MANJU YOGESH VARMA,MULUND (WEST) MUMBAI vs. INCOME TAX OFFICER WARD 41(2)(3), MUMBAI

PDF · subscribers
ITA 7735/MUM/2026Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai30 October 2026AY 2020-215 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal noted the assessee's repeated non-compliance before the authorities below, which prevented an examination of contractual conditions, actual consideration received, possession, and the effect of judicial proceedings. The Tribunal acknowledged new documents submitted by the assessee, including a purchaser's confirmation of partial payment, an interim order from the Bombay High Court, and an assessment order in a similar case, which required verification. Citing CIT v. Balbir Singh Maini (supra), the Tribunal explained that mere registration of an agreement does not automatically establish a taxable transfer, and the real accrual of income depends on examining contractual rights, possession, and fulfillment of conditions. In the interest of substantial justice, the Tribunal set aside the impugned order and restored the issue to the NFAC for fresh adjudication. The NFAC is directed to examine specific documents and principles laid down in CIT v. Balbir Singh Maini, and the assessee is directed to cooperate, failing which the NFAC can decide based on available material. The remand is confined to the addition in question.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Manju Yogesh Varma, is appealing an order dated 14.05.2026 by the National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC), Delhi, for Assessment Year 2020-21. The assessee entered into a registered Agreement for Sale on 07.09.2019 for a flat for Rs. 6,03,00,000/-. The Assessing Officer, in an order dated 08.11.2024, treated the agreement's execution as a transfer under section 2(47) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, and added Rs. 1,18,73,562/- as long-term capital gains. The assessee claimed only Rs. 5,00,000/- was received, and neither balance consideration nor possession had changed hands. The assessee failed to respond to show-cause notices from the Assessing Officer and notices from the NFAC, leading to the addition being sustained.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the execution of the registered Agreement for Sale dated 07.09.2019 constitutes a transfer under section 2(47) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, for the Assessment Year 2020-21, warranting the addition of Rs. 1,18,73,562/- as long-term capital gains, despite the assessee's claim of partial payment and non-transfer of possession? Assessee's contentions: The assessee argued that only Rs. 5,00,000/- was received against the total consideration of Rs. 6,03,00,000/-. Possession was conditional on full payment and fulfillment of contractual obligations. Due to disputes between developers and proceedings before the Bombay High Court, the transaction remained incomplete. The assessee relied on CIT v. Balbir Singh Maini, (2017) 398 ITR 531 (SC). Revenue's contentions: The Revenue supported the orders of the authorities below and highlighted the assessee's non-compliances.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 2(47),Section 53A,Section 250,Section 147,Section 144B

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, MUMBAI BENCH “D”, MUMBAI

Before: SHRI NARENDER KUMAR CHOUDHRY & SHRI RATNA DASGUPTA

For Appellant: Shri Satish Gupta, Shri Prasana Prakash Tewari, SR
Pronounced: 30.10.2026

Per : Narender Kumar Choudhry, Judicial Member

This appeal has been preferred by the Assessee against the order dated 14.05.2026, impugned herein, passed by the National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC), Delhi (in short, 'Ld. Commissioner'), under section 250 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (in short, 'the Act'), for A.Y. 2020-21.

2 ITA No. 7735/M/2026 Manju Yogesh Varma 2. Briefly stated, the Assessee entered into a registered Agreement for Sale dated 07.09.2019 with M/s Siddhivinayak Realtors LLP for sale of Flat No. B-3, 12th Floor, B-Wing, Bayview Building, Andheri (West), Mumbai, for Rs.6,03,00,000/-. The Assessing Officer, vide assessment order dated 08.11.2024 passed under section 147 read with section 144B of the Act, treated the execution of the agreement as a transfer under section 2(47) of the Act and made an addition of Rs.1,18,73,562/- towards long-term capital gains, notwithstanding the Assessee's claim that only Rs.5,00,000/- had been received and neither the balance consideration nor possession had changed hands.

3.

The Assessing Officer issued a show-cause notice dated 07.10.2024, requiring compliance by 17.10.2024, proposing the aforesaid addition. However, the Assessee failed to respond, and consequently, the Assessing Officer made the addition on the basis of available material. Even before the Ld. Commissioner, despite notices dated 01.07.2025, 11.07.2025 and 07.11.2025, the Assessee neither complied nor furnished any rebuttal or supporting evidence. Accordingly, the Ld. Commissioner affirmed the addition, holding that the registered agreement created enforceable rights in favour of the purchaser, constituting a transfer under section 2(47) of the Act.

4.

Thus, the Assessee being aggrieved, preferred the instant appeal. The Ld. Counsel submitted that, although the agreement stipulated payment of the balance consideration within 60 days, only Rs.5,00,000/- was received against the agreed consideration of Rs.6,03,00,000/-. Further, possession was conditional upon payment of full consideration and fulfilment of contractual obligations. Owing to disputes between the developers and proceedings before the Hon'ble Bombay High Court, the transaction allegedly remained

3 ITA No. 7735/M/2026 Manju Yogesh Varma incomplete. The Assessee also relied upon CIT v. Balbir Singh Maini, (2017) 398 ITR 531 (SC). On the contrary, the Ld. DR supported the orders passed by the Authorities below and highlighted non- compliances by the Assessee.

5.

We have heard the parties and perused the material available on record. Admittedly, the Assessee failed to avail the opportunities afforded by both the authorities below, resulting in the addition being sustained without examination of the relevant contractual conditions, actual consideration received, possession and effect of the judicial proceedings. The Assessee has now relied upon the purchaser's confirmation dated 08.10.2026 regarding payment of only Rs.5,00,000/-, the interim order dated 10.02.2020 of the Hon'ble Bombay High Court and the assessment order dated 08.11.2024 passed in the case of another flat purchaser, namely Aditi Priyank Himani, wherein a similar transaction was reportedly accepted as not having materialised. These documents and their factual relevance require independent verification.

5.1 The Hon'ble Supreme Court in CIT v. Balbir Singh Maini, (2017) 398 ITR 531 (SC), has explained the requirements of section 2(47)(v) read with section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, and the principle of real accrual of income. Mere registration of an agreement does not, by itself, establish a taxable transfer, nor does non-receipt of the entire consideration necessarily negate accrual. The contractual rights, possession, fulfilment of relevant conditions and enforceable right to receive consideration require examination in the light of the applicable law and evidence.

6.

Considering the peculiar facts and circumstances, particularly the Assessee's repeated non-compliance before both the authorities below, resulting in the absence of proper factual

4 ITA No. 7735/M/2026 Manju Yogesh Varma examination, and the documents now relied upon requiring verification, we deem it appropriate, in the interest of substantial justice, to afford the Assessee one further opportunity to substantiate its claim. Accordingly, we set aside the impugned order and restore the issue concerning the addition of Rs.1,18,73,562/- to the file of the Ld. Commissioner for fresh adjudication in accordance with law.

6.1 The Ld. Commissioner shall examine the Agreement for Sale, actual consideration received, contractual conditions governing possession and transfer, purchaser's confirmation dated 08.10.2026, and relevant judicial orders, particularly paragraph 21 of the interim order dated 10.02.2020 passed by the Hon'ble Bombay High Court. The Ld. Commissioner shall also examine the factual comparability of the assessment order passed in the case of Aditi Priyank Himani, without treating the same as binding, and determine whether any taxable transfer occurred during the relevant previous year, in accordance with section 2(47) of the Act and the principles laid down in CIT v. Balbir Singh Maini (supra). The Ld. Commissioner may obtain a verification report from the Assessing Officer, if considered necessary.

6.2 The Assessee is specifically directed to cooperate and furnish all requisite evidence, failing which the Ld. Commissioner shall be at liberty to decide the issue on the basis of available material in accordance with law. The Ld. Commissioner shall afford a reasonable opportunity of being heard and pass a reasoned and speaking order. The remand is confined to the addition under consideration, without expressing any opinion on its merits.

7.

In view of the aforesaid findings, the remaining procedural grounds do not require separate adjudication.

5 ITA No. 7735/M/2026 Manju Yogesh Varma 8. In the result, the appeal of the Assessee is allowed for statistical purposes.

Order pronounced in the open Court on 30.10.2026.

Sd/- Sd/- (RATNA DASGUPTA) (NARENDER KUMAR CHOUDHRY) ACCOUNTANT MEMBER JUDICIAL MEMBER (ANKIT, PS)

Copy to: The Appellant The Respondent The CIT, Concerned, Mumbai The DR Concerned Bench //True Copy// By Order ABHINAV ANANT Digitally signed by ABHINAV ANANT GAVANDE GAVANDE Date: 2026.11.06 15:49:18 +05'30' Dy/Asst. Registrar, ITAT, Mumbai.

More judgments on Section 2(47)

All 946 judgments and leading authorities on Section 2(47) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →