VAIBHAV MORARKA,MUMBAI vs. A O 19(3)(1), ,MUMBAI
What did the Tribunal hold?
The Tribunal held that the withdrawal of the set-off of Rs. 93,981/- of brought-forward capital loss for AY 2023-24, through the rectification order, was beyond the limited power of rectification. The Tribunal noted that while processing of returns in preceding years does not create a binding adjudication, it forms part of the history. The Tribunal set aside the first appellate order concerning this withdrawal and directed the CPC/AO to restore the set-off and recompute the consequential tax and interest. Regarding the foreign tax credit of Rs. 3,69,273/-, the Tribunal noted that the CIT(A) had confined his adjudication to brought-forward losses. However, the summary of the rectification order showed a difference of Rs. 3,69,273/- in tax liabilities, corresponding to this credit. Therefore, the Tribunal restored this issue to the jurisdictional Assessing Officer for limited verification of the treatment in the original intimation and rectification order, and to examine the assessee's claim in accordance with law, including applicable DTAA, Form 67, and evidence of foreign taxes paid. The appeal was partly allowed.
What were the facts?
The assessee, Vaibhav Morarka, filed an appeal against the order dated 30.12.2025 passed by the Additional/Joint Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals), Faridabad. This order stemmed from a rectification order dated 20.09.2025 passed by the Centralized Processing Centre (CPC), Bengaluru, under section 154 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, for Assessment Year (AY) 2023-24. The original return for AY 2023-24 was filed on 29.07.2023. The CPC's rectification order withdrew a set-off of Rs. 93,981/- of brought-forward long-term capital loss. The assessee also sought to raise an additional ground concerning the denial of set-off of brought-forward loss from AY 2018-19, stating the return was filed within the statutory due date, with only the ITRV acknowledgement being delayed.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the Additional/Joint Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) erred in passing the order exercising powers under section 250 of the Act, and if the order is bad in law, illegal, and without jurisdiction, violating principles of natural justice by not granting a proper opportunity of being heard? (Assessee's contention: Yes, the order is bad in law and without jurisdiction. Revenue's contention: Not recorded). 2. Whether the adjustment made by the CPC under section 143(1)(a) was beyond its scope and power, and if the issue of foreign tax credit allowability under section 90 in case of delayed Form 67 filing is debatable and thus not adjustable under section 143(1)? (Assessee's contention: Yes, the adjustment was beyond scope and debatable. Revenue's contention: Not recorded). 3. Whether the assessee is entitled to relief from double taxation on foreign tax credit of Rs. 3,69,273/- under section 90/90A for taxes paid in Portugal, and if the CIT(A) erred in holding otherwise based on surmises and wrong factual findings? (Assessee's contention: Yes, entitled to relief. Revenue's contention: Not recorded). 4. Whether the denial of set-off of brought-forward loss from AY 2018-19 is bad in law and illegal, given that the return was filed within the statutory due date, with only the ITRV acknowledgement being delayed?
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 250,Section 154,Section 143(1)(a),Section 90,Section 90A,Section 139(1)
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, MUMBAI BENCHES, MUMBAI
Before: SHRI SAKTIJIT DEY & SHRI MAKARAND VASANT MAHADEOKAR
PER MAKARAND VASANT MAHADEOKAR, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER: This appeal by the assessee is directed against the order dated 30.12.2025 passed under section 250 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (‘the Act’) by the Additional/Joint Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals), Faridabad (‘the learned CIT(A)’). The impugned order arises from the rectification order dated 20.09.2025 passed by the Centralized Processing Centre, Bengaluru (‘CPC’), under section 154 of the Act for A.Y. 2023–24.
The original grounds of appeal dated 02.02.2026 are reproduced below:
ITA No. 1429/MUM/2026 VAIBHAV MORARKA 1. THE ORDER IS WITHOUT JURISDICTION 1.1 The Additional Commissioner of Income – tax / Joint Commissioner of Income – tax (Appeals), Faridabad [‘Ld. CIT (A)’] erred in passing the order exercising the power u/s. 250 of the Income – tax Act, 1961 [‘the Act’]. 1.2 In the facts and the circumstances of the case, and in law, the order is bad in law, illegal and without jurisdiction, as the same is not in accordance with the provisions of the Act and the scheme. WITHOUT PREJUDICE 2. THE ORDER IS BAD IN LAW AND ILLEGAL 2.1 In the facts and the circumstances of the case, and in law, the order is bad in law and illegal as the same is passed in gross violation of the principles of Natural Justice. 2.2 Without generality of the above, the order is bad in law as no proper effective and fair opportunity of being heard was granted to the Appellant while passing the order. 2.3 The order is otherwise also bad in law as the same is highly arbitrary and perverse. WITHOUT FURTHER PREJUDICE TO THE ABOVE 3. DISMISSAL OF APPEAL IN LIMINE 3.1 The Ld. CIT(A) erred in dismissing the appeal of the Appellant in limine. 3.2 It is submitted that in the facts and the circumstances of the case, and in law, no such action was called for. WITHOUT PREJUDICE TO THE ABOVE 4. ADDITION / ADJUSTMENT WITHOUT JURISDICTION 4.1 The Ld. CIT(A) erred in failing to appreciate that – (a) The adjustment made by the Deputy Director of Income Tax, Centralised Processing Centre, Bengaluru [‘the A.O.’] was beyond the scope and power of the provisions of section 143 (1)(a) of the Act and, consequently, was without jurisdiction; (b) The adjustment so made by the A.O. did not fall under any of the limbs of section 143(1)(a) of the Act; (c) In any case and without prejudice, the issue of allowability of the foreign tax credit u/s. 90 of the Act in case of a delay in filing Form 67 is highly debatable in nature and, consequently, no adjustment in this regard could have been made by the A.O. in an intimation u/s. 143 (1) of the Act. 4.2 In the facts and circumstances, and in law, no such adjustment / addition was called for. 5. ON MERITS 5.1 The Ld. CIT(A) erred in holding that the Appellant was not entitled to get relief from double taxation on foreign tax credit of Rs. 3,69,273/- u/s. 90 / 90A of the Act with respect to the taxes paid in Portugal with respect to his rent income.
ITA No. 1429/MUM/2026 VAIBHAV MORARKA 5.2 While doing so, the Ld. CIT(A) erred in: (i) Basing his action on surmises, suspicion and conjecture; and (ii) Taking into account irrelevant and extraneous considerations. 5.3 While doing so the Ld. CIT (A) erred in giving wrong factual finding that the Appellant had not claimed any such relief u/s 90/90A of the Act in his return of income. 5.4 It is submitted that in the facts and the circumstances of the case, no such disallowance of the foreign tax credit was called for. 6. LIBERTY The Appellant craves leave to add, alter, delete or modify all or any the above ground at the time of hearing. 3. By an application dated 01.08.2026, the assessee has sought leave to raise the following additional ground: 6.1 The Additional / Joint Commissioner of Income – tax (Appeals), Faridabad [“Ld. CIT (A)”], erred in confirming the action of the Centralised Processing Centre in denying the set off of brought forward loss of A.Y. 2018 – 2019 on the ground that the return of income for A.Y. 2018 – 2019 was not filed within the statutory due date. 6.2 While doing so, the Ld. CIT (A) failed to appreciate that the return of income for A.Y. 2018 – 2019 was filed within the statutory due date and the delay was only in submission of the ITRV acknowledgement. 6.3 It is submitted that in the facts and the circumstances of the case, and in law, such denial of set off of loss is bad in law and illegal. 7. The Applicant craves leave to add, alter, delete or modify all or any the above ground at the time of hearing. 4. In the application, the assessee explains that the ground concerning loss set-off was inadvertently omitted while preparing the original grounds. It is stated that the relevant facts already form part of the record, no investigation into fresh facts is required for entertaining the ground, and its omission was unintentional. The assessee further submits that the proposed ground raises a question of law affecting the correctness of the tax liability and that the Revenue would have an opportunity to contest it on merits.
The material facts may first be noticed. The assessee is an individual. The return for A.Y. 2023–24 was filed on 29.07.2023. The CPC summary records total income of Rs.1,53,47,970/-. The first appellate order records
ITA No. 1429/MUM/2026 VAIBHAV MORARKA long-term capital gain of Rs.10,86,647/- and short-term capital loss of Rs.9,92,666/-, leaving a balance capital gain of Rs.93,981/-. The assessee's case is that brought-forward long-term capital loss was set off against this balance. The return was initially processed under section 143(1) by intimation dated 31.07.2024.
In the application for admission of the additional ground, the assessee has furnished the following particulars of capital losses: Assessment year Short-term capital loss Long-term capital loss 2018–19 — Rs.38,23,333/- 2019–20 — Rs.75,16,682/- 2020–21 Rs.9,706/- Rs.18,93,759/- Total Rs.9,706/- Rs.1,32,33,774/-
The assessee has further submitted that the following amounts of brought-forward long-term capital loss were allowed to be set off while processing the returns for the respective assessment years: Assessment Amount of Position stated by the assessee year set-off 2021–22 Rs.1,62,662/- Accepted on processing the return 2022–23 Rs.25,51,156/- Accepted on processing the return 2023–24 Rs.93,981/- Initially accepted under section 143(1), but subsequently withdrawn under section 154
These particulars are recorded as submissions of the assessee explaining the origin and subsequent utilization of the brought-forward losses. Their independent determination for the earlier assessment years does not arise for consideration in the present appeal, which concerns the withdrawal of the set-off of Rs.93,981/- for A.Y. 2023–24.
For A.Y. 2018–19, the assessee states that the return was electronically uploaded on 08.08.2018 declaring income of Rs.35,00,830/- and claiming carry-forward of long-term capital loss of Rs.38,23,333/-. The extended due date relied upon is 31.08.2018. The application acknowledges that the ITR-V was furnished subsequently and states that it was received by 4
ITA No. 1429/MUM/2026 VAIBHAV MORARKA CPC on 26.03.2021. The distinction drawn by the assessee is between timely electronic transmission of the return and subsequent verification thereof.
The CPC thereafter passed the rectification order dated 20.09.2025 under section 154. The stated basis was that brought-forward loss had erroneously been allowed although the return for the year to which the loss pertained had been furnished beyond the due date specified in section 139(1). The order states that notice under section 154 had been issued. Its summary records total income of Rs.1,53,47,970/- in both columns, tax liability after relief of Rs.48,72,299/- as provided by the taxpayer and Rs.52,41,572/- as computed by CPC, interest and fee of Rs.14,797/- and Rs.96,521/- respectively, prepaid taxes of Rs.48,87,099/-, and net demand of Rs.4,50,990/-. The summary does not separately quantify an increase in total income attributable to the disputed loss set-off. Consequently, the demand cannot be treated in its entirety as tax attributable to withdrawal of that set- off.
The assessee filed the first appeal on 17.10.2025. Notice under section 250 was issued on 06.12.2025, to which a reply was furnished on 12.12.2025. The assessee submitted that the A.Y. 2018–19 return had been filed on 08.08.2018 within the extended due date and sought allowance of set-off of Rs.93,981/-. The reproduced reply refers to return acknowledgements, computations for A.Ys. 2018–19 and 2023–24, and the press release dated 26.07.2018 concerning extension of the due date. A further notice dated 17.12.2025 was answered on 24.12.2025. The impugned order expressly records consideration of that reply.
The learned CIT(A) identified the controversy as denial of brought- forward loss. Paragraph 4.2 mentions amounts of Rs.17,09,516/- and Rs.18,93,759/- in the CPC's loss particulars. That paragraph contains an inconsistent description of the first loss year and refers to a rectification date of 20.02.2025, whereas the primary CPC order and the introductory 5
ITA No. 1429/MUM/2026 VAIBHAV MORARKA particulars of the first appellate order identify the relevant rectification order as dated 20.09.2025. The reproduced first appellate material also contains differing returned-income figures, including Rs.1,53,47,973/- and Rs.1,55,76,110/-. We adopt the primary CPC summary for identifying the order and its recorded total income. Those differences do not enlarge the specific set-off of Rs.93,981/- claimed for relief in this appeal.
In paragraph 4.4, the learned CIT(A), after referring to the CPC portal, accepted that the return for A.Y. 2018–19 had been filed on 08.08.2018 but stated that it had subsequently been declared invalid because the ITR-V was received after the prescribed time. It was further recorded that no reply had been furnished to the notice issued by CPC. As regards A.Y. 2020–21, paragraph 4.5 records an original return dated 09.01.2021, receipt of ITR-V on 26.03.2021 and a revised return dated 17.02.2021. The learned CIT(A) treated receipt of the ITR-V beyond 30 days as rendering the return belated. Relying upon the mandatory character of sections 80 and 139(3) the learned CIT(A) sustained the disallowance of brought-forward losses and dismissed the appeal.
Before us, the learned AR reiterated the assessee's facts and submissions and relied upon Principal Commissioner of Income-tax v. Electronics and Controls Power Systems (P.) Ltd. [2022] 134 taxmann.com 267 / 285 Taxman 92 (Karnataka), judgment dated 26.10.2021 in ITA No.273 of 2018. He also relied upon the coordinate Bench's order in the assessee's own case, Vaibhav Morarka v. ITO, ITA No.1386/Mum/2026 for A.Y. 2020–21, dated 29.06.2026. The former concerns delayed ITR-V submission and carry-forward of losses; the latter concerns foreign tax credit and belated furnishing of Form No.67.
The learned DR supported the impugned order. Drawing attention to paragraph 4.4, he submitted that the assessee had not replied to the notice issued by CPC and that the return had consequently been treated as invalid. 6
ITA No. 1429/MUM/2026 VAIBHAV MORARKA He further submitted that the foreign tax credit grievance did not arise out of the first appellate order presently under challenge.
We have considered the rival submissions and examined the material on record. We first deal with admission of the additional ground. Rule 11 of the Income-tax (Appellate Tribunal) Rules, 1963 permits a ground omitted from the memorandum to be urged with the Tribunal's leave and requires an adequate opportunity to the affected party. The discretion is to be exercised judicially to determine the actual controversy arising from the order under appeal. Here, the loss set-off is not an unrelated claim introduced for the first time. It is the very matter examined and decided in paragraphs 4.1 to 4.6 of the impugned order. The omission to formulate a specific ground before this Tribunal has been explained as inadvertent. Both sides have addressed the controversy, including the CPC notice and the finding of invalidity.
In National Thermal Power Co. Ltd. v. CIT [1998] 229 ITR 383 (SC), the Hon'ble Supreme Court recognized the Tribunal's jurisdiction to consider a legal question arising from facts already found by the authorities and affecting the assessee's tax liability. In paragraph 7, the Court observed: ‘Undoubtedly, the Tribunal will have the discretion to allow or not allow a new ground to be raised.’ The present case stands on a stronger footing for admission because the issue was expressly adjudicated by the first appellate authority. Admission does not require acceptance of every factual assertion in the application. We are satisfied that the additional ground should be entertained, and accordingly admit additional ground Nos.6.1 to 6.3.
On merits, the relevant statutory provisions must be read together. Section 74 permits the unabsorbed portion of long-term capital loss to be carried forward and set off against income arising from a long-term capital asset, subject to the statutory conditions and the prescribed eight-year limit. Section 80 restricts carry-forward and set-off of the specified losses unless they have been determined in pursuance of a return filed in accordance with 7
ITA No. 1429/MUM/2026 VAIBHAV MORARKA section 139(3). Section 139(3), in turn, contemplates a loss return furnished within the time allowed by section 139(1), in the prescribed form and verified in the prescribed manner. Timely furnishing and proper verification are therefore relevant statutory requirements. It does not follow, however, that every controversy over the legal effect of delayed verification can be decided by rectification.
The proceeding before us arises from section 154, not from a fresh scrutiny assessment. Section 154(1)(b) permits amendment of an intimation under section 143(1), but only to rectify a mistake apparent from the record. Section 154(3) additionally requires notice and reasonable opportunity where liability is increased. Compliance with the requirement of notice cannot dispense with the anterior requirement that the alleged mistake must be apparent. A failure to reply does not confer a power of review or convert a disputable inference into a patent error.
The controlling principle is stated in T.S. Balaram, ITO v. Volkart Brothers [1971] 82 ITR 50 (SC): ‘A decision on a debatable point of law is not a mistake apparent from the record’. The distinction is between correcting a demonstrable error and reconsidering the legal consequences of facts through a process admitting of competing views. Section 154 permits the former. The existence of a return on the portal, its date of transmission, subsequent verification, the legal effect of a notice and the consequences for an already accepted set-off cannot be reduced to a mechanical date comparison where those consequences are themselves the subject of judicial consideration.
The judgment relied upon by the learned AR in Electronics and Controls Power Systems (P.) Ltd.(supra) directly demonstrates the legal dimension of this controversy. In that case, concerning A.Y. 2008–09, the return had been electronically filed on 30.09.2008 and the ITR-V furnished on 31.03.2009. The Revenue sought to deny carry-forward under section 80 8
ITA No. 1429/MUM/2026 VAIBHAV MORARKA by treating verification as belated. The Hon'ble Karnataka High Court rejected the Revenue's appeal. In paragraph 11, the Court observed: ‘The view of the Department is hyper-technical for the reason that the e-filed return data indeed was transmitted on the date of such return filed electronically to the server designated by the e-Return Administrator which necessarily contains the data of the claim made by the assessee for carry forward of losses. ITR-V is verification Form which would be construed as Annexure of statement to be made to the e-filed return of income.’ 22. The Court further held in the same paragraph: ‘In our considered view, the delay caused in submitting the ITR-V does not make the return submitted on 30-9-2008 [e-filed return] invalid for denying the carry forward of losses in future years.’ 23. The said judgment is persuasive authority for this Bench and directly concerns the distinction between timely electronic filing and delayed verification in the context of loss carry-forward. We are conscious that it dealt with an earlier year and considered the commencement of the electronic-filing regime and the relaxations granted by CBDT. It cannot be read as dispensing with verification for every year or as automatically condoning every delay. Nevertheless, its reasoning provides substantial support to the assessee's contention and, at the least, excludes the proposition that withdrawal of the previously accepted set-off in the present circumstances was an indisputable correction falling within section 154. We apply that reasoning to the precise rectification issue before us.
The Hon'ble Karnataka High Court also considered the jurisdictional High Court's judgment in Crawford Bayley & Co. v. Union of India [2012] 343 ITR 232 (Bombay), dated 01.12.2011. In paragraph 7, the Hon'ble Bombay High Court observed: ‘Treating a return filed by the assessee as an invalid return has serious consequences.’ That case involved material evidencing dispatch of the ITR-V and an assessment yet to be completed; the Court permitted verification and set aside the communication treating the return as invalid. Its factual setting is different. We do not proceed on an assumption that no notice was issued here or that the present assessee had 9
ITA No. 1429/MUM/2026 VAIBHAV MORARKA proved timely dispatch. Its relevance lies in the need to examine the verification mechanism and the statutory opportunity before treating electronic filing as having no legal effect.
The learned DR's reliance on paragraph 4.4 has been considered specifically. We accept, for deciding this appeal, the finding recorded therein that the assessee did not reply to the CPC notice. The assessee cannot succeed merely by asserting that no opportunity was given. However, non- response does not answer whether the withdrawal of set-off constituted rectification of an apparent mistake. The first appellate authority itself records the electronic filing date as 08.08.2018. The adverse inference is drawn from delayed verification and the portal status of that return. Determining the effect of that status upon a later-year set-off, in light of the judicial distinction noticed above, entails a legal adjudication. The jurisdictional limitation of section 154 persists despite non-compliance with a notice.
We also distinguish the CPC notice from proceedings before the learned CIT(A). The impugned order records replies dated 12.12.2025 and 24.12.2025. There is consequently no basis for describing the first appeal as dismissed merely for non-prosecution or in limine. Our interference rests upon the legal infirmity in sustaining withdrawal through section 154 and does not rest upon a finding that the first appellate authority received no submissions.
There is a further error in the discussion of A.Y. 2020–21. Notification No.5/2022 dated 29.07.2022, issued by the Directorate of Systems, reduced the verification period to 30 days with effect from 01.08.2022 and expressly preserved the earlier 120-day period for return data transmitted before its effective date. Therefore, the mere fact that an ITR-V received on 26.03.2021 followed an original upload dated 09.01.2021 by more than 30 days could not justify the conclusion recorded in paragraph 4.5. We notice 10
ITA No. 1429/MUM/2026 VAIBHAV MORARKA this error because it forms part of the reasoning used to sustain the rectification. We do not, on that basis, direct allowance of the entire loss for A.Y. 2020–21 or decide the status of every return of that year, which would exceed the additional ground before us.
As regards A.Y. 2018–19, the stated receipt of ITR-V on 26.03.2021 was substantially later than the original verification period. Our conclusion does not depend upon treating that delay as falling within 120 days, or upon assuming that an automatic relaxation covered that date. The question here is whether the CPC could, by invoking section 154 for A.Y. 2023–24, reverse the specific set-off already accepted when doing so required resolution of the legal consequences of delayed verification. For the reasons given above, that question must be answered in favour of the assessee. This order does not separately set aside an earlier-year invalidation communication or confer a general validation of all earlier returns.
The references in the impugned order to the mandatory character of sections 80 and 139(3) do not resolve this jurisdictional difficulty. We do not dilute those provisions. The issue is their application to an electronically transmitted return followed by delayed verification and the permissible scope of the later rectification. General propositions concerning belated loss returns do not establish that this particular withdrawal was an apparent error. The learned CIT(A) did not address the distinction in Electronics and Controls Power Systems (P.) Ltd. (supra) or test the CPC's action against the limit imposed by section 154. The order sustaining the withdrawal therefore cannot stand.
The assessee's assertion that earlier set-offs had been accepted also requires a confined treatment. Processing of returns in preceding years does not establish a binding adjudication of every element of loss entitlement, nor does it prevent correction of a genuine apparent mistake within the statute. It does, however, form part of the history in which the present set-off was 11
ITA No. 1429/MUM/2026 VAIBHAV MORARKA claimed and accepted. We grant relief because the subsequent withdrawal travels beyond the limited power of rectification in the circumstances examined, rather than because earlier processing creates an unconditional right to the whole loss balance.
We accordingly set aside the impugned first appellate order insofar as it sustains withdrawal, through the rectification order dated 20.09.2025, of the set-off of Rs.93,981/- claimed against capital gains for A.Y. 2023–24. The CPC/jurisdictional Assessing Officer shall restore that specific set-off to the position obtaining before the impugned rectification and recompute the consequential tax and interest. This is a direction to give effect to our decision, and not a remand for reconsideration of the merits of that set-off. No fresh enquiry into the legal entitlement settled by this order is authorized at the stage of giving effect. Equally, this direction does not determine or enhance the entire carried-forward loss balances for other assessment years.
We next consider the original grounds concerning foreign tax credit. The learned DR is correct that the order dated 30.12.2025 does not adjudicate that claim. Its identified controversy and findings concern brought-forward losses. The coordinate Bench's order dated 29.06.2026 in the assessee's own case, ITA No.1386/Mum/2026, concerns A.Y. 2020–21 and credit for taxes paid in Spain. Paragraph 27 states: ‘Consequently the claim made by the Assessee under Section 90 of the Act is allowed, subject to factual verification by the Jurisdictional Assessing Officer.’ That decision does not adjudicate the present year's loss set-off, and its relief cannot be mechanically imported into this appeal concerning a different order and assessment year.
Ground No.4.1(c) and ground Nos.5.1 to 5.4 concern foreign tax credit of Rs.3,69,273/- in respect of Portuguese rental income. The learned DR has submitted that this grievance does not arise from the impugned order. We find that the learned CIT(A) has confined his adjudication to brought- 12
ITA No. 1429/MUM/2026 VAIBHAV MORARKA forward capital losses. However, the summary accompanying the rectification order records identical total income in the taxpayer’s and CPC’s computations, while the difference between the respective tax liabilities after relief is Rs.3,69,273/-, corresponding to the foreign tax credit disputed by the assessee. The complete computation underlying this difference requires verification.
We therefore restore this issue to the file of the jurisdictional Assessing Officer for the limited purpose of examining the treatment of the disputed foreign tax credit in the intimation dated 31.07.2024 and the rectification order dated 20.09.2025. The Assessing Officer shall compare the complete computations and ascertain whether the impugned rectification denied, withdrew or otherwise altered the credit claimed by the assessee, or merely carried forward a demand arising from the original intimation.
To the extent that the disputed denial or withdrawal forms part of the impugned rectification, the Assessing Officer shall examine the assessee’s claim in accordance with law, having regard to the applicable statutory provisions, the relevant Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement, Form No.67, evidence of foreign taxes paid and the corresponding income offered to tax in India. The judicial decisions relied upon by the assessee, including the coordinate Bench’s order in the assessee’s own case for A.Y. 2020–21, shall be considered after examining their applicability to the relevant facts and assessment year. We express no opinion on the substantive entitlement to credit.
If the verification establishes that the disputed denial arose exclusively from the original intimation and was neither considered nor altered in the rectification proceedings, the Assessing Officer shall record that position with reasons. This remand shall not authorize reopening of an independent proceeding otherwise outside the scope of the present appeal. A reasonable
ITA No. 1429/MUM/2026 VAIBHAV MORARKA opportunity of hearing shall be afforded to the assessee, and a speaking order shall be passed.
These grounds are accordingly allowed for statistical purposes to the limited extent indicated above. The direction to restore the capital loss set- off of Rs.93,981/- shall be implemented independently, without awaiting disposal of the foreign tax credit issue.
In view of our decision allowing additional ground Nos.6.1 to 6.3 and directing restoration of the capital loss set-off of Rs.93,981/-, the remaining original grounds concerning jurisdiction, opportunity of hearing and legality of the adjustment, insofar as they relate to the loss controversy, are rendered academic and require no separate adjudication. Ground No.4.1(c) and ground Nos.5.1 to 5.4 concerning foreign tax credit are allowed for statistical purposes, subject to the limited verification and adjudication directed above.
In the result, the appeal of the assessee is partly allowed, with the grounds concerning foreign tax credit allowed for statistical purposes in the terms indicated above. Order pronounced in the open court on 27-10-2026.
Sd/- Sd/- SAKTIJIT DEY MAKARAND VASANT MAHADEOKAR VICE PRESIDENT ACCOUNTANT MEMBER Mumbai Dated: 27.10.2026
ITA No. 1429/MUM/2026 VAIBHAV MORARKA
Copy to: VAIBHAV MORARKA, 12-14, BRADFY HOUSE V . N ROAD 1 CHURCHGATE N MUMBA8I, MUMBAI-400001, MAHARASHTRA
A O 19(3)(1), 4TH FLOOR ,PIRAMAL CHAMBERS , 2 LALBAUGH, MUMBAI-400012, MAHARASHTRA
3 THE PCIT / CIT, 4 THE D.R., ITAT, MUMBAI BENCH 5 GUARD FILE
More judgments on Section 154
- Sanjeev Kumar, Uttar Pradesh vs Ward 3 (2)(4) Muzaffarnagar, Aayakar…ITA 6556/DEL/2026[2021-22]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2021-22
- Sanjeev Kumar, Uttar Pradesh vs Ward 3 (2)(4) Muzaffarnagar, Aayakar…ITA 6555/DEL/2026[2020-21]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2020-21
- Lowes India Private Limited, Bangalore vs Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle…ITA 1245/BANG/2026[2022-23]Status: Disposed16 Nov 2026AY 2022-23
- Dyneshwar Nagrao Nimbulkar Through Legal… vs ITO Ward 4(4), NagpurITA 817/NAG/2026[2011-2012]Status: Disposed16 Nov 2026AY 2011-2012
- Dyneshwar Nagrao Nimbulkar Through Legal… vs ITO Ward 4(4), NagpurITA 816/NAG/2026[2011-2012]Status: Disposed16 Nov 2026AY 2011-2012
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- M/S Sun Shine Metal Works vs. State Of U.P And AnotherAllahabad · 4 Nov 2026
- M/S Bansal Sanitary Store vs. State Of U.P. And 2 OthersAllahabad · 4 Nov 2026
- M/S Princess Girls Collection vs. State Of U.P. And AnotherAllahabad · 4 Nov 2026
- Prabhat Kumar vs. The State Of BiharPatna · 4 Nov 2026
- Siddharth Barai (Prop- Siddharth Design Studio) vs. The Superintendent CGST And Central Excise, Balangir RangeOrissa · 4 Nov 2026