SHRI CHANDRAPRABH CHARITABLE SANSTHA,JAIPUR vs. ITO(E), WARD-1, JAIPUR, JAIPUR
In favour of the assessee: the assessee's appeal was allowed. From the AI summary of this appeal.
What did the Tribunal hold?
The Tribunal held that the net income of the Assessee for both assessment years is chargeable to tax under section 164(2) of the Act at the rates applicable to an association of persons, with the benefit of basic exemption, and not at the Maximum Marginal Rate (MMR). The reasoning was based on three features of section 164(2): (i) it applies to income derived from property held under trust for charitable/religious purposes, irrespective of registration; (ii) the income is taxed 'as if' it were the income of an AOP, fixing the rate at AOP rates with slab structure and basic exemption; and (iii) MMR is specifically attracted only when exemption is lost due to section 13(1)(c) or 13(1)(d). The Tribunal found section 167B inapplicable as the Assessee has no members with shares in its income. Reliance was placed on CBDT Circular No. 320 and previous Tribunal decisions. The AO was directed to recompute tax accordingly. Ground 1 was allowed. Ground 3 (costs) was dismissed. Ground 2 was general.
What were the facts?
The Assessee, Shri Chandraprabh Charitable Sanstha, is an institution engaged in medical relief. For Assessment Years (AY) 2018-19 and 2019-20, it was not registered under section 12A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, leading to denial of exemption under section 11. The Income Tax Officer (AO) initially denied exemption. For AY 2019-20, the Tribunal directed tax on the net income after considering surplus and deficit. The AO then charged tax at the Maximum Marginal Rate (MMR). The Assessee sought rectification under section 154, arguing tax should be at Association of Persons (AOP) rates under section 164(2). The AO rejected these applications. The CIT(A) directed expenditure allowance for AY 2018-19 and recomputation of tax on net surplus but upheld taxation at MMR, relying on section 167B and a Delhi Tribunal decision.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the surplus income of the Assessee, a charitable institution not registered under section 12A, is taxable at the Maximum Marginal Rate (MMR) under section 167B of the Act, or at the rates applicable to an Association of Persons (AOP) under section 164(2) of the Act. Assessee's Contention: The Assessee argued that since no member or trustee has a share in its income, section 164(2) is the specific provision for taxing income of a charitable trust not exempt under sections 11 and 12. It contended that MMR is only attracted under the proviso to section 164(2) if exemption is lost due to section 13(1)(c) or 13(1)(d), which is not the case here. Reliance was placed on Dr. Shalmali Khasbardar Foundation v. ITO (Exemption). Revenue's Contention: The Revenue relied on the orders of the authorities below, implying that the net surplus income should be taxed at MMR.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 167B,Section 164(2),Section 11,Section 12,Section 154,Section 250,Section 13(1)(c),Section 13(1)(d),Section 164(1),Section 167A,Section 254(2B)
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, ‘A’ BENCH, JAIPUR
Before: Shri Kuldip Singh & Shri Prakash
IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL ‘A’ BENCH, JAIPUR (PHYSICAL HEARING) Before: Shri Kuldip Singh, Judicial Member And Shri Prakash, Accountant Member
ITA Nos: 632 & 633/JPR/2026 Assessment Years: 2018-19 & 2019-20
Shri Chandraprabh ITO (E), Charitable Sanstha, Shree Ward-01, Jaipur (Respondent) Digamber Jain Mandir Vs Campus, Durgapura, Jaipur PAN: AAGTS7441B (Appellant) Assessee Represented: Sh. P. C. Parwal, CA Revenue Represented: Sh. Abhimanyu Singh Yadav, CIT Date of hearing : 07-10-2026 Date of pronouncement : 03-11-2026 ORDER
PER : PRAKASH, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER:-
These two appeals by the Assessee are directed against the separate orders of the learned Additional/Joint Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) 2, Bengaluru [hereinafter referred to as "the learned CIT(A)"], both dated 02.01.2026, passed under section 250 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as "the Act"), arising out of the orders passed by the Income Tax Officer, Exemption Ward 1, Jaipur (hereinafter referred to as "the AO") under section 154 of the Act dated 19.02.2025 for the assessment year 2018-19 (ITA No. 632/JPR/2026) and dated 13.08.2024 for the assessment year 2019-20 (ITA No. 633/JPR/2026). The issue in
ITA Nos. 632 & 633/JPR/2026 Shri Chandraprabh Charitable Sanstha both the appeals is the same and they are disposed of by this consolidated order, with ITA No. 632/JPR/2026 taken as the lead case.
The grounds of appeal raised by the Assessee before us in the memorandum of appeal in Form No. 36 in ITA No. 632/JPR/2026 read as under:
"1. The Ld. CIT(A) has erred on facts and in law in holding that surplus is to be taxed at MMR u/s 167B of the Act by not appreciating that income derived from property held under trust wholly for charitable OR religious purposes is chargeable to tax as income of AOP u/s 164(2) of the Act and not at MMR. 2. The appellant craves to alter, amend and modify any ground of appeal. 3. Necessary cost be awarded to the assessee." The grounds raised in ITA No. 633/JPR/2026 are identically worded.
Briefly stated, the facts are that the Assessee is a charitable institution engaged in medical relief and allied activities. It was not registered under section 12A of the Act in either of the two years, and the exemption claimed by it under section 11 of the Act was denied, under section 143(1) of the Act for the assessment year 2018-19 and under section 143(3) of the Act for the assessment year 2019-20. For the assessment year 2019-20, this Tribunal, in Shri Chandraprabh Charitable Sanstha v. ITO (ITA Nos. 363 & 364/JP/2023, order dated 18.08.2023), held that only the net income of Rs 1,86,658, after netting the surplus and deficit of the three activities of the Assessee, could be brought to tax. While giving effect to that order, the AO charged tax on that income at the maximum marginal rate. The Assessee sought rectification under section 154 of the Act in both the years, contending that the tax should be computed at the rates applicable to an association of persons under section 164(2) of the Act, and for the assessment year 2018-19 additionally that the tax had been
ITA Nos. 632 & 633/JPR/2026 Shri Chandraprabh Charitable Sanstha computed on the gross receipts of Rs 7,88,172 without allowing the expenditure. The AO rejected both the applications.
The learned CIT(A), following the order of this Tribunal for the assessment year 2019-20, directed the AO to allow the expenditure for the assessment year 2018-19 and to recompute the tax on the net surplus of Rs 1,53,756. That direction is not in challenge before us. On the rate of tax, however, the learned CIT(A) held in both the years that the Assessee is an association of persons governed by sections 160 to 167 of the Act, reproduced section 167B of the Act, observed that "it is presumed that the Appellant falls within the purview of section 167B of the Act and is subject to tax at MMR without basic exemption", and for the assessment year 2019-20 also relied on Air Force Navy Farm Owners Welfare Association v. ITO [2020] 183 ITD 611 (Delhi Trib.).
The position in the two years is summarised below:
A.Y. Returned Income first Net income Tax effect income computed 2018-19 Nil Rs 7,88,172 Rs 1,53,756 Rs 47,511 2019-20 Rs 24,670 Rs 7,63,433 Rs 1,86,658 Rs 58,237
Before us, the learned Authorised Representative (hereinafter referred to as "the learned AR") reiterated the grounds of appeal and the submissions made before the learned CIT(A). It was submitted that none of the members or trustees of the Assessee has any share in its income, that section 164(2) of the Act is the specific provision for the income of a charitable trust which is not exempt under sections 11 and 12 of the Act, and that the maximum marginal rate is attracted under the proviso to that sub-section only where the exemption is lost by reason of section 13(1)(c) or section 13(1)(d) of the Act, which is not the case here. Reliance was placed on Dr. Shalmali Khasbardar Foundation v. ITO 3
ITA Nos. 632 & 633/JPR/2026 Shri Chandraprabh Charitable Sanstha (Exemption) (ITA No. 3811/Mum/2024, order dated 30.09.2024). The learned Departmental Representative (hereinafter referred to as "the learned DR") relied on the orders of the authorities below.
We have heard the rival contentions and perused the material on record. The controversy is narrow. It is not in dispute that the exemption under sections 11 and 12 of the Act is not available to the Assessee and that the income liable to tax is the net surplus. The only question is whether that income is to be taxed at the maximum marginal rate under section 167B of the Act or at the rates ordinarily applicable to an association of persons under section 164(2) of the Act. Section 164(1) of the Act, which charges tax at the maximum marginal rate where the beneficiaries or their shares are indeterminate, opens with the words "Subject to the provisions of sub- sections (2) and (3)". Section 164(2) of the Act reads as under:
"(2) In the case of relevant income which is derived from property held under trust wholly for charitable or religious purposes, or which is of the nature referred to in sub-clause (iia) of clause (24) of section 2, or which is of the nature referred to in sub-section (4A) of section 11, tax shall be charged on so much of the relevant income as is not exempt under section 11 or section 12, as if the relevant income not so exempt were the income of an association of persons: Provided that in a case where the whole or any part of the relevant income is not exempt under section 11 or section 12 by virtue of the provisions contained in clause (c) or clause (d) of sub-section (1) of section 13, tax shall be charged on the relevant income or part of relevant income at the maximum marginal rate." 8. Three features of this provision decide the matter.
First, it applies to income "derived from property held under trust wholly for charitable or religious purposes". The test is the character of the property and the purpose, not the registration of the trust. Registration under section 12A of the Act is a condition for the exemption under section 11 of the Act, and section 164(2) of the Act
ITA Nos. 632 & 633/JPR/2026 Shri Chandraprabh Charitable Sanstha is enacted precisely for the income of such a trust which "is not exempt under section 11 or section 12". A trust whose exemption fails for want of registration falls squarely within those words.
Secondly, the income is to be taxed "as if" it were the income of an association of persons. This fiction fixes the rate, which is the rate prescribed for an association of persons in the Finance Act of the relevant year, with the slab structure and the basic exemption that go with it.
Thirdly, Parliament has itself specified when the maximum marginal rate is to apply to such income: only where the exemption is lost by virtue of section 13(1)(c) or section 13(1)(d) of the Act.
Having stated the exception expressly, Parliament cannot be taken to have intended the general provision in section 167B of the Act to impose the maximum marginal rate in every other case, for that would make the proviso to section 164(2) of the Act meaningless. A specific provision prevails over a general one.
Section 167B of the Act does not lead elsewhere. It presupposes an association or body which has "members" and in which those members have "shares" in the income, whether determinate or indeterminate, and sub-section (2) turns on the total income of those members. A charitable institution has no members entitled to a share in its income; its income belongs to its objects and not to the persons who manage it. That is why section 164(2) of the Act taxes the income "as if" it were the income of an association of persons instead of treating the trust as one. The learned CIT(A) has recorded no finding that the Assessee has members with shares in its income or that any member has income above the exemption limit. The order rests on a presumption, and a charge of tax at the highest rate
ITA Nos. 632 & 633/JPR/2026 Shri Chandraprabh Charitable Sanstha cannot rest on a presumption. The Central Board of Direct Taxes took the same view when the predecessor provision, section 167A of the Act, was introduced. Circular No. 320 dated 11.01.1982 states in paragraph 2:
"Similarly, in the cases of registered societies, trade and professional associations, social and sports clubs, charitable or religious trusts, etc., where the members or trustees are not entitled to any share in the income of the association of persons, the provisions of new section 167A will not be attracted and, accordingly, tax will be payable in such cases at the rate ordinarily applicable to the total income of an association of persons and not at the maximum marginal rate." 10. The co-ordinate Benches of this Tribunal have consistently taken this view, in Dr. Shalmali Khasbardar Foundation (supra) and in National Association of Interlocking Surgeons v. ITO (Exemption) [2025] 172 taxmann.com 9 (Pune Trib.), the latter in an appeal arising, as here, from the rejection of an application under section 154 of the Act.
Air Force Navy Farm Owners Welfare Association (supra), relied upon by the learned CIT(A), does not assist the Revenue. The assessee there was an association of Air Force and Naval officers formed to manage the farmhouses allotted to them, which claimed mutuality. It was not a charitable trust, no question under section 164(2) of the Act arose, and section 167B(2) of the Act was applied because the assessee had not disputed that the income of its members exceeded the basic exemption limit. There is no such member and no such finding here.
We therefore hold that the net income of the Assessee for both the years is chargeable to tax under section 164(2) of the Act at the rates applicable to an association of persons under the Finance Act of the relevant year, with the benefit of the basic exemption, and not at the maximum marginal rate. The AO is directed to recompute the tax accordingly on Rs 1,53,756 for the assessment year 2018-19 and on Rs 1,86,658 for the assessment year 2019- 20 and to grant consequential relief. Ground no. 1 in both the appeals is 6
ITA Nos. 632 & 633/JPR/2026 Shri Chandraprabh Charitable Sanstha allowed. Ground no. 3 seeks costs; no circumstance warranting costs under section 254(2B) of the Act has been shown and the ground is dismissed. Ground no. 2 is general.
In the result, both the appeals filed by the Assessee are allowed.
Order pronounced in the open court on 03.11.2026
Sd/- Sd/- (KULDIP SINGH) (PRAKASH) JUDICIAL MEMBER ACCOUNTANT MEMBER Dated 03/11/2026 *Ganesh Kr., Sr. PS Copy of Order Forwarded to:- 1. Assessee 2. Revenue 3. Concerned CIT 4. CIT (A) 5. DR, ITAT 6. Guard file. By order, Digitally signed by Ganesh Kumar Date: 2026.11.04 11:34:24 '+05'30 Assistant Registrar/Sr. Private Secretary, Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Jaipur
More judgments on Section 167B
- Shri Chandraprabh Charitable Sanstha, Jaipur vs ITO(E), Ward-1, JaipurITA 633/JPR/2026[2019-20]Status: Disposed3 Nov 2026AY 2019-20
- Estate of Pappu Nandlal Tolani, Mumbai vs ITO 19(1)(1), MumbaiITA 1688/MUM/2026[2024-25]Status: Disposed29 Oct 2026AY 2024-25
- Samaj Sahyogi Sanstha, Jaipur vs Income Tax Officer, JaipurITA 126/JPR/2026[2024-2025]Status: Disposed6 Oct 2026AY 2024-2025
- The Windsor Flat Owners Welfare… vs ITO, Ward-11(1), HyderabadITA 1385/HYD/2026[2023-24]Status: Disposed30 Sept 2026AY 2023-24
- Golden Sports and Recreation Club, Madurai vs ITO, Ncw-1(7), MaduraiITA 2022/CHNY/2026[2023-24]Status: Disposed28 Sept 2026AY 2023-24
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- M/S Sun Shine Metal Works vs. State Of U.P And AnotherAllahabad · 4 Nov 2026
- M/S Bansal Sanitary Store vs. State Of U.P. And 2 OthersAllahabad · 4 Nov 2026
- M/S Princess Girls Collection vs. State Of U.P. And AnotherAllahabad · 4 Nov 2026
- Prabhat Kumar vs. The State Of BiharPatna · 4 Nov 2026
- Siddharth Barai (Prop- Siddharth Design Studio) vs. The Superintendent CGST And Central Excise, Balangir RangeOrissa · 4 Nov 2026