Section 3(2) of the Income Tax Act

The decision most relied on for Section 3(2) is Asia Satellite Telecommunication Co. Ltd. v. Dy. CITT (85 ITD 478), cited in 44 of the 69 judgments on BharatTax that turn on this section.

Leading authorities on Section 3(2)

Asia Satellite Telecommunication Co. Ltd. v. Dy. CITT
85 ITD 478 · 2003 · ITAT
44
citing judgments

Payments for transponder services do not constitute payment for the use of equipment and therefore do not qualify as royalty income under section 9(1)(vi) of the Income-tax Act for a non-resident. The use of satellite transponder services by broadcasters is not considered the use of equipment.

Bharti Airtel Ltd. v. ITO
178 TTJ 708 · 2016 · ITAT
38
citing judgments

Payments made for interconnect usage charges to foreign telecom operators are not considered 'royalty' under Section 9(1)(vi) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, nor are they subject to tax withholding under Section 195 of the Act.

WIPRO Ltd. v. ITO
86 ITD 407 · 2003 · ITAT
24
citing judgments

Consideration paid for the 'use' or 'right to use' equipment is taxable as royalty, even if there is no actual present use, as the right to use in the future triggers the royalty clause.

S.M. Ram Lal & Co. v. Secretary to Government of Punjab
5 SCC 574 · 1998 · Reported
22
citing judgments

The ordinary meaning of the word 'use' as a noun is the act of employing a thing, putting it into action or service, or applying it to a given purpose.

Vodafone Idea Ltd. (formerly Vodafone Essar\nSouth Ltd.) v. DCIT (IT)
457 ITR 189 · 2023 · High Court
15
citing judgments

Payments for interconnect usage charges are not taxable as 'royalty' if they do not involve human intervention and are fully automatic. Such charges are not to be termed as technical services.

8/238 Taxman 577/382 ITR 114 and CIT v. Siemens Aktiongesellschaft
177 Taxmann 8 · 2009 · Reported
13
citing judgments
Ram Jethmalani v. Union of India
219 ITR 618 · 1996 · Supreme Court
12
citing judgments

Penalty proceedings do not fall within the ambit of Section 245E of the Income-tax Act, and the Settlement Commission exceeds its jurisdiction if it drops penalty proceedings while deciding a settlement application.

Trib.) 16-23 5. Telefonica Depreciation Espana SA v. ACIT(IT)
154 Taxmann.com 436 · 2023 · Reported
4
citing judgments
Trib.) 6. Al Telekom Austria Aktiengesellschaft v. DCIT
156 Taxmann.com 155 · 2023 · Reported
4
citing judgments
155 39-59 (Bangalore-Trib) 7. DCIT v. Orange (formerly
158 Taxmann.com 186 · 2024 · Reported
3
citing judgments

Judgments on Section 3(2)