Indian & Eastern Newspaper Society v. CIT

119 ITR 996Supreme Court of India1979#441 most cited

What is Indian & Eastern Newspaper Society v. CIT authority for?

An assessment cannot be reopened under Section 147/148 based on a mere change of opinion by the Assessing Officer on material already considered during the original assessment, clarifying the scope of 'escaped assessment'.

205

judgments rely on this decision, according to BharatTax’s citation analysis of 384,082 Indian tax judgments — from 2008 to 2026.

Also referred to as

Indian & Eastern Newspaper Society v. CIT · 119 ITR 996 · Section 147 · Section 148 · reopening assessment · change of opinion · validity of reassessment · material already considered · Kalyanji Mavji clarification · quasi-judicial proceedings · opportunity of being heard · Section 147(b)

Also reported as

2 Taxmann 1972 Taxmann.com 197

Issues it is cited on

Judgments citing Indian & Eastern Newspaper Society v. CIT

The Shipping Corporation of India Ltd., Mumbai vs. Addl.C.I.T. Ltu, Mumbai

In the result, the appeal filed by the assessee is allowed and the revenue’s appeal is dismissed

ITA 2548/MUM/2012[2005-06]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai22 Jan 2020AY 2005-06

Bench: Shri Rajesh Kumar (Am) & Shri Ram Lal Negi (Jm) Assessment Year: 2005-06 The Shipping Corporation Of India The Additional Commissioner Limited, Of Income Tax (Ltu), Shipping House 10Th Floor, 29Th Floor, World Trade 245, Madam Cama Road, Vs. Centre, Colaba, Nariman Point, Mumbai - 400006 Mumbai - 400021 Pan: Aaact1524F (Appellant) (Respondent) & Assessment Year: 2005-06 The Acit-Ltu, M/S The Shipping Corporation 28Th Floor, Centre-1, Of India Limited, World Trade Centre, Cuffe Parade, 245, Madam Cama Road, Mumbai - 400005 Vs. Nariman Point, Mumbai - 400021 Pan: Aaact1524F (Appellant) (Respondent)

For Appellant: Shri Nitesh Joshi (AR)For Respondent: Shri R. Manjunatha Swamy (CIT)
Section 143Section 147Section 148

…notice placed heavy reliance upon the case Kalyanji Mavji and Co. (supra). However, on the above aspect it has been held to be no longer good law by the subsequent decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Indian and Eastern Newspaper Society v. CIT (1979) 119 ITR 996 (SC) wherein the Supreme Court has observed thus (page 1004): “Now, in the case before us, the Income-tax Officer had, when he made the original assessment, considered the provisions of section 9, and 10. Any different view taken by him afterwards on the application of those provisions would amount to a change of opinion on material already consi…

Addl CIT Ltu, Mumbai vs. The Shipping Corporation of India Ltd, Mumbai

In the result, the appeal filed by the assessee is allowed and the revenue’s appeal is dismissed

ITA 2128/MUM/2012[2005-06]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai22 Jan 2020AY 2005-06

Bench: Shri Rajesh Kumar (Am) & Shri Ram Lal Negi (Jm) Assessment Year: 2005-06 The Shipping Corporation Of India The Additional Commissioner Limited, Of Income Tax (Ltu), Shipping House 10Th Floor, 29Th Floor, World Trade 245, Madam Cama Road, Vs. Centre, Colaba, Nariman Point, Mumbai - 400006 Mumbai - 400021 Pan: Aaact1524F (Appellant) (Respondent) & Assessment Year: 2005-06 The Acit-Ltu, M/S The Shipping Corporation 28Th Floor, Centre-1, Of India Limited, World Trade Centre, Cuffe Parade, 245, Madam Cama Road, Mumbai - 400005 Vs. Nariman Point, Mumbai - 400021 Pan: Aaact1524F (Appellant) (Respondent)

For Appellant: Shri Nitesh Joshi (AR)For Respondent: Shri R. Manjunatha Swamy (CIT)
Section 143Section 147Section 148

…notice placed heavy reliance upon the case Kalyanji Mavji and Co. (supra). However, on the above aspect it has been held to be no longer good law by the subsequent decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Indian and Eastern Newspaper Society v. CIT (1979) 119 ITR 996 (SC) wherein the Supreme Court has observed thus (page 1004): “Now, in the case before us, the Income-tax Officer had, when he made the original assessment, considered the provisions of section 9, and 10. Any different view taken by him afterwards on the application of those provisions would amount to a change of opinion on material already consi…

DCIT Cir 3(1), Mumbai vs. Icici Bank Ltd, Mumbai

ITA 5191/MUM/2009[2004-05]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai03 Jul 2019AY 2004-05

Bench: Hon’Ble Shri Saktijit Dey, Jm & Hon’Ble Shri Manoj Kumar Aggarwal, Am आयकरअपील सं./ I.T.A. No.5191/Mum/2009 (िनधा"रण वष" / Assessment Year: 2004-05) Dcit-Circle 3(1) Icici Bank Limited बनाम Room No.607, 6Th Floor नाम/ नाम नाम Icici Bank Towers Aaykar Bhavan Bandra-Kurla Complex Vs. Mumbai-400 020. Mumbai-400 051. "थायीलेखासं./जीआइआरसं./Pan/Gir No. Aaaci-1195-H (अपीलाथ" / Appellant) (ू"यथ" / Respondent) : & C.O. No.127/Mum/2010 [Arising Out Of I.T.A. No.5191/Mum/2009] (िनधा"रण वष" / Assessment Year: 2004-05) Icici Bank Limited Dcit-Circle 3(1) बनाम नाम नाम/ नाम Room No.607, 6Th Floor Icici Bank Towers Bandra-Kurla Complex Aaykar Bhavan Vs. Mumbai-400 051. Mumbai-400 020. "थायीलेखासं./जीआइआरसं./Pan/Gir No. Aaaci 1195 H (""ा"ेप ""ा"ेप ""ा"ेप /Cross Objector) ""ा"ेप (ू"यथ" / Respondent) :

For Appellant: Ms. Aarti Vissanji-Ld. ARFor Respondent: Shri P.C. Chhotaray -Ld.DR
Section 10Section 143(2)Section 143(3)Section 147Section 148Section 35DSection 36(1)(vii)

…f that income has escaped assessment has to be the reasonable belief of the Assessing Officer himself and cannot be an opinion and/or belief of some other authority. In fact, the Supreme Court in the matter of Indians & Eastern Newspaper Society v. CIT [1979] 119 ITR 996/ 2 Taxman 197 has held that whether an assessment has escaped assessment or not must be determined by the Assessing Officer himself. The Assessing Officer cannot blindly follow the opinion of an audit authority for the purpose of arriving at a belief that income has escaped assessment. In the present facts, it would be noticed that the reasons fo…

DCIT4(1)(1), Mumbai vs. Arcadia Share & Stock Brokers P. Ltd, Mumbai

In the result, the appeal Revenue is dismissed and the CO of the assessee is allowed

ITA 5712/MUM/2017[2008-09]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai21 May 2019AY 2008-09

Bench: Sri Mahavir Singh, Jm & Sri Nk Pradhan, Am Aayakr Apila Sam./ Ita No. 5712/Mum/2017 (Inaqa-Arna Baya- / Assessment Year 2008-09) The Dy. Commissioner Of Arcadia Shares & Stock Income Tax, Circle 4(1)(1) Brokers Pvt. Ltd. Room No. 640, 6Th Floor, 328/324, Ninad Chs, 1St Vs. Aayakar Bhavan, M.K. Road, Floor, Bldg No. 7, Service Mumbai-400 020 Road, Near Bhavishya Nidhi Bhavan, Mumbai-400 051 .. (P`%Yaqaai- / Respondent) (Apilaaqai- / Appellant) स्थायी लेखा सं./Pan No. Aaaca4562G प्रत्याक्षेप M./ Co No. 44/Mum/2019 (Arising In Ita No. 5712/Mum/2017 For Ay 2008-09) Arcadia Shares & Stock The Dy. Commissioner Of Brokers Pvt. Ltd. Income Tax, Circle 4(1)(1) 328/324, Ninad Chs, 1St Room No. 640, 6 Th Floor, Vs. Floor, Bldg No. 7, Service Aayakar Bhavan, M.K. Road, Near Bhavishya Nidhi Road, Mumbai-400 020 Bhavan, Mumbai-400 051 .. (P`%Yaqaai- / Respondent) (Apilaaqai- / Appellant) अपीलाथी की ओर से / Appellant By : Shri Satischandra Rajore, Dr प्रत्यथी की ओर से / Respondent By : Shri Dr. K. Shivaram, Ms Neelam Jadhav, Ars सुनवाई की तारीख / Date Of Hearing: 13-05-2019 घोषणा की तारीख / Date Of Pronouncement : 21-05-2019

For Appellant: Shri Satischandra Rajore, DRFor Respondent: Shri Dr. K. Shivaram
Section 115JSection 143(3)Section 147Section 148Section 14A

…e impugned notice under section 147/148 would obviously be on the basis of a mere change of opinion by the income-tax authorities, which would not be valid as held by the Supreme Court in Indian & Eastern Newspaper Society v. CIT[1979] 18 CO No. 44/Mum/2019 119 ITR 996 1 ;Gemini Leather Stores v. ITO[1975] 100 ITR 1 (SC) and Jindal Photo Films Ltd. v. Dy. CIT[1998] 234 ITR 1702(Delhi), etc. 12. In the decision of the Tribunal in the assessee's own case O.N.G.C.'s (supra), it has been held that the income from the contract between the parties was business income and not fee for technical services. 13. Although…