two sources, namely agriculture and house property for the years 1986-87 to 1997-98 did not exceed the taxable limits and the nature of investments from the savings made over the years were shown.

Things would have been different altogether, had the Assessing Officer or the Tribunal disbelieved the statement referred to above. Not a word was said about it. Section 158BB of the Act prescribes the procedure to be followed in the context of computation of undisclosed income of the block period. Broadly stated, the undisclosed income to be so arrived at, is the one which is found as a result of search or requisition of books, added by the loss, which the assessee may have incurred in the block period or deducted by the income which is already disclosed.

Clauses (a) to (f) of sub-section (1) of Section 158BB of the Act stipulate the components that are added or deducted, as the case may be, for the process of computation of undisclosed income. Clause (c) thereof reads as under:

“(c) where the due date for filing a return of income has expired, but no return of income has been filed (A) on the basis of entries as recorded in the books of account and other documents maintained in the normal course on or before the date of the search or

requisition where such entries result in computation of loss for any previous year falling in the block period; or (B) on the basis of entries as recorded in the books of account and other documents maintained in the normal course on or before the date of the search or requisition where such income does not exceed the maximum amount not chargeable to tax for any previous year falling in the block period;”

From a perusal of this, it becomes clear that even where an assessee did not file returns for the block period, the facts and figures mentioned in the books of account must be taken into account. The Tribunal did not disbelieve the statement submitted by the appellant. On the other hand, an observation was made to the effect that the allowance to that extent is to be made. It reads as under:

“The assessee has shown the house property income for assessment year 1987-88 till date of survey on 10.10.1996 which are below taxable limit. While relying on the decisions 265 ITR 327 (Kerala), we direct to exclude the income in a block assessment years which is below taxable limit, the rental income is on records of the Revenue. Since the effect of the decision 254 ITR 245 (Kerala) is nullified by amendment in introducing Section 158BB(1)(c)(B) to the Act”

This observation should have led to a conclusion that the refusal on the part of the Assessing Officer to take into account the facts and figures mentioned with reference to the block period cannot be sustained in law and the order of assessment ought to have been set aside or at least modified. However, the appeal was dismissed as a whole.

We are of the view that this is a rare case in which the result of the appeal does not accord with the reasons furnished in the course of discussion. On merits also, we are satisfied that the appellant explained the source of income and the order of block assessment passed by the respondent is contrary to law.

The appeal is accordingly allowed and the order of assessment, dated 29.10.1997, is set aside. There shall be no order as to costs.

The miscellaneous petitions, if any, filed in this appeal shall also stand disposed of.

_____________________

L.NARASIMHA REDDY,J

_______________________ CHALLA KODANDA RAM,J Dt:10.12.2014

Note: L.R. copy to be marked. kdl

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →