DHARMAGARI SURENDER REDDY HUF,HYDERABAD vs. ACIT., CENTRAL CIRCLE-3(2), HYDERABAD

PDF · subscribers
ITA 1969/HYD/2025Status: DisposedITAT Hyderabad30 October 2026AY 2021-2249 pages

In favour of the assessee: the assessee's appeal was allowed. From the AI summary of this appeal.

AI SummaryAllowed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal admitted the additional grounds raised by the assessees, citing the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in CIT vs. NTPC [1998] 229 ITR 383 (SC), as they were purely legal and could be adjudicated based on existing records. On additional grounds 5 to 7, the Tribunal found that the AO reopened the assessment based on seized material which he had allegedly rejected during the assessment of the searched party (M/s. Vasavi Developers). The Tribunal also noted that the alleged cash received was in respect of a Joint Development Agreement (JDA), but it was proposed to be assessed as income from other sources, not capital gains. The Tribunal observed that the AO's approach of treating the amount as income from other sources when capital gains were not assessable was not permissible. Consequently, the Tribunal held that the notices issued under Section 148 of the Act were invalid and liable to be set aside. On merits, the Tribunal found that the AO had not assessed any other income except for the alleged cash receipts for the assessment years 2019-2020 to 2022-2023. In view of the findings on the invalidity of the notices and the merits of the case, the Tribunal held that the additions were not sustainable and liable to be deleted. The appeals were allowed.

What were the facts?

The appeals by three HUFs (Dharmagari Ravinder Reddy HUF, Dharmagari Narender Reddy HUF, and Dharmagari Surender Reddy HUF) are against CIT(A) orders for assessment years 2019-2020 to 2022-2023. The assessees are co-owners of land at Nanakramguda, Hyderabad, and entered into a Development Agreement-cum-General Power of Attorney with M/s. Vasavi Developers on September 1, 2018. Following a search in the premises of M/s. Vasavi Group on August 17, 2022, which revealed loose sheets and tally data indicating cash payments to the assessees, the Assessing Officer (AO) issued notices under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The AO made additions on account of alleged cash receipts treated as income from other sources, which were upheld by the CIT(A). The assessees filed additional grounds challenging the validity of the Section 148 notices and the reassessment orders.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the reopening of assessment under Section 147 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, was valid in the absence of new tangible material or incriminating evidence relating to the appellant (Section 147). 2. Whether the addition of Rs. 58,89,104/- was sustainable when there was no evidence of receipt, accrual, benefit, transfer, or consideration, and the addition was based solely on uncorroborated third-party statements and assumptions, without an opportunity for cross-examination (Section 68, Section 69). 3. Whether a taxable event occurred under Section 2(47) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, during the year, and if the impugned order was non-speaking and passed without proper consideration of submissions and evidence (Section 2(47)). 4. Whether the notice issued under Section 148 of the Act was invalid due to the AO considering seized material that he himself had rejected during the assessment of the searched party (M/s. Vasavi Developers) (Section 148). 5. Whether the approval granted by the Principal CIT under Section 151 of the Act for the issuance of the Section 148 notice was mechanical (Section 151). 6. Whether the AO erred in issuing the notice under Section 148 without following the due procedure under Section 148A of the Act (Section 148A). Assessee's Contentions: - The reopening under Section 147 was invalid due to lack of new tangible material. (Ground 1) - The addition was based on presumptions and uncorroborated third-party statements without cross-examination. (Ground 2) - No taxable event occurred, and the order was non-speaking. (Ground 3) - The Section 148 notice was invalid as the AO used seized material that he had rejected for the searched party. (Additional Ground 5 & 6) - The approval under Section 151 was mechanical. (Additional Ground 7) - The Section 148 notice was issued without following the procedure under Section 148A. (Additional Ground 8) - The assessment order under Section 147 was vitiated due to mechanical approval under Section 148B. (Additional Ground 9) - Relied on CIT vs. NTPC [1998] 229 ITR 383 (SC) for admitting additional grounds. Revenue's Contentions: - Opposed the admission of additional grounds as they were not raised before the AO or CIT(A).

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 147,Section 148,Section 148A,Section 151,Section 2(47),Section 68,Section 69,Section 56

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, HYDERABAD

Before: SHRI VIJAY PAL RAO & SHRI MANJUNATHA G.

Hearing: 17.09.2026Pronounced: 30.10.2026

PER VIJAY PAL RAO, VICE PRESIDENT:

These seven appeals by related assessees are directed against the separate Orders of the learned CIT(A) for the assessment years 2021-2022, 2022-2023 and 2022-2023 and 2019-2020 to 2022-2023 respectively.

2.

The assessee’s have raised common grounds of appeals arising from the identical facts. The grounds raised by the assessee in ITA.No.1947/Hyd./2025 are reproduced as under:

3 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 “Ground 1 Invalid Reopening and Lack of Incriminating Material

The learned CIT A erred in upholding the reassessment us 147 in the absence of any new tangible material or incriminating evidence relating to the appellant, rendering the reopening bad in law.

Ground 2 No Evidence of Income and Addition Based on Presumption

The learned CITA erred in confirming the addition of Rs.5889104 despite there being no evidence of receipt, accrual, benefit, transfer, or consideration the addition is based solely on uncorroborated third party statements and assumptions, without granting the appellant opportunity for cross examination.

Ground 3 No Taxable Event and Non-Speaking Order

The learned CITA failed to appreciate that no transfer u/s 247v occurred during the year and no taxable event arose; the impugned order is non-speaking and passed without proper consideration of submissions and evidence.

Ground 4 The appellant craves leave to add to, withdraw or modify the grounds of appeal at the time of hearing.

4 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 Prayer

It is respectfully prayed that the Hon'ble Tribunal may:  Delete the addition of Rs.58,89,104/- in full; and  Grant consequential relief and any other relief that the Hon'ble Tribunal deems fit.”

3.

The assessees are HUF managed by their Karthas Sri Dharmapuri Ravinder Reddy, Sri Dharmapuri Narender Reddy and Sri Dharmapuri Surender Reddy. The assessees are the co-owners of the land measuring ac.5.09 guntas in survey no.123, 124, 125, 136 and 137 situated at Nanakramguda (v), Serilingampally (M), KV Ranga Reddy District. The assessees entered into a Development Agreement -cum- General Power of Attorney dated 01.09.2018 with M/s. Vasavi Developers for development of the land into multistoried residential and commercial project. There was a search and seizure action conducted in the premises of M/s. Vasavi Group and its related concerns on 17.08.2022. During the course of search proceedings, certain loose sheets, rough notings and tally data were found and seized by the department showing the cash payment by the

5 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 developer to the assessees. Accordingly, the Assessing Officer issued notice u/sec.148 of the Income Tax Act [in short "the Act"], 1961 to the assessee on 12.10.2023 which was replied by the assessee by filing the return of income on 30.01.2024 declaring total income of Rs.NIL. The Assessing Officer completed the assessment for the assessment year 2021- 2022 in the case of Dharmapuri Ravinder Reddy whereby an addition of Rs.58,89,104/- was made on account of cash receipts as income from other sources. The assessee challenged the action of the Assessing Officer before the learned CIT(A) but could not succeed.

4.

Before the Tribunal, the assessee has also filed additional grounds challenging the validity of the notice issued by the Assessing Officer u/sec.148 of the Act dated 12.10.2023 and consequent re-assessment order. The additional grounds filed by the assessee read as under:

“5. The Ld.AO has erred in considering the seized material, which himself rejected the same seized material during course of assessment of searched party and utilised the same rejected seized material for the purpose of reopening

6 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 the case of the appellant u/s. 148 of the IT Act, which is bad in law.

6.

The Ld.AO has erred in considering the seized material, which himself rejected the same seized material in the course of assessment of searched party and utilised for the purpose of making the addition in the hands of the Appellant.

7.

The Approval granted by the PCIT Central u/s. 151 of the IT Act is mechanical for issuance of notice u/s.148.

8.

The Ld.AO has erred in issuing the notice w/s. 148 of the IT Act without following the due procedure u/s. 148A of the IT Act. 9. On the facts and circumstances of case, the assessment order passed u/s 147 is vitiated and has become unsustainable in law since the approval u/s 148B has been accorded by Addl. CIT/JCIT (Range Head) in a mechanical manner."

5.

The learned Authorised Representative of the Assessee has submitted that the additional grounds raised by the assessee is purely legal in nature and that there is no necessity of fresh investigation into facts for adjudicating the additional ground. He, therefore, pleaded that the additional grounds raised by the assessee may please be admitted for

7 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 hearing and adjudication. In support of his contention, he has relied upon the Judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of CIT vs. NTPC [1998] 229 ITR 383 (SC).

6.

On the other hand, the learned DR for the Revenue opposed for admission of the additional grounds raised by the assessee. He submitted that the assessee has not raised this ground either during the assessment proceedings or before the learned CIT(A).

7.

We have heard learned Authorised Representative of the Assessee as well as learned DR on the admission of additional grounds. It is pertinent to note that for adjudication of the above additional grounds, no fresh material or record or facts are required to be investigated, verified or considered, but the same can be adjudicated on the basis of the material and facts already on record. Accordingly, by following the Judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of National Thermal Power Co. Ltd., vs., CIT [1998] 229 ITR 383 (SC), we admit the additional

8 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 grounds raised by the assessee and take up the additional grounds for hearing and adjudication.

8.

In additional ground nos.5 to 7, the assessee has challenged the validity of the notice issued by the Assessing Officer u/sec.148 of the Act dated 12.10.2023 on the ground that the Assessing Officer has reopened the assessment based on the alleged seized material however, the same was rejected by the Assessing Officer in the case of the searched [M/s. Developers] person Vasavi while passing the assessment order u/sec.143(3) r.w.s.147 of the Act dated 17.07.2024. Further, the assessee has also challenged the validity of the approval granted u/sec.151 of the Act as mechanical in nature when the alleged cash received by the assessee is in respect of the Joint Development Agreement [in short “JDA”] entered into between the assessee and the developer but the same was proposed to be assessed as income from other sources as there was no capital gain assessed or proposed to be assessed by the Assessing Officer for the year under consideration. The learned Authorised Representative of the Assessee has submitted that the

9 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 Assessing Officer in the case of Vasavi Developers vide assessment order dated 17.07.2024 has rejected the alleged seized material as incomplete and incorrect accounts and employed a wrong accounting method. The learned Authorised Representative of the Assessee has pointed out that the Assessing Officer after rejecting the books of account as well as the alleged seized material has estimated the income of the searched person and had not considered the transactions as recorded in the said seized material being tally data taken from the searched person during the course of search operation containing the alleged transaction of cash payment to the assessee. The learned Authorised Representative of the Assessee has submitted that the Assessing Officer in the case of M/s. Vasavi Developers for the assessment year 2021-2022 himself has recorded the finding that the secondary set of books of accounts are defective on various points highlighted by the Assessing Officer as payable to the land lords were recorded under capital group, requirement of funds for the partners and redistribution of surplus fund to the partners from time to

10 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 time, site to site/project to project transfer by the customers, fund transfer from one project to another project, from one site to another site by the partners, notional entries passed, transfer from one ledger to one other ledger of the same partner, cancellation of booking advance etc. Thus, the Assessing Officer found various defects in the secondary books of account which are the basis for reopening of the assessment of the assessee. Once the Assessing Officer has considered and decided that the seized tally data are defective while framing the assessment of the searched person, the same cannot be the basis for reopening as well as assessment in the hand of the assessee. The learned Authorised Representative of the Assessee has further submitted that the law requires the recording of satisfaction before issuing the notice u/sec.148 of the Act on the basis of the seized material found in the case of third person. However, in the case of the assessee, the satisfaction recorded by the Assessing Officer is not a definite one, but it is only from suspicion and further the alleged cash cannot be given a different class of income than the amount received by the assessee through cheques.

11 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 The Assessing Officer has not assessed the amount received by the assessee through cheque but assessed only the alleged cash as per the seized material. Therefore, if the amounts received by the assessee in cheque is not taxable for the year under consideration being the consideration under the JDA or at the most transfer of land then, the assessment of cash as income from other sources is not permissible and therefore, the Assessing Officer was having no reason to believe that the income on account of the alleged cash payment to the assessee has escaped assessment or is assessable to tax when the other payments to the assessee through the bank account are not assessable to tax as income of the assessee for the year under consideration. Thus, the learned Authorised Representative of the Assessee has submitted that the approval granted u/sec.151 of the Act as well as the approval of the satisfaction before issuing the notice u/sec.148 is invalid being mechanical without applying the mind on the bare fact that once the payment received by the assessee under the JDA is not considered as income assessable to tax then, how the payment if at all

12 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 received in cash under the same JDA can be assessable to tax. The learned Authorised Representative of the Assessee has thus submitted that in the said approval the Assessing Officer in the proforma at Sl.No.7 has stated the income escaped assessment is quantified as ‘zero’ and further, the Pr. CIT at Sl.no.11 of the said proforma for approval also marked as ‘No’ against question where the show cause notice u/sec.148A(b) contain the details of information as per Explanation-(1) of sec.148. Therefore, the manner in which the approval is granted shows that there is no application of mind on the part of the PCIT while granting the approval u/sec.151 and consequently, the notice issued u/sec.148 is invalid and liable to be quashed. In support of his contention, he has relied upon the following decisions: i. Judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of CIT, Jabalpur (MP) vs. S Goyanka Lime & Chemical Ltd. [2015] 64 taxmann.com 313 (SC); ii. Judgment of Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of Capital Broadways (P.) Ltd vs. ITO [2024] 167 taxmann.com 533 (Del.);

13 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 iii. Judgment of Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of PCIT vs. N.C. Cables Ltd. [2017] 88 taxmann.com 649 (Del.);

8.1. Thus, the learned Authorised Representative of the Assessee has submitted that the alleged receipt is against a capital transaction cannot be assessed as ‘Income from other sources’ and therefore, in view of the fact that the seized material being the second set of books of account of the searched party is held as defective and rejected by the Assessing Officer then, the same seized material cannot be the basis of reopening of the assessment of the assessee.

9.

On the other hand, the learned DR has submitted that as per the satisfaction note recorded by the Assessing Officer it is clear that during the course of search and seizure action in the case of M/s. Vasavi Developers incriminating documents and books of account maintained in the tally software were found and seized. The said tally data were in respect of various projects of the Vasavi Group containing set of books of account was retrieved and seized during the course of search action revealing the fact that various cash

14 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 payments were made to the assessee from the Vasavi Group of entities on account of development agreement which was not disclosed by the assessee in the return of income. Thus, the cash transaction as found from the seized material is an incriminating material to disclose the undisclosed income of the assessee assessable to tax to the tune of Rs.58,89,104/- for the assessment year 2021-2022 and the other like amounts in the other assessment years. The learned DR has then submitted that the Assessing Officer has recorded the satisfaction on 29.09.2023 and approval was granted u/sec.151 of the Act by the PCIT, Central, Hyderabad on 12.10.2023 and thereafter, notice u/sec.148 was issued. Thus, the learned DR has submitted that at the time of initiating the proceedings u/sec.147/148 of the Act what is required is that prima facie the Assessing Officer himself have reason to believe that income assessable to tax has escaped assessment and in the case in hand, when the Assessing Officer received the material seized from the search and seizure action in the case of M/s. Vasavi Developers showed that huge amount of cash payments were made to the

15 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 assessees by the developer during these assessment years. Therefore, at the time of recording the satisfaction there was tangible material with the Assessing Officer to form the belief that the income assessable to tax has escaped assessment and moreover, undisclosed income in the hand of the assessee was found during the course of search and seizure action. Thus, the learned DR has submitted that reopening of the assessment is valid when it is based on the tangible material found and seized during the course of search and seizure action of M/s. Vasavi Developers. He has further submitted that rejection of books of account in the case of M/s. Vasavi Developers cannot lead to the conclusion that the seized tally data was bogus, fabricated, unreliable or inadmissible. The assessment proceedings of the seized person and assessment of the assessee are separate proceedings involving separate taxable persons and therefore, the rejection of books of account by the Assessing Officer in the assessment framed in the case of searched person would not automatically amounts to inadmissibility of the seized material for the purpose of assessment in the case

16 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 of the assessee. He has further submitted that the assessment order relied upon by the learned Authorised Representative of the Assessee is not a material or fact already available on record and therefore, the same cannot be considered while deciding the additional grounds raised by the assessee. The learned DR has further submitted that the assessee has not disputed the cash receipt, but the only explanation of the assessee was that amount was a refundable advance. Thus, the seized material had the direct nexus with the assessee and was duly corroborated by the assessees in their admission. Thus, the learned DR has submitted that at the time of reopening of the assessment the Assessing Officer was having tangible material to form the belief that income assessable to tax has escaped assessment and there is no infirmity in the reopening of the assessment. Once the Assessing Officer has recorded satisfaction based on the seized material then, granting approval by the Authority u/sec.151 of the Act cannot be questioned. He has relied upon the Orders of the authorities below.

17 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 10. We have considered the rival submissions as well as relevant material on record. The Assessing Officer has recorded the satisfaction dated 29.07.2023 as under:

18 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 10.1. The Assessing Officer has stated in the satisfaction that on preliminary analysis of the seized books of account, it was found that the assessee received Rs.4,05,59,100/- from M/s. Vasavi Group of entities on account of development agreement with M/s. Vasavi Developers. It is further stated that out of the above amount, a sum of Rs.58,89,109/- was received in cash during the financial year 2020-2021 which remains undisclosed by the assessee. The Assessing Officer then referred to the explanation to sec.148 for issuing the notice u/sec.148 of the Act to assess the income escaped assessment to the tune of Rs.58,59,104/-. The Assessing Officer has also obtained approval u/sec.151 of the Act dated 12.10.2023 from Pr. CIT, Central, Hyderabad as under:

19 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025

20 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025

21 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025

10.2. Thus, it is emanate from the approval that the quantum of income which has escaped assessment is shown at Sl.No.7 of the proforma as ‘zero’ and further there is no mention in the recommendation of the Addl/Joint CIT regarding the amount of income assessable to tax has escaped assessment and the nature of the income proposed to be assessed. The Assessing Officer himself has admitted the fact that the entire amount of Rs.4,05,59,104/- was received by the assessee under development agreement and out of which, only Rs.58,89,104/- was allegedly received in cash during this year. The Assessing Officer, while framing the assessment in the case of the assessee, has given the details of the transactions as found in the tally data in the shape of ledger account at Page nos.5 and 6 of the assessment order as under:

22 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025

23 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025

10.3. Thus, in this ledger account there were various transactions of payment made by Vasavi Group to Sri Dharmagari Ravinder Reddy. The Assessing Officer in Para no.4 of the assessment order has also stated as under:

24 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 “4. As seen from the above ledger copy, during the FY 2020-21 relevant to AY 2021-22 under consideration, an amount of Rs.83,89,104/- was paid by M/s Vasavi Developers to the assessee out of which an amount of Rs.25,00,000/- was paid on 19.02.2021 to the assessee through banking channel and the balance amount of Rs.58,89,104/- (Rs.83,89,104-Rs.25,00,000), during the FY 2020-21, was paid either directly by way of cash to the assessee or paid by way of cheque/ RTGS to various entities on behalf of the assessee and recorded as cash paid to the assessee, which can be clearly seen from the particulars and narration given in the above ledger copy. These cash payments, as evident from the above ledger copy which were received by the assessee were not recorded in the regular books of accounts of either the assessee or of the Vasavi Group.”

10.4. Thus, it is clear that the Assessing Officer noted that there were payments through cheque as well as cash and a sum of Rs.25 lakhs paid on 19.02.2021 to the assessee through the banking channel was not considered by the Assessing Officer for the purpose of assessment on account of the receipt from M/s. Vasavi Developers. Thus, it is clear that the payment received by the assessee under the development agreement was not considered by the Assessing Officer as income assessable to tax during the assessment year under consideration as this was on account of transfer of capital asset and is assessable as capital gain only that too

25 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 when the transaction of transfer is completed or on the sale of the constructed property. Once the undisputed amount received by the assessee through banking channel is not considered as income of the assessee then, the alleged amount of cash received by the assessee cannot be assessed as income of the assessee for the year under consideration. Both the receipts i.e., through banking channel as well as cash are related to the same transaction of capital asset then, the receipt in cash cannot be given a different class of income than the receipt in cheque/RTGS. Further the Assessing Officer has just reduced the amount of Rs.25 lakhs from the total receipt during the year as per the said ledger account whereas the other entries in the said ledger account also showing the details of cheques/RTGS etc. The Assessing Officer himself has admitted the fact that the other payments were by way of cheque/RTGS to various entities on behalf of the assessee. Once the payments were made through cheque and RTGS, the same cannot be regarded as cash payment to the assessee. Therefore, prima facie recording the satisfaction by the Assessing Officer that income assessable to tax on

26 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 account of cash received by the assessee under development agreement has escaped assessment is not permissible nor justified when the other payments received under the same agreement are not considered as income of the assessee for the year under consideration. By considering these facts, the approval granted by the PCIT u/sec.151 manifest non- application of mind as the Assessing Officer cannot choose and select a particular transaction of receipt as income escaped assessment or undisclosed income of the assessee when other payments received by the assessee under the same agreement are not considered as income of the assessee for the year under consideration. Further, in any case, the nature of income is undisputedly capital gain and not income from other sources as assessed by the Assessing Officer. Once the capital gain arising from the transaction under the development agreement is not assessable to tax for the year under consideration then, the payment received by the assessee under the development agreement in cash cannot be assessed separately than the other consideration received by the assessee. Hence, in the facts and circumstances of the

27 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 case as discussed above, the satisfaction recorded by the Assessing Officer is contrary to the facts and lacks substance that income assessable to tax for the year under consideration has escaped assessment when there is no income either proposed or assessed by the Assessing Officer in respect of similar other receipts through banking channel. Hence, notice issued by the Assessing Officer u/sec.148 of the Act is not sustainable in law and the same is set aside.

11.

On merits of the addition, as it is clear from the record that the Assessing Officer has assessed the said amount of Rs.58,89,104/- as income from other sources whereas in the satisfaction note itself the Assessing Officer has stated that the entire amount of Rs.4,05,59,104/- including this amount of Rs.58,89,104/- are under the development agreement. Once the other payment received by the assessee is not found as income assessable to tax for the year under consideration then, the alleged amount of Rs.58,89,104/- cannot be held as income assessable to tax for the year under consideration. The assessment of the income by the Assessing Officer as income from other sources

28 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 is also contrary to the facts as well as the record. Further, the Assessing Officer has just presumed that the other payments recorded in the seized material in the nature of ledger account are payment to the assessee through other entities however, no fact or material brought on record by the Assessing Officer to show that the payment was made in cash to the assessee. Once the assessment is framed based on the seized material then, the Assessing Officer cannot go against the transactions recorded in the seized material which clearly show that the payments were made through cheque as well as RTGS and presumption of the said payment made to the assessee in cash is also without any basis or material rather the same is contrary to the record of the alleged seized material. It is also pertinent to note that the Assessing Officer in the case of M/s. Vasavi Developers for the assessment year 2022-2023 vide order dated 17.07.2024 has rejected the books of account as well as the secondary books of account as found and seized during the course of search and seizure action in Para nos.16 to 16.4 as under:

29 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025

“16. REJECTION OF BOOKS OF ACCOUNT:

16.1. As per the provisions of section 292C of the Act where any books of account, other documents etc., are found in the possession or control of any person In the course of a search u/s 132 or survey u/s 133A of the Act, it is presumed that such books of account, other documents etc., belong to such person and that the contents of such books of account and other documents are true.

16.2. The nature of transactions, volume of the transaction, the complexity of Accounts requires special concern. Report of the Tax Audit may not cover these issues. If the assessee is liable to get its accounts, doubt about the correctness of the accounts, the multiplicity of the transactions in the Accounts may arise. As per the search findings the assessee is maintaining two sets of books of accounts. The master books contain details of all transactions of both cash and cheque. During the course of the assessment proceedings it has been pointed out that the secondary set books are also defective on broad issues tabulated below:

Sl.No. Particulars 1. Payables to Landlords were recorded under Capital Group 2. Requirement of the Funds for the Partners & Redistribution of surplus funds to the Partners time to time 3. Site to Site (or) Project to Project Transfers by the Customers. 4. Fund Transfers from One Project to another Project /from One site to another site by the Partners. 5. Transactions relating to Transfers between Partners 6. Notional Entries Passed 7. Transfer from one Ledger to another Ledger of the same Partner (Internal Transfers) 8. Bank Receipts 9. Cancellation of Booking Advances

30 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 16.3. Section 145(3) of the Act covers situations in which accounts may not be complete/correct, or have employed the wrong accounting methods. In this case, the AO can make an assessment based on his/her preferred method as per the provisions of Section 144 of the Act. As the assessee is found to be not maintain a regular mode of accounting, the undersigned may employ the method of referring to special audit as per provisions of section 142(2A) of the Act or after taking in to account all relevant material which are found during search proceedings and gathered during the assessment proceedings to make the assessment of total Income to the best of his judgement and determine the sum payable by the assessee on the basis of such assessment.

16.4. Secondly, it is not in dispute that the assessee group has not recorded the entire sale receipts (cash &cheque) in the regular books of account nor has recorded the cash expenses. In other words, neither the cash income that was received nor the cash expenses that have been incurred have been incorporated in the regular books of accounts. Therefore, the audited books of account filed by the appellant do not give a correct picture of the profits earned. Hence, the audited books of account are defective and cannot be relied upon. Hence, I proceed to reject the books of account u/s 145 of the Act as I am not satisfied about the correctness and completeness of the books filed by the assessee.”

31 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 12. Thus, it is clear that these secondary books of account in the tally data were not found to be reliable and suffering from various defects of duplication of the entries and internal transfer, cancellation of booking advance etc., then, the same material cannot be considered as admissible evidence for making the assessment in the case of the assessee. The seized material which is found to be not admissible or acceptable being defective in the hand of the seized person then, the same cannot be considered as admissible evidence in the hand of the person other than searched person. Therefore, even the addition made by the Assessing Officer based on the alleged seized document as income from other sources is not sustainable, being contrary to the facts and law. The amount which is considered under the development agreement cannot be assessed as income from other sources but at the most the same can be assessed as a consideration for transfer of the capital asset and resulting in income from capital gain. Therefore, in the facts and circumstances of the case as discussed above, the

32 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 addition made by the Assessing Officer is not sustainable and liable to be deleted. We order accordingly.

13.

Since we have set aside the notice issued by the Assessing Officer u/sec.148 of the Act as well as decided the issue on merits in favour of the assessee therefore, the other grounds raised by the assessee become infructuous and are accordingly dismissed.

14.

In the result, ITA.No.1947/Hyd./2025 of the assessee for the assessment year 2020-2021 is allowed.

ITA.No.1948/Hyd./2025 – A.Y. 2022-2023 DHARMAGARI NARENDER REDDY HUF:

15.

The assessee has raised an identical issue except the quantum of addition made by the Assessing Officer. We have already admitted the additional grounds raised by the assessee for the assessment year 2021-2022 and the Assessing Officer recorded the satisfaction identical to the satisfaction recorded for the assessment year 2021-2022 except the quantum of income escaped assessment as Rs.25 lakhs in cash during the year under consideration.

33 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025

16.

The Assessing Officer has reproduced the seized material in Para nos.3 and 4 of the assessment order as under: “3. The secondary set of books in the form of seized tally data mainly contained both accounted and unaccounted transactions with respect to 49 distinctive projects. Out of the above, the transactions with respect to the project Vasavi Waterfront at Nanakramguda, Hyderabad being developed by M/s Vasavi Developers are maintained in the tally book named "Vasavi Water Front - Wipro Circle". Perusal of this tally book, a ledger by name "Narender Reddy Suspence" is identified, screenshot of which is given below:

34 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 4. As seen from the above ledger copy, during the FY 2021- 22 relevant to AY 2022-23 under consideration, an amount of Rs.2,00,00,000/- was paid by M/s Vasavi Developers to the assessee out of which an amount of Rs.25,00,000/- was paid by way of cash to the assessee as can be clearly seen from the particulars and narration given in the above ledger copy. These cash payments, as evident from the above ledger copy which were received by the assessee were not recorded in the regular books of accounts of either the assessee or of the Vasavi Group.”

17.

Thus, the Assessing Officer has considered that the total amount received by the assessee during the year was Rs.2 crores, out of which, a sum of Rs.25 lakhs was in cash. These facts are identical to the facts for the assessment year 2020-2021. In view of our findings on the issue of validity of the notice issued u/sec.148 of the Act for the assessment year 2021-2022, the notice issued u/sec.148 of the Act in order to assess the cash payment of Rs.25 lakhs out of the total amount of Rs.2 crores is not sustainable in law. Once the total payment was received under the same agreement and in the same nature being against the capital asset then, the mode of payment would not warrant re-categorization of the income from capital gain to income from other sources. It

35 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 is apparent that since the capital gain was not assessable to tax for the year under consideration therefore, the Assessing Officer has opted this modus operandi to assess the said income as income from other sources which is not permissible under law.

18.

On merits also, the Assessing Officer has not assessed any other income except the income on account of cash receipt of Rs.25 lakhs. Therefore, in view of our findings on merits for the assessment year 2020-2021, the addition is not sustainable and liable to be deleted. We order accordingly.

19.

In the result, ITA.No.1948/Hyd./2025 of the assessee for the assessment year 2022-2023 is allowed.

ITA.No.1949/Hyd./2025 – A.Y. 2022-2023 – DHARMAGARI RAVINDER REDDY HUF

20.

The assessee has raised identical grounds except the quantum of addition made by the Assessing Officer. We have already admitted the additional grounds raised by the assessee for the assessment year 2021-2022 and the

36 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 Assessing Officer recorded the satisfaction identical to the satisfaction recorded for the assessment year 2021-2022 except the quantum of income escaped assessment as Rs.2,61,70,000/- received in cash during the year under consideration.

16.

The Assessing Officer has reproduced the seized material in Para nos.3 and 4 of the assessment order as under:

“3. The secondary set of books in the form of seized tally data mainly contained both accounted and unaccounted transactions with respect to 49 distinctive projects. Out of the above, the transactions with respect to the project Vasavi Waterfront at Nanakramguda, Hyderabad being developed by M/s Vasavi Developers are maintained in the tally book named "Vasavi Water Front - Wipro Circle". Perusal of this tally book, a ledger by name "Ravinder Reddy Suspence" is identified, screenshot of which is given below:

37 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025

38 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025

4.

As seen from the above ledger copy, during the FY 2021- 22 relevant to AY 2022-23 under consideration, an amount of Rs.2,91,70,000/- was paid by M/s Vasavi Developers to the assessee out of which an amount of Rs.30,00,000/- (Rs.5 Lakh on 05.06.2021 and Rs.25 Lakh on 01.12.2021) was paid to the assessee through banking channel and the balance amount of Rs.2,61,70,000/- (Rs.2,91,70,000- Rs.30,00,000), during the FY 2021-22, was paid either directly by way of cash to the assessee or paid by way of

39 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 cheque/ RTGS to various entities on behalf of the assessee and recorded as cash paid to the assessee, which can be clearly seen from the particulars and narration given in the above ledger copy. These cash payments, as evident from the above ledger copy which were received by the assessee were not recorded in the regular books of accounts of either the assessee or of the Vasavi Group.”

17.

Thus, the Assessing Officer has considered that the total amount received by the assessee during the year was at Rs.2,91,70,000/- out of which, the Assessing Officer considered an amount of Rs.2,61,70,000/- as cash or by way of cheque/RTGS to various entities on behalf of the assessee. Therefore, it is clear that the entire alleged amount was not received in cash but even in the seized material it was referred to as cheque or RTGS but the Assessing Officer presumed that the amount was ultimately paid to the other entities on behalf of the assessee. Once the other amounts received by the assessee under the same agreement are not considered as income assessable to tax for the year under consideration then, the alleged amount of cash as well as through other entities cannot be assessed to tax for the year under consideration or would not warrant re-categorization of the

40 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 income from capital gain to income from other sources. It is apparent that since the capital gain was not assessable to tax for the year under consideration therefore, the Assessing Officer has opted this modus operandi to assess the said income as income from other sources which is not permissible under law.

18.

On merits also, the Assessing Officer has not assessed any other income except the income on account of cash receipt of Rs. Rs.2,61,70,000/-. Therefore, in view of our findings on merits for the assessment year 2020-2021, the addition is not sustainable and liable to be deleted. We order accordingly.

19.

In the result, ITA.No.1949/Hyd./2025 of the assessee for the assessment year 2022-2023 is allowed.

ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 & 1970/Hyd./2025 – A.Ys 2019-2020, 2020-2021, 2021-2022 and 2022-2023 – DHARMAGARI SURENDER REDDY HUF:

41 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 20. For the assessment year 2019-2020 in ITA.No.1967/Hyd./2025, the assessee has raised the following grounds of appeal:

“Ground 1: Invalid Reopening & Lack of Incriminating Material The learned CIT(A) erred in upholding the reassessment u/s 147 in the absence of any new tangible material or incriminating evidence relating to the appellant, rendering the reopening bad in law. Ground 2: No Evidence of Income & Addition Based on Presumption The learned CIT(A) erred in confirming the addition of Rs.2,00,00,000/-despite there being no evidence of receipt, accrual, benefit, transfer, or consideration; the addition is based solely on uncorroborated third-party statements and assumptions, without granting the appellant opportunity for cross-examination. Ground 3: No Taxable Event & Non-Speaking Order The learned CIT(A) failed to appreciate that no transfer u/s 2(47)(v) occurred during the year and no taxable event arose; the impugned order is non-speaking and passed without proper consideration of submissions and evidence. Ground 4: The appellant craves leave to add to, withdraw or modify the grounds of appeal at the time of hearing. Prayer It is respectfully prayed that the Hon'ble Tribunal may:

42 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025  Delete the addition of Rs. 2,00,00,000/- in full; and  Grant consequential relief and any other relief that the Hon'ble Tribunal deems fit.”

21.

The assessee has raised additional grounds for all the four assessment years under consideration except the quantum of addition. The additional grounds raised for the assessment year 2019-2020 in ITA.No.1967/Hyd./2025 is reproduced as under:

“5. The Ld.AO has erred in considering the seized material, which himself rejected the same seized material during course of assessment of searched party and utilised the same rejected seized material for the purpose of reopening the case of the appellant u/s. 148 of the IT Act, which is bad in law. 6. The Ld.AO has erred in considering the seized material, which himself rejected the same seized material in the course of assessment of searched party and utilised for the purpose of making the addition in the hands of the Appellant. 7. The Approval granted by the PCIT Central u/s. 151 of the IT Act is mechanical for issuance of notice u/s.148. 8. The Ld.AO has erred in issuing the notice u/s. 148 of the IT Act without following the due procedure u/s. 148A of the IT Act. 9. On the facts and circumstances of case, the assessment order passed u/s 147 is vitiated and has become unsustainable in law since the approval u/s 148B has been accorded by Addl. CIT/JCIT (Range Head) in a mechanical manner."

43 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 22. The learned Authorised Representative of the Assessee has submitted that the additional grounds raised by the assessee are purely legal in nature, goes to the root of the matter and that there is no necessity of fresh investigation into facts for adjudicating the additional grounds. He, therefore, pleaded that the additional grounds raised by the assessee may please be admitted for hearing and adjudication. In support of his contention, he has relied upon the Judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of CIT vs. NTPC [1998] 229 ITR 383 (SC).

23.

On the other hand, the learned DR for the Revenue opposed for admission of the additional grounds raised by the assessee. He submitted that the assessee has not raised these additional grounds either during the assessment proceedings or before the learned CIT(A).

24.

We have heard learned Authorised Representative of the Assessee as well as learned DR on the admission of additional grounds. It is pertinent to note that for adjudication of the above additional grounds, no fresh

44 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 material or record or facts are required to be investigated, verified or considered, but the same can be adjudicated on the basis of the material and facts already on record. Accordingly, by following the Judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of National Thermal Power Co. Ltd., vs., CIT [1998] 229 ITR 383 (SC), we admit the additional grounds raised by the assessee and take up the additional grounds for hearing and adjudication.

25.

The learned Authorised Representative of the Assessee as well as the learned DR have fairly submitted that the additional grounds raised by the assessee are identical to the grounds raised for the assessment year 2021-2022 in ITA.No.1947/Hyd./2025 in the case of Dharamagari Ravinder Reddy HUF and reiterated their arguments made for the assessment year 2021-2022 in the case of Dharamagari Ravinder Reddy HUF shall be applicable in the case of Dharmagari Surender Reddy HUF to the appeals filed for the assessment years 2019-2020 to 2022-2023.

45 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 26. We have heard the learned Authorised Representative of the Assessee as well as learned DR. During the post-search proceedings, statement u/sec.131 of the Act was recorded from the assessee on 08.02.2023 in which it was stated that the assessee along with his four brothers in their capacities as HUF have executed a development agreement cum general power of attorney vide doc.no.16534/2018 on 01.09.2018 with M/s. Vasavi Developers for development of land held by them into multistoried residential and commercial complex. In this regard, the assessee and his brothers have received an amount of Rs.26 crores as refundable deposit through banking channel. The assessee has denied of having received any cash which is contrary to the evidence available in the form of ledger extracts from seized tally data. However, the Assessing Officer was not convinced with the explanation offered by the assessee for these assessment years 2019- 2020 to 2022-2023 and after taking necessary approval u/sec.151 of the Act from the Pr. CIT (Central), Hyderabad as well as DGIT, issued notice u/sec.148 of the Act dated

46 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025

07.12.2023, 12.10.2023 for the assessment years 2019-2020

to 2022-2023 respectively. In response to the notice issued

u/sec.148 of the Act, the assessee filed return of income for

the assessment year 2019-2020 2022-2023 as under:

A.Y. Return of income Total income filed on declared 2019-2020 30.01.2025 Rs.NIL 2020-2021 30.01.2024 Rs.29,550/- 2021-2022 30.01.2024 Rs.29,550/- 2022-2023 30.01.2024 Rs.29,550/-

27.

However, the Assessing Officer after considering

the submissions of the assessee made the following addition

for the assessment years 2019-2020 to 2022-2023 on

account of cash received from M/s. Vasavi Developers by

treating the cash as income from other sources u/sec.56 of

the Income Tax Act, 1961.

Addition made A.Y. Total sum by Assessing received Officer U/s.56 of the Act. 2019-2020 Rs.2,00,00,000/- Rs.2,00,00,000/- 2020-2021 Rs. 82,00,000/- Rs. 82,00,000/- 2021-2022 Rs.1,92,00,488/- Rs.1,92,00,488/- 2022-2023 Rs.3,77,64,969/- Rs.3,02,64,969/-

47 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 28. The Assessing Officer has reproduced the seized material in Para nos.3 and 4 of the assessment orders with identical observations except the quantum of addition in respect of the assessment years 2019-2020 to 2022-2023 tabulated hereinabove. The Assessing Officer has considered that the total amount received by the assessee during the assessment years 2019-2020 to 202-2023 as cash or by way of cheque/RTGS to various entities on behalf of the assessee. Thus, it is clear that the entire alleged amount was not received in cash but even in the seized material it was referred to as cheque or RTGS but the Assessing Officer presumed that the amount was ultimately paid to the other entities on behalf of the assessee. Once the other amounts received by the assessee under the same agreement are not considered as income assessable to tax for the year under consideration then, the alleged amount of cash as well as through other entities cannot be assessed to tax for the year under consideration or would not warrant re-categorization of the income from capital gain to income from other sources. It is apparent that since the capital gain was not assessable to tax

48 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 for the assessment years under consideration therefore, the Assessing Officer has opted this modus operandi to assess the said income as income from other sources which is not permissible under law. Hence, in view of our finding on this issue in ITA.No.1947/Hyd./2025, we hold that the notices issued u/sec.148 of the Act are invalid and liable to be set aside. We Order accordingly.

29.

On merits also, the Assessing Officer has not assessed any other income except the income on account of cash receipt for the assessment years 2019-2020 to 2022- 2023 tabulated hereinabove. Therefore, in view of our findings on merits in the appeal in ITA.No.1947/Hyd./2025, the addition is not sustainable and liable to be deleted. We order accordingly.

30.

In the result, ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/ Hyd./2025 of the assessee are allowed.

31.

To sum-up, all the appeals of the assessees are allowed. A copy of this common order be placed in the respective case files.

49 ITA.Nos.1947, 1948 and 1949/Hyd./2025 AND ITA.Nos.1967, 1968, 1969 and 1970/Hyd./2025 Order pronounced in the open court on 30.10.2026

Sd/- Sd/- MANJUNATHA G. VIJAY PAL RAO ACCOUNTANT MEMBER VICE PRESIDENT Hyderabad, Dated 30th day of October, 2026 VBP Copy to: DHARMAGARI RAVINDER REDDY HUF, Plot No.191, street No.21, Telecom Nagar, 1 Gachibowli, Serilingampally K V Ranga Reddy, Hyderabad. PIN – 500 032. Telangana. DHARMAGARI NARENDER REDDY HUF, 2-52, 2. NANAKRAMGUDA, GOLCONDA, HYDERABAD. PIN – 500 008. TELANGANA. DHARMAGARI SURENDER REDDY HUF, 3. 9-1-364C/11, Gandhi Nagar, Langeer House, HYDERABAD – 500 008. Telangana. The DCIT & ACIT, Central Circle-3(2), 4 & 5 Aayakar Bhavan, Opp. LB Stadium, Basheerbagh, Hyderabad. 6 THE PR. CIT-(Central), HYDERABAD. THE D.R., ITAT, HYDERABAD A-BENCH, 7 HYDERABAD. 8 GUARD FILE TRUE COPY Digitally signed VADREVU by VADREVU PRASADA RAO PRASADA Date: ASSISTANT REGISTRAR / RAO 2026.10.30 I.T.A.T. HYDERABAD 12:36:44 +05'30'

More judgments on Section 147

All 57,238 judgments and leading authorities on Section 147 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →