DYNESHWAR NAGRAO NIMBULKAR THROUGH LEGAL HEIR PRASHANT NIMBULKAR,NAGPUR vs. ITO WARD 4(4), NAGPUR

PDF · subscribers
ITA 817/NAG/2026Status: DisposedITAT Nagpur16 November 2026AY 2011-201212 pages

In favour of the assessee: the assessee's appeal was allowed. From the AI summary of this appeal.

AI SummaryAllowed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal held that the assessment order framed in the name of a deceased assessee, when the Assessing Officer was aware of the death, is illegal and bad in law. The Tribunal noted that the notice under Section 148 for re-assessment proceedings was issued on 29.03.2018, but the assessee had expired on 10.08.2011, much before the initiation of these proceedings. Despite being aware of the death, the Assessing Officer proceeded with the assessment in the name of the deceased. The Tribunal relied on the Delhi High Court's decision in *Savita Kapila LH of Late Shri Mohinder Paul Kapila* and its own decision in *Sunita Pankaj Patel LH of Pankaj Patel*, which held that issuing a notice under Section 148 to a deceased person is a jurisdictional defect and renders the assessment proceedings null and void. The Tribunal admitted this legal issue, even though raised for the first time, as the facts were apparent on record. Consequently, the re-assessment order dated 29.12.2018 was quashed, and the additions were deleted. The penalty under Section 271(1)(c) was also deleted as it was dependent on the quantum addition. The finding of the Ld. CIT(A) was set aside.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Dyneshwar Nagrao Nimbulkar, through his legal heir Prashant Nimbulkar, filed appeals against orders of the CIT(A) concerning Assessment Year 2011-12. These orders arose from a rectification order under section 154 and a penalty order under section 271(1)(c) passed by the ITO. The appeals were filed with a significant delay of 839 and 686 days, attributed to the previous tax consultant's failure to inform the assessee about the dismissal of an earlier appeal. The Tribunal condoned the delay subject to a cost of Rs. 1000/- per appeal. The primary grievance on merits was the addition of Rs. 21,96,661/-. The assessee contended that the assessment order was illegal as it was framed in the name of a deceased person, despite the Assessing Officer being aware of the assessee's death.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the assessment order framed in the name of a deceased assessee, despite the Assessing Officer being aware of the death, is valid in law? (Question of law, turning on Section 147 and Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961). Assessee's Contention: The assessment order is illegal and bad in law as it was framed in the name of a deceased person. The Assessing Officer was aware of the assessee's death. Reliance was placed on various High Court and Tribunal decisions, including *Sunita Pankaj Patel LH of Pankaj Patel vs. DCIT*, *Savita Kapila LH of Late Shri Mohinder Paul Kapila vs. ACIT*, and *Late Jankidevi Nandlal Jaiswal vs. ITO*. Revenue's Contention: This legal issue was raised for the first time before the Tribunal and had not been raised before the Ld. CIT(A).

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 154,Section 271(1)(c),Section 250,Section 148,Section 147,Section 143(2),Section 149(1)(b),Section 143(3)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, NAGPUR SMC BENCH, NAGPUR

Before: SHRI MANISH BORAD

For Appellant: Shri Dilip Lohiya, CA
Hearing: 16/10/2026Pronounced: 16/11/2026

IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL NAGPUR "SMC" BENCH, NAGPUR BEFORE SHRI MANISH BORAD, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER (through virtual hearing)

ITA No. 816 & 817/NAG/2026 (Asst. Year : 2011-12) Dyneshwar Nagrao ITO, Ward-4(4), Nagpur Nimbulkar through Legal vs Heir Prashant Nimbulkar, 30 Hudkeshwar Road, Mahatma Gandhi Nagar, Nagpur-4400024. PAN : ACGPN 3911 P Assessee Revenue

Assessee by : Shri Dilip Lohiya, CA Department by : Miss Jaya Lakhwani, Sr.DR Date of hearing : 16/10/2026 Date of Pronouncement : 16/11/2026

O R D E R This appeal filed by the assessee is directed against the order of Ld. Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)/NFAC, Delhi (for short, “CIT(A)”) dated 29.02.2024 & 31.07.2024 passed u/sec. 250 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (for short, “Act”) which are arising out of rectification order dated 24.07.2019 passed u/sec. 154 of the Act and penalty order dated 28.06.2019 passed u/s. 271(1)(c) of the Act by the ITO, Ward-4(5), Nagpur for the Assessment Year (A.Y.) 2011-12 respectively.

2.

Registry has informed that there is a delay of 839 and 686 days in filing the present appeals. Applications for condonation of delay along with affidavits are placed on record. The main reason for delay is that assessee was dependent on the earlier

2 ITA No.816 & 817/NAG/2026 (Dyneshwar Nagrao Nimbulkar through LH Prashant Nimbulkar) Tax Consultant, who did not inform the assessee about dismissal of appeal by the Ld. CIT(A) and the assessee came to know only after receipt of notice of outstanding demand and immediately approached the present Tax Consultant and took steps to file the present appeal, which resulted into filing the appeal belatedly. Considering the facts and circumstances and in the interest of justice and taking guidance from the judgments of Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Collector Land Acquisition, Anantnag vs. Mst. Katiji & Ors [1987 (2) SCC 107] and also in the case of Inder Singh vs. State of Madhya Pradesh dated 21.03.2025 [(2025) INSC 382)], I hereby condone the delay subject to payment of costs of Rs. 1000/- for each appeal, to be deposited with Maharashtra State Legal Services Authority within 30 days from the date of receipt of this order.

3.

In the quantum appeal in ITA No.816/NAG/2026, the grievance of the assessee, on merits, is against the addition of Rs. 21,96,661/- (after rectify claim of demand as per order u/sec. 154 dated 24.07.2019). On merits, it is contended that assessment order deserves to be quashed as it has been framed in the case of deceased person and that the information about death of the assessee was very much made available with the Ld. AO and the Ld. AO has incorporated the same in the assessment order. In support, reliance is placed on the following decisions:-

i) Sunita Pankaj Patel LH of Pankaj Patel vs. DCIT (ITA No.439/NAG/2025, dated 19.06.2026) (Nag. Trib.) ii) Savita Kapila LH of Late Shri Mohinder Paul Kapila vs. ACIT in WP(C) No.3258/2020 dated 16.07.2020 (Del. HC)

3 ITA No.816 & 817/NAG/2026 (Dyneshwar Nagrao Nimbulkar through LH Prashant Nimbulkar) iii) Late Jankidevi Nandlal Jaiswal through LR Amit Mohanlal Jaiswal vs. ITO (ITA No. 238/NAG/2024, dated 27.03.2026) (Nag. Trib.) iv) ACIT vs. Raniben Khimji Patel LH of Shri Khimji Karmashi Patel (ITA No.1743/MUM/2025, dated 1308.2025) (Mum. – Trib.) v) Rajesh Punyani L/H of Late Bhagwandas Punyani vs. ITO (ITA No. 179/NAG/2025, dated 09.06.2025) (Nag. – Trib.) vi) Madan Lal Kochar thrugh Sahil Kochar vs. PCIT (ITA No. 2516/DEL/2024, dated 05.09.2024) (Del.–Trib.) vii) Smt. Jubedabai M. Reshamwal through LH Shri Salim M. Reshamwala vs. ITO (ITA No. 1478/AHD/2016, dated 28.09.32020) (Ahd. – Trib.)

4.

On the other hand, Ld.DR supported the order of Ld.CIT(A) and submitted that this legal issue has never been raised before the Ld. CIT(A) and has been raised before this Tribunal for the first time.

5.

I have heard the rival submissions and perused the material placed before me. So far as merits of the case is concerned, assessee has already been granted major relief by the Ld.AO as per order u/s. 154 of the Act. So far as legal issue is concerned, it is contended that the information about death of assessee was available with the Ld. AO and in spite of being aware of the death of assessee, Ld. AO has framed assessment in the name of deceased person which is illegal, bad in law and therefore assessment order deserves to be quashed. I notice that assessment proceedings for A.Y.2011-12 were initiated and notice u/s. 148 of the Act dated 29.03.2018 was served upon the legal heir of the assessee namely, Prashant Nimbulkar. During the course of re-assessment proceedings itself, it was informed that assessee has expired on 10.08.2011 which is much before initiation of re-assessment proceedings. In spite of

4 ITA No.816 & 817/NAG/2026 (Dyneshwar Nagrao Nimbulkar through LH Prashant Nimbulkar) being aware about the death of assessee, Ld. AO carried out the proceedings and all the notices were replied by the legal heir, but finally assessment order has been framed in the name of the deceased assessee i.e. Dyneshwar Nagrao Nimbulkar. Whether such assessment order can be termed as valid having been made in the name of deceased person and subsequently even Ld. CIT(A) passed the impugned order in the name of the deceased person. Now at this juncture, I take note of the decision of the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in the case of Savita Kapila LH of Late Shri Mohinder Paul Kapila (supra) wherein also notice issued u/s.148 dated 31.03.2019 to the deceased assessee after his death i.e. 21.12.2018 and the Hon'ble Court held in favour of the assessee quashing the re-assessment proceedings observing as follows:-

“25. In the present case the notice dated 31st March, 2019 under Section 148 of the Act, 1961 was issued to the deceased assessee after the date of his death [21st December, 2018] and thus inevitably the said notice could never have been served upon him. Consequently, the jurisdictional requirement under Section 148 of the Act, 1961 of service of notice was not fulfilled in the present instance. 26. In the opinion of this Court the issuance of a notice under Section 148 of the Act is the foundation for reopening of an assessment. Consequently, the sine qua non for acquiring jurisdiction to reopen an assessment is that such notice should be issued in the name of the correct person. This requirement of issuing notice to a correct person and not to a dead person is not merely a procedural requirement but is a condition precedent to the impugned notice being valid in law. [See Sumit Balkrishna Gupta Vs. Asstt. Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle 16(2), Mumbai & Ors., (2019) 2 TMI 1209 - Bombay High Court]. 27. In Chandreshbhai Jayantibhai Patel Vs. The Income Tax Officer, 2019 (1) TMI 353 - Gujarat High Court has also held, "the question that therefore arises for consideration is whether the notice under Section 148 of the Act issued against the deceased assessee can be said to be in conformity with or according to the intent and purposes of the Act. In this regard, it may be noted that a notice under Section 148 of the Act is a jurisdictional

5 ITA No.816 & 817/NAG/2026 (Dyneshwar Nagrao Nimbulkar through LH Prashant Nimbulkar) notice, and existence of a valid notice under Section 148 is a condition precedent for exercise of jurisdiction by the Assessing Officer to assess or reassess under Section 147 of the Act. The want of valid notice affects the jurisdiction of the Assessing Officer to proceed with the assessment and thus, affects the validity of the proceedings for assessment or reassessment. A notice issued under Section 148 of the Act against a dead person is invalid, unless the legal representative submits to the jurisdiction of the Assessing Officer without raising any objection." Consequently, in view of the above, a reopening notice under Section 148 of the Act, 1961 issued in the name of a deceased assessee is null and void. ALSO, NO NOTICE UNDER SECTION 148 OF THE ACT, 1961 WAS EVER ISSUED UPON THE PETITIONER DURING THE PERIOD OF LIMITATION. CONSEQUENTLY, THE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE PETITIONER ARE BARRED BY LIMITATION AS PER SECTION 149(1)(b) OF THE ACT, 1961. 28. Also, no notice under Section 148 of the Act, 1961 was ever issued to the petitioner during the period of limitation and simply proceedings were transferred to the PAN of the petitioner, who happens to be one of the four legal heirs of the deceased assessee vide letter dated 27th December, 2019. Therefore, the assumption of jurisdiction qua the Petitioner for the relevant assessment year is beyond the period prescribed and consequently, the proceedings against the petitioner are barred by limitation in accordance with Section 149(1)(b) of the Act, 1961. 29. In Smt. Sudha Prasad (supra) the petitioner had challenged the assessment order and demand notice only. Neither non- issuance of notice was challenged nor the issue of proceedings being barred by limitation was raised or decided. Consequently, the said judgment is inapplicable to the present case and is therefore, of no help to the revenue. AS IN THE PRESENT CASE PROCEEDINGS WERE NOT INITIATED / PENDING AGAINST THE ASSESSEE WHEN HE WAS ALIVE AND AFTER HIS DEATH THE LEGAL REPRESENTATIVE DID NOT STEP INTO THE SHOES OF THE DECEASED ASSESSEE, SECTION 159 OF THE ACT, 1961 DOES NOT APPLY TO THE PRESENT CASE. 30. Section 159 of the Act, 1961 applies to a situation where proceedings are initiated / pending against the assessee when he is alive and after his death the legal representative steps into the shoes of the deceased assessee. Since that is not the present factual scenario, Section 159 of the Act, 1961 does not apply to the present case.

6 ITA No.816 & 817/NAG/2026 (Dyneshwar Nagrao Nimbulkar through LH Prashant Nimbulkar)

31.

In Alamelu Veerappan Vs. The Income Tax Officer, Non Corporate Ward 2(2), Chennai, 2018 (6) TMI 760 - Madras High Court, it has been held by the Madras High Court, "In such circumstances, the question would be as to whether Section 159 of the Act would get attracted. The answer to this question would be in the negative, as the proceedings under Section 159 of the Act can be invoked only if the proceedings have already been initiated when the assessee was alive and was permitted for the proceedings to be continued as against the legal heirs. The factual position in the instant case being otherwise, the provisions of Section 159 of the Act have no application." In Rajender Kumar Sehgal (supra), a Coordinate bench of this Court has held, "This court is of the opinion that the absence of any provision in the Act, to fasten revenue liability upon a deceased individual, in the absence of pending or previously instituted proceeding which is really what the present case is all about, renders fatal the effort of the revenue to impose the tax burden upon a legal representative." THERE IS NO STATUTORY REQUIREMENT IMPOSING AN OBLIGATION UPON LEGAL HEIRS TO INTIMATE THE DEATH OF THE ASSESSEE. 32. This Court is of the view that in the absence of a statutory provision it is difficult to cast a duty upon the legal representatives to intimate the factum of death of an assessee to the income tax department. After all, there may be cases where the legal representatives are estranged from the deceased assessee or the deceased assessee may have bequeathed his entire wealth to a charity. Consequently, whether PAN record was updated or not or whether the Department was made aware by the legal representatives or not is irrelevant. In Alamelu Veerappan (supra) it has been held "nothing has been placed before this Court by the Revenue to show that there is a statutory obligation on the part of the legal representatives of the deceased assessee to immediately intimate the death of the assessee or take steps to cancel the PAN registration." 33. The judgment in Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax v. Maruti Suzuki India Limited (supra) offers no assistance to the respondents. In Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax v. Maruti Suzuki India Limited (supra) the Supreme Court was dealing with Section 170 of the Act, 1961 (succession to business otherwise than on death) wherein notice under Section 143(2) of the Act, 1961 was issued to non-existing company. In that case, Department by very nature of transaction was aware about the amalgamation. However, the said judgment nowhere states that there is an obligation upon the legal representative to inform the Income Tax Department about the death of the assessee or to

7 ITA No.816 & 817/NAG/2026 (Dyneshwar Nagrao Nimbulkar through LH Prashant Nimbulkar) surrender the PAN of the deceased assessee. The relevant portion of the said judgment is reproduced hereinbelow:- "35. In this case, the notice under Section 143(2) under which jurisdiction was assumed by the assessing officer was issued to a non-existent company. The assessment order was issued against the amalgamating company. This is a substantive illegality and not a procedural violation of the nature adverted to in Section 292B. xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx 39. In the present case, despite the fact that the assessing officer was informed of the amalgamating company having ceased to exist as a result of the approved scheme of amalgamation, the jurisdictional notice was issued only in its name. The basis on which jurisdiction was invoked was fundamentally at odds with the legal principle that the amalgamating entity ceases to exist upon the approved scheme of amalgamation. Participation in the proceedings by the appellant in the circumstances cannot operate as an estoppel against law. This position now holds the field in view of the judgment of a co-ordinate Bench of two learned judges which dismissed the appeal of the Revenue in Spice Enfotainment on 2 November 2017. The decision in Spice Enfotainment has been followed in the case of the respondent while dismissing the Special Leave Petition for AY 2011-2012. In doing so, this Court has relied on the decision in Spice Enfotainment. 34. Consequently, the legal heirs are under no statutory obligation to intimate the death of the assessee to the revenue. SECTION 292B OF THE ACT, 1961 HAS BEEN HELD TO BE INAPPLICABLE VIZ-A-VIZ NOTICE ISSUED TO A DEAD PERSON IN RAJENDER KUMAR SEHGAL (SUPRA), CHANDRESHBHAI JAYANTIBHAI PATEL (SUPRA) AND ALAMELU VEERAPPAN (SUPRA). 35. This Court is of the opinion that issuance of notice upon a dead person and non-service of notice does not come under the ambit of mistake, defect or omission. Consequently, Section 292B of the Act, 1961 does not apply to the present case. 36. In Skylight Hospitality (supra) notice was issued to Skylight Hospitality Pvt. Ltd. instead of Skylight Hospitality LLP. In that factual context, this Court had observed, "Noticeably, the appellant having received the said notice, had filed without prejudice reply/letter dated April 11, 2017. They had objected to the notice being issued in the name of the company, which had ceased to exist. However, the reading of the said letter indicates that they had understood and were aware, that the notice was for them. It was relied and dealt with by them." The Supreme

8 ITA No.816 & 817/NAG/2026 (Dyneshwar Nagrao Nimbulkar through LH Prashant Nimbulkar) Court while dismissing the SLP had also observed "In the peculiar facts of this case, we are convinced that wrong name given in the notice was merely a clerical error which could be corrected under Section 292B of the Income Tax Act." 37. In any event, Section 292B of the Act, 1961 has been held to be inapplicable viz-a-viz notice issued to a dead person in Rajender Kumar Sehgal (supra), Chandreshbhai Jayantibhai Patel (supra) and Alamelu Veerappan (supra). In all the aforesaid cases, the judgment of Skylight Hospitality (supra) had been cited by the revenue. IN RAJENDER KUMAR SEHGAL (SUPRA) A COORDINATE BENCH OF THIS COURT HAS HELD THAT SECTION 292BB OF THE ACT, 1961 IS APPLICABLE TO AN ASSESSEE AND NOT TO A LEGAL REPRESENTATIVE. 38. This Court is also of the view that Section 292BB of the Act, 1961 is applicable to an assessee and not to a legal representative. Further, in the present case one of the legal heirs of the deceased assessee, i.e. the petitioner, had neither cooperated in the assessment proceedings nor filed return or waived the requirement of Section 148 of the Act, 1961 or submitted to jurisdiction of the Assessing Officer. She had merely uploaded the death certificate of the deceased assessee. In Commissioner of Income Tax-VIII, Chennai Vs. Shri M. Hemanathan, 2016 (4) TMI 258 - Madras High Court it has been held "In the case on hand, the assessee was dead. It was the assessee's son, who appeared and perhaps cooperated. Therefore, the primary condition for the invocation of Section 292BB is absent in the case on hand. Section 292BB is in place to take care of contingencies where an assessee is put on notice of the initiation of proceedings, but who takes advantage of defective notices or defective service of notice on him. It is trite to point out that the purpose of issue of notice is to make the noticee aware of the nature of the proceedings. Once the nature of the proceedings is made known and understood by the assessee, he should not be allowed to take advantage of certain procedural defects. That was the purpose behind the enactment of Section 292BB. It cannot be invoked in cases where the very initiation of proceedings is against a dead person. Hence, the second contention cannot also be upheld." 39. Even a Coordinate Bench of this Court in Rajender Kumar Sehgal (supra) has held "If the original assessee had lived and later participated in the proceedings, then, by reason of Section 292BB, she would have been precluded from saying that no notice was factually served upon her. When the notice was issued in her name when she was no longer of this world, it is inconceivable that she could have participated in the

9 ITA No.816 & 817/NAG/2026 (Dyneshwar Nagrao Nimbulkar through LH Prashant Nimbulkar) reassessment proceedings, (nor is that the revenue's case) to be estopped from contending that she did not receive it. The plain language of Section 292BB, in our opinion precludes its application, contrary to the revenue's argument." 40. Consequently, the applicability of Section 292BB of the Act, 1961 has been held to be attracted to an assessee and not to legal representatives. CONCLUSION 41. To conclude, the arguments advanced by the respondent are no longer res integra and have been consistently rejected by different High Courts including this jurisdictional Court. In view of consistent, uniform and settled position of law, to accept the submissions of the respondent would amount to unsettling the “settled law‟. In fact, in Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax v. Maruti Suzuki India Limited (supra), the Supreme Court speaking through Hon‟ble (Dr.) Justice Dhananjaya Y. Chandrachud has succinctly observed as under:- "40. We find no reason to take a different view. There is a value which the court must abide by in promoting the interest of certainty in tax litigation. The view which has been taken by this Court in relation to the respondent for AY 2011-12 must, in our view be adopted in respect of the present appeal which relates to AY 2012-13. Not doing so will only result in uncertainty and displacement of settled expectations. There is a significant value which must attach to observing the requirement of consistency and certainty. Individual affairs are conducted and business decisions are made in the expectation of consistency, uniformity and certainty. To detract from those principles is neither expedient nor desirable." 42. Keeping in view the aforesaid, the present writ petition is allowed and the impugned notice dated 31st March, 2019 and all consequential orders/proceedings passed/initiated thereto including orders dated 21 st November, 2019 and 27th December, 2019 are quashed.”

6.

I also take note of the decision of this Tribunal in the case of Sunita Pankaj Patel LH of Pankaj Patel (supra) where the Tribunal similar issue has dealt with and quashed the re-assessment proceedings, as notice issued u/s. 143(2) of the Act has been issued in the name of the deceased assessee observing as follows:-

10 ITA No.816 & 817/NAG/2026 (Dyneshwar Nagrao Nimbulkar through LH Prashant Nimbulkar) 8. We have given thoughtful consideration to the material on record and are of considered view that though the ground has been raised specifically before this Tribunal, but in Form–35 also, assessee has raised ground as follows;– “1. The learned Assessing Officer erred in law as well as in facts and also in the circumstances by framing an assessment order u/s. 143(3) of the IT Act, 1961 which illegal and is bad in law ab– initio.” 9. Thus at one hand, the ground No. 1 as raised before Ld. First Appellate Authority sufficiently covers the issue wherein impugned assessment order is challenged for want of jurisdiction and illegality vitiating the assessment order, on the other hand being a pure question of law which can be decided on admitted facts, the ground could have been raised before this Tribunal too. Thus, for any delay and latches, the appellant’s claim in ground No. 1 before us cannot be dismissed. 10. Then we find that admittedly assessee Pankajbhai Natwarlal Patel had died on 19th of July, 2018 and on 31st July, 2018, the return was filed. In Para 2 of the assessment order, Assessing Officer has taken note of the fact that the case was transferred to Judicial Assessing Officer from National e– Assessment Centre, Delhi on the grounds of bringing legal heirs on record. Subsequently, the widow of assessee Smt. Sunita Patel, who is appellant before us, has given her undertaking and consent to act as legal heir in the proceedings initiated under Section 143(2) of the Act as her three daughters are non–resident Indian. The assessment order shows that the return income as per ITR filed on 31st July, 2018 has been accepted and based upon the same, the return of income was accepted and disputed additions made. 11. Thus, it is sufficiently established that Assessing Officer was well informed of the fact of death of assessee on 19th July, 2018 well before the filing of the return of income and initiation of assessment proceedings. Further, Assessing Officer has accepted the return as filed and processed it under Section 143(2) by assuming jurisdiction and completed the assessment passing assessment order in the name of deceased Pankajbhai Natwarlal Patel. Admittedly, the demand notice has also been issued in the name of deceased assessee Pankajbhai Natwarlal Patel. That being the state of affairs, the contentions which Ld. DR as raised that due to some technical glitches, notices were issued in the name of Shri Pankaj Patel, but in the annexures attached, the name of Smt. Sunita Patel is duly depicted even if considered good enough an explanation for the issuance of notice under Section 143(2) of the Act in the name of deceased, yet the conclusion of assessment and framing the assessment in

11 ITA No.816 & 817/NAG/2026 (Dyneshwar Nagrao Nimbulkar through LH Prashant Nimbulkar) the name of deceased person vitiates the assessment order altogether and for that the plea that it was merely defect in the caption, is not sufficient and cannot be considered to be an irregularity which can be ignored or which the law otherwise allows to be condoned. The judicial precedents relied on behalf of the assessee, make it crystal clear that there is no statutory requirement imposing a legal obligation upon legal heirs to intimate the death of the assessee, yet in the case in hand, Assessing Officer was well informed of all the legal heirs so much so that Jurisdictional Assessing Officer had received the case record from National Faceless Assessment Centre only for the reason of impleading the legal heirs. 12. Thus, we are inclined to sustain the ground No. 1 before us. The appeal is allowed and the impugned assessment order is quashed.” 7. In the light of the above decisions and considering the fact that the assessee in the present case expired on 10.08.2011 which is much prior to the date of issuance of notice u/s. 148 of the Act and most importantly Ld. AO is very well aware about the death of the assessee, therefore even though this issue has been raised for the first time before this Tribunal, but since the facts are very much apparent on record, I admit this legal issue and considering the judicial precedents herein referred above, I find that re-assessment proceedings carried out in the case of deceased assessee are illegal, bad in law and deserves to be quashed. Accordingly, re-assessment order dated 29.12.2018 is hereby quashed and the impugned additions are deleted. Finding of Ld. CIT(A) is set aside and dealing with the remaining grounds on merits is merely academic in nature, and thus needs no adjudcation. Effective grounds of appeal raised by the assessee are allowed.

8.

So far as ITA No. 817/NAG/2026 is concerned, the same is against levy of penalty u/s. 271(1)(c) of the Act. Since I have quashed the re-assessment framed u/s. 143(3) r.w.s. 147 of the Act no addition survives for the impugned assessment year and

12 ITA No.816 & 817/NAG/2026 (Dyneshwar Nagrao Nimbulkar through LH Prashant Nimbulkar) since penalty is dependent upon the quantum addition, therefore impugned penalty has no legs to stand and is hereby deleted. Grounds of appeal raised by the assessee are allowed.

9.

In the result, both the appeals of the assessee are allowed.

Order pronounced on 16th November, 2026 under Rule 34(5) of the Income Tax (Appellate Tribunal) Rules, 1963.

Sd/- (MANISH BORAD) ACCOUNTANT MEMBER Pune & Dated : 16th Nov., 2026 vr/- Copy of the Order forwarded to: 1. Assessee 2. Revenue 3. PCIT concerned. 4. DR, ITAT, “SMC” Bench, Nagpur. 5. Guard File

BY ORDER Vukkem Digitally signed by Vukkem Rambabu //True Copy// Rambabu Date: 2026.11.17 10:38:34 +05'30' Senior Private Secretary ITAT, Pune (on tour)

More judgments on Section 154

All 9,427 judgments and leading authorities on Section 154 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →