RAJESH KUMAR AGARWAL vs. INCOME TAX OFFICER HALDWANI UTTARAKHAND
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court held that for the transfer of an immovable property to an AOP to be effective for income tax purposes, it must comply with the provisions of the Transfer of Property Act and the Registration Act, which require a registered instrument. The court noted that Section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act provides for transfer taking effect when there is an agreement to transfer, part performance, and possession by the transferee. In this case, there was no conveyance by the appellant in favour of the AOP, nor was there any agreement coupled with the AOP's contention of possession in pursuance of such an agreement. Therefore, the court found no just reason for the CIT(Appeals) to interfere with the AO's order. The court also observed that the Tribunal did not consider the requirements of transfer under general law and income tax law. However, since the revenue had not filed an independent appeal, the High Court refused to interfere with the order of the Tribunal. The appeal filed by the appellant was dismissed.
What were the facts?
For the assessment year 2008-2009, the appellant, Rajesh Kumar Agarwal, was selected for scrutiny. The Assessing Officer (AO) confronted the appellant with a report from the annual information wing indicating the sale of an immovable property for ₹39 lacs. The appellant claimed he transferred agricultural land to an Association of Persons (AOP) formed with other landowners, which then sold the land after conversion to industrial use. He argued this transfer to the AOP did not attract capital gains. The AO rejected this, finding no evidence of transfer to the AOP and noting the land was converted to industrial use before the AOP was constituted, with the industrial land subsequently sold. The AO taxed the entire capital gains on the appellant. The CIT(Appeals) found the AOP was formed on June 16, 2007, and the land was sold by the AOP on February 12, 2008. The CIT(Appeals) held that taxing the full capital gains on the appellant was incorrect as he was only a constituent of the AOP. The CIT(Appeals) directed the AO to initiate proceedings under Section 150 read with Section 147/148 against individual members for short-term capital gains on transfer to the AOP, using the circle rate on June 16, 2007, as the transfer price. The CIT(Appeals) also directed assessment of capital gains in the hands of the AOP upon its sale to the ultimate purchaser. The Tribunal refused to interfere with this order. The High Court heard an appeal by the appellant.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the transfer of agricultural land by the appellant to an AOP attracted capital gains tax in the hands of the appellant, considering the provisions of Section 2(47) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. Assessee's Contention: The appellant contended that the transfer of agricultural land to the AOP did not attract capital gains tax. He argued that the AOP was formed, and the land was transferred to it, after which the AOP applied for conversion and subsequently sold the industrial land. The capital gains should arise in the hands of the AOP upon its sale to the ultimate purchaser. Revenue's Contention: The revenue, through the AO, contended that there was no evidence to suggest the transfer of agricultural land by the appellant to the AOP. The AO found that the land was converted from agricultural to industrial before the AOP's constitution, and the industrial land was sold thereafter, thus fastening the entire capital gains tax on the appellant. 2. Whether the CIT(Appeals) was justified in directing the AO to initiate proceedings under Section 150 read with Section 147/148 against individual members of the AOP for assessing short-term capital gains on the transfer of capital asset to the AOP on June 16, 2007, and also assessing capital gains in the hands of the AOP upon its sale to the ultimate purchaser.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 143(2),Section 2(47),Section 150,Section 147,Section 148
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
IN THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Income Tax Appeal No. 04 of 2013
Rajesh Kumar Agarwal
………….. Appellant
Versus
Income Tax Officer-3, Income Tax Office, Haldwani, District Nainital, Uttarakhand.
.…………. Respondent
Present: Mr. Sudhanshu Srivastava and Mr. Chetan Joshi, Advocates for
the appellant.
Mr. Hari Mohan Bhatia, Advocate for the respondent.
JUDGMENT
Coram: Hon’ble Barin Ghosh, C.J.
Hon’ble Servesh Kumar Gupta, J.
BARIN GHOSH, C.J. (Oral)
For the assessment year 2008-2009, appellant was selected for scrutiny assessment and, accordingly, a notice under Section 143(2) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’) was issued to him. In course of scrutiny assessment, assessee was confronted with the report submitted by the annual information wing, which held out that the assessee has sold an immovable property at a consideration of `39 lacs. Appellant contended that he had an agricultural land which land and land situate in the vicinity were declared as industrial estate. Appellant contended that he and other land owners having agricultural land within that declared industrial estate formed an AOP, transferred the agricultural land to AOP, whereupon AOP applied for conversion of land use and the same having been granted, the industrial land was ultimately sold by AOP. It was contended that transfer by him of a piece of agricultural land to AOP does not attract any capital gain. Steps taken to sell the industrial land will attract capital gains in the hands of the AOP. This contention was not accepted by the Assessing Officer,
inasmuch as, there was no evidence to suggest transfer of any agricultural land by the appellant to AOP. It was found as a fact that before constitution of AOP, the land was converted from agricultural to industrial, and thereafter, in fact, the industrial land was sold. The entire capital gains tax was fastened upon the appellant. Appellant approached the learned CIT (Appeals). The CIT (Appeals) found that AOP came in to existence on 16th June, 2007 and the land in question was sold by AOP on 12th February, 2008. It, accordingly, held that assessing full amount of capital gains in the hands of appellant is not correct since he is only one constituent of AOP. CIT (Appeals) held that when the land vested in the AOP on 16th June, 2007 the land had already been converted from agricultural to industrial. The CIT (Appeals) held that in terms of Section 2 (47) of the Act, the land in question stood transferred on 16th June, 2007 from individual owners to AOP. The CIT (Appeals) directed the Assessing Officer to initiate proceedings under Section 150 read with Section 147/148 of the Act on each individual member/constituent of AOP for assessing the short term capital gains on each one of them on account of transfer of capital asset to AOP on 16th June, 2007. For that purpose, Assessing Officer was directed to consider the price of transfer to AOP on the basis of the circle rate prevailing on 16th June, 2007. The CIT (Appeals) then directed assessment of capital gains in the hands of AOP also when it sold ultimately the land in question to the ultimate purchaser on 12th December, 2008. Aggrieved thereby, appellant approached the Tribunal, but the Tribunal refused to interfere.
No doubt that for the purpose of income tax, a capital asset may be transferred to an AOP as is provided in Section 2 (47) of the Act. However, when the capital asset is an immovable property by reason of the provisions contained in the Transfer of Property Act read with the Registration Act, transfer of an
immovable property of the nature dealt with herein requires an instrument which is also required to be registered. In accordance with the provisions of the Income Tax Act read with the various instructions/clarifications/directions issued by CBDT from time to time, transfer will take effect in a situation as provided in Section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act, namely, when there is an agreement to transfer and, in part performance thereof, the transferee is in possession of the immovable property agreed to be transferred. In the instant case, there is no conveyance by the appellant in favour of AOP, nor there is any agreement between the appellant and the AOP coupled with the contention by the AOP that in pursuance with that agreement and in part performance thereof it is in possession of the property in question. We are, therefore, of the view that there was no just reason by the CIT (Appeals) to interfere with the order of the Assessing Officer and we are also of the view that the Tribunal did not take notice of what may be treated as a transfer from one to the other in terms of the general law as well as in terms of the laws applicable to income tax. However, there being no independent appeal by the revenue, we refuse to interfere.
The appeal fails and then same is dismissed.
(Servesh Kumar Gupta, J.) (Barin Ghosh, C.J.)
25.06.2013 25.06.2013
P. Singh
More judgments on Section 2(47)
- Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax… vs Mukesh Sharma, Gautam Buddha NagarITA 4645/DEL/2025[2020-21]Status: Disposed13 Nov 2026AY 2020-21
- Manju Yogesh Varma, Mulund (West) Mumbai vs Income Tax Officer Ward 41(2)(3), MumbaiITA 7735/MUM/2026[2020-21]Status: Disposed30 Oct 2026AY 2020-21
- Dharmagari Surender Reddy HUF, Hyderabad vs ACIT., Central Circle-3(2), HyderabadITA 1970/HYD/2025[2022-23]Status: Disposed30 Oct 2026AY 2022-23
- Dharmagari Surender Reddy HUF, Hyderabad vs ACIT., Central Circle-3(2), HyderabadITA 1969/HYD/2025[2021-22]Status: Disposed30 Oct 2026AY 2021-22
- Dharmagari Surender Reddy HUF, Hyderabad vs ACIT, Central Circle-3(2), HyderabadITA 1968/HYD/2025[2020-21]Status: Disposed30 Oct 2026AY 2020-21
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Anjanarani Jena vs. The Commissioner,CGST, Cx And CustomsOrissa · 10 Nov 2026
- M/S Alok Kumar Sethi, Bhubaneswar vs. Principal Commissioner, CGST And Central Excise, BhubaneswarOrissa · 10 Nov 2026
- Natuk Mra vs. The Union Of INDIA And 3 OrsGauhati · 10 Nov 2026
- Tatvam Procon Private Limited, Gujarat vs. Commissioner Of CT And GST, CuttackOrissa · 10 Nov 2026
- Swapna Acharya vs. Superintendent, GST And Central Excise, Bhubaneswar-1Orissa · 10 Nov 2026