DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, CHENNAI vs. M/S. HANDHOLD VENTURES PVT LTD, NAMAKKAL

PDF · subscribers
ITA 1256/CHNY/2026Status: DisposedITAT Chennai23 October 2026AY 2016-1720 pages

In favour of the assessee: the Revenue's appeal was dismissed. From the AI summary of this appeal.

AI SummaryDismissed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal held that the CIT(A) was correct in deleting the addition of Rs. 9 crores. The primary issue revolved around the evidentiary value of the director's statement. The Tribunal noted that the statement was recorded under Section 131 of the Act, not Section 132(4) as claimed by the Revenue, and was subsequently retracted. The judgment emphasizes that a retracted statement, without corroborating documentary evidence, cannot form the sole basis for an addition, especially in the context of block assessments. The Tribunal cited the case of CIT v. Naresh Kumar Agarwal, which held that a retracted statement cannot constitute a basis for an order under Section 158BC. Since no other incriminating material was brought on record by the AO to suggest the payment of on-money sale consideration, the addition was rightly deleted by the CIT(A). The appeal filed by the Revenue was dismissed.

What were the facts?

The Revenue is in appeal against the order of the CIT(A) for Assessment Year 2016-17. The assessee, M/s. Handhold Ventures Pvt Ltd, filed its return of income disclosing Rs. 4,79,710. During a search operation on M/s. Agni Estates and Foundations Pvt. Ltd., an agreement of sale dated 28.06.2015 was found, indicating the sale of 2.16 acres of land for Rs. 15.50 crores. However, the registered sale deed dated 26.08.2015 was for Rs. 6.05 crores. The Assessing Officer (AO), based on a statement from the assessee's director admitting to on-money payment of Rs. 1.9 crores per acre out of unaccounted income from his proprietorship concern, added Rs. 9 crores as unexplained investment. The CIT(A) deleted this addition, leading to the present appeal by the Revenue.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the CIT(A) erred in deleting the addition of Rs. 9,00,00,000/- made under Section 69B of the Income Tax Act, 1961, for AY 2016-17? Assessee's contentions: - The proceedings under Section 153C were invalid. - The addition was made solely based on the statement of the director, Mr. T. Kumarsamy, which was later retracted. - The Fair Market Value (FMV) of the property did not exceed the sale consideration due to Coastal Regulation Zone restrictions. - The unregistered sale agreement has no legal sanctity. Revenue's contentions: - The CIT(A) failed to consider the evidentiary value of the director's sworn statement recorded under Section 132(4). - The director admitted that the on-money payment was from unaccounted income generated from his proprietorship concern, M/s. Christy Friedgram Industry. - The property was previously purchased by the Agni group from Shri Karti P. Chidambaram on 27.03.2014, for Rs. 9.18 crore, and the current sale deed registered it below that price.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 69B,Section 132(4),Section 153C,Section 131,Section 158BC

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, CHENNAI BENCHES,

Before: SHRI INTURI RAMA RAO & SHRI MANU KUMAR GIRI

Pronounced: 23.10.2026

आयकर अपील�य अ�धकरण, चे�नई पीठ�, चे�नई INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL, CHENNAI BENCHES, CHENNAI BENCH: B BEFORE SHRI INTURI RAMA RAO, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER AND SHRI MANU KUMAR GIRI, JUDICIAL MEMBER ITA No.1256/CHNY/2026 िनधा�रण वष�/Assessment Year: 2016-17 Deputy Commissioner of M/s. HANDHOLD VENTURES PVT Income Tax, LTD, Investigation Wing, Room 1/37-(2) SIDCO Industrial V No.B3, Ground Floor, New Estate, Andipalayam, Namakal, s. No.46, M.G.Road, Chennai – Tamilnadu – 637214. 600034. अपीलाथ� Appellant ��थ� Respondent Permanent Account Number of AADCH4145B Assessee: अपीलाथ� �ारा/Appellant represented by: Mr.S.Sundar Rajan – CIT ��थ� �ारा/Respondent represented by: Mr.M.V.Prasad – CA & Mr.K.S.Rajendra Kumar – CA सुनवाई की तारीख / Date of conclusion of hearing: 25.08.2026 घोषणा की तारीख / Date of pronouncement: 23.10.2026 आदेश / ORDER PER INTURI RAMA RAO, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER : This is an appeal filed by the Revenue directed against the order passed by learned Commissioner of Income Tax(Appeal)[NFAC], dated 22.12.2025 passed u/s.250 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 for the Assessment Year 2016-17.

2.

The Revenue raised the following grounds of appeal : “1. The order of the learned Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) is erroneous on facts of the case and in law.

2.

The Ld. CIT (A) erred in deleting the addition of Rs.9,00,00,000/-made u/s 69B of the Act for the AY 2016-17.

3.

The Ld.CIT(A) failed to take note of the fact that the Director and main person of the assessee company had admitted in the sworn statement recorded from him u/s 132(4) of the Act that the sources for the payment of on-money was the unaccounted income generated out of his proprietary concern, M/s. Christy Friedgram Industry.

4.

The Ld.CIT(A) failed to note that the impugned immovable property was earlier purchased by the Agni group from Shri Karti P. Chidambaram on 27.03.2014, vide Document No. 4701/14, for Rs.4.25 crore per acre, aggregating to Rs.9.18 crore and the current sale deed had registered the same below the said price.

5.

For these grounds and any other ground including amendment of grounds that may be raised during the course of the appeal proceedings, the Order of Ld.CIT(Appeals) may be set aside and that of Assessing Officer may be restored.”

3.

Briefly, the facts of the case are that the respondent- assessee is a company incorporated under the provisions of Companies Act, 2013. It is engaged in the business of trading and financial services. The respondent-assessee filed Return of Income on 25.10.2018 u/s.139 of the Act for the Assessment Year 2016-17 disclosing income at Rs.4,79,710/-. Against the said Return of Income, no scrutiny assessment was made.

4.

However, during the course of search and seizure operations u/s.132 of the Act were conducted in the business premises of M/s.Agni Estates and Foundations Pvt. Ltd group of cases, an agreement of sale dated 28.06.2015 entered into between M/s.Agni Estates and Foundations Pvt. Ltd., and Handhold Ventures Private Limited (i.e.respondent-assessee company) was found and seized vide Annexure No.ANN/ARS/AGP/LS/S-15. In terms of said agreement, it was agreed that M/s.Agni Estates and Foundations Pvt. Ltd., agreed to sell land admeasuring 2.16 acres of land at Survey No.98/9A in Muttukadu Village for total consideration of Rs.15.50 crores i.e. @ 7.14 crores per acre. However, it was found that the sale deed was executed and registered for total consideration of Rs.6.05 crores only. Based on this information, the Assessing Officer of M/s.Agni Estates and Foundations Pvt. Ltd., recorded satisfaction note as envisaged u/s.153C of the Act and forwarded the same to the Assessing Officer of the respondent-assessee. Based on this satisfaction note, the Assessing officer of respondent-assessee issued notice u/s.153C of the Income Tax Act, 1961 on 22.09.2020 calling upon the respondent-assessee to file Return of Income. In response to the notice u/s.153C of the Act, the respondent-assessee filed Return of Income for A.Y.2016-17 same as filed u/s.139 of the Act.

5.

Against the said Return of Income, the assessment was completed by the DCIT, Central Circle-2(1), Chennai(hereinafter called ‘AO’) vide order dated 14.06.2021 passed u/s.153C of the Income Tax Act, 1961 at total income of Rs.9,04,79,710/-. While doing so, the Assessing Officer made addition of Rs.9 crores on account of unexplained investment on purchase of property. The Assessing Officer had taken into consideration the agreement of sale deed dated 28.06.2015 entered into between the M/s.Agni Estates and Foundations Pvt. Ltd., and respondent-assessee which was found and seized vide Annexure No. ANN/ARS/AGP/LS/S-15, indicating sale of land admeasuring 2.16 acres for total consideration of Rs.15.50 crores @ Rs.7.14 crores per acre. However, the Assessing Officer noticed that the property was purchased deed vide dated 26.08.2015 registered vide document no.10845/15, SRO, Thirupporur for a total consideration of Rs.6,50,00,000/- only. The Assessing Officer also recorded statement from one of the Directors of the respondent-assessee company namely Mr.T.S.Kumarsamy u/s.131 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 on 03.09.2018, wherein, in response to answers to question no.4, 5, 6, 7 and 8, he stated that he paid on-money sale consideration in cash of Rs.1.9 crores per acre. He also stated that on-money consideration in cash was paid out of the money of unaccounted income generated from his proprietorship concern from M/s.Christy Friedgram Industry. Based on this evidence, the Assessing Officer inferred that the respondent-assessee made unexplained investment on purchase of property of Rs.9 crores. Accordingly, the Assessing Officer made the addition in the assessment made u/s.153C of the Act. 6. Being aggrieved by the above assessment order, an appeal was filed before the Learned CIT(A), challenging the very validity initiation of proceedings u/s.153C of the Income Tax Act, 1961 and also challenging the conclusion reached by the Assessing Officer that the respondent-assessee made on-money consideration on purchase of land from M/s.Agni Estates and Foundations Private Limited. The Assessing Officer ought not have made addition merely based on the statement given by Mr.T.Kumarsamy, Director of the respondent-assessee company. The respondent-assessee company also stated that the Fair Market Value(FMV) of the property did not exceed the apparent sale consideration for the reason that there were restrictions on the usage of land as it was falling under Coastal Regulation Zone.

It is further contended that the unregistered document has no legal sanctity as it is not enforceable in the eyes of law. The Learned Ld.CIT(A) after duly considering written submissions, the additional evidence filed by the appellant and also after calling for remand report from the Assessing Officer concluded that in the absence of any incriminating material suggesting payment of on-money consideration, the question of addition does not arise. Accordingly, directed the Assessing Officer to delete the addition of Rs.9 crores. Thus, the appeal filed by the respondent-assessee before the Learned CIT(A) came to be allowed.

7.

Being aggrieved by the order of the Learned CIT(A), the Revenue is in appeal before us in the present appeal. The Learned CIT-DR submits that the Learned CIT(A) had failed to consider the evidentiary value of the statement recorded from the Director of the respondent-assessee company and also failed to take into consideration fact that M/s.Agni Estates and Foundation Private Limited bought lands from Shri Karti P.Chidambaram on 27.03.2014 vide document no.4701/2014 for total consideration of Rs.9.18 crore @4.25 crore per acre.

8.

On the other hand, the Learned Counsel-Mr.Rajendra Kumar submits that the statement given by Shri T.Kumarsamy cannot be relied upon, in as much as, it was retracted subsequently vide letter dated 14.01.2019. He further submitted that the sale agreement was never acted upon due to restrictions in the usage of property and sale price was renegotiated and arrived at consideration of Rs.6.5 crores, accordingly, sale deed was executed and registered on 26.08.2015 and also the respondent-assessee company also filed an Affidavit to this effect before the Learned CIT(A). The addition was made by the Assessing Officer based on assumptions and surmises. The Learned CIT(A) had rightly deleted the addition made by the Assessing Officer.

9.

We heard rival submissions and perused the material available on record. The solitary issues that arises for our consideration is whether the Learned CIT(A) is correct in law in holding that there was no incriminating material suggesting the unexplained investment on purchase of property of lands situated at Survey No.98/9A in Muttukadu Village from M/s.Agni Estates and Foundations Private Limited. Admittedly, the respondent-assessee had purchased lands admeasuring 2.16 Acres from M/s.Agni Estates and Foundations Private Limited for consideration of Rs.6.5 crores vide sale deed dated 26.08.2015. During the course of search and seizure operations conducted in the premises of M/s.Agni Estates and Foundations Private Limited, it was stated that the Department had found and seized an agreement of sale entered into between the M/s.Agni Estates and Foundations Private Limited and respondent-assessee company, wherein it was agreed to sell the said land for consideration of Rs.15.50 crores. The Assessing Officer also recorded statement from one of the Directors of the respondent- assessee company Shri T.Kumarsay, in reply to Question No.4, 5 and 6 appears to have admitted that he had paid on-money consideration in cash @ 1.9 crores per acre and also stated that the said on-money consideration cash was paid out of income generated from his proprietary concern. Based on this evidence, the Assessing Officer inferred the existence of undisclosed income and accordingly issued a notice u/s.153C of the Act to the respondent-assessee company and accordingly, the assessment was completed by the Assessing Officer after making addition of Rs.9 crores as unexplained investments. On appeal before the Learned CIT(A), the Learned CIT(A) opined that there was no incriminating evidence found suggesting payment of on- money consideration of Rs.9 crores, in the absence of conclusive evidence, no addition can be made. He, accordingly, granted the relief to the respondent-assessee company. The findings of the Learned CIT(A) were under challenge before us by the Revenue. We had carefully perused the assessment order and found that the basis of addition made by the Assessing Officer is an agreement of sale dated 26.08.2015 found during the course of search and seizure proceedings conducted in the case of M/s.Agni Estates and Foundations Private Limited and the statement recorded from one of the Directors of the Company Shri T.Kumarsamy. The Assessing Officer neither referred to the terms of the sale agreement, nor referred to the evidence of payment of on-money consideration by the respondent-assessee company. The submission of the respondent-assessee company that the sale agreement was not acted upon and subsequently, terms and conditions of the sale were renegotiated after the respondent-assessee company had come to know of the restrictions on the usage of land on account of coastal regulations remains uncontroverted. It is also an undisputed fact that there was no objection from the registering authority as to the guidelines value for the stamp duty purpose. This fact would goes to show that there is a depreciation in the value of property as compared to the value purchased by the seller from Shri P.K Chidambaram. In any event, we are of the considered opinion that in making the assessment pursuant to notice issued u/s.153C of the Act, the Assessing Officer cannot travel beyond incriminating material found in the case of searched person i.e. M/s.Agni Estates and Foundations Private Limited. As observed by us(supra), the Assessing Officer had not brought any conclusive evidence to show that the respondent-assessee company had paid on-money consideration over and above the apparent consideration paid. Therefore, in the absence of conclusive evidence, no addition can be made as held by the Hon’ble Madras High Court in the case of CIT vs. P.V.Kalyanasundaram [2006] 282 ITR 259 wherein, it held as under : “6. We also found that the Assessing Officer did not conduct any independent enquiry relating to the value of the property purchased. He merely relied on the statement given by the seller. If he would have taken independent enquiry by referring the matter with the Valuation Officer, the controversy could have been avoided. Failing to refer the matter was a fatal one.

7.

In view of the foregoing conclusions, we find no error in the order of the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal and requires no interference.

Hence no substantial questions of law arises for consideration of this Court. Accordingly, the above tax case is dismissed. No costs.”

10.

The above decision of Hon’ble Madras High Court in the case of CIT Vs. P.V.Kalyanasundaram(supra), was confirmed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of CIT Vs. P.V.Kalyanasundaram 294 ITR 47(SC).

11.

As regards to the evidentiary value of Director of the respondent-assessee company Shri T.Kumarsamy, suffice to hold that the statement was recorded from him during the course of assessment proceedings, it cannot form the basis for making addition in the assessment pursuant to notice issued u/s.153C of the Income Tax Act.

12.

In this connection, reliance can be placed on the decision of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of CIT vs. Harjeev Aggarwal, 70 taxmann.com 95 (Delhi). The relevant paragraphs of the decision of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of Harjeev Aggarwal (supra) are extracted as under :- “19. In view of the settled legal position, the first and foremost issue to be addressed is whether a statement recorded under Section 132 (4) of the Act would by itself be sufficient to assess the income, as disclosed by the Assessee in its statement, under the Provisions of Chapter XIV-B of the Act.

20.

In our view, a plain reading of Section 158BB(1) of the Act does not contemplate computing of undisclosed income solely on the basis of a statement recorded during the search. The words "evidence found as a result of search" would not take within its sweep statements recorded during search and seizure operations. However, the statements recorded would certainly constitute information and if such information is relatable to the evidence or material found during search, the same could certainly be used in evidence in any proceedings under the Act as expressly mandated by virtue of the explanation to Section 132(4) of the Act. However, such statements on a standalone basis without reference to any other material discovered during search and seizure operations would not empower the AO to make a block assessment merely because any admission was made by the Assessee during search operation.

21.

A plain reading of Section 132 (4) of the Act indicates that the authorized officer is empowered to examine on oath any person who is found in possession or control of any books of accounts, documents, money, bullion, jewellery or any other valuable article or thing. The explanation to Section 132 (4), which was inserted by the Direct Tax Laws (Amendment) Act, 1987 w.e.f. 1st April, 1989, further clarifies that a person may be examined not only in respect of the books of accounts or other documents found as a result of search but also in respect of all matters relevant for the purposes of any investigation connected with any proceeding under the Act. However, as stated earlier, a statement on oath can only be recorded of a person who is found in possession of books of accounts, documents, assets, etc. Plainly, the intention of the Parliament is to permit such examination only where the books of accounts, documents and assets possessed by a person are relevant for the purposes of the investigation being undertaken. Now, if the provisions of Section 132(4) of the Act are read in the context of Section 158BB(1) read with Section 158B(b) of the Act, it is at once clear that a statement recorded under Section 132(4) of the Act can be used in evidence for making a block assessment only if the said statement is made in the context of other evidence or material discovered during the search. A statement of a person, which is not relatable to any incriminating document or material found during search and seizure operation cannot, by itself, trigger a block assessment. The undisclosed income of an Assessee has to be computed on the basis of evidence and material found during search. The statement recorded under Section 132(4) of the Act may also be used for making the assessment, but only to the extent it is relatable to the incriminating evidence/material unearthed or found during search. In other words, there must be a nexus between the statement recorded and the evidence/material found during search in order to for an assessment to be based on the statement recorded.

22.

In CIT v. Shri Ramdas Motor Transport [1999] 238 ITR 177/102 Taxman 300, a Division Bench of Andhra Pradesh High Court, reading the provision of Section 132(4) of the Act in the context of discovering undisclosed income, explained that in cases where no unaccounted documents or incriminating material is found, the powers under Section 132(4) of the Act cannot be invoked. The relevant passage from the aforesaid judgment is quoted below:— "A plain reading of sub-section (4) shows that the authorised officer during the course of raid is empowered to examine any person if he is found to be in possession or control of any undisclosed books of account, documents, money or other valuable articles or things, elicit information from such person with regard to such account books or money which are in his possession and can record a statement to that effect. Under this provision, such statements can be used in evidence in any subsequent proceeding initiated against such per son under the Act. Thus, the question of examining any person by the authorised officer arises only when he found such person to be in possession of any undisclosed money or books of account. But, in this case, it is admitted by the Revenue that on the dates of search, the Department was not able to find any unaccounted money, unaccounted bullion nor any other valuable articles or things, nor any unaccounted documents nor any such incriminating material either from the premises of the company or from the residential houses of the managing director and other directors. In such a case, when the managing director or any other persons were found to be not in possession of any incriminating material, the question of examining them by the authorised officer during the course of search and recording any statement from them by invoking the powers under section 132(4) of the Act, does not arise. Therefore, the statement of the managing director of the assessee, recorded patently under section 132(4) of the Act, does not have any evidentiary value. This provision embedded in sub-section (4) is obviously based on the well established rule of evidence that mere confessional statement without there being any documentary proof shall not be used in evidence against the person who made such statement. The finding of the Tribunal was based on the above well settled principle."

23.

It is also necessary to mention that the aforesaid interpretation of Section 132(4) of the Act must be read with the explanation to Section 132(4) of the Act which expressly provides that the scope of examination under Section 132(4) of the Act is not limited only to the books of accounts or other assets or material found during the search. However, in the context of Section 158BB(1) of the Act which expressly restricts the computation of undisclosed income to the evidence found during search, the statement recorded under Section 132(4) of the Act can form a basis for a block assessment only if such statement relates to any incriminating evidence of undisclosed income unearthed during search and cannot be the sole basis for making a block assessment.

24.

If the Revenue's contention that the block assessment can be framed only on the basis of a statement recorded under Section 132(4) is accepted, it would result in ignoring an important check on the power of the AO and would expose assessees to arbitrary assessments based only on the statements, which we are conscious are sometimes extracted by exerting undue influence or by coercion. Sometimes statements are recorded by officers in circumstances which can most charitably be described as oppressive and in most such cases, are subsequently retracted. Therefore, it is necessary to ensure that such statements, which are retracted subsequently, do not form the sole basis for computing undisclosed income of an assessee.

25.

In CIT v. Naresh Kumar Agarwal [2014] 369 ITR 171/[2015] 53 taxmann.com 306, a Division Bench of Telangana and Andhra Pradesh High Court held that a statement recorded under Section 132(4) of the Act which is retracted cannot constitute a basis for an order under Section 158BC of the Act. The relevant extract from the said judgement is quoted below:— "17. The circumstances under which a statement is recorded from an assessee, in the course of search and seizure, are not difficult to imagine. He is virtually put under pressure and is denied of access to external advice or opportunity to think independently. A battalion of officers, who hardly feel any limits on their power, pounce upon the assessee, as though he is a hardcore criminal. The nature of steps, taken during the course of search are sometimes frightening. Locks are broken, seats of sofas are mercilessly cut and opened. Every possible item is forcibly dissected. Even the pillows are not spared and their acts are backed by the powers of an investigating officer under section 94 of the Code of Criminal Procedure by operation of sub-section (13) of section 132 of the Act. The objective may be genuine, and the exercise may be legal. However, the freedom of a citizen that transcends, even the Constitution cannot be treated as non- existent."

"18. It is not without reason that Parliament insisted that the recording of statement must be in relation to the seized and recovered material, which is in the form of documents, cash, gold, etc. It is, obviously to know the source thereof, on the spot. Beyond that, it is not a limited licence, to an authority, to script the financial obituary of an assessee."

"19. At the cost of repetition, we observe that if the statement made during the course of search remains the same, it can constitute the basis for proceeding further under the Act even if there is no other material. If, on the other hand, the statement is retracted, the Assessing Officer has to establish his own case. The statement that too, which is retracted from the assessee cannot constitute the basis for an order under section 158BC of the Act."”

13.

In view of the above discussion, it is crystal clear that there was no incriminating material brought on record by the Assessing Officer suggesting the payment of on-money sale consideration in cash at the time of purchase of land, therefore, the Learned CIT(A) rightly reached conclusion that there was no evidence of the incriminating material to show that on-money consideration in cash of Rs.9 crores was paid at the time of purchase of land. Accordingly, we do not find any merit in the grounds of appeal filed by the Revenue.

14.

In the result, appeal filed by the Revenue stands dismissed. Order pronounced in the open Court on 23rd October, 2026.

Sd/- Sd/- (MANU KUMAR GIRI) (INTURI RAMA RAO) JUDICIAL MEMBER ACCOUNTANT MEMBER Chennai; िदनांक / Dated : 23rd Oct, 2026 SGR, Sr.PS आदेश क� �ितिलिप अ�ेिषत / Copy of the Order forwarded to : अपीलाथ� / The Appellant. 1. ��यथ� / The Respondent. 2. 3. The CIT Chennai/Madurai/Coimbatore/Salem. 4. िवभागीय �ितिनिध, आयकर अपीलीय अिधकरण, “बी” ब�च, चे�नई / DR, ITAT Chennai. गाड� फ़ाइल / Guard File. 5.

GANGADHARA Digitally signed by GANGADHARA RAO SALEELA RAO SALEELA Date: 2026.10.29 10:40:24 +05'30'

More judgments on Section 69B

All 1,647 judgments and leading authorities on Section 69B →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →