JCIT, SPECIAL RANGE, PANAJI vs. M/S V. M. SALGAOCAR & BROTHERS PVT, LTD, VASCO
What did the Tribunal hold?
The Tribunal decided the issues as follows: Regarding the deletion of addition for destination sampling charges/ore analysis paid to outside parties (Revenue's Ground 6), the Tribunal noted that while the assessee claimed these were for export activities, it failed to demonstrate with sufficient evidence that these payments to agencies in Japan, China, and Hong Kong directly culminated into export orders and earned income from outside India. Therefore, this issue was remitted to the CIT(A) for fresh adjudication, requiring a remand report from the AO. This issue was allowed for statistical purposes. Concerning the deletion of disallowance of TDS on employee's salary (Revenue's Ground 7), the Tribunal upheld the CIT(A)'s deletion, relying on the Madras High Court's decision in CIT v. Cross Fraser, holding that differential tax paid on salaries to regular employees is incurred in the course of business and deserves to be allowed as business expenditure. This ground was dismissed. Regarding the deletion of TDS paid under Section 195 on reimbursements to Marriot International Inc., USA (Revenue's Ground 8), the Tribunal upheld the CIT(A)'s deletion, relying on CIT v. Cross Fraser (Madras High Court) and the Delhi Bench decision in Italian Thai Development Public Co. Ltd. v. ACIT. The Tribunal found that the assessee bore the taxes as part of business liability for international sales and marketing expenses, thus deserving allowance as business expenditure. This ground was dismissed. On the deletion of ship dry docking expenses (Revenue's Ground 9), the Tribunal followed the Bombay High Court's decision in Tax Appeal No. 70/2015 (upholding the Tribunal's decision in Salgaocar Mining Industries Pvt. Ltd.) which allowed the claim as revenue expenditure for preservation, maintenance, and upkeep, not resulting in improvement or addition to capacity. This ground was dismissed. The judgment explicitly states that all appeals of the assessee are dismissed, and the appeals of the Revenue are partly allowed for statistical purposes. The specific findings on the assessee's grounds (closing stock, education cess) and other Revenue grounds (Section 14A, forward contracts, depreciation, sundry creditors) are not detailed in the provided excerpt, but the overall result indicates these were decided against the assessee or in favor of the Revenue to some extent, leading to the dismissal of assessee's appeals.
What were the facts?
These are cross-appeals filed by the assessee, M/s. V.M. Salgaocar and Brothers Pvt. Ltd., and the Revenue (JCIT) for Assessment Years 2010-11, 2011-12, and 2012-13. The appeals challenge orders of the CIT(A), Panaji-1, which arose from assessment orders passed under Section 143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The assessee is engaged in mining, iron ore export, wind power generation, and shipping agency. For AY 2010-11, the assessee declared income of approximately Rs. 436.90 crore, which was processed under Section 143(1). The case was selected for scrutiny, and after assessment proceedings, additions totaling Rs. 27,96,29,345/- were made, assessing the income at Rs. 464,86,42,485/-. The assessee partly succeeded before the CIT(A), leading to these cross-appeals.
What were the issues?
The Tribunal had to decide several issues, including: 1. (Assessee's Ground 1a & 1c) Whether the CIT(A) erred in confirming the addition to the closing stock of Iron-ore (3,64,548 MT) earmarked for sale to related entities, amounting to Rs. 1,75,61,926, representing the difference between current cost of production and the cost of production as of April 1, 2009, by valuing it at the current cost of production. 2. (Assessee's Ground 1b & 2b) Whether the CIT(A) erred in not restricting the disallowance on account of valuation of closing stock only to AY 2006-07. 3. (Assessee's Ground 2a) Whether the CIT(A) erred in confirming an addition of Rs. 1,33,84,700 on account of stock belonging to third parties, representing the difference between current cost of production and the cost of production as of April 1, 2009. 4. (Assessee's Ground 3) Whether the liability for education cess on income tax paid should be allowed as a deductible expense. 5. (Revenue's Ground 2) Whether the CIT(A) was justified in deleting the addition made under Section 14A read with Rule 8D, despite the AO recording dissatisfaction with the assessee's claim of expenditure. 6. (Revenue's Ground 3) Whether the CIT(A) was justified in deleting the addition on account of loss debited on forward contracts, which the AO considered speculative foreign exchange loss not set off against business income. 7. (Revenue's Ground 4) Whether the CIT(A) was justified in deleting the addition for higher depreciation on a JEEP vehicle, considering it could carry more than six persons and thus not a commercial vehicle eligible for higher depreciation. 8. (Revenue's Ground 5) Whether the CIT(A) was justified in deleting the addition under Section 41(1) concerning unproved sundry creditors, where the assessee neither produced confirmations nor proved payment. 9. (Revenue's Ground 6) Whether the CIT(A) was justified in deleting the addition under Section 40(a)(ia) for destination sampling/ore analysis charges paid to non-residents, overlooking retrospective amendments to Section 9(1) and Article 12 of the DTAA with Japan. 10. (Revenue's Ground 7) Whether the CIT(A) was justified in deleting the addition for short TDS on employee's salary, considering it not a business liability. 11. (Revenue's Ground 8) Whether the CIT(A) was justified in deleting the addition for income tax paid under Section 195 on behalf of Mariott International Inc. USA, considering it not a business liability. 12. (Revenue's Ground 9) Whether the CIT(A) was correct in holding dry docking expenses as eligible for claim as current repairs, overlooking the AO's finding that it was for restoration and created enduring benefit, requiring capitalization. The assessee argued its grounds by referring to written submissions and paper books. The Revenue supported the AO's orders where the CIT(A) granted relief and relied on the CIT(A)'s findings for the assessee's grounds.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 143(3),Section 14A,Section 8D,Section 41(1),Section 40(a)(ia),Section 9(1)(vii)(b),Section 195,Section 37,Section 192
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, PANAJI DB BENCH, PANAJI
Before: DR.MANISH BORAD & SHRI VINAY BHAMORE
IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL PANAJI DB BENCH, PANAJI BEFORE DR.MANISH BORAD, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER AND SHRI VINAY BHAMORE, JUDICIAL MEMBER आयकर अपील सं. / ITA Nos.273, 274 and 298/PAN/2019 Assessment Years : 2010-11, 2011-12 and 2012-13 JCIT, Special Range, Vs. M/s. V.M. Salgaocar and Panaji, Goa Brothers Pvt. Ltd., Salgaocar House, Dr.F.L. Gomes Road, Vasco Da Gama, Goa – 403802 PAN : AAACV5950B Appellant Respondent
आयकर अपील सं. / ITA Nos.261, 262 and 283/PAN/2019 Assessment Years : 2010-11, 2011-12 and 2012-13 V.M. Salgaocar and Vs. JCIT, Margao Range, Brothers Pvt. Ltd., Margao, Goa P.B.No.14, Salgaocar House, Dr.F.L. Gomes Road, Vasco Da Gama, Goa – 403802 PAN : AAACV5950B Appellant Respondent
Assessee by : Shri Ketan Ved, CA Revenue by : Shri Naveen Kumar B CIT- DR Date of hearing : 10.08.2026 Date of pronouncement : 05.11.2026 आदेश / ORDER PER DR. MANISH BORAD, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER :
These are cross appeals filed by the assessee as well as Revenue for the A.Yrs. 2010-11, 2011-12 and 2012-13 and are directed against the separate orders of ld.CIT(A), Panaji-1
emanating out of respective Assessment Orders passed u/s.143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (in short ‘the Act’).
Some of the issues raised by the parties in these appeals are common. We therefore proceed to disposed of the appeals by this consolidated order for the sake of convenience.
Since major issues have been commonly raised in these appeals, we take the cross appeals for A.Y. 2010-11 first. Grounds of appeal raised by the assessee as well as the Revenue reads as under :
Grounds by Assessee :
“1 (a) The learned CIT (A) erred in confirming the addition to the closing stock of Iron-ore of 3,64,548 MT earmarked for sale to Salgaocar Mining Industries Ltd. and Sallitho Ores Ltd. to the extent of Rs. 1,75,61,926, being the difference between the current cost of production as on 31 March 2010 and the cost of production as on 1 April 2009. 1 (b) The learned CIT (A) erred in not appreciating the fact that the disallowance on account of valuation of closing stock was to be restricted only to assessment year 2006-07. 1 (c) The learned CIT (A) erred in holding that the closing stock needs to be valued at as per the current cost of production by following the decision of Hon'ble Panaji Tribunal in appellant's own case for the assessment year 2006-07. of 2 (a) The learned CIT(A) erred in confirming addition to the extent Rs. 1,33,84,700 on account of stock belonging to third party, being the difference between the current cost of production as on 31 March 2010 and the cost of production as on 1 April 2009. 2 (b) The learned CIT (A) erred in not appreciating the fact that the disallowance on account of valuation of closing stock was to be restricted only to assessment year 2006-07. 3. The Appellant prays that the liability for education cess on income tax paid for the year ought to be allowed as tax deductible expense while computing its taxable income. 4. Each one of the above grounds of appeal is without prejudice to the other 5. The appellant reserves the right to amend, alter or add to the grounds of appeal.”
Grounds by Revenue :
“1. The order of CIT(A), Panaji-1 is bad in law ignoring the relevant facts and findings of the Assessing Officer. 2. Whether on facts of the case, the CIT(A), Panaji-1 was justified in deleting the addition made U/s 14A rw Rule 8D when the AO had recorded his dissatisfaction regarding correctness of claim of such expenditure made by the assessee in the return of income filed.
Whether on facts of the case, the CIT(A), Panaji-1 was justified in deleting the addition made on account of loss debited on account of forward contract when it was clearly brought out by the AO that the loss debited in the accounts was on account of loss in foreign exchange and not on account of any contract in commodities manufactured or sold by the assessee. Such loss debited was clearly speculative in nature and not permitted to be set off against income from business and profession. 4. Whether on facts of the case, the CIT(A), Panaji-1 was justified in deleting the addition made on account disallowance of higher depreciation on JEEP vehicle without appreciating the fact that the Jeep Vehicle can carry more than six persons which is akin to a maxi cab and hence doesn't fall under the definition of a commercial vehicle eligible for claim of higher depreciation. 5. Whether on facts of the case, the CIT(A), Panaji-1 was justified in deleting the addition made u/s 41(1) in respect of unproved sundry creditors overlooking the fact that the assessee was neither able to produce any confirmation of credit balance nor was the balance paid till the date of assessment.
Whether on facts of the case, the CIT(A), Panaji-1 was justified in deleting the addition made u/s.40(a)(ia) in respect of expenses incurred on destination sampling charges / ore analysis charges paid to outside parties overlooking the retrospective amendment carried out by Finance Act of 2010 to section 9(1) wherein it was obligatory on the part of the assessee to deduct tax at source on payment made under technical services to a non-resident for rendering services to an Indian resident outside India for carrying out assessee's business activity in India. The CIT(A) also overlooked article 12 of DTAA entered into with Japan which provides for taxing of fees for technical services in the contracting state in which they arose. 7. Whether on facts of the case, the CIT(A), Panaji-1 was justified in deleting the addition made on account of expenditure debited by way of short TDS made in respect of employee's salary when taxes of employees of the company are definitely not an business liability of the assessee and cannot be stated to be expenditure wholly & exclusively incurred for the purpose of carrying out business of the assessee and cannot be allowed deduction U/s 37 of the Act.
Whether on facts of the case, the CIT(A), Panaji-1 was justified in deleting the addition made in respect of expenditure debited by way of income tax paid U/s 195 of Mariott Internation Inc USA when taxes of such foreign company are definitely not an business liability of the assessee and cannot be stated to be expenditure wholly & exclusively incurred for the purpose of carrying out business of the assessee and cannot be allowed deduction U/s 37 of the Act. 9. Whether on facts, the CIT(A), Panaji-1 was correct in holding that the dry docking expenses incurred by the assessee is eligible for claim as current repairs overlooking the findings of the AO wherein the assessee has incurred expenses for restoration of the ship and not for preserving or maintaining the ship thereby creating an enduring benefit requiring capitalisation of expenses. The aseessee's case is squarely covered by the decision of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Ballimal Naval Kishore which relied on the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of New Shorrock Spg & Mfg Co Ltd V/s CIT as reported in 30 ITR 338 to state that current repairs means expenditure on buildings, machinery, plant or furniture which is not for the purpose of renewal or restoration but only for the purpose of preserving or maintaining an already existing asset. 10. The appellant craves to amend or alter any grounds of appeal or add the same, if deemed necessary.”
Brief facts of the case are that the assessee is a Private Limited Company engaged in the business of Mining and Export of processed iron ore, Wind power generation and other incidental services including shipping agency. Income of Rs.436.90 crore approx.. declared in the return for A.Y. 2010-11 e-filed on 07-03- 2011 and the same was processed u/s.143(1) on 29.07.2011. Thereafter, case selected for scrutiny under CASS followed by valid serving statutory notices u/s.143(2) and 142(1) and submission were filed by the assessee and on due consideration of the same assessment proceedings have been completed making various additions totaling to Rs.27,96,29,345/- and income assessed at Rs.464,86,42,485/-. Against the various additions assessee preferred appeal before ld. CIT(A) and partly succeeded and now both the Assessee and Revenue are in appeal before this Tribunal.
Ld. Counsel for the assessee vehemently argued referring to the detailed written submissions dated 21.08.2026 along with reference to various paper books in support of the grounds raised in the assessee’s appeal as well as against the grounds raised by the Revenue.
On the other hand ld. Departmental Representative supported the order of Assessing Officer on the issues where the CIT(A) has granted relief to the assessee and so far as the grounds raised by the assessee reliance has been placed on the finding of ld. CIT(A).
We have heard the rival submissions and perused the record placed before us. We will first take up the assessee’s appeal and observe that common issues have been raised for A.Ys. 2010-11, 2011-12, 2012-13. 8. So far as the ground of appeal raised by the assessee against the disallowance of Education Cess, at the outset, ld. Counsel for the assessee requested for not pressing this ground and therefore the said ground commonly raised for A.Ys. 2010-11 to 2012-13 is dismissed as not pressed.
Ground No.1 commonly raised by the assessee for A.Ys. 2010-11, 2011-12 and 2012-13 is against of addition to closing stock being difference between current cost of production as on 31.03.2010 and the cost of production as on 01.04.2009. Brief background on these issues and the relevant submissions of the assessee reads as under:
“Brief Background A survey under section 133A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, ('the Act') was conducted upon the Appellant on 7 December 2005. One of the issues raised during survey proceedings pertained to the valuation of stock in pursuance to the High Court Order of 14 March 1990. In terms of clause 87(c) of the Hon'ble Bombay High Court order of 14 March 1990-(relevant extract of the order can be referred at page No. 191 of the paper book), the Appellant was required to sell 93,387 tons of run-off-mines ('ROM') and 2,40,740 tons of Screened Fines to Salgaocar
Mining Industries Ltd. ('SMI') at Rs. 38.66 per ton. Out of the above, the Company had sold 1,60,900 tons of Screened Fines to SMI at Rs. 38.66 per ton in March 1990, thereby leaving a balance of 93,387 tons of ROM and 79,840 tons of Screened Fines to be sold to SMI at Rs. 38.66 per ton. Similarly in terms of clause 88 of the Hon'ble Bombay High Court order of 14 March 1990, the Appellant was required to sell 2,99,880 tons of ROM to Sallitho Ores Ltd. ('SOL') at Rs. 53.35 per ton. Out of the above, the Company had sold 1,08,559 tons of ROM to SOL at Rs. 53.35 per ton, thereby leaving a balance of 1,91,321 tons of ROM to be sold to SOL at Rs. 53.35 per ton. Thus, the Appellant valued the closing stock of iron-ore of 3,64,548 MT (93,387 tons of ROM + 79,840 of Screened Fines + 1,91,321 tons of ROM) at the rate prescribed by the Bombay High Court as per its Order dated 14 March 1990 which was to be given to SMI and SOL During survey proceedings, it was agreed with the department that the Appellant was ready to adopt the value of the aforesaid stock (valued as per HC Order dated 14 March 1990) at the cost of production prevailing then, for the purpose of payment of advance tax for the AY 2006-07 subject to appeal remedies available to the Appellant against valuation without prejudice to the contention that the said stock of ore earmarked for sale as per HC Order dt. 14 March 1990 has been correctly valued and a condition that the said adjustment to value of stock will not be made in various other years. In consequence to the above survey proceedings, the Assessing Officer, for the Assessment Year 2006-07 made an addition to the closing stock for the difference between the value as per the High Court Order and the cost of production as on 31 March 2006, which has been confirmed by the CIT(A) as well as the Hon'ble Panaji Bench of Tribunal, and the matter is pending before the Hon'ble High Court. AO's Observation The Ld. AO observed that the value of closing stock shown by the Appellant for AY 2011-12 on this Issue is not accepted by the tax department and the said stock is valued as per production cost as on 31 March 2011. Accordingly, the Ld. AO made an addition of the differential value between value of the said stock of Iron ore as per the cost of production as on 31 March 2012 and value of closing stock as on 31 March 2011, to the total income. Thus, making an addition of Rs. Rs. 5,11,71,474 (Para 3.4.5, page 21 of Assessment order) CIT'A Observation The Ld. CIT(A) followed the order passed for AY 2010-11 and AY 2011- 12 and sustained the additions made by the Ld. AO in assessment order passed for AY 2012-13. (Para 41 to 44, page 27 to 28 of CIT(A)'s order)
Appellant's Submission Although in principle, the above addition to the closing stock has been decided against the Appellant for the AY 2006-07 by the Hon'ble Panaji Bench of Tribunal refer page No. 325 to 352 of the paper book for AY 2010-11 (matter pending in appeal before the HC), the Appellant submits that the said adjustment should not be made for the current assessment year as it was clearly agreed with the department that the above adjustment to the closing stock would be made only for the Assessment Year 2006-07 i.e. the year of survey and not any other year. In this connection, the Appellant would also like to draw your Honour's attention to para 9 of the letter dated 28 February 2006 (page 210 to 211 of paper book), wherein it has been clearly stated and agreed that for the various other assessment years, no additions will be made by the department relating to valuation of closing stock. The Appellant would further like to highlight that the above position has been accepted by the Assessing Officer in the assessment of the subsequent assessment years and that no addition had been made by the assessing officer for the assessment years 2007-08, 2008-09 and 2009-10. Consequently, the Appellant submits that no addition should have been made for the assessment year 2012-13 as well. Even otherwise, on merits, it is respectfully submitted that no addition whatsoever is called for in the year under consideration considering that the sales value in respect of stock has been determined by Hon'ble High Court and accordingly such sale value being Net Realisable Value should be considered for valuation of stock. In view thereof, the Appellant requests Your Honour to kindly delete the above addition made by the learned AO.
We further find that ld. CIT(A) on duly considering the decision of this Tribunal in assessee’s own case for A.Y. 2006-07 has decided the issue observing as follows:
“61. At the outset, the AR of the appellant in all fairness brought my attention to the fact that the issue of valuation the closing stock to current cost of production has been decided against the appellant by the Hon'ble Panaji Tribunal in the appellant's own case for the A.Y. 2006-07 and the matter is pending before the Hon'ble Bombay High Court. However, the AR vehemently argued that during the survey proceedings it was clearly agreed with the department that the above adjustment to the closing stock would be made only for the A.Y. 2006-07 1.c. the year of survey and not for any other year. In this connection, the AR drew my attention to the submissions made to the AO as well as the statement recorded during the course of survey proceedings. 62. The AR further submitted that the said position of restricting the disallowance on account of valuation closing stock only to A.Y. 2006-07 was agreed by the revenue, which can be borne out of the fact that no disallowance was made in the A.Ys 2007-08, 2008-09 and 2009-10. On that basis it was submitted by the AR that disallowance made in A.Y. 2010-11 is unwarranted and hence, ought to be deleted. 63. The AR then drew my attention to para 9.3 of the assessment order wherein the AO has computed the disallowance of Rs. 2,77,52,475/ by taking the difference between the present cost of production as on 31 March, 2010 and value of closing stock as on 31 March, 2006 as disallowed in A.Y. 2006-07. In other words, the AO has made additions in relation to valuation of stock for intervening A.Ys 2007-08 to 2009-10 as well. The AR vehemently argued that without prejudice to the claim that no addition should be made in the current year in respect of the closing stock, if at all the addition has to be made, it has to be restricted to Rs. 1,75,61,926/- being the difference between valuation of stock as on 1 April, 2009 and 31 March, 2010. 64. I have gone through the facts of the case, the written submissions and arguments of the AR. I find that and has been very fairly pointed out by the AR, the issue of valuation of closing stock came up for the first time in A.Y. 2006-07 wherein the AO made the disallowance, which was confirmed by the Hon'ble CIT (Appeals) as well as by the Hon'ble Panaji Tribunal. Therefore, by following the decision in appellant's own case, I principally agree that the closing stock needs to be revalued as per the current cost of production and the main ground of appeal is decided against the appellant. 65. As regards the plea of the appellant that no addition should be made in the current assessment year on the basis that it was agreed during the course of survey proceedings that the disallowance would be made only in A.Y. 2006-07, I do not find merit in such contention of the appellant as there is no change in facts in the current year as compared to A.Y. 2006- 07. However, I agree with the alternative contention of the AR that the quantum of disallowance should be restricted to only current A.Y. i.e. Rs. 1,75,61,926/ being the difference between valuation of stock as on 1 April, 2009 and 31 March, 2010. I find that the AO has wrongly computed the disallowance at Rs. 2,77,52,475/- by taking the difference between the present cost of production as on 31 March 2010 and value of closing stock as on 31 March 2006 as disallowed in A.Y. 2006-07. The AO cannot make addition in relation to valuation of stock for intervening A.Ys 2007-08 to 2009-10 and should have restricted to only current A.Y. i.e. the difference between valuation of closing stock as on 1 April, 2009 and 31 March, 2010. 66. The AR has also raised an alternate ground that the closing stock for A.Y. 2010-11 for the aforesaid items for which addition is being made, should be considered as opening stock for A.Y. 2011-12. However, the AR has fairly pointed out that in the assessment order passed by the AO for A.Y. 2011-12, the AO has considered the same. Hence, this ground becomes academic in nature. In view of the above, this ground is partly allowed in favour of the appellant and partly in favour of the revenue.”
The above finding of ld. CIT(A) remains to be controverted by the ld. Counsel for the assessee except stating that no addition
whatsoever is called for in the year under consideration since the sales value in respect of stock has been determined by the Hon’ble High Court and accordingly such sale being Net realizable value should be considered for valuation of stock. We, however, considering the fact that this issue has already been examined by this Tribunal and therefore find no reason to make any interference in the finding of ld. CIT(A) giving part relief to the assessee. Therefore, the common issue raised by the assessee in Ground no. 1 for A.Ys. 2010-11, 2011-12 and 2012-13 is dismissed.
Ground No. 2 commonly raised for impugned three assessment years is against the addition to closing stock (belonging to the third party and lying with assessee since 1990) being difference between current cost of production as on 31.03.2010 and the cost of production as on 01.04.2009. Brief background of this issue has been stated in the written submissions filed by the assessee and the same reads as under:
“Brief Background During the survey proceedings conducted on 7 December 2005, one of the issues raised was pertaining to the valuation of stock of iron-ore of 286,365 MT belonging to third party. The Appellant had been regularly purchasing iron-ore from Mr. Painguinkar, which was extracted by some third party. Similarly, the Appellant had also been regularly purchasing iron-ore from the said third party. This arrangement continued till 30 June 1989. From 1 July 1989 till 31 March 1990, the iron-ore extracted by the said third party was stacked in the area where the iron-ore of the Appellant was stacked. This quantity of iron-ore does not belong to the Appellant and therefore it has been excluded from the closing stock from the year 1989-90 till date. The Appellant has been all along, since March 1990, has been accounting the net closing stock after reducing the quantity belonging to third party. The quantity of the stock not belonging to the Appellant has also remained unchanged except during the year 31 March 1991, where some quantity of stock was lifted by third party.
However, in order to buy peace, during the survey proceedings, It was agreed to consider the stock belonging to third party for the purpose of determining the total income for the year ended 31 March 2006, subject to the condition that appropriate deduction would be allowed from the computation of the total income of the year in which the stock of iron-ore belonging to third party is returned back to them-refer page No. 210 to 211 of the paper book. AO's Observation The Ld. AO observed that the value of stock belonging to third party lying in the premises of the appellant which is not accounted in the books of accounts should be valued as per current cost of production as on 31 March 2012. Accordingly, the Ld. AO made an addition of the differential value between the value arrived as per the present cost of production as on 31 March 2012 and value of closing stock as on 31 March 2011 (as assessed), to the total income. Thus, making an addition of Rs. 3,87,79,548 (Para 3.9.2, page 35 of Assessment order) CIT(A)'s Observation The Ld. CIT(A) followed the order passed for AY 2010-11 and sustained the additions made by the Ld. AO in assessment order passed for AY 2012-13 also as he followed the same in AY 2011-12. (Para 83 to 86, page 36 to 37 of CIT(A)'s order) Appellant's Submission The Appellant submits that the said adjustment should not be made for the current assessment year as it was clearly agreed with the department that the above adjustment to the closing stock would be made only for the assessment year 2006-07 1.e. the year of survey and not any other year. In this connection, the Appellant would also like to draw your Honour's attention to para 9 of the letter dated 28 February 2006 (page 210 to 211 of paper book), wherein it has been clearly stated and agreed that for the various other assessment years, no additions will be made by the department relating to valuation of closing stock. The Appellant would further highlight that the above position has been accepted by the assessing officer in the assessment of the subsequent assessment years and that no addition has been made by the assessing officer for the assessment years 2007-08, 2008-09 and 2009-10. Consequently, the Appellant submits that no addition should have been made for the assessment year 2012-13 as well. In view thereof, the Appellant requests Your Honour to kindly delete the above addition made by the learned AO.
We find that ld. CIT(A) has examined this issue in the light of the decision of this Tribunal and held as follows:
“154. At the outset, the AR of the appellant in all fairness brought my attention to the fact that the issue of valuation the closing stock to current cost of production has been decided against the appellant by the Hon'ble Panaji Tribunal in the appellant's own case for the A.Y. 2006-07 and the matter is pending before the Hon'ble Bombay High Court. However, the AR vehemently argued that during the survey proceedings it was clearly agreed with the department that the above adjustment to the closing stock would be made only for the A.Y. 2006-07 i.e. the year of survey and not for any other year. In this connection, the AR drew my attention to the submissions made to the AO as well as the statement recorded during the course of survey proceedings. 155. The AR further submitted that the said position of restricting the disallowance on account of valuation closing stock only to A.Y. 2006-07 was agreed by the revenue, which can be borne out of the fact that no disallowance was made in the A.Ys 2007-08, 2008-09 and 2009-10. On that basis it was submitted by the AR that disallowance made in A.Y. 2010-11 is unwarranted and hence, ought to be deleted. 156. The AR then drew my attention to para 18 of the assessment order wherein the AO has computed the disallowance of Rs. 1,93,18,183/- by taking the difference between the present cost of production as on 31 March, 2010 and value of closing stock as on 31 March, 2006 as disallowed in A.Υ. 2006-07. In other words, the AO has made additions in relation to valuation of stock for intervening A.Ys 2007-08 to 2009-10 as well. The AR vehemently argued that without prejudice to the claim that no addition should be made in the current year in respect of the closing stock, if at all the addition has to be made, it has to be restricted to Rs. 1,33,84,700/- being the difference between valuation of stock as on 1 April, 2009 and 31 March, 2010. 157. The AR also submitted that if at all the addition to the closing stock is sustained; appropriate directions should be given to the AO to allow the deduction in the year in which the stock of iron-ore belonging to third party is returned back to them. The AR in this connection pointed out that the Hon'ble Panaji Tribunal in the appellant's own case for the A.Y. 2006- 07, while confirming the addition gave similar directions to the AO to grant deduction in the year of return of such stock. 58. I have gone through the facts of the case, the written submissions and arguments of the AR. I find that and has been very fairly pointed out by the AR, the issue of valuation of closing stock came up for the first time in A.Y. 2006-07 wherein the AO made the disallowance, which was confirmed by the Hon'ble CIT (Appeals) as well as by the Hon'ble Panaji Tribunal. Therefore, by following the decision in appellant's own case, I principally agree that the closing stock needs to be revalued as per the current cost of production and the main ground of appeal is decided against the appellant.
As regards the plea of the appellant that no addition should be made in the current assessment year on the basis that it was agreed during the course of survey proceedings that the disallowance would be made only in A.Y. 2006-07, I do not find merit in such contention of the appellant as there is no change in facts in the current year as compared to A.Y. 2006-07. However, I agree with the alternative contention of the AR that the quantum of disallowance should be restricted to only current A.Y. i.e. Rs.1,33,84,700/- being the difference between valuation of stock as on 1 April, 2009 and 31 March, 2010. I find that the AO has wrongly computed the disallowance at Rs. 1,93,18,183/ by taking the difference between the present cost of production as on 31 March, 2010 and value of closing stock as on 31 March, 2006 as disallowed in A.Y. 2006-07. The AO cannot make addition in relation to valuation of stock for intervening A.Ys 2007-08 to 2009-10 and should have restricted to only current A.Y. i.e. the difference between valuation of closing stock as on 1 April, 2009 and 31 March, 2010. 160. The AR has also raised an alternate ground that the closing stock for A.Y. 2010-11 for the aforesaid items for which addition is being made, should be considered as opening stock for A.Y. 2011-12. However, the AR has fairly pointed out that in the assessment order passed by the AO for A.Y. 2011-12, the AO has considered the same. Hence, this ground becomes academic in nature. 161. In view of the above, the addition to the closing stock to the extent of Rs. 1,33,84,700/- is confirmed. However, following the order of the Hon'ble Panaji Tribunal in the appellant's own case for the A.Y. 2006-07, I direct the AO to allow the deduction in the year in which the stock of iron-ore belonging to third party is returned back to them. 162. In view of the above, this ground is partly allowed in favour of the appellant and partly in favour of the revenue.”
The above finding of ld. CIT(A) is duly supported by the decision of this Tribunal and therefore respectively following the same we find that no interference is called for in the finding to ld. CIT(A) and accordingly dismiss the common issue raised in ground No. 2 for A.Ys. 2010-11, 2011-12 and 2012-13. 15. Now we take up the Revenue’s appeal. First common issue relates to disallowance u/s. 14A of the Act. Assessee has earned dividend income of Rs.26,03,978/- and suo moto disallowance has been made by the assessee at Rs.58,966/-. However, ld. Assessing Officer has made the disallowance at Rs.5,78,783/-. Ld. CIT(A) has deleted the disallowance observing that the assessee has not recorded any dissatisfaction as regards the correctness of claim of such expenditure and has mechanically proceeded to apply Rule 8D. For this, he placed reliance on the decision of the Tribunal in the case of CIT v. Sesa Goa Limited and in the assessee’s own case of A.Y. 2008-09 and 2009-10. 16. We have gone through the records and observe that ld. Assessing Officer has examined this issue u/s. 14A of the Act by firstly referring to the dividend income earned during the year and thereafter verified the suo moto disallowance offered by the assessee and subsequently dealt with the issue of recording of satisfaction and finally has proceeded applying Rule 8D of the Income Tax Rules. We therefore find that considering the fact the Rule 8D has been amended and also the facts for each of the year are distinct and also on duly examining the observation of Assessing Officer we find that for the impugned assessment years valid satisfaction has been recorded by the Assessing Officer prior to applying Rule 8D of Income Tax Rules for computing disallowance u/s. 14A of the Act. To this extent the finding to ld. CIT(A) is reversed.
However, so far as the computation of disallowance u/s. 14A is concerned, for the interest disallowance in Rule 8D(2)(ii), on due examination of the Financial Statements, we note that the assessee’s owns surplus funds with the assessee in each of the years are sufficient to cover up investments and that no interest bearing borrowed funds detected by the Assessing Officer which have been utilized for making new Investments. In view of the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of South Indian Bank Limited v. CIT (2021) 438 ITR 1 and also the judgment of Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the case of CIT vs. HDFC Bank Ltd.
(2014) 366 ITR 505, no interest disallowance is called for under Rule 8D(2)(ii).
As regards the third limb of calculation of disallowance at 0.5% of the average value of investment is concerned, we find that in view of the judgment of Hon’ble Special Bench in the case of ACIT vs. Vireet Investment Pvt. Ltd. (2017) 82 Taxman 415 (Delhi - Trib.) (SB) the disallowance u/s.14A of the Act is to be restricted for the investments which fetches exempt income, i.e. only the investments yielding dividend income should be included for the purpose of calculating disallowance at 0.5% of the average value of investments. For this purpose, the issue deserves to be restored to the file of Assessing Officer who shall examine the facts to be placed by the assessee and thereafter calculate the disallowance under Rule 8D(2)(iii) but the total disallowance u/s. 14A should not exceed the dividend income and secondly the suo moto disallowance offered by the to be deducted. The common issue raised by the Revenue for the impugned assessment years is allowed for statistical purposes.
Ground no. 3 raised by the Revenue for A.Y. 2010-11 is against the deletion of disallowance of loss on account of cancellation of forward contracts.
We find that the appellant had taken forward contracts in the normal course of business to hedge the export receivable from sale of iron ore but due to business exigencies in order to reduce the risk of losses on account of unfavourable exchange fluctuation, the forward contracts were cancelled by the assessee to reduce the losses. We note that firstly Assessing Officer has disallowed the claim but ld. CIT(A) following the decision of the Sesa Goa Limited vide ITA no. 85/PAN/2012 wherein the Tribunal following the judgment of Hon’ble High Court in the case of CIT v. Badridas
Gauridu Pvt. Ltd. 261 ITR 256 observed that loss incurred by the assessee on forward contracts has direct nexus with its export activities and such loss is incidental to the business activity and cannot be regarded as speculative loss. The above finding of ld. CIT(A) is based on the decision of this Tribunal in the case of Sesa Goa Limited and remains to be controverted by the ld. DR by placing any binding precedent in favour of the Revenue . We therefore fail to find any reason and to interfere in the finding of ld. CIT(A). Ground No. 3 raised by the Revenue is dismissed.
Next common issue has been raised by the Revenue is against the deletion of disallowance claimed on the jeeps at higher rate.
Assessee has claimed depreciation @50% on the purchase of new jeeps. However, ld. Assessing Officer observed that these jeeps do not come under the purview of commercial vehicles. However, ld. CIT(A) considering the decision of Coordinate Bench, Mumbai in the case of Daleep S. Chandnani v. ACIT (2007) 14 SOT 233 (Mumbai) has allowed the claim of the assessee wherein under similar set of facts higher rate of depreciation on jeeps were allowed. Considering the same, we fail to find any infirmity in the finding of ld. CIT(A) appeal. This common issue raised by the Revenue for A.Ys. 2010-11, 2011-12 and 2012-13 is hereby dismissed.
Next issue raised by the Revenue for A.Y. 2010-11 is against the deletion of disallowance on unpaid sundry creditors u/s. 41(1) of the Act. Ld. Assessing Officer had observed that Sundry creditors of Rs.4,05,958/- are pending for more than 3 years and had invoked section 41(1) of the Act and made the addition. However, Ld. CIT(A) considering the decision of this Tribunal in assessee’s own case for A.Y. 2009-10 vide ITA No. 56/PAN/2014 has observed that the provisions of section 41(1) of the Act gets invoked only upon the remission/cessation of the liability because the liability of an assessee does not cease merely because the liability is barred by limitation. Following the decision of this Tribunal in assessee’s own case for A.Y. 2009-10, we fail to find any infirmity in the findings of Ld. CIT(A) and accordingly dismissed Ground no. 5 raised by the Revenue for A.Y. 2010-11. 24. Next common issue raised by the Revenue for A.Ys. 2010-11, 2011-12 and 2012-13 is against the deletion of disallowance on destination sampling charges, ore analysis charges u/s.40 (a)(i) of the Act.
We observe that the assessee is in the business of mining and export of processed of iron ore. Assessee has taken services from Italab Japan, Italab (China) Pty Ltd. Hong Kong and Mitra SK, Hong Kong to conduct sampling and ore analysis at various destination ports in the respective countries. These charges were relating to services rendered for sampling and ore analysis at the destination ports and the purpose is for earning income from sources outside India. Ld. Assessing Officer has observed that in view of the retrospective amendment made by the Finance Act, 2010 in Explanation 2 to section 9 of the Act, Consultation/Technical services rendered outside India will be deemed to be accrued or arise in India. Ld. Assessing Officer also mentioned that CBDT has withdrawn the Circular 786, dated 07.02.2020 vide subsequent Circular No.7/2009 dated 22.10.2009 and that the assessee has also not obtained any certificate u/s.195(3) of the Act for non- deduction of tax at source. However, when the matter travelled before Ld. CIT(A) he deleted the disallowance observing that destination sampling and ore analysis charges has been availed by the appellant outside India in the course of its export activities to earn income source from outside India and hence these services
squarely fall within the exception provided under clause (b) of Section 9(1)(vii) of the Act.
Before this Tribunal. Ld. Counsel for the assessee has contended that the payments are covered by exception u/s. 9(1)(vii)(b) of the Act. On similar state of facts, this Tribunal has decided in favour of the assessee in the case of M/s. Tumkur Minerals Pty. Ltd. v. JCIT vide ITA No. 401/PAN/2018 and has held for such type of payments are covered by exception provided in section 9(1)(vii)(b) of the Act. We find that the nature of services provided by the companies namely, Italab Japan, Italab (China) Pty Ltd., Hong Kong and Mitra SK, Hong Kong are purely in the nature of Fees for providing Technical services which are for sampling and ore analysis and they issue the reports for carrying out such analysis. Now the claim of the assessee is that it falls in the exceptions of section 9(1)(vii)(b) as the expenses has been incurred for the purpose of making or earning any income from any source outside India, i.e. for the purpose of carrying out the export activity. We however notice that the assessee is in the business activity which includes export also but it is not the evident from the records whether the alleged payments made for sampling charges, ore analysis are specifically for the purpose of carrying out the export activity. The assessee needs to demonstrate as to what were the analysis tests carried out by these companies, based on such analysis whether the assessee has been able to procure export orders and finally exported the goods. Making a general submission that these expenses have been incurred for the purpose of earning income export from outside India will not be sufficient for the assessee to make the payments towards Fees for Technical services without deduction of tax at source. We deem it appropriate to afford one more opportunity and remit this issue to the file of ld.CIT(A) for afresh adjudication and call for a remand report from ld.
Jurisdictional Assessing Officer and only in case the assessee is able to demonstrate with sufficient evidence that the payments made towards the Fees for Technical services to the alleged agencies located at Japan, China and Hong Kong finally culminated into the export orders and that the assessee has been able to earn income from exports from outside India, then only alleged disallowance will be uncalled for. This common issue is allowed for statistical purposes.
Next issue raised by the Revenue through Ground No.7 is against the deletion of the disallowance of TDS on employee’s salary at Rs. 88,818/-.
We notice that the assessee has deducted less TDS u/s.192 but subsequently paid the differential amount in respect of salaries paid to regular employees and claimed it as deduction. Ld.Assessing Officer denied the same as an allowable expenditure. However, the Ld. CIT(A) has deleted the disallowance observing that any tax liability borne by the appellant on its business expenditure partakes the character of business and does not fall within the ambit of Section 40(a)(i) Act. We find that the findings of ld. CIT(A) are supported by the judgement of Hon’ble Madras High Court in the case of CIT v. Cross Fraser (Division by Agent BHEL) [2000]244 ITR 654 (Mad.) and find that the differential tax was paid in respect of salaries paid to the regular employees and therefore, are incurred in the course of business and therefore deserves to be allowed as business expenditure. Ground No. 7 raised by Revenue for A.Y. 2010-11 is dismissed.
The next common ground raised by the Revenue for A.Ys. 2010-11, 2011-12 and 2012-13 is against the deletion of TDS paid u/s.195 of the Act on certain reimbursements.
We note that the appellant agreed to bear and pay taxes on certain reimbursements made to Marriot International Inc., USA which were claimed as business expenditure. However, Ld. Assessing Officer observed that the tax liability even if paid by the assessee has to be recovered from the said creditors and the same cannot be claimed as business expenditure. Ld. CIT(A) has allowed it as business expenditure placing reliance on the judgement of the Hon’ble Madras High Court in the case of CIT v. Cross Fraser (Division by Agent BHEL) [2000]. 244 ITR 654. Further, the findings of the Ld. CIT(A) are supported by the decision of co-ordinate Bench, Delhi in the case of Italian Thai Development Public Co. Ltd. v. ACIT 49 SOT 450. We fail to find any infirmity in the findings of ld. CIT(A) since the assessee has borne the taxes as part of the business liability incurred towards International sales and Marketing expenses, therefore deserves to be allowed as business expenditure. This common ground raised for A.Y. 2010-11, 2011- 12, 2012-13 by the Revenue is dismissed.
The last issue for our consideration is for A.Y. 2010-11 which is against the deletion of Ship Dry Docking expenses. Assessee has incurred alleged sum towards maintenance and upkeep of Trans-shippers namely, Swathi Rani as part of the current repairs and claimed as expenses. Ld. Assessing Officer however treated the expenses as Capital expenditure and disallowed the same. Further, ld. CIT(A) based on the decision of the Tribunal in the case of Salgaocar Mining Industries Pvt. Ltd. 361 ITR 362, which was subsequently upheld by the Hon’ble Bombay High Court and vide Tax Appeal No.70/2015 allowed the said claim as Revenue expenditure observing them in the nature of repairs carried out in relation to dry docking, towards preservation, maintenance and upkeep of Transhippers and has not resulted in any improvement or addition to the capacity of the Transhippers. The above findings of ld. CIT(A) are duly supported by the judgment of Hon’ble Jurisdictional High court. We therefore respectively following the same fail to find any infirmity in the findings of ld. CIT(A) and accordingly dismiss Ground No. 9 raised by the Revenue for A.Y.2010-11. 32. In the result, all the appeals of the assessee are dismissed whereas the appeals of the Revenue are partly allowed for statistical purposes.
Order pronounced on 05th November, 2026 under Rule 34(5) of the Income Tax (Appellate Tribunal) Rules, 1963. (VINAY BHAMORE) (MANISH BORAD) JUDICIAL MEMBER ACCOUNTANT MEMBER Panaji; दिन ांक / Dated : 05th November, 2026. Satish Satish Kumar Digitally signed by Satish Kumar Madishetty Madishetty Date: 2026.11.05 15:50:57 +05'30'
आदेश की प्रतिलिपि अग्रेषित / Copy of the Order forwarded to : अपीलार्थी / The Appellant. 1. प्रत्यर्थी / The Respondent. 2. 3. The Pr. CIT concerned. विभागीय प्रतिनिधि, आयकर अपीलीय अधिकरण, Panaji 4. ‘DB’ Bench / DR, ITAT, Panaji ‘DB’ Bench गार्ड फ़ाइल / Guard File. 5. आदेशानुसार / BY ORDER,
////
More judgments on Section 14A
- Indian Herbs Specialities Private Limited… vs ACIT Circle-12 (1), DelhiITA 1785/DEL/2026[2017-18]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2017-18
- Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Ainthapali… vs The Koraput Central Cooperative Bank Ltd…ITA 475/CTK/2025[2017-18]Status: Disposed12 Nov 2026AY 2017-18
- Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Ainthapali… vs The Koraput Central Cooperative Bank Ltd…ITA 475/CTK/2025[2017-18]Status: Disposed12 Nov 2026AY 2017-18
- Agriculture Insurance Company of India… vs ITO Circle 1(1), DelhiITA 7997/DEL/2025[2022-23]Status: Disposed11 Nov 2026AY 2022-23
- Agriculture Insurance Company of India… vs ITO Circle 1(1), DelhiITA 7996/DEL/2025[2020-21]Status: Disposed11 Nov 2026AY 2020-21
Latest GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Puran Singh Fartyal vs. Khushal SinghUttarakhand · 18 Nov 2026
- Rama Gupta Construction vs. State Of UttarakhandUttarakhand · 18 Nov 2026
- Abhay Kumar Sharma vs. State Of OdishaOrissa · 18 Nov 2026
- Sunita Pandey vs. State Of UttarakhandUttarakhand · 17 Nov 2026
- Ashutosh Gupta vs. The Commissioner Central Goods And Services TaxUttarakhand · 17 Nov 2026