ESTATE OF PAPPU NANDLAL TOLANI,MUMBAI vs. ITO 19(1)(1), MUMBAI

PDF · subscribers
ITA 1688/MUM/2026Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai29 October 2026AY 2024-2510 pages

In favour of the assessee: the assessee's appeal was allowed. From the AI summary of this appeal.

AI SummaryAllowed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal held that the income of the estate of Late Mrs. Pappu Nandlal Tolani is chargeable to tax at the normal individual slab rates applicable for AY 2024-25, and Section 167B is not applicable. The reasoning was that Section 168 specifically governs the taxation of estates of deceased persons. While Section 168(1)(b) mandates assessment as an AOP when there are multiple executors, this is a legal fiction for procedural assessment and does not imply that the executors form a voluntary AOP for income generation with indeterminate shares, which is the prerequisite for Section 167B. The Tribunal noted that executors act in a fiduciary capacity. The CPC's computation based on the AOP status and indeterminate shares in the return was not conclusive for applying Section 167B. Reliance was placed on coordinate bench decisions in Estate of Late Nalini Atul Bhagwati and Estate of Late Harkishin Bhojraj Chanrai, which held that tax rates for estates of deceased persons do not change regardless of whether assessed as an individual or AOP under Section 168. The Tribunal also noted consistent treatment in the case of the deceased's husband. The order of the Ld. CIT(A) was set aside, and the Assessing Officer/CPC was directed to recompute the tax liability using normal individual slab rates. Ground Nos. 1 to 6 were allowed. Ground No. 7 regarding surcharge was allowed for statistical purposes, directing recomputation as per individual rates.

What were the facts?

The assessee is the Estate of Pappu Nandlal Tolani, and the revenue is the Income Tax Department. The assessment year is 2024-25. The appeal is against the order of the Ld. CIT(A)/ADDL. JCIT (APPEAL) FARIDABAD, dated 20-Jan-2026. The deceased, Mrs. Pappu Nandlal Tolani, executed a Will appointing two executors and passed away on 10.11.2021. The estate obtained a PAN and was registered under the status of an association of persons (AOP) as per Section 168(1)(b) due to multiple executors. The return was filed in Form No. 5 under the sub-category 'Estate of Deceased' within the 'artificial juridical person' category. The CPC processed the return under Section 143(1), accepting the returned income but computing tax liability at the Maximum Marginal Rate (MMR) of 35.88% instead of individual slab rates.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the income of the estate of a deceased person administered by more than one executor is taxable at the Maximum Marginal Rate (MMR) under Section 167B, or at the normal individual slab rates as per Section 168 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. (Question of law) Assessee's contentions: The assessment of a deceased person's estate is exclusively governed by Section 168. Section 167B is an anti-avoidance provision for discretionary AOPs/BOIs and not applicable to estates of deceased persons assessed under Section 168. The AOP status was assigned due to multiple executors, not voluntary association for income generation. The tax rates should be individual slab rates, not MMR. Reliance was placed on Section 168(1)(a) and decisions in Estate of Late Nalini Atul Bhagwati v. ADIT, CPC and Estate of Late Harkishin Bhojraj Chanrai v. DCIT, and appellate orders for the deceased's husband. Revenue's contentions: The assessee was assessed under AOP/AJP status with indeterminate shares, justifying the invocation of Section 167B and the levy of tax at MMR, as upheld by the Ld. CIT(A).

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 168,Section 167B,Section 143(1)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, MUMBAI BENCHES, MUMBAI

Before: SHRI SANDEEP GOSAIN & SHRI BIJAYANANDA PRUSETH

Pronounced: 29.10.2026

PER SHRI SANDEEP GOSAIN, JUDICIAL MEMBER:

This appeal is filed by the Assessee against the order of Ld. CIT(A)/ADDL. JCIT (APPEAL) FARIDABAD vide DIN: ITBA/APL/S/250/2025- 26/1084969348(1) dated 20-Jan-2026 for the Assessment Year 2024-25. The Assessee has raised the following grounds of appeal:

1) The Learned CIT(A) has erred in law and on facts in upholding the application of section 167B and Maximum Marginal Rate to the income of the Estate of a deceased person, ignoring the specific and overriding provisions of section 168, which exclusively govern assessment and rate of tax of such Estates 2) That the learned CIT(A) has failed to appreciate that section 167B is an anti avoidance provision applicable to discretionary AOPs BOIs, and has no application to an Estate of a deceased person assessed under a special statutory regime. 3) The Learned CIT(A) as well as CPC have erred in not considering that the status of A.O.P is allotted to the Assessee as the number of Executors to the Will is more than one and the formation of the Estate is not on account of the regular association of two OR more persons for a common purpose OR common action, nor is the object to produce income, profits OR gains. 4) The Learned CIT(A) as well CPC have erred in not considering that the Assessee came into existence on account of a Will executed by the deceased, Mrs. Pappu Nandlal Tolani and therefore the tax rates applicable on the assets of the Assessee will be the Individual tax slab rates instead of the maximum marginal rate of 30 per cent. 5) The Learned CIT(A) as well CPC have erred in not considering that as per section 168(1)(a), had there been only one executor, the assessment would have been as if the executor were an Individual and, it is only for statistical purposes that the executors of the estate of the deceased are assessed as AOP otherwise, for the purpose of tax rates, etc., the assessment has to be deemed to be on the assessee OR the actual beneficiaries and the applicable tax rate would be as for an Individual. 6) The Learned CIT(A) has erred in placing reliance on the procedural filing of return in Form 5 under the status AJP, has incorrectly considered name of the Executors mentioned in the ITR Form as members of AOP, and arrived at the conclusion that the share of members of the AOP was indeterminate shares, to determine the rate of tax, instead of applying the substantive charging provisions of the Act. 7) The Learned CIT(A) has erred in disposing Ground No. 7 pertaining to levy of higher Surcharge of 22.63 per cent as consequential in nature without considering the facts and submissions of the Assessee. 8) The Appellant craves leave to add and OR alter the above grounds of appeal.

2.

The relevant facts are that Mrs. Pappu Nandlal Tolani was an individual assessee who regularly filed her income-tax returns under PAN ABSPT9010A. During her lifetime, on 22.08.2019, she executed a Will appointing two executors to administer her estate. She passed away on 10.11.2021. Following her demise, the executors applied for and obtained a Permanent Account Number (PAN AACAE1176E) in the name of the “Estate of Pappu Nandlal Tolani”, and the estate was registered under the status of an association of persons (AOP), having regard to Section 168(1)(b) of the Act, which provides for assessment as if the executors were an AOP where there is more than one executor.

3.

For the assessment year under consideration, the return of income was filed in Form No. 5. Owing to the structure of the electronic return utility, the sub- category “Estate of Deceased” was available under the broader category of artificial juridical person (AJP), rather than under AOP, and the status was selected accordingly. In Schedule/Column (E) of the return, which requires particulars of partners, members, trustees or executors, the details of the two executors administering the estate were furnished.

4.

The return of income was processed by the CPC, Bengaluru, vide intimation dated 19.12.2025 under Section 143(1) of the Act. Although the returned income was accepted without any substantive addition, the tax liability was computed by applying the Maximum Marginal Rate (MMR) of 35.88%, inclusive of surcharge and cess, instead of the normal individual slab rates.

5.

Aggrieved by the intimation, the assessee preferred an appeal before the Ld. CIT(A). The Ld. CIT(A) dismissed the appeal vide order dated 20.01.2026, holding that, since the return had been filed under the status of AJP in Form No. 5 and Column (E) reflected indeterminate shares of the members of the AOP, the provisions of Section 167B were attracted and the levy of tax at the Maximum Marginal Rate was justified.

6.

Aggrieved by the order of the Ld. CIT(A), the assessee is in appeal before us.

7.

The Ld. AR for the assessee submitted that the assessment of the estate of a deceased person is governed by the specific provisions of Section 168 of the Act. Section 168(1)(b) provides for assessment as if the executors were an AOP solely on account of there being more than one executor. He submitted that the executors do not constitute an AOP formed through voluntary consensus or a common design to produce income, but are fiduciaries discharging their duties under the Will. The Ld. AR further submitted that Section 167B is an anti- avoidance provision applicable to AOPs and BOIs in cases where the individual shares of the members are indeterminate or unknown, and that it has no application to an estate assessed under Section 168.

8.

The Ld. AR also contended that the selection of the status in Form No. 5 was necessitated by the structure of the electronic return utility and that the substantive tax liability could not be determined solely on the basis of a procedural classification in the return. Reliance was placed on the decisions of the coordinate Benches of this Tribunal in Estate of Late Nalini Atul Bhagwati v. ADIT, CPC (ITA No. 2177/Mum/2024, dated 16.01.2025) and Estate of Late Harkishin Bhojraj Chanrai v. DCIT (ITA No. 2324/Mum/2021, dated 29.06.2022). Reliance was also placed on the appellate orders passed in the case of the deceased’s husband, Estate of Nandlal Pribhdas Tolani, for A.Ys. 2020–21 and 2023–24, dated 14.08.2024 and 07.11.2024, respectively.

9.

The Ld. DR, on the other hand, relied on the orders of the lower authorities and submitted that, since the assessee had been assessed under the status of AOP/AJP and the shares of the members were shown as indeterminate in the return, the CPC had rightly invoked Section 167B and the Ld. CIT(A) had correctly upheld the levy of tax at the Maximum Marginal Rate.

10.

We have heard the rival submissions, perused the material available on record and considered the judicial precedents cited before us. The principal issue arising for our consideration is whether the income of the estate of Late Mrs. Pappu Nandlal Tolani, administered by two executors, is taxable at the normal individual slab rates or at the Maximum Marginal Rate under Section 167B of the Act.

11.

For the purpose of adjudicating the issue, it would be appropriate to refer to Section 168 of the Act, which reads as under:

“Executors.

168.

(1) Subject as hereinafter provided, the income of the estate of a deceased person shall be chargeable to tax in the hands of the executor,—

(a) if there is only one executor, then, as if the executor were an individual; or

(b) if there are more executors than one, then, as if the executors were an association of persons;

(2) The assessment of an executor under this section shall be made separately from any assessment that may be made on him in respect of his own income.

(3) Separate assessments shall be made under this section on the total income of each completed previous year or part of a previous year included in the period from the date of the death of the deceased to the date of complete distribution to the beneficiaries of the estate according to their several interests.

(4) In computing the total income of any previous year under this section, any income of the estate of that previous year distributed to, or applied to the benefit of, any specific legatee of the estate during that previous year shall be excluded; but the income so excluded shall be included in the total income of the previous year of such specific legatee.

Explanation.—In this section, ‘executor’ includes an administrator or other person administering the estate of a deceased person.”

12.

A plain reading of Section 168(1) shows that the Act specifically provides for the taxation of the income of the estate of a deceased person in the hands of the executor. Under clause (a), where there is only one executor, the income is chargeable to tax as if the executor were an individual. Under clause (b), where there is more than one executor, the income is chargeable to tax as if the executors were an AOP.

13.

The legal fiction created under Section 168(1)(b) must be understood in the context of the statutory scheme governing the administration and taxation of a deceased person’s estate. The executors are appointed under the Will to administer the estate, collect its assets, discharge the liabilities of the deceased and distribute the estate to the beneficiaries in accordance with the testamentary directions. They do not, merely by virtue of their appointment as executors, acquire beneficial interests in the income of the estate.

14.

An AOP, in its ordinary legal sense, involves the coming together of two or more persons for a common purpose or common action, with the object of producing income, profits or gains. The executors in the present case are not stated to have voluntarily associated for carrying on an income-producing activity. Their role arises from the Will and is fiduciary in nature. The fact that the Act requires the income of the estate to be assessed as if the executors were an AOP does not, by itself, establish that the executors are members of a discretionary AOP whose individual shares in the income are indeterminate or unknown.

15.

Section 167B provides for the application of the Maximum Marginal Rate in specified cases involving an AOP or BOI where the individual shares of the members are indeterminate or unknown, subject to the conditions and exceptions contained in that provision. The applicability of Section 167B must, therefore, be determined by reference to its statutory requirements and the nature of the entity being assessed. In the present case, the income under consideration is that of an estate governed by Section 168, and the executors are administering the estate in their fiduciary capacity.

16.

The Ld. CIT(A) appears to have treated the particulars of the executors furnished in Column (E) of Form No. 5 as establishing that they were members of an AOP having indeterminate shares. However, the disclosure of the executors’ particulars in the return is consistent with the requirements of the electronic return utility and the nature of the assessee as an estate of a deceased person. Such disclosure, by itself, cannot be conclusive of the applicability of Section 167B. The tax liability must be determined in accordance with the substantive provisions of the Act and not solely by reference to the manner in which the relevant particulars are captured in the return.

17.

We also find merit in the contention that the provisions of Section 168 must be interpreted in a manner consistent with the legislative scheme governing the taxation of estates. The distinction between clauses (a) and (b) of Section 168(1) is based on the number of executors appointed to administer the estate. The legal fiction under clause (b) cannot, without examining the requirements of Section 167B, automatically lead to the conclusion that the income of every estate administered by more than one executor must be taxed at the Maximum Marginal Rate. The number of executors, by itself, does not establish that the conditions prescribed under Section 167B are satisfied.

18.

The issue is also covered by the decisions relied upon by the Ld. AR. In Estate of Late Nalini Atul Bhagwati v. ADIT, CPC (ITA No. 2177/Mum/2024, dated 16.01.2025), the coordinate Bench of this Tribunal observed as follows:

“When the status is taken either as ‘individual’ or ‘AOP’ as per sec. 168(1) of the Act, we are of the view that the tax rate applicable on the income of ‘estate of deceased person’ cannot change in both the situation.”

19.

Similarly, in Estate of Late Harkishin Bhojraj Chanrai v. DCIT (ITA No. 2324/Mum/2021, dated 29.06.2022), the coordinate Bench directed the Assessing Officer to compute the tax on the income of the estate at the normal individual slab rates instead of applying the Maximum Marginal Rate.

20.

It is also relevant that, in the case of the deceased’s husband, Estate of Nandlal Pribhdas Tolani, the Ld. CIT(A), vide orders dated 14.08.2024 and 07.11.2024 for A.Ys. 2020–21 and 2023–24, respectively, accepted the position that the income of the estate was to be taxed at the normal individual slab rates. While each assessment year is a separate unit of assessment, the treatment adopted in the assessee’s own circumstances, together with the decisions of the coordinate Benches cited above, supports the assessee’s contention.

21.

In view of the specific statutory scheme under Section 168 and the judicial precedents discussed above, we hold that the income of the assessee’s estate is chargeable to tax at the normal individual slab rates applicable for A.Y. 2024–25 and that the Maximum Marginal Rate under Section 167B is not applicable on the facts of the present case.

22.

Accordingly, the order of the Ld. CIT(A) is set aside on this issue. The Assessing Officer/CPC is directed to recompute the tax liability by applying the normal individual slab rates applicable for A.Y. 2024–25. Ground Nos. 1 to 6 are allowed.

23.

Ground No. 7 relates to the levy of surcharge at the rate of 22.63%. Since the tax liability is required to be recomputed by applying the normal individual slab rates, the Assessing Officer/CPC is directed to recompute the surcharge, if any, in accordance with the provisions applicable to an individual for A.Y. 2024– 25. Ground No. 7 is allowed for statistical purposes.

24.

Ground No. 8 is general in nature and does not require separate adjudication.

25.

In the result, the appeal filed by the assessee stands allowed.

Order pronounced in the open court on 29.10.2026.

Sd/- Sd/- BIJAYANANDA PRUSETH SANDEEP GOSAIN ACCOUNTANT MEMBER JUDICIAL MEMBER Mumbai Dated: 29.10.2026 RY-SrPS Copy to: ESTATE OF PAPPU NANDLAL TOLANI, 1100, PRABHU KUTIR, 15 ALTAMOUNT 1 ROAD, BREACH CANDY, MUMBAI-400026, MAHARASHTRA

ITO 19(1)(1), ROOM NO.501, 5TH FLOOR, PIRAMAL 2 CHAMBERS, PAREL, MUMBAI, MUMBAI-400012, MAHARASHTRA

3 THE PCIT / CIT, 4 THE D.R., ITAT, MUMBAI BENCH 5 GUARD FILE

More judgments on Section 168

All 59 judgments and leading authorities on Section 168 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →